Who Really Hired Muffet To Kill Us? Undertale Theory | UNDERLAB

My Patreon: / underlab
A video explaining why I use Patreon and why I'd so massively appreciate it if you'd like to contribute: • My Last Ever Video? UN...
Muffet is a fan favourite character from Undertale, despite only being a miniboss! She also happens to be a hitwoman hired to kill us - but who by? She gives us a brief description that narrows down the potential suspects, but only one monster can be responsible! Join UNDERLAB as we go to court to find out who hired Muffet to kill us... also, is she a cannibal?
"Spider Dance" Orchestrated: • Spider Dance Orchestr... by King Mel
Underlab explores the secrets and obscurities of UNDERTALE, that game everyone seems obsessed with. There's a lot of said secrets and obscurities. Like, a lot. It also showcases and explains the lore and story of the game in an attempt to explain, clarify, and perhaps even discover completely new stuff...
Underlab on Twitter: / underlabyoutube
Gaster Fully Explained Theory: • Gaster's Final Secret ...
UNDERTALE is a game by Toby Fox
Awesome channel art by FrauLion! / frau-lion
"Best Friend" art by Moofinseeker
Muffet coloured by C4DGUY995
Harry Wakamatsu created the UNDERTALE replica fonts used in this video
UNDERTALE sprites ripped by The Spriters Resource community (thanks UnderFail, JamminJelly and ILLUUM)
UNDERTALE OST extended by Elu Tran
Extremely convenient save states provided by HylianAngel
Special thanks to my best friend(s)
Buy UNDERTALE here: undertale.com/ (six out of seven dogs recommend it)

[@RagingHorseGirl]

"gaster is having difficulty existing" lol me too fam.

[@iexist2907]

Sans destroyed the machine He was in

[@notinsideyourwalls]

Viper 2091 nuuuuuu

[@cheesestickhathreturned6875]

Matthew Ray .

[@smashfanx7560]

@Matthew Ray i think

[@icantthinkstraight8853]

Same

[@virasa907]

“i heard that spiders have a favorite food. it’s spiders.” -Riverperson

[@smashfanx7560]

CANIVALISIM BOIIS!

[@MHTMC]

*YES*

[@annemoon5964]

YEEEEEEEEEE!

[@serenitysphere1967]

BRUH!

[@vhsvirus4042]

Bojour

[@goommooster7572]

“May be Optimus Prime” “Likely a serial killer” “Definitely a serial killer.” These details are hilarious.

[@vincentnegansan440]

Yea

[@aprillardnerrose5567]

Tru

[@cinniebun5464]

Muffet isn't actually a greedy monster- when you win, she drops 0 gold, meaning she was just trying to get money to help her family.

[@randomgamer7193]

Also, she kills her family to feed her family. And she probably didn't want to give us any money

[@fenvinetwist]

shes trying to raise money to get the other spiders out of the ruins

[@coolboypogiakoih2077]

@Andrew no actually in ruins its so much cheaper and its just magics

[@GameshellAnkit]

So papyrus and undyne are also poor Wow so sad

[@fenvinetwist]

@@GameshellAnkit yeah that makes sense because when undyne’s house burns down she loses everything and papyrus is practically sans child in the sense that sans pays all the bills and has multiple jobs to pay for the house n stuff

[@DragonNestH077y]

"Its rude to talk about someone whose listening" Well ITS RUDE TO EVESDROP ON OTHER PEOPLE'S CONVERSATIONS!

[@lyfecresent7509]

I know

[@alt7697]

Original

[@snappishorc_legacy8506]

@@alt7697 mate You mont late (Also I saw that In a comic dub)

[@wizandsquiggytheguineapigs2996]

Gaster: 🖕🖕

[@dominichoward2439]

He started the conversation, most likely made the core, and now forgotten. Your being rude to him :(

[@corvusquidballsack]

✔️Maybe Optimus Prime ✔️Likely a Serial Killer ✔️Definitely a Serial Killer

[@kaosking5036]

I liked the optimus prime check

[@yesyes4964]

I’m not lying i almost died from laughing 😆

[@alura26]

Squiddi95 - Juno Pegastilia ha

[@alura26]

Squiddi95 - Juno Pegastilia i said definitely a serele (siri ly) killer

[@zackisimpson9199]

I knew it it is cereal killer Optimus prime

[@KanaPain]

Its mettaton, during the battle he says "Im the one whos hired everyone to kill you."

[@TheHellfirejen]

Jevil.. HOW YOU STILL ALIVE

[@Mime-Face1022]

the mettaton ex fight is the big debut to the public and that means it's the very first time (except for alphys and asgore) to see his smile or even his ex form.

[@Mime-Face1022]

but she is implying the enemys is the core but you could be right

[@nebolousanimating5773]

I bet mettaton stole alphys money.

[@ClarissaMcLaughlin]

I’m pretty sure that’s just in reference to the monsters in the core which, Alphys confirmed, weren’t supposed to be there at all

[@sydneyhapgood6298]

Underlab: "Undyne can't transform" Undyne the Undying: Am I a joke to you?

[@Matmania69420]

Lol ur right

[@nginahardy891]

Exactly lmao

[@dominichoward2439]

Elpingumanya KZbinr she must use all her determination, she only has that much energy once she goes down in one hit and feels like you will destroy the whole world, she does not have a sweet smile!

[@hennyychi]

Undyne the undying is determination.....

[@drduran6148]

True

[@The_Abaddon_69]

Wait if Sans is so rich then why didn't he just pay his tab already?

[@noahdodds3877]

Guess he's just too lazy to pay it off.

[@averageemus1993]

Undertale Fandom that is why he is rich he doesnt pay for food

[@absolution9249]

Xxkawaii cornXx lol

[@im_concerned9989]

your right....

[@Marsbarz_]

EXACTLY thats why i out rule him

[@Abioticbeing]

Mettaton Notattem Not attem Not a ttem Not a tem METTATON NOT A TEM CONFIRMED?!?!?

[@CutTheRedWire]

MinecraftWolfPlays 100 lol

[@LittenBitten]

LOL XD

[@mettatonex7221]

What an astute observation.

[@masteroflame6141]

LEG SO HOT HOT HOT LEG LEG SO HOT YA FRY AN EGG

[@aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa4932]

MinecraftWolfPlays100 Oh, I was thinking he was this strange tem ghost inside a robot body! But nope.

[@kurse5385]

Gaster might want you dead to get your soul and actually turn himself into something in the undertale timeline, as an official part of the timeline Gaster could just rule the underground.

[@-Rush-]

That's what I was thinking. If he's having difficulty existing, he'd want a soul to... actually... exist?

[@cappyd5872]

Definitely Mettaton because it stated on the pacifist route,” I hired everyone to kill you.”

[@jonathangultom2863]

Wrong he just said hired everyone in core not hotland

[@ojogador6316]

It's chara in genocide she will talk about chara when entering spider entrance

[@cappyd5872]

Ok, thanks for the feedback!

[@jonathangultom2863]

The Person Who Did These Are Not Someone I Know Who Did This Now

[@TheRepublicOfDixionconderoga]

yes

[@Jayup]

It’s prob mettaton! He has 3 different forms and he’s smiling in 2 of em! He also has ‘a thirst for killing humans’ as alphys said before. It fits all the descriptions!

[@angelthebagel7776]

Flowey can change forms. Maybe just maybe he could be the one. Very unlikely though

[@kikikaka2148]

i agree with this. didn't mettaton said in the fight that he was the one who hired everyone to kill you?

[@dusttrust2441]

Kiki Kaka actually i did neutral and i forget if he did say it or not lol.

[@Anthony-pt8ws]

Owen George mettaton has no control over his ex form, judging by the fact that he doesn’t use it all the time. Mettaton also remarks that Frisk sees the debut of his ex form, meaning no one else has seen it before

[@TheRepublicOfDixionconderoga]

besides he says he "hired everyone to kill you" at the start of the fight.

[@wolfranck7038]

You know, Underlab, Mettaton clearly say "YES, I WAS THE ONE THAT RE-ARRANGED THE CORE! I WAS THE ONE THAT HIRED EVERYONE TO KILL YOU!" So you took 12 minutes to explain something that's said in the game, well played Good video though

[@katmanxrocks444]

WolFranck I always assumed Mettaton was on about the monsters who attack you in the Core, that they were the ones he hired to kill the player, and not Muffet :o

[@Karmonit]

Exactly what I was saying.

[@theseabassi9638]

katmanxrocks444 He is talking about them. He's also talking about Muffet. The two contracts are not mutually exclusive.

[@dogeheldcaptive6658]

WolFranck but how does mettaton flip his switch himself? he didnt really do it himself during the pacifist/neutral because youre the one that has to flip the switch. GOD DAMMIT IF ONLY IT COULD BE SOLVED >:0

[@MarkSKristensen]

I think you'd have to be pretty dimwitted to not realise that it was Mettaton lol.

[@dalord5818]

it has to be mettaton! rich smiley 3 forms he wants you dead, like this. 6:10

[@Godfrelt]

Chara qlso

[@wrengles_]

Lmao this was my first thought ever

[@mihalgry]

He even confirmed it before fight with him

[@gachagamer347]

No one cares if someone is rich

[@drduran6148]

Mettaton psycho confirmed?

[@GippyHappy]

I still think it's Flowey. Flowey knows you have the ability to reset, so it doesn't matter if you get killed. We don't know that taking all 7 souls was his plan from the start, maybe he's mad that you are overriding his ability to reset. He likes messing with the timelines (even if its gotten boring) and might just want to see what Frisk/Chara does. Maybe he knew you'd win and wanted to test if you'd kill Muffet. Maybe he just doesn't like spiders. Before anyone says it's Mettaton: His new body had never been seen before, so there's no way he was able to transform. He'd been pestering Alphys about getting his body ready for such a long time, why would he change just to change back? Why would he need to change form to hire Muffet at all? He admits to hiring the monsters in the core, but not Muffet. He didn't need to transform to hire them either. It just doesn't fit.

[@persefonisubject1173]

**Looks at thumbnail** Uh, isn't Muffet a Black Widow? Black Widows eat their mates.

[@JS-pk8gv]

Persefoni Subject that's cannibalism

[@Douj1n]

confirmed

[@Douj1n]

or probably trying to bite us

[@withoutname9575]

@@Douj1n or playing with her pet ahuhuhu

[@bixelkoven6645]

@@JS-pk8gv Yes. And black widows do that

[@bookbutterfly6613]

I’ve literally been yelling “Mettaton” from the start 😂😂

[@withoutname9575]

Me: tra la la beware the man speaking in hand

[@johnnydez9479]

Me to

[@alanahdick5407]

🤬it says that at the end

[@LD0MM]

bruh me to

[@themanwhospeaksinhands220]

👎︎❒︎➕♎︎♑︎♋︎💧❄️♏︎❒︎

[@moogive]

Mettaton hired everyone in hot land including muffet it even says when your about to fight mettaton ex

[@Mime-Face1022]

the mettaton ex fight is the big debut to the public and that means it's the very first time (except for alphys and asgore) to see his smile or even his ex form.

[@celticraider5482]

Sans says he's "flat broke" and asks you to pay the bill when you go with him to Grillby's

[@luvaesa]

then he says just kidding and tells grillby to put it on his tab..

[@mortalkings512]

maybe it was mettaton? He has three forms and can transform at anytime. His EX form as a sweet smile, and he definitely wants your soul. I mean he tries to kill you more than 3 times. He has a lot of money because he is a movie star, and he even said, “I was the one who hired everyone to kill you” and that’s why I think it’s him. :3

[@effendyudin6220]

So do you watch until the end or you want to spoil the video?

[@sheilasellers8192]

Evan Poncavage alphys is a girl not a boy

[@choiny5029]

He says he just wants to put on a show

[@andylim9000]

@@flubaldooble1615 and how do you know that

[@andylim9000]

Mettaton is a he not a she if you google

[@thestoopidiot870]

BTW I think it was mettaton. here's why: lots of money - he is the only TV star in the underground motive - he wants to go to the surface and become a star THERE transformation - his ex form to interest muffet, then going back to his normal one since mettaton ex is energy inefficient. smile - IT'S METTATON EX!

[@temdatem5654]

In the game he says " I was the one who hired everyone to kill you "

[@redhead05071]

Plus, he's a killing machine as Alphys says.

[@aidenhanson884]

I had the same theory

[@heartshaker3889]

TigerRod and he has his own resort

[@floofycupkim1197]

Yep

[@funnyeh1298]

Mettaton hired her. It’s in the before-fight of Mettaton EX. “It was me! I was the one who hired everyone to kill you!” Is what he says.

[@Mime-Face1022]

the mettaton ex fight is the big debut to the public and that means it's the very first time (except for alphys and asgore) to see his smile or even his ex form. His smile hasn't been seen to the public let alone muffet so it would be mtt if mtt didn't say this is the debut of my new body

[@mf6610]

The first part sounds like a... You know... reference

[@notastella5031]

@@mf6610 ???

[@bonthebunnycat667]

@@mf6610 it was me...DIO!

[@mf6610]

@@bonthebunnycat667 Finally this guy gets it

[@Garfunkellasanga]

It’s Temmie,she was a sweet smile,and transforms with her face.Reason:Wants dog residues

[@Garfunkellasanga]

Also she used her collage funds

[@azcutlers3134]

9:26 who's that monster? its Mettaton!

[@azcutlers3134]

I can't wait to get the Mettaton EX card!

[@Abioticbeing]

Make. This. A. Thing. Wait! There's undertale tarot cards!! e621.net/pool/show/7271 :D AND THERE'S METTATON

[@mettatonex7221]

OH YESSSSS

[@zeinktm8317]

lol u made my day today

[@Bleu_2ay]

mettaton, INTERNET-COSSPAYING

[@petritdauti6258]

I love how Undertale is still relevant

[@Nova-uq9nw]

A n o n y m o u s It will always be relevant, my friend. You can never escape it.

[@STILLTHEBEST-cm8ph]

but its not tho

[@Karmonit]

It's certainly still relevant on this channel.

[@mwsn736]

"...showing that he has gold to spend" Apparently not enough to pay his tab

[@LilacJuvia]

I always thought it's metatton- oh well. Watching this video was kinda-

[@Mime-Face1022]

the mettaton ex fight is the big debut to the public and that means it's the very first time (except for alphys and asgore) to see his smile or even his ex form. His smile hasn't been seen to the public let alone muffet

[@kqzo]

Mettaton has a good smile (i guess) he shapeshits and he wants you *dead*

[@sensorydeprivationgaming]

"Shapeshits" Omg lol.

[@Sam-fq5hc]

Mettaton shits shapes?

[@WONDERHO111]

Shapeshits.

[@FuryousD]

u all should know what kazotsky meant, spelling mistakes are common on internet, instead of joking about the miss spelling why not tell them they spelled the word wrong? also they could know and their keyboard didn't register a key press i know mine does that allot

[@sleepystal]

@@FuryousD We aren't making fun OF them, it's just a funny error

[@infernalsquid]

Mettaton himself states that he was the one who hired all the monsters to kill you. Problem solved, no need for this video, I can walk away.

[@stagemedia7276]

Underlab just milks undertale lore for more theorys =more videos=more money.

[@floofycupkim1197]

Toriel is also a fan fave Undyne is also a fan fave

[@strangeangel235]

Before Mettaton admits it later on, I really thought it was Flowey because getting our soul and then not paying Muffet would just be just the kind of jerk move he would pull.

[@polargrizbear992]

Mettaton means the core and Mettaton has no face so he can’t smile

[@floofycupkim1197]

@@polargrizbear992 his screen can make a face if placed in the right place

[@thisisasupersayin376]

Coming back to this because I heard a theory that Muffet being "Hired" to kill you could be a sneaky reference to the fact that she was created by a deep-pocketed Kickstarter backer who literally paid for her to be a boss

[@Lumberjack_king]

That’s also why she’s depicted as greedy

[@elisibethjames7488]

2:00 Optimus Prime is a serial killer confirmed.

[@colbygarcia7693]

autobots murder out

[@siren7567]

What if Mettaton is Optimus Prime?

[@temdatem5654]

It's mettaton because 1 He is famous so he has a lot of money 2 he can transform 3 admit it, he has a beautiful smile 4 In the game he actually says "I was the one who hired everyone to kill you"

[@duckduckinator3185]

HoI!

[@duckduckinator3185]

Im surprised there isnt one hundred replies saying HoI!

[@yurimezurashi]

At first I thought it was Flowey...He could've transformed into Asriel. It wasn't, though...

[@shagarakar]

I love that profile picture

[@Mime-Face1022]

heres the thing the mettaton ex fight is the big debut to the public and that means it's the very first time (except for alphys and asgore) to see his smile or even his ex form. His smile hasn't been seen to the public let alone muffet so it would be mtt if mtt didn't say this is the debut of my new body

[@siwifatcat]

I always thought that it was Mettaton in a Pacifist or Neutral Route and Alphys in a Genocide Route. Here's why. Just before fighting Mettaton EX, one of the lines of dialogue when he's in his box form, he'll say "I WAS THE ONE WHO HIRED EVERYONE TO KILL YOU!" Although he could be talking about the CORE enemies, he could also be talking about others, such as Muffet. But this is unlikely, because Mettaton doesn't have a smile in his Box Form, and I doubt he would flip his switch just to hire someone to kill us. This makes it more likely to be Flowey, or someone else. As for Alphys, when you are about to fight Muffet, she wasn't actually supposed to be there, and was supposed to evacuate with Alphys. So Muffet technically wanted to eat you up on her own, without having anyone to tell her to do so. This is because before fighting her in a No Mercy Run, I noticed a few changes in her dialogue, such as "I heard that they love to stomp on them," changes to "I heard that they hate everyone." Some other changes would be during her battle, if you haven't killed her yet that is. She will describe the person who came to like some nerd junk, and that they told her that she had to leave or else she would die. I don't exactly remember the dialogue, but it was something similar to that, and the only way I found out about this was because I was trying to do as many betrayal kills as I could in my Genocide Route (MUAHAHA). I hope this was supportive to your theory, thanks for reading!

[@hornyluvsickness]

Wow! Thanks for telling

[@siwifatcat]

youre welcome c:

[@thamonrasmirodjanathum6445]

thanks

[@MichaelPandaPlayz]

Wow..i never knew that.. i always thought it was Flowey.. but now reading this comment makes me wanna rethink that....

[@invisibilius1978]

*(MUAHAHA)* makes sense +1

[@Earl_Black]

It might be Jerry lol no Or Maybe BurgerPants?

[@captainb1049]

Let’s be honest, burgerpants’S smile is far from sweet

[@jonathangultom2863]

@@captainb1049 yes

[@auroralovesmettaton8509]

I think that's Mettaton that hired Muffet.

[@jonathangultom2863]

Maybe Toby That Maybe Make Sense

[@whocaresaboutthename6850]

@@auroralovesmettaton8509 r/wooosh

[@duckworshipper2587]

“She’s a mini boss” My friends are stuck on her... can’t wait for them to get to undyne the undying

[@paulrance5445]

They would’ve beaten Undyne if they’re on Muffet..

[@duckworshipper2587]

Paul Rance in pacifist bro they were doing a pacifist first

[@paulrance5445]

God I didn’t expect you to reply so fast.. I didn’t realise that. Should’ve made it more clear bro

[@paulrance5445]

Also tell them they can skip Muffet

[@duckworshipper2587]

Paul Rance they’ve finished the game and done with it. It’s been almost a year...

[@loooooo2]

BREAKING THE THEORY: It actually was Mettaton, didn't you know that?

[@ermite8-bit625]

+sans I don't think so.

[@isosk1229]

he's just saying that it's confirmed in the game.

[@Majorkill675]

haha! it would actually work! he had a great smile he can transform.... and has money!

[@bulldoggamer2693]

obviously, very obvious.

[@christinamillacci7472]

Gasriel Dreemurr i totally agree

[@pasteltheartisticskeleton4140]

I first thought it was Mettaton

[@temmietastrophy7]

yub scriber yeah, me too

[@bellflowersimp2827]

yub scriber same, since he hired other monsters to kill us so.... hiring another monster sure makes us thinks kinda sence.... but tho

[@PsychicBeetle]

yub scriber same

[@aleksabanjevic8316]

yub scriber i thought flowey

[@willowdoesvideos]

it is tho

[@clintonabsolom7069]

UnderLab: Talks about Alphs Also UnderLab: *Literally talking about yourself*

[@agentlitisprettycool]

Underlab: *says muffet in his own accent (daz how u spell it right?) 2 times* Subtitles: MOFFET! MAFIA!

[@wtfastra]

mettaton duh it says he was the one that hired everyone to kill you and shapeshifting ex > box form he was smiling in the ex form then he went back to his box form

[@quink2060]

And nobody's seen MTT EX before, maybe he was going back to his box form and she saw him shifting as she left

[@Bumblebee2361]

BOX FORM XDDDDDD

[@Bumblebee2361]

MTT is a she ban"she"e

[@thebeag2491]

xbb2 B O X form

[@shupasopni]

Ultra Shark // The Squad...Muffet is in the Core/Hotland.

[@ravagamerboy9064]

OH YEAH! METATON ACTUALLY SAID THAT HE HIRED EVRYONE TO KILL FRISK BEFORE HE TRANSFORMED INTO METATON EX!

[@diamondkid2229]

And Muffet said that she saw the person who hired her in the shadows changing shape, which could relate to Mettaton and Mettaton EX.

[@whocaresaboutthename6850]

@@dockydocks8694 "Is Mettaton Neo a joke to you?"

[@sevvenvermeulen3151]

Gaster could need the soul to get power for him to exist.

[@loomianlegacyskits2451]

Definitely mettaton. Sweet smile, transforming, payed money.

[@VenomousPrime41]

NO It's OPTIMUS PRIME

[@KanaPain]

@@VenomousPrime41 or Amazon Prime

[@Mime-Face1022]

the mettaton ex fight is the big debut to the public and that means it's the very first time (except for alphys and asgore) to see his smile or even his ex form. His smile hasn't been seen to the public let alone muffet so it would be mtt if mtt didn't say this is the debut of my new body

[@Zoukos23]

King Mel hired Muffet to kill Frisk!!!! I know your dirty secret, Mel! 😂

[@Ultimate64716]

XD

[@fortismus3351]

😀😀😀😀😀😊😀😊

[@richardorban2861]

DUN DUN DUUUUUUN!!

[@mistressofdreams6031]

wow language jeez

[@tincan6239]

Toriel will beat his ass if muffet tells Frisk then Frisk tells Toriel...

[@goose4736]

"The Boba fett of undertale" great definition

[@zekion.]

Woah, I'm credited in the description, awesome dude.

[@VickiVictoria]

“ May be Optimus prime” I died when I saw that. Sub earned to you.

[@TheRepublicOfDixionconderoga]

reinforced we thinking it was mettaton(think. rich, smile, forms(is at least in control of NEO), by his own words hired everyone to kill you

[@chyuuchyuu]

Omg metaton even said "I was the one who hired them to kill you. But that was a short sighted plan." Next time look deeper Underlab!

[@InnocentSweetie123]

pm1.narvii.com/6282/75ea694acafc63182e4bc4c8590c89f67e876a71_hq.jpg

[@fanter3261]

ikr the entire video i was waiting for him to mention it

[@skywarp_8493]

I know

[@samlk11]

Yes but that was after the core. I personally believe that she meant that she only hired final froggit, anistigmatism, and whimsalot.

[@shadowforce2444]

Ikr

[@colleenlavery6596]

Me when you start saying it might be undyne: ** realises mettaton smiles and can shapeshift and probably has money from her show** IT'S METTATON IT'S METTATON!!!

[@haz6908]

Her? *The "Oh yes" *The way he talks and/or the way he mentions blooky. *The dress scene is obviously a comedy (-A-are you wearing a.. Dress? Mettaton, no! -METTATON YES!)

[@paulrance5445]

MTT is genderless

[@Mime-Face1022]

the mettaton ex fight is the big debut to the public and that means it's the very first time (except for alphys and asgore) to see his smile or even his ex form. His smile hasn't been seen to the public let alone muffet

[@iwilldefenestrateyou]

It's a he. Not a she.

[@notastella5031]

@@paulrance5445 He is a male- Toby fox confirmed it

[@lilylove1744]

Water fox: I may know the prince of the underground.

[@bird557]

Flowey pretty much has infinite money, due to the fact he breaks the 4th wall by knowing about your power to save the game, so that probably means he can edit the save file just as much as you can... _Creepy_. So Flowey probably can add as much gold to his save as he wants, meaning he could easily give muffet as much gold as she wants. So, Flowey can get as much money as he wants, but he can't seem to kill you... So he hired muffet to kill you... *Make sense?*

[@Underlab]

Good idea! It seems plausible, Dr. Gaster.

[@bird557]

Underlab thank You, I love your thumbnails, they look very good 👍

[@funnyfactorysux2495]

W. D. Gaster right but ... nevermind

[@clod-nm2up]

W. D. Gaster that actually makes sence!I never thought of that that makes flowey even higher on the sucpecs list but it is still unkown who hired muffet

[@thelunar2712]

W. D. Gaster again, flowey wanted our soul ounce we killed asgore, because even if he did get our soul asgore could just get the 6 souls he does have and destroy flowey.

[@mr.monokuma4786]

In the genocide run Muffet refers to the person that hired her as a "she" but in the pacifist run she calls them they. So it might be MTT in pacifist but I think it's Alphys in genocide

[@asrielthegodofgaming1437]

Mr. Monokuma could be.

[@strangeangel235]

Actually, that makes sense. Alphys, by this time knows you are a danger to all monsters and she is aware that Mettaton in NEO form has very little likelihood of beating you. She may also know that Muffet is formidable, but might not care one way or the other about defending monsterkind without some financial motivation, so...yeah. Could be.

[@phenomenalprofile7189]

nobody hires her in the genocide route Alphys tells Muffet to evacuate but she decided to stay there

[@dontbotherknowingwhythisch528]

Hah! The beginning is so relatable! My 2 favourite characters in undertale are 1 sans duh I love his attitude and how he acts. 2 muffet cuz she’s so unique and cool!

[@Huevito847]

“May be optimus prime” I had my optimus prime figure next to me when you said that. *f e a r*

[@SansfnafrpguyOfficaltheguy]

*that moment when sans is taller than you*

[@Bleu_2ay]

😕 sans isn't short, not inherently

[@im_concerned9989]

.....Im as tall as Papyrus so i dont have to worry xD

[@Bumblebee2361]

... DUN DUN DUNNNNN

[@teenietinytony]

It's possible that the monsters are actually much taller than we think. Pyrogothnerd on tumblr talked about that a bit more detailed. So I think Sans might be taller than many of us. x3

[@furrygohanztv491]

@Laila Wolf you jumped off that Cliff a year ago did you survive?

[@dizknots9357]

"Did mettaton hire muffet to kill you?" NO! MUFFET HIRED MUFFET TO KILL YOU

[@yes2768]

Don't Do That. It fits my aswear

[@tammyanderson1765]

Don't Do That Awwwwww omg

[@Loosay_osu]

Me when watching video : Yes, yes gaster is doing all things in the undertale. Me after watching video : HEY, GASTER IS DOING ALL THINGS IN THE UNDERTALE!

[@Kret-o]

0:50 muffet be like dis ma logo now

[@fanyar_]

You're right. Muffet has 3x more porn than Any main character

[@TripleG992w]

Dragonblaze you forgot toriel

[@KingkyLeor]

and sans... sadly

[@aboiwithtea3542]

Dragonblaze chisk

[@D.Dragon]

Dragonblaze I REALLY hate that I have to 'correct' you on this...

[@beauner4627]

Dragonblaze yup

[@lockerhead]

I can't be the only one who was screaming "IT'S METTATON GODDAMMIT" For the entire time until he got talked about.

[@Mime-Face1022]

the mettaton ex fight is the big debut to the public and that means it's the very first time (except for alphys and asgore) to see his smile or even his ex form.

[@originalname4813]

im not the only one here a year later huh

[@panquake5698]

My first thought after reading the title : IT’S THE TEMS *!!!* they smile a lot, the’re special attack has longated legs,and If you watch a lot of underlab video’s, you’d know that they have an unlimited amount of money that they can *ONLY* spend to but things and not for *collage*

[@Mime-Face1022]

*gasp* you're right omg you're right

[@cheesenovel1249]

Chara could be a suspect too, though. I don’t really know why they would need your soul, but they’re ALWAYS smiling, they probably have tons of gold because they have presumably done genocide multiple times, plus there’s a good chance they can transform since they are basically A GOD

[@drek.475]

I was basically screaming "METTATON" the whole video. I knew it was him since I read the description when I first saw Undertale

[@captainacorn2088]

Mettaton: neo form, ex form, and regular form! Smiles fabulously in EX form! And, of course, tries to get your soul ( I forgot why)

[@eitokasa]

So *HE* could cross the barrier and save humanity and become a star.

[@thatrandomperson1562]

Beginning: *spider dance fades in* End: *death by glamour fades in” Me: 2 good theme songs in one video... The video deserves a free like.

[@stickthebug2151]

Nice this is in my recommendation list and this video is great!

[@streamtail9835]

Wait @Underlab, what if Gaster getting the human soul would give him a more substantial being in space? #Theory

[@dilaramawlamonzurschoice8011]

It would but after that, he would try to take more souls and become like flowy so... hopefully not or else there might be a whole undertale 2 😀

[@Mime-Face1022]

gaster is having dificulty to exsist

[@Mime-Face1022]

@1v1 Savaş Simulasyonları hmmm but how does he interact with the player then (with the exception of muffet) if he was serios about getting your soul he might not only send muffet a greedy spider to go after you for your soul. and with gaster being able to practically control time and space than why isnt there a fun value that makes you actually fight one of his followers, and even at that shouldnt his followers know that he needs your soul to be able to exist again and instead of saying different things about him. i dont think it is gaster

[@FroztyGaming]

@@dilaramawlamonzurschoice8011 Deltarune Chapter 2

[@ExplosiveOmega]

*likely a serial killer* *definitely a serial killer*

[@DanilegoPlays]

Now that I think about it, it's kinda weird that Alphys doesn't warn you about Muffet or mention her at all, considering she warns you about literally everything else and Muffet is the most dangerous part of Hotland.

[@P1r4n]

To be honest, as soon as Muffet mentioned 'such a sweet smile', Mettaton was the one who came to my mind as the monster who wanted you dead.

[@memebyerin4712]

Jerry hired Muffet

[@lpswhiskers1688]

Memebyerin yeah probably

[@et8173]

Memebyerin -_-

[@110tacles]

Memebyerin he does not smile

[@kayotic_catgirl]

Well that one of the many many reasons why we hate Jerry!

[@scarletsparkrose9002]

the book is the true culprit the snail book hired muffit huazaa!!!!!!!!!!

[@Millekop]

Um... I don't think you did that much research? Muffet is actually seen before her fight, trying to sell Spider Donuts/Ciders. And in the CORE, Mettaton literally says that he hired monsters to kill Frisk.

[@nickwhite921]

Poké-Bob1000 Sir, I think that YOU need ro do more research. Muffett tells us that someone hired her to kill you.

[@TrulySomeone]

Which means Mettaton hired Muffet to kill you...

[@jwd-fr6bp]

Dude, Meta ton smiles a lot he can change from his true form to his regular blocky robot form, and he certainly has a lot of gold from making his reality TV show

[@star_skaterr8401]

I was screaming Chara the whole time... Edit: Just to clarify, Chara has what yo would call a “Sweet Smile” and I may remind you, can change their face and contort it, they also want our soul, you can find this out in the true genocide run. Now, it could be Flowey, I’m more leaning towards him because he wants all the human souls and monster souls. But it could be either.

[@KanaPain]

=)

[@star_skaterr8401]

@Chara Wow a total fan girl

[@star_skaterr8401]

@Chara sooooooo scary

[@cring7455]

I knew it was mettaton when I played the game

[@rachelhardy2957]

Thank you!

[@abyssboi6377]

it was mtt

[@kiroshi6859]

Mettaton is surely, he had a really sweet smile, he's rich, also Mettaton is in Hotland,and Muffet is in Hotland too, so he can acces and tell her about us.

[@julias5356]

And form ex. Muffet said he/have other form

[@Magst3r1]

Everyone knew it

[@cerealocelot8278]

I knew exactly why the thumbnail says cannibal spider right away. She makes food made OF spiders!

[@bastion6]

I love how when muffet picks up alphys she is not phased

[@user-jw5sr3xj9o]

Mettaton literally states that he hired people to kill you!! Also...2019? Probably not lol

[@Mime-Face1022]

the mettaton ex fight is the big debut to the public and that means it's the very first time (except for alphys and asgore) to see his smile or even his ex form. His smile hasn't been seen to the public let alone muffet so it would be mtt if mtt didn't say this is the debut of my new body

[@SpikyBollocks]

And the river man says you know what a spiders favourite food is other spiders

[@strangeangel235]

So true about spiders. However, you just assumed the river person's gender...

[@FuryousD]

@@strangeangel235 omg someone assumed a video game characters gender blasphemy :)

[@strangeangel235]

FuryousD 😁

[@cagkiller0786]

Wait..... that means muffed is a hitman? ._.

[@TheMysticashes]

It means she is desperate for money to save her people. People will do crazy things for family.

[@110tacles]

Dogz4life The Dog Nation people yknow

[@ashantiallen5219]

Dogz4life The Dog Nation butttt she did not know she liked spiders

[@MyDickIsATriangle]

Dogz4life The Dog Nation hitwoman*

[@Abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz1024]

Dogz4life The Dog Nation hit-spider you racist lol

[@swirltales6046]

If you look at a genocide run of Muffet where they play along and don kill her until the end, you'll see that instead of the usual description, she says that the person who hired her was a huge nerd. She wouldn't give two different descriptions of the same person, would she? Alphys is absolutely not the culprit. She might be the only one with rock-hard evidence against her.

[@clrosso]

“There’s a character that has probably been on your mind sense this video started” Me: Mettaton! “Gaster” Me: 0-0

[@thegentleraindrop2375]

them: why does she just describe them? me: ITS INDIE YO

[@thegentleraindrop2375]

btw I was scrolling through the comments and found that it was Mettaton (who is also not a temmie)

[@demete1230]

@@thegentleraindrop2375 "who is also not a temmie" * nods wisely *

[@DanielR1-MIDI]

4:49 look at sans' arms. Do you see crosses(like from the Bible)?I do, someone make a theory out of this I'm too lazy

[@Dacrafter1_]

good to know there is another Christian watching!

[@UltraZombie115]

DanielR1 I am too

[@coralkwinxwx4889]

God is bae 5evah

[@clod-nm2up]

DanielR1 actually its at 4:47 but yah I see the crosses!

[@militaryjones9468]

DanielR1 pretty sure that's just how it came out because you know it's pixel art but maybe it can be a Theory someone called matpat

[@The10thring]

Muffet said that she saw the person changing shape, Flowey’s face can change to many different people.

[@aidenconnolly2565]

0:47 Muffet:Goodbye Underlab Sign

[@Screenments]

I always assumed it was Mettaton ever since I saw his EX form

[@ItzMeTehGamer]

Even in my first playthrough I felt like it was Mettaton. Since he tried to kill us in the lab. Which is the first place where he transformed.. Folding in his arms and leg(...) and popping out a jet thruster on his bottom side. Edit: He also has a display for a face so he could probably make a nice smile.

[@ellzjo8966]

He actually admits that he hired everyone to kill you in the battle, so it must be :)

[@gwenogyt5619]

4:25 "Sans BEFRIEND us the moment we enter Snowdin" Me: Wait a minute..

[@error0976]

In the Mettaton fight I think the part when he turns into mettaton neo but Normal mettaton says: “ I hired all the people to kill you”

[@Shadowhite]

6:37 Love how you put "solved" in quotation marks 😜

[@Underlab]

The Game Theorists make good, well animated videos... but I'm not so sure on the theories! Claiming to have explained Gaster once and for all seems a bit crazy!

[@Shadowhite]

Totally agree with you, and he does make a few good points, but he definitely didn't solve the mystery he claimed to solve 😛

[@Shadowhite]

Mr. Heating, yeah, Underlab's video was significantly better

[@tim4330]

Mr. Heating it the different of going to a specialty shop and a Walmart.

[@Voidbear_FNaF_and_Undertale]

Underlab, did you see my comment on his last part of the theory?

[@subtotalaljar3620]

So tell me if I’m wrong about something I forgot or didn’t playthrough (since I only played neutral and pacifist route.) But I think of you went to muffet during your genocide route it wouldn’t make sense for flowey to want you dead. Nor Sans for the Pacifist. So my idea was that Toby put “the person had a nice smile.” To mean eithier depending on which path you took. That way we could make up our own minds on which was more plausible to us.

[@attackehh]

Nor sans?

[@ekaterinao1709]

I always assumed it was Mettaton, since he’s rich and has a nice smile

[@Mime-Face1022]

the mettaton ex fight is the big debut to the public and that means it's the very first time (except for alphys and asgore) to see his smile or even his ex form. His smile hasn't been seen to the public let alone muffet so it would be mtt if mtt didn't say this is the debut of my new body

[@luvaesa]

@@Mime-Face1022 maybe mettaton transformed just to tell muffet as a disguise

[@goldenheart__]

Also Mettaton literally says in his fight with the EX form ‘Yes, I was the one who hired all those people to kill you!’ so i mean i think that’s reason enough

[@corvusquidballsack]

For all you who think KZbin is drunk, like "Omg 0 views 7 likes" um no, a view only counts after the first half of the video, so they just liked before that. COPY AND PASTE EVERY TIME YOU SEE A COMMENT LIKE "omg 0 views but 10 likes wtf yt!!"

[@bongoh8923]

Chara could'we hired muffet.She has a sweet smile,she can kinda shape shift,and she wants to kill us.

[@zoruamaster2495]

NekiTamoČovjek JakoDaleko chara is always with you though

[@110tacles]

NekiTamoČovjek JakoDaleko chara is not material unless frisk genocides his way

[@110tacles]

And she is the narrator

[@popptartze]

And Chara isnt female. Chara doesnt have a gender. Also I did think it could be Chara, but they only want us dead in the Genocide run when we kill their loved ones.

[@xiiomqcookiex8057]

Chara is dead and she can't transform sadly

[@pinkie_55x54]

2:33 your teacher's face when she gives you the exam

[@KanaPain]

Ok i scrolling through these comments, and i cant not like this

[@KanaPain]

Ok i scrolling through the comments and i cant not like this