WHO'S THE SCARIEST COMMANDER IN cEDH - NITPICKING NERDS vs PLAY TO WIN - HALLOWEEN SPECIAL

This week we're joined by Beezy and Joe Cheries of the Nitpicking Nerds to play some scary commanders for halloween!
NITPICKING NERDS - / nitpickingnerds
ZOMBIE TOKENS - www.playtowinmtg.com/merch/10...
HALLOWEEN PLAYMATS - www.playtowinmtg.com/merch/ha...
DECKLISTS - www.moxfield.com/bookmarks/Yv...
PATREON - / playtowin
SKULL PLAYMATS/SLEEVES/COINS - www.playtowinmtg.com/merch
SHIRT DESIGNS - www.bonfire.com/store/play-to...
DRAGONSHIELD AFFILIATE LINKS - (US LINK) www.dragonshield.com/webshop/...
The EU link - www.dragonshield.com/webshop/...
TCG PLAYER AFFILIATE LINK - shop.tcgplayer.com/magic/prod...
ALTERSLEEVES - www.altersleeves.com/playtowin
INSTAGRAM - / playtowinmtg
TWITTER - / playtowinmtg
PODCAST Spotify! - open.spotify.com/show/0jkKhZ9...
PODCAST iTunes! - podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
LINK TREE - linktr.ee/playtowinmtg

[@rowrow_]

Squandered Resources only adds a mana the land could produce, so Cameron should only be able to make a black off Phyrexian Tower not a green, which means he wouldn't be able to play the elves of deep shadow to sac for diabolic edict (doesn't affect the outcome, but maybe affects the decisions he makes) Love the spooky theme, the guests, and the All Hallow's Eve name

[@maxwester8978]

Also means he couldn’t have cast the finale

[@ethanstates884]

This part was a little cringy, because of what he could or couldn’t do afterwards. Bit of a whoopsie, but for as long as they have been playing/recording, mistakes happen and it can be forgiven on this one.

[@oscarrivasflies9680]

he never played a diabolic edict (?) (but a diabolic intent)

[@marlonlam6959]

The ONLY thing that has stopped the new Polyphia album repeat fest in my house. Love you guys ❤

[@AricinGrey]

Honestly same lol

[@daderr99]

Is there a new polyphia album?

[@AricinGrey]

@@daderr99 "Remember That You Will Die" released two days ago on the 28th!

[@veganwiener8047]

Same lol

[@marlonlam6959]

@@daderr99 you didn’t notice the skies parting a few days ago?

[@TheRensvind]

This is awesome! Both pairs of my two favorite content creator pairs in the same episode

[@PlaytoWinMTG]

Hell yea

[@sloblo]

hell yea

[@Its-Lulu]

I absolute LOVED that second game win. A truely flavorful win 🎃

[@PlaytoWinMTG]

VERY SCARY

[@MVchris06]

I use Thassa's Oracle in my Aminatou, the Fateshifter deck and

[@bongzong9824]

I do not play CEDH, but this is by far one of the best channels guys. Keep up the work.

[@Ray-ws6rk]

My two favorite channels, TOGETHER? This is going to be awesome :D

[@xenorex3668]

Looking at the top card after deciding to mulligan is just Schrödinger’s topdeck

[@LakeVermilionDreams]

"I'm going to cast my second nightmare of the game..." *Heavy Metal riffs hit*

[@q2kfallen464]

Oh you already know this is going to be a fantastic episode! Glad you were able to get the nerds on to sling some spells. Much love to both channels.

[@ssitam]

12:07 BAH GAWD THATS DOOM WHISPERERS MUSIC

[@amarauk9687]

Nobody in my time being a magic players managed to *not* whiff the gitrog combo when I demanded the demonstration of the loop, so for me it's still (and always will be) slow play Rant over, love the content guys

[@ryanvandale6541]

The crossover I didn’t know I needed

[@avatarofpapermagic]

I absolutely love that you had Joe and Beezy on, absolutely adore them lads and for my two favourite cEDH content creators to host my two favourite EDH content creators is awesome!

[@SP-ik6cc]

Dylan: „Did you say ‘you’re poop‘ ??“ Cherries: „Yup“ Dylan: 🫣

[@OmegaMTG]

Cool to see Joe and Beezy as guests. Good games. Thank you for the upload.

[@Avialence]

Love seeing my two favorite channels come together for some spooky season EDH! Keep up the great work.

[@DaxVerus]

the literal juxtaposition of cam's shirt to dylans just shows their personalities as well. I love it

[@SvviftDeath]

It's been so long since I've seen a Karador deck. Sad it didn't do better but I looked over the decklist. There is a lot of similarities between my version too. I am going to review the list and make adjustments to mine accordingly. Great game and glad that Squandered Resources misplay didn't decide the outcome.

[@MarcellusI7]

Nice to see the NN boys on your channel, I watch a lot of both of your content. Keep up the good work!

[@patrickboswell4399]

love to see my two favorite channels playing together!

[@arisespiritu4162]

The collab Ive been waiting for

[@ScoopPhase]

Spoooooky wins. The Nerds getting into cEDH is 🔥

[@unnoticed67]

I LOVE tiny Dylan popping up to say "Hey! You! You can buy this zombie token and you should do that!" Fantastic marketing boys. 12/5

[@orsettomorbido]

3:45 that Bayou on the bottom left is SO NICE °_°

[@DMBlade4]

3:53 - Yo, a Necropotence that doesn't take your life away? Sounds dope

[@Varler_]

Great episode! I love how cEDH can still be flavorful.

[@bryanlincks8323]

Two of my favorite channels converging

[@pwoo581]

Loved the spooky cards, Fun quick games

[@adrianybarra24]

HOLY CRAP TWO OF MY FAVORITE KZbin CHANNELS IN ONE VIDEO!!!

[@miguelflorendo7771]

Flavor overload episode. love it!

[@halvsketchy9293]

Thank you for this sexually pleasurable halloween special🥰

[@stevenlorenzo7399]

When someone tries to explain a Gitrog wincon to me me, I’m usually like, uh-huh, great, play another? ( without Gitrog )

[@oscarperezcame]

Awesome game! And what a flavorful finish, Dylan!

[@CptMoralSupport]

Anyone else notice Cam missed putting his life down to four but didn’t change the outcome

[@zut8448]

At 7:00 - In my opinion a chance to win is a chance to win. If you don’t interact you are purposefully increasing your opponents win % and decreasing your own. In that case, I think its fair for Dylan to interact with Cam’s combo! My opinion tho :)

[@AandNDanceAndGames]

How Cam explains combo lines..... Gitrog goes brrrrrrrrrr haha

[@eric.ingram]

Dudes. Thanks for explaining how that Necro line worked. I was soooooooooo confused for a hot second.

[@eric.ingram]

Also Gitrog lines are insane and even having a Gitrog game under my belt doesn't make understanding the lines any easier.

[@Xalyn937]

Nitpicking Nerds are great to have! I love your content

[@gypsieking3280]

It was my pleasure indeed. Great game(s)!

[@nzephier]

BZ going "nitpicking nerds I believe," like he doesn't know his own channel name made me legit laugh

[@SavageD-qi2ti]

Awesome games dude! That was fantastic.

[@Orelusz]

This was really amazing! I enjoyed it entirely that doomsday oof nice stop there with an offering , got trick or treat'd

[@goblintoken]

“And it’s not sexually pleasurable whatsoever.” 😂

[@asianextinction]

They clearly aren't familiar enough with their audience

[@TheWaffleDad]

This is easily the best magic channel on the internet ❤️

[@mitsosoftheelves]

But we want Dylan to say "for your pleasure"! :D

[@andrewrockwell1282]

Love it. Love the Nitpicking Nerds.

[@wshaver]

G1, I don't mind the explanation, but I wish Cam went through the loop at least a couple of times. Sometimes watching someone do it is easier to understand than listening to an explanation. Love the content as always.

[@Oneslicknick]

Gitrog is such a chef’s kiss of a deck. I’ve been piloting it for years and you did a great job! Some lil here’s and there’s but nonetheless, great job 👏

[@aamazie]

Lovin the spooky metal vibe on this. Hardcore cEDH RAWRR

[@joshuabillie5083]

My two favorite commanders piloted by my fav cedh channel!

[@Y0utube5ucks]

I do love the differences in EDH and CEDH. Cherries with the "Mine's not as exciting....TURN one Sol Ring...." ban CEDH! lol it's way too fun. Let's end it and all buy 30th anniversary edition instead.

[@reeceaustin481]

Slightly embarrassed but definitely laughed pretty hard at CoLander

[@michaelatbarnett]

Is that final outro distorted song the normal guitar lick with the piano from *In the House in a Heartbeat* laid over the top? If so, I love it. If not, I'm hearing things and YOU ALL KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK, THANK YOU FOR THE GREAT CONTENT!

[@jacob510]

You know we've had 2 double features this year and this one by far was the best. WotC could learn a thing or two from you guys

[@swat6591]

"And it's not sexually pleasurable whatsoever." -Cam Maybe to you Cam but you can't control my body.

[@Chastises]

"And it's not sexually pleasurable whatsoever." Challenge accepted!

[@maxbodifee3263]

Wow it is so much nicer to hear Beezy when his voice isn't pitched and ffwd to 500

[@ethanstates884]

Good games fellas. Happy Halloween!

[@brianknowles3980]

Always look! If there is no point of reference then it’s tough to see if the quality of the mulligan was worth the risk. A better/worse hand alone doesn’t quantify it. Thank you for coming to my TED talk. Lol. See you all at Okotober!

[@TCG9777]

I don't really find them to be too reliable for edh advice sometimes so this took a decent surprise turn for me

[@RequiemFortheFallen]

Omg the flavor win in this episode!

[@Vryson]

Inalla is the most terrifying in all regards. Only needs one card

[@IamJoshEast]

Cameron does not know how Squandered Resources works, but then again neither do the other players it seems😭

[@quintonmacdonald6683]

“It’s not sexually pleasurable whatsoever” 😂😂😂

[@it5rayray]

Dammit Cameron got me dying saying collander like wtf lol

[@dantebeleren]

💀Spooky scary Skeletons send shivers down your spine💀

[@mightyone3737]

Really surprised to see Gitrog win a game, such a peculiar deck.

[@dannymerritt7746]

Dylan's cenobite shirt is AMAZING

[@ThatOneGuy-fq5eo]

Wouldn’t necropotence stop the gitrog loop? With discards becoming exiled, unless he can stack the triggers, kind of interested to see how they interact with each other

[@firstandlast.1254]

Nerds! Ya just love to see it.

[@fnaw17]

at 14:50 small microplay you can do with lurrus and remora: on the first turn where the upkeep for remora is still 1 mana, just tap and pay for it so you can still hold up lurrus ability for another permanent instead, you can do this with remora alternating between upkeep paying and casting it from graveyard and it will still be just 1 mana for the fish :D

[@fnaw17]

tho- thinking about it now, you probably knew this and just wanted more information on the draw instead before paying mana for the fish

[@frankdetank9126]

Happy all hallows eve! Have you considered doing a best enchantress deck in cEDH video?

[@ZypherWildfire]

Another awesome game. Shouldn't Cam have gone down to 4 life at 4:00 when he used [Necropotence] for four at the end of turn? Not a big difference, but still could have perhaps given the other players a chance to finish Cam off?

[@zachpenrod8109]

How is cam getting colored mana off of the squandered resources? I.e when he sacrificed the gemstone cavern and phyrexian tower. Doesn’t squandered give you one mana of a color that sacrificed land could produce?

[@charlesmaillho367]

The nerds seem out of their element here in a cEDH game.

[@AimbotBrandon]

MY TWO FAVORITE CHANNELS

[@joeschmoe8301]

That Hellraiser shirt is fire

[@mandielyn0416]

Game two was definitely pleasurable…

[@felipeandreas3783]

Idk Cam that second game was pretty sexy for me. On a plus note, i've read an pdf once, where someone proves that Gitrog loops are deterministc

[@intention21]

Joe and beezy!!!!!!!! YES!!!!!!!!! 2 of my best here TOGETHER!

[@luxurycars2263]

You can also play Mensis World. It's a play-and-earn shooter game with a sustainable economy.

[@maxbodifee3263]

Love the flavor win in game 2 🧙‍♀️

[@RodrigoCML7]

Of course it was super pretentious to explain the Gitrog line like that, Dylan Why do you think we love this channel?

[@danielchang3213]

What version of command tower is the gitrog playing? Seems like retro frame but there are none as of currently.

[@tylercraig5633]

Nitpicking Nerds into cEDH?? Nice!!

[@gabrielemarogna9444]

Yeah yeah, "we chose these games cause they were spooky, not because we dominated in them", yeah yeah totally 😂 Seriously though, my favorite episode in a while, always love to see flavorful pods, which I guess is what I the channel was always about, but just so you know, I'd still love to see plane and lore based pods "best commander on dominaria - phyrexia etc.."

[@pitakon]

Was there a yavimaya in play on game 2? I don't know how a squandered phyrexian tower produced green mana

[@fallen5771]

Appreciate the no spite play.

[@bundung123]

Very spooky very nice 👍

[@Xeno-MTG]

"Not sexually pleasurable whatsoever" ... How dare you assume to know my kinks, Cam? :D

[@mimic_ssb]

I didn't know Joe was nonbinary! Neat!

[@snowj1ggles]

You're wearing a Hellraiser shirt. Things sounding like a sexual innuendo is on brand lol

[@AldhaRoku]

How could I make the loop with the earth if necropotence says: "Whenever you discard a card, exile that card from your graveyard." to make that combo, you need to discard constantly. Can someone explain it to me?

[@markwilliams6008]

What a flavor win 😂

[@Flip4Crypt]

That second game's win was one of the most flavorful wins I've ever seen, that was phenomenal If I stepped down at the table- game one is turn one Necro, game two is turn one Doomsday.... I'm just gonna enjoy my time while it lasts hahaha Great Shit guys always amazing Dylan, I feel the same way when I hop in for someone on accident hahaha "how pretentious of me" All great Shit though! I love this channel and all the content you guys release

[@P122aGuy]

Truly a erotic second game 😂😂 as always great games guys

[@raycebannon6422]

What's the track that starts playing when the Doom Whisperer gets played?

[@iansamuel1811]

I think the scariest commander is Rocco... then Gitrog. Scary because when you sit down, you know that they have zero intention of doing anything but trying to murder the table and they are incredibly consistent to the point that they always have it when they get a window to go.

[@emmettmccleary4946]

beezy's altered duals 🥵

[@primeshifter1699]

Pretty cool change kraum does it for me