WHOA, This One is GOOD

[@leocubiasmusiclifestyle7460]

After listening to the “phi rope 4 emails guy” song , I feel sorry for the previous instrumental entries, that song was absolutely awesome

[@DanielRochetti]

@@griffinsteel3488 holy s*, just listened and it's true. It's just a different mix. Exactly same song. Awesome song but... Disqualified! ps: shame on the writer to make it sound like it was something brand new with the 4 emails and "missing tracks mistakes".

[@leocubiasmusiclifestyle7460]

@@griffinsteel3488 no way !!! Are you serious?

[@leocubiasmusiclifestyle7460]

@@DanielRochetti agree , if it’s true what you guys say !!

[@leocubiasmusiclifestyle7460]

@@griffinsteel3488 wow that’s a shame cause with that kind of talent writing a new song shouldn’t be a problem, don’t you think ?

[@NahuPyrope]

Copy pasting what I commented on other posts "I had a talk with Trey, since you can hear in many of my songs that I used the same or a similar melody, either nodding to it or using it, like an artist's leitmotif, here, listen to the song that people are pointing out to nahupyrope.bandcamp.com/album/daybreak He's going to have to think if it stays or not, but the song doesn't share structure, progression, solo, riffs, they only share that leitmotif and maybe the intro is a bit similar."

[@willlacy112]

Yoo "I'm sorry man" was rad af. I'd listen to that whole album

[@ronikinnunen298]

Exactly what I was gonna comment

[@DanielRochetti]

Fortunately or unfortunately, the album exists: Nahu Pyrope - Daybreak. Listened to the first 3 tracks and it's pretty awesome. Just a shitty attitude to submit a remix of their existing stuff, but it's good music.

[@NahuPyrope]

@@DanielRochetti Copy pasting what I commented on other posts "I had a talk with Trey, since you can hear in many of my songs that I used the same or a similar melody, either nodding to it or using it, like an artist's leitmotif, here, listen to the song that people are pointing out to nahupyrope.bandcamp.com/album/daybreak He's going to have to think if it stays or not, but the song doesn't share structure, progression, solo, riffs, they only share that leitmotif and maybe the intro is a bit similar."

[@NahuPyrope]

@@pgon9097 Where's the synth solo?

[@teschnermax]

@@NahuPyrope I'm sorry but you can't just name a thing thats not the same from your old tracks and use that as an excuse here. There clearly is more than just the intro that has been copy pasted here. I think dq is clearly necessary. However i still dig that track a lot.

[@adambailey890]

Dude. When Nahu just comes along with a full on anime fight scene score. Holy shit.

[@drebrose1983]

@@pgon9097 explain pls

[@NahuPyrope]

@@drebrose1983 Check post where Trey also answered, I inserted my artist's leitmotif on the song, something I use in many other songs, posted explanation on a bunch of other comments, and talked to Trey about it.

[@ethosfm1262]

@@NahuPyrope you named it the same fucking thing. Cmon man, stop it. Get some help.

[@manflabs5209]

@@pgon9097 You seem jealous of his talent

[@druidhugger6311]

@@pgon9097 One seriously talented "Hack" . He should be signed up by a major label now....

[@Oilid]

*"I'm sorry man" WINS* my heart! 150% what I like. Could easily be signed on a big label!

[@Hetriani]

Totally agree my brother!!!

[@SonsOfDeForest]

let us pray that never happens.

[@BigDatsquatch]

Nahu is definitely the best entry I've heard so far. So solid.

[@atticuscrowley]

The "I’m sorry man" song sounds like if periphery recorded music for wii sports resort and I love it

[@scottb2698]

Well if Periphery recorded music for wii sports resort, it would sound fucking awesome.

[@atticuscrowley]

@@scottb2698 exactly!

[@SlyHikari03]

Same

[@superwhitesugar1977]

“I am sorry man” song gave me chills literally chills fuuuck. That song needs to be in final fantasy for sure

[@NahuPyrope]

Thank you!

[@ZakkiLowe]

"I'm Sorry Man" sounds like Final Fantasy Christmas Metal. All of which I love.

[@frogtofall]

Final Fantasy Christmas Metal! 😂😂😂

[@MrLionheart560]

Damn, Nahu absolutely nailed it here!! Well done bro!! That’s amazing!!!

[@allyourbasearebelongtous2191]

Dude brought the fuckin 🔥didn't he?!!? Fuck me.Lol. .

[@matiaspenaloza8793]

"I'm sorry man" is like Plini, David Maxim Micic and Sithu Aye birth a weeb orchestral prog homunculus. Loved it

[@peterpoulos5518]

Definitely got a David Maxim Micic / Plini feel from it. Would enjoy seeing more from this artist!

[@Даниил-ы3ш3ц]

Kinda sounds like Terraria boss theme to me

[@russellzauner]

ITS THE OL CHIME N CHUG! YEEEEEAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHH *Dmitry Demyanenko has entered chat*

[@russellzauner]

*TSO has entered chat*

[@obsidianmetalofficial717]

I was thinking like a Symphony X instrumental.. probably cuz I've never heard of those other cats

[@andybungert]

9:59 came back to listen to Nahu's track, because it's sick AND because it's honestly super refreshing just hearing Trey be excited, flabberghasted, and happy about an entry. That make this one even more enjoyable to listen to. Damn fine work Nahu!!!!

[@swim_ad]

That one sounds good ..

[@rishiraj1205]

I'd pay to listen to that whole song!! so damn amazing, Nahu Pyrope , you're one creative freak my dude!!

[@martinpettersenlangebraate5153]

The melodeath song was a killer! Probably the best entry so far. Insomnium meets Amon Amarth

[@darkbardskg]

Thank you sir! Glad you liked it! 🤘😁🤘

[@martinpettersenlangebraate5153]

@@darkbardskg You're welcome, melodeath is one of my favourite subgenres of metal

[@darkbardskg]

@@martinpettersenlangebraate5153 mine too! I love Melo death! 🤘😁🤘

[@grey_fox7]

Was awesome, I'd listen to that any day of the week. Very pro work!

[@darkbardskg]

@@grey_fox7 thank you sir! 🤘

[@wesleytrott6397]

The "I'm Sorry Man" song was f'ing awesome! I would not be surprised if that's the winner.

[@guitars.nmetal]

Nahus Orchestral instrumental was Killer!! Propably my favorite so far, the swedish melodeath was pretty good too..

[@darkbardskg]

Thank you! 🤘😁🤘 (Elias)

[@Imfreehowaboutu]

Nahu Pyrope killed it with this track. Straight fire as the kids say. The orchestration was very impressive, excellent melodies, interesting changes, progressive yet cohesive and most importantly very enjoyable to listen to. My favorite thing about music is how it makes me feel and this song made me feel great. Where can I download this track? Take my money please!

[@guitarheroIX]

Man if he wants to record his reactions to all the entries he's gonna have to put out more videos per week. One a week will take him a few years to share.

[@jonathanfitch32774]

“I’m sorry man” is so far my favorite song in this contest. This and “stuck in my head” are the best entries IMO.

[@saintluciaofficial2019]

That melodic death metal song, kicked ass. Definitely hear the Dark Tranquility vibe in that one.

[@darkbardskg]

Thank you Elijah! Glad you enjoyed it! 🤘😁🤘

[@saintluciaofficial2019]

@@darkbardskg I definitely did. Hoping to hear more from you guys.

[@skeletonxsoup7864]

Thanks Trey! I really appreciate your feedback, you made some pretty good points. Structuring tracks is something I usually struggle with and my knowledge of music theory is fairly basic, it's definitely an area I need to improve on, just need to keep trying and learning. Bloody hell though all the entries before mine were outstanding! I was clearly out of my league, well done guys! 👌

[@noobasaurusrex9608]

Sounded dope tho dude!

[@skeletonxsoup7864]

@@noobasaurusrex9608 aww thanks dude!

[@karolkozak64]

you did really well man hats off to you.

[@Oubaama]

I would say you had the second best entry in this video! Trey made some good points, but that doesn't mean that your music isn't already good. I myself found it not only listenable but also genuinely enjoyable. I have a playlist full of songs just like this that I enjoy a lot. What I'm trying to say is: As a songwriter you're already above the amateur level. You are capable of writing songs that people want to put in their playlist, and that's a pretty big achievement!

[@karolkozak64]

It sounded amazing. Felt like the intro to Stranger Things :)

[@jamiewashere]

I want to listen to that instrumental song many times. Great job Nahu!! Impressive!

[@dfnymusic3396]

Wow. That Nahu track gave me the chills! All the surprises. All the dynamics. Really awesome

[@DennisFeinsteinCEO]

And the winner is! 💜🙌

[@DevrimOdabas]

Nahu is not only the best instrumental , i think it is the best overall entry so far holy shit that was awesome!

[@NateRange]

Nahu out here, making me VERY self conscious 🤣

[@Balesz36]

Nice job man, suprisingly smashing stuff!

[@Vortexafternoon]

So so good!!!

[@griffinsteel3488]

Nahu Pyrope released this song in 2018. It's called Daybreak on his album of the same name.

[@Balesz36]

Sounds like he did a remake on it for the contest. I’m not sure if that’s enough for disqualification. Mr. Xavier, let us know your opinion.

[@griffinsteel3488]

@@Balesz36 It sounds like he just remixed it a bit to shorten it to 4 minutes.

[@darkbardskg]

Thank you Trey for reviewing my song! Tbh, I think you are right about the second intro! Anyway, thank you ALL for the feedback!! I want to wish all the contestants the best of luck! 🤘😁🤘 Elias!

[@phaelgal9037]

"I'm sorry man" sounds a bit like Plini mixed in Liquid Tension Experiment

[@21centdregs]

if you don't know david maxim micic check that shit out. it's very much in that same vein

[@Ryan-ro1dg]

Sithu Aye is probably the best version of this kind of thing that I've come across

[@noahsmith4148]

Dude, you legit got starry eyed when the piano came in during that epic breakdown! Very rad.

[@simebagtank]

Damn, even the "bad" songs have great production. Can't wait until Trey asks if my song was recorded at the bottom of a well 🤦🏼‍♂️

[@naejin]

Dude, I want Nahu's song either by itself on loop or a longer version of it. I kind of want it to be Mike Oldfield's Tubular Bells length. It's such an interesting fusion of different sounds. Actually I think I want to listen to Tubular Bells now.

[@Mrcreeperjkh]

Nahu you're a god damn genius I REEEEAAAAALLLYY HOPE,WANT AND NEED TO HEAR MORE STUFF FROM YOU i guess we all need that!

[@jaycon505]

Man that phi rope is sick! Love the instrumentation its like dream theater, intervals and anime synth vibes.

[@JorisGriffioen]

I've rewatched this multiple times now for I'm sorry man... That shit should 100% win

[@zacharypegg7051]

Yo, that instrumental fucking SLAYS. Worth 4 emails for sure lol I NEED MOAR

[@CoenBijpost]

Nahu Pyrope… That’s some incredible music! Wow. Don’t really care if the motif has been copied from an earlier song. My bet is that 95% of contestants have used their best idea ever and put into the song for this contest. I would be surprised if everyone made songs with ONLY new material. That song was worth me going through this whole contest months after to find. It’s a pretty unique style with EDM and prog metal influences, and that just tickles a lot of my pickles. Good job! 👍

[@bitznpiecez9747]

“I’m sorry man” had native construct vibes, that was sick

[@Tephomab]

7:55 Dark Tranquility meets Deathklok haha

[@highpsi7463]

No shit I've listened to "4 email guys" track 5 times over. Amazing. Best song in the comp.

[@jasonguest5820]

I love the bass riffs and tones for 'I'm Sorry Man'

[@DanielJenkins]

Hahaha thanks for reviewing the track, yeah it's pretty amateur hour and we only had a day to come together to record it. Appreciate you listening and we'll definitely work on our songwriting for the next one

[@crankydragon]

Like the contest being closed to new entries is going to have anything to do with people sending in entries but you already know this!

[@seventhsealhere]

That instrumental was solid work! Really enjoyed it. Agree, best instrumental so far. It was like Pirates of the Caribbean meets Its a Small World meets Periphery hanging out with Dream Theater lol 👍

[@rawkinj6609]

Yup! NAHU (aka :phi rope 4 emails guy) Nailed it !!! Bravo! That was out of this world!! He's not an idiot, he's a genius! And he can build a guitar solo like an adult!! A++

[@okbro7449]

Holy God that symphony metal track is what I'd brush my teeth to every morning

[@cmorrow74]

Is there a link to the “I’m sorry, man” song? That one deserves a permanent spot in my playlist.

[@thomascrawley99]

You know an entry is great when you wake up the next day and come BACK to the video to listen to it again. Goddamn

[@xneurianx]

I'm Sorry Man is 100% what the riffsalad guys THINK they are writing. It is 100% not.

[@No-cg9kj]

It's still "riff salad". The difference is you actually like it.

[@GREENWARRI0R]

@@No-cg9kj yeah, I was a little confused cause "I'm Sorry Man" kinda sounds like riff salad to me...

[@robbynaumann439]

@@No-cg9kj I think people just define riff salad different. I think the different between riff salad and I’m sorry man is that riff salad is just riff after riff after riff that sound really similar and it doesn’t go anywhere. I’m sorry man has riffs, but then let’s the synth handle the melody and the guitar switches to rhythm. It’s still riff heavy but there’ are breaks and the song actually progresses

[@Kwert]

@@No-cg9kj Not really. The ideas develop and are well linked in I'm Sorry Man. Riff salad songs throw a bunch of riffs together with barely formed/coherent transitions and ideas that don't really develop well.

[@youdontknowme3842]

Yea I think I'm Sorry Man should try submitting a couple in for Placements in video games, movies, etc.. I think he should definitely look into that. Indi developers would eat that shit up.

[@TheTSamC]

Somebody please tell Pie-Rope-Ey to release that song on Spotify and make a KZbin video dissecting how he made it! I'd love to learn from him.

[@NahuPyrope]

A lot of people seem interested in how I do my music, I might!

[@TheTSamC]

@@NahuPyrope please do it! it would be awesome to see how you make this stuff. the orchestral stuff can have its own separate tutorials (libraries, ideation and execution, etc.), also the metal and edm can have their own stuff. Then Genre-bending (like what you've done here) can be its own section of tutorials on your channel.

[@TheTSamC]

@@NahuPyrope Just subscribed to your channel!

[@NahuPyrope]

@@TheTSamC If I knew how to teach better, I would've already done it!, I used to stream my song making process, maybe I can do that?

[@TheTSamC]

@@NahuPyrope yeah, that would be perfect!

[@SlyHikari03]

That intro part was so funny. Also, “I’m Sorry man” was pretty good.

[@Imfreehowaboutu]

Back here again to hear “I’m sorry man”. Still my favorite entry by far. Would love to see what he can do with that revv.

[@analyticequals]

That Nahu sounds like him and Jason Richardson need to link up and do a thang. It was killer.

[@pedropessoa2246]

It'd be gooooold!

[@Dwoalin]

That Sorry track made me question if I was playing a video game, watching a Disney movie or watching an anime but holy shit I loved it!

[@lucasmcarthur4941]

I rewound this video 4 times to listen to '4 emails guy'... amazing song

[@RandallHammer]

10:10 HOLY SHITE!! Waiting to see today's announcement to see if he got it, my favorite so far.

[@noobasaurusrex9608]

Damn man, every single entry this episode was awesome!!!

[@treyxaviermusic]

Finally right?

[@mutatedart]

@@treyxaviermusic This makes me feel good. If you ever need a logo designed ;-p

[@saberreiter8569]

the contest is going great, really looking forward to next week

[@Reavermyst]

I got some hella Plini vibes from 4 emails guy. Clear winner in this video

[@down1tone]

Voyager got kinda of nice TOBACCO twist to it, but there could be a bit more rhythmic variation or something to take it somewhere else

[@jordantaylorthomas1936]

That was super cool. I could see that being in like 10 video games at the same time. Awesome composition!

[@OHgreensguy]

20:55 for the 80s movie intro

[@LexiPixeL_]

Holy shit. Some of these are great, but "I'm Sorry Man" kicks so much friggin ass. It's got super strong like, Genesis (the console) era Sonic the Hedgehog vibes meets like, David Maxim Micic. I want more of that in my life for sure. Nahu, my dude, please, where can I get more of this? Absolutely stellar work.

[@NahuPyrope]

Genesis Sonic is actually one of my favorite games!, And the Sonic 3 & knuckles OST is my favorite!

[@LexiPixeL_]

@@NahuPyrope My bad, I didn't get a notification for your message. Abso-friggin-lutely S3&K. That game (games?) are easily the biggest reason I became a musician, FF7 as a close second. I'm nowhere near that level of songwriting prowess (or at your level either, for that matter lol), but maybe one day I'll get there haha. Very happy I subbed to your channel, you've got a lot of kickass tunes. I think I read elsewhere that you've got an album in the works? Def post like an announcement vid when it releases. Sorry for the ADHD rambling lol. Best of luck in the contest!

[@Alexislavergne]

It’s the 5th time I watch this video just to listen to “Sorry Man”. Any chance there’s a link where I can just get the audio? Looking forward to listen to this on Spotify!!!

[@NahuPyrope]

It's on my channel!

[@Alexislavergne]

@@NahuPyrope thanks! Just went to listen to it, and then saw that you mentioned that it was released on Spotify. So immediately went to save it on my favorite songs! Got yourself a new fan!

[@ThomsenTower]

@@NahuPyrope Will subscribe. Congratulations on a most excellent job!!!!

[@ThomsenTower]

@@NahuPyrope Your song should win this contest, no doubt about it

[@sveintheberserk]

that super epic song was like Equilibrium!

[@BTL400]

That intro, though. I want to hear a full song out of it!

[@Bouillestfu]

5:00 That's some heavy Kalmah influences!

[@darkbardskg]

I really like Kalmah! 🤘😁🤘thank you! 😁😁

[@Bouillestfu]

@@darkbardskg 🤘

[@kaleidojess]

11:18 one is pretty awesome , really different and fun. Love it.

[@cobrasys]

Every few months I come back here to watch Trey get his mind blown to smithereens by Nahu's "Daybreak". It's a fantastic song and Trey's reaction to it makes it even better.

[@machtnyx]

Almost a year later I'm still feeling Trey's excitement when listening to "I'm sorry man".

[@bassimprovjams3772]

The mellow death song reminded me of deafheaven a bit another good one but just different growls vs George's screams

[@darkbardskg]

Thank you! 🤘😁🤘

[@RemusHerciu]

not sure what hurts more, you going through all contest entries or me reading every video title thinking it's me

[@MrLasseAassveen]

I am very happy about my own song for this contest, but if Nahu wins I wont even be mad about it. Holy shit that was awesome!

[@whiskeysoul89]

GOD DAMN DUDE! YOU GO FOUR EMAILS GUY!

[@mutatedart]

Glad you liked my logo! Sorry for the 'djazz' tease - maybe next time.

[@fredlaroche6969]

Pwitty Bwootal was you? Do I hear some Martyr influences in there? Sounded awesome

[@mutatedart]

@@fredlaroche6969 Hey man! Yeah that was me. I had just bought an 8-string and wanted to make something that sounded very metal - it worked out with the timing of this competition. I think Gear Gods is right that I could have added more of a top line, but I'm overall happy with this review. Sadly I cannot say there is Martyr influence in there, however you just gave me a band I should check out! Thanks for that! Also thank you for the compliment - I'm glad you enjoyed it! When I was writing it I had hoped to find someone to scream over it but I had no luck and I was worried about the deadline so I just submitted it as is. I appreciate your comment 100%, definitely makes me feel happy that I did this.

[@mutatedart]

I think I might get a "Gimme the Jazz" t-shirt made. What a great quote.

[@andrewthomas7628]

Did anyone else rewind to 4 emails guys song and listen to it over and over again. Just listened to it 4 times

[@Z_Twe12e]

I want to listen to the I'm Sorry Man dude's song on repeat. That was dope!!

[@PooNinja]

13:13 that look that says someone from Disney really wants this amp!

[@RyanWithersAway]

Dude that instrumental was wicked. Does anyone know if this is available on streaming platforms?

[@NahuPyrope]

Soon!, it's uploading!

[@RyanWithersAway]

@@NahuPyrope dude. Hit me with the link when it's finished? Really great work buddy. I loved it

[@DavidNwokoye]

Who's Mr "I'm sorry man". I want a KZbin link asap

[@NahuPyrope]

Me!

[@DavidNwokoye]

@@NahuPyrope OMFG DUDE YOU'RE A BEAST. +1 sub

[@rmp5s]

Dude...pi ropy...what the serious fuck!? It's like someone asked what kind of instrument and tone you want and you said, "yes." Friggin EPIC, man!

[@donicsm7684]

Here to replay that Pyrope track. Goddamn you’re my songwriting idol. I hope you win man. That track was insanely out of everyone else’s league.

[@donicsm7684]

@@dongonzulman6478 I’d pay money to listen to this. No fucking contest. Solo was super tasty as well.

[@donicsm7684]

This guy can give Plini a run for his money. Damn

[@ryans8907]

loved the song so much too. thats why i sadly found out it wasnt new. wanted to hear more of this guys music.

[@donicsm7684]

@@ryans8907 It isn’t? You have a link to the track?

[@ryans8907]

@@donicsm7684 my comment with it got deleted i guess kzbin.info/www/bejne/pqibmX6NhpmEr7M

[@JusticeXFalls]

"I'm sorry man" was amazing ngl

[@TheGrimmRiffer_667]

1,000+ entries at 5 songs a week is gonna take like 4 years to get thru

[@rodreyes8436]

“I’m sorry man”… umm no apology l needed. That entry was all good with me. I loved that one.

[@rodreyes8436]

@@pgon9097 oh gosh, had this playing in the background, I missed that detail. I have to agree with you here.

[@PC85X]

4 e-mails man fucking killed the competition stone. cold. dead... Wow!

[@Codester91670]

Nahus song was like like a great piece of art for like a Fzero racing game or a sonic level. Epic

[@josephbates7967]

Happy bday man!

[@MrMentalDisease]

I know what you mean when you say riff's aren't a song, but it can be used efectively. Listen to My Dying Bride - The Cry of Mankind. The intro melody/riff plays almost throughout the whole 12 minute song.

[@ThatBaritoneGuitarGuy]

* "Fall Apart" reminded me of a SepticFlesh song, and I very much enjoy that fact. Great song! Well done! * "I'm Sorry Man" sounds like if Nintendo games had metal soundtracks. Literally. Imagine Nintendo made DOOM. * "Pwitty Bwootal" very much is a mix of djazz and metal. It sounds odd, but it works well. * "Voyager" made me see pretty colours. Not that pretty colours are a bad thing. Let's just say Admiral Kirk would say I did a lot of LDS in the 70s.

[@darkbardskg]

Thank you for the feedback! Glad you enjoyed it! (Elias)

[@ThatBaritoneGuitarGuy]

@@darkbardskg You are very welcome! And well done!

[@darkbardskg]

@@ThatBaritoneGuitarGuy 🤘😁🤘

[@Meccarox]

"I'm sorry man" sounds like an anime theme song.

[@AllThingsMan]

The “I’m sorry man” song was the shizznit!!!!

[@johnnyeproductions]

That track was absofuckinglutely amazing! It was like Dragonforce'ish... but even more on a bigger scale! Damn!!!! That was crazy

[@tybkc87]

Need to upload "I'm sorry man" TO EVERYWHERE

[@bryscorpio]

Nahu...omg, just holy shiiiiit...I loved that...love watching you be real..

[@gregmerritt9366]

"...mathcore without the math." I'm dead. 🤣🤣🤣

[@Azidoazideazide.]

I am amazed by the I'm Sorry Man

[@Savitzen]

When Elise's song is called Fall Apart and my submission was called Falling Apart LMAOOO

[@darkbardskg]

Hahah! Elias here.. So.. We had the same idea! 🤣

[@NavidKhan84]

Gimme te jazz!! Raise the DORIAN!!! love it!

[@ZakkiLowe]

Really digging that melodeath song.

[@darkbardskg]

Thank you very much! 🤘😁🤘

[@guyfromnj]

That 3rd track was killer. That was cool.

[@raysmetaltracks6782]

1000 songs! Damn, okay that is a shitload of stuff to listen to - roughly 2.7 days (non-stop).

[@BrakBnei]

Which would also be 8.3 working days (of 8 hours each).

[@SorooshMhs]

@@BrakBnei assuming there’s nothing to disqualify tho 😏

[@BrakBnei]

@@SorooshMhs True that... true that!

[@paimei2339]

@@SorooshMhs Judging by the entries so far at least 500 will be disqualified.