Why Afghans Hate Pakistan - Afghanistan History Explained By Historian

Watch The Full Episode Here: • How Are Non-Muslims Tr...
Follow Tilak Devasher's Social Media Handles:-
Twitter: / tilakdevasher1
Additional Links:-
1. Pakistan: Courting the Abyss - amzn.eu/d/ewhaGuE
2. The Pashtuns: A Contested History - amzn.eu/d/hqngN1v
3. Pakistan: At the Helm - amzn.eu/d/5U1Qsjp
4. Pakistan: The Balochistan Conundrum - amzn.eu/d/18gtoUF
✅ Subscribe To Our Other KZbin Channels:-
BeerBiceps (English Channel):
/ beerbicepsofficial
Ranveer Allahbadia (Hindi Channel):
/ ranveerallahbadia
TRS Clips हिंदी (Hindi Podcast Highlights):
/ @theranveershowhindi
BeerBiceps Shorts (English Shorts):
/ @bestoftrs
Ranveer Allahbadia Shorts (Hindi Shorts):
/ @bestoftrshindi
RAAAZ. :
/ @raaazofficial
RAAAZ Shorts :
/ @raaazshorts
BigBrain Plus :
/ @bigbrain_plus
Link to our blog: beerbiceps.com/
--
In this episode of The Ranveer Show, we welcome Tilak Devasher, an author, and a retired Special Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat of the Government of India. He is currently serving as a National Security Advisory Board (NSAB) member and a consultant for Vivekanand International Foundation. He is the author of three widely known books based on Pakistan; ‘Pakistan: Courting the Abyss’ (December 2016), ‘Pakistan: At the Helm’ (July 2018), and ‘Pakistan: The Balochistan Conundrum’ (July 2019).
Today, Tilak Devasher decodes Pakistan’s current situation and also sheds light on what happened during the partition of India & Pakistan. He talks about the history of Pakistan, the real story behind the India & Pakistan Partitions, his honest opinion on present-day India, and what could have been different if the partition didn’t take place. He further dwells upon Muhammad Ali Jinnah and how he led to the partition. Along with that, Tilak sir talked about the present scenario of Pakistan and what is the situation of non-Muslims in Pakistan.
This was an in-depth conversation about the India and Pakistan partition and how it happened. We also talked about the geopolitical scenario of Pakistan. I hope you enjoy this episode as much as I did and tell us your opinions in the comments!
#pakistan #tilakdevasher
--
INSTAGRAM : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
FACEBOOK : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TWITTER : @beerbicepsguy
/ beerbicepsguy
LINKEDIN : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TELEGRAM: @beerbicepsguy
t.me/beerbicepsguy
SNAPCHAT: @beerbicepsguy
----------------------------------------------
About :
TRS Clips is a collection of SHORT CLIPS from The Ranveer Show podcast. Enjoy our latest knowledge-fueled videos from the BeerBiceps team. Every conversation on #TheRanveerShow is intellectual, deep & progressive. We cover everyone from entrepreneurs to Bollywood film stars to even athletes.
Today, The Ranveer Show or TRS - Happiness Through Curiosity. A show where we host the world's greatest success stories and try digging out their secrets to success. Every conversation is an EXTREME learning experience for the viewer.

[@Madmansmax]

Ranveer shutting his mouth for 90% of the interview is GOLD!

[@nomadicmritunjaya774]

True

[@vivekbhardwaj88]

Baccha he abhi...padh nahi pata podcast k chakkar me. .aur sa mne sab padhe likhe ate...

[@GoneGirl-hr8cj]

:) aww Ranveer bahut Acha bandah hai

[@fd.dadnankhan2083]

Being a Pashtoon I wanted to tell you that this guest has a lot of knowledge.

[@umar7182]

@@harshitsingh7035 pushtoon do not consider themselves hindus

[@harshitsingh7035]

@@umar7182 Yes because there ideology converted to islam... And they forgotten there roots.. Of.. Hindus... And... Buddhist... They don't know peshawer was know as purushpur.. And was capital of king kanishka... Who was secular king.. Follower of hindus... And buddhism.... Jainism.... You people have study your real history..

[@Alice-7777]

​@@umar7182cuz they are just now Mind washed zombies

[@waseemafridi1844]

Before islam we are Jewish.

[@adamkhan3421]

​@@harshitsingh7035bro your talking way back nobody cares it's like saying Pakistanis were Hindus once but does it matter now? We are muslim

[@aftabahmad6099]

Being a pashtun from KPK PAKISTAN I must appreciate the research by the Author

[@robertmitchell8630]

Question Mr pashtoon First war Pakistan fought was with how ? Yup Afghanistan First Pakistani Prime Minister to be assassinated was by an Afghan national Only nation who opposed Pakistan membership in the UN Yup Afghanistan Do your own research The entire city of Herat Afghanistan was razed to the ground , towers of skulls over ocean of innocent blood by these invading Islamic terrorist hyenas from central Asian The ancient University and it's library at taxillia Afghanistan burnt to the ground All knowledge in the Quran

[@robertmitchell8630]

The most effective way to control and oppress a people is to deny and obliterate their understanding of their own history George Orwell author of 1984 Until the (Pathan) Lion can write his own history ,(the Islamic )hunters would always be glorified ( be their heroes) Adapted African Proverb.

[@IndianKGB]

He is R&AW , He do not need research

[@robertmitchell8630]

Turkish Nationalists did everything in their power to humiliate and belittle the Caliph. Within hours, the Imperial family was asked to leave Turkey. The passport issued to the deposed Khalifa referred to him simply as ‘Monsieur Abdul-Mejid file d’Abdul Aziz’ and The dejected ex-Khalifa had to spend the rest of his life on a stipend from the Nizam of Hyderabad, donations from Indian Princes and magnates and funds from the Red Cross Society Source: (The Khilafat Movement in India, 1919-1924, Muhammad Naeem Qureshi, dissertation submitted to University of London, 1973, pp.269-271, 276). The British Foreign Minister Lord Curzon addressing the British Prime Minister shortly before the Second World War. He stated, “We must put an end to anything which brings about any Islamic unity between the sons of the Muslims. As we have already succeeded in finishing off the Khilafah so we must endure that there will never arise again unity for the Muslims whether it be intellectual or cultural unity” (this means the unity on the viewpoint about life, something that affects daily affairs, namely the social, economic, education and ruling systems of Islam). Lord Curzon Effectively, by 1924 the Ottoman Empire was over. In his famous quote Curzon pronounced the following: “The situation now is that Turkey is dead and will never rise again because we have destroyed its moral strength, the Khilafah and Islam.” (The Khilafah Osmania) Lord Curzon, an Enemy of Islam

[@Anonymous-8080]

Bro have you all killed 5 women in the viral video 20.years ago? Do you remember that?

[@syedgilani810]

Afghanistan is not only pushtoons...it has tajiks,uzbiks and many more ethnicities

[@motivation5044]

​@@Unknown___5only endian calls this way For their some agenda

[@warnpassion]

@@motivation5044 The entire world knows but the arrogant paxtani punjabi refuses to accept.

[@subhradeepsonowal6241]

@@motivation5044 bikharis 😂😂😂😂🐖🐖🐖

[@parione4640]

Afghanistan is a Pashtun country, the other ethnicities came to Afghanistan from other countries.

[@roheyaadil8475]

​@@Unknown___5 we gilgat baltistani are also Pakistani ❤

[@_vs04]

Rajput rulers conquered kabul for mughal empire. Marathas under raghunath rao, sikhs under hari singh nalwa defeated pashtuns.

[@FilesdocumentsAndreposit-kr3vb]

True They are shown as inconquerable when even Raja kishan singh ( Mughal commander) had invaded and ransacked Afghanistan

[@idzkk]

Holding it is hard though

[@esapzai9844]

Nalwa got killed in the end. Dont know enough about ragunath rao. The mughals after babur had a serious pashtun problem. Akbars reigns greatest defeats was at the hands of the pashtuns of pashtunkhwa..

[@jitendratiwari6886]

Sikhs defeated them several times and it is because of Sikh Duraani empire was ended.

[@ajaybakalkar]

Peshwa Raghunath Rao conquered till ATAK and hoist maratha flag at Atak border.

[@mustafarahjoe4543]

Afghanistan is not only Pashtun ethnic group it has like Baluchs, Tajiks, Turkmen, Uzbek, Hazara, Qesilbash, Nuristani, and many more.

[@dk-zp5ze]

The prominent one bro

[@Harry-gy4fp]

Yeah. Bro Jan but the discussion were all about pushton that's why he didn't mention our tajiks, Uzbek, hazara or any other tribal brothers. As pashton we love and respect our all tribes. Long live Afghanistan

[@beluga9596]

He is a very knowledgeable man , his books are the most detailed guide to Paksitan

[@robinphilip1989]

Not all invasions came via Afghanistan. The Europeans came via the sea.

[@subbaduvvuri3925]

British came for business and later invaded

[@sanjayb0886]

Very informative - thanks. Love the line - A Pashtun took revenge after 100 years and said he took it too soon.

[@kartikeydetha6614]

Man Singh decisively defeated five major tribes of Afghans including Yusufzai and "Mandar" tribes. The flag of Amber was changed from "Katchanar" (green climber in white base) to "Pachranga" (five colored) to commemorate this victory. This flag continued in use until accession of Jaipur state in India.

[@amirkhan-ej7hc]

​@@kartikeydetha6614revenge🤩🤩🤩

[@vamsiharati3206]

Got to know about Pashtuns today .. Thanks .. Don’t have to read loads of books .. TRS clips will get me the gist 👍.. Danke’

[@Dschannel7]

Yes I’m Pashtun and I’m telling you there are a lot of bad things and news about us but we are lovely, the people not the government

[@hariskhan16065]

very informative..

[@honestreviews2433]

I'm pashtoon from peshawar pakistan. I agree mostly with the guest and respect his true and deep knowledge of his about pathans but he missed the main question why Afghan hate pakistan. 1 pakistan have captured KPK formerly known as NWFP but now all the pashtoons of NWFP love pakistan. 8 out of 11 pakistan cricket team players are pashtoon. 2: in 1979 Afghanistan was attacked by USSR and Afghanistan Liberal government was helping USSR but some people stood against it and pakistan helped them against USSR as it was pakistans religious duty and engage USSR in Afghanistan and stop them from entering Pakistan for hot water. Now liberals afghanis hate pakistan y pakistan helped Jihaadis in Afghanistan. And this time against USA.

[@umar7182]

even afghan taliban hate pakistan

[@blacksheep6174]

​​@@umar7182they don't hate Pakistan they hate our government and army bro majority of Pakistanis hate government . As a Sindhi I'm proud Pakistani but I hate estabilishment army and government. So afghans don't hate Pakistan they hate govt and even we hate govt . There are many afghans in Pakistan . My friend went to Afghanistan he was welcomed and we have same culture . Those afghans who hate Pakistan are liberal anti islam proWestern wo sided with ussr then USA and now moved to west they are not real afghans

[@ExamCracker912]

I'm pashtun but you just represent yourself. Neither are all the pashtuns cricketers nor religious. Most are unhappy with punjab+military colonialism

[@dk-zp5ze]

Lol religious duty. Pak army generals earned a shit load of money from usa during the Afghan invasion & post 9/11 era.

[@wkhan5]

@@ExamCracker912the majority of us Pakhtuns in Pakistan love Pakistan. It’s a fact, whether you like it or not. Also that so called Punjabi army that you are referring to, has a sizeable number of Pakhtuns (3 of whom have been army chiefs in the past).

[@FilesdocumentsAndreposit-kr3vb]

3:26 - that's a famous myth but there were many other survivors as well..

[@armaanamin5495]

Being a pashtoon I can say he is right on the spot

[@kartikeydetha6614]

Man Singh decisively defeated five major tribes of Afghans including Yusufzai and "Mandar" tribes. The flag of Amber was changed from "Katchanar" (green climber in white base) to "Pachranga" (five colored) to commemorate this victory. This flag continued in use until accession of Jaipur state in India.

[@Harry-gy4fp]

Very accurate video about pushton i have came across the you tube. Because i am pushton and i know all the things about pushton and Afghanistan ther is also others ethnicities like: tajik, uzbak, hazara, Baloch and many more. Love Afghanistan so much

[@kartikeydetha6614]

Shadman Beg, commander-in-chief was wounded by Suraj Singh, brother of Kuar Man Singh.Afghans were defeated and their commander died soon. Jaipur estate still has 'panchrangi neja' which means 5 coloured flag in the memory of defeating 5 kabilas of Afghanistan.

[@pascalwager4544]

Tribal people who live in hardy atmospheres like deserts, mountainous terrain, glaciers, and tundra as opposed to people who live in plains, valleys and meadows are built differently and they end up carving and developing this very rugged life and have this unuttered code of conduct they live by. Tribal Arabs also had similar codes of conduct where they would go to the earths end to exact revenge or to give shelter to a sworn enemy etc.

[@safiullahmehmood3570]

I am a MEHSOOD from the tribes of SOUTH WAZIRISTAN, I love my traditions, my culture and the values that my people hold. But Unfortunately much of our culture has been destroyed and distorted. We were not allowed to step foot in our own lands for 10 to 14 years and became refugies in our own country(Pakistan) that we are part of. Our people have been deprived of education and it is only now that most of us are reaching to the education which is our right. "Right", Up until the day we merged with KPK, our rights were way different then our fellow Pakistanis and even if I told them they won't believe me. But after all that, wounds are healing and everything's coming back. I am happy and thankful that i had education. But my rich culture and the traditions that I saw and heard about from my grandfathers and grandmothers are no where to be seen. Only fractions and broken pieces is all that remains.

[@brocklesnar2150]

Inshallah Afghanistan will free Waziristan long line waziri ❤️❤️

[@Useroi12]

​@@brocklesnar2150😂

[@IbrahimKhan-id6wi]

@@brocklesnar2150 inshallah

[@himakrand]

As someone commented earlier, durand line was border of Maharaja Ranjit Singh’s empire & british just changed its name. Mr. Deweshwar may have know it but missed to refer in discussion. I don’t know if it’s there in his book..

[@Nderitu.G]

Thank you for speaking English...

[@vanmeetstalwar]

The Durand line was created by Maharaja Ranjit Singh during the Sikh empire data. The British changed the name of the border to “Durang Line” in an attempt to ensure the Sikh empire name can be forgotten. So the area South if the Ranjit Line was captured by his army and the northern part of that line was Afghanistan - modern day Afghanistan demarcation.

[@jaqenhghar764]

Durand line run between entirety of Pakistan and Afghanistan covering areas like Baluchistan, Kandahar etc, which are the regions Ranjeet Singh never reached. So stfu.

[@PashtunNomad]

Oh bhai ranjeet never crossed peshawar. I don’t understand the fake history being taught.

[@vanmeetstalwar]

⁠😂 First off Ranjit? He is not your chachu jaan. He is Maharaja Ranjit Singh! Here educate yourself, just Google Sikh Empire Maharaja Ranjit Singh. Google Hari Singh Nalwa - who had conquered parts of Afghanistan, which is now so called Durand line. Lahore was the capital of Sikh Empire. Amritsar was the getaway/vacation place.

[@awesomestevie27]

Most of the Durand line was because of the Sikhs but the south part was because of the British

[@zebrunstate2815]

Defeat of Pathans by Hindu and Sikh soldiers was the reason why brother were able to draw that line

[@Based.Afghan]

As afghan : Our territory is upto attock where the pashtuns border panjabes (indian peoples) and we will never accept durand line.

[@jishamp7539]

Bhai....don't call them Indians when they themselves doesn't consider it..

[@Based.Afghan]

@@jishamp7539 Im talking about the panjabes and sendhi people. They are indians everyone knows this.

[@bhoyongkor]

@@Based.Afghan Punjabis and Sindhis as well as Muhajir migrants are not Indian, but "Indic", there is a difference. Being Indic means sharing a common vedic cultural history and belonging to the civilisations same was as we Bengalis do and being Indian means being from the republic of India. Funny thing is, the name was given by foreigners so India has a name of a river mainly in Pakistan. The KPK region never should have been part of Pakistan as well as Bengal, but thankfully we separated and Pakistan is nearly a failed state ran by Shias.

[@Based.Afghan]

@@bhoyongkor yes ur right i mean indic. Which means south asian also

[@bhoyongkor]

@@Based.Afghan South Asia is a much broader term brother. Bhutan is south asian but not Indic at all and part of Afghanistan is "politically" South Asian but not Indic at all.

[@naeemmughal871]

I'm half Afghan from 🇵🇰, Nd whatever this guy is telling about Punjabis Nd Pakhtoons is true!!!

[@shreyashjadhav1303]

i wish if ranveer did a fan podcast to share some ranom thoughts

[@ShahPadayachee]

I meet few Pashtoon and I must say they are best people they are kind and friendly people, they are trustworthy and true freinds ,brave people and stand up against injustice, regards South Africa

[@Omprakash-.]

Bhaiya lisp ke upar ek video Usko Kaise Thik Kare

[@avd2111]

Please have a discussion on how 100% Hindu & bhuddist Afganistan became 100% muslim Present day 🇦🇫 When the terrain remains the same 🤔

[@shiviwithmami]

i watch your vedio that your belive in quantum healing or nlp technigue please app ram verma ji ko boliya apna podcast ma he is master on nlp technique

[@frankifatfingers9088]

Mr. Partition is very passionate

[@FawadKhan-cs5vu]

I am Pakistani pashton living in fata and he is 97 percent right,,,

[@mohammedqadir9949]

You should make a video of Why are indians so obsessed with Pakistan and whatever Pakistan is doing

[@waniakhan6377]

😂 underrated comment

[@ishaanrohmetra3447]

People write books about the topic they have researched upon. The guest wrote books in Pakistan, pashtuns etc thats why he was on the show. Pakistan is cut out from india so obsession will always be their from both the sides.

[@user-ly6lm4zf8g]

Entertainment is one reason, we take al bakistan name, lot of entertainment going on, you know more than I, be it cricket or politics. Btw just see how many of urs journos making videos youtube, tell them to focus on China na, ur kaafir dost.

[@durandwilliams1138]

Why did they want to put me in the middle of their beef? lol Good interview.

[@MissAlive1]

Bhaiya yeti ke sawal kyun nai pooch rhe?

[@pashtunwarrior3676]

Afghanistan/Pashtunistan Zindabad inshallah we will all be United 🤲🏽❤️

[@brocklesnar2150]

Long live Loy Afghanistan ❤️

[@ElMaestro-pe4xz]

Being a pashtun i can tell this guy has alot of knowledge about us

[@armaanamin5495]

Being a pashtoon knowing the reality I can say we are Hindus or sindus . As we live near river indus and there is a difference between being hindu and being sanatan dharmi.. bytheway being a true Muslim love for sanatan Daharam

[@IbrahimKhan-id6wi]

think you are indian but we are not indian

[@babayaga7164]

Saare comment krne wale iss bande se zyada samajhdaar hain jisne itne saal laga diye ye sab seekhne me. Waah re tuchiyo

[@Mahipsinghh]

Raja man singh of amer(jaipur) smiling from sky

[@JourneyWithMystics]

Guest Suggestion ❤ 📍 Dr. Biswaroop Choudhary 🌟 📍 Dr. Bm Hegde 🌟🌟 📍 Pilot wale baba (if possible) 📍 Sri M (Again) please 🙏 📍 Deepanshu Giri (Astrologer) 📍 Ashish Shukla (Deep Knowledge) 📍 Ravi (Aayam India)AjapaTantric have deep spiritual experience 🌟

[@sos5546]

Ranveer is showbiz. His expression will create bad impression for learned guests. Just improve buddy stop making over expressions and laughs

[@Lilwayne911Eminem]

Brother I couldn’t agree more !

[@VoyagerIsHere]

Dear Ranveer. A suggestion for you. Please stop talking so much over your guests. Let them talk. Just ask questions and be quiet. You go on endless rants and narrations.

[@rammohanbalagopal1180]

Well said the interviewer Ranveer talks a lot unnecessarily.

[@adityapratapsinghpanwar9357]

It's like Indian Tamil and Sri Lankan tamil

[@n.kraghavan3726]

Afghanistan during Mahabharat times was called upaganasthan. Gandhari was from Kandahar. It is believed that she cursed her brother who inherited upaganasthan that his kingdom shall never be peaceful because of what he did to her and her children. Looking at what has happened in Afghanistan over the last few millennia one wonders how powerful must have been that curse .

[@brijeshmandavi6795]

bollywood's late kadar khan saab was pashtoon...

[@kanishka_shah]

Not Putting the historian’s name in video title says a lot about TRS

[@bhaskar4486]

In description

[@IndianKGB]

He is not historian but R&AW

[@ehsankhorasani_]

only 37% of Afghanistan are Pashtuns! and 35% are Tajiks ( Persians ). actual name of Afghanistan is Khorasan and name of Afghanistan is imposed by British

[@Aliy.zai.dt5lc]

There are Pashtun,s population also in India. around 5 to 7 millions

[@SharoozK]

All Pashtuns are ethnic afghans 🇦🇫 wither they are in India or Pakistan.

[@shashwatnandan5083]

Afghanistan is grave yard of superpowers.

[@Zoomzoom532]

Sikhs defeating Pashtuns is in a Bollywood movie.😂😂😂😂 Not in reality. Sikhs bravely DEFENDED an invasion by the Pashtuns, they never tried to invade Pashtuns! Over 54 of the most powerful nations including a superpower (USA) tried for over 20years and they couldn’t conquer the Pashtun nation.

[@ranveerbajwa4970]

I don’t know if they don’t tell this intentionally or they just don’t know anything about khalsa raj. The Durand line was made their because sikhs stretched there territories further than Attock So when British came into power. They got that part along

[@esapzai9844]

The sikhs had peshawar and a few districts along the indus. The rest was taken by brits .

[@ranveerbajwa4970]

@@esapzai9844 please mention the rest

[@MA-sp9dl]

@@ranveerbajwa4970 It was mostly with the permission of locals. People from khyber and kurram dist were unhappy with durrani kings sitting in Kabul. Shinwaris and Gilzai tribes were being unfairly treated by Durranis (Abdali) due to their rivalry through out generations. Pashtun usually never resist invasions since Pashtuns are never unite on single agenda. But if something happens against cultural norms or some form of insult that thing unites Pashtun to a single point and agenda and that is where Pashtun excels beyond imagination. Chabi chahiya hoti hy. Pashtun are very slow to respond, probably not as smart as Punjabis Off-course.

[@farantaimoorbutt5028]

​@@MA-sp9dlthey never unite because they are also not same.Afghanistan also consists of people from Persian, Turks and Tajiks breed .

[@Trollslayer_LA]

Afghans have been subjected to indiscriminate violence for the last 200 years perpetrated by the British Raj, USSR and USA but none of these superpowers were able to extinguish the free spirit nor erase the ethos of the Afghan people, be they Pashtun, Tajik, Turkmen, Uzbek, Hazara and other minorities. All Afghans fought for their motherland with equal vigor and lost countless lives in the process. Afghanistan and Iran are the only two countries in the region distinguished for resisting colonialism. We are not claiming to be a superior martial race compared to others in the neighborhood. Orientalist writers who are and were mostly British wrote these fabricated books to sow divisions among the people of the region to serve their colonial interests. Afghans fought to defend and protect their motherland from the evil white man and their brown partners and will continue to do so, as long as an Afghan has an ounce of life in him. One love! ❤🇦🇫🇮🇳🇮🇷🇱🇰🇧🇩🇵🇰 The human race is one big family. Spread love not war.

[@Devra380]

Ranveer-Ye yeti Afghanistan me bhi rehta hai kya

[@muhammadkaleemullahsharif]

I m Pakistani my dear friends Pakistan and Afghanistan are just like brothers only few afghans are against Pakistan because of money and investments of foreign country on them

[@amtojsingh423]

Pashtun story at the end of the video sounds more like Son of Sardar.

[@thelibralordastrology1824]

Do some Hindus respectively like to argue just to argue , what percentage of us our on the path of moksha and will we obtain moksha in this life ? How?

[@VIPIN4528]

Bro this moksh concept u r talking about The word is heavier than the planet earth

[@thelibralordastrology1824]

@@VIPIN4528 if god exists then, and wether he has full power or not , he nasty huh

[@user-ln3zw3cz8u]

Pashtun or Panjabi, both are formidable opponents who have earned respect not only amongst their friends but also amongst their enemies. It's not wrong to say they come from the same warrior stock as Pashtuns and Panjabis both have similar genetics in that they have Turk-Steppe, Messegetae and Scythian genes. I am a Panjabi I have hazel eyes, my grandfather's were green and my cousin's and nephews are green and often we are mistaken for Pashtuns.

[@Harry-gy4fp]

Bro. Pushton and Punjabi are completely different. Pushton are not Indians meanwhile Punjabis are Indian race. Pushton are iranic. One thing that pushton share with Punjabi is just the religion of Islam. They don't have any similarity with Punjabi.

[@jaikumarjadhav6575]

Read or Watch more on "The Great Game"

[@umeshambadi2519]

pathans seems ancient kshtriya tribe with a code of conduct

[@VaibhavSingh_1]

They are, even my ancestors came from Kabul.

[@patrioticindian7685]

Every Muslim is a warrior

[@umeshambadi2519]

@@patrioticindian7685 how radicalised Islam you follow is the main question?

[@praveengeorge8413]

After something insightful like this, his next video is probably going to be about bhoothinis and enchanted coconuts. I swear, this guy just wont allow people to take him seriously. 🤦

[@praveengeorge8413]

@@Hare-Krishna.. Actually I shouldn't have talked about enchanted coconuts. Baba Ramdev might patent it now. Damn it! Was a good business idea cuz people like you exist.

[@adityamenon4914]

0

[@Rohitweasley]

@@praveengeorge8413lol got triggered because somebody made fun of his “saints” and their “miracles”, nobody should take you seriously as well 🤣

[@praveengeorge8413]

@@Rohitweasley No comments. I don't think you read my second comments to the other guy.

[@halosung79]

@@praveengeorge8413 bawahahahaha That's the laugh of Ravan for ya. 😂 🤣

[@Zubair-Khan]

Punjabi and Pashtoon hate is not new its from Sikh empire when Ranjeet Singh defeated Abdalis armies and captured Peshawar etc

[@waniakhan6377]

Sad to see as myself Pakistani my opinion is there are different communities being Pakistani claiming to hate Pakistan for what what . they don't have their own country doesn't mean you will hate Pakistan is that because of Pakistan or what was decided my country always welcome every religion everyone . See it shows in comment section but some of them just hate Pakistan because of the government we are either citizens of Pakistan we hate government but not Pakistan that's why maybe Allah is helping Pakistan even in so much hard time so much haters still welcome people 💔🇵🇰💫

[@user-ly6lm4zf8g]

every religion is welcome really, we know what you did ahmedi people and we saw the rallies shia kaafir hey and we know how the population of minorities during partition and now. Forget about welcoming every religion, first do justice to ahmedi Dr. Abdus Salam a Pakistani theoretical physicist Nobel Prize in Physics in 1979.

[@sokikrong2649]

I like the rajput reference. interject like that, add to it don't interrupt the flow man. The west bengal reference was so bad i killed myself and then god said you will go to hell and i came back to continue watching your video. 😩

[@mohammadjadoon]

80% of world pashtuns are Pakistanis and 20% are afghanis. We the Pakistani pashtuns are the majority

[@uddeshchauhan7209]

Ohkkk

[@faisalHotak313]

😂

[@abdulrehmanzahidshah]

​@@uddeshchauhan7209 reailty hurts😮

[@818-SIGMA]

Pakistani people don't care about haters.

[@KhanKing-ds5rm]

I.m pashtun from khyber pakhtoon khowa i.m afghan 🇦🇫

[@bhanusingh69669]

India should support Afghanistan on pashtun dispute.

[@hamidtrk58]

Rivalry with Punjabis has its roots in Afghan Sikh wars after Ahmad Shah abdali. And hate for Pakistan is because Pakistan always trying to destabilise Afghanistan.

[@trinayanakaushik811]

Northern and Southern WB are not really same.

[@maarunava2825]

All Afghans and pashtoons were Buddhists....long ago...but the invasions change 96 % to 98 % to Islam....same with India...The main fertile and dominated regions of India i.e Punjab and Bengal was targeted...see know those two areas were Pakistan and Bangladesh.... other areas of UP.junagar.hyderabad can't cope bcz they get surrounded by huge Hindu majority population...not Punjab and Bengal partition of Bengal and separate electorate was done by British to destroy India...as they know ethnically they all are Indians may be language different religions different dress different traditions different but they are Indians by Race...no any other identity...it may cause unison among the people of India...they fear that.

[@taod01]

Afghans don’t hate pakistanis. We are brothers in islam

[@BulleyBhakt]

Afghan Taliban has killed so many Pakistani soldiers just yesterday! Abdali, when he captured Lahore killed thousands of Punjabi Muslims! Afghans don't recognize the Durant line...one day, Peshawar and all of FATA and KP will be part of Afghanistan, inshallah, is what all Afghanis say...if you are their brother, then give them what they want..why is Pakistani Army fighting Pashtuns?

[@RohitSingh-hs7my]

In your dreams BLA, TTP and Afghans are playing so well tum Pakistani apni imaginary world se niklo bangladesh bhi muslim country thi 😂

[@kaka-editx]

​@@RohitSingh-hs7mywo muslim country hee hai

[@kartikeydetha6614]

historian RN Prasad - “Kabulis were overawed and they submitted to the Kachhawaha forces. Kabul lay at the feet of Kuar Man Singh” (Raja Man Singh of Amber Pg 65).

[@kartikeydetha6614]

“Kabulis were overawed and they submitted to the Kachhawaha forces. Kabul lay at the feet of Kuar Man Singh” (Raja Man Singh of Amber Pg 65).

[@freedom3040]

Pashtuns were Buddhists first, they became muslims and killed invaders who wanted to invade.

[@Unknown___5]

Pashtun were Zoroastrian first then budisht

[@susan_finds]

Oh 😂 fool I'm also Pathan we was (bani Israel) we was jews🇮🇱

[@Unknown___5]

@@susan_finds da kam zai pashtun ye ao kaam de sa dae? Its proven we are iranic not yahudi You are yahudi maybe but not pashtun.

[@Sapnfap]

@@susan_finds maybe one day israel and pashtun can be good friends I hope

[@ExamCracker912]

Ask aurangzeb we pashtun sold mughal soldiers in central Asia who had fallen to us as prisoners. The past was past now pashtun is more dangerous with AK 47. 😂. Always those succeeded who had divided us and our pashtun only can be bought with money or can be divided . But we cannot be defeated in the war field. I am pashtun I know that for me giving life is easier than anything when it comes to badal or revenge, pride, and dignity and respect

[@daimhussain8509]

Grow up

[@dk-zp5ze]

Maro ek dusre ko fir. Duniya bohot aage chale gae hai

[@itsVbts]

Manikant sir ko bulaye please please🙏

[@_Tavster]

Its gorkhaland not northern bengal

[@rounakrizvi2915]

Oo sabji Bengoli log humko maar Raha Hain । Gorubathan ke base main jate Hain wo safe hoga

[@HimanshuSingh-nw2yy]

Raja Man Singh commander of Mughal empire conquered Afghanistan.

[@patrioticindian7685]

Lol then what about the retaliation they literally fucked up every rajput that came in their way

[@abhiframes]

Why this invading pasthuns couldn't make a sea port for Afghanistan,which now has to depend on other countries for foreign trade??

[@strawmanfallacy8666]

Afghanistan is a landlocked country

[@tacticalthinkers3133]

Pastun follow there ancient khatriya rule... Till now..

[@IndianKGB]

what is that

[@IndianKGB]

khatriya or kshatriya ?

[@patrioticindian7685]

Every muslim is a kshatriya

[@adnan_hashmi]

Afghans engage in 'bacha-baazi'; Pashtuns do not.

[@allahmuhammad225]

Actually it is only Pashtuns in Afghanistan who are Bacha Baz… there are dozens and dozens of videos of Pashtoon Taliban soldiers and commanders who are engaging with each other, in that kind of act. New York Times, Los Angeles Times, times of UK Boston Globe, and Washington times - these are the most prestigious and trusted newspapers in the world- all of them have articles about Pashtun Bacha Bazi - check them out on Google

[@IndianKGB]

Pakistanis engage in 'bakri-baazi'

[@Aliy.zai.dt5lc]

There are about 85 to 90 million,s Pashtun ,s in the world 🌎

[@syedahmed9040]

This guy is obessed over Pakistan like an Ex. Bhai jaan chor dou aur koi cheez pr kaan karlo 😂

[@dk-zp5ze]

The guy is a researcher lol he's not your prime time news anchor. Some of his books are used as textbooks in pakistan.

[@Aliy.zai.dt5lc]

Afghan or pakhtun or pashtun or pathan or Awghan

[@igautamlasgotra]

1st comment, Pin!!❤

[@maheshjs4251]

Please make some useful comments

[@puskarhazra3614]

❤ From Bengal 🚩🇮🇳

[@divyata.a4540]

Hindustan matlab Punjab belt…….??…….I think…….according to ths afghans.

[@anilsharma3407]

Bravery tales 😅😅 Soviets killed more than 30 lakhs pashtoons with only few thousands casualties 😢😢 U.S.A killed more than 12 to 13 lakhs , with 3 to 4 thousand casualties and kept taliban in control for almost 18 years --

[@Alice-7777]

Lol

[@gauravdey4163]

Both failed ultimately with Trillion dollars money spent. Everyone needs to Come together to Civilise Taliban.

[@mansoorahmad822]

Lol

[@ExamCracker912]

War is the number game it is the final moment who plead for surrender treaty

[@sokikrong2649]

Dude i love the guests but questions are so off putting. Breaks the flow🥲

[@allahmuhammad225]

This guy is spreading misinformation and trying to sale Afghanistan as a Pashtun country. But the fact of the matter is, Pashtuns make up 35 to 40 percent of the population, the other 60 to 65 percent is Iranian Tajiks, Mongolic Hazaras and Turkic Uzbeks. The country in its current geography came into existence in the last 2 decades of 19th century, through an agreement by the Russian czars and British India, they fixed its borders in the north with Central Asia and its southern borders with British India - with the intention to have it serve as a buffer zone between these two powers. Ever since some puppet Pashtun was installed as the figurehead by some outside power. Just like today, Pashtun Taliban are brought to power by the Pakistani establishment. Now the Question arises why these foreign powers didn’t install a figurehead from other ethnic groups in the country? Other ethnic groups are more independent minded, and think on individual basis vs Pashtuns who are backward and tribal people - they are against everything that modern humans see it as progress. The only thing that they’re interested from the modern world is weaponry AK-47, and that is because throwing stones and beating each other with the sticks will not cause much damage. So this kind of mindset and mentality give an advantage to a foreign power to control them easily, and if they convinced the tribal leader about something, the whole tribe was at their service.

[@priyanshshrivastava7006]

But the fact is every Afghani hates bhikharistan

[@abc30610]

​@@priyanshshrivastava7006The Fact is Pakistan hosts highest number of Afghan refugees in the world.why they seek refuge/migrate to Pakistan when they hate it.

[@imranfaisal9040]

I agree with you, there are other ethnic groups as well, why don't we highlight them and talk about them

[@Unknown___5]

Pashtun are themselves iranic race lol.

[@allahmuhammad225]

@@Unknown___5 They are not a homogeneous racial group. There are many groups mixed and interbreed with them, including Iranians as well as Turks Semitic Jews, even Dravidians.

[@bvssrsguntur6338]

Such a horrible loud music at the end. Who comes up with such ideas

[@nomadicmritunjaya774]

Ranveer do not behave like a child before guests, listen like a mature person, otherwise if you want to make it a personal conversation then do not put in on youtube please. Interrupting continously is irritating for us to watch.

[@ghalibthemagnificent]

The largest population of Pashtuns live in Pakistan's southern city of Karachi, which is far away from Pashtun homeland of Pakhtunkawa and Afghanistan Pashtun areas. Stop feeding lies to Indian public and stop with this narrative of Afghans hate Pakistan.

[@danielandresgarciadelgado4337]

I surrender ❤

[@dingusfartacus9624]

interviewer is out of his depth

[@coolsummer5748]

Pakistan pakhon is best and educated.

[@ammarrashid3535]

Pakistani pashtuns in Pakistan are definitely not a fan of Afghanistan. My pashtun friend has quoted that afghan pashtuns are the bad lot among pashtuns. Pashtuns of pakistan are an intergral part of Pakistan for example the ex PM was a pashtun and he was voted in Punjab in majority. KPK which is pashton majority province is an intergal part of Pakistan. The historian is a little off from the ground reality.

[@furqanulhaq7250]

At the end of the day we are Muslims and muslims are brothers. These man made borders cant divide us. I know it makes hindus unhappy.

[@IndianKGB]

Hindus don't care and the person you see in video is R&AW who served there in pakistan and he is just here to share his opinion. cope.

[@susan_finds]

@@IndianKGB then you obsessed with us 😂😂😂

[@Taken11111]

Nath daal ke rakhi hui thee Sikh Sardaro ne Afghano ko...is ke ilawa..70aadmi napoleaon ke army se Iran ke king ke paas Aaye thee Naukri ke Liye...usne kaha Mai Maharaja Ranjit Singh se pooch ke bataugaa...to unka jawab thaa hum fir unke paas he jayenge...Bera garak kar diya Pakistani Muslim punjabio ne Baad me...inke baro ne naa jaante Kitne dukho se Islam zabardasti kabool Kiya Hoga lekin...inke bachhe ...tauba...wo to kehte hai Islam he sab Kuch hai...isko kehte hai un bareeeoo se Pyar ho jaana Jo kabhi Tumhe pehniyee gayee thee...aur agar koi un bariyoo ko utaaree to Tum us se laro Maro...Bhai Kya nahi thaa India me Jo Tumhe paraii qaum ka mazhab itna Pyar ho gaya...kum to koi Hindu religion bhi nahi...achi khaase cheese hai isme...Haal ye hua ke Pakistani punjabio ke festivals bhi safe Arabi ke ho gayee...Khana bhi badlo...lekin wo mushkil hai chahae Tumm prophet Muhammad ka bhi wasta de do.....

[@akashvaidsingh]

Its look like they are brain dead, taking revenge is superior then anything

[@MA-sp9dl]

These things are disappearing and does not happen any more.