Why Does Hermione Google Autofill | Harry Potter Film Theory

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

Make J Grow a Mustache in May Follow in Instagram :: instagram.com/jonkerlin/ Sign up for our Newsletter :: supercarlinbrothers.com/ Donate to Stop Sarcoidosis :: stopsarcoidosis.rallybound.org/SuperCarlinBrothers

[@danielsantiagourtado3430]

Love your content guys! Hearth please ❤❤❤❤❤

[@MrAlmostEasy69]

What if Hermione was in Raven claw?

[@ZedemMonk]

I wonder what sort of donation would be required to make it a toothbrush mustache...

[@plotholedetective4166]

Better help is a scam and the advice you gave is super unhealthy. You should not be suppressing emotion like that, anger is not bad nor is hate. Hate is the natural reflex a person has to protect something they love by any and all means including but not limited to violence or destruction. Tolerance is a persons ability to ignore something that is bad and is not good for you either. You need to stop embracing your weakness.

[@lukemiller5986]

love the mustache!

[@mikebrown1881]

Hermione modified her parents memories, not erased them. A modified memory can be reversed to normal, an erased memory cannot be retrieved. So the movie is wrong, she didn’t used obliviate on her parents.

[@jennifercook6497]

❤

[@satsujin-shathewitchkingof6185]

Makes me wonder why Slughorn didn't erase the horcrux memory

[@mikebrown1881]

@@satsujin-shathewitchkingof6185maybe out of guilt and knowing Dumbledore would want to know the truth at some point…

[@TheKabuto90]

@@satsujin-shathewitchkingof6185 Well, I'd imagine that Obliviate is an incredibly dangerous spell. We've only actually seen it cast on-page one time and we all know what the result of that was, just total amnesia. We have no precedent for erasing just specific memories so we have no way of knowing if that much is even possible.

[@mikebrown1881]

@@TheKabuto90 Hermione uses obliviate on Dolohov when the trio is attacked by two Deatheaters in a cafe in London. Later it seems that Dolohov is quite well. Lockhart uses obliviate on the wizards whom he steels the stories and they are not suffering of total amnesia. He forgets everything because it was his intent for Ron and Harry. I think Slughorn didn’t erase his memory because he knows it is a precious one, even if he doesn’t like what it shows of him.

[@Flatline1914]

Love to hear the return of “THESE SOCKS ARE AMAZING” 😂

[@camwyn256]

Wait, that actually happened? I thought I just imagined it.

[@camwyn256]

And I do need new socks

[@madethistocomment727]

I was not expecting that

[@bethanyhill8088]

As a person from the UK at the grand old age of 30, snogging is an absolutely horrific word

[@anilnandakumar9452]

It just sounds..........disgusting

[@kaitlynmcarthur]

i’m 18, and from Scotland. i agree.

[@amberr3662]

As a person from the UK who is under 18, it's still used, and still sounds gross

[@fingolfin9086]

To be fair, I’m 36 from the US and we would just say making out, which isn’t any better.

[@Karak971]

​@@fingolfin9086 im sorry, but "making out" is **leagues** better than "snogging"

[@malcolm32]

On the contrary, I think the Weasleys definitely own at least one if not several lawn mowers (have you MET Arthur??), and making one of her boys mow the lawn without magic seems like exactly the type of chore Molly would use as a punishment.

[@Kmmlc]

And not the gas ones, the old push bladed ones. But I always interpreted her like for the smell as being something she smells at the Weaseley's (along with Harry's floral scent that he smells there too). But honestly freshly mown grass is a fantastic smell, it's almost like a cilantro smell to me and always evokes freshness.

[@danmcnamara4640]

well to be fair barty crouch jr does have access to the T.A.R.D.I.S. so i dont think he needs a time turner

[@MatildaV1980]

😂😂

[@laurahudson8210]

ba-da-bum-tish

[@Beanzoboy]

As often as the T.A.R.D.I.S. misses its mark (often by years/decades) not sure it would be all that useful for going back by an hour multiple times per day, every day for years.

[@kandipiatkowski8589]

Best comment ever!!!

[@DanielaDormiaru-ih9xf]

😄😄

[@MiladyMacabre]

Hermione knows the scent of freshly mown grass from her Muggle upbringing.

[@Mary_Studios]

Right like how could they forget about that?

[@missnight0wl333]

Yeah, I feel like it really is a big stretch just to support Harmione. I'm pretty sure not all scents in Amortentia has to be related to your romantic attraction. I mean, new parchment could be related to both Ron and Harry, but mostly it's about something she enjoys HERSELF. Also, how long is Harry supposed to smell like FRESHLY MONW grass after mowing it during the summer holidays?

[@alisemaleneohme4666]

I always thought this was a "mown grass is done during summer, during summer she's at home with her parents, whom she love"

[@justloadalready8839]

Honestly I think the smell of love potions may change ovetime for the person smelling it, as we grow and experience new moments of love. Hermione likely smells grass because of her childhood (living in a well of suburb area, so a love of home), Parchment (from the library, for her love of learning), and spearmint (representing her love of her parents). These are likely what makes Amortentia so powerful, in my opinion. Your greatest moments of love are being reflected at your mind and befuddling your senses, making you feel those powerful sensations all at once with so many types of love. It's why it doesn't make real love, only an obsessive sort. The person using it will never create their own actual moment of love to make a smell attach to such a powerful memory, so it fades when the user stops dosing their chosen love interest.

[@sawanna508]

That's a beautiful explanation thank you.

[@nerdragon2649]

4:02 I've always interpreted this specific point as Obliviating Charms being different from Memory Altering Charms. As in, Obliviate erases one's memory, while what Hermione did to her parents merely "camouflages memories", leaving false memories in their stead. Of course, I could be totally wrong but it's the only way I can think of to solve what would be a plothole otherwise.

[@manvsmachineyt]

Could be a confundus charm

[@nerdragon2649]

@@manvsmachineyt Well, I guess it's a possibility, but Confundus feels more like it just makes people dumb and confused, not something able to completely rewrite their memories with a completely new backstory and personality.

[@d22777]

This is exactly what happened. Although we know that the Obliviating charm also does not erase memories(Voldemort could make them resurface),but the Memory Altering charm is a lighter version of that. It's implied, heck straight up said by Hermione that if she survives, she will restore their memories. She doesnt say it will be complicated or anything. But regardless "modyfing" and "deleting" memories were always different things. We know the spell for the "memory deleter" charm which is "Obliviate" we dont know the other one(hence why Hermione said she didn't do the "delete" charm before)

[@nerdragon2649]

@@d22777 My point exactly. And yes, Obliviate is Memory Deleting-ish, since severe trauma can un-delete said memories. Its more like a Memory Blocker charm, burying them so deep in your subconscious that only very severe trauma may cause them so ressurface. Of course, that could mean that the plot hole is real and Hermione did in fact erase her parents' memories, which in turn means that her solution to restoring their memories is prolonged severe torture. Which I dunno, but doesn't sound like Hermione at all...

[@d22777]

@@nerdragon2649 no it's clearly different. Like the obliviating charm is delete-ish(and can only be restored with difficulty. For example stuff deleted from a hard drive can be restored only with skill and time. But if you put stuff into a hidden folder, that's just a click of a button to restore. And we saw how a badly(superficially modified memory looks like with Slughorn. My guess is that her parents' memories would be similar that's why she sent them to Australia. She said that it will be easy to restore them.

[@alastorclark3492]

8:40 I saw no point to Hermione not telling the truth here. The second part is basically the truth she just didn't know about the troll while in the bathroom

[@Beanzoboy]

Yeah. "I was in the bathroom before the troll came in. They knew I was here and came to save me." 100% true, and doesn't make her look like an idiot. Not sure why she didn't just say it.

[@kiweping5]

As far as she knows, they just came looking for the troll, so she just said she went looking for the troll instead to show her gratitude.

[@alastorclark3492]

@@kiweping5 That's a fair argument although I think it's fair to say she could have assumed they were looking for her. It's not really laid out plainly that that is what she was thinking short of that it does better fit why she lied.

[@kiweping5]

@@alastorclark3492 she was only in the bathroom because Ron made her cry, I don’t think her first thought would have been that they were looking for her

[@Nesmerized]

I always assumed she lied so that only she'd be punished with loss of house points, while they'd loose dubble the amount if Harry and Ron were the guilty ones. Felt like a clever Hermione-thing to do, but now I'm not so sure.

[@RiseeRee]

Hermione is a bit judgmental of Fleur, so mocking her is definitely in character lol. She constantly comments on Fleur’s complaints. Like when Fleur said she wouldn’t fit into her dress robes because of how heavy the Hogwarts food was, Hermione sarcastically says “Ooh there’s a tragedy”. And later on she and Ginny complain about Fleur being full of herself.

[@dontmisunderstand6041]

I enjoy analyzing stories. One of the fascinating parts of that analysis, to me, is figuring out where the author's biases shine through to break otherwise solid worldbuilding, character writing, or narrative structures. Harry Potter is particular interesting in that regard because Rowling's beliefs come across more clearly than anything else in her work. The way she uses caricatures to lambast facsimiles of people she doesn't like in her own life. The way the wizarding world reflects the flaws in her own view of how our world works. It really is fascinating. You can learn a lot about a writer by examining their writing.

[@JahanMisra]

4:15. Hermione probably uses the confundus charm on her parents, not obliviate. It seems that obliviate (the memory charm) erases memories but it doesn’t create new ones. the only spell we see that creates new false memories and removes memories is the confundus charm. Snape uses it on Mundungus to make him think the 7 Potters plan was his idea and to forget that he ran into Snape.

[@BigRob1994]

Who says that wizards dont mow grass? Ludo Bagman gave the Weasleys tickets to the World Cup because Arthur helped with a lawnmower that was acting unnaturally

[@victoriahua5856]

Your recall is detail! This comment is so underrated

[@MortenJessen-o7s]

If I recall correctly, what ever that lawnmower did, it was NOT mowing grass... Unless mowing grass using muggle metods, is so embarrassing for wizards, that Ludo Bagman just had to pay 9 (iirc) luxury tickets for the world cup to hide the embarrassment his brother Otto cost the family for using muggle methods.

[@BigRob1994]

@@MortenJessen-o7s but why would they have a lawnmower at all if they don’t mow grass?

[@scbafreak]

I prefer Hermione and Ron. When Harry is off doing something by himself, they are spending time together. In the books, Ron is not as useless and Hermione recognizes this and they respect each other's different skills, but still are able to joke with each other.

[@rainbowshiningstar2770]

I know right!! I think about that all the time.

[@marshawargo7238]

And they had lots of time for a friendship to grow into more when getting to know each other without Harry as a third wheel because of his entrapment at the Dursley's each summer that Hermione is there ❤

[@fishandjam5383]

Also, in Philosopher's Stone (the book):- Harry: "So light a fire!" Hermione: "Yes - of course - but there's no wood!" Ron: "HAVE YOU GONE MAD? ARE YOU A WITCH OR NOT?" 7 years later, in Deathly Hallows (again, the book), at the base of the Whomping Willow:- Ron: "How - how're we going to get in? I can - see the place - if we just had - Crookshanks again -" Hermione: "Crookshanks? Are you a wizard, or what?"

[@thegingergyrl455]

Book Ron was awesome. Movie Ron, no so much. ✌🏻👩🏻‍🦰👍🏻

[@edopronk1303]

There's also somewhere in the books that Harry compares Mr and mrs Weasley's bickering to Ron and Hermione.

[@МаксимЯромич]

That was Mr and Mrs Granger googling why Hermione doesn't come home. After the memory charms🤣

[@I_WillB]

@SuperCarlinBrothers I'm pretty sure the reason Hermione says "ze Grindelows" is because that is what exactly what Fleur says in the book: "Fleur had broken free of Madame Maxime and was hugging her sister. 'It was ze Grindelows ... zey attacked me ... oh, Gabrielle, I thought ... I thought...' " I assume in the movie since they had Hermione deliver the line instead of Fleur, she was directly quoting her (or making fun or her accent maybe).

[@missnight0wl333]

I'm sorry, but I feel like calling Ron and Hermione's jealousy game "toxic" is a bit of an overkill. It's not super healthy, but it's really not that bad, considering their relationship overall. And the fact they're teenagers.

[@baystated]

Hermoine could have told the truth about the troll. It would have still extolled the boy's bravery.

[@morrigankasa570]

But she was embarrassed that she was upset and crying in the bathroom before the troll stuff.

[@Beanzoboy]

@@morrigankasa570 "I was in the bathroom before the troll came in. They knew I was here and came to save me." 100% true, and doesn't make her look like an idiot. Not sure why she didn't just say it.

[@erikaczyn]

Yeah but maybe she thought the boys went after the troll, not that they were trying to help her?

[@RoseWillow13]

She didn't want them to get in trouble for insulting her and making her cry in the bathroom, because they saved her. It was repaying them for saving her life, not letting them (Ron mostly) get in trouble for bullying (or behind the back name-calling).

[@CarolynsReadingRamblings]

Awesome video as always! So what I always wondered with the Time Turner situation (that I'm sure many people have also thought of before) is why didn't Hermione also use the Time Turner to GET ENOUGH SLEEP?! Like surely Professor McGonagall would say that falls within the rules so then Hermione isn't getting so emotionally and physically exhausted from all the extra classes and work that she falls asleep in her normal classes and even the broom closet? (which is precisely what happened). And I would get the idea that she can't run into herself but she could wake up first thing in the morning then rotate the time turner back several hours and just find a secluded spot in the castle where no one goes at night and take a sleeping bag with her and that way she doesn't run into herself in the dorm. Is it ever explained why she doesn't use the Time Turner to get enough sleep? Okay sorry for the long ramble, again, amazing video as usual :D.

[@RJMiller73]

When would Hermione have ever smelled Harry after he’d mown the lawn? How would she even know he mows the lawn? The mown grass is obviously a reference to her hanging out with Ron at the Burrow before school started.

[@davidioanhedges]

Hermione's father is a dentist, who lived in an ordinary suburban house, and so presumably had a lawn and mowed it ... Fresh cut grass is a childhood memory - she never visited Privet Drive so it would not be associated with Harry

[@sarahlandis289]

Also toothpaste smell because her parents are dentists.

[@lauryn7158]

HEYYYYY BROTHERRRRR

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

Hey Brother!

[@DefileOdds]

​@@SuperCarlinBrothers heeeyyyy motheeeerrrr... Doh!

[@arilion11]

Hey brother!​@@SuperCarlinBrothers

[@SzaboB33]

I laughed out loud on that burn out joke at 16:37 but then I thought about how relatable it was and almost started crying ;-;

[@ronakdave4466]

J in moustache looks like he would come to me and ask me a difficult math question 🤣🤣

[@lauramathews3151]

Maybe the freshly mown grass had to do with the quidditch pitch.... like Harry and most of the Weasley kids [including Ron] were on the Gryffindor team...Also Arthur loves muggle stuff...

[@Soph1aF]

Ben and J, I just wanted to let you know that i LOVE your guys' videos! This is definitely my favorite channel. Thank you for being SUPER! :)

[@jennifercook6497]

I honestly get so tired of the Ron and Ginny hate from the Fandom. Hermione smelling the grass and the toothpaste makes perfect sense because they literally talked about it in the books when she was at Ron's place. Those two moments were purposely highlighted in the books. Also, in the books, Ron and Ginny were awesome and very complex. Ginny was perfect for Harry, and Ron was perfect for Hermione. Now none of them were perfect people, because nobody is perfect, but they complemented each other in the perfect way. The movies just RUINED the characters because they didn't believe in people's abilities to understand complexity, so they made Ron and Hermione as basic and annoying as possible, and practically made Ginny nonexistent until the end of the movies. Also, HARRY'S LOVE FOR HERMIONE WAS AS A FRIEND! The same as with Lily towards Snape. People romanticize friendships and make it really weird. Please stop. When we do this, we just enforce this negative societal stereotype that girls and guys can't just be good friends. That's why Snape and Lily's friendship went so badly. He kept taking friendship as something completely different from what it actually was, then got offensively angry when the situation didn't go the way he wanted. He was so angry that she married James Potter that he was willing to let this woman's husband AND ONE YEAR OLD CHILD die just so he could have a chance with her!🤢🤮

[@PhilBagels]

I'm sorry I can only give you one like. When I read the very first book - before the movies even came out - it was obvious that Harry and Ginny would wind up together. Ginny had a crush on Harry from the beginning, and the way it was described in the books was pretty obvious foreshadowing. And Ron and Hermione acted toward each other like an old married couple from the beginning as well.

[@Leentjhuuu]

This is such a great point. I only have to disagree about Snape. He truly loved Lilly in a Romantic way. He definitely takes it badly when she doesn't return, but there's a lot more to then just reading too much into a friendship.

[@resathe6760]

@@Leentjhuuu Snape might "love" her romantically (although I would rather call it an obsession, especially later in life) but Lily clearly only sees him as a friend.

[@Acromion11]

You crazy

[@LylaNox]

Slight correction; it states in the books thats Harry sees hermoine as a sister. But apart from that. I agree

[@center_nova_idols]

💡Random thought: You really need to put another wand in the empty space below the Spiderman poster on the opposite side facing the Elder Wand! Maybe Voldie's?😏 Then the painting would look like a collision between spells!🤯 Pleeeaase!!! 😆

[@Ralph-rr9iv]

Honestly, I ALWAYS!!! believed Ron and Hermonie were perfect for each other. They were just too stubborn to realize it tell book seven.

[@kiminimuchu__]

Hermione didn't solve the mystery of the chamber of secrets before Ginny steals the diary back from Harry, nor that would have made any sense. She figures it out and is immediately petrified, Ginny had already stolen the diary days before and was now writing on it again, hence the attack on Hermione even being able to happen.

[@JordanIdk]

Here's a Harry Potter theory, how is it possible that multiple classes for the same year run at once (as we know from year 3?) We know that students pick two elective subjects from five. This means they're going to be students in the same year taking multiple different combinations of subjects, so someone would always be unable to attend both of their subjects. This is further compounded by only some houses having some subjects together, which implies the teachers must teach these lessons multiple times per week. Another thing that doesn't make sense, despite being elective, it appears that every student in Gryffindor appears in care of magical creatures and divination. Are we supposed to believe that everyone just chose the same two subjects as Harry? Was Hermione the only one who took arithmancy, ancient runes or muggle studies in the entire year?

[@needsanameedit4982]

I honestly forgot about the "These socks are amazing" bit at the end of the videos.

[@jessicaf316]

Can you explain “towel section down below”?????

[@doll9340]

​@@jessicaf316I want to know this too. Why do they call the comment section towels

[@LoneWolfLuna28]

10:55 That's not a red flag or toxic. It's just a basic teenage relationship.

[@tazisme5751]

"Parenting is easyy" got me

[@regs137]

Fun fact. Better Help is under investigation by the FTC .

[@pinchusyagid8225]

Got any more info?

[@mareezollinger3184]

Cinema Therapy addressed this. From the info they provided, that is no longer the case. Better Help complied to everything requested and helped adjust laws and policies regarding the protection of personal information and are helping that change be implemented in other health companies, as well. From what the guys on Cinema Therapy said, Better Help didn't do anything illegal and were totally compliant in helping everything be made right for any alleged accusations. I don't know the details, myself, but last I knew this was the case. 🤷‍♀️

[@littlefoot5013]

I have an interesting what if idea: What if Mundungus had been killed instead of Moody during the Battle of the Seven Potters? I mean, Mundungus looked liked Harry, due to the Polyjuiice potion, and it was mundungus fleeing that got Mad Eye off his guard and left him open to attack. Now, it's possible that Mad Eye might find his way to Grimmauld Place, just like Lupin did. However, the issue is, with Mundungus dead, Harry would have trouble tracking down the locket. On the other hand, and this would be a more major change, now without Yaxley being taken to Grimmauld Place, Harry, Ron, and Hermoine may have kept using it as a hideout for longer. Not sure how much longer, but perhaps a while. And if they didn't happen to have been where Dean Thomas, Ted Tonks,a nd the goblings were, they wouldn't have realized the important information about the sword, and also, that fight with Ron may not have happened. Plus, it was the malovenlt influence of the Horcrux that was influencing Ron that brought it out of him. But they wouldn't have it here. Still, without the information about the sword, it's possible that Ron and Hermoine said no about Godrich's Hollow. And, if so, then Harry didn't break his wand.

[@spencertaylor-mrliltay]

Yeah I'm definitely not on the side of Harry and Hermione should've ended up together. Especially in the books Ron and Hermione, and especially Harry and Ginny are built up to much better than in the movies.

[@TheKabuto90]

It's never made sense to me. They absolutely love each other but it's very much a relationship closer to siblings than romantic partners.

[@spencertaylor-mrliltay]

@@TheKabuto90 Yeah that's how I always felt about Harry and Hermione. Like I know really the whole trio might seem that way at least for the first 3 books/movies. It doesn't really even occur to Ron and Harry to look at Hermione as things like "pretty" until their 4th year and after but when they finally do it's Ron who seems to feel more that way whereas Harry and Hermione just continue to love each other as something like siblings.

[@Tomthestarhartnell]

I feel like Ron and Hermione balance each other out. Ron's courage and strength definitely comforted Hermione, and his support for her gave her confidence in her abilities.

[@wolverinefangowings]

I love how many of these can be answered with "the movies got it wrong."

[@danielsantiagourtado3430]

Google autofil is amazing! Thanks For this 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@Foxy2D]

Yay J has uploaded and he has a new beautiful mustache

[@Mpot1us]

Say what?

[@mikkelgravsholt4693]

Theory idea: Why didn’t Voldemort protect the location of his Hocruxes in himself with the Fidelias Charm?

[@kaylahensley1581]

Voldemort couldn’t trust anyone to be his Secret Keeper.

[@PerovNigma]

​@@kaylahensley1581 Maybe Nagini?

[@kaylahensley1581]

@@PerovNigma Theoretically, but I don’t think a snake could be a Secret Keeper.

[@PerovNigma]

@@kaylahensley1581 She has human intelligence, and she's not incapable of communicating. I see no reason why not.

[@chrisbirch2848]

Love y’all’s channel man I watch it all the time you guys have single handedly change the game with Harry Potter it takes me back to that world all over again I’ve read the books multiple times but I love how yall do what if’s and theory’s just makes it that more magical

[@mistajay6522]

I haven't watched this channel in years and it warms my heart to see that despite all the changes and struggles this still remains with the same energy and passion. This brings me so much nostalgia and I am here for that. ❤

[@erictayet]

I've written about this before at this channel IIRC. Hermione is insecure even when she scores great in school. Harry, with all the dark things happening around him ALL THE TIME doesn't give her any sort of security. She loves him for sure because she respects the incredible courage Harry shows and how great his abilities are. Ron on the other hand has the same courage but none of the indecisiveness nor does he attracts dark wizards left right and centre. Ron is also pretty shallow and will generally just do as he's told by his loved ones so he'll make a great husband. Harry needed someone who's strong and can be an equal partner emotionally. Ginny can take care of herself in a fight and she's had a crush on Harry since before the meeting at Platform 9 3/4. She is also willing to accept all the dark things since she was part of Tom Riddle's plan in Chambers of Secret. It's too bad Ginny wasn't given much screen time in the movies so I'm starting to read the books. Viktor is like a toyboy or celebrity football star. Hermione like smart guys. Haven't read the books, dunno if Viktor is smart, don't cast Crucio on me!

[@DawnoftheDance4477]

This is the best breakdown I’ve seen for this. I always just thought JK wanted to make them all family but I like your explanation better

[@juliaellertsouza3577]

Viktor is actually smart and also likes to read. He meets her at the school library and that's when he starts to have a crush on her

[@erictayet]

@@juliaellertsouza3577 thanks for that. :) I'm starting to read the books so I didn't know that yet. Many books to go before Goblet of Fire.

[@dontmisunderstand6041]

You forgot what actually makes Ron a good partner for Hermione. Her ego lets her get carried away too often. Ron is the one to call her out on her nonsense. He sticks up for her when she deserves it, and calls her out on it when she's the problem. He balances her out, to literally make her a better and more complete person.

[@lilia3944]

I'd disagree with Ron doing as he's told - he argues with Hermione freuqently and calls her out on her bs. Book Ron is smart, he just doesn't study much, he supports Hermione when that's needed and gives her a reality check otherwise. That - in a healthy, adult way instead of 12yos bickering - is exactly what Hermione needs. Harry doesn't like arguments (understandable, considering his history), he avoids Ron and Hermione when they're bickering, he's loyal and forgiving to a fault. He needs someone keeping him grounded, Hermione needs someone keeping her grounded, they think of each others as siblings and that works great. If you haven't read the books, you'll have a lot of character to look forward to! Ron and Ginny are more fleshed out, Hermione gets the flaws the movies gave to Ron back and they're overall more balanced.

[@xarenanotmyrealname4134]

⚠️Off topic from video day two of asking⚠️ Here are the what ifs I think need to happen. 1: What if Dudley went to Hogwarts? 2: What if Aang died and one of the other characters became the avatar? I think the most interesting would be Zuko or Sokka. 3: What if Prim became the Mockingjay? The only way I see this happening is if Katniss gets caught hunting and either gets killed or sent to the Capital to become an avox a year or two before she gets reaped and has to get survival skills not as good as Katniss but better than nothing.

[@lordenz1666]

That was awesome! Thx Jonathan for the informative video 😁. Do you plan on doing this segment more often, maybe with Snape?

[@jetjunkie3417]

I'm more of a harry + luna than harry and hermione.

[@daniilmihalev2552]

A video idea - what if Peter Petigrew was sorted in Slytherin? How does the story change, does he became friends with James and a secret keeper?

[@sarahlandis289]

He definitely shouldn't have been in Gryffindor, he's a coward.

[@lizzlocke3130]

6:47 oh my god you did not just drop in my favorite Hermione moment. Actually one of my favorite moments in general. Her tone and her sweetness just melts my heart! ahh 12:22 is my other favorite!

[@diamondz104]

Day 11 of asking can you do a video where the Potters survived? The scenario I'll make up is when Voldemort breaks in, Instead of killing James, he tortures and used the paralyzing spell on him and makes him pass out and plans to finish him off later when Harry is dead because as Snape said, he likes waiting for his enemies to beg for death before killing them. Upstairs with Lily, the same thing basically happens except Lily misses the curse and falls on the ground. Harry still gets the love protection and Voldemort still loses his body because Lily was prepared to sacrifice herself for Harry. We saw this in Deathly Hallows when Harry's protection from sacrificing himself stopped Voldemort from torturing Neville when he stood up, Even though Harry didn't die.

[@sawanna508]

Harry did die but came back. He had a near death experience sort of.

[@clid8585]

The stash is coming along well

[@goodsamaritangaming1997]

I still don't understand why Hermione would lie. She could simply have said she didn't know about the troll so Harry and Ron came to let her know and ended up saving her from the troll. Or something along those lines closer to the truth. You wouldn't think they'd get in trouble for letting someone know about the danger when the teachers didn't know she wasn't with the rest of the group.

[@leventebardossy5962]

True, but when asked why she wasn't with them at the Halloween feast, she wouldn't have been happy to admit she was there crying her eyes out about Ron's comment all afternoon.

[@goodsamaritangaming1997]

@@leventebardossy5962 True. Although, if she was going to lie anyway, she could have simply lied about why she was in the bathroom and saved herself from taking the fall when she wasn't to blame either. I don't know. Her taking the blame might have been for the best after all.

[@XxCJOxX]

Love the stash, J

[@Bethany-fo6lt]

Maybe it's because I've read too many fanfics, but I have a sad head cannon that her parents started to either be afraid of Hermione's magic or disproved of it somehow, or that they wanted her to go into the family business, but she liked magic too much. After many arguments, she started to see them less and less, choosing to stay in the Wizarding world, but she still loved them, so put the memory charms on them to protect them.

[@lilia3944]

That's an interesting theory. I always thought Hermione didn't want them to worry about the war and everything - she's not great at hiding her emotions, and it's easier to pretend everything is fine in letters than in person.

[@HPOL001]

On the point of Hermione and Viktor Krum I’ll never understand how people have never talked about how creepy that relationship really is. She’s 14 (maybe 15 cuz she’s older than the boys) and Viktor is what?? Maybe 18 at youngest. They’re basically the equivalent of a freshman dating a senior in American schools and I’ll never let go how creepy that is and nobody ever seems to point that out.

[@LegioXXI]

I don't think so. At 18 you still a half child, no matter if you are legally an adult (in the real world), your adult life just started. In many nations there are even still age restrictions for certain things to the age of 20 or 21 because of that. At the same time Hermione is very mature for her age and Krum never behaved inappropriately towards her (or any other person as far as we know). If he was already 20+, then i would agree. But calling it "creepy" is a bit harsh, especially considering what a shy dork Krum actually is towards her. Not every Teenager develops at the same speed, this is why imho it's not justified to just dogmatically count the years of age difference between teens and then judge it, without considering any other factor whatsoever. Inappropriate - maybe. But "creepy"? It's not like they slept together. People throw the word "creepy" around way too often these times.

[@sawanna508]

Since Hermione used a time turner and was already older then the boys she is surely beyond 15. -Also at the time the movie came out 15 was the concense age in my country. But even if you go by US standarts. In the 90s movie "What women want" the 15 year old daughter of the protagonist ahs a relationship with an 18-year old. The protagonist is against it of course and in the end the boyfriend treats her badly. How ever my point is that the girl's mother dosn't ahve any opjections against the realtionship and through a great part of the movie the father's reation is portrait as a little overreacting.

[@carlrood4457]

Altering her parents' memories doesn't really make sense unless she was MORE concerned that they'd try to help, rather than just protect them from the Death Eaters. The witness protection thing in Australia would have amounted to the same level of protection because the Death Eaters' memories weren't affected. THEY still would have known what the Grangers looked like. Whether THEY remembered they had a daughter was irrelevant. In fact it prevented them from being aware they were even in danger. If they were found, they could still be used against Hermione because SHE still remembered and cared about them.

[@marshallpeters7174]

Sending them to Australia was to get them away from the situation. The Death Eaters would have had a hard time finding them that far away, when they could be anywhere in the world. She modified their memories so they wouldn't be worried about her or miss her, and they could live out their lives happily if she didn't survive. She sent them away so the Death Eaters couldn't use them as hostages to get to her, as you said.

[@morrigankasa570]

Hermione and Ron fall in love because they are soulmates meant to be together! What's more they balance each other out & even in the 1st book it was hinted at she liked him. What's more it creates the best intersection of families. Ron marrying Hermione ties their families close together. She is an only child and then gets multiple siblings-in-law. Ginny marrying Harry ties their families closer together. He is an only child (though was raised with Dudley but it's not a good relationship until after 5th year). But now has a loving family with multiple siblings-in-law. If however Harry married Luna then would be 2 only childs marrying each other=smaller family, similarly if he married Hermione same thing. Which would also leave Ron being alone/unmarried miserable forever. 4:28

[@RVGrannyWA]

I always thought Hermoine fell for Ron because she was an only child and was in love with his big beautiful family. Also in the book she was supposed to be homely. The movie version of her character was beautiful and that confused a lot of the audience who didn't read the books. In contrast the actress who portrayed Jenny was pretty, Jenny in the book was very popular and described as gorgeous.

[@darthmeticulous6901]

#1 Rule of Interacting With Hermione Jean Granger… DO NOT make Hermione angry. It won’t end well.

[@PhilBagels]

You wouldn't like her when she's angry.

[@LegioXXI]

Hermione is actually very bad when it comes to controlling her anger. She barely tries to de-escalate, is sarcastic and insulting and hold grudges much longer than Ron or Harry. You can already see this in Book 3, where she utterly refuses the possibility of thinking she could be wrong (another frequent trait of her) to the point where she risked the friendship with Ron. This is why i like Book Hermione waaay more than her movie adaptation, where she was basically made a Mary Sue. In the books she has flaws and is wrong many times like every real human being, which is also highlighting how she needs a relationship with a guy like Ron who actually stands up against her when she is wrong. Almost all other people she interacts with just reinforce her self-image of the "clever girl who is never wrong" (especially teachers, where she really does shine with her knowledge), but with this attitude you can't grow as a person. Ron grounds her. Harry for example barely does that, usually he just quietly retreats when there is a conflict between him and her - like when they argue about the Deathly Hallows. Or he even just agrees because he is too tired to argue, even when he has more arguments over her (like just knowing that there is a Horkrux in Hogwarts thanks to his understanding and connection of Voldemort, and Hermione just keeps dismissing it).

[@jimmy50908]

17:22 You guys often say this that Percy and Crouch jr. also must have had a time turner, but I think you are forgetting that Hermionie always tried her absolute hardest to get the best possible grade in her tests (getting 112% in charms in her first year, and similar in future tests). So she would have been definitely going for Outstanding marks in all her tests/assignments, so she would have needed a time turner to do this. But I think Percy and especially Crouch jr. might have just settled for Acceptable or Exceeds expectations grades in their 12 classes, meaning they probably could have just worked hard but not used a time turner. Although I think if either of them had it, it was Percy due to your additional theory about Fred & George using a time turner to know the result of the quidditch world cup and bet all their money with bagman based on that result.

[@erikaczyn]

She needs the time turner to be in two classes at once because some of the classes are scheduled at the same time

[@zoelaetitiabeatrix6656]

@@erikaczyn I think they are saying that maybe they missed some classes and went to them alternately each week

[@Charzar816]

I need the COS episode of Book Covers!!

[@andrewwashere82]

Shame Richard Harris passed after the first 2 movies. He was how I envisioned Dumbledore while reading the books. Nothing personal to Michael Gambon.

[@BasicallyBaconSandvichIV]

"Why does Hermione fall in love with Ron?" is actually a good question because in the OTHER teenage fantasy book series which grows up with the reader and was written by a white English woman (Among many other things they have in common.) Camicazi doesn't end up in love with Hiccup or Fishlegs if I remember correctly. Showing that when you have a trio of main characters with one girl and two boys it ISN'T NECESARY for some of them to fall in love. Especially SINCE THERE'S A BLOODY WAR ON! Things like this is why I think more people should read the How To Train Your Dragon books. It is INCREDIBILY different from the movie, but still as good. Perhaps even better. Definitely better then the later movies.

[@tinas_hotdog_sophie]

I also call some people by their full names, even in writing. So many of my friends go by shorter versions of their names and I call them that, but with some I just can't.

[@kjs22]

Mustache looking great Jazzy J

[@jennifercook6497]

❤😂

[@HogsHighlights]

Actually, Hermione did not obliviate her parents, she put a charm that momentarily made her parents forget about her, and she did uplift the cham. I believe she talks about this at the end of The Half-Blood Prince.

[@sarahloveless1726]

HOW LONG HAS THIS BEEN BACK. I LOVE this game and have never clicked on a video so quick

[@ElliePlayzGamez]

Always a Good day when you guys upload !!

[@kuroneko5390]

I dont think Ron and Hermine are a toxic couple, I think they are both insecure teenager's. As a teenager even if you suspect that someone likes you back it's still hard to just go and confess to them also they always have so much trouble going on having to be there for Harry. They know they bicker an fight alot so maybe they are affraid of what will happen if they get together and they have a fight that can't be resolved. Also they both want to be there for Harry and that's hard if they are fighting so maybe that's why they don't have enough courage to tell each other what they feel. Also Ron has this fear that she will prefer Harry, like all the other people do and he is not the most emotionally intelligent person. I do think it needed Lavander for Hermine to see that she has to be the proactive part if she wants to end up with him, but then Dumbledore died amd they had stuff to do and they put helping Harry first. I think we oftend forgett that these characters are teenagers , they still need to learn to be in a relationship and that means making mistakes. Also being a teenager sucks in general and they have to save the world a lot on top of this. I also think we use the word toxic a bit to much, not every person who makes a mistake or has some bad behaviours is a toxic personality. We all have pur flaws that we need tp grow out of, ecpecially when we are Teenagers. It's not like they are manipulative, abusive or gaslighting to each other. They are just struggling teenagers that have a complicated relationship.

[@Alvin-AbuVash]

15:33 you missed the mark. I'm sure her muggle father also mows the lawn. Good fathers teach their daughters what their future husbands should be like.

[@FulcanMal]

With the mention of Catelyn Stark, I would love for you guys to do something with 'A Song of Ice and Fire'. I know it's a lot more mature than the content you cover on this channel, but man it would be a wonderful blend of two things I really enjoy. Your content and 'A Song of Ice and Fire'. Yes, I know it is rather hindered by having, you know, not been finished.

[@AutumnFlower5]

I believe another reason why Hermione imitated Fleur by saying " ze grindylows" is because when Fleur arrived she insulted the food. Fleur went out her way to insult the food in english, a language that she and her friends and the rest of the Hogwarts students could understand versus speaking in french, a language that maybe not everyone in Hogwarts or at least in close proximity to her could understand. She insulted the food so everyone could hear and understand her perfectly instead of a language that they perhaps wouldn't all understand.

[@ehsteve23]

I’d love to hear some of Star Wars or Marvel what ifs in the style of your HP ones

[@matthewfrome7904]

And same with me too here so yeah!:)

[@t.j.armendariz354]

Hermione isn’t around Harry mowing grass, so she wouldn’t associate that with Harry in that way, it’s probably an allusion to her parents

[@markbrown2640]

I have not bothered to check any prior comments. I think that Hermione calling Ron "Ronald" is supposed to call back to when children upset their mothers and those mothers shout at the children using their full names. If you haven't figured out what I mean, let's imagine that she shouted "RONALD BILLIUS WEASLEY!" Are you getting the picture now?

[@patrickdematosribeiro1845]

Why does Hermione marry Ron is an easy one for me. Because she loves to argue and needs someone to fight back.

[@pb99-z3r]

5:25 Didn't you notice the trend here? The movie writers hated the Weasleys. They gave Ron's lines to Hermoine, dumbed down Ginney to the ground, removed Charlie, to name a few. 5:57 Or maybe because Lavander was using polyjuice potion in the first few years at Hogwarts *wink* change of actress. 7:14 Or maybe because Lavander got a plastic surgery but Hermoine despite being the daughter of dentists couldn't fix her buck teeth. 11:32 She has no blood bond requirement, now does she? 15:13 The spearmint toothpaste is an indication towards Ron because of a scene in the Borrows (also in HBP) where Ron mentions that Hermoine has toothpaste on her face. 16:02 Hermoine grew up in the muggle world, maybe she remembers mowing grass in her own house?

[@anilnandakumar9452]

Firstly, harry and hermi9ne only dance in the very non cannon movies. Secondly, Harry wouldn't have smelt of grass because the durselys stopped bullying him as much because of the Order's threat! So, no! Also, Ron and Hermione aren't toxic! At least not to each other! So just stop, pleeaaseee

[@bboops23]

I heard a great theory that Hermione actually modified her parents memories in the winter of her 5th year. She gives back for a ski trip and after that we have no evidence that she's actually ever seen them again. It's interesting to think about

[@elisabethcheesedragon]

Hermione likes freshly mown grass because it reminds her of her childhood.

[@hufflepom]

I’m way too excited for the Through the Griffin Tour. I may or may not be working on a massive project for y’all. lol.

[@ginnyjollykidd]

I have always wanted to know about Neville longbottom.

[@timothycoetzee1232]

loving the stache👌

[@PalmelaHanderson]

While Hermione is very smart, it's not until she gets a bit older that she really starts to be creative with her knowledge. When she first gets to Hogwarts, she just kind of regurgitates everything she reads from a book. I think that's why she didn't end up in Ravenclaw. Ravenclaw isn't just about rote memorization, they want you to think creatively. Hence why Luna is in Ravenclaw.

[@valathor95]

16:00 your ready for a long jog after that stretch. 😂

[@BlueJay2]

I really can't get behind the Harry and Hermione ship. He says that he thinks of Hermione like a sister, and in fourth year when he was only hanging out with Hermione because he and Ron had that fight, he was miserable and straight up thought that he liked Hermione, but he didn't really like hanging out with her one on one because it was really boring sometimes. That doesn't really sound like ship material to me.

[@NsTheName]

Agreed. People like the cliche main male and female together and that’s something that I love about Harry Potter. It flipped it on its head. The movies didn’t help with their clear Hermione bias. They took away all of her flaws and gave her all of Ron’s strengths to make her perfect and him an empty shell.

[@BlueJay2]

@@NsTheName yes exactly

[@dontmisunderstand6041]

@@NsTheName They very much didn't take away Hermione's flaws. Her main character flaw is allowing her ego to let her get carried away. It's exactly this self-destructive tendency that makes Ron a good match for her... because he's always the one to call her out on this. Every time. He sticks up for her when she deserves it, and calls her out when she's the problem. He's exactly the balance she needs in her life. I can't really see what she does to help him, but y'know... half of it makes sense. Whereas neither side really works with the harry/hermione ship. If anything, Harry exacerbates Hermione's existing flaws.

[@NsTheName]

@@dontmisunderstand6041 I definitely agree that Harry and Hermione aren’t a good match, but I still think they took out the majority of Hermione’s flaws. In the movie it seems like she believes in the Deathly Hallows because it’s never communicated to us that she thinks it’s absolute rubbish. She’s completely unable to think outside of the box. Harry is the one who immediately believes and won’t let it go. Also, the smith and flesh memories thing was Harry too. As soon as the minister was gone and they were up in Ron’s room he put it to his mouth and then they all debated over what they thought it meant. That’s just an example of where they switched it up to make Hermione even smarter, but she didn’t know everything and I liked that about her. She was extremely smart, but if something couldn’t be explain to her in a way that seemed logical then she wouldn’t accept it. Which actually makes me laugh because to be a witch or wizard in the muggle world is illogical. I imagine she accepted it fairly quickly because she’d been making things happen. Anyway, tangent. Haha

[@zimonzieclown1633]

3:07 This makes me wonder why Harry and Hermione didn't just disapparate to escape the Snatchers.

[@Dilophoraptor-q5b]

I so enjoy these Google auto files. Don't stop.😁

[@Aryan-jq8bt]

J aged 5-7 years by growing a moustache, officially looking like a dad.

[@anakamarvelous]

Read somewhere that the girls in school make fun of Luna and call her “Looney Love Good” and apparently Hermione be right there with em akekekeing so she just had a freudian slip in the carriage which surprised even her.

[@EpicMuttonChops]

after this video, i've learned the golden trio really should've ended up as a polycule

[@ArtByDesign80]

8:30 But that STILL MAKES NO SENSE! She could have told the truth to the same effect! That they knew she was in the bathroom and they came to get her. It does not matter WHY she was there.

[@glandersonbooper9342]

Keep that stache growing, goodsir.

[@chefRyan38]

I can't think of any instance Hermione would have been with Harry after he mowed the grass at the privet drive house

[@doll9340]

The scent was brought up because Hermione was raised muggle so she would know the scent of mowed grass and since Harry was also raised muggle he would have the scent. Plus maybe they have crossed paths that isn't stated in the books or movies

[@lizzlocke3130]

The theory that the three represent the other houses is a nice theory! It speaks to how different personalities balance each other out!

[@taylorsunshine17]

I don't know why you guys always think it's unlikely Hermione would mock Fleur! She is very open about not liking her, even Ginny calls her Phlem. 😂

[@NsTheName]

Especially since book Hermione is honestly kind of mean and she’s definitely judgmental. She has a lot of good qualities, of course, but her bad qualities were erased in the movie.

[@brendanrodriguez5111]

Yeah as honestly a big luna lover for how nice she seems and how she’s always helping out, I don’t love hermione for constantly like shutting her down so viamently and being a tad harsh. Aside from lupin, she’s my favorite HP character.

[@sonjaimmonen6610]

I always took the "ze grindylows" comment being mocking. I can imagine Fleur being angry and frustrated in a "I would have completed that task if it weren't for those grindylows." She must have been going on and on about it and Hermione had just heard her say ze grindylows multiple times.

[@marshallpeters7174]

I guess I haven't actually seen the movie that much, but I didn't realize it was Hermione that said that. In the book, that was Fleur's line, explaining to her sister why she couldn't get to her.

[@edopronk1303]

About the Percy and Barty, isn't it explicitly said in the book that the scedule this year doesn't allow it? It could be that in the years they studied, the scedule could allow it; that maybe some lessons that now could overlap because no one (exept Hermione) choose them, where as in their years, multiple students both chose Divination ánd (the wizard math stuff) , so the scedule couldn't overlap them.