Why Golwalkar Endures | Swapan Dasgupta, V Sampath, Islam & N Mukhopadhyaya | INDIA TODAY CONCLAVE

[@l.d.agarwal3893]

I am not a Member of RSS but know many active members of the Organisation ! Totally convinced that RSS has no parallel in India 🇮🇳 towards patriotism, nationalism !

[@rka-truthalwayswins5127]

We saw only RSS, NOT Muslim league, Church or Rahul Vinci's congress saving people during covid!!

[@combinatorics1224]

@@rka-truthalwayswins5127 There were volunteers from CPM called "Red Volunteers" who were helping distressed patients in COVID. I appreciate their efforts but I am firmly against all kinds of communism and prefer free-market capitalism which exists in Hong Kong and Singapore to some extent. Now will you say that the CPM party is patriotic even though they had supported China in the 1962 war? Will you say that RSS is humane even though its founders had spread vicious communal hatred against Muslims and Christians? Even the Nazi party had charity organizations to help the poor.

[@combinatorics1224]

@@rka-truthalwayswins5127There are differences between constructive criticism and spreading hatred. Atheists like Richard Dawkins and Christopher Hitchens have criticized all religions ... especially radical Islam and their misogynist Sharia law. But they have never said to wipe out all innocent Muslims.

[@sanketsarangi5170]

​@@combinatorics1224Muslims can't be innocent. This terrorist attack of hamas proved that

[@sanketsarangi5170]

Ok as per you muslim league is a peaceful non communal organisation? 😂

[@l.d.agarwal3893]

Was in Delhi with one of my friend from Kolkata ! He took me to Keshav Kunj, where RSS has its HQ ! Was shocked and surprised to find Topmost Known Leaders and Ideologues of RSS living in around 100 sq feet rooms ! Many of these are PHD, Doctors, Engineers who have left their families to work for RSS ! Don’t know which other Organisation can come anywhere near RSS !

[@Noushad320]

Bania and brahman are head of rss ont dalit .

[@MrDaddu123]

​@@Noushad320that is because earlier minds of Dalits were influenced by agenda jivis and so they did not join RSS. That is why there are no senior level workers who could make it to head. Now many are joining and a day is not far when a patriotic dalit will head the RSS. We will be proud of that moment.

[@sitarampradhan8488]

​@@Noushad320Modi is from back ward caste. Your propaganda go to dustbin.

[@rajeshkumarpanda7057]

​@@Noushad320women's are their but in ur Masjid woman's are not allowed so better concentrate on ur religion and change it first give respect to womens

[@endurance24601]

​@@Noushad320tere baap dada kya the be katwe?

[@shankariyer8378]

Mr Islam must know that even a hardcore Golwalkar could never influence Hindus as much as Islam has done worldwide. That being so, Hindus have to rise to defend their civilisation.

[@peddadanarasingarao9957]

Dr Vikram Sampath analysis of RSS over a period of these 100 yrs was very good

[@vishakhasharma2209]

Sampat ji has explained RSS more clearly than mr. Mohan Bhagwat himselfs . 🙏 Thanks to RSS and to historians Sampath ji for being one of the bastions of our civilisation.

[@l.d.agarwal3893]

RSS the most Patriotic and Nationalist Organisation in Country !

[@GauravKumarji77]

undoubtedly

[@gopalramanathan7062]

It is destined to grow and grow in strength as it ushers in the Dharmic renaissance and unifies BHARAT 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@sitarampradhan8488]

No We are not nationalist but we are patriotic want our country posporous. Nationalist means forcefully promote regional hegemony. Like han Chinese, Pakistan Punjabi supremacy, anatolian Turks supremacy.

[@GauravKumarji77]

@@sitarampradhan8488 yes u can even never be nationalist because it needs sacrifices and talent u don't have either

[@sukalalshinde4144]

माफीवीर की औलाद

[@deepakdandekar8473]

Modi's all ministries portfolio are of RSS background i.e. Narendra Modi, Amit Shah, Rajnath Singh, Nitin Gadkari, Ashwini Vaishnav, Nirmala Sitaraman, S.Jaishankar, Ajit Doval etc. All these team members works hard for the progress of Indian's growth in the last nine years. We did'nt see such creative and collective workmanship in any previous regime before 2014.🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@CEBKashifAhmed]

Andha hai kya

[@malasharma4987]

🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@shreepadpurkar9835]

We know how Sudhindra has exhibited his behaviors , do we think is there any Substance ?

[@ranmalkeshwala2691]

Good for India's future.

[@pakakaka4227]

That's RSS effect vs Goo-laa-b & Gand-Hi gang influence, ruled nation over 60+ years doing noting except naming more than 600+ items/events/road/awards/trophies & what not after their names but forgetting completely about building this great nation called BHARAT!

[@whomraja1704]

Shamsul knowing his brother Rajdeep is the moderator is pouring his heart out

[@gopalramanathan7062]

You said it👍

[@shankarb5229]

Only speaker who made much sense was Vikram Sampath 👍

[@janakiramvenkatakrishnanj8365]

Level head he is non party man

[@rka-truthalwayswins5127]

Absolutely!! And see leftist, India Today's definition of debate & democracy..!! When they talk of RSS, they take 1 anchor & 3 panelists who are against RSS and no one to defend RSS but an academician/historian (Vikram) who is neutral!!

[@gamechanger0656]

Mr V. SAMPATH was MINDBLOWING in this Discussion👌👌👌

[@vip129870]

Opposition parties created the Waqf Act with unlimited powers. These communal actions will guarantee RSS growth.

[@gopalramanathan7062]

The day the Wafq Board is disbanded Bharat 🇮🇳 will advance.

[@Rohit09p]

Vikram Sampath is a great speaker, great historian and an awesome intellectual. Pseudo and fake intellectuals doing debate for name and fame and showoff can learn from this ground to earth historian and intellectual.

[@shivkumarn6257]

@Rohit09p you mean DOWN TO EARTH.

[@visit_ujjal]

RSS provides social security. RSS is showing the world the way. Thanks to Dr. Swapan Dasgupta and other honorable speakers. Very high level discussion.

[@adutta8]

Who came here to listen to Mr V Sampath ✋

[@anvivek]

Sudheendra Kulkarni given 5-6 minutes uninterrupted time by Rajdeep. No one else gets such timing from him

[@parameahwarbt4920]

He encourages anti national forces😮? 😊

[@gopalramanathan7062]

That’s the treat one SICKular offers one of his own.

[@AnandRajappan]

Vikram Sampath 💥🔥👏👏👌🙋🙏✌️

[@srinivaskatti9137]

Guruji's initial thoughts only reflected th anger of àll indians against muslims who effeçted partion of bharàth.bt his later thoughr refĺèct hiß aďjustìng to unàoidàble reality

[@pratikpawar3759]

Mr. Islam have problem with cheery pick statements of Guruji golwalkar but he didn't have any issues with 1400 yr old his own religious text?? Why are so selective ness in progressive idea... 🤔

[@samratkundu9269]

Golwalkar is always right, he says to fight jihadism and protest Christian missionaries. Create a Hindu brotherhood for the protection of Hindus.

[@rakhimukerji7937]

What they.did.for poor marginalised Indians?

[@samratkundu9269]

@@rakhimukerji7937 search rss school and help line .

[@vijaykrishnann6483]

RSS is for the betterment of the nation

[@dheeraj6514]

Please attend RSS sakkha and see the representations of Brahmins supremacy and I bet you their ideology based on hate, patriarchal, caste supremacy...

[@l.d.agarwal3893]

Known many RSS members who are serving the nation thru their selfless service like working for tribals thru organisations like Van Bandhu Parishad, Ekal Schools !

[@RaviNayyar]

The organisers knew exactly what they were doing by focusing the event on G, and not the RSS.

[@yatirajadave5756]

Shamshul Islam aise lag raha hai jaise kisine show me aane se pahle thappad mara ho 😀😀😀 Itna gussa ??? Bhai kya kar sakte hai 😀😀😀

[@shiladityabanerjee5210]

Because of the power that he and his quom does not have in India and also the organisation that he and his ilk demonised over the years ,now is the main point of talks

[@gopalramanathan7062]

Shameful Islam😐

[@haridasshenoy8334]

Hats of to Vikram Sampath. Paying obeisance to the founder is not compulsory. Organisations should change with time to serve the nation.

[@amoseannamalai4506]

The nation is not served here it’s the interest of the leaders of the Hindutva ideology !

[@satyamevjayte3149]

जय हिन्दू राष्ट्र घोषित किया जाएगा भारत को

[@vip129870]

The opposition parties of India have guaranteed RSS will grow for the next 100 years.

[@shankariyer8378]

The equanimity with which Vikram speaks and the erudition he reflects, shows Mr Islam as a prejudiced snd poorly read person. Sudheendra Kulkarani spent his entire life with Advani. Does he disown that and also accept that most of his life has been a waste?

[@gopalramanathan7062]

Mr Islam true to his name is a committed fanatical jihadist.

[@थानापतिसेवानंदगिरीउज्जैन]

राष्ट्रीय स्वयंसेवक संघ सही है जय हिंदू राष्ट्र जय सनातन धर्म जय काशी विश्वनाथ हर हर महादेव

[@smitaratnakar7185]

👏👏👏 well said Vikram Sampath. Beautiful explanation.

[@budhinarsimloo6038]

Mr Sanpath is correct and logical and reflects order of the day

[@Ihavegotnewsforyou]

Rajdeep Sardesia in his usual elements put back in place by the eurdite Vikram Sampath who hits the nail on the head.Everytime.This Islam Nasrul is one unhappy man for apparent no legitimate reasons.

[@gopalramanathan7062]

Which is why Sardesai and his sidekick Prof. Islam constantly interrupt him.

[@l.d.agarwal3893]

RSS trying to take Bharat to its Golden Era thru working at grass root level in every village, town and metro of India 🇮🇳 !

[@DurgaMenon]

Who else can feel the pain of Rajdeep chacha while talking n hearing positives about RSS

[@SubhashBirari-ll5rh]

R S S है इसलिये ये भारत देश बचा है,यही देशका सौभाग्य है इसके लिये पुरा श्रेय RSS को जाता हैं. उनके लिये शत शत प्रणाम.

[@ratneshdubey503]

Gurus and Gurujis are proud India.

[@Tatugusar1111]

Whatever rss does n says is fully right that's why rss continuty never ends n will last for longer millennium to come. There is a saying "only truth can last forever".

[@sridharancr1542]

All these characters like Rajdeep will not be remembered even for a day after him & the fact that the Founders are remembered & followed even after after 100 years.

[@yogitashivhare2672]

Vikram was only who sounded logical... dr islam is behaving like a child who dont get candyflos ...

[@Picaulhas]

Any one related to his name. Have such irrational behaviour traits in social and political area.

[@ameyshirolkar5468]

Maturity is when you realize its important to discuss Dr Hedgewar first, and then Guruji.

[@ritugarg6245]

Vikram sampath as usual at HIS BEST

[@beenamenon6749]

RSS devotion and commitment to duty before all other considerations is exemplary, inspiring and commendable..instead of inviting people to pull it down, let us study why RSS has endured despite the naysayers, @ Rajdeep Sardesai

[@mpadhi180]

Agree 💯 with Vikram Sampat

[@subirlahiri1277]

HOW COME RAJDEEP SARDESAI CAN BE AN INDIAN AT THE SAME TIME , DERIVES SO MUCH PLEASURE DECRYING ANYTHING OF REAL INDIA, IN THE DISGUISE OF LIBERALISM , BEYOND ANY GENUINE INDIAN'S IMAGINATION. HE PROVES VERY GENUINELY THAT, NOT ONLY INDIA GAVE BIRTH OF ONE MIRJAFOR BUT STILL IS , MANY OF THEM. 28:45

[@harihara1151]

Hail Vikram. It is chatrcter that defines a civilization . No doubt let is tegain and pravtice it .let rss do it

[@shivanandyadrami2341]

Wherever this r@scal street fighter rajdeep is there, sane people like Swapan Da and Vikram Sampat should avoid to go. Rajdeep is suitable for street fights only not for the discussions

[@bbhusari]

One needs a large heart ❤, empathy, intellect and a historic social perspective to understand ParamPujya MSG or Guruji! He inherited the mantle from founder, and lead the RSS to glory and service of the Nation. Today he is neither dated nor sidelined or disowned, such snobbish TV Programs hardly add anything to the understanding of icons like MSG ! Nevertheless it was heartening to note that SK talking sensibly !

[@bmmr]

if Rajdeep wants to question RSS, he should also question other organisations from different religions

[@sudhakarbhave6111]

The founders of RSS have identified the exact ills of our nation and tried to correct them by addressing the Hindu society. It is very difficult to imagine our nation without RSS. Fortunatly there is RSS to counter anti national elements in every sphere, be it parliament or street fight or academics or courts. That is the real worry for anti national people. Jai hind.

[@amoseannamalai4506]

You are an anti national yourself ! You want everyone to be a Hindutvaadi😅 . Not happening babu

[@RaviNayyar]

BJP has 28x as many cadres as the RSS. RSS is not the bogeyman the Western/Indian Left commentariat loves imagining it to be.

[@samratkundu9269]

boss RSS still have a foot roll in India.

[@RaviNayyar]

@@samratkundu9269, of course, I am not denying 'ideological influence on Narendra Modi', but they can't sabotage his re-election by refusing to campaign for him, like they sabotaged ABV in 2004 and lost him that election.

[@samratkundu9269]

@@RaviNayyar due ABV not alining with the RSS line. So, they refused the campaign but they learned their lesson.

[@drishaantrivedi159]

Vikram is really original thinker.

[@suryakantgd]

Kulkarnji talked sense first time😀

[@nivedithajags]

Did you listen to his last comment?

[@budhinarsimloo6038]

Excellent clarifications

[@FS1to10]

Hats off to you Sampath ji

[@DeveshSingh-gx2zr]

Uniformity doesn't mean to strict someone. But in terms of uniformity because our country runs on constitution and law so everyone should be treated accordingly. It doesn't mean to restrict someone's identity.

[@rka-truthalwayswins5127]

The question India Today should have asked IS: "WHY Nehru & Congress Endures"??!!

[@Sensible_human123]

RSS teaches you what every parent needs to teach their kids that is how to respect your country and character building. It’s so beautiful ❤❤ RSS Jai hind❤

[@paragkunjalwar8376]

We are not members but we are Swayamsevak.

[@Harvey97]

Vikram Sampath is such a genius! ❤

[@kitnanaai]

The 1/2 front that Bipin Rawat mentioned is very much true. You can see those cheering Pakistan everyday and shouting “Pakistan Zindabad”. Their loyalty is always with the ummah except for a very few pattiotic people.

[@Krishnan.V]

Rajdeep meltdown from @29:07 to 29:17

[@l.d.agarwal3893]

Sudheendra Kulkarni the most opportunist politician I have seen !

[@gopalramanathan7062]

Part of the anti national SICKular brigade.

[@Teju87]

14:34 this is 100% true.

[@spacelion6318]

Hindus n hinduism itself survive today because of ability to evolve n change with the changing times

[@jayasankarshivakumar471]

Vikram is outstanding

[@krishansaxena2389]

Mr. Aalam is not objective. He is emotional. Muslim league in 1946 and Pakistan since then has crushed Hindusfrom 20% to 1% where as Muslims are prospering in India. Yet, Mr Aslam wants to bad mouth Mr. Modi. Get some sense and objectivity or listen to Arif Ajakia, former mayor of Karanchi in Pakistan. Randeep Sardesi himself is a confused man. Vikram Sampat, the youngest, has the best perspective on history. Kudos to Vikram Sampat.

[@vijaymenon3011]

Rajdeep who is a known Anti Hindu journalist is doing a program on RSS is surprising. It’s good to see this.

[@n.p.jayagopalannambiar9114]

Guruji is the real Hero

[@HELENOGRADYNaviMumb]

When Rajdeep closes his eyes and speaks it means "arre bhai yein sahi nahi hein , mere paise katenge"

[@padmakarahirrao1194]

Only Gayatri mantra can unite Hindus &BJP.

[@unknownperson8541]

In my opinion most effective organization in the Indian freedom fight is the Anushilan Samiti K. B. Hedgewar was a member of the Anushilan Samiti so I believe the ultimate goal of RSS is the well-being of our nation.😊😊😊😊

[@satyamevjayte3149]

RSS IS BHARAT,I STAND WITH RSS

[@shreeshchandrapandey3033]

Patriotism is the last refuge of scoundrel said Dr Johnson . The thread of opposition against the Malechas runs in the heart of a devout Hindu . Now the question is who are they? Priestly domination of every society creates fissures in the society to benefit their class. Our caste system was stratified because of Dharm gurus who were crypto politicians without taking any responsibility. RSS was born to oppose others who were not Hindus. Even in modern times that thread is not lost.Gaining political power has not made the organisation any wise . Unfortunately power does not make any one wise.The founding fathers of RSS have made indelible mark which cannot be wiped out. Golwalkar can’t be ignored for making contribution to RSS

[@sudhakarbhave6111]

There is nothing perfect in life. Similarly no perfect personalities. Select what is worthy from all directions, preachings and thoughts and adapt for better life. Judge a person based on his intentions and not few words. Jai hind

[@sitting1000]

0:20 Narendra Modi "Ji"....!! How your tone has changed Mr Sardesai 😅

[@venkatraman9699]

It is called " E.D" effect !!

[@kpsreenivasan6142]

Bunch of thoughts is not a book published by any RSS organization. But collection of speaches published by a publisher in Bangalore and it is not exactly the same speaches made by Golwalkar.

[@newstoday6894]

It's demand of HINDU RASHTRA by TIME 🙏

[@Shaivaite_mulnivasi]

Will reservation continue or snatched away bcoz 3000yrs dalits sc st have been kept away from education and u can't except them to fight back in 70yrs they should get another 30yrs atleast

[@pduttagupta]

On 6th December 1992 after breaking of Babri Masjid secular journo Rashid Talib said very confidently on Doordarshan that India will not survive because Babri Masjid has been broken..now another secular indian musalmaan iin 2023 s threatning India will not survive bcOz of RSS..Indian muslims whether secular or non secular loose no opprtunity to threaten that India will not survive! We hindus should get used to it!

[@avikgope4156]

We are proud of our RSS🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩

[@amulyamishra5745]

Islam came out as the biggest loser in this debate with loose knitted arguments and lots of emotions.

[@MR-le5fc]

If RSS stands against the idea of Islam completing their long long cherished ghazwa e hind and transforming it into Darul islam then they must be respected and supported at every step. The original leaders of RSS understood that very well.

[@saitejg7342]

RSS has to sustain when Islamists become majority in india

[@RaviNayyar]

Hoo boy, the third speaker was fired up.

[@blackrock1404]

😂😂😂85% poor vs 14%rich +1% super rich people all over world and each country😂😂

[@CHARAK143]

Aap Kabhi v RSS KO samajh hi na payange .Jai RSS Jai RSS Jai RSS 🙏🏻🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@BHUPENDRAMONDAL]

RSS is bigger than anyone can ever imagine. Anyone trying to measure it in numbers can waste their time.

[@SubrataSarkaar5076]

Moral of the story: wherever is Islam, anarchy comes

[@RaviNayyar]

Rajdeep is only employed by IndiaToday because he can get the Sonia Gandhi interview which will never go to air.

[@RAGUREDDY-o3l]

Proud to be sangheee🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@raveebn]

Rajdeep sir, good topic ! Based on every one talked, RSS or Hindus and their thoughts are not the same as 19th century and adopted to 2023 world. Now the question to you, Muslims say "our god is the only god(you hear the prayer LOUD and CLEAR everyday 5 times, unless you are deaf(sorry for the language)" ), if any religion belives ambiuous phylosophy in a secular democracy it is not personal stuff anymore, Can they change it themself ? they don't need to change this for Arabs or for whole world, if they like India can they change for India atleast? to have a communal harmoney ? see biggest lies we were fed from birth is all religion are same, Still hindus believed because it came in our sanskar and adopted it, can muslim scholars say it or believe all religions are same ? if yes what is the problem in modifying this "ours is the only god you need to believe in" you may comment on this or have a next conclave on this topic. I know you can't do that because there are so many pretending deafs like you in India. Biggest surprize in this world for me is how people think, India has been destroyed by Islamic invaders for 800 years and they tried to eleminate hinduism from map but failed, all happened because of blind faith in their religion, why Media and politicians give benifits of doubts to Muslims ? and question Hindus loyalty on the inclusive phylosophy ? rather they should question who dodn't believe all religion are same, or not believed in inclusiveness ! One thing what Jai Shankar says we need to respect is, India has problems with pluristic society becaus they practically practice different religious practices and different believes, this is normal, world can't take this because they never let native or multi cultural people to live on the land, they have wiped them off !

[@melodiousgupta777]

Rss should come out of glamour and should change its leadership and work more actively for hindus

[@harshitakrishna78]

You are uncivilised when you hackle the participants on the stage. Vikram Sampat never hackled.

[@suniljogdeo8345]

Rajdeep is Hindu or not? From his surname he looks to be.. He should know that he like other Hindus exist alive just due to RSS.

[@PS-ej2xn]

His family is Christian. Nothing wrong, but he belongs to the kind of Christians who work against Hindus.

[@khannakl]

Koregaon defeat of Peshwas has turned out to be a deep wound on the caste and group pride in history. Indian society has been paying for that defeat and continues to do so. .... ....// Defeats of fathers have been visiting again and again on the revengeful children. More so with Baba saheb Ambedkar's rise in esteem. Respect and role of his in the history was yet again a Bhima Koregaon. Thora deep jaaiye.

[@chadleo85]

Who all fast forward when Sardesai speaks😅

[@srihari772]

Not even the presence of one RSS member in the panel on the debate (unfairly allotted short time on such an important topic and the conspicuous absence of the most relevant and important panel member!) about the organization's endurance and its founders??!!

[@ketanpatel-wu3ds]

Rather than worrying about what RSS is, Shamsul Islam should be more worried about the violence preached by Mr. Islam's Islam. The kind of barbaric violence propagated by the religion he follows is repulsive. If he believes in humanitarian values, he would be ashamed of some of the teachings coming from the religious books of Islam.

[@user-ju1fm8rn1g]

0:07 in world

[@kalyansubramani7076]

All very nice. But 95% of Indians who have a vote won't understand one word of what is being discussed here and will go to vote next year and in every election based on what's in it for them or their caste or whatever. The only winner in the discussion is the media that is making some of money with these conferences etc.

[@harish-ISH]

why are they reiterating they're not part of RSS as though even if they were it's a thing of shame..?!!

[@padmakarahirrao1194]

Gayatri mantra is simple and Acceptable