Why the Maccabees are not in the Tanakh? Rabbi Weisblum הסיפור האמיתי של חנוכה הרב ויסבלום

[@נאוהשליט]

Historically correct, brilliantly presented clear and concise. thank you Rabbi Weisblum for your work

[@mosheweisblum3450]

Thank you for your kind words

[@nadavmetzger9768]

Fantastic combination of storytelling and wise advice about how to understand and connect to Chanukkah

[@mosheweisblum3450]

Thank you for your kind words

[@JerryLat]

Uplifting, thought provoking, intelligent and sincere. It is a privilege to hear.

[@mosheweisblum3450]

Thank you

[@dvorahkatz5843]

Interesting, informative and entertaining

[@mosheweisblum3450]

Thank you

[@nanhop8717]

Enlightening intelligent coherent & very brilliant talk. Thank you.

[@mosheweisblum3450]

Thank you for your kind words

[@sherrylev4510]

An erudite Rabbi and Scholar that I have great respect for. His speech is eloquent, succint and to the point. Let's all live in peace.

[@mosheweisblum3450]

Thank you for your kind words

[@derpi5505]

Remarkable lecture

[@mosheweisblum3450]

Thank you for your kind words

[@tisber7489]

Thank you so much for this awe-inspiring lecture, beautiful to listen to, deeply meaningful for reflation on into the future.

[@mosheweisblum3450]

You're very welcome

[@tziporalamberger8795]

Absolutely ingenious

[@15minoflame]

Looked everywhere to find a Rabbi explaining this .

[@jackmeirhoff156]

So beautiful, amazing, and humbling. To construct such human-made magnificence ideas by Chazal blows my mind! Just WOW!

[@hannasomach5324]

WOW> Very informative

[@mosheweisblum3450]

Thank you

[@richardcohen7930]

Agree %100

[@raylevinger4662]

Great lecture. I’m curious as to how some would feel about the idea that “god’s” word was so easily amended over time.

[@susanroth3874]

Agree

[@mosheweisblum3450]

Thank you

[@Kurogane_Shin_]

Maccabees and the other books of Alexandrian Canon aren't in the Jew Canon because those books say things that bothered the Sadducees like resurrection and other themes, because the Sadducees was the elitè of Israel and they had chose the canon

[@IsraelSuperguide]

17:43 Correction, Anthiocus IV! How ironic is this whole story, we accept legends (i.e. the so called miracle of the oil, which there is not historical record, no the author of the Maccabees, Josephus, Philo even the N.T mention this myth), made up by the rabbis but that which is historical they rejected. We rather live in fairy tail than in reality. What is wrong celebrating a military victory. Not everything have to be base in miracles and the super natural. If it wasn't for the church, we would not have these books, we ought them preserving these books. 28:01 Pompey takes over 63 BCE, you gotto check your dates and names. Also, the decisions of the rabbis was political, rather than theological to leave these books out, they hated the Hasmoneans, but we should we grateful and thankful that if it wasn't for them, Judaism would not have survived!!!!!!!!!!!! So, lets call things as they are and stop being political correct.

[@JNieckarz]

The Macabbess are in the Catholic Bible.

[@ΝΙΚΟΣΒΟΓΙΑΤΖΑΚΗΣ]

The maccabee is in the bible and celebrated by the orthodox church 4 of augoust also the mother is considered a saint