Why There Will Never Be Another Straw Hat Pirate

[@kingace6186]

Last straw.

[@vianabdullah2837]

Carrot was the strangest one to me. Because he seemed to be set up in Whole Cake Island with her own tragedy with Pedro's death and associated motivation to see the dawn of the world, alongside having a dynamic with the existing members. But then got promptly sidelined in Wano for one reason or another.

[@qncymrtn]

I've had this argument so many times, Carrot had all the set up for being a SH, she behaved like them, she had the desire to see the world, lookout role all of it was there, then Yamato got introduced and her desire to set sail made people really forget what happened in WCI. The hate she got just baffled me.

[@ChuckFinnley944]

Another thing is that, none of those characters that could be added serve a unique function in the crew. Luffy is the captain, Zoro is first mate, Nami is the navigator, Usopp is the sniper, Sanji is the cook, Chopper is the doctor, Franky is the shipwright, Robin is the archeologist, Brooks is the musician, and Jinbe is the helmsman. They have enough strong fighters, so any additional crew member needs to bring something else too.

[@aneonfoxtribute]

I think that every unofficial crew member will come back in the final war. Vivi, Yamato, Carrot, I think they're all gonna return and join for the final battle.

[@petertraicer]

I dont know if we get more nakama, but im sure we get friends that will help in the final battle, and then be like honorary nakamas. Vivi, Carrot and Yamato will definitly help at the end, and we can include the minks, the samurai of wano, Law and his crew, Smoker and co, Rebecca and her father, and Bon Chan. And then, there is the fleet of luffy, with all that people.

[@TheSpencermacdougall]

I mean, it makes sense. I might be miss remembering, but I'm fairly sure at the very start of the adventure, Luffy said his goal was 10 crew members. So if this is true, Oda probably planned that from the very start.

[@qncymrtn]

That's 10 excluding Luffy.

[@hiwiechakib]

@@qncymrtn is the sunny a strawhat ?

[@Juliusmankey]

All straw hats have horrible parents or their dead, we’re liberated by Luffy and fit a role in the straw hat crew.

[@Erif-]

yamato will join (HOPIUM) yamato will show up when they need him the most(COPIUM). I WILL NEVER STOP BELIEVING.

[@TheEpicWalrus1]

jinbe's prototype name was also Saigo meaning final or last in japanese

[@NeroPiroman]

in the very first chaper of the manga luffy said that he would like 10 crewmates, curently it is 9, therefore mostlikely someone will join before the very end, most likely vivi or yamato, the way wano ended, there is a clear way for yamato to join, based on the dialoge with luffy

[@chuuyaism1653]

i personally think it was a meta thing and Oda meant there would be ten total including Luffy specially because Carrot was perfectly setup i know people are more upset about Yamato but i still think that one is explainable but Carrot's was really weird so if anyone else was gonna be joining it would have been her. If someone DOES get added then I'll just be proven wrong lol

[@chuuyaism1653]

I'm so happy i can watch your new one piece videos as they get uploaded now that I'm finally caught up

[@-Mintyy]

I just watch his and tekkings videos. Have never read a chapter but know as much as most casual readers forsure lol.

[@chuuyaism1653]

@@-Mintyy me with naruto lol I haven't even read most of the original let alone shippuden but i know a whole lot just from youtube analysis and what if videos lol

[@-Mintyy]

@@chuuyaism1653 lmao yea KZbins Lit. But I cannot recommend enough to read the Naruto manga rather than anime!

[@chuuyaism1653]

@@-Mintyy manga it is then!! i was debating it cuz i had already started out with the anime and i find it difficult sometimes to switch mediums but manga is just so much easier to get through and prevents getting stuck due to the length of a series that is as huge as Naruto so yeah tldr: manga it is!!

[@-Mintyy]

@@chuuyaism1653 exactly the reasons I suggested. Also the filler and few changes they make in the manga are typically horrible and unnecessary.

[@dallascoggins1534]

Smoker 4 nakama

[@mrbushido56]

I think we get 3 more

[@theblackmike1129]

There is one character that fits in, in the same way jinbei does; Sabo. Sabo was introduced before the time skip and while he is a part of the revolutionary army it is possible the army is defeated or succeeds in their goals. If anyone joins the crew out of existing character it could be him. It probably won't happen, but it could make sense.

[@vovabars1234]

0:11 dawg Luffy didn't talk to Franky for 5 years at some point, post time skip strawhats character interaction fell off hard compared to the pre time skip

[@Newworld-gk6us]

Vivi was a Strawhat.

[@LJkAze]

Guarantee there will be a 10th Straw Hat with Aokiji being announce as 10th Titanic Captain of the Blackbeard Pirates

[@qncymrtn]

With Kuzan you really need a powerhouse so I can see Yamato coming in to play(I wish it was Carrot)

[@vojtechtesar7114]

I think Vivi should join and then noone else. Even if Vivi won´t be a fighter, the crew doesn´t need other fighters. With the tenth titanic captain revealed to be Aokiji, it is likely that he will either betray Blackbeard or fight someone outside of the Strawhat pirates. After that we have 9 titanic captains vs 9 strawhats and Luffy vs Blackbeard.

[@murderman8578]

Not confirmed that Aokiji will turn traitor

[@vojtechtesar7114]

@@murderman8578 this is just my thought. Anyway, even if he is truly evil Law can beat him

[@murderman8578]

@@vojtechtesar7114 I don't think Law can win against Aokiji

[@vojtechtesar7114]

@@murderman8578 before Onigashima Rai though, who would have thought Law can defeat Big Mom, even if it was 2v1?

[@murderman8578]

@@vojtechtesar7114 it was a Collab effort with their DF powers, neither could've done it alone given low haki diff

[@murderman8578]

Not Confirmed by Oda

[@harlock1550]

Yamato is not trans. SHE is canonically a woman, confirmed by Oda. This idea that she was trans came about from a wildly mishandling of the transition pre-introduction when Kaido mentioned her as his brat. This was taken as Kaido having said his son rather than his kid/brat, with the word for this having multiple meanings in Japanese and the language being very contextual. This is no different to how Hachinosu has been mistranslated as Beehive rather than Honeycomb, since Hobeycomb fire is the process of firing a gun(s) at a target with the intention of filling it with as many holes as possible, hence Fullalead island. Yamato idolized Oden and wishes to live as he did, but she doesn't want to be a man. In Yamato's eyes, Oden being a man doesn't even matter. It's his character that she respects not his genitals or chromosomes.

[@frozenandchosen]

At the end of the Wano arc Yamato bathes with the male characters not the female

[@harlock1550]

@@frozenandchosen And? This isn't really evidence of anything? Stuff like that is just anime doing anime stuff. The entire Yamato trans thing is a misconception based on a poor translation of a single word that blew up into a mess of misunderstanding and misrepresenting the facts.

[@frozenandchosen]

@@harlock1550 I feel like Oda made that choice for a reason and was implying/intending to relay something to the audience, but we view the choice different ways and that’s alright, he hasn’t been 100 percent clear on the subject so that leaves it open to interpretation

[@harlock1550]

@frozenandchosen One Piece isn't up to interpretation, and Oda has been clear about it. He made his choice when he made her Kaido's daughter. He even differentiated Yamato from Kiku (who is actually "trans") and is part of the same arc. There is no debate about it, Yamato isn't trans.

[@hiwiechakib]

@@harlock1550 you are right , yamato never calls herself a "he" unlike kiku who litteraly said that she's a woman at heart , yamato never said such thing , she was just extremely inspired by oden and i'm pretty sure she will have some sort of character growth where she'll realise that she doesn't need to be oden to inherit his will and values . She's already learning all sorts of stuff with kinemon in the latest cover story .

[@aftertone8339]

Idk. I do see Carrot potentially joining simce the last scene we saw, ended so unconclusive. Like, dosen't that scene seem like a red haring? She didn't even get a goodbye scene with the Strawhats

[@harlock1550]

I completely agree, it also felt forced into her rather than her decision, which goes against the themes of freedom and choosing your own path that One Piece has. Carrot also ticks all the boxes for joining, even Luffy using her real name from the start.

[@qncymrtn]

I had hope up until Egghead really started moving, it is kind of odd for her to show up later to join.

[@ChuckFinnley944]

It seems like they have their full crew. Now they’re making relationships with important and powerful figures that will help them down the line. Wano will go to war for Luffy, no questions asked. And it will be Yamato and Momonosuke at the front of their forces. Same for Carrot and the Zoe.

[@AustinIsTheGreatest]

Oda's obbession with the monster trio needs to stop. Yamato should have joined the crew because if she really wanted to follow in Oden's footsteps she would have tried anything to leave Wano like Oden tried to do all the time. He couldn't set out to sea and had spent years trying. Only able to leave becuase Whitebeard helped him. Oda literally made her character motivation take a 180 with a lame excuse of wanting to explore Wano.

[@johnsidney4147]

Preach, Austin. Preach.

[@thesurvivorssanctuary6561]

Not to mention she is like the most powerful woman in One Piece, and practically the most powerful woman in Shonen history! It would have been a game changer to have her, and her naive and enthusiastic energy would have complinented the crew nicely! Too bad man, and it still saps Mmy interest in continuing this story.

[@aneonfoxtribute]

You've misunderstood it completely. First, there is no reason to believe that the monster trio is the reason why Yamato did not join. Second, Yamato very explicitly states that they aren't joining the crew because they need to protect Wano. They needed an outside force to save Wano from Green Bull, and they need to be able to hold the fort before Yamato will feel right leaving. The "traveling Wano" bit was an excuse she gave to Momonosuke.

[@Oblivion___]

@@aneonfoxtribute Finally someone who understands, if it wasn't for Shanks GB would have caused chaos in Wano, people greatly underestimate the power of the Admirals, Green Bull just didn't move on because he got cornered by two Yonko and their crews, otherwise he it would be a second Kaido attacking Wano and that the Straw Hats would have to face, Green Bull's power terrified Yamato. Wano doesn't have the slightest chance of surviving the World Government without the protection of a Yonko, even with Luffy being a Yonko Green Bull was willing to face him and take Wano (even though that wasn't Akainu's orders), he just stopped the attack when a second Yonko appeared. Yamato's decision to stay behind was right, her desire above all is to protect Wano, that is her priority, she could have left to see the world like Oden did when Ace appeared but she stayed behind to protect Wano, because that is her main objective, Yamato will only leave Wano when Wano is safe, she still has several chances to travel the world.

[@qncymrtn]

​@@Oblivion___I was a bit disappointed that Oda didn't have Zuneisha destroy those WG ships, to me that would let the world know they can't just invade because Yamato is strong but is she I can take on an entire fleet strong.

[@FaizalKuntz]

strawhat pirate all has a dream and goal, that's why vivi stop being a member because her dream is not with the strawhat. while Yamato has unfinished business in wano but as long someone has a dream left unfinished anyone will join the crew.

[@okameii]

I personally think the last one will be Vivi, and i’m still holding on hope. Idc if i’m delusional.

[@BestgirlJordanfish]

I was really surprised when Yamato didn’t join. I really hope he comes back for some nice moments though. I think part of the magic of pre-timeskip was seeing new characters join, but I also get that with a bloated cast it’s hard to give everyone their moments each arc.

[@dogperson432]

She

[@isauldron4337]

Yamato is a she

[@meias.]

​​@@dogperson432*loud incorrect buzzer *

[@meias.]

​@@isauldron4337Nuh uh ‼️

[@TrulyBS-QJ]

its cuz I planted a bunch of roaches in all the hat factories that used straw and got them closed down to make them run outta hats.

[@kunalfadtare2056]

considering this is the last saga, it just doesn't make sence to have another strawhat. and what would there role in the crew be? that's the big issue i had with yamato. sure he want to be oden and what is his goal that he will work towards.

[@qncymrtn]

Carrot Lookout Inherited will from Pedro, who wasn't able to travel with Roger, to help bring in the dawn of the world. Now I have no faith that's what will happen but imo everything you needed for a new SH was right there with Carrot.

[@isauldron4337]

Yamato is a she not a he Also supplementary materiales implies there's a last strawhat to join

[@mrbushido56]

I am still 100% on carrot joining

[@qncymrtn]

I wish but what would be the purpose of removing a SH from the final saga.

[@StardustMonkey]

This guy makes this video during the arc where Bonney becomes the next strawhat

[@nathandanczak7822]

We didn't get too emotionally attached to the alabastans in this arc, of course ruling over people seems clear to the eye, we didn't care about that. That's why there even was the deal over wether she would still travel with them. That's my biggest disappointment feeling i've ever gotten from the series and it sucked to be the strawhats who still didn't get public credit for stopping the rebellion. The crew were even still disappointed even after vivi gave her reason. I think it's because you really felt the "x scene", that it's accepted she just had to leave. I thought she would make frequent appearances after........ No! She's not talked about by the crew after they easily let robin on and we do the whole thing with trying to get her back from the government. After you've forgotten about her. At the end, you finally drew her, and it's just oda trying for you to not question robin joining was okay or not. And she appears amazingly again at the very end of the timeskip, where she gets the supposed code(which i'm like, oda,this doesn't make up for 330 episodes -380 chapters without her, you've really done nothing with vivi). Then she tragically goes silent until at the end of zou. We get excited, then not in 2 chapters. Another long arc happens and she's at the mariejois, okay other characters are there too, okay, and this dark figure brings up her picture out of everyone to the "throne"... Okay maybe some- no. Don't get the answer and fans already speculate the(uninteresting) "reasons" why and move on. And then egghead, okay, and she's a d, I would have more attached to this revelation 13 years ago. I'm team strawhat vivi, but every opportunity there's just very little and people get more attached to characters with powers then didn't get the bond treatment with vivi and just want them to be full members. They don't have any chemistry with the crew the same vivi did. Her being brought back for very little just is a sicker torture than any of wayne gacy's gein's dshmer's any other serial killer's, combined. That's what I said. Oh.... If she's not the whole piece to the end, i'll make a nuke look like a micro-force. Ha (Yamato is a girl, she has the breasts, butt and data confirms her too.

[@deveshtyagi2996]

Marco

[@zero1188]

well luffy said in the beginning he wanted 10 pirates. BB have 10 pirates on his crew. doesnt make sense to get more at this point

[@gobulgobbler]

Isn't this an argument for there being one more crew member though? Blackbeard has 10 captains, and there are 9 Straw Hats aside from Luffy. So there would need to be one more to match up evenly with Blackbeard's crew.

[@zero1188]

@@gobulgobbler what you mean? They have 10.

[@gobulgobbler]

@@zero1188 It's the 10 Titanic Captains. Blackbeard isn't included in that. 1. Jesus Burgess 2. Shiryu 3. Van Augur 4. Avallo Pizarro 5. Lafitte 6. Catarina Devon 7. Sanjuan Wolf 8. Vasco Shot 9. Doc Q 10. Kuzan Straw Hats have 1. Zoro 2. Sanji 3. Usopp 4. Nami 5. Chopper 6. Robin 7. Franky 8. Brooke 9. Jimbei

[@zero1188]

@@gobulgobbler luffy and bb counts. Its 10 on each side

[@gobulgobbler]

@@zero1188 If you count Blackbeard, it's 10 Straw Hats and 11 BBs. I literally listed Blackbeard's 10 Captains.

[@bruhsound446]

Does any think bonney might join the straw hats considering whats happening with the current manga arc and she has a personal grudge or dream that is destroying the world government and it is the enemy for the last saga

[@aftertone8339]

I just don't see why she wouldn't just join the revolutionary army

[@qncymrtn]

No, the supernovas are rivals to the SHs best she might do is travel to the next island and I don't think she wants to do that.

[@Mooglatan]

Koby

[@meir2161]

0:23 Brook, Jinbe, plus franky and chopper post time skip

[@brianlowe904]

yes it is an exaggeration.

[@PowerLord83]

Why do keep calling Yamato "him"? Yamato is female.

[@mochii813]

Woke culture