Why Waterproofing Membranes Fail

[@noobknifereviews9205]

Most of this is quite true for membrane failures, but there are many technologies for membrane protection that are great when installed correctly. Just relying on concrete admixtures, crystalline additions, other pore blocking technologies which is referred to here, is just 1 approach to watertight construction. But concrete cracks, and also has many placement considerations that can upset this also. Dry basement construction is about 3 types of protection as per British standard. 1. is membrane protection. 2. is integral concrete quality plus the joints / CJ's using waterstops. 3. Drainage design. This is a layered approach to dry basement design, and covers multiple lines of defense, as you say, application issues are common. You have to plan for success and have all parties working to a common cause. Having QA and hold points verified at key times, will improve any application. Adding pore blockers alone is perilous and disrespectful to understanding the overall dynamics of waterproofing.

[@genecarden780]

In the USA a huge problem is careless backfilling and large rocks damaging ( sometimes severely) the protection board/ drainage board

[@dprev87]

🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation: 00:19 👷‍♂️ Waterproofing membrane installation requires skilled labor and 90% of failures are due to poor workmanship. 00:32 ❌ Picking an inappropriate membrane for the intended application can lead to failure of the waterproofing application. 01:03 💧 Any debonding of the membrane leads to water penetration into the concrete. 01:26 ⬇️ Certain membranes not fully adhering to the concrete surface make them unsuitable for below-grade applications. 01:39 🌧️ Applying a membrane to a damp, wet or uneven surface can cause debonding. 01:52 🔄 Lack of adequate priming prior to waterproofing application can result in failure. 02:19 🔗 NOT fully bonding overlaps can cause potential breaches in the waterproofing layer. 02:32 🎈 Failure to properly prime a surface may lead to air becoming trapped under the membrane, causing debonding and blistering. 03:01💔 Damage such as puncturing and tearing from construction activities often cause breaches of the waterproofing layer. 03:30 ⏲️ Over time, waterproofing membranes may deteriorate due to exposure to the environment, which can lead to failure. 04:24 🔄 In conclusion, new technologies that permanently reduce permeability and improve concrete properties are recommended as a solution over membrane applications. Made with HARPA AI

[@tedm2416]

25 years ago I had some Ice and Water Shield left over so I put it on, 2-ply, on a patio as a "temp" solution. This stuff is only approved as an underpayment. It is still in service and has not even deteriorated, de-bonded, or become stiff. It has never leaked. What matters is if your installer is a professional and understands his/her materials. That is the real take-a-way here. The alternatives? Well, over competency, you have none (also the take-a-way here). You (or someone later) can pay for your mistakes, or, you can pay a professional--who might make a mistake. Or wait till we can just print it.

[@SUNBOy416]

Can't agree your point even more

[@jimalston5485]

it not the product as such and yes some are better than others more the installer if he/she knows what there doing and has pride in there work so you are bang on

[@oellejoven1758]

Very informative however the researcher should recommend what are the latest technology for water proofing

[@rehanzamindar6533]

It's crystalline Waterproofing. Also called as Integral Waterproofing.

[@jagboy69]

@@rehanzamindar6533 And it's super expensive!

[@Missisa995]

Use a hydrophobic pore-blocking ingredient to make concrete repel water, such as Caltite by Cementaid

[@Grokit-br7np]

WaterKote by Kote Products

[@ronaldc8634]

4:45 Can you name some of these newer technologies?

[@christinemiller6997]

Nice music. Answered my questions.

[@vbh90]

Nice 3D representations, but I do not agree on stating that TPO o PVC membranes do not work (or even bituminous ones). It is always required some kind of protection for the concrete so water doesn't corrode the rebars or damage concrete. Fully adhered membranes work perfectly since these can be either post o pre applied and the adherence is both chemical and mechanical to concrete. In severe cases compartment systems can be used to have a segmented waterproofing, so in case there is a punctual failure it will only affect one specific compartment. Several solutions such as wet applied membranes, fully adhered TPO membranes, PVC membranes with compartment systems. injection hoses and polyurea, among many others, might be the solution. Bituminous membranes stand approximately up to 0.5 bars, while fully adhered TPO membranes can stand up to 2 bars. It cannot be said that a technology doesn't work if you don't know the factors such as water column, water quality, durability expectations (service life), available budget, level of permeability required based on use type (according to BS 8102:2022).So, my recommendation, don't generalize, bituminous membranes in some projects that are not exposed to agressive conditions or don't require a long service life. Another point: if by any reason the membrane fails, you can always use injection resins as a corrective way to stop water in negative pressure.

[@sorconsbuildingmaterialsin2014]

Dimple membranes called as drainage sheet are one of the most versatile and effective materials for waterproofing of the buildings. It is (HDPE) High Density Polyethilen based and provides speed in your construction projects, sustainability and environment friendly solution.

[@darren234r23d]

I think they are referring to either waterproofing concrete admixtures...... and/or liquid applied. Hope that helps.

[@nathandsnow]

they dismiss liquid membrane at the 2:05 mark

[@EarendilTheBlessed]

@@nathandsnow He's refering to liquid applied waterproofing concrete admixtures. Check Kryton. But these systems are not perfect either, probably why they don't discuss it in the video.

[@paulbains9152]

I did not have problems with my membrane leaking for 15 years , until new development next door began blasting to remove rock . Considering an alternative ?

[@manishasharma8518]

No overlapping of the membrane edges done, does it effect its durability and functionality?

[@markproulx1472]

Over four minutes of criticism with no information regarding best practices.

[@johndelc18]

video ends with no answer given, ...new technologies exist... but doesnt says which ones =(

[@TheMartinSavard]

I wish they would anwer your question....

[@JohnSmith-gb3dc]

Yep. I wanna know what's the new tech that better protects the foundation as I'm about to build

[@ClowderBeatsAnimals]

@@JohnSmith-gb3dc long shot but what material did you use in your build? We are about to build ours. TIA

[@jamesrgibsonha]

Good arguments for nor using membranes. What solutions do you recommend instead?

[@alexhermawans]

he give the solution which the properties and durabilities of the concrete itself must be increased which we have now like fly ash which can fill the porous of concrete

[@jamesrgibsonha]

@@alexhermawans That is not really a solution since you are not waterproofing the concrete. The reference to newer technologies is vague and can be interpreted in many different ways. There is no real option provided in this video.

[@alexhermawans]

@@jamesrgibsonha ok I get it. So not just integrated concrete needed then, we also need coating the concrete right?

[@JohnSmith-gb3dc]

I wanna see some sort of solution that blends in with the wall and cladding above

[@lionelolivier5827]

Agreed James. Nice video about the problems without any reference to the alternative. So what should we look into using then?

[@sugyulee7090]

Nice Video to explain about membrane waterproofing fails

[@anshumandriwedi6971]

Polyasphratic with epoxy primer is the best solution for these problems.

[@boedillard8807]

Ummm - so what are the newer technologies that solve this issue?

[@penetronadvancedwaterproof664]

Penetron

[@sexytaxi69]

Nice video. It explains very well.

[@jayce0015]

So what should be applied instead of membrane??

[@elmerkilred159]

Nobody ever bothers putting that info in the videos.

[@jenson3810]

So, what to use.??

[@penetronadvancedwaterproof664]

Penetron

[@SonnyDarvish]

the older I get, the more problems I face. what should I do now if membranes fail? are we doomed?

[@rediaz08]

Informative and on beat

[@nureone6885]

what cause waterproofing failures in pre cast concrete or IBS ?

[@nathandsnow]

the only take away I got, was the things NOT to allow when installing these various types of waterproofing membranes.

[@MultiYlin]

that is why dimple mat was made

[@flopas123]

The problem are the clients most of the time i work for renesco and we are always fighting with clients because they provide us with poor surface and explaining to them that we cant apply anything there is a nightmare and all they want us to do is install membrane but they dont care about the fact that we are comprimising the quality of the waterproofing with poor surface

[@AshwanikumarSainiARTER]

which newer technologies?!

[@ReichenbachEsq]

What waterproofing solution exists for an existing slab foundation?

[@penetronadvancedwaterproof664]

Penetron

[@vbh90]

Waterproofing injection resins

[@howardrickert2558]

Application accounts for 90% of failures, but skilled labor placed it... what?

[@PromoAfricanClash]

What's the alternative? Are the liquid membrane any good?

[@nathandsnow]

they dismiss liquid membrane at the 2:05 mark

[@Will-nb8qk]

It sounds like all options are doomed to failure at some point. Should just source what the old guys did with those building that have lasted for centuries!! 😉

[@XenusMama]

I use 2layers of self leveling liquid membrane. Works great.

[@galaxymetta5974]

@@XenusMama The only problem left is durability. Cheers.

[@elmerkilred159]

Not sure why liquid EPDM would fail other than not putting the primer on. It's pretty elastic and you can layer it pretty thick. You could also not have to worry about screeding because the EPDM will fill the gaps and remain elastic. You would think that you could put a 60mil liquid EPDM barrier and encapsulate the entire exterior and it would be more water tight than a frogs ahole.

[@Jeph629]

Remake. Tell us about the "newer" technologies and leave out the headache music.

[@tunnelingtechniques9910]

whether longitudinal joint can be provided in pvc membrane in tunnels if required

[@fanislekkas3177]

still the issue of poor overlap detailing applies.

[@penetronadvancedwaterproof664]

Use Penetron Product

[@pavlos500]

Wha? Provide all the problems but not the solutions?

[@chrisw.5138]

Well, thanks for just being negative and don't provide statistics, just anecdotal evidence. Better yet, no better solution was presented. Lame. If it is really such an error to use those membranes, then please have the decency to provide answers to the problems you raise. Thank you.

[@flopas123]

Even as i am writing this comment i am at work on standby because the waterproofing areas are not ready and hs2 is pissed😂😂

[@AndrewSchwerin-g3y]

music too loud

[@stratmoreconstructionsolut4630]

it's a no-brainer.....

[@mbomam89]

The most common problem is to buy a cheap membrane from a local store. And allowing it to be installed by an idiot who has no idea what he is doing.

[@josephbohme7917]

So pessimistic.

[@p72910]

What's the Newer technologies ????????

[@Danny-de3ok]

Sprayed and rolled waterproofing

[@stw9362]

liquid membrane

[@nathandsnow]

@@Danny-de3ok they dismiss liquid membrane at the 2:05 mark

[@nathandsnow]

@@stw9362 they dismiss liquid membrane at the 2:05 mark