Why Whisper of the Heart is my Favorite Animated Movie

Get Surfshark VPN at Surfshark.deals/rillas​​ - Enter promo code RILLAS for 83% off and 3 extra months for free!
Schaff talks about peak fiction.
Editor's Channels:
Goop: / goopvideos
Lavender Whale: @LavenderWhale
OneTuffPuff: @onetuffpuff
3aminjupiter: www.inprnt.com/gallery/3aminj...
Patreon: / schaffrillas
Twitter: / schaffrillas
Redbubble: www.redbubble.com/people/scha....
Reddit: / schaffrillas. .
Esteemed $5+ Patrons:
aheaney15
Aiden Mcgillicuddy
Amaru Dejesus
Alexandra
Andre Gutierrez
Andrew Young
Anna Chanthaphavong
Ashley Forrest
BATMAN
Boolobo
CG Lemonade
Charlotte M
Childish Memphino
Clarissa Wee
ClownDuck
Cole Jackson
Crimson Court
Daniel Goldhorn
Danmccould
Delaina Rachelle
Dman990099
Dr Noe Context
Edgar Gutierrez
Emily Allen
Eric Banks
Flan
Francis Sheepie
Gabi Christie
Gabriel Vega Barreto
Gavin T360
Hankshark
Harvey Mulvihill
Ian Seebach
Jacob Baum
Jacob LaBossiere
Jake Albert
Jake G
Jonathan Kermanian
Joseph
Juan-the-Dingus
Justin Gonzales
Kim Trakartwichit
KingsDay
Leif Bradshaw
Logan McQuaid
Matt Fernandes
Michael David Rose
Michael Thomas
Migs
Milky
Milosz Kluski
MirrorWqve
Nessie
Night Man52
NoneLovesMe
Oceanechoes
Olivia Mendel
Osbers Gaming
Peri
Peter Hollens
Pierre Desbrieres
PinkiePotPie
Prismabunny
Put 9-Volt in Smash Bros. Please
Quetzal the Snek
rEactor
Reagan DeFriece
Rebel Friend
Red Mustached Alien
Rocco Damiano
RoscoesDad
Ryland Tews
Sassy
Scott St Jean
Seth Howell
Soloco
Star Giant Productions
Suarez
Sugargae
SuperJimmy978
Tailored Muffin
Teasel
That Guy Named Rai
The GAG Reflex
The TARDIS Pig/TC
Tom
Toxic shock
Tyler Rumbold
Uncultured Swine
Vellum Tony
Vintage
Volianer
Wafflegamr
Winny
YINSED

[@zobiah6263]

When it takes him 5 minutes just to explain the concept of storytelling, you KNOW its an impactful movie

[@sonicfan9144]

And you know he loves a movie when he talks about it in that calm, soothing voice.

[@DaxSchaffer]

Yoshifumi Kondō died so tragically soon after directing this movie. His last credit would be as an animation director and character designer on Princess Mononoke. He was so clearly meant to take the reins as one of Ghibli's most capable directors, and I'm so sad he never got to make another masterpiece like this. At least he directed one film for us before he was gone. I always loved how translation between English and Japanese became a main theme of this story and how that's reflected even in the name of the film. In Japanese, the title "Mimi wo Sumaseba" translates to "If You Listen Closely," while the English title is "Whisper of the Heart," so across both language titles there's an implied complete title of, "If You Listen Closely (You'll Hear a) Whisper of the Heart."

[@catherinepoteat]

Im sobbing 😭😭😭 thats so beautiful

[@hamoiq908]

man got me tearing up, that’s just fucking spectacular art yet again

[@bouncycow3010]

Yeah, his passing was really tragic. Whats always made me feel especially sad about it was the fact whisper of the heart is movie rooted in the magic of storytelling, and the joy in working to create art, whilst Yoshifumi Kondōs death was at least in part caused by the stress at working at ghibli. Really sad to see a creative go when it feels like they just started, but at the same time, I love whisper of the heart so much, and I'm glad he could at least make that.

[@DaxSchaffer]

@@bouncycow3010 His death was, unfortunately, emblematic of larger systemic problems regarding the animation industry. The Japanese even have a word for overworking yourself to death: karoshi. So it's also a problem in the Japanese job market as whole. I know Miyazaki was incredibly sad when Kondō passed and wrote a lovely eulogy for him. I do wonder what might have happened if Miyazaki had forced the man to take more breaks rather than throwing him immediately into another huge project though. Health management is so important, and no piece of art is worth losing your life for. I wish he was still around, but his message of finding joy in creating art is beautiful. He practically gave his life to embody that experience in his own art, so the least we can all do is remember it absolutely.

[@n9cole480]

i love this sm kms😭😭💗💗💗

[@Fenkuro]

i'm so glad someone is finally giving this movie some credit. it's been my favorite ghibli movie for years and it always hurt to see how overlooked it was in the ghibli catalogue despite being one of the strongest, most emotional films they've made in my opinion

[@alexathechris4513]

Same! I relate so much to the protagonist and it’ll always have a place in my heart.

[@sonicfan9144]

I’m gonna say it. Whisper of the Heart is even better than Spirited Away imo.

[@youdontknowprincessjin4255]

@@sonicfan9144to be honest I think so too

[@josefstrauss9017]

In my opinion the most emotianal one was Only Yesterday, i can kinda relate to that. But my all time Favorite always will be princess monoke. But Whisper of the heart is still beautiful.

[@fahr]

it's my favorite too, and I've watched them all so much

[@SillyBoyKisser74]

Shizuku's parents almost made me cry because I realized how much my parents have been supporting me, even when I had like 800 followers on twitter and I had dropped out of 2 colleges, they werent mad at me in fact they recommended an art school, and now I am a full time artist, they understood me without me understanding myself, I was making like 10 bucks every few days when someone was kind enough to ask for a commission, but I guess they just saw the passion I had

[@xxx-ff9gw]

That's cuz ur soft

[@rossana8958]

Congrats

[@m4plemar]

omggg that’s so cool also what’s ur twitter @ !

[@loggerT123]

I love how schaff almost never talks about the latest trend (e.g. bad movies, fnaf trailer, etc.) and just talks about what genuinely interests him. I'm in awe at his consistency.

[@viswajithsaravanan4419]

Just spread positivity and that's why i love him, I do like dunking and listening to PPL dunk on marvel and Netflix, but I can't really replace someone just pouring their heart abt something they love

[@Animestar21]

@@viswajithsaravanan4419yeah, remind people of the joys of film and TV rather than focus on the negatives

[@Antasma1]

He kinda does on Twitter

[@Adamant_Adam]

Right, And I love it. No matter what he uploads I always finding myself clicking and enjoying. There's just something about that personal passion, like you said, that shines through so much that I don't care if he's talking about media I've never even seen or had no interest in viewing. He's just a joy to watch

[@LY3355]

Is what we should all do. About what matters to us. Not the trends or what’s popular.

[@nanashi7779]

This just about the best thing I could have wished for on a Friday evening. A 1 hr pls schaff video on one of my favourite films, and easily one of Ghibli's most underrated

[@BrianCannan-em1nk]

I just saw the runtime this is gonna be so great

[@BrianCannan-em1nk]

@@OfficerBMTnot this troll

[@TheIconicPictures]

Exactly, I’ve seen some great Ghibli movies but this one always hit with me the first time I watched it.

[@UTTPEmperorOfAnimeSucks]

UТТР IS BETTER

[@aclaymushroomwithaberet7084]

who asked you@@OfficerBMT

[@ChenoWolf]

FINALLY WHISPER OF THE HEART GETTING THE APPRECIATION IT DESERVES IT'S BEEN MY FAVOURITE GHIBLI MOVIE SINCE THE FIRST TIME I SAW IT AND MOST PEOPLE DONT EVEN KNOW IT EXISTS. It's inspired me so much as an artist and I keep going back to it when I need an extra push to keep going.

[@sullivan6763]

FR

[@Cattensu]

This is the best Ghibli movie. No, magic, or battle, or war. No over the top extreme fast pace moments. No unexpected twists. Just mondane life playing out. It is so relatable, and comforting. It is mine and my mom's favorite ghibli movie for the simple nature of it. And the Cat Returns is great as well. Such a fun wonderland style fantasy. And a nice look at what could be the story that Shizuku wrote. With some refinement.

[@DavidFowlerMusic]

"For me, it was Patrick." Holy shit, Schaff. Didn't think your video on a Ghibli film would make me break into tears today, but here we are

[@Amalada_]

May i ask who is patrick? I dont know the story if any

[@haihai9022]

@@Amalada_ Patrick was Schaffrillas’s brother, who unfortunately died in a car accident alongside with one of Schaff’s mates

[@carlosandleon]

Star?

[@yshihootelle]

Just finished the video and can confirm that I am in tears.

[@CCela1608]

Came looking for this comment 😢

[@petermarchand1298]

The final remark about the person you needed being Patrick really cuts deep. I’ve always felt like I’m behind where I’m supposed to be in my life compared to everyone else. So thanks for creating something, and making me feel less alone

[@nullpoints0]

rest in peace, Patrick.

[@circependragon1201]

You probably won’t read this anymore, but this video couldn’t have come at a better time for me. After years of not putting a single word on the page out of self doubt and lack of inspiration and creativity, I’ve finally started writing again this last week. It was my two best friends who inspired me, and I’ve even already found a tiny community of other writers at various points in their progress to swap critique and feedback with. I can’t say that watching your video or remembering this film I’ve last watched years ago was what inspired me to write again, but watching it was like an encouraging push, as if the universe said “go on, now. you’re on the right track.” Thank you.

[@intreoo]

There are still people here reading your comment. You're not alone in being inspired :).

[@xxx-ff9gw]

Your soft 😂

[@doremi383]

I read ur comment and im rooting for u in your writing journey. I hope to do it one day too.🤙

[@MarcyRavenManji]

​@@xxx-ff9gwyou're opaque.

[@diversity6681]

That first 4 and a half minutes of the video made me tear up, schaf talking sincerely about a dream that occupied everyone's heads at least once when they kids, adressing the eternal importance of storytelling , showing some his favourite works while speaking with that genuinely touching tone was something i really needed on this saturday evening

[@thataintfalco7106]

Undertale playing the background certainly helped too. Such an incredible score that assists literally every video

[@willpower8289]

You know it’s serious when Schaff immediately jumps into things without an opening joke or wacky segway into the movie the video is about.

[@i8dacookies890]

And no wacky sponsor transitions either.

[@magdawind13]

1) I saw The Cat Returns before I saw Whisper of the Heart, but after I watched Whisper of the Heart I was CONVINCED The Cat Returns was a story written by Shizuku. 2) I thought the abrupt ending was perfect. This movie is not a typical telling of fiction - it’s about reality and chasing your dreams and honing your skill and overcoming obstacles. The climax of the movie (like you said!) was utterly silent while shizuku waits for her story to be read for the first time; so for me to make the ending have a second big climax wouldn’t make sense. Real life doesn’t have a story book ending or a movie ending with a big bang and swooning music - life just keeps going. You have to keep chasing your dreams and aspirations, there’s no finish line.

[@perlamartinez4769]

This makes so much sense! Omg i love this idea 💕

[@t.rae.storyteller]

YES I love this take on the ending 👏

[@alicecarter9672]

I love how much you contextualize each segment. You put so much effort into making sure we understand the intention behind each scene and wow does it pay off.

[@SingerOfW]

As a translator, I'm used to thinking I can only regurgitate other people's works, so this did feel quite inspiring. I'm currently mostly expressing myself through tabletop RPGs with friends, but simply reading and (re)writing so many different stories for my job does put me in the "Hey, maybe I can write something of my own" headspace from time to time. And even if I don't, maybe this video will make it easier for me to sit down today and push through that one passage I've been having trouble with over this week. So thank you.

[@--Cat--]

As someone who has thrown three complete novels in the trash despite being told how good they were and how talented I was by not only friends and family, but also strangers who were only able to read my work because I was forced to share it with them in a class, the opening of the video really spoke to me. I have been told on numerous occasions how amazing my writing is, but I re-read some of the things I write and I can't help but hate them. I think about how awful it is and how it would never resonate or work in a professional sense, and then I delete months or years of work because I doubt the quality of my writing so much that I can't even bare to keep it. I have lost dozens of short stories, multiple partially done novels, and again three completely done novels to my self doubt. Im currently working on another novel, I'm about 20,000 words in and I've begun to lose motivation again. Between work, college, and my personal life I have very little motivation to continue writing, and now I have begun to re-read it and find flaws that could probably be easily fixed but cause me to think that the entire work is trash that is beyond repair. I have managed to control myself and haven't completely abandoned it yet, and I have a free week coming up so I really hope i can regain the motivation, and this video has certainly inspired me to put some serious effort into putting something I created into the world. Thank you for that Schaffrillis.

[@Luke-hd3jm]

You got this!

[@theannoyingdog]

I'm sure what you're making is great. I hope one day you'll be able to see that! Until then don't give up :)

[@Antasma1]

Fun fact: Stephen King threw away what would be his first hit novel and it would have remained in the trash if his wife did not retrieve it

[@eswart2881]

I once got a tip that someone's first draft is always going to be terrible no matter how good of a writer you are because it's the first time you write your story so see it as the bones of your project. As you go on the bones will take form and the body or project will take shape.

[@trevorwhiteboy2649]

I dropped everything to watch this when I saw it was uploaded. Whisper of the Heart hit me in a way I didn’t think was ever possible and is one of my favourite films ever made, as well as my favourite Ghibli movie. To have one of my favourite KZbinrs on this platform also feel the same way makes me feel even more seen. Thanks Schaff, you’ve inspired all 1.77M of us.

[@yummers2401]

@@Fourmann Don't care

[@yummers2401]

@@OfficerBMT Didn't ask

[@odil7583]

@@OfficerBMTBot

[@jitterbuggs]

I think Shizuku is probably the most relatable character in any piece of fiction I've ever consumed, I don't think I've ever connected to a character's struggles as much as I have with hers. Funnily enough, I relate to her more now as an 18 year old done with high school than I did when I first watched the film as a 14 year old the same age as Shizuku. What you said about it being okay to not have everything figured out yet and moving at your own pace was really comforting to me, since it's an insecurity that I've struggled with for years. I've battled with the fear that I'd never amount to anything and that my passions are pointless if I'm not going to pursue them as careers. I've been burnt out by school since I was 12 and trying to figure out what I want to do with my life hasn't gotten any easier now that I've finished high school. But even if I haven't got it sorted out now, I find comfort in the idea that someday I will, someday I'll be just fine and I'll continue pursuing my passions and I'll make a positive impact on the world around me through those passions. Someday, somehow.

[@sematy4948]

I really find Shizuku's version of Country Roads in Japanese more uplifting. I think it's somewhat the opposite of the original version. The original talks about nostalgia and going back home, but her version is about her coming-to-age and pursuing her dreams, about she wants to go back and remain, but cannot since she has to grow up and improve. My favorite line in her song is "Kaeratai, kaeranai", which roughly translates to "I want to go home, but I cannot". It shows that for her to grow, she has to leave the comfort of the home that she once had. It's a typical coming-of-age sentiment but it really fits her story, especially since she has doubts in her ability to be a writer. :D

[@Thatguy57364]

Ive been waiting for this. Its genuinely so great to see schaff talk about things he loves

[@UTTPEmperorOfAnimeSucks]

UТТР IS BETTER

[@Someguy6851]

THATGUY57364?!??! ARE YOU TRYING TO STEAL MY IDENTITY?!?

[@Thatguy57364]

@@Someguy6851 Wait. Brother?

[@yummers2401]

@@Fourmann Ratio

[@yummers2401]

@@OfficerBMT L

[@COCO-tm3gp]

I love it when James casually drops huge videos like in the middle of the afternoon like this

[@WigglyTurdMan]

​@@OfficerBMT🤡

[@roydekock656]

Oh yes, THE AFTERNOON. (Laughs awkardly in 0:44 am in my timezone)

[@Loonaki]

I just wanted to clear up the mystery of the "discordant squelchy sound effect" at 20:55 , because it blew my mind when I noticed! It's the Japanese words for "concrete road" コンクリート道路 (Konkurīto dōro) that are slightly distorted, but you can hear it once you let google translate read it to you! (I'm about to watch the rest of the video now, but I love this movie deeply, so thank you for covering it!)

[@betterlatethannever4536]

Came to the comments to make this remark, seconded! Thanks for making this video, Shaffrilz, I watched this movie with my sister when I was a young adult too and it always made me feel hopeful.

[@thumb5647]

My sister would vlast into laughter yo this because we didnt know what It said when we first watched back in our childhood so thanks for clarifying that information It does make sense now I also noticed that the next scene to Shizuku imitating Seiji while drinking something from the refrigerador the music that Is playing Is that same sentence repeiting over again. 😂😂😂

[@Wadosan]

HOLY CRAP I’m so glad this movie is getting the recognition it deserves. As a creative myself this is one of the few movies that really made me rethink my creative process and what really matters in my art. Such a powerful film.

[@Lady_ETHNE]

I've never seen any Ghibli movie before but man... the way you describe her, Shizuko is almost EXACTLY like me. She hasn't figured out what she wants in life, she would rather escape to fictional worlds than face reality, she gets lost in her own world, she gets excited and inspired over the littlest things, and she wants to create but has self-doubt about her abilities. As a college/high school student in a very messy part of my life, this video really spoke to me in a way I wasn't expecting. Beautiful work Schaff. Ok time to find a place to watch this movie and cry like a baby :) Edit: Ok as of December 2023, two months after the og video came out, I've seen one Ghibli movie and it was Spirited Away. I watched it for my Japanese class and MY GOODNESS it was magical! Now I need to go watch the other Ghibli films.

[@Hoodles321]

Oh you have got to watch them, especially if you liked this!

[@99oildrops]

Spirited Away is Ghibli's greatest film imo. I don't love Whisper of the Heart as much as some but it's definitely worth watching. The protagonist in particular is really strong and I can still relate to her to a degree even though I'm currently 29. 🙂

[@dieselpatches]

I still need to check this one out. Spirited Away will probably always be my favorite Ghibli film though. Too many memories.

[@neplvr]

WOWH ITS YOU

[@roydekock656]

Omg daddy Diesel

[@lpc9929]

What are this? the English? this is English. The. hey Google where am I what is this. Hey Alexa

[@lpc9929]

Google internet go back

[@lpc9929]

I am infertile from eating scented candles

[@Aevyk]

This movie hit too close to home, reminding me of my lonely days of high school and how I started writing and creating my own fantasy world. When I first watched it, I found myself wishing I'd have the same support from my parents. I started rewriting and publishing my own books three years ago, after being fired and unable to get another job. I also discovered back then that I really want to work as a writer. Writing has helped me a lot (my life has never been easy) and being able to share my stories has made me feel less lonely and useless. My parents are still forcing their outdated ideas on me but I still find time to create, draw and write my stories. Hopefully one day they'll be able to help someone as much as writing them is helping me.

[@R0-83-RT]

Watching this review I think something just hit in my brain. The reason Seiji desires to make violins instead of playing them matches narratively to what his character does. Seiji doesn't make the music rather he provides the tools & "instruments" for people to play & create music, similarly Seiji provides Shizuka the inspiration to make her own story.

[@thetacotrucksupporters7976]

I remember the day I watched this film for the first time. It is incredible, it will forever be in my top 10 films of all time. What an incredibly powerful movie that honestly did change my life for the better.

[@UTTPEmperorOfAnimeSucks]

UТТР IS BETTER

[@TheDiamondCore]

@@OfficerBMTimagine buying a bot to make fun of a persons deceased loved one You’re a waste of human space and resources, L.

[@BrianCannan-em1nk]

@@TheDiamondCorenow it’s gonna go “fIrSt WaRnInG!” Because you called someone out for being an awful person

[@DanGamingFan2846]

This film is truly an underrated masterpiece, and the ultimate comfort and inspiration for any artist. Shizuku's struggles really make me feel seen, and and seeing her overcome them gives me the strength to keep going. I'm so glad Schaffrillas feels the same way and is giving this the analysis and praise it deserves.

[@watershipup7101]

Why are there so many hate replies in here?

[@BrianCannan-em1nk]

@@watershipup7101 they’re hate bots

[@dylaninpieces2]

@@OfficerBMT Three people got into a car accident; two died and one injured, and you still have the urge to make fun of a tragedy like that. How would you feel when you lose your sibling and your best friend in a car crash? Please read the room.

[@waterbullstudios9195]

Yes, I'm so glad he's covering this amazing work of art.

[@thusnameddigital9397]

​@@waterbullstudios9195Finally, an actual reply.

[@JuriAmari]

I love Whisper of the Heart and the Cat Returns. My dad bought both films together when I was a teen and I always imagined The Cat Returns as the story Shizuku eventually finishes and publishes and the film’s an adaptation of said story. So glad I’m not alone in this! 😊 The song itself (Country Roads) has a really cool backstory and it makes the connection with Whisper of the Heart that much more powerful when you think about it while watching. 23:04 - also the magic of Lo Fi Girl is not lost on me 😂. I imagine her as Shizuku’s left handed cousin since Shizuku is right handed.

[@howveryedits]

Schaff I cannot thank you enough for making a video discussing Whisper of the Heart. I was genuinely in tears from your words not 5 minutes into the video, as well as seemingly the entire second half. I will be writing some of your script from this video into my journal cause it genuinely hit me so hard. This has been my favourite animated film for years and I was thrilled to hear you discuss not just why it's such an emotionally captivating, brilliant piece of animation, but also how it has personally impacted you and your life. Whisper of the Heart is such a powerful, important piece of storytelling and experiencing it for an hour and 20 minutes through your eyes was like I was experiencing it again for the first time. Thank you for the time and effort you put into your videos - they always feel so special but this one was next level. It's always a pleasure to hear your perspective and voice through your youtube projects, so I can't wait for the day that you release your video game or any other creative projects you produce. You have a true talent for what you do and for connecting to your audience. This came out a bit rambly but I really needed you to know how deeply I enjoyed and appreciated this video of yours, and you as a creator.

[@justinattai1633]

From the bottom of my heart, Schaffrillas: thank you for making this video and introducing me to this movie. I'm a guy in my mid-20's and this video brought me to tears. As someone who loves to create but has recently felt stuck in that regard, both the movie's message and your analysis of it genuinely resonated with me. I don't think I can put into words how much raw emotion I felt as I wondered if making art/content was worth it or even my calling anymore. I rarely leave KZbin comments, but I hope you read this. I don't think I can thank you enough for inspiring me (with this video and plenty of previous videos) and best of luck with your new game!

[@pennycat6317]

I remember being so charmed by how magical this movie was, like I've fully learnt how to play Country Road

[@GorillaFan_32]

Did ask. I make worse content 😭💦

[@yummers2401]

@@Fourmann Not even an NPC, just the main antagonist's brainrotted minion

[@edentimbery]

Thank you so much for making this

[@t.rae.storyteller]

I first watched whisper of the heart because of Shaff's ghibli ranking too, and it immediately became one of my all-time favorites 💕

[@paterpater100]

Damn man, making me tear up at the end. I know Patrick would've been proud of you no matter what you do going forward! Good luck on your game and I can't wait to check it out when it's ready!

[@a17yearoldonyoutubeluigi]

I can completely agree that this film is one of Ghibli’s best and most underrated works. It is such a beautiful and well realized story about what it means to want to create something, and how even if the process of such gets us down at times, we just have to keep perceiving. Who knows? Maybe we will be able to create something the world will recognize, even if it’s a few or even one person. I actually watched it cause of your Ghibli ranking and I couldn’t be more thankful. Continue to keep making great content that touch and inspire the lives of thousands Schaff. 💜 RIP Yoshifumi Kondo

[@NAFProjects]

"For me, it was Patrick" Shit, man.

[@emotionalsupportgoblin]

I cried within the first 10 minutes of this video because no one i know has understood this feeling when i explain. This was so spot on what i needed right now. Honestly i think you may have just helped me change my life

[@zytrux1627]

Alright Shaff, you got me with this one. I wanted to make a story too, and I've been struggling with many things about it. Will people like it? Will I be remembered with it? Will this impact others? .... or will it be a waste of time and effort? Many things in my life made me want to create this story. Life experiences, comic and animation inspirations, hearbreaks, talented artist friends from other countries, and more. I really... really wanted it to succeed... But I kept it for a while. Wrote it for myself and my friends. Its been 3 and a half years I started writting, not counting the many years it cost me to make the world, with currently writting "episode 19" of it as today. One day, last month.... I decided that I wanted to share it to the world. My friends were telling me how good it is, and that I really should. I was petrified. Scared of what I could have done, and if others would think positive as well, or hate it, and mark my name with a dissaster.... Yet.... I took the time to rework the 1st ever episode I wrote thise years ago, remake it, and finally, post it as a script/novel for the public to see, in Google Drive. .... My eyes couldn't believe the positive feedback I got with it. People told me that they loved it. They took their time to read it, and shared it with friends, telling me that they are waiting for the next episode, excited... I even recieved fan art of the characters, and caught my mom reading it out of nowhere, also telling me that she loved it.... My chest felt warm, the moment some people told me that I inspired them to create stories as well.... I understand how you feel deeply Schaff, with the struggle with time and will to create stories, and this video made me respect you more in that reguard, as well as making me watch this movie, which I haven't seen yet. Thank you for it man, and hopefully, the future will grow for you as well as a creator, whatever is by making more videos, or any future projects. For those curious, below the comment is episode 1 of the story I'm making, called "Power Shock". Just if you are interested. If not, it's all good. Thank you so much Shaff for this video, a great inspiration to go on ✨

[@zytrux1627]

Here Is the story in question, just for those interested, in both english & Spanish: drive.google.com/drive/folders/1eqFEkBlKvOdIBnG4VHf9I70nWxfqUPIX

[@kazooha524]

Hey Schaff. There’s no words to describe how this video, and honestly your channel as a whole, has inspired my own creative projects. Your reviews, thoughts and ideas, and just the way you analyze other works have given me a whole new perspective and appreciation for storytelling, and has inspired me to start writing (and drawing) stories. Though I’m nowhere near where I want to be, and not even 10% of the way through what I’m working on, I always find the strength to keep going because of your videos. Whenever I feel like this project is too advanced or ambitious for me, or whenever I’m about to give up because of my insecurities, your videos remind me what I love and found inspiring about storytelling in the first place, and something inside me just can’t give up that feeling no matter how crushing the self doubt can get. It’s too important of a feeling to let go of. So all of this is to say; thank you for your content. Thank you for all your ideas and reviews and comments and analysis. Thank you for all the honest and hard work that you put into these videos and everything you make. And thank you for having the immense courage to post it for the public to see. I can say with 100% confidence that I wouldn’t have even thought about making my own story/animated movie if I had never found your channel, much less actually start working towards it. You have given me inspiration and motivation that some people spend their whole lives searching for and I don’t think I’ll ever find the right words to accurately express my gratitude for it. If I ever do make my movie and have the courage to send it out into the world, you will definitely be one of the people I will dedicate it to, and it would be the biggest honour in the world if you got to see it and give your opinion on it (as much as wishful thinking that is lol). Anyways thank you again for everything, please always keep creating to your heart’s content, and I look forward to playing your game when you finish it :)

[@mr.lantern1111]

I really love it when a fan takes their time and really pours their heart into a comment. It’s just the greatest feeling.

[@autisticDementia]

@kazooha524 Bro wrote a whole ass essay an expected all of us to read it

[@dablloydtruther]

@@autisticDementiai read allat

[@1minute667]

⁠​⁠@@autisticDementia Wasn’t for us

[@octop0de]

I wanted to say something like this too, but I didn’t know how to word it. Thankfully you worded it for me hahaha :) I have a lot of comics i want to make, and it feels really nice seeing all these other people on similar paths. Schaff has indirectly helped me so much through his analysis videos lmao, i owe him a lot for that. I’m so hyped for his game!!!

[@BugsyFoga]

Major props to Schaff essentially making a review about as long as an animated film, that takes quite a bit of time and effort.😁👌

[@OneNamelessHero]

​@@OfficerBMT What a disgusting thing to say...

[@yummers2401]

@@OfficerBMT THAT'S NOT "okey" - Ness, Earthbound

[@aliyan247]

​@@OneNamelessHerothis person is a troll, don't give them any form attention to them

[@OneNamelessHero]

@@aliyan247 I'm perfectly aware of that and usually never respond. Just couldn't handle myself this time.

[@redactedsystem606]

Man, I think this video just breathed new life into how I see my art. I've always wanted to make a comic/story, but as of late, I've just been drawing, cause that's what I do. Even without this video I have been going back to drawing steven universe ocs, which Is how I started making art. I always loved how Su always showed how kindness and compassion can do so much. You basically grabbed me by the shoulders and explained my problem in a way that my brain refuses to put together. I needed this so bad. It feels like a reset of my mentality, and while I don't exactly know where my art will go, I do know how to start.

[@m3rrys0ngstr3ss]

What I had found myself wondering was if "The Cat Returns" was supposed to be that first story Shizuku wrote, or if she's now written a whole "Baron-verse" and this was further down the line in that series. I like either idea!

[@dogymacdogface.478]

Schaffrillas, I gotta say, that was one of my favorite videos I have seen from you in a long time. I don't even watch Japanimation, but you make this movie sound legitimately magical. It was truly a joy to hear you cover your favorite animated movie in a long form video and tell us exactly why it was your favorite and every last detail about it. It really was something special. And the messages about art and pursuing your passions, no matter what they are, is really something special. Get Shakespeare on the phone man, a new poet is in town. I have created a few things myself over the years. Actually, I recently wrote a short story that is just a dude thinking on a porch. It was dumb, sure, but I enjoyed writing it and felt it had some weight to it. I even have a few tv show ideas lingering in the back of my mind. While I'm indifferent to Studio Ghibli, this video is absolutory excellent, and perfectly showed off your writing skills, sense of humor, and general way of sharing thoughts. When I write these things, I'm sure I'll think not only of this movie, but of your journey and what it means to you. Truly amazing, there was never a dull minute. I wish you the best Schaffrillas.

[@tictac2102]

Gonna be honest man, this review has made me feel something I’ve never felt before, and something I never expected to feel, especially from, a movie review, but somehow, in the last 20 minutes, you brought me to tears, and I don’t even understand why… thank you, for sharing your thoughts, they’re inspiring.

[@tuckerroveto3586]

Same dude

[@chainsawpochita]

It’s interesting to note that The Cat Returns was also based on a manga by Aoi Hiiragi, so there’s an extra layer with the movie being an adaptation

[@joey1723]

Wow, I had no idea!

[@marialewis204]

Can I just say I fell in love with this movie when I was younger (I was exactly the same age as the protagonist this movie came around at the perfect time for me in my life.) This was my favorite Ghibli film, anytime I showed it to anybody everyone thought it was boring and didn't understand why I loved this one. I'm so happy there are other people who consider this their top Ghibli film❤

[@rory3727]

I know you weren't but throughout this whole video I felt like you were talking to me directly. Ive been working on this story for 5 years, I don't have alot finished (50 pages of a script which would be 30% of the way done) but its been in the back of my mind for so long. I always loved your videos because more than anyone I feel like your passion for storytelling shines through your work, your love for each piece of media is so infectious and this video is no different. Making a story and sharing it with the world is something I want to do more than anything, this video spoke to me like no other has. I still am a procrastinator but I would be lying if I said this video didn't motivate me to continue working on my stuff. I just hope you know the impact you have yourself before even sharing your game.

[@tuckerroveto3586]

He was tho..

[@5uper8eedle]

I was surprised by how much I needed this video. Good job to the entire Schaffrilous crew, and rest in power Patrick and Chris

[@scottfitzpatrick1939]

I had the privilege of seeing this movie in Japan when it released in the theater. Was an unforgettable experience

[@Legend_7272]

1. Holy shit the ending made me cry, twice. 2. Please tell us when you release the game. My poor college ass will 100% buy it if I can still afford 2 packs of instant ramen a day afterwards.

[@mrduckky9661]

Dude, I've been trying to write this book for almost a year now, and I've just been so self deprecating about it. It's only 70 pages long right now and I've haven't written on it in a long time. This video definitely inspired me to start writing it again. I'm setting the goal to finish it before next summer. Thank you so much for making this video and helping me continue my writing, and I'm absolutely going to check out this movie.

[@BlueBoltVA]

I honestly needed this. These past few weeks being in college for the first time have been the hardest and depressing days of my life. To the point I nearly gave up and had impostor syndrome and self doubt. To the point where I wasn't just giving up on school, but in life as well. What you just said motivated me to keep going with my characters and world, do the cartoon I aspired to do since I was a kid, and possibly. Inspire someone... Thanks so much, Schaff... ❤

[@yummers2401]

Good luck brother, you can do it :)

[@tejakausik6205]

it's also my first weeks in college and i really really get it, i feel like no one ever talks about how lonely college is and how difficult it can be to find a "friend group". but we got this, and we can do it!

[@de_larama]

1:11:40 Schaf I found you in 2020, in some of my worst times. You were the one who convinced me to watch this movie when I first got Covid as I bawled my eyes in the ending. I return to this video, a college student, who had previously quit writing even though it was my dream to conquer my other dreams, science. But you were the one, here, to convince me to look at my stories again. To laugh at the mistakes. To love the playlist of a story I never wrote but made my friend cry once. To look at a book I wrote where I was inspired by my now boyfriend, my love of pirates, my best friend- everyone. You have given me hope for something I thought was going to die as soon as I moved into college. I can't wait to support you in your new video game, and I hope you know this video is the art that moved me to create more art. Thank you, from the bottom of my heart :)

[@bethminers5709]

i once drew a portrait of someone’s daughter with her favourite squishmallow, and afterwards the mother thanked me so much and told me that squishmallow was the last present her daughters dad gave her before passing away, and that it meant so much to both of them because of that. that moment made my whole art career worth it, being able to touch someone’s heart so deeply :) this video helped me remember that and is motivating me to keep going with my art!

[@Hellifyoudont66]

This is the single funniest and emotional video I've seen from the channel as a whole. You (the team) deserve all the eyes, ears, and hearts that y'all get to touch, talking about the things you love (or tolerate, even if barely). Thank you for continuing to push the Whisper of the Heart agenda, even as somebody who doesn't embrace their creativity since thinking of myself as an adult, this story and its impact is some of the most important things anybody can experience.

[@thiagoescalante6245]

The part about parents thinking they know whats best really touched me. I'm a college student that is fighting every day to get out of a dark emotional abyss that I fell into because of how my parents disregarded my feelings in order to make me follow their beliefs and what they think is right for me. Currently I'm far from my worst moment but I'm still recovering and I'm certaintly gonna need a lot of help to fully recover. I just want to say something to all young parents out there, be careful with your children's emotions, neglecting your children's mental health could lead them to very dark places and you could end up loosing them just how my parents almost lost me.

[@luigiboard6456]

"The world will be better with your work of art in it" is the most upplifting statement i've ever heard.

[@angniumfrost5314]

I had your video in the background while I sat staring at a computer screen full of a university assignment full of numbers and it struck me when you mentioned how to tell your story near the end. I don't think this will really affect anyone, or if anyone sees this since it's almost guaranteed to get buried in a thousand or so comments, but I think this has given me the want to push forward with this work I find myself running into escapism to avoid. My entire self is built on a dichotomy between my passion for art yet my skill in science, and I have yet to see someone portray this interest, I feel like I finally have a reason to do so; just to have anyone's interest piqued, or the chance to find my stories interesting. I whole heartedly appreciate your videos, and I find such inspiration within them I don't find many other places, so thank you. While it is unlikely that I will genuinely pursue this passion due to my wanting to excel in science based stuff, I want to carry this inspiration with me. I'm asipiring to be a civil engineer, someone who can turn a sketch of a building and an idea into a real, physical structure that real people can literally inhabit! and I find that fascinating. I hope that one day I can actually achieve these ideals. The last total shot in the dark is that if you are looking for beta testers for your game, I am one interested person who enjoys the dumb fun of the internet and would like to give feedback and support. Obviously I a nameless, faceless dude on another screen, but I'll extend my interest here nonetheless. Thank you for your inspiration. and sorry for a random rant in the comment section. Get good rest and good food man.

[@jgeybp]

James you're the reason why I watched this movie and it is in fact now, my favorite Ghibli movie of all time in a landslide.

[@me0101001000]

I have to ask. Are you an artist too? Because I feel like this movie is absolutely a love letter to all artists. Edit: I should clarify. When I say artist, I mean any kind of artistic or creative work. Music, photography, painting, film, anything like that.

[@jgeybp]

@@me0101001000 i guess i can say that I aspire to be. Same as James, but like he said in his intro, it’s hard to invest so much time on something that has a high probability of failure and doesn’t give stability, hence working on our daily jobs.

[@yummers2401]

@@me0101001000 You feel that way, because, well, it pretty much is!

[@buttercuptheclown4599]

I remember anytime that I wasnt feeling well, I would stay up late and watch this masterpiece of a film Now that I'm older, I feel like I can really understand Whisper of the Heart more, and that just makes it better

[@UTTPEmperorOfAnimeSucks]

UТТР IS BETTER

[@yummers2401]

@@OfficerBMT get

[@yummers2401]

@@UTTPEmperorOfAnimeSucks ratio'd

[@cryguy0000]

This movie instantly became my favorite Ghibli movie, and one of my favorite films in general. It was surprisingly relatable and almost made me cry, thinking about how I wanted to write stories but lost my hopes and passions. The characters are great, the protagonist felt so real with her self doubt, struggles and interactions. Thank you for making this video and talking about the struggles of people who dream to write. It means a lot to me

[@nomu5873]

YOUR GAME WILL BE AWESOME. also yes you inspired me to keep working on a private project! as you said mentioning the mere existence of something like this can feel.. weird.. so thats why im not telling you what it is, but know that you had an impact on me.

[@iyqcha1789]

Man, i love when Schaff talks like this, so much passion, love, it makes me happy just by hearing him talk. Damn you, Crustacean for making me feel!

[@exploringcreativeideas7666]

​@@Fourmannkeep on spamming loner

[@toonbotime]

Thank you Scahff. When I finished the Ratatouille video, it made me cry and inspired me to go back to learning art on my own. I'm only 15m in, and you've already done it again. You're an amazing writer! It's hard to put down why you love things earnestly in a script, and you always seem to do it flawlessly, and in a way where I feel the same. I hope you finish, and publish your stories. They're important. Everyone's stories are, no matter the quality, no matter the effort.

[@Binkus_.]

This is probably my favorite video on the internet. It’s filled with so many interesting topics brought up, how the movie makes those things flow through its story, how many of these things connect to real life. AND the message Schaff is bringing with this video. I love it.

[@chloeandemilysworld]

1:18:38 I think this might be one of my favorite shafrillas videos of all time. I've heard so many people tell me this sentence in my life, and yet I never really believed it up until this video. Yesterday was emotionally one of the hardest days for me as an artist and writer But to know that someone I admire like shafrillas can not only understand that pain but be brave enough to tell his audience his own struggles with his own project Is something I admire more than the little "you can do its" or "just keep trying" I could make a video about how amazing this video in general was But I'll just leave it to this comment Im excited to play your game Schafrillas And I'm proud of you for being brave enough to share it with us ^^

[@ShockedTaiLung]

Always great to see Schaff be really passionate about how GOOD something is

[@lbricks7631]

Your opening monologue was amazing. Worthy to sit in the artistry of Film. Edit: Also its crazy that the lo-fi girl was inspired by that shot of Shizuku writing at her desk. 2nd Edit: One physical representation of Shizuku's writing struggles was how her knee wouldn't sit still. That hit a little too close to home. 3rd Edit: I'll try not to get turned into an Ostrich but I make no promises.

[@Sunkissin]

Funnily enough, as I FINALLY got around to watch this, I've actually been sketching out story characters of mine! This is my favourite animated movie too, and the one movie that everyone needs to watch imo - ESPECIALLY creatives and storytellers. I've been so looking forward to watching this video because I knew it would be FILLED with the same genuine emotions and passion that the film evokes in me, too. this was just as wonderful and meaningful and powerful as I knew it would be. You never, ever disappoint. Thank you so much for this, it really got to me in so many ways as it always means a lot hearing someone talk so positively and warmly about a piece of media that means a lot to you. this is one of Ghibli's most underrated films imo, and I hope this video drives more people to watch and experience it. 💜

[@Xelaria]

I know no one may see this, but this video has inspired me to write, I’ve seen this movie countless times during my childhood because I grew up in a Japanese household, but I never truly understood it or appreciated it until now. I always wanted to make films. But your videos help me give preparative behind the good and bad. And I want to add my work to the world, so one day, you may honestly review it, with a video essay like this.

[@irongrahn824]

Going into this movie blind knowing nothing about it is an experience I wish to re-experience. My girlfriend and I were laughing so hard when we heard Country Roads playing. We had no clue one we were about to watch one of our favorite movies.

[@ethanotoroculus1060]

_"It takes an exceptional creative vision to make me cry, but when you give me an extra element of fun, then bada boom, you are now officially one of my favorite things of all time."_ My mind immediately went back to this when I heard that description of the game at the end. And you know what? I think I agree. I'm looking forward to this, at any pace it may come.

[@EmaLee-097wvz]

At 17, I’ve been consistently trying to decide on whether I choose a safe path or a path alongside my passions. When I say that this narrative truly whispered to what I’ve been dealing with- this film is truly for those with hearts that struggle with the weight of their own future and the art they pursue. I’m so grateful that this movie exists for this reason alone.

[@sixfootnai]

this is one of the most beautifully written videos i've seen in a long time. i am also a creative writer who's been stuck in the development process of writing a novel. thinking everything has to be perfect before conception has really had me stuck in a rut and kept me from writing for such a long time. i have this paralyzing fear that people will not enjoy my story & even raise eyebrows at the subject matter. i fear that it won't be interesting enough, that i won't characterize my characters well enough, & that i'm not poetic enough in my prose to keep people interested. i'm so scared & worried about writing something that won't be beautiful enough to be proud of that it's set me back years. watching this video has filled me with some kind of relief, but also solidified those fears. i love watching your content and you're so good at making things entertaining when they need to be, but also thoughtful and beautiful when they need to be. thank you for making this content for us and giving us a safe place to dump these insecurities and feel normal about them. i would love to give your visual novel a try when you're done with it, so i'll be lookin out for updates in your videos! thank you again, schaff!

[@oceansidez4741]

Im 14 years old and have been trying to write a story for almost 3 years. It’s amazing how hard it is to write a story, even if you have it all in your mind. I love this movie for how relatable it is. I’ve been working on my story for so long now I think about it multiple Ike’s a day everyday, the characters are like my friends and family, and I get so excited when they get to smile and be happy within my stories. I write fantasy stories, and my story focuses on relationships between people. I hope to one day self publish my story, and have it find at least one person to inspire.

[@nintengy64]

It’s really great to see a movie like this get an hour and a half video essay. It really is a wonderful work of genius that deserves more attention.

[@starmis8307]

As someone who wants to become a film director/writer and wants to tell stories that I feel no one has really thought of, I can really relate to this video and movie and I wanna say thank you for giving my favorite movie the spotlight and 1 hour+ analysis it deserved.

[@X-SPONGED]

22:30 How I do love foreshadowing that pays off

[@lelgounderlaine7001]

The Undertale music made my heart melt for a moment, and made me really connect not only to the video, but to my desires of being a creator once again. I still don't know what being a creator fully means to me, but with this video in, I felt myself in it, I feel inspired. Thank you for sharing this masterpiece of art and motivating us to continue, Schaff!

[@jesusa.adorno6933]

Whisper of the Heart is such an amazing story that truly represents Hayao Miyazaki’s talents as a storyteller & adaptor of a manga, & Yoshifumi Kondo’s direction & helped capture Whisper of the Heart’s visual moments, emotional moments and its moments of joy. These men & the team captured a beautiful adaptation about a teenager’s struggles & her relationship of a young boy to show that they have more in common than they’ve realized. This film might be my personal favorite Ghibli film, but Grave of the Fireflies is another masterpiece directed by Isao Takahata that I also hold dear to my heart. Ghibli rules, man.

[@MW_1994]

Whisper of the heart was the first ghibli film I was ever gifted and saw. It always holds a special place in my heart ❤️

[@JewelDoodle]

I’ve been in a rut artistically lately and just kinda in life in general, and I didn’t really know how much I needed a video like this right now. One of my favorite things about animation and film in general is how it inspires people and I’ve always wanted to animate and bring to life stories that can inspire people like others have for me. You are a big inspiration as your love of the things that inspire you and your passion for the things you create makes me feel like I can accomplish that too. Thank you Schaff, this was such a lovely and special video with a lot of heart in it

[@pocketofvegetables866]

It’s just such a sweet and gentle movie. Very nice analysis, you pointed out a lot of things I hadn’t thought about. My favorite scene will always always be the one where Shizuku cries after Nishi gives her feedback on her story, it hits so close to home

[@ethanotoroculus1060]

Goddamn. I'm not even 5 minutes into this 1 and a half hour video and I'm already on the verge of getting emotional. I am so ready for this.

[@shooshiwhooshi8736]

If I had to rank all of Shaff's videos this would undoubtedly be on top. I relate to everything you talked about and felt a lot of emotions out of this one. I cannot beleive it took me seven months to watch this. Not to be too specific, but I felt inspired to something about my life, so thanks!

[@angeliquecheung574]

"Whisper Of The Heart" is one of the top two favorites of Studio Ghibli when I was a kid. The other was "My Neighbor Totoro." Glad this movie is talked about. I just realized there are two movies that talk about the process of creativity: "Whisper Of The Heart" and "Kiki's Delivery Service."

[@ClaireJamesLadybug]

As an artist and romance genre lover, Whisper of the Heart is hands down my favorite Ghibli movie. I'm glad to see so many other artists like yourself feel connected with this film! (Edit: I can't wait to see your game come out! Whether it's a beta or fully complete)

[@theadaptationstationmaster]

Great choice for a favorite. And The Cat Returns is good too. Apart from all the stuff about being a writer or an artist in general. I love that Shizuku guesses early on that the boy who checks out all the same books she does is the same boys who annoys her and freaks out at the idea rather than it being a twist that only every viewer saw coming.

[@Karuminu2]

I love this movie so much, but I don't allow myself to watch it very often because I can't help get so emotional at some of the scenes, especially the climax. I relate so damn hard to the fears and self criticism of creating something from your own mind and sharing it with people who may or may not approve or understand the meaning behind it all and can harshly mock you for opening yourself up and criticize your imagination so cruelly. And the characters who remind me so much of real people who were a huge impact in my life, both positive and negative, especially Nishi who is so much like my late Grandad who is the reason why I took up painting and massively supportive of my creative aspirations. I can't help tear up with at scenes with Nishi because I still miss my Grandad so damn much. I love the art style, the gorgeous painting and the colors that bring the city scenery to life, both the background and the foreground together, the distant views of entire neighborhoods and the city, the sunlight rays through clouds and tree branches...Despite it being a concrete world, like, oh my gawd! I want to LIVE there! Why can't the city I live in be THAT beautiful and fun to explore??

[@tigerbalm20000]

This movie has always had a special place in my heart. One of my first Ghibli films and it’s stuck with me ever since. The music, the animation, the mundane little moments, everything is just perfect.

[@sarahcoulthard5780]

I loved this movie so much as a kid. It was truly something special and still is

[@OnizukaAllMighty]

Among more underrated Ghibli movies This is in my top 5, a beautiful slice of life with great story, characters, animation and music 👌

[@4dragons632]

I've spent the last year or so making a video game. Its consumed my life in my off time outside of work. Watching this got me right in the feels, and that was before you said you were making one too. I wish you all the best!

[@TallTailsTales]

15:00, she's busy being the original Lo-fi girl

[@typhoonthunder]

yes yes yes YES YES YESSSSS THIS MOVIE IS BEYOND INCREDIBLE Whisper of the Heart came at an important time in my life where I had just finished working on a piece of art I had spent two years of my life on and became absolutely convinced that I had embarrassed myself in front of the whole world. Seeing Shizuku break down in front of Nishi about her novel after internalizing her self-doubts and insecurities made me realize it’s okay to feel that way about your work, even things you’ve poured your life into. This review is absolutely excellent and so is this movie. Rest in peace to Yoshifumi Kondō, who died a few years after directing this movie due to overwork. May his encouraging words to all artists live on forever.

[@thatdrunkplaugedr8710]

I love writing and its something I have a passion for. And I think like you said there is something special about creating a world and giving life to multiple characters and creatures alike.

[@doodleman9150]

honestly schaff this is like your best video imo, ive never been so inspired by a youtube video before but your interpretation of Whisper of the Heart and your message to aspiring artists genuinely struck a chord with me, you did a stellar job on this video, great job man

[@cocobeebunnied7371]

I loved this movie as a kid- bit of a strange one for a five year old to be obsessed with but I genuinely think it ended up as a huge influence twords my love of the little, slow and mundane parts of life and relationships