Will Pope Francis Ban Latin Mass This Year? Dr. Taylor Marshall

Please click here to sign up for my Free Catholic Webinar on 3 Lost Traditions in the Catholic Church: event.webinarjam.com/channel/...
Some are saying that an official Vatican document with the signature of Pope Francis is being drafted that will be the “end game” for the Traditional Latin Mass and the Traditional Catholic movement.
The general failure of Traditionis Custodes has liberal Modernists in the Vatican hungry for a second course of restrictions. Are the rumors true. Dr. Taylor Marshall weighs with his analysis.
Subscribe to this channel for future updates on this topic: kzbin.info...
Get a FREE signed copy of the book Rosary in 50 Pages (AND a free Rosary) mailed to you while the offer lasts:
/ drtaylormarshall
Dr Taylor Marshall's newest book: Antichrist and Apocalypse is on amazon (amzn.to/3ESfDEL) or get an autographed copy at / drtaylormarshall
Dr Marshall's previous book: Infiltration - The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within: amzn.to/2ENisHk
Will you please help me in 3 ways? 🙏🙏🙏
✅ 1) Please click Thumbs-Up Like Button 👍🏻 if you like it.
✅ 2) Please SHARE 📲 this video on 📘 FACEBOOK/Twitter using the "Share" Button next to Like Button.
✅ 3) Please SUBSCRIBE (and click bell 🔔) to my 📺 CHANNEL: kzbin.info...
🏠 Real Estate for Life: realestateforlife.org/ (and select "Dr. Taylor Marshall Show")
Follow Dr Taylor Marshall on Social Media:
📺 Taylor's KZbin: kzbin.info...
📘 Taylors Facebook: / drtaylormarshall
🐦 Taylor's Twitter: / taylorrmarshall
Take Dr. Marshall’s online Catholic courses by signing up as a student at newsaintthomas.com
Thank you!
Please LIKE 👍 and SUBSCRIBE 🔔

[@JohnLovesMary]

I am 14 years old, and in July I am going to be trained as an Altar boy for the Tridentine Mass! I regularly serve at the N.O. mass, but now it's getting less reverent and Jesus is suffering so much, and I am praying for the complete restoration of the church to come very soon so that Christ may be glorified on His day and not tortured. Vivo Christo Ray.

[@deluge848]

HOW BEAUTIFUL YOUNG MAN!!! I CAN SEE YOU BECOMING A VERY HOLY TRADITIONAL CATHOLIC PRIEST!! GOD LOVE YOU!!!

[@mrsducky3428]

This gives me hope for the future generations!

[@barbaramprisco5593]

God bless you, young man. I join you in prayer for the return of the TLM w/ the humility & reverence that accompany it. 🙏⛪️🙏

[@user-qf7lp1yb4l]

Awesome comment. Many blessings to you. May you grow in the grace of the Lord under the constant protection of Our Lady and Saint Joseph.

[@loist9022]

God love and bless you. May you become a holy saint.

[@richardcopperfield8978]

Two weeks ago our parish priest was assisted by a newly inaugurated priest. He was however from Cape Verde and didn’t speak Dutch nor English. We have a large group of people from Cape Verde living in our city, Rotterdam. Our parish priest told us just before the Eucharistic Prayer that he would pray in Latin so that his assistant could join in prayer. It was great to hear it. It also reminded me that we are a global Church and it would be great if we could honour Latin more during the Sunday mass.

[@nancywrinn6251]

Amen!

[@PSC9634]

Amen!

[@patriciamathews5975]

One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church. Pre 1970s. All around the world the Latin Mass was attended. 🙏✝️🙏

[@AnthonyAnthony-tk4ye]

Amen and exactly! It is the universal language of the Church!

[@simonewilliams7224]

It is a shame the atheistic modernists don’t consult Jesus Christ and the saintly Popes about any of the changes that started with the Vatican Council One, that were not barely started before it was closedown because of waring factions in Italy in the 1860’s. The Modernists were probably very upset they didn’t get their changes in back then, so they were gung-ho when P. John XXIII announced a new council to be convened. But there was no consulting of the Holy Spirit it seems. It was all about human beings and leaving the layout along with the Lord wondering what went on. Re-crucifying Him daily since the 1960-70’s with a bulldozer, with no regard for foundation in Christ’s will. Ludicrous!

[@suzannedoolittle1768]

Pray for us St. Pope Pius V

[@loist9022]

Amen.

[@Veedon7]

I was a very devout catholic as a child. I loved being an altar boy and serving the early mass . Then I began to see the Church changing and then the Latin mass was gone .I became a lapsed catholic and remained so until the local town I live in started to have an occasional Latin mass The honest truth is I need it to remain faithful

[@taroman7100]

It's ties are to the First Church, the lingua franca of Rome, Latin. We used to kick butt with the beautiful hymns we sang. I DO NOT recognize any Catholic about being Catholic anymore!

[@Veedon7]

@@taroman7100 Ah yes the beautiful hymns all gone and replaced with protestant hallelujah songs .I so agree with everything you say

[@paulbastier3773]

My story is similar to yours. I was an altar server and sacristan in my teens and twenties. When the novus ordo Mass was forced on us with all its variations and innovation I reached a point when I could not stand anymore of it. After one particular offensive desacralized performance of what was being served up to us the Holy Mass, on my way home I called the house of my friend Brenda who had already stopped going to Mass, and told her “that is it. They have gone too far and I can’t stand anymore of it. I cannot believe what I am seeing and hearing in our churches.” I now log into a daily Tridentine Mass in Germany that I access from Malaysia where I live. There are a number of others online sites around the world with timings to suit the time where you live.

[@Veedon7]

@@paulbastier3773 These online Masses are something I would love to tune into .Thankyou very much

[@RichardHansSegel]

Ave. Maria ​@@taroman7100

[@pepitovergarasilvestre7864]

ST. MICHAEL THE ARCHANGEL WITH THY SWORD, DEFEND & PROTECT US AGAINST ALL HERESIES, CONFUSIONS, DECEPTIONS, LIES, ERRORS & FROM ALL EVIL. AMEN

[@mrsducky3428]

Amen!

[@loist9022]

Amen!

[@loist9022]

@@edm-london1660 We are definitely not Saints, eh?

[@gerardducharme2146]

I attend the SSPX and have been for about 40 years. The Bull Quo Primum was in the front of every Altar missal up until Vatican II. I will die in the faith of my ancestors. I pray my own family, who have separated, will come to know and love the church as much as I have. I truly hope that our Lord will grant me this grace of final perseverance. As our Lord said. In the garden not my will, but thy will be done. God bless. Saint Pius V pray for us.

[@user-rc2mj9rp6w]

Majority of Catholics are not aware that before 1969, the Mass was in Latin, and the Liturgy was totally different. The priest was facing the altar, the music was Gregorian Chant, women wear veils, faithfuls receive Communion on the tongue, kneeling, from a priest only, everyone in their Sunday best clothes, etc. The Holy Sacrifice of the Mass was a re-presentation of the Sacrifice of Jesus on Calvary about 2000 years ago, not a meal to celebrate the resurrection of Jesus. From the very first Mass that Jesus instituted on Maundy Thursday (33AD), it developed from when Constantine made Christianity legal (313AD), to Pope St. Gregory the Great (590AD). But with limited communication and collaboration, people around the world had variations of the liturgy. So Pope St. Pius V codified the Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) or Tridentine Mass (Council of Trent) as official and universal, with Apostolic Constitution Quo Primum (from the first) on July 14, 1570. TLM was essentially the same as the first Mass, only improved, more reverent and more solemn. Not until April 3, 1969, when Pope Paul VI promulgated the New Mass (Novus Ordo Missae) via Apostolic Constitution Missale Romanum, where 87% of the TLM was either removed or revised, to make it less offensive and more accommodating to non-Catholics. The modernist mindset, which Pope St. Pius X warned us about, finally gained an upper hand in the hierarchy and among the clergies, causing crisis in the Church until this day. They think that everything must change and adapt to the modern times. If you want to experience the Mass of the ages, before it gets suppressed again soon, look for a TLM near you. Don't worry about the language. There are good hand missals to translate Latin to English. The common ones are the 1962 and pre-55 Daily Missals. Here are the more popular saints from 1570 to 1968, who attended Traditional Latin Mass and received a more efficacious sanctifying grace: 1572 Pope Pius V 1582 Teresa of Avila 1584 Charles Borromeo 1591 Aloysius Gonzaga 1581 John of the Cross 1595 Philip Neri 1617 Rose of Lima 1622 Francis de Sales 1637 Lorenzo Ruiz 1639 Martin de Porres 1660 Vincent de Paul 1665 Maria de Jesus de Agreda 1672 Pedro Calungsod 1690 Margaret Mary Alacoque 1716 Louis Marie de Montfort 1719 John Baptist de La Salle 1787 Alphonsus Liguori 1821 Elizabeth Ann Seton 1824 Bl. Anne Catherine Emmerich 1837 Francis Xavier 1857 Dominic Savio 1859 John Mary Vianney 1860 John Neumann 1876 Catherine Laboure 1888 Don Bosco 1890 John Henry Newman 1897 Therese de Lisieux 1902 Maria Goretti 1903 Gemma Galgani 1914 Pope Pius X 1919 Francisco Marto 1920 Jacinta Marto 1936 Pedro Poveda 1941 Maximilian Kolbe 1968 Padre Pio Let us pray for the restoration of the Traditional Latin Mass! 🙏 May God give us holy priests and Traditional Pope. Amen. 🙏

[@annaanderson2242]

Amen, Amen Amen!!!❤

[@user-ys6sj4sx7j]

Saint Robert Bellarmine 1936. Allan.

[@loist9022]

Thank you for the recap!

[@user-rc2mj9rp6w]

@@loist9022❤️ welcome

[@mmont]

I love your list of "Tridentine" saints.

[@Floridiansince94]

Seems like SSPX will be the last man standing then 🫤😳

[@matthewashman1406]

Schismatic

[@holymarymotherofgodprayfor7388]

They're not schismatic, weren't you listening heretic!

[@Sole-tx9cx]

@@matthewashman1406 no, your buddy Bergoglio and his friends are the schismatics

[@Fundamentis]

@@matthewashman1406 that’s getting very old now..

[@jjmj7095]

This is all part of the plan. The Pope and his circles of Marxists have been planning this all along in my humble opinion.

[@kingpatriarch224]

Once you come to the reality that Vatican II really did create a new religion that is now bearing its "fruits", one is left with a very difficult decision. I was recently speaking to an Orthodox priest who is fairly knowledgeable on Roman Catholic issues and in fact, admires pre-Vatican II Roman Catholicism. Even he said one only needs to look at the Roman West before and after the so-called pastoral council to see what is objectively occurring.

[@marcokite]

Come home to Orthodoxy brother.

[@toddpund5761]

Bingo

[@TheCrusaderPub]

Yes, definitely trust the schismatic.

[@kingpatriarch224]

@@TheCrusaderPubis what the priest said objectively true or not? Please answer.

[@TheCrusaderPub]

@@kingpatriarch224 no, it’s absolutely not.

[@jonathonpalmieri8655]

My NO parish used to offer the TLM once a month. Then within the last few years it’s been taken away. I sent a letter to my Bishop if there would be a way that it could be brought back because we have a large group of faithful Catholics who would love it’s return. I was met with a loud no.

[@taroman7100]

Dictators. The Mass is just about unrecognizable. Cant stand any of it except for Communion.

[@isa2104]

😢 That's so sad, what state was this at? I love to go to TLM, I really don't know what I'm going to do if they ban it.

[@Tom-vh6bh]

So when they ask for money you know what to do.

[@shepherddog1199]

Become a Byzantine rite Catholic!

[@yellowroses8736]

I know one person who has recently left for the orthodox. We are now at the SSPX full time since our diocese decided to limit the TLM during Holy Week and for the sacraments. I'm frustrated and sad about it. A loss of the TLM in the diocese is a loss for all of us.

[@maryvz345]

Even though I attend Sunday Traditional Mass, my home parish offers all of the old traditions in this Novus Ordo parish….daily rosary, May Procession, Adoration and Benediction, Assumption Day procession and devotions, Corpus Christi procession and devotions, Stations of the Cross around town, Schola Masses etc etc

[@LetiTonarelli]

Same at st. Clare parish in roseville,ca

[@karencronin9502]

Same here in NC!

[@taroman7100]

All the forms observed that made it special to be Catholic.

[@beebella2800]

It’s not his to ban. We already know how it ends regardless of what he does or says. The gates of hell shall not prevail. The Church triumphs! 🎉🎉🎉 Amen Pope Pius V.

[@annaanderson2242]

Amen, Amen, Amen!!! ❤

[@Millingtorres]

Mediator Dei of Pius XII, 58: It follows from this that the Sovereign Pontiff alone enjoys the right to recognize and establish and practice touching the worship of God, to introduce and approve new rites, as also to modify those he judges to require modification." Pius V amended his own missal post Quo Primum - did he incur the wrath of the Apostles? No. Neither did the Pope who added the feast of Pius V to the missal, nor Pius XII's Holy Week changes, nor John XXIII with the 1962 version. There are good arguments for making the TLM available, Quo Primum binding all futures pontiffs on a matter of discipline is not one of them.

[@bluemango8689]

exactly, so the whole existence of this channel is pointless and waste of time

[@marybaer4660]

​@@bluemango8689IF YOU DONT LIKE IT THEN GET LOST

[@williammcenaney1331]

A total ban would break canon law because the TLM is the received, approved liturgy for the Church's Latin Rite. That means a full ban would be unjust. So, I could attend an underground TLM with a clear conscience. Thank God Traditionis Custodes doesn't affect the SSPX. My pastor and other priests assured me that Our Lord wanted me to join the SSPX's third order. So, I'm privileged to belong to it now.

[@krystynakucaa3690]

❤

[@concernedcitizen780]

There other groups that offer the TLM. SSPX,FSSP, SSPV, There are other catholic groups Ukrainian, Byzantine, Coptic

[@patriciamathews5975]

Yes, Quo Primum by St. Pius V states that this TLM Mass is for all time.

[@truth7294]

The year 2012 mean anything....?

[@williammcenaney1331]

@@truth7294 I forgot what it meant.

[@TheGringoSalado]

The Parallels between watered down education and Catholicism are uncanny.

[@taroman7100]

So true. The Catholics were once the best educators.

[@sjs4802]

A great big 'LIKE' in honour of Saint Pope Pius V🙏🏻

[@PSC9634]

Dr Taylor Marshall: you restore my faith. Thank you. Pray for the return to tradition. Pray 🙏

[@UlyGooly]

😮😮 Jesus restores my Faith.

[@loist9022]

If it's an illegal order, it does not need to be followed. We are obliged to follow Our Lord Jesus, and His holy will.

[@mariamedeiros268]

AMEM

[@chrisnewberry6691]

That's very protestant

[@essolano]

Mother Angelica, St. Padre Pio, Pope John Paul I were witness of the “INFILTRATION” Let’s continue praying for our Holy Catholic Church. Pray for pope Francisco. ❤🙏🏽❤️ Thank you Dr. Taylor

[@acrxsls1766]

Angelica and John Paul were both instrumental in the creation and propagation of heresy in the Church.

[@user-ds4xh8fj2c]

After reading Quo Primum. How can the novus ordo mass even be considered valid?

[@williammanhire4424]

I've wondered that for a long time.

[@katarinateburcia3046]

Dr. Marshall....I've always loved you little enuendos. You always crack me up while speaking the truth to us lay people. Some get it, some don't. I do and I love it! Keep spreading the truth, no matter what. Your reward is unseen.

[@edtrent3789]

The Final countdown is by Europe and the funny part is that they are going to be in concert in Trent ( council of Trent) Italy this summer.

[@racheljames7]

No way, that's so weird 😂 I love it.

[@rosannerossi6376]

God bless Archbishop Lefebvre. I’ve been at the SSPX since the lockdown. My daughter’s pastor does a Tridentine Mass on Sundays. So when we visit we don’t have to stay home.

[@loist9022]

Yes. God bless Archbishop Lefebvre! He has courageously tried to always do God's holy Will.

[@shanejur]

I've been a Catholic all my life, that's insane

[@holymarymotherofgodprayfor7388]

So have I, what's your point!

[@beebella2800]

It doesn’t matter what Bergoglio tries to do, the gates of hell shall not prevail. We already know how it ends.. The Church Triumphs! 🎉

[@jamescurcurato5779]

It's Bolshyvik Infiltration of the Church, it's been going on since Martin Luther, maybe before.

[@jeromeron2418]

Now I advice you can o wake up Catholic is not the true church What's written in the bible is CHURCH OF GOD GOD IS THE OWNER ITS BEAR HIS NAME UNLIKE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH IS FOR ROMANS

[@Hopeternal316]

@@jeromeron2418ridiculous read the Didache… it is clear round about the world in so many ways, that the devil is loose and roaming rampantly throughout the world and no less attempts to destroy the one true Roman Catholic Church. This division isn’t a sign of any falsehood, but of the truth we represent! ‘…and so we came to Rome’ Book of Acts. Displaced the evil Roman empire of the all the Nero’s! There cant be another location for Rome… Rome is Rome this is where Jesus showed his triumph over the devil’s then major stronghold in ancient Rome. It is symbolic and is actual factual as well… all evil direct attacks the Catholic faith in one way or another. Merciful God fasten us to your bride, the Church.

[@baysideharpy8350]

I’m very lucky and blessed to have an SSPX chapel nearby so that’s where I go.

[@mrbaker7443]

“Er but Taylor, perpetuity means until a week Tuesday…” 😂

[@0311catholic]

Guys pray for me im a catholic and im in a very dark place spiritually and mentally please my brother's and sisters

[@TyranyFighterPatriot]

You a vet? What war?

[@Alex-gy6gz]

I have always had a deep love for Catholic masses in Latin. As a young girl in secular public school, we would sing songs in Latin for our Christmas concert. Gratias agimus tibi, Dona nobis pacem, ave Maria etc. imagine that, a bunch of 12 year olds reciting songs 1000 yrs old! I loved it. The few times I went to church as a kid I was in awe of the beauty of the language. I yearned for Catholicism. As an adult coming into the church, I was a little shocked at how “lax” the American novus ordo mass is. I was surprised I could understand the priest. I didn’t realize my Dads side of the family was very traditional, old school Catholics until I went to the parish in my new town. (Of course my grandma was old school, she was born in the 40s before novus ordo existed!) I remember mass being in Latin and I just thought it was like that everywhere. I was expecting some “espiritu sanctu” or anything like that but no… it was all English. I don’t think it is necessarily BAD but the beauty of Latin is missing. I feel like the Latin versions are more attractive, you feel like you are learning a big part of hidden history. I love the fact that you could attend a Catholic Latin mass anywhere in the world and still follow along. Here in the suburbs of NY, there are barely any TLMs anymore. Probably 2 within a 50 mile radius, and that’s only once a week. I wish they offered more Latin services. Latin enriches our lives more than we know- you learn roots and meanings of words you’d probably never care to learn, you can understand foreign languages better when traveling (because a lot of languages are derived from Latin), you have an upper hand when learning about science (periodic table elements) and medical terms because they still use Latin roots. Why? Cause it’s universal. We cannot let Latin die! If the TLM is banned, the church becomes very similar to that of a modern, American Protestant church. That’s just my thoughts.

[@loist9022]

Beautiful experience that you were very fortunate to have. Do not let it go to waste....Even if you cannot get to a TLM as often as you would like.... Remember to say some Latin prayers in your home. That way your rich experience as a youngster will be fruitful even today!! You are blessed.

[@edtrent3789]

God help the Pope to be merciful toward the Latin mass faithful.

[@dianneraimondi8382]

Wolves aren't merciful.

[@taroman7100]

The 'commie' pope. Why not a younger man?

[@steveschmidt5156]

God have mercy on Francis, for his sins are scarlet.

[@johnfisher247]

Pope Francis has no authority to suppress the traditional Latin Mass. Quo Primum also states it isn't possible.

[@marcokite]

You Romans MUST accept that the Bishop of Rome DOES have that authority - time for Holy Orthodoxy.

[@christinereich6050]

@@marcokite Not interested. you do you.

[@taroman7100]

The old bouncer needs to be bounced out of office. He has brought nothing to the Church.

[@philipguillermond2483]

How about a total ban on Francis?

[@patriciamathews5975]

Now you're talking!😊

[@MRFThorne]

I'm hoping that will come when his entire pontificate is rescinded, or whatever word would apply in this case, sometime in the future.

[@eddieschwab864]

It's called digitalis...

[@pablotope3070]

Francis is a false Pope- he wants any semblance of tradition eradicated. Put your vote by abstaining at the collection baskets - he doesn't need our support at all.

[@julescopy]

How about you guys stop insulting the pope so he doesn't ban TLM?

[@teresaritchie2177]

I love the reverence a Latin mass delivers, I’m a cradle Catholic and was so upset when the NO mass came into being, my current church has a Tridentine mass once per month, a Latin rosary once a month, at Sunday mass verse can be English/Latin… Mass in Latin is beautiful, reverent, holy and makes some feel that their concentration whilst praying to God is more intense… why cant congregations be listened to if Catholic congregations want Latin in the mass then it should be allowed to remain.

[@ellen823ful]

Ignore him! Do the Latin mass if you WANT to. It’s Holy. It’s for Jesus! The pope is a mortal man who’s gone astray.

[@bluemango8689]

sounds like a regular Protestants

[@nicholaswilson2155]

You're right, probably the best way to look at it. Alot of us are frustrated with this pope wrecking tradition like a bull in a China shop,so it's hard not to see it as another attack, especially when the whole world is upside down, changing for the worse. We want our pope to at least be solid,but he is just a man.

[@littlerock5256]

Catholics must obey the pope in matters of faith, morals, and liturgy. A pope cannot, by the graces of the office, go in those matters. If Francis has, then he does not have papal authority.

[@richardsherman9963]

​@@littlerock5256Last 6 words you said: Bingo!

[@littlerock5256]

@@richardsherman9963 So few seem to see it. They will describe Francis being a non-pope but refuse to say that Francis is a non-pope.

[@user-ge9yk2mm8p]

Dr. Marshall, didn’t you always say the “Our Father” in Latin on your show? I remember hearing it and really love hearing it though I do not know Latin. It’s very comforting and beautiful.

[@caroldavis7008]

I am so glad for this podcast and hearing about this document. We have been so lied to for so long. This is solid not abstract.

[@johnarellano8212]

Final countdown is a song by Europe a Swedish rock band in the 80s led by Joey Tempest

[@cjgodley1776]

The best I understand, it can't be done. Quo Primum. Priests and laypeople simply need to disregard these attempts. That, and stand firm when blowback comes for disregarding them. Quo Primum, Quo Primum, Quo Primum! Until someone explains how or *why* Quo Primum would not still be in force, it certainly seems as though the Tridentine can. never. be. abrogated.

[@Millingtorres]

Quo Primum is a disciplinary bull and future popes cannot be bound on discipline by previous popes. Pius V himself altered the missal after Quo Primum, as did various other popes including the Pope who added the feast of Pius V. As did John XXIII. These all confirm that the missal relating to Quo Primum can be changed by future pontiffs, as Pius V himself did. Mediator Dei paragraph 58 states things clearly enough I think: "It follows from this that the Sovereign Pontiff alone enjoys the right to recognize and establish any practice touching the worship of God, to introduce and approve new rites, as also to modify those he judges to require modification." I think there are various good arguments for the 1962 to be more widely used, but I don't think the idea of Quo Primum being still binding is one of them.

[@Donna-li5vq]

I love your book Infiltration, it is very instructing and filled with facts and thr Truth!

[@gregorymikula4249]

Dear JohnLovesMary...God bless you and Our Lady guide you as you begin your service at the altar of the Traditional Roman Rite of Mass. Ave Maria!

[@ortho-g9826]

Taylor there is a phenomenon happening in my local Orthodox Christian parish.....a massive influx of Catholics. I can't logically explain it but it is happening.

[@taroman7100]

It used to mean something to be Catholic we had to make time for Holy days of Obligation. Try telling Muslims here what they cant do. We lived in a time when stores were closed on Sunday because we were more of a Chrisitan country then.

[@ortho-g9826]

@@taroman7100 Yes, I remember those days being 63 years old. I have a copy of the 1962 Roman Catholic Missal. For the life of me I can't understand why the Roman Church gave this up. Latin on one side English on the other side of the page and pages. THIS is real LITURGY. I am Eastern Orthodox and I reverence our tradition(s) but I can certainly respect this Tridentine Canon. My lawyer, may God rest him, was a devout Irish Catholic who was very active in the local Catholic diocese and he told me that prior to Vatican II the churches were full and after the Council they began to empty out. Very unfortunate. God bless.

[@JamesMartinelli-jr9mh]

@@ortho-g9826 Why don't the Orthodox who are ecumenically inclined put pressure on the Pope to keep the Liturgy of St. Peter / the Roman Rite?

[@user-wt5cp9fu7s]

If they took the TLM away. All people should open their mouths to receive the Eucharist and when they refuse WALK OUT and Hope most will in time follow!

[@taroman7100]

We were never allowed to handle the Host. It's sacriliges and I wont do it!

[@kdmdlo]

You're loony. It is well, well established that a priest cannot deny someone the Eucharist because the want to receive on the tongue. You're making a straw man so that you have something to complain about and knock down. But it doesn't exist. Oh, and not for nothing, but if you're so antsy to leave His Church, you know where the door is. And remember that it'll still be open when you decide to come back.

[@CatalinaSiena]

God took me to the Traditional Mass, I was already tired of seeing how the Lord is mistreated at the Novus Ordo Mass, my son has already begun to serve at the altar, and it is incredible how in such a short time my son is seriously dedicated to this service. Blessed God and blessed be the traditional Mass.🙏🏻

[@chrisoverbey5937]

FSSP priests are hardcore, they will keep doing their thing no matter what the Pope says. The FSSP and ICK & the Pope Pius crowd are not afraid of schism. There will be two popes, the social justice one in the Vatican and a second traditional one somewhere else

[@osar2870]

That would be extremely sad , it’s a very tough situation because to be a good priest you must ask be obedient

[@racheljames7]

I would hate that. I go to an SSPX Chapel and I want one Pope in the Vatican and I want him to be good.

[@Jesus-jt7tq]

Praise the lord 😂😍🎚 Thank you very much ✋

[@roseangela2797]

Thank you very much, Dr Marshall. HOD BLESS YOU ABUNDANTLY.

[@johnmaguire9305]

Really good presentation. My view is that Quo Primum was given for all time. Fr. Hesse has a number of very good audio recordings on this subject.

[@senterman01]

Great video! I have been waiting for a Quo Primum video! Thank you Dr. Taylor Marshall for all you do!!

[@StanislausJoseph2021]

Dr. Marshall, you've got your "Amen".

[@nicholaswilson2155]

A valid pope wouldn't ban TLM, or in any way support gays or abortion, therefore, Francis doesn't seem very valid to me.

[@steveschmidt5156]

Francis is to the papacy what Joe Biden is to the presidency: both degenerate holders of their respective offices.

[@concernedcitizen780]

He invites comedians…. What does that mean….

[@poesia-com-cafeina]

Just because he does something you don't agree with, doesn't mean he isn't your pope. If claim to be Catholic, then he is your pope.

[@concernedcitizen780]

@@poesia-com-cafeina “ don’t agree with” maybe doctrinally absurd and against the prior teachings of the church and prior popes. But.. you are correct. He is still the pope.

[@poesia-com-cafeina]

@@concernedcitizen780 The tridentine mass didn't even come about until the 16th century so even that was new at one point

[@andreamariterickson5885]

I went to the TLM today. Father said things will get worse but we will weather this storm as long as we have a disciplined prayer life. Father also said that the papal document on the final solution for the Tlm that will come out this year on July 16. pray and fast. Seriously, that's what he said. My annual 33 days of prayer before my anniversary of total consecration to Jesus through Mary began June 13. Not saying there is a significance between the two.

[@loist9022]

Yes. Your priest is right. We must all pray and fast. Thanks for following his good advice. May you be blessed.

[@cianmoriarty7345]

I go to the FSSP. The priests are fantastic. The parishioners are fantastic. The men's group is fantastic. The liturgy frequently moves me to tears. But it is a three hour round trip for me. When I have three Catholic churches in walking distance.

[@JDeF.39]

About a year ago I registered in a second parish where the TLM is celebrated every Sunday morning. My other (more frequent parish) is only about 10 mins away and they quit the TLM a couple of years ago when their one Benedictine priest was transferred. I admit I go there when the weather is bad or I have no other choice but I miss the TLM and go to my 2nd parish as often as I can...I live in the suburbs and it is located in downtown Detroit...so if the weather is bad and I cannot get there alone (I am a 73yo widow) I don't go. I miss it like crazy, grew up with it, want it EVERY TIME. I don't know what else to do... 😥 ...

[@andreamariterickson5885]

Contact the parish office and ask them to put a notice in the bulletin asking for a volunteer to drive you to mass.

[@loist9022]

You are doing the right thing. You go to the Tridentine Mass as often as you can. Good job. Bless you!

[@christinereich6050]

I love my Douay-Rheims bible. Interestingly enough I believe it was Dr. Marshall who suggested it back in the day, on the radio. Later I discovered him on YT.

[@Donna-li5vq]

I agree with you Taylor on all counts!

[@shanseli7490]

St Pius V, Pray for us

[@MommaNanaKay]

The local FSSP priest has already been requested (required?) to attend the diocesan Chrism Mass and he has attended for the last two years. Our bishop is not friendly to the TLM and our diocese is a mess. We are looking elsewhere.

[@b.c.h.u.a]

Ours in Parramatta NSW allows FSSP to continue. Which location are you.

[@harryjohnson3975]

Taylor, AMEN AND AMEN.

[@reggiejenkins6458]

The only solution is for us to stop going to mass and stop donating until it’s overturned. If the church loses a big chunk of money, they will fold. It will be terrible missing mass but it will be fighting the good fight for future generations.

[@ashleyslack5960]

No. You do not sin so that good may come.

[@user-ys6sj4sx7j]

M Carrick got big donations from the Nazis in Argentina. Allan.

[@user-ne4ly3vh6b]

It is not a sin to lower the amount of money one gives to a Church that in some cases -see NCHD and some activities of Catholic Charoties-supports evil

[@deusvult8340]

That is an actual mortal sin no matter what you think of the mass

[@reggiejenkins6458]

@@deusvult8340 it depends who you ask

[@mikesteele5498]

Amen! Dr. Taylor Marshall 🌵

[@jameshogan6142]

Decades ago I used to feel a filial devotion to our pope and a willingness to pray for his intentions and follow his decrees.

[@VeronicaJohnson-cq5xp]

Amen, Amen, Amen. St Pope Pius V Pray for us.

[@jeffgriscoa8131]

He has no right to suppress the Latin mass. We don’t have to obey this type of behavior from anyone. That’s like taking your most powerful medicine away from you! God is not for this and neither are we!

[@zalobo]

PRAY, PRAY, PRAY FOR THE TRUE CATHOLIC CHURCH OF JESUS CHRIST !!!

[@mollyoneil809]

I think listening to Quo Primum just nailed the coffin in the Novus Ordo for me.

[@Mark3ABE]

Cardinal Roche (Prefect of the Dicastery for the Liturgy) announced some time ago that the Tridentine Form of the Mass represented a Theology now no longer acceptable to the Church and must be discontinued entirely. He was wrong on so many counts. Firstly, the Council decreed that all existing forms of the Liturgy were to be reverenced and preserved. The Council intended that the Tridentine form of the Mass should remain unaltered - with parts (not all) being translated directly into the vernacular. So, it was not the Theology which was out of date, but the language. Secondly, it is impossible to state that the Theology is wrong, since that is to say that the Church taught error for five hundred years. An unkind English friend who knows (and likes) Cardinal Roche commented that he is a lovely man, but that if his brains were dynamite, there would be enough in there to blow his hat off.

[@dsonyay]

FSSP and ICKSP will not be affected

[@michellemcdermott2026]

Thank God

[@paulmorse2977]

Dr. Marshall. I’ve been subscribed for about 3 years and have looked up several of your episodes before that time. I enjoy hearing your information and your opinions. Lately I find that your shows are much lower in content and excessive in product placement for your other work. Also too much time spent reading live chats.

[@kailaleebabineau3962]

This holds true across all of KZbin unfortunately

[@Mark-rd1it]

The final count down was by Europe. You have a great voice Taylor. I am serious. You could be a singer as well as a writer.

[@chrisboone5069]

Well Francis is really stepping in it now💩. I transferred to the Byzantine Rite when I was 19 years old. Glad I did.☦️

[@demsrchildabusers7959]

The other rites are next on the list.

[@chrisboone5069]

Yeah no doubt ​@@demsrchildabusers7959

[@josemont4291]

Some traditions have been lost because the "faithful" Catholics do not practice them any more! You know what I mean, you lose something because you don't care about it

[@francislocke5094]

It was in force for 399 years without challenge. That makes it Tradition and must be accepted

[@NovusDisorder-so6un]

Dr. Taylor Marshall, where will we go? What will we do?

[@janicecolon-mahoney5397]

Very interesting, had no idea. Thanks

[@paulquist2475]

Today, Wednesday, June 19 at 5:30 pm St. Patrick's Cathedral in Melbourne, Australia celebrates it's last TLM - shutting down because of Traditionis Custodes 😢

[@mariamartin94]

I’m sorry😔our Cathedral with a huge TLM community ended the Mass during Lent. Heart-wrenching isn’t it?

[@loist9022]

Mother Mary, Holy God the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, have mercy on us!

[@nikkisanner1496]

What quo primum said doesn’t matter to the current hierarchy. They expect you to follow their “rules” but none apply to them!!! Ask bishop Strickland about how quo primum protected him from being removed.

[@Dee-mj3pu]

Thank you!

[@mmont]

Questions: So, the replacing of the Tridentine Mass with the Novus Ordo was illicit, right? And if the Tridentine liturgy was established in perpetuity by the Pope's absolute authority, then that's without a doubt an infallible pronouncement on our shared faith, correct?

[@Millingtorres]

Not correct. Pius V amended his own missal, so did the Pope that added the feast of Pius V and various other changes have happened to the missal up to the 1962 version. If you take Dr Marshall's stance here then all of those Popes, including Pius V himself, brought upon themselves the wrath of the apostles by amending the missal. Mediator Dei paragraph 58 makes it clear that the Pope can approve or introduce new rites. Quo Primum was promulgated as a disciplinary bull using the language typical of such documents of the time. A Pope cannot bind his successors on disciplinary matters, which liturgical rites fall into. There are good arguments as to why the TLM should be celebrated more widely, that Quo Primum is still binding is not one of them.

[@samwyz69]

One pope “abolishes” it, the next pope restores it, the pope after that abolishes it, then the following one restores it, and so on it goes.

[@daveufirst]

Sounds like US politics.

[@eugeniadoucette4510]

One Pope should never go against any predecessor in regards to anything that is good and wholesome especially the traditional liturgy just for hermeneutic of continuity. Messing with the mass like this is very dangerous and causes scandal and confusion. It's like saying a certain Saint is not a saint anymore bc of the changing times. It's insane

[@zsofiasz.8533]

I would love to register but I’m in Hungary. Is it going to be available to watch later in a different form? :) Thank you 🙏

[@margaretmccrann467]

He May Ban our Mass but we are stronger than him ,if we have to Have our Mass Underground so be it For us In Ireland we have been through this Before and we still are here PS Dr don't give up your Day Job singing is not your Style x

[@taroman7100]

We have a rogue priest here in Albuquerque southwest corner of the city. He has Latin Mass at his home!

[@albertoascari2542]

We think a channel called Proffessor Dr Taylor Marshall is scamming your channel. Didn't realise till I noticed the non image recordings and comments

[@maximoo9861]

Yes I saw that in the last day or so it's got some of Dr Marshall's old recordings on it

[@albertoascari2542]

It seemed his channel so I subscribed but its a bit off somehow as we haven't got the official ok from Taylor

[@user-qf7lp1yb4l]

Dear Dr Marshall, thanks for this lecture. It is also important to bring to everyone's attention on the final period on Quo Primum Papal bull. Here is the English text: "Therefore, no one whosoever is permitted to alter this notice of Our permission, statute, ordinance, command, precept, grant, indult, declaration, will, decree, and prohibition. Should know that he will incur the wrath of Almighty God and of the Blessed Apostles Peter and Paul". It seems that no changes were allowed, even for centuries after its promulgation on the 14th July 1570. As clear as daylight, I would say. I am adding the original text: Pius Episcopus Servus Servorum Dei Ad Perpetuam Rei Memoriam Quo primo tempore ad Apostolatus apicem assumpti fuimus, ad ea libenter animum, viresque nostras intendimus, et cogitationes omnes direximus, quae ad Ecclesiasticum purum retinendum cultum pertinerent, eaque parare, et Deo ipso adjuvante, omni adhibito studio efficere contendimus. Cumque inter alia sacri Tridentini Concilii decreta, nobis statuendum esset de sacris libris, Catechismo, Missali et Breviario edendis atque emendandis: edito jam, Deo ipso annuente, ad populi eruditionem Catechismo, et ad debitas Deo persolvendas laudes Breviario castigato, omnino, ut Breviario Missale responderet, ut congruum est et conveniens (cum unum in Ecclesia Dei psallendi modum, unum Missae celebrandae ritum esse maxime deceat), necesse jam videbatur, ut, quod reliquum in hac parte esset, de ipso nempe Missali edendo, quam primum cogitaremus. Quare eruditis delectis viris onus hoc demandandum duximus: qui quidem, diligenter collatis omnibus cum vetustis nostrae Vaticanae Bibliothecae, aliisque undique conquisitis, emendatis atque incorruptis codicibus; necnon veterum consultis ac probatorum auctorum scriptis, qui de sacro eorumdem rituum instituto monumenta Nobis reliquerunt, ad pristinam Missale ipsum sanctorum Patrum normam ac ritum restituerunt. Quod recognitum jam et castigatum, matura adhibita consideratione, ut ex hoc instituto, coeptoque labore, fructus omnes percipiant, Romae quam primum imprimi, atque impressum edi mandavimus: nempe ut sacerdotes intelligant, quibus precibus uti, quos ritus, quasve caeremonias in Missarum celebratione retinere posthac debeant. Ut autem a sacrosancta Romana Ecclesia, ceterarum Ecclesiarum matre et magistra, tradita ubique amplectantur omnes et observent, ne in posterum perpetuis futuris temporibus in omnibus Christiani orbis Provinciarum Patriarchalibus, Cathedralibus, Collegiatis et Parochialibus, saecularibus, et quorumvis Ordinum, monasteriorum, tam virorum, quam mulierum, etiam militiarum regularibus, ac sine cura Ecclesiis vel Capellis, in quibus Missa Conventualis alta voce cum Choro, aut demissa, celebrari juxta Romanae Ecclesiae ritum consuevit vel debet, alias quam juxta Missalis a nobis editi formulam decantetur, aut recitetur, etiamsi eaedem Ecclesiae quovis modo exemptae, Apostolicae Sedis indulto, consuetudine, privilegio, etiam juramento, confirmatione Apostolica, vel aliis quibusvis facultatibus munitae sint; nisi ab ipsa prima institutione a Sede Apostolica adprobata, vel consuetudine, quae, vel ipsa institutio super ducentos annos Missarum celebrandarum in eisdem Ecclesiis assidue observata sit: a quibus, ut praefatam celebrandi constitutionem vel consuetudinem nequaquam auferimus; sic si Missale hoc, quod nunc in lucem edi curavimus, iisdem magis placeret, de Episcopi, vel Praelati. Capitulique universi consensu, ut, quibusvis non obstantibus, juxta illud Missas celebrare possint, permittimus; ex aliis vero omnibus Ecclesiis praefatis eorumdem Missalium usum tollendo, illaque penitus et omnio rejiciendo, ac huic Missali nostro nuper edito, nihil unquam addendum, detrahendum, aut immutandum esse decernendo, sub indignationis nostrae poena, hac nostra perpetuo valitura constitutione statuimus et ordinamus. Mandantes ac districte omnibus et singulis Ecclesiarum praedictarum Patriarchis, Administratoribus, aliisque personis quacumque Ecclesiastica dignitate fulgentibus, etiamsi S.R.E. Cardinales, aut cujusvis alterius gradus et praeeminentiae fuerint, illis in virtute sanctae obedientiae praecipientes, ut ceteris omnibus rationibus et ritibus ex aliis Missalibus quantumvis vetustis hactenus observari consuetis, in posterum penitus omissis, ac plane rejectis, Missam juxta ritum, modum, ac normam, quae per Missale hoc a Nobis nunc traditur, decantent ac legant; neque in Missae celebratione alias caeremonias, vel preces, quam quae hoc Missali continentur, addere vel recitare praesumant. Atque ut hoc ipsum Missale in Missa decantanda, aut recitanda in quibusvis Ecclesiis absque ullo conscientiae scrupulo, aut aliquarum poenarum, sententiarum et censurarum incursu, posthac omnino sequantur, eoque libere et licite uti possint et valeant, auctoritate Apostoloca, tenore praesentium, etiam perpetuo concedimus et indulgemus. Neve Praesules, Administratores, Canonici, Capellani et alii quocumque nomine nuncupati Presbyteri saeculares, aut cujusvis Ordinis regulares, ad Missam aliter quam a nobis statutum est, celebrandam teneantur: neque ad Missale hoc immutandum a quolibet cogi et compelli, praesentesve litterae ullo umquam tempore revocari, aut moderari possint, sed firmae semper et validae in suo exsistant robore, similiter statuimus et declaramus. Non obstantibus praemissis, ac constitutionibus, et ordinationibus Apostolicis, ac in Provincialibus et Synodalibus Conciliis editis generalibus, vel specialibus constitutionibus, et ordinationibus, nec non Ecclesiarum praedictarum usu, longissima et immemorabili praescriptione, non tamen supra ducento annos, roborato, statutis et consuetudinibus contrariis quibuscumque. Volumus autem et eadem auctoritate decernimus, ut post hujus nostrae constitutionis, ac Missalis editionem, qui in Romana adsunt Curia Presbyteri post mensem; qui vero intra montes, post tres; et qui ultra montes incolunt, post sex menses, aut cum primum illis Missale hoc venale propositum fuerit, juxta illud Missam decantare, vel legere teneantur. Quod ut ubique terrarum incorruptum, ac mendis et erroribus purgatum praeservetur, omnibus in nostro et S.E.R. dominio mediate, vel immeditate subjecto commorantibus impressoribus, sub amissionis librorum, ac centum ducatorum auri Camerae Apostolicae ipso facto applicandorum: aliis vero in quacumque orbis parte consistentibus, sub excommunicationis latae sententiae, et aliis arbitrii nostri poenis, ne sine nostra vel speciali ad id Apostolici Commissarii in eisdem partibus a nobis constituendi, licentia, ac nisi per eumdem Commissarium eidem impressore Missalis exemplum, ex quo aliorum imprimendorum ab ipso impressore erit accipienda norma, cum Missali in Urbe secundum magnum impressionem impresso collatum fuisse, et concordare, nec in ullo penitus discrepare prius plena fides facta fuerit, imprimere, vel proponere, vel recipere ullo modo audeant, vel praesumant, auctoritate Apostolica et tenore praesentium similibus inhibemus. Verum, quia difficile esset praesentes litteras ad quaeque Christiani orbis loca deferri, ac primo quoque tempore in omnium notitiam perferri, illas ad Basilicae Principis Apostolorum, ac Cancellariae Apostolicae, et in acie Campi Florae de more publicari et affigi, ac earumdem litterarum exemplis etiam impressis, ac manu alicujus publici tabellionis subscriptis, nec non sigillo personae in dignitate ecclesiastica constitutae munitis, eamdem prorsus indubitatam fidem ubique gentium et locorum, haberi praecipimus, quae praesentibus haberetur, si ostenderentur vel exhiberentur. Nulli ergo omnino hominum liceat hanc paginam nostrae permissionis, statuti, ordinationis, mandati, praecepti, concessionis, indulti, declarationis, voluntatis, decreti et inhibitionis infringere, vel ei ausu temeratio contraire. Si quis autem hoc attentare praesumpserit, indignationem omnipotentis Dei, ac beatorum Petri et Pauli Apostolorum ejus se noverit incursurum. Datum Romae apud S. Petrum, anno Incarnationis Dominicae millesimo quingentesimo septuagesimo, pridie Idus Julii, Pontificatus nostri anno quinto. Caesar Glorierius

[@loist9022]

Wow. Thank you for that. Really good to know!

[@user-qf7lp1yb4l]

@loist9022 Thanks so much for your gracious comment. I enjoy reporting original texts after analysing them. I am so glad I studied Latin and still master it after so many years. Blessings in Our Lord, Our Lady and Saint Joseph. Saint Peter and Paul pray for us.

[@maryoregan6770]

Every time I hear the name of Cardinal Roche it reminds me that he was Bishop of Leeds England, during the time I lived there. I met him when he led our diocesan pilgrimages to Lourdes on several occasions. I had no idea then that he had those views on the liturgy. Wish I had.

[@Mosux2007]

He is one Roche that needs a Roche Motel.

[@ellem6050]

He's clearly one of those wolves in sheep's clothing we've been taught about.

[@Sole-tx9cx]

I will NEVER go to a Novus Ordo mass. I will go to SPPX or Ukrainian Catholic if I have to.

[@matthewashman1406]

Go Baptist

[@tojesusthroughmary8932]

founder?Man-made church​@@matthewashman1406

[@andrewstahl3531]

protestant much?

[@matthewashman1406]

@@tojesusthroughmary8932 like sspx 😂

[@Sole-tx9cx]

@@matthewashman1406 Yeah, no. I don’t do heretical religions.

[@MrAwak3]

If Rome considers EO valid churches, what prevents you from attending them until these issues are resolved? If there is a ban on Latin Mass and people do it in protest, you will be in schism as well.

[@ashleyslack5960]

Not everyone has access to them.

[@108257able]

Is there anyway of watching the webinar? I missed original airing

[@Mark3ABE]

Some comments on the use of the Latin language in the Church. The Church was founded in Palestine. It spread into what we now know as Turkey, at that time, called Asia Minor. Then, the Roman Emperor became Christian. The Barbarians invaded Italy and the Emperor and the Roman Patrician families fled from Rome to Constantinople. There, the official langue of the Eastern Roman Empire remained Latin. The Emperor Justinian wrote his famous Legal Code in Latin. However, the every day language of the people was Greek. The Bible, the Mass and all the Liturgy were in Greek. Then, the Barbarians were converted and Rome had Christian rulers. As the Church became established there, the Greek Liturgy was used originally. Then, there was pressure to have the Bible and the Liturgy in the vernacular. So, St. Jerome translated the Bible into the vernacular, or vulgar, tongue. The Mass was translated into the vernacular, however, one part remained in Greek, the Kyrie, and the Kyrie remained in Greek even after the whole of the Latin Rite Church adopted the use of the vernacular in the Liturgy. By the time of the Second Vatican Council, once again, just as in the early Church in Rome, there was pressure to have the Liturgy in the vernacular. This was approved by the Council. Initially, the Kyrie remained in Greek - it was a tangible connection to the early Liturgy of the early Church. Finally, it was translated into the vernacular. Now, if I were the Pope, what would I do? I should have the Liturgy in the vernacular. I should have the Kyrie in Greek, once again, as a link with the early Liturgy. I should have several of the central prayers of the Mass in Latin, perhaps the Angus Dei and the Domine Non Sum Dignis as a connection with the earlier Latin liturgy. I should restore the Prayers at the Foot of the Altar and the Last Gospel - in the vernacular. However, I am not the Pope and one thing I can guarantee - despite all of the talk of Synodality, the Pope would not pay any attention at all to anything I might say. He would not pay any attention to anything which Taylor Marshall might say.

[@Hopeternal316]

At some point, i should think logically, that following the persecution which initially drove them from Rome, some of the Christians declared that they must return ( after all the Lord is triumphing over ancient Rome seat of the devil, with Christianity, (and i read this in a history book somewhere in my conversion to Catholic but havent been able to locate it yet again) to which the fearful exclaimed to the effect of, if we go back there they will kill us! And the brave, insistent to return to Rome exclaimed that if then they die, they die! In Rome… anyone familiar with this? St Anthony if this is true, help me locate this…

[@loist9022]

I think that the Pope is paying attention to Taylor Marshall. He is infuriated by what Marshall is saying. He is more than likely trying to figure out a way to silence Taylor. But he cannot quite figure out the expedient way to do that. Just my opinion.

[@chiaramaria308]

I belong to a TLM Parish and will never go to an irregular Society, or independent Catholic Church. No. What we WANT or prefer cannot pull us away from the faith. Persecution is nothing new. We may lose all Masses, and have to go underground. Until then, stay the course. One other point, let's cut back on the fear mongering also. Where is the faith in Divine Providence here.

[@GKC97]

So you will attend “underground Mass” presumably offered in open defiance of the Pope and the local Bishop, but you will “never” go to the SSPX. Just go to the SSPX folks. Don’t buy into the circular FSSP brain washing. Vatican 2 is a Masonic Robber Council that managed to bind the faithful to absolutely nothing. Lefebver is a Hero of the Faith.

[@emilios9216]

I live in California, after many years of looking for a church that celebrated the Latin Mass, I found one, which I have been attending, a couple of months, the priest on the homily, told us to follow the teachings of Pop Francis, that there many propaganda against his actions, that if we were listening and not wanting to follow Pop Francis we were excommunicated. He used a different word but, when I told this to my confessor, he called excomunión

[@marccrotty8447]

Emilios. Your Priest is confused. Pope Francis documents are trash.

[@debbiescott3889]

What church?

[@judithblanche-agathaabito6712]

Amen and may! G0d be praised

[@user-do5qk3fj3k]

What I don’t understand is how could the Church change our Holy Mass of All Ages and restrict it despite the Pius V’s Quo Primum. This is the most devastating to me - not only is it restricted but now its existence threatened all together. However, I’m certain that with God’s help we won’t allow it to happen. That we’ve learned on our parents’ and grandparents’ mistakes. Quo Primum is a great gift from Puis V, so we should use it going forward. Along with Benedict XVI’s Summorum Pontificum.

[@Millingtorres]

What I don't understand is how could the Church change our Holy Mass of All Ages and restrict it despite Pius V's Quo Primum" - because Quo Primum was a disciplinary bull which does not bind his future successors. Pius V himself changed the missal by adding a feast, as did the Pope who added the feast of Pius V, Pius X who changed the calendar, and Pius XII who amended the Holy Week rites. Pius XII's Mediator Dei paragraph 58 confirms: "the Sovereign Pontiff alone enjoys the right to recognise and establish any practice touching the worship of God, to introduce and approve new rites, as also to modify those he judges to require modification". I've said this a few times in this thread but there are numerous reasons why the TLM should be celebrated more widely, Quo Primum being binding on Pius V's successors is not one of them.

[@christineplaton3048]

Total Restoration is absolutely necessary. It's non arguable. Bull Quo Primum.

[@concernedcitizen780]

If forced to go to a Novos Ordo mass one solution might be to place 1 cent in and envelope and a card that says bring back the Traditional Latin Mass and I’ll put in 20$+

[@loist9022]

Good.

[@marriedkiwi]

Are you recommending the final countdown song for the end of the latin mass?

[@valeriabrugger9011]

Taylor, when will you study about the changes in the words of ordinations and and how that affects one’s validity as a priest? I haven’t heard a podcast from you with regards to that, but maybe I’ve just missed it.

[@anthonymckinney9904]

There are way too many protestants here. I wonder how many people know that the Mass is a discipline.

[@marie-bernadettebenedict3007]

I’m legally blind. The closest TLM I can get to is a walk, 2 trains, and a further walk away to get to. I have to leave at 8am to get to Mass at 10:30, and it’s impossible to get to in the winter when it’s too dark in the mornings and the weather makes it difficult to travel with my multiple other disabilities not just sight impairment

[@mariekatherine5238]

Are you in NYC?

[@eddieschwab864]

Uber not a viable option to get there?

[@marie-bernadettebenedict3007]

@@eddieschwab864 yes but it’s £30 per ride to travel that far.

[@marie-bernadettebenedict3007]

@@mariekatherine5238 no. England. Coventry specifically. The closest TLM is Birmingham

[@mariamartin94]

It’s understandable in your case that you can’t attend the TLM. I pray you have a reverent Novus Ordo nearby❤️🙏🏼

[@davidkelly715]

The problem is that PPV cannot bind the popes to come after him. His authority ended the day he died.

[@Millingtorres]

Exactly, well said. Mediator Dei paragraph 58 makes this quite clear. There are good arguments for why the TLM should be available to be celebrated, Quo Primum still being binding is not one of them.

[@josephsmith976]

Is there a way to watch the webcast? I just saw this and I cannot sign up to see the recording as it says it took place already.