Hidden Dimensions: Exploring Hyperspace

Extra dimensions of space-the idea that we are immersed in hyperspace-may be key to explaining the fundamental nature of the universe. Relativity introduced time as the fourth dimension, and Einstein’s subsequent work envisioned more dimensions still--but ultimately hit a dead end. Modern research has advanced the subject in ways he couldn’t have imagined. John Hockenberry joins Brian Greene, Lawrence Krauss, and other leading thinkers on a visual tour through wondrous spatial realms that may lie beyond the ones we experience.
The World Science Festival gathers great minds in science and the arts to produce live and digital content that allows a broad general audience to engage with scientific discoveries. Our mission is to cultivate a general public informed by science, inspired by its wonder, convinced of its value, and prepared to engage with its implications for the future.
Subscribe to our KZbin Channel for all the latest from WSF.
Visit our Website: www.worldsciencefestival.com/
Like us on Facebook: / worldsciencefestival
Follow us on twitter: / worldscifest
Original Program date:June 5, 2010
MODERATOR: John Hockenberry
PARTICIPANTS: Escher String Quartet, Brian Greene, Lawrence Krauss, Linda Dalrymple Henderson, Shamit Kachru
Brian Greene and a moment of physics. 00:00
Einstein and what is gravity. 04:40
Three dimensional space and the warps and curves of gravity. 06:33
What does 3D space look like? 10:55
Escher String Quartet. 16:34
John Hockenberry Introduction. 21:22
Participant Introductions. 24:17
The history of multi-dimensions. 25:43
Who preceded mathematician Kaluza. 31:14
Whats the difference between math and physics 33:21
Graviton's and quantum particles. 40:42
Do experimental physicists except the math as truth? 45:45
Quarks, Leptons and Forces. 53:10
The Calabi-Yau manifold 55:34
Einstein's lunar eclipse experiment. 01:00:00
Describing the fourth dimension 01:05:56
Will there be discoveries outside of just mathematics? 01:07:10
Physics... It is not easy and it takes along time. 01:15:25
Everything we see is just pollution. 01:19:35
The excitement the super string theory. 01:23:22

[@WorldScienceFestival]

Hello, KZbinrs. The World Science Festival is looking for enthusiastic translation ambassadors for its KZbin translation project. To get started, all you need is a Google account. Check out Hidden Dimensions: Exploring Hyperspace to see how the process works: kzbin.info_video?ref=share&v=h9MS9i-CdfY To create your translation, just type along with the video and save when done. Check out the full list of programs that you can contribute to here: kzbin.info_cs_panel?c=UCShHFwKyhcDo3g7hr4f1R8A&tab=2 The World Science Festival strives to cultivate a general public that's informed and awed by science. Thanks to your contributions, we can continue to share the wonder of scientific discoveries with the world.

[@jasonnm83]

World Science Festival m

[@nicknormousreports3378]

World Science Festival how do you in good conscience use except when accept is the proper word?

[@timeisapathwalkingtounderstand]

thank you for the video good job putting it together I'm a late bloomer learning it now that I'm old

[@kjojar3808]

Nicknormous Reports, cymatically speaking, they are homophonic, thus identical. Grammar is a grimoire, so/sew write/right your/yore own spelling. Break/brake the spell and/end change the ritual/writ-you-all of habitual speech that speaks us into servitude. Rune/ruin the chords/cords that bind the strongman...which/witch is you/ewe, and/end cut your/yore sentence/sin-tense from the page that has you bound in the book...of spellings. Are you with me? OR, continue pointing out insignificant details that do naught but flex ye false measure of superior intellect. It does knot proove...save for obedience to a life bound in books and spells and grimoires/grim wars... or function chains if programmed via computer logistics..you know/no, (if:then),(if:then)?. Guess which logos began the dance with machines? λ lamb-da. Lamb, the...That's us. You clearly understood what he meant, so why correct him? Comprehension and communication are the purpose, besides, have some fun with new wyrding and open that mind of yours. Calm Eunich Yay Shuns. In Crip Ted . May King .Wee. Cree Ate Of. Bee.

[@progressivethinker4635]

In india vedas more than trillion dimnsions are not ony discovered but used. Primitive west. shameless people of west copied from india vedas. WE ARE GOING TO SUE THE WEST. Vedic scientists like Razor Skidrow, Logical Hindu, Magical indian put lots of video evidence on youtube. We will form a society and sue the west for copying our ancient hindu scriptures

[@neil6477]

How wonderful to listen to an intellectual debate in which the participants truly discuss such deep ideas. Most media seems to be obsessed with getting people to argue or disagree - what this shows is the true strength of human intellect. It is beautiful to listen to these people - and to learn about such ideas. Incredible!

[@collinstewart9234]

I know! Krauss and Green were at odds and carried on a civil, knowledgeable discussion. It was excellent.

[@fiziksisfun5317]

I only wish I could keep up with it all! Ah well, one day

[@scienceexclamationpoint8429]

Shoshin This is why science is infinitely more important than the useless, cyclic endgame of hand-over-hand politics. Talk about an ideal world where objectivity rules and you find science.

[@badazzmuffin5781]

You suck. Your turn. Kidding. You think antimatter is the fabric that creates the warps and such leading to gravity?

[@daniels1263]

Patrick Simmons well ur probably deluded like everybody else then

[@hassannabil9792]

I have this video several times. I never get tired of watching. Those are great scientists. Thanks for the world science festival for bringing this out.

[@Dr10Jeeps]

Another excellent discussion at the World Science Festival. It's these kinds of talks that make the internet so valuable.

[@chris432t6]

Agree. Thank you.

[@maichelle123]

I agree this is important . This is we’re it goes to show you can’t keep a good man down,ladies especially you stand up take your place as leaders and caretakers of the ones who were every hat imaginable to the greater good of the human race . We ladies have allowed this one way thinking take over our universe we have let the children we raised to single us out and keep us on a plain of one dimension. We ladies have let this happen ,we let them control our countries let them let our children,in the universe go hungry wene we do the cooking we support the everyone but us to grow and learn off our time fram. We have put ourselves in a thinking a stay at home mom(female or male) on the bake burner to put the needs of our family’s before our own . Now we get to go to work and still do the household chores how is that smart ladies . Team is two doing each other jobs and every job. Stop letting these society’s single the thought right into one way one dimensional thinking and forcing that way of thinking on us . They are the ones who make us , limit us and keep us from rising above and being of the universe and limite us to this space and this time. They are the ones who formed the scientist who found water has memory right to his death and stole his aids project and cure for all cancers. Stop limiting the scientist,our people into one dimension thinking.

[@nathaniels8371]

The stupidity makes me leave, but this type of though provoking discussion/lectures keeps me coming back.

[@yishmiraibenisrael8771]

Brian, I love you for seeing that the glass is half full. Please, don't ever change in your optimism because truth will always be verifiable. Peace and infinite blessings, yishmirai.

[@beerye3750]

Thank you! Peace and infinite blessings to you too.

[@yixe2253]

The fact almost all of these videos start with something to do with Einstein shows the impact of one man.

[@einsteindrieu]

Then Einstein is not dead.

[@leone41ll]

@-sYn- and have you ever thought why this might be the case? Maybe because it is one of the most tested theories there is? Maybe because it gets so much right? You can't just discard a theory for "new ones" if the new ones can't predict additional things and explain why the previous appeared so right. Don't let the delusion of "one man's idea" discredit its merit. Perhaps it needs modification but thats for future physicists to find out. But there is without a doubt there is something fundamentally true about the theory with respect to the cosmos

[@3hundredyearsago296]

@@leone41ll only two people that ever lived know the truth of general relativity origins...einstein and maric.although it's believed by many that Mileva had more that just a contributing role. Some like myself would even go as far to say it is her work...common happening of the day where the husband would take full credit of his wife's ideas and work. I detest people of this calibre and you see it happen all the time. people taking credit and basically stealing another person's work is at its best thievery and at its worst character assasination. On top of this general relativity to my understanding breaks down at the quantum level. And his description of spacetime as a flat flexible fabric is appealing to the mind in a 2d realm as this video shows it doesn't really work in a 3 & 4 d universe. Einstein had some great ideas even though most are overrated and alot just simply wrong. Einstein himself knew his ideas should be left to the interpretation of the reader. On closing the great Einstein believed for most of his career in a static universe until proven by Hubble to be expanding. This changed allot of his fundamental ideas even to make it look like he was just riding coat tails...this is all my opinion just as you have yours

[@TheDavidlloydjones]

@NESHMETAL The con man.

[@TheDavidlloydjones]

@NESHMETAL Built nice sparky machines that looked good in the silent movies. Um, anything else?

[@armandofelipegarcia4865]

I love how it takes a medium smart guy to explain to kind of smart people what's very smart people are talking about. Thank you for the science Festival! It's amazing.

[@aliservan7188]

lol, that's my favourite comment of the past 6 months. I'm using that :D

[@drivenhome7840]

Please check your grammar smarter guy.

[@Flamo353]

"medium smart guy" lol

[@AntonioRuiz-zl3de]

Medium smart guy? This guy was a math prodigy child, he graduated from Harvard University and got his doctorate from Oxford University. He is a theoretical particle physicist and one of most complete scientist out there. He's not a medium smart guy, he is actually a genius.

[@skwozies3083]

Genius is not something that can be taught by education. It is a gift of nature that presents its blessings to man. It is precisely that the genius goes beyond his educators and the current knowledge available that we call him a genius. Education can never raise up anything more than those who follow routine. This is great for preserving established knowledge and presenting that to the genius as a tool to work from but it can do nothing more.

[@Astraeus..]

Beethhoven being able to compose that kind of music whilst entirely deaf is like the ultimate artistic flex possible.

[@stephanvanhoek7529]

Actually he never finished his 9th. It was doable at first because he basically had already written it but after that he couldn't be certain of many things

[@Davi-ou7gj]

I like classical songs. They help me to calm down and improve my concentration.

[@craigwall9536]

But he WASN'T _totally_ deaf. That's a myth.

[@chingring4926]

Wish I had the head for the higher sciences like these people, but at least I can watch and listen and still be amazed by them. A great watch.

[@naterlandsw2963]

Take inspiration from where you can get it...but he certainly wasn’t deaf deaf. Nor was his all his work really “flex” worthy.

[@Drone_PilotSG]

Brian green’s expression and hand gesticulations were so convincing that if I didn’t have the volume up, I’d have thought he was describing where and how we could assess the 4th dimension

[@RavengerX1]

Wish I had the head for the higher sciences like these people, but at least I can watch and listen and still be amazed by them. A great watch.

[@ANOLDMASTERJUKZ]

You are living within the dimension of your belief in your limitations, break out and your mind will grow like a flower and open up like a lotus blossom, you will find the hidden dimension of understanding.

[@fiziksisfun5317]

If you want it enough, you can have it- provided you're willing to work for it!

[@amiracleone2803]

The Truth of the Matter Einstein was very good at math. Its a urban legend that Einstein was not good at math.

[@aryanbista747]

@@amiracleone2803 he was pretty good but not as good as physicists were.He had to take help to make an equation for his theory

[@amiracleone2803]

@@aryanbista747 Yes I will concede to your comment, I was just meaning has was not bad he was not the best either.

[@marcremillard4052]

"One person's space is another person's time." I think he was late because someone took his parking spot.

[@PT-ty8kd]

Im fcking dead 😂😂

[@Hugatree1]

Mark Smith the quantum world comes together to conspire against us, just to prove its real and mess with our heads!

[@onesec8005]

!

[@TheAwillz]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂👌✌️

[@TheAwillz]

HP Lovecraft it really does, I find it’s got a brilliant sense of humour

[@devvildogg1775]

I would love to see a discussion about this with these brilliant minds on LSD or mushrooms. I hope that doesn't sound like I am a dopehead or ignorant but I know some will scoff anyways, but a lot of what they are describing that may be one way of understanding these things are ACTUALLY what you SEE/HEAR/EXPERIENCE when you are on those types of substances.

[@twosongs7396]

I so admire Dr. Brian Greene’s humility and so enjoy the layman fashion in which he simplifies and imparts the intricate subjects he addresses and so successfully conveys. He’s my favourite Author. Do look up all of its books, which I highly recommend if you enjoy this lecture; I own and most cherish all of his books. This man is exceptionally brilliant, as is Dr. Michio Kaku, yet another favourite Author of mine.

[@RouteofAges]

Man I love this stuff. I never learned mathematics this high to understand the theories well, but the fabric of the universe with these extra dimensions seems to be like the physical basis of computer programming, the hardware containing the on/off switches, the basis for EVERYTHING we do with computers. Speech recognition, programming robot movement, watching youtube on my monitor, all goes back to the on/off switches, the ones and zeroes. The Almighty gave us the hardware of reality, the building blocks of all of our experience, and with our hands and minds we are able to program it and use it to learn about ourselves, where we are, what we are, and continue to grow. To me, the more we learn about the nature of reality, the more evidence there is of design and purpose. Btw I dont intend to turn this into a religious discussion, just sharing my personal opinion.

[@itsiwhatitsi]

I love how the only real way to understand reality is to lose it, going beyond

[@bertil0424]

Moms spaghetti

[@rickevans3959]

The strings are made of schrodinger's cat gut like those violins strings

[@Watchingthesim]

Schizophrenia & parallel universe/multiverse and the classic, particles in boxes observed & unobserved

[@BilalHussain-yd6ck]

@@bertil0424 lol

[@pixieclub6259]

Unlimited beliefs

[@AgainstOdds]

Great moderator. The host really sets the ceiling for the level of the conversation.

[@lifebalanceportal3389]

When we are looking with the Mind's eye in deep meditation, we are capable of seeing into many dimensions as they are all contained within as well as around us.

[@annaak7849]

Yes and move within them

[@jasonspringer2983]

I see 3 of them before brushing my teeth in the morning. It's all downhill from there

[@lilwater7358]

@@jasonspringer2983 ahaha

[@lilwater7358]

@@annaak7849 The question is what is you?

[@NextWorldVR]

I like Brian Greene A LOT more on stage like this than in a goofy documentary with silliness.

[@arjoon]

The goofiness are for those less inclined to be interested in these sort of topics... but I fully agree.

[@killsobmeanie2300]

+michael jordan Dora! I'm a backpack!

[@jeupater1429]

Totally! I can't stand the auxiliary nonsense, even the whole cubism thing. I could careless about picasso, it's boring and a waste of time. just talk abt the ideas.

[@LexingtonBand]

This is just so good. Thank you for such a wonderful panel and sharing it. I'm so glad I stumbled across this tonight.

[@sarahsmithers4725]

I love the analogy of the dimensions and Beethoven’s Grosse Fuge Op 133! Just close your eyes and move with the music. You can almost feel them spinning around you. A perfect coupling.

[@ErnieLG]

So glad Krauss (only non-string theorist) is here to spice things up.

[@PlebstersPictionary]

I've never been to Hyperspace, but I've heard you can get there with 50mg of N,N-DMT.

[@quantumimpressionismfinear241]

+Kenneth Thulesen Try this Quantum Impressionism An artistic insight into Quantum Reality. FineArtLightWorks.com

[@gerard8791]

I use DXM cough syrup - poor man's dmt. That shit got me out of body, communicating with interdimensional beings (fourth plateau)

[@timw3241]

Yea, I'm kind of curious about that. Many also claim to get there through deep meditation, OBE's. I'm starting to think there is really something to it.

[@timw3241]

David R - Well, certainly not in a physical body. However, I am starting to believe there may be something to the notion of "traveling" to other realms in spirit. It is not clear that you actually "travel" or move in any way whatsoever. It may all be in the mind. But that doesn't necessarily mean it's imagined either. Seems to me there are far to many instances of people doing this that see the same things. Reports of "shadow people" come from almost anyone who's experienced an OBE.

[@timw3241]

I would like to try DMT. My problem is I don't know where to get it, or if I did, verify it is DMT and not some other hallucinogen. However, practitioners of OBE's say it's far better to train yourself to reach these realms without the use of drugs. And of course, if you can accomplish it naturally there's no question.

[@bidibibip]

This is absolutely wonderful. I love how science and art are given such equal weight in understanding our reality. Thank you for bringing us such quality content, I am so very grateful! :)

[@daphne4983]

I absolutely hate those violins

[@belindacarter6872]

I appreciate that these people have made their work intellectually accessible.

[@miscibi]

I just can't be grateful enough for you guys uploading these videos. They are coming with a near perfect timing into my life right now. Thank you for all your efforts.

[@downloadthis4148]

Watch a film called Interstellar if you want to see extra dimensions in action/an amazing film

[@marthagillespie14]

Interstellar, greatest movie ever. Hans Zimmer, greatest movie score ever. Watched and listened a hundred times.

[@zioo3117]

Watching all of these utube presentations of Quantum Mechanics, I seem to recall that one of the reasons that gravity exists and electro-magnetism is motion. But not just any motion, but rotation. It seems that whether the universe is expanding or not, within the various masses, there is rotation. It is notable that rotation in our universe is often counter clockwise, but it can also be clockwise (moons; planets). With some mention of the molten interiors of cores of planets, making these heated entities involved with both electro-magnetism and gravity. Not only does the earth revolve, our entire galaxie revolves, orbits or rotates. In the largest of senses, black holes are orbiting. In addition of the universe expanding and getting further away from one another, relative to at least one other entity, there is orbiting or revolution. So the question is that when one gets down into the various dimensions where "strings" of energy or matter exist and vibrate, what influence occurs within each string of energies/matter exerts a rotational force. So are these "floating" fields of energy or matter, or are they actually rotating in relationship to something? To anything? To one another? Thus is there anything in the smallest forces that tends to also "orbit?" AF

[@zeefar5541]

Wow! I was also thinking same... May be they do

[@MrPaulafish]

I believe gravity comes from stars, the sunlight itself be it related to the photons or electrons or whatever. Our science is fundamentally wrong I believe.

[@peterhumphreys7078]

Rotation is not intrinsically clockwise or counterclockwise, this surely depends on which way up the observer is, compared to what is rotating. For example, we say that the planets move and rotate anti-clockwise (okay, rotation for most of them), yet that's because we assume that the North Pole of the Earth is "up", and take everything from that. If civilisation had first appeared in, say, Patagonia, we would see everything differently...

[@eastafrica1020]

What about the potential energy at any given point in space? That should affect the other dimensions.?

[@siansbooks]

I remembered this quote from Galliani (16th c. I believe or so) that says « when infinite cannot be reached by progression, it is reached in rotation ». ☮️

[@corvoneagle8083]

its 3 in the morning how did I get here....i barely passed general math classes

[@hanaa816]

Lmao i love this comment!

[@rocky7895]

And somehow i learn more here 🤣

[@dinodemeter]

😂😂😂😂

[@lilwater7358]

Probably because of one of this three reasons or a combination of them: Bad Teaching, Lack of Definition for important words, Lack of sleep/nutrition (overall not being ready to study)

[@BillMcSwain]

This IS the reason the internet was made! Beautiful!

[@williamreynolds1522]

It's like Michael Scott and Fox Mulder had a baby and he grew up all smart-like.

[@bernardkiprotich2365]

Brian Greene....always doing an incredible task of breaking down complex material in physics so well that a kid can appreciate this knowledge

[@brianmattsson3263]

he like to gets hes big ego out @Patrick Simmons

[@moesnnargul1717]

@Patrick Simmons this is where you fucked up, shrooms and holy spirit i live my early childhood train as a Vanguard to banish Holy Spirit as far as i know World Spirit Population has gone down to 80% thanks to Vanguard and lord Keneth himself had slew Yahweh in 1986 spirits are now close to myth more than ever

[@chaoticmasterpiece]

Oh my God, how did you attract all these junkies? It's amazing.

[@sidda7085]

@@chaoticmasterpiece that’s what I’m thinking! Haha these people can’t even make sense 🤦🏼‍♀️

[@jordansanders8592]

And he does so with a big ego-centric projection of an "I'm better than you" self-loving voice, always fishing for applause.

[@Mickeycuatropatas]

Krauss rocks! 1:20:16 "30% dark matter & 70% almost dark energy...everything you see is irrelevant". I would love to see this panel after they tried DMT and broke through to hyperspace - that would be a stimulating conversation.

[@mike-0451]

Please. for the love of god. stop acting smart because you take drugs. you are not revolutionary. your premise is wrong to begin with and you've taken it too far. "wait till hey take dmt and break through hyperspace". listen in order to travel to a higher dimension a discreet amount of energy is required, the location must be known. dmt is a drug. the human brain is a human brain not a super advanced technology

[@frodowiz]

sadly reality states dark matter and dark energy have never been proven. Only messed up neural pathways from drug use is a real thing.

[@Mike-rt1vh]

@@mike-0451 your linear way of thinking can get you so far only. It is why there needs to be more than one path of study in the realm of knowledge. Scientists understood it so there is more than one theory being studied

[@nikitasingh6359]

Best conversion to get a sense of how diverse reality is.

[@BlowinFree]

Probably still not diverse enough for the libtards

[@chris432t6]

I really like how Brian communicates and outlines his presentations. The tone, pace and dynamics in his speech convey the science beautifully. Green and Kaku are my favorite modern physicists. Thank you WSF.

[@earllarrabee7026]

I am so glad this video has over a million views. This was very good and well explained. Lawrence Krauss makes me laugh because he is known for challenging everything (often times gets caught up in debates about does God exist or not) But he makes a valid point, we need experimental evidence. String Theory still is exactly that...a theory. In a way String theory is analogous to Plato's allegory of the cave in that the physicists are trying to explain detectable phenomena (Shadows on cave walls) like quarks, gluons, forces etc with a theory that tries to explain what is causing the phenomena. Problem is, string theory may end up working mathematically, but the theory may just be a representation of what actually exists, like the puppets casting the shadows in the allegorical cave, puppets which, are only caricatures of what truly exists outside of the cave. And we still don't know if the math truly implies 12 physical dimensions. The reality is that everything actually exists in the 3rd and 4th dimension (Time and Space). A point, a line, and a plane technically do NOT exist in the real world. If you were to draw , a point, a line, or a surface it is impossible to do without 3 dimensional space. Meaning a drawn line will always have a thickness and a depth, even if the line is only an atom deep and an atom wide, our representation of our invented mathematical models must exist in 3D. What we consider the first and second dimensions are imaginary in a sense, they do not exist in reality. So the mathematics that requires an 11 dimensional universe for string theory to work, could just end up being a hypothetical explanation that doesn't explain reality in its entirety. Perhaps the Unified Theory of everything is much simpler than what the 11th dimensional math suggests. But who knows at this point, I agree with Lawrence Krauss in that we need experimentation. Having to scale down to a factor of 1x10 ^15 power to describe or confirm vibrating strings seems pretty daunting though. Another thing we need to realize is Newton's laws of gravity and motion work perfectly at the human scale, proven time and time again. The math was solid for 100's of years until Einstein came along. His theory of relativity more accurately described the orbit of Mercury and the eclipse experiment proved his theory that the curving of spacetime bends light. It seems likely that newer mathematical models will come out that are even more accurate and precise beyond string theroy mathematics. The search for a unified theory of everything is such a profoundly interesting field of study and discovery. I would love to sit down and converse with some of these physicists, that would be epic. anyway awesome discussion, they all did a really good job of explaining this science so that it can easily be understood.

[@murlidharkhatkale5208]

Visualizing multidimensional systems statically or dynamically may probably would be easier to explain analytically but to conceptualize mentally or hold many dimensionality would 🤔 be beyond ordinary human nature.

[@brickley2000]

How pleasant to find somethng like this on youtube, that gives me a break from the selfie-twerking, and top ten lists, that seem to fill every channel of mindless garbage.

[@DerperDaDerpa]

550+ videos I just subscribed world science festival, ted talks are awesome too.

[@dang2979]

Dave Perkins Where were you guys in high school? I coulda used some friends.

[@eugeneyujin3409]

Exactly.

[@piotrchrusciel2927]

Hey guys, take a look of some of these channels if you enjoyed this lecture : Minutephysics, The Royal Institution, Sixty symbols, Vsauce, Veritasium, CGP Grey, MinuteEarth, and as mentioned already TED. There is really a lot of 'fast-food' around - quick reward memes and pointless time consuming apps. I find uplifting that we're slowly making use of the instant and unbounded information flow.

[@SrFrancia0]

brickley2000 My brain wouldn't say "pleasant"

[@joshshelor2349]

I never would have understood a word in this, if it wasn't for the mini concert segments. thank you so much.................

[@litzybaby9014]

The music blew me away as much as the physics

[@fomalhauteighteen4459]

"A tree is to the universe as a string is to the atom" ~Brian That art was strange-looking although very cool because of the age. Can you imagine string theory being thought of like that one day,yeah that's crazy🤯

[@abhisheknegi7811]

Great step to give knowledge and introduce science to youngsters like me and all I have learned a lot from these

[@TheMsLady4Real]

Nothing like intelligent people! I could listen to them all day, especially my hero Neil!

[@Mick0722MX]

Give me a break. This guy is spouting the same bullshit the rest of the quacks champion. The reality is that space does not curve, and neither does time.

[@odette5031]

@@Mick0722MX how are you certain

[@Mick0722MX]

@@odette5031 There is no such thing as spacetime.

[@spacewarrior1737]

@@Mick0722MX @Mick0722MX There is no spacetime...? but what is there then...? 😂 Space isn't an object like you can outright claim it doesn't exist. You are inside a space and that's why you exist 🙂 Same thing, Time isn't a thing as your statement assums. It is a flow of event, (occurance ) If there is no events, how are you here? How are you typing random things coming in your brain? 😩 Get some help man...

[@Mick0722MX]

@@spacewarrior1737

[@gregbaker6215]

You all are on the right track, somehow I feel it's easier than the complicated processes that take place. Not that I can explain the simplicity either. When I was a teenager, 13, 14, my friends and I had a discussion about the after world. As we worked our way through beliefs, scripture and what not. I had a vision that seemed to come from GOD. And the way I explained it was that out there in the vast universe are different worlds similar to ours or even duplicates to some degree. As we pass on from this realm we are directed to another world or dimension. I'm forgetting something's from back then but thats the bulk of what we discussed. Of course the others had there own opinions and beliefs and I may have swayed a couple of them to mine. That's something I have held on to and reflect on over the years from time to time. Thank you, great video. Can never get enough of that subject. So much to discover and learn but so little time...

[@akatsuki2793]

Plz don’t bring all that god talk here. We are classy ppl of science here.

[@chinookvalley]

Bands of musicians are taken into war to make it more beautiful. These artists took my breath away. Music can open our minds as nothing else humans can compare.

[@sagus_mage]

And also to induce trance-like states in soldiers. War drums. Perhaps the deep felt vibrations of drums have something to do with this.

[@SybotLV5]

want to skip that violin part at 16:34 ? go to 21:10 :P

[@yenjinchoi9328]

Thank

[@melodymontana5370]

Dhukino thanks!...wish I knew that before I heard that mess lol..no disrespect to the strings

[@anthonyjensen8347]

Why would you want to skip Beethoven? What did he ever do to you? :(

[@sotogremble953]

Thanks. At least it wasnt a dance troupe this time. I still dont understand why anyone would presume higher dimensions are visible or within our realm of experience. I assume they aren't and work on how that might make sense, everyone else wants to make them into tiny strings. Maybe there is no difference in the results one gets, but i cant help but think its the Albatross thats dooming this voyage!

[@kenlieck7756]

So we're talking about string *quartet* theory now?

[@LinuxLuddite]

I find Brian Greene can put down any complex theory in layman's terms and that's why I find very captivating. Been following him for a while now

[@Watchingthesim]

So do u have an answer for why e.g an ant under observation has never disappeared into a smaller, higher dimension if it's there & accessable to them?

[@LinuxLuddite]

@@Watchingthesim This is just an illustration with ants so simple folks can understand it. The extra higher dimensions predicted by String theory are much much much... smaller... Probably at Planck's scale .

[@Watchingthesim]

@@LinuxLuddite thx for calling me simple minded, hope that improves yr self worth

[@LinuxLuddite]

@@Watchingthesim girl not everyone is a theoretical physicist in this world and can understand such complex hypotheses. So that's why physicists have to find ways to present it in a way that common folks can understand it. I am not a physicist myself, just a common folk with a deep interest in science. It's not an offensive term. Sorry if you got offended

[@rayc056]

@@LinuxLuddite You made a nice comment and were asked a question. You kindly engaged in the discussion with what turned out to be a terribly ignorant simple minded fool. You then apologized undeservedly to the troll showing kindness yet again. You make the internet a better place.

[@chuckyspearsmusicpage2329]

For some reason.. I'm addicted to these lectures.. I never new Science could be so entertaining🤌🏾👌🏾👍🏾 I didn't even know that I was interested in Science, until witnessing these lectures... keep it going.. Great Job 👍🏾 I love it..

[@jessicaprintke4973]

I appreciate you exist in a higher understanding

[@CarsonsVideos]

This has got to be one of the best videos on KZbin!

[@benalkan8559]

Wow, I've accidently stumbled across this channel and this is amazing. Thank you.

[@user-ck9gs8rf9n]

Excellent content once again.The mention of Scandinavian metal bands had me cheering like a good metal fanboy.

[@UTINNI_36]

What part of the interview is it where they have the discussion about Viking metal?? Big metalhead here - check out Gojira they sing about “echo-friendly” French grove metal band like death, obituary, Pantera, Soulfly and morbid angel all mixed into one..old stuff is waaay Bette imo then new albums..start with demo 1096 staturate , then go to ‘From Mars to Sirius’ they sing about all this wild stuff to haha sickk

[@Sandeeprudram]

Me too. Maiden fan here. \m/

[@lisengel2498]

Wonderfull to listen to these ways of trying to communicate in different ways of the dimensions of reality. I always wondered about experience because when you really open your ways of being aware - it seems to mexthat experience is multidimensional. We can experience any phenomena from unlimited perspectives - ans that is a basic experimental way in working with art --💜

[@davidinmossy]

This video gave me good vibrations ...

[@theway5258]

I will give you more dzzzzz dzzzzzzz dzzzzzzz )))

[@CDeruiter5963]

I thought this was a really interesting discussion. Granted, i'm still a layperson when it comes to String Theory/ Hyperspace/ Quantum Physics, but I did think it was fascinating nonetheless. I found myself agreeing (at least partly) with Lawrence Krauss and Shamit Kachru. I didn't think Krauss needed to be so underhanded about his critique of String Theory, but I do agree that we need to exercise caution in placing too much hope into a theory that has had a great difficulty in being verified experimentally. Although like Shamit said, it could just be a matter of time.

[@leighauza1977]

this was sooo good, thank you 💛

[@b.e.pleasant5098]

I'm glad that KZbin could bring that to me. Since I couldn't be there.

[@tmst2199]

16:30: Greene is a showman par excellence.

[@mysticwine]

Showmen are good at disguising their ignorance with feats of drivel.

[@kirkabrahamson6424]

I feel enlighten by this video😶😯

[@lamarkingram5320]

That was an invigorating fun discussion!

[@lemonpepper4065]

My problem with the "sheet" visualization for gravity has always been that the sheet isn't just under the space time and mass, its above and below and part of it, woven into and through. The gravity of all other objects is, sometimes miniscule, sometimes not, affecting all others. The "sheet" analogy doesn't really hold up if you think outside of "gravity makes things go down".

[@Evan_C.]

I had that same feeling while watching the sheet analogy. Where’s the extra dimensions for the sheet, it’s a 2D representation of a 3D model!

[@iaingraham7586]

@@Evan_C. Would other universes be in other spatial dimensions, or would additional universes exit within our 3D space and time? I'm not well versed in the difference between universes , and spatial dimensions.

[@guntherultraboltnovacrunch5248]

I fell asleep while this was on, and I dreamt that I was on a bus having this conversation with Brian.

[@stamatakisgenebe1517]

Amazing ! Good job sir. A void can not exist but yet again if you zoom in into something , everything is a sphere or presented as one and there is void in between , or rather everything is a vibrating string and there is void in between , Void can not exist but here is void ... really smooth. Atomism at it's best , all hail the great axioms .

[@voilaliov]

Flatland by Edwin A. Abbott is one of my all time favorite books. Really interesting and mind blowing.

[@craigwall9536]

It's not that great. The IDEA is cool, but the execution of the 2D world is really flawed. And guess what? It would be _impossible_ to do it right. So as a vehicle for illustrating the reality of a 2D world, it is RIDDLED with slipshod contradictions.

[@garykuzminski7969]

Thank you. So perfect. Art & Science.

[@lucifermorningstar4595]

reading the comments in this video make me wonder how we have been able to create technology and science. Amazing...

[@user-nf3hh8kn5r]

hahahaha!

[@deviantan021]

Yeah.. we didn't do anything, those guys and their colleagues did.

[@lucifermorningstar4595]

My problem was with all the non sense here in the comment section despite the incredible minds of the people that came out with the string theory.

[@verylwoody]

OK, but your statement explains nothing.

[@andreashoyer4662]

the usage of commas is not essential to scientific endeavor and technological progress

[@gregtuve1109]

On a more serious note, it sounds like there is no hope whatsoever of doing experimental work at the energy levels required to reveal strings, so I make this suggestion instead: Begin by assuming that everything is some sort of fractal that self organized out of Planck sized particles. Such a fractal would have detail that might remain forever invisible due to its smallness, however it would also have emergent properties--large scale structures that the fractal tends to return to at ever growing sizes. Such emergent properties would effectively ECHO the smaller scales we can't see, and might allow confirmation of some theoretical conjectures. Great video. If you watch enough of this stuff, some of it sinks in.

[@adeceptikon]

i have similar ideas about the fractal thing

[@ryangoodwin3799]

I like that theory

[@belgianvanbeethoven]

Classical music and theoretical physics and presented by an incredible group of physicists and it has jokes in it, this must be heaven

[@davidbudo5551]

I couldn't be happier that your Great Fugue was used to represent dimensional space bursting into being. It's four dimensional music.

[@chloeeroberson5332]

Amazing video thank you!☺️👏🏼💫

[@OldBuford]

There some things in this life that I intimately understand...trying to comprehend a plane of existence I can not hope to physically interact with is not one of them. I still enjoy the fun of these theories and can't wait to see what we learn next

[@TheTrillkage]

Visuals help with physics so much

[@joeferrari4117]

Thank you fo a terrific presentation and talk. It was awe inspiring and easy to understand. And the string quartet was beautiful.

[@axlrosegnr]

Just returned from a dmt trip, and saw at least 7 of 'em. ;)

[@pureenergy4578]

7 dimensions? I have read this DMT also resides within us.

[@MKEditsxx]

The most obvious "shadows" we observe in our universe are BLACK HOLES. So my questions is: if my 3 dimensional arm can leave a 2 dimensional shadow in a 2 dimensional plane, does it mean then that black holes are "shadows" of 4 or more dimensional matters (when even time is more than one dimension) in our 3 dimensional space????? The movie "Interstellar" gives us an idea about this but not quite convincing... P.S. this excellent conference really got me not just thinking but also reflecting :)

[@youguy9550]

No clue-but I like this question!

[@Post-Alone]

Good question..

[@keyboardevangelist8956]

Eternal life in heaven is a free gift from God. No human being deserves it due to his/her good works. We have all sinned and fall short in glory of God(eg.Jesus says if any man looks at woman with lust he has committed adulterly with her in his heart..No man is that pure😅). So how did God give us this free gift🤔? He sent his only begotten son to be betrayed,humiliated ,beaten and die as fine/payment for our sins and rose from the dead on the third day. Since he is a just God and has to punish sin. All you have to do is humbly repent of all your sins(read the 10 commandments) honestly turn away from them. Believe in/trust that Jesus did that for you. Confess with your mouth that he is your lord and saviour..You will be saved from hell🔥. The holyspirit(his omnipresent spirit) will in dwell within you and convert your cold heart of stone into that of flesh that can truly love God and be a slave of righteousness and not of sin. This might be the last time you read the true gospel of salvation..look around 🔥🔥 the end is nigh. Please don't reject God's gift. Your soul is on the line.Jesus loves you❤

[@marcelgaddis9319]

time is a black hole

[@UniformedDisorder]

Thats some deep shit dude!

[@colinmurphy4985]

Hard wired to "think" things are beautiful

[@aerialdronevision]

🛑 I love the learning, thank you all involved with making, sharing this film ❤️

[@gibbleway]

Awesone channel, awesome speakers, love this guy.

[@Eric-ue9pm]

The more we learn the more it looks like we are in a program, only here threw an energy that we can't see or tell where these energy's are comming from.

[@elliot1405]

*through

[@konstantinechristo7574]

We ARE The Aether. The more we access it, the more attention we will DEMAND. :)

[@barbaraheiam-bjornsen7466]

We agreed to come into this Universe to help through it's transition. Many have forgotten our role here.

[@TheSoltor]

This is so brilliant:-)))))

[@dmwoodward59]

identifying additional dimensions in theory is done. now it its a matter of learning to interact with these additional dimensions. Consciousness may be one way we already interact with other dimensions. Improving how we lucid dream may also be a way to improve conscious interaction because subconsciously we already interact. makes a good story

[@garyjosephchandler63]

The flatlanders, spoken of, had a river running through their land. They called it River , In their own language of course. The jungle people & the mountain people, also had rivers which they also, in their own language, called the name, River. They had no way of knowing there were other rivers. It is the same way for humans on this planet, in this realm, with something that we call Time. We have no way of knowing there are other rivers of time.

[@rmilesjr9594]

I understand the way we ofc work together cough tango(not the dance)

[@moderatorbonniem6655]

Wow! this was an excellent presentation, so much so, it made it easy to really comprehend to a non scientic minded person as myself.

[@TheSlimbridge]

Is it me or does he really look like "Agent Mullder"

[@Apathy474]

he does.

[@Postghost]

The truth is out there.

[@bradreeves2944]

Darkon Ookami

[@jonesrbd1]

I want to believe.

[@timothyhennig3770]

TheSlimbridge it's you

[@LawrencRJUTube]

A long but excellent presentation. Doctor Green is very elloquent and I enjoyed the humor he brought in to the initial part of the presentation. I think of my self more as an engineer/musician than a scientist. If you look in the dictionary for the word "skeptic" you might find my picture there. All of this information we learn regarding particle physics/string-theory may have practical applications, but the only one I can see is the possibility of lazing the nucleus of a neutron with a fairly low energy "particle/wave" that has a frequency that is the resonant frequency of the neutron that can have it come apart and yeild gamma radiation according to E=MCsquared where its entire mass is converted to energy. Fusion only yields about 2% of a proton's mass and requires humungus temperatures and tricky magnetic bottles. If the neutron has a resonant frequency that we can take advantage of, we can break it apart (like a wine glass is broken by a soprano singing) we wouldn't need high temperatures, instead the problem would be keeping the system cool from the energy created. Socrates might say of me "give that man a penny and throw him out." But Dark energy and "Inflation" I see as "fudge factors" created to save that absurd creature called THE BIG BANG. I am 83 and my prayer is to live long enough to see what the James Webb Telescope reveals. I can see the possibility of it revealing a surprise that will bring down BBT like a house of cards.

[@JamaaLKellbass]

Topics and videos i like. Reasonable people. Really worth my time! Ty

[@danielovercash1093]

I'd love an 8ish hour conversation with about 10-20 participants.

[@Brandon-su4re]

Too think that there’s potentially another me in another world with events playing out practically similar to the one I’m in is literally crazy

[@pureenergy4578]

I have been reading about unlimited universes in many books beginning 40 years ago. These Seth books prove to me that we are images, that nothing is solid or physical, and that whatever we look at we are projecting our own image of what it should look like upon it literally.

[@7deepbreaths.sounds]

Excellent talk and presentation!!

[@PaynePresents]

18:20 I just imagined Mickey Mouse going off with the magic spells

[@edmundkempersdartboard173]

Seeing that sheet music made me feel dumber than the entire opening lecture.

[@flfl186]

@hope dies Which lecture ?

[@Kayla-StellaRose]

When I was a kid I would have the craziest dreams. I would say I feel like I went somewhere else in my sleep. I experienced sleep paralysis when I was a child (haven’t experienced it again as an adult.) when I experienced the sleep paralysis I thought it was because my soul (or astral body) wasn’t quite back in alignment with my physical body just right. Also when I would fall in my sleep (I’m sure everyone experiences that) I thought that was my soul or astral body leaving but because my physical body wasn’t quite asleep it would fall back into the body. I still believe our soul (or astral body) travels through dimensions in our sleep 😴 I believe our imagination is a lot stronger than most people think and we are creative beings.

[@JPAdventures123]

His explanations are the best!

[@destoo0]

I would have liked to see this in 1999, when I was working on particle physics. :D Thanks for sharing.

[@plutoswifelife4074]

I watched this and it taught me ☝️ thing I am dumb af 😩.....It totally opened up my eyes and revived some dead brain cells 😁

[@mbunds]

Original Comment - (Why is time considered to be the fourth dimension? It seems like it should be the first; thinking in terms of conventional theory, even a unidimensional construct can't exist unless it exists within a framework that allows it to exist from moment to moment. Coordinates become meaningless outside of the context of time...) Today, November 5, 2021 Welcome back. This is a (so-far) six-year long conversation that has barely begun, unless one of you has uncovered "the answer" (and no, "42" is PROBABLY not the correct one). The thing is, I have learned a crapload about this topic in the last six years, and accomplished...nothing. Such is research. Just to clarify; I need a place to start a mathematical model for (attempting to) describe or experiment with certain of the more challenging conundrums in physics. This model is, and will be no more and no less "interesting", "useful", or "groundbreaking" than any other, and in fact, will likely result in nonsense like most others (string theory). It is also not meant to "disprove Einstein", or any other established science having solid merit (although I do have some particular issues with special relativity.) So far over the past six years, I have built-up mathematical models that broke immediately due to comments from this very forum, because of, you know, "common sense" which is not one of my strengths. I built 7 that were just crap, two others that had promise, and then turned to crap, and fascinating one that's still waiting to be fleshed out, requiring some supercomputer time before being proven to be crap, and then flushed. Why? Because I AM one of more than a million chimpanzees attempting to randomly generate Shakespeare, so maybe one day I'll get a few characters right. And, I have found that "crowdsourcing" visitors here is saving a lot of otherwise wasted time. So, when building a universe, where does one start? Launching any project has prerequisites; so what are mine? Well, I need a PLACE in which to build it, and I need sufficient TIME to build it. But...will I need to first carve-out time in which to locate a place? It would seem so, placing TIME firmly in the first slot; but then again, TIME only exists when there is a MATERIAL change, which implies that MATTER takes the first slot, but then again, MATTER must exist within sufficiently formatted SPACE, which has to contain the MATTER over a certain duration of TIME, but SPACE outside of the context of TIME and MATTER is meaningless to begin with. It's easy to understand why the singularity got all worked-up and just went "BANG!" - getting the universe started is like working for the government; I would have exploded also...

[@jamegumb7298]

That is simply how Einstein wrote it down. Dimensions equal space, and x, y and z are already taken, so there needs to be yet another, or you cannot equal time to space. If space equals time, time must be a dimension.

[@matjamitja]

Mark Bunds Actually, you should think of "forth" more in the sense that it should be treated on equal footing with the three spatial dimensions. That said, if you say it is the first, second, third, or fourth, does not really matter. This is how time is treated in general relativity.

[@clapton79]

martin bures Fair enough, even Einstein suggested that there is SpaceTime on its own. Dimensions x, y and z are just features that describe SpaceTime but they are not Spacetime itself. So actually space does not make sense without time and vice versa. The project Imagining 10 dimensions is worth a youtube search that gives this another context.

[@SimonShilo]

Mark Bunds kzbin.info/www/bejne/g2rWk5eohbuZhbM

[@Gravitationification]

Dude, you're looking at it the wrong way, there is no order. The only one putting them in order is you. And that last sentence of yours is garbage. You don't need a time dimension to represent some object's position. You only need it if you want to change the position.

[@Hasblock]

I really dislike how eager everyone is to interrupt each other or how rushed they try to explain what they’re saying without being interrupted. But apart from that, an interesting discussion

[@sangeethpm4504]

Thank you for this fascinating experience 💙

[@seanwilkinson3975]

To me, hyperspace is just a button on a video game cabinet that sends your ship to a random point (or causes it to blow up).

[@Chloroxite]

I like to imagine that it is some sort hyper version if our universe, that is, the matter and energy in such a place would be hyperactive. Basically a more chaotic, and interesting version of our universe, with lots of hypermatter.

[@nmarbletoe8210]

Sean Wilkinson hyperspace could actually work like that in real space

[@Mac2point1]

when he said Plato, I thought he said play-dough

[@jerimow8400]

LMAO!!

[@chrisschoenfeld4414]

I watch a ton of these and this one is better than average because it speaks to the pain I always have, which is that sense that we haven’t had a breakthrough since quantum mechanics was proven (in terms of gut) and may not for decades or perhaps ever, and how does that affect enthusiasm for popularizing and studying physics.

[@hiennganguyen6364]

When my electromagnetic field is stable and in sync with my soul mate's electromagnetic field, we feel enjoyment. Magnetic fields give calmness and electric field give excitement. If these electromagnetic fields are in turbulence, we cannot achieve the highest pleasure.

[@Arahansannihilation]

Until fish grow leg and walk on to land it's hard for a turtle to explain the reality exist outside of water.

[@navnnavn6852]

+AlienElysium There are already fish that can walk on land. And there are "flying" fishes. They live on both sides of the water, just as many other animals that can walk from the land into the sea.

[@nizkar]

+Navn Navn You must be fun at parties

[@navnnavn6852]

If you do not belive me, then look at this www.flickr.com/photos/kjfnjy/3598273178

[@nizkar]

Navn Navn Wasn't saying you're wrong, just that you might take analogies a bit too seriously

[@johnmendezdesign]

+nizkar ~ I like to call ourselves 'literalists'. We like factoids. And yes we are fun at parties.

[@islaarundel3741]

We need more Richard Feynmans. We need more brilliant born communicators with a passion for education who realise just how important it is to get out in the world and bridge the gap between the ivory towers of academic scientific research and the bulk of society who are frequently stumbling around in the dark feeding on the small crumbs of meaning we can glean when we don't speak the language of mathematics or theoretical physics. See, in the darkness, people are susceptible to any light offered them - and when it's organised religion that holds the torches in their gathering places on every street corner, promising easy answers and ultimates truths... people grasp at that. What we need are science centres near every church, mosque and synagogue. We need alternative, accessible places for people to come and listen and share and learn and find some damn light and hope in reality and the wonder of science, rather than the tall theological tales of institutions chiefly designed to stifle thought and imagination and keep the masses in check, as well as lining their own purses. You can argue that there's no really effective way to combat the evils of religious fundamentalism, and maybe you're right, but surely the problem begins with apparently inoffensive moderate religion. Once you've sanctified that you've laid the poisoned foundations for all the madness that can follow. Scientists have to take some responsibility in our collective future as a species. It's not enough to be doing wonderful research and formulating brilliant ideas in a comfortable academic atmosphere of mutual admiration - more of them need to be out in the world on the ground getting their hands dirty, making sure that people understand the progress that's being made. If not, maybe one day they'll stumble on that unified theory of everything but realise there's nothing left of humanity to appreciate it.

[@Skaed]

Isla Arundel GREAT COMMENT! ☝🏻

[@patricioansaldi8021]

anything, including science, can be used as a sort of "religion" or ideology to keep our heads down

[@conjeevkumar8961]

Yes - The panel appeared like a Scientific Fox Channel selling String Theory Agenda. A very selective group of scientists feeding each other. I would appreciate they included Sean M Caroll and Leonard Susskind in particular to bring out counter points and thought process to debate on this effort they are pushing to show us the Pink Elephant on extra dimensions.

[@26Toshiro]

Conjeev Kumar I think that we should appreciate that Brian and Lawrence emphasized that what they were discussing as a panel could be “utter nonsense” so I wouldn’t say that this is necessarily like a Fox panel. But I do agree with you in that they could have brought others who would refute their arguments.

[@MadcapActivityDomain]

Naheel Khatri Why should they consider the supernatural? Sheesh. What good does it do to consider that? You can’t test for supernaturalness. So......how exactly do you consider it? Should they just......think about whether magic exists and then arbitrarily decide whether to believe it or not? Is that how you do it, Naheel? I don’t even understand your suggestion in this context. Also, you seem really angry. Hope you do better with that. Maybe you could cast a “Calm” spell on yourself, or drink a homeopathic potion of tranquility, or an exorcism. Take care!

[@ltwig476]

Myself and other artist as well have viewed that science experiments have actually come to a temporary stopping point, mostly caused by their valiant attempt to prove string theory. We see it as not being solved in our life time. So many of us have moved on to working with trying to feel extra dimensions while doing our work. That is the ability to understand our world as we know it is a matrix mostly created by evolution of societies. Therefore, we try to set aside the matrix and work in the possible extra dimensions that likely exist according to science. Some folks have termed it the "awakening." Whatever it may be, a delusional experience or an ability to escape into other dimensions; we find it just as positive experience as science working to discover the unknowns. For it is and always was us artist that can better communicate reality to the general public. Our position is much the same as the scientist, that if we do not somehow get through to society very quickly, life on this planet will become impossible.

[@eatcool2852]

The Muon was discovered last month, and this is what we are talking about in 2015. Theoretical Physics is beautiful