Wudu and Nail Polish (Some Misconceptions)

[@maishamaliha1850]

I personally think doing sala with nailpolish is fine. Because Firstly we must apply nailpolish after wadu. Now our nails are clean and coated with nail polish. Since water can't enter dirt can't enter either. So doing wadu with nail polish should be fine. Wadu is mainly done for spiritual cleanliness and also partly physical cleanliness.

[@chams-eddinecherid5111]

Allah's religion has nothing to do with what you personally think

[@brokenhero6828]

@@chams-eddinecherid5111Allahs religion doesn’t have anything to do with what you think either. Islamic fiqh is based on logical interpretation if there is no evidence from the Quran or Sunnah.

[@brokenhero6828]

You are 100% speaking very logically I believe the same. We can compare this ideology to leather socks and washing over themz

[@chams-eddinecherid5111]

@@brokenhero6828 Whattt hahah...your comment makes no sense. Lame dude trying to be relevant. Whatever you have to say smart boy, my comment still applies. If you want to make stuff halal for people because you think you are a scholar, then good luck with your entry to hell hahaha....niggas think they can interpret things themselves hahaha....how sad this generation has become...followers of the jews and christians

[@sub7se7en]

It's not nails getting dirty that breaks wudu. In your situation if you break wudu you wouldn't be able to do it again because the nails are covered.

[@seffindi]

I absolutely loved your explanation and point of view. Thank you.

[@mariamii7443]

I totally agree with you.

[@cooldoode30]

I totally gree with you sir. Respect

[@yaqub0r296]

Regarding the 2nd opinion, can you point us to evidence in the time of Rasulullah (saw) where someone applied something, anything, to any part of their body, out of preference, not necessity, and it was then considered a part of their limb and able to be made wudu over? Regarding the 3rd opinion, even if nail polish followed the rule of mas'hah, then it must follow all the rules. So a woman would have to completely remove it every 24 hours for wudu and then could re-apply it. But we don't even need to get that far, mas'hah is allowed on particular parts of the body and under certain conditions. The hands are not one of those parts.

[@cooldoode30]

Why don’t you educate yourself more because I don’t think u understood the logic he explained in this video. No offence brother

[@devitharastyaa1804]

you should to know about meaning of wudhu and think the logic he explained.

[@layyyyy3540]

How about fake nails is wudu valid if women wear fake long nails?

[@deerdear9286]

During wadhu the water should touchhhh your cuticles okay?

[@layyyyy3540]

Yes but having fake nails obviously water cannot touch your cuticles because the nail gel covers it.

[@Charcmode]

“Personal opinion” is not a guidance. Qiyaaas? If you want to analogy would mean that the original thing that you are doing the analogy with is valid in the first place Habibi. Otherwise there is no internet analogy with something which is baatil.

[@brokenhero6828]

All Qiyas is personal opinion using logic when there isn’t explicit evidence.

[@shrutijadhav5716]

Aap hindi me bolate ho achha hota mujhe kuch bhi samjhme nahi aya jji, Sir jji

[@mohamedalphajalloh8154]

Wearing nail polish is wrong with wudu same like I can't make wudu with surgical gloves for example

[@MultiKadafi]

Stupid comparison 🤦‍♂️

[@kalimch1061]

Agreed t

[@timekiller8403]

I think he is misguiding us.......

[@socalbarbie1040]

Well then do what you feel is right no need to be suspicious. He’s just trying to offer some perspective

[@xshiromorix]

@@kanizfatima1377 Sister, should you not rather ask yourself if this brother in the video has any proof for what HE is saying? The judgement for wiping on socks has very specific conditions related to it. The hadith from the Prophet (sallallahu ^alayhi was-sallam) that makes it permissible to wipe on socks refers exclusively to foot coverings. If it is not permissible to perform wudu' while wearing gloves (and it isn't), then why would it permissible to perform while wearing nail polish? These two situations are not analogous at all. Secondly, on what basis is this brother saying that nail polish becomes "part of her body" when a woman puts it on? When performing wudu', if there is a barrier which prevents water from reaching the part to be washed, and that barrier CAN be removed (which nail polish can), then it MUST be removed.

[@nijhaspencer9163]

@@xshiromorix but it's permissable to dye your hair. If you can make wudu over that can't you do the same with nails?

[@xshiromorix]

@@nijhaspencer9163 No. It is permissible to colour your nails with a stain such as henna or the like, just as it is permissible to dye your hair, and you can make wudu' over stained nails, but nail polish is not a stain; it's a varnish. The difference is that, unlike a stain which only changes the colour of your nails, the nail polish creates an impermeable barrier between your nails and the water. You can test this yourself by painting nail polish on a piece of paper and then putting water on it. You will see that the water doesn't soak through to the paper underneath. A condition for the validity of wudu' is for water to reach every part that must be washed, and that includes the fingernails. If you were to put on nail polish after having made wudu', you could pray while wearing it, but at such time as you needed to make wudu' again, you would need to remove the nail polish completely, make wudu', and then reapply it. It doesn't really seem worth the effort.

[@nijhaspencer9163]

@@xshiromorix yeah thank you. Yesterday I got my nails done at the salon but I know that I must remove it. I actually got fake nails too. I'll remove it all. I have the things to do so. It cost so much yesterday but making Allah happy is all that matters.