Q&A: Is It Sinful to Not Wear Hijab? | Dr. Shabir Ally

[@Nazreen9997]

I like how he is only speaking about what is being said in the quran without adding in his own opinions, like many other scholars.

[@aiyratabajara6934]

Exactly!!!!

[@zahednow]

Well that is the problem because he has only translated..... not explained the commandment of Allah

[@mr.d6998]

@@zahednow He has clearly explained using the translation, instead of putting words into Allah's mouth aoothobillah, which is what the vast majority of scholars do on this subject. Allah is trying to make it easy for the women at that time, by telling them that all they have to do is use their pre-existing head covering to cover their chest. Allah is not saying you MUST wear the khimar and cover your head,, he is saying to make sure you cover your chest with whatever clothing you have, and because there is nothing wrong with wearing a khimar, and it may even be preferable, Allah is saying that all you have to do is drape it over the front instead of the back. That is not the same as saying that a head covering is mandatory. Those who are saying that are twisting the words of Allah, and could be committing major sin.

[@tauseefahmad2241]

@@mr.d6998 So do you mean it is perfectly alright for woman to go without head or breast covered? I can't understand what logic you used brother or have I misinterpreted you?

[@mr.d6998]

@@tauseefahmad2241 Don't try and deliberately twist what I have said. What I have said is very clear. Learn English or stop acting like Shaytaan.

[@najumaibrahim]

I think the scholar made the point clear...covering ur chest is more important than covering ur hair....we can see the modern 'hijabis' stylishly covering their head but avoiding the chest....same as the pre Islamic woman....let Allah Almighty help us to be righteous and pious....ameen

[@sadiakhann]

I think his main point was that covering your hair is as important as covering your chest. Doing one or the other doesn't do much. It's doing both at the same time that benefits you. Let's use an analogy: Say there's a table that has many boxes and things under and on it. You happen to have guests coming over on short notice and so it would be best to hide it. The person puts over a table cover so that they can hide the stuff. The table cover is only long enough to cover one side of the table not the entire table. Yes, part of the table is covered but there are still a lot of exposed areas. Therefore, the cover isn't of much use.

[@user-ft5jp1ot2h]

@Abeera Khawaja You're using the bible to justify the Qur'an? Seriously?

[@muha6998]

@@sadiakhann great explained, thanks

[@mahmmediaabulhasan9569]

@@user-ft5jp1ot2h I think he didnt ment it that way . scince the bible orignaly had the same messege as the quran but then was currupted thy boath may have some similaryty that ware not changed. so since they boath have this in common i think that helps it to justify that it is mendatory. However I do agree it is a small sin and it is up to the individual to commit or not to commit it. But i do think a women should have the liberty to ware it dont you.

[@minyoongi7005]

I don’t wear hijab or cover my hair, however I do wear loose clothes that don’t reveal my chest, is that okay?

[@rifqiaji5031]

The conclusion is wearing jilbab is recommended for some good reasons but not wearing it doesn't make the woman sinful

[@vazhipokkan1931]

Agree with first half of your statement. Dr. Shabir says that he would hesitate to say that omitting it would make a person sinful. He didn't CATEGORICALLY say that not wearing hijab is not sinful.

[@samiraxh9559]

O Prophet ,tell your wives and your daughters and the woman of believers to bring down over themselves (part) of their outer garments.That is more suitable that they will be known and not be abused.

[@Nazreen9997]

@@samiraxh9559 but woman are being abused for wearing the headscarf, so today it won't make sense then🤔 it's not serving the purpose

[@Nazreen9997]

@@luluah1198 a hijab is not a scarf, a hijab according to the quran doesnt refer to a piece of clothinh

[@zahednow]

That is a very wrong conclusion ALLAH HAS COMMANDED BELIEVING WOMEN TO COVER THEIR AWRAH, SO WHO EVER DOESN'T OBEY ALLAH IS OF COURSE DOING SIN Watch these videos for better understanding kzbin.info/www/bejne/sJTdmIeaerONmZY kzbin.info/www/bejne/ipKXkp6Kd7ukptE

[@marliesbaker7001]

I love how he put that. It doesn't make someone feel awful about not wearing hijab or that their the worst person on earth and Allah hates them. So nice thank you. I myself struggle with waves or wearing and not wearing. It is hard because I can feel the wave of criticisim coming my way.

[@narutokun427]

Sameeee, do you wear it or not?

[@marliesbaker7001]

@@narutokun427 I do wear hijab. Have not gotten a wave of not wearing wanting to wear it yet. It have been a consistent wearing 5 months or so now.

[@user-sn1bt9uk7d]

@@marliesbaker7001 i feel the same way, I didn't wear it at work a few days and coworkers asked about it, some looks and stares but I'm actually the only hijabi on my shift but the other Muslim women never wear it, my mother would probably lose her mind if she saw me outside uncovered lol, I want to do better inshallah

[@cristinewithnoh840]

@@user-sn1bt9uk7d If thats you on your profile pic you are getting shoe on your face

[@ni-kiminaj2503]

@@marliesbaker7001 is it necessary to wear a hijab and I still didn't got it is it a sin or not?

[@valeriedhodson3014]

He is so kind. Because of this and his references to Allah's own words, I feel more likely to be attentive to listening.

[@meriamemagam8232]

At the end, does he say "won't make a person sinful" or "would make a person sinful" ??

[@valeriedhodson3014]

@@meriamemagam8232 I don't know

[@tooemms]

@@meriamemagam8232 "I would hesitate to say that omitting it would make a person sinful"

[@shannonschilling1282]

He went to my University! :)

[@JamesElmquist]

Jesus saves

[@amarachaudhary3321]

"People are not our servants; they are servants of God" Sold!

[@e.k874]

He clearly knows a lot more about religion than anyone commenting down below including me, everyone needs to listen to what hes saying and stop using vile language towards each other

[@Truth_Seeker1]

Its a pretty simple question lol i have read the quran it does not mention it being a sin hes right.

[@1eV]

@@Truth_Seeker1 lol the word khimar literally means something related to the head. Know Arabic first. xD It's mandatory in Islam and that's how the people of that time understood it. You think you understand Quran better than the sahabs?

[@greengalaxy8873]

@@1eV , Sahabas will not be responsible for other people. Every soul is responsible for him or her. Taking the opinion of anyone blindly, be it sahabas or any other people is dangerous and misleading.

[@1eV]

@@greengalaxy8873 exactly. Don't take anyone's opinion blindly. Not even this shykh's. Study what the prophet (pbuh) said about hijab, read what sahabas did with hijab, read what the imams said about hijab and niqab and then follow the right path. In this specific case, the ummah is in ijma that covering the head is fard. Doing otherwise will lead you to destruction.

[@greengalaxy8873]

@@1eV , Where the hell did you get the idea that one has to follow the opinion based on ijma or else one would be sinning? Know that ijma has never been mentioned in the holy Quran and it is just a logical fallacy. Tell you what, please pick up the holy Quran and read verses 13:1, 6:116 and 25:44. Then do a google search of "argumentum ad populum." You need to educate yourself. Neither me nor anyone is following Dr. Shabir Ally blindly. Everyone will be personally responsible for his or her afterlife. Your intervention in other people's salvation is uninvited. Please go and educate yourself before exposing yourself as a fool.

[@food-chief]

The main reason I like to hear from Dr. Shabir Ally because he doesn't give his own opinion but sees the Quran and says what is written in the Quran.

[@mikk3150]

With all due respect to him, he's not an Alim, he is not qualified to give fatwa on issues like this, especially when there is unanimous consensus that wearing headscarf is mandatory.

[@hbsblkk3842]

@@mikk3150 it's not unanimous though.

[@ahmedakhan1]

@@mikk3150 Do you thinks that scholars and alims have the right to make Islam a religion of their own? The Quran is the word of Allah and does not mandate head covering. As Allah warns us, "Rabbis and monks determined what is forbidden and what is not instead of God" (The Quran, 9:31), these scholars are the "rabbis and monks (who) have determined what is forbidden" instead of Allah!

[@mikk3150]

@@ahmedakhan1 The command is clearly in the Quran. It is clearly established in the Sunnah.

[@ahmedakhan1]

@@mikk3150 No there is no command in the Quran for a woman to cover her head! Please do not refer me to 24:31 because all it says is for women to draw the ends of the khimar to cover their bosom. The khimar was a head dress commonly worn by women of that time and place including pagans. Allah is very clear in His commands as the Quran tells us, so if He wanted women to cover their heads He would have said so clearly. As far as the sunnah is concerned there is a hadith attributed to Abu Dawud where the Prophet is said to have indicated what should be covered of a woman. It is a weak hadith, and in any case a hadith cannot be used as the basis for a law. The Quran is a complete Book with regards to what is essential for a Muslim to practice religion, so if anything is not in the Quran then it is not binding! We Muslims must not allow the scholars to make a religion of their own, as the Quran warns us: "Rabbis and monks determined what was lawful and what was not instead of God" (The Quran, 9:31), and "And we have revealed the Book to you which has a clear explanation of everything" (The Quran, 16:89). Finally, "If you obeyed most of those on earth, they would lead you away from the path of Allah. They follow nothing but speculation - they are merely guessing" (The Quran, 6:115)!

[@fahimamoidu5161]

It’s funny that now ppl are covering their head but displaying their chest 😏and they criticize people who dress modestly but don’t cover their heads (SOCIETY).

[@SaoudAqeel]

Why are you seeing the negative side of people? Women can wear modest clothes and also the right way of Hijab.

[@dv.oo7]

Shairana Rubaiyat exactly that is why I don’t wear hijap

[@dv.oo7]

Shairana Rubaiyat because I don’t look good in it and it affects my confidence

[@dv.oo7]

Shairana Rubaiyat thanks for not judging me 💕

[@farhanasyraf2123]

@@dv.oo7 Hijab is an obligatory requirement for every Muslim woman after she’s reached puberty. It is not sunnah to wear it, it’s a mandate from the Quran and specifications regarding its definition and understanding is prescribed for us in the sunnah. No reputable scholar will tell you otherwise.

[@aishatate9037]

Allah knows best! but for me I feel it is my identification my duty and my honor . For when Allah called me to islam it was like my heart aches for the purity and peace that I have found and covering became natural for me. Allah made it easy even in the crazy heat of Florida. I am proud to be a Muslim women and I want to be seen as such. It really is a women’s choice but I see it as a layer of protection and out of obedience to Allah. May we all find our way and find Allahs path for us Ameen . And may we not sit in judgement of others for Allah is the only one that has that right .

[@samiraxh9559]

O Prophet ,tell your wives and your daughters and the woman of believers to bring down over themselves (part) of their outer garments.That is more suitable that they will be known and not be abused.

[@victorrodrigues5448]

allah is the pagan god that the pagan meccans used to paganly worship at the pagan kaaba. Still 'proud to be a muslim'? Hve you kissed - or licked - the pagan black stone already? Women used to rub their vaginas before touching it at Muhammad's times.

[@victorrodrigues5448]

smashallah, 'sister'!!!

[@tauseefahmad2241]

@@victorrodrigues5448 We can't believe you until you show any authentic proof and reference!

[@victorrodrigues5448]

@@tauseefahmad2241, of course you can't believe! Only when you go deep in the study of the quran and the hadiths, besides of History, you realize islam is pure arab paganism.

[@ezgiozer762]

As a non-hijabi, this kind of an answer which is "It is recommended practiced but I'd hesitate omitting it would make a person sinful." makes me get closer to wear a hijab. As Salam aleykum.

[@1eV]

If there's no sin, why would you do it?

[@ezgiozer762]

@@1eV If it is recommended, then I would know that there's good in this deed for me and all women.

[@1eV]

@@ezgiozer762 Dr Shabir added the recommended part from his own opinion. He clearly said that Allah ordered to cover the chest. Allah didn't order explicitly to cover hair. Then where does he get the recommendation part?

[@minifuzz2531]

@@1eV the problem is that you take this individual as an authority in this field when with all due respect he is a "Dr" with a Ph, and none of schooling was the traditional Alim/Islamic Studies. He grew up and studied religion for his major so why in the world he is speaking on Fiqh issues is beyond me. The real scholars have unanimously agreed that Hijab *is* mandatory and not wearing it is a sin in the eyes of Allah swt.

[@1eV]

@@minifuzz2531 I agree. I don't take him as an authority. In fact, I'm not even sure if he can be called a Muslim because he thinks cutting hand for theft isn't applicable now.

[@Joo20231]

As a muslim woman , I dont wear hijab or we must say khimar as hijab has an another meaning in quran , and as he said in the aya what really was the order is to cover the chest with the khimar women were wearing over their heads and bodies at that time so it was a traditional and cultural thing not specific to islam. And of course not wearing it is not a sin , it is not written in any verses . Hamdoulillah and may Allah bless me with more knowledge if it is not the case .

[@nidaaizaz3625]

I agree that wearing revealing clothes is objectionable but what if the whole body is covered and the head is not. I hope that doesn't make one sinful..

[@ameenomar__]

it is part of the attire that Allah commanded to cover your hair. Everything should be covered except for hands and face (with some differences about that).

[@ameenomar__]

Perways Hussein You're right, the mention of hair isn't explicit but if you know the language then you'll know it's implied. Not sure which scholars you've taken this understanding from. All our tradition has ever known is that Allah commanded women to cover everything but hands and face. There are many many proofs for this but to keep it simple just look at how the best of Muslim women understood this verse (the female companions and wives of the Prophet). They certainly didn't show their hair. Allah knows best.

[@mechamartini]

Its not sinful , the garment your describing is modest enough.

[@ameenomar__]

Perways Hussein There are too many assumptions and personal opinions in your response to address each one. I'm afraid hundreds of years of Islamic scholarship+Quran+Sunnah+Actions of the companions prove you wrong. Please bring one scholar of Islam who holds your view.

[@mechamartini]

Seera Masters 100s of years of scholarship and many other sunnahs and tafseer has been questionable to say the least. Their mere judgement that a womens face or hair is their private parts(awrah in arabic) is completely bogus since their judgement was from the verse itself ,Surah 24:31. And there is no mention of either face or hair in that verse. This authority over womens for the sake of Allah is just shameful , Women can choose whatever they need to wear , Quran encourages modesty. And Allahs knows the rest. No man can dictate whats sinful or not , unless its from the Quran.

[@Omar-zo6ux]

No it’s not My family are all very religious people but my sister and my mom don’t wear the hijab. Before the 70’s tons of people were Muslims and didn’t wear hijab. Then some extremists in Saudi Arabia decided that the hijab shouldn’t be a recommended choice but instead mandatory because they needed people to know that people are Muslims from the outside. But truly being a Muslim truly matters on the inside. But it still is mandatory to cover your legs and arms and torso.

[@k-addictt6315]

Yesssss.....i agree with you fully 100%😃😃😃😃🥺🥺🥺

[@potato0269]

hijab is mandatory but not to be forced on anyone.

[@peanutbutter-bananashake.]

You Should be very Careful of Words you Use, Statements Like This Could Automatically Take One Out The Fold Of Al Islam. because The Prothet ( peace be upon him ) Wife's The Mother of the Believer's May Allah be pleased with them, are Mother's Weard a Niqab/burqa etc. It's Also in the Quran and Hadiths, Going Against What Allah as legislative is dangerous. Alllaah is the one Who as made it Mandatory for every Muslimah to wear Niqab (Hijab as prescribed in Islamic teachings) in obedience to Allah and His Messenger, and so as to protect and maintain her honour, good conduct, religious commitment and chastity Hayah ie bashfulness, self-respect, shame, shyness, humility. We Don't Follow Are ForeFathers We Follow The Quran and Sunnah with the understanding of Our Pious Predecessors

[@rogerssteve9302]

@@peanutbutter-bananashake. Looking at a non mahram women is haram but men muslim do it. It is even more OBLIGATORY FOR MUSLIMS MEN to LOWER THEIR GAZE.

[@mitsume_slay]

​@@potato0269 but it only says showing body is harma not hair

[@sibelkavak5587]

I'm 18 and started wearing hijab this ramadan, Alhamdulillah

[@SyedMHashimK]

Mashallah

[@inshasiddiqui7226]

Same here but I have not started...yet but now I am deciding to wear

[@sibelkavak5587]

@@inshasiddiqui7226 if you are still hesitating then start wearing hijab this ramadan, it will be a blessing, prepare yourself to become a better muslim inshaAllah and everything will be alright.

[@inshasiddiqui7226]

@@sibelkavak5587 oh dear thank you...now I am 19 too May allah help us to become a better muslim..☺️ our society needs the girls like you..😊😊

[@AbyssMoonrise]

It sounds to me from the verses Dr. Shabir quoted of the Quran that a woman should cover her chest, not her head. Therefore, the modern hijab seems like it's a relic of traditional dress, not religious, since hijab isn't mentioned in the Quran, and a woman can cover her chest through other means or modest clothing.

[@AbyssMoonrise]

The tradition of head covering isn't the same as the call for women to cover their chest. The practice is mentioned because it was pre-Islamic tradition and carried over into Islamic culture. However, there are many other cultural traditions from the past that have fallen by the wayside. So tradition cannot be equated to religious practice or commands.

[@worldpeace8824]

Quran 24:31 "and to wrap [a portion of] their headcovers over their chests and not expose.." Head cover was normal, already in effect. In addition it says cover the chest. So for a muslim cover your head and chest when going out.

[@devinmacdonald7502]

Abyss Moonrise Hijab is mentioned in Quran. Nouman Khan explains it well here. /watch?v=AALgGKSnU2g

[@just_a_woman-h9s]

Devin #TeamDefinoTwins , you believe in Noman khan's interpretation and I believe in Shabir Ally.

[@just_a_woman-h9s]

+Mohannad Khabradoui, what about other religious laws in Quran which are extremely discriminating towards women? 1: A woman's testimony is considered half 2: A woman gets half a share in inheritance (keep in mind that in current times, due to poverty, women have to take financial burden actually) . 3: An adult woman needs a male guardian all her life (regardless of her age) to take consent from . 4: A man can verbally divorce his wife anytime without giving any reason to anyone, a woman has to go to the court and provide a valid reason for divorce. 5: In case of divorce, child custody of children over 7 is automatically given to father. 6: In case of divorce, all a man has to do is give the woman haq meher money set at the time of marriage and she has to leave the house (regardless if she spent 20 years in the house raising kids) 6: Men can have multiple wives. Dont you think we need ijitahd/reform to make islam compatible with current times? Just like Slavery is allowed in Islam/Quran but banned all over the world, why cant some of the above practices be banned by law?

[@syedsharjeelaskari2161]

It is mandatory for believing women to wear a headscarf but why do the men always forget that Allah commands men to lower their gaze in Surah Nur verse 30 (24:30) (O Prophet), enjoin believing men to cast down their looks 29 and guard their private parts.30 That is purer for them. Surely Allah is well aware of all what they do. Believing men are simply not allowed to gaze at the women, be it believing woman or any other woman. Believing men are ordered to lower their gaze, when they go through the market they need to walk while lowering their so that they don't observe any non-mahram. Believing men are simply not allowed to stare at the girl's face and hair, even if they do look at the face of the woman accidentally, then they should lower their gaze and not look again. and in the same way Women are ordered to lower their gaze so that no fitna occurs

[@troyviper19]

Yeah. No where in that sura or anywhere else in the Quran does it say women must cover their heads with cloth. This is a pre Islamic practice used for utility in a hot desert that carried over. It is the same reason men in the Arabian Peninsula wear thobes. Yet I see no one twisting the Holy Quran to force men to wear thobes and headscarves...

[@youtubeshadowbannedme]

Nope wearing a headscarf isn't mandatory only covering private parts and other areas that can induce sexual arousal

[@samiraxh9559]

O Prophet ,tell your wives and your daughters and the woman of believers to bring down over themselves (part) of their outer garments.That is more suitable that they will be known and not be abused.

[@1eV]

Then watching these "islamic" videos hosted by a woman is also prohibited isn't it? Don't tear apart the Quran and take what you like and leave what you don't like.

[@zahednow]

Brother you are confusing the topic......Hijab for muslim men is lowering gaze, Hijab for muslim women is dressing modestly with cloak over the garments that covers everything expect face & hands

[@iqbalhussain6064]

I totally agree with Dr. SHABIR nothing wrong with exposing hair, however women should and must cover blossoms as this is a Quranic directive. Please note directive means to do something fully, however how to do it is left upon the individual. So you can for instance cover your bossom by scarf, shirt, coat, outer garment, chadar, any clothing as long as it is covered. Wear and be modest, yet can look stunning and fashionable at the same time

[@iqbalhussain6064]

Bossom must not be exposed

[@meriemmaroc319]

Joseph Yusuf i agree

[@tash9523]

I guess? Whatever you wear it should be modest and covering your chest. It’s hard for Muslim girls in the modern western world but I still try to cover up and be modest. I’m not really sure but I mean hair isn’t sexual so yea, revealing it it’s not a big deal right?

[@youtubeshadowbannedme]

I see you're a man of culture referring to breasts in such a civilized way 😏

[@tripleatrilogy]

@@tash9523 Believe it or not Muslim men have a dress code as well.Also Modern Western World or the Modern World prefers anything and everything to be Over sexualized, in most if not all forms of media, especially TV series.Just as there as many women exposing private parts, there are many men exposing their underwear with lowered pants. Both are not allowed for Muslim men and women.

[@ashley_brown6106]

In my country the hijab is not common AT ALL. This leads men to see it as something mysterious and exotic, and even sexy🙄😒😒 I tried wearing the hijab and I attracted 10 times the male attention I usually attract, so it defeated the whole purpose. If I continued wearimg it it would be THE OPPOSITE of being modest!! Being modest is all about your surroundings and your culture. We don't live in a vaccuum!

[@aqlll9911]

That's actually interesting. It is true in current time, males tend to be curious to what's covered.

[@VT_22-z7j]

Don't dare to conclude with your false propaganda. It's irrational behaviour because the hijab is literally meant to serve the purpose. That's the men's problem and your problem is what you end your conclusion with.

[@nightsky5037]

@@VT_22-z7j it's not irrational bcs in the quran the reasoning is literally given... so that you'll be recognized and not molested. it's actually very contextual

[@hediyeheastanbul3446]

How about stop telling women what to wear and start telling men not to molest.

[@Kavyathegreat]

you are perfectly right women should be allowed to wear clothes however they life. women don't need male validation !!

[@CenturionX941]

You're totally right. This is what said in Quran to men, but nobody talks about it

[@willbygosh4887]

May Allah bless those who wear a hijab and for those who don't.It's a personal choice!

[@d.naiken8371]

Dr. Shabir seems very intelligent. I like the way he speaks too.

[@samiraxh9559]

,O Prophet ,tell your wives and your daughters and the woman of believers to bring down over themselves (part) of their outer garments.That is more suitable that they will be known and not be abused.

[@rajafuad6911]

He is one of the best Muslim speaker out of the many I’ve heard

[@seraj240]

He may be smart but what he just said here is not very smart because he is discrediting Allah's commandment.

[@PIWADAPLAYS123]

So omitting the headscarf is not sinful. Leaving your 5 daily prayers is however without exception, sinful. Please zoom out on the bigger picture before focusing on the finer points. Hijab including the head scarf is a beautiful thing. Unfortunately rather than honouring the muslim woman it is being used as a tool by ignorant oppressive male dominated cultures ie. Indian subcontinent as a way to exert their unjust authority over women - keeping them from educating, spiritually developing or contributing to public life. The fact that women are not allowed in mosques to pray -the God given Right of every human being - is proof of that.

[@pierreemerick-aubameyang1096]

I dont know for sure and I agree with you but I believe the women dont pray in the moscs because you need a seperate mosc for man and women

[@thinkingphoenix297]

@@pierreemerick-aubameyang1096 no not really women aren't allowed to pray infront of or beside men. But they can behind them

[@thinkingphoenix297]

@@pierreemerick-aubameyang1096 it's just that alot of moscs separates the men and women so that wome can be more comfortable

[@pierreemerick-aubameyang1096]

@@thinkingphoenix297 are you sure? I will research

[@pierreemerick-aubameyang1096]

@@thinkingphoenix297 okay so bascically there isnt enough space for the women this is why Women dont need to pray in mosc but men do Most moscs are already crowded enough and if women were invited behind than many men who its cumpulsory to pray in masjid would be stopped Whereas for women its not cumpulsory Idk where you live but I have seen in both where I live and in other countries there is barely enough space in the masjid as it is

[@sorabae04]

I would like to explain an issue I have which is about the hijab. I grew up with my mother who is very strict on religion and forced me to wear the hijab, I was a little child back then so I didn’t understand what was happening and I obeyed her rules. Now, at this age I don’t want to wear the hijab because of how it really affects my confidence, and I am really afraid to admit this because I really want to like wearing my hijab and sometimes I do feel honored and proud but it really affects my confidence and I don’t feel that beautiful. My mother doesn’t really treat me fair since I live in a household with 4 brothers and no father and my brothers don’t respect women. They call them cuss words and so much more. I feel much more beautiful wearing modest clothing but without my hijab. I know that it seems I’m trying to disobey Allah (SWT) but I really respect Him and am proud to be a Muslim. I wish I had the opportunity to choose wether I should wear a hijab or not and I wish to not to. I’m in middle school right now and if I had a choice of wearing a hijab I would not until I feel comfortable doing so. I don’t like being forced by my mother and want it to stop. I really respect Allah (SWT) and His wishes but I’m sure that my happiness is sinking because of this. It hurts that I feel this way because I don’t want to be a bad Muslim. Is there any way I can solve this issue with my parents? This issue has been hurting me so much and I really want to fix it.

[@dv.oo7]

that is why I don’t wear hijap i am just not confident with if nor do i look good so what is the point

[@cutievm6500]

@@dv.oo7 are u wearing it for allah or a man? Allah gave us choices in this world but those choices determine on how you use them. For me i am proud to wear a hijab but will never take it as a way to force others. People mix up advice and judging togther. So can I ask u this, who are u pleasing in this world. Are you scared of what u think about others, it dont matter whether you wear hijab or not. Do the choices that you think whats best for you not for others, dont be ashamed for being a Muslim.

[@dv.oo7]

SiaBae I don’t because i am not ready and I don’t feel confident wearing it and I don’t wear it because I don’t wanna not to please any one

[@lizaazman6243]

Just show this youtube vid to your parents. He's a well respected Islamic scholar, why wouldnt your parents listen to him?

[@MUZLIM1234]

Allah will reward your efforts please continue to wear It inshallah you will love it when you’re older and get to buy all sorts of cute things to make an outfit you like.

[@iffipathaan5089]

I really do not understand what Christians do over here. . . If u like Islam then accept if not don't type rubbish comment when you don't know about our Quran. . .

[@alyssasheikh1928]

I’m a Muslim, and I wear the hijab, but I don’t want to wear it anymore. I feel more comfortable without it, so..can I still be a Muslim and not get sins for not wearing it outside? How I dress will be appropriate, I just don’t like wearing the hijab

[@ayeshaqadeer9495]

Yes covering ur head n ur chest is mandatory in islam u have to do it Allah commanded us a in the Quran sura noor and surah azaab..

[@k-addictt6315]

Do as u want🙃as long as u r comfy..cs its ur lyf ur choice..just be modest in clothing i dont think not covering hair will give us sins😐Allah will understand us.. As he knows our heart...He did not force it to us..and yeah try to be good from inner self 😊😊Allah Hafiz

[@ahmedakhan1]

@@ayeshaqadeer9495 No, covering the head is not mandatory! Do not ascribe to Allah what He did not say! That is indeed a sin!

[@kashfiaislam9995]

@@ayeshaqadeer9495 Wearing the hijab is obligatory but it is NOT obligatory for a Muslim woman to cover her stomach and back in front of her male mahrams. 🕌🕋

[@Thirst-4knowledge]

For those people in comment section who constantly disagree with Dr. shabeer, I would assume that they themselves are probably scholars themselves that no one knows about them. If they are scholars/ or so knowledgeable about these issues then why are you wasting your time on watching videos that are supposed make things clear for the common average person?

[@Truth_Seeker1]

@@madmedic7174 Hes a great man have you seen hes videos? TBH i already knew a lot of what he says about Christianity and Islam.

[@nishkm]

@@Truth_Seeker1 Singapore.. An Islamic country is going to kick him out for spreading hatred against people who were living there for centuries.

[@youtubeshadowbannedme]

They're either trolls disguising themselves as fundamentalists or they're a vocal minority that goes against mainstream Islam because they know people take them as a joke in real life

[@zahednow]

He is not the only scholar in this world that all should oblige to him..... moreover there are other scholars who have different opinion on veil for women

[@zahednow]

Watch these videos for better understanding on hijab kzbin.info/www/bejne/sJTdmIeaerONmZY kzbin.info/www/bejne/ipKXkp6Kd7ukptE

[@DictatoRat]

I think wearing a hijab is useful in keeping long hair out of your face when praying traditionally, or keeping you protected from the sun. :)

[@streglof]

I can completely understand the recommendation for women to cover their hair, neck, and bosom from a historical context, in a sense that in those times, it would protect women from being raped or from being molested by sexually frustrated men, since in those days, women had a lot less protection from the law of the land if there even was such a thing and even if they did, it wouldn't protect them in any practical way. In short it just seems to tell women in a practical way to protect themselves, rather than giving a judgment on what parts of their bodies are allowed to be seen by others.

[@dv.oo7]

I knowwwww I honestly don’t wear hijab it just doesn’t fit me I don’t think that it fair for guys to go out wearing nothing but for girls nothing should be showing 😑

[@cutievm6500]

@@dv.oo7 men are also supposed to wear clothes to cover themselves. They wear shirts and tight clothing and ect, yet they go after women who don't wear hijab. I am proud to wear hijab and it was what Allah had said but if I ever sin and someone tries to give me advice I will listen but also give them advice. (I wont ignore there advice but I will also give them advice.

[@peanutbutter-bananashake.]

It's not recommendation, it's a command From Allah. this Speaker is no Scholar. First and foremost You Wear Niqab/Hijab For Allah an act of Worship to him. It's obligatory for every Muslimah to wear Niqab (hijab as prescribed in Islamic teachings) in obedience to Allah and His Messenger, and so as to protect and maintain her honour, good conduct, religious commitment and chastity Haya ie bashfulness, self-respect, shame, shyness, humility.

[@kashfiaislam9995]

@@peanutbutter-bananashake. Wearing the hijab is obligatory but it is NOT obligatory for a Muslim woman to cover her stomach and back in front of her male relatives. 🕌🕋

[@shitomoha9291]

Omg this video changed my perspective

[@greencagar1355]

﴿يَـبَنِى آدَمَ لاَ يَفْتِنَنَّكُمُ الشَّيْطَـنُ كَمَآ أَخْرَجَ أَبَوَيْكُم مِّنَ الْجَنَّةِ يَنزِعُ عَنْهُمَا لِبَاسَهُمَا لِيُرِيَهُمَا سَوْءَتِهِمَآ إِنَّهُ يَرَاكُمْ هُوَ وَقَبِيلُهُ مِنْ حَيْثُ لاَ تَرَوْنَهُمْ إِنَّا جَعَلْنَا الشَّيَـطِينَ أَوْلِيَآءَ لِلَّذِينَ لاَ يُؤْمِنُونَ ﴾ (27. O Children of Adam! Let not Shaytan deceive you, as he got your parents out of Paradise, stripping them of their raiment, to show them their private parts. Verily, he and his tribe see you from where you cannot see them. Verily, We made the Shayatin friends of those who believe not.) Allah warns the Children of Adam against Iblis and his followers, by explaining about his ancient enmity for the father of mankind, Adam peace be upon him. Iblis plotted to have Adam expelled from Paradise, which is the dwelling of comfort, to the dwelling of hardship and fatigue (this life) and caused him to have his private part uncovered, after it had been hidden from him. This, indeed, is indicative of deep hatred (from Shaytan towards Adam and mankind). Allah said in a similar Ayah, ﴿أَفَتَتَّخِذُونَهُ وَذُرِّيَّتَهُ أَوْلِيَآءَ مِن دُونِى وَهُمْ لَكُمْ عَدُوٌّ بِئْسَ لِلظَّـلِمِينَ بَدَلاً﴾ (Will you then take him (Iblis) and his offspring as protectors and helpers rather than Me, while they are enemies to you What an evil is the exchange for the wrongdoers.) ﴿18:50﴾. ﴿وَإِذَا فَعَلُواْ فَـحِشَةً قَالُواْ وَجَدْنَا عَلَيْهَآ ءَابَاءَنَا وَاللَّهُ أَمَرَنَا بِهَا قُلْ إِنَّ اللَّهَ لاَ يَأْمُرُ بِالْفَحْشَآءِ أَتَقُولُونَ عَلَى اللَّهِ مَا لاَ تَعْلَمُونَ - قُلْ أَمَرَ رَبِّي بِالْقِسْطِ وَأَقِيمُواْ وُجُوهَكُمْ عِندَ كُلِّ مَسْجِدٍ وَادْعُوهُ مُخْلِصِينَ لَهُ الدِّينَ كَمَا بَدَأَكُمْ تَعُودُونَ - فَرِيقًا هَدَى وَفَرِيقًا حَقَّ عَلَيْهِمُ الضَّلَـلَةُ إِنَّهُمُ اتَّخَذُوا الشَّيَـطِينَ أَوْلِيَآءَ مِن دُونِ اللَّهِ وَيَحْسَبُونَ أَنَّهُم مُّهْتَدُونَ ﴾ (28. And when they commit a Fahishah, they say: "We found our fathers doing it, and Allah has commanded it for us.'' Say: "Nay, Allah never commands Fahishah. Do you say about Allah what you know not'') (29. Say: "My Lord has commanded justice and that you should face Him only, in every Masjid and invoke Him only, making your religion sincere to Him. As He brought you (into being) in the beginning, so shall you be brought into being again.'') (30. A group He has guided, and a group deserved to be in error; (because) surely, they took the Shayatin as supporters instead of Allah, and think that they are guided.)

[@m4ri4mhus]

Same

[@samiraxh9559]

O Prophet ,tell your wives and your daughters and the woman of believers to bring down over themselves (part) of their outer garments.That is more suitable that they will be known and not be abused.

[@ahmedakhan1]

@@greencagar1355 What's your point? Do you disagree with Dr. Shabbir about the head covering or disagree?

[@MohammedAlSharif2002]

The hijab is obligatory.

[@fromsanfrancisco1]

Dr Shabir ‏ clearly and simply pointed out what is in the Quran and Sunah. You can listen to him more than once, but it’s all we have to go by. Nothing really confusing about what he said.

[@1eV]

Didn't even mention one hadith and your telling me he stated what's the sunnah? Lol. He deliberately avoided the sunnah to prove his point of it being not mandatory.

[@fromsanfrancisco1]

@@1eV God created the Quran and god protects only the Quran.

[@1eV]

@@fromsanfrancisco1 God didn't create the Quran, it it God's word verbatim. And Allah said we will preserve the zikr. Sunnah is included in zikr alongside Quran.

[@1eV]

@@fromsanfrancisco1 but that wasn't the point. Shabir Ally didn't mention the sunnah as you claimed.

[@sam-ie2eq]

Hijab is the traditional dress of the Arabs and even Jew women use to cover their heads, so I think it's more a cultural thing. I think Quran would have ordered the women to cover their hair straight away, but does the word hair used anywhere?

[@sam-ie2eq]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gp2kpJKsic2SaNk

[@samanthaextra6641]

its not only for arabs i am turkish and so many people wores it in my country but i dint wore it even i am muslim.

[@sameera6255]

Like he said in the video women already covered their heads during the time the verse was revealed. Thats why the ruling was to cover the chest. The women already covered their heads. But I have no idea if that is true or not allahu alim

[@time4chai995]

This makes so much sense! What a refreshing perspective.

[@just-some-muslim]

Conclusion : Modesty is the key, Not Hijab, you can be modest without Hijab But, At the end it's your choice.

[@hutaowo750]

So it's your choice if u wanna wear it or not?

[@ahmedakhan1]

@@hutaowo750 Of course, it is always for each muslim to follow faithfully what they believe to be right. On Judgement Day, the excuse that one followed someone else's advice will not suffice. If a person sins through ignorance or incorrect understanding, then surely Allah is most forgiving!

[@zahednow]

Well that's actually a wrong conclusion and yes you have a choice for everything in religion. Whether you follow the commandments or not is your choice but in the judgement day you will be judged as per your choices

[@zahednow]

@وردة سيرا yes

[@1eV]

Yup. It's your choice if you want to sin by not wearing hijab or not.

[@DrZxinab]

Wearing the hijab/khimar is a fard (obligation)and not following obligations is a sin....please don’t mislead the Muslimat..

[@alexojideagu]

There is no verse that says covering the hair is mandatory. It says cover the body.

[@DrZxinab]

@@alexojideagu please refer to (Al-Ahzab 33:59) and (An-Nur 24:31). And this is a hadith: It was narrated from Safiyyah bint Shaybah that ‘Aa’ishah (may Allaah be pleased with her) used to say: When these words were revealed - “and to draw their veils all over Juyoobihinna (i.e. their bodies, faces, necks and bosoms)” - they took their izaars (a kind of garment) and tore them from the edges and covered their faces with them. Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 4481

[@alexojideagu]

@@DrZxinab It doesn't say face or head. That's an interpretation and assumption. It says body.

[@DrZxinab]

@@alexojideagu it is interpreted by scholars who've studied Islam and its history for years. A normal person can't just come and interpret as they please. Plus the hadith is very clear.

[@alexojideagu]

@@DrZxinab Many scholars disagree with that interpretation. For a ruling to be Mandatory it has to be clear. Nowhere in the Quran does it say women must cover their face and head. The Hadith is not clear either. Where is the Arabic for Face and Head?

[@naeeemnaeeem1080]

nice... straight to the point....

[@michaelruggiero148]

Straight to the point if you want to disregard a Fardh requirement to wear hijab and fish for a justification to change the Deen to suit your own personal needs rather than changing yourself to suit the Deen.

[@Asos80]

What is nice about that🤔 his ignorance regard of understanding The subject.

[@samiraxh9559]

O Prophet ,tell your wives and your daughters and the woman of believers to bring down over themselves (part) of their outer garments.That is more suitable that they will be known and not be abused.

[@Nuzzrio]

@@samiraxh9559 so a woman should not wear a hijab in America cus they could be harassed

[@samiraxh9559]

@@michaelruggiero148 👍👍👍

[@MrAfzalaziz]

If you put it in context the 33:59 verse is specifically for that particular time period where they were some men who used to trouble women. Majority of the verses in Quran regarding head cover or hijab is in relation to the specific middle eastern culture during that time where all communities ie Christian/Jewish women also used to cover their hair. There is no unambiguous verse in Quran directing women to cover hair. To infer, it had been an Arabic practice of head cover which is wrongly being accepted as an Islamic practice (as many other Arabic practices) over a period of time which does not have Quranic backing.

[@md.nazrulislam9207]

hey afzal aziz pls tell me how I can contact you I really wana discuss islamic issues with you. u really understand things

[@hbsblkk3842]

I agree. If heads were to be covered it would be clear cut in the Quran, which it is not. There is no sin at all in covering your head but according to the Quran it isn't a sin to not cover your head.

[@peanutbutter-bananashake.]

Sisters please Fear Allah and Don't Speak without Knowledge, because now if a Sister see this and Acts Upon Your Comment and goes out the House With out the Correct Hijab You will gain the Same Sin She Does EveryTime She Walks Out the House. It's dangerous, use forget there Also Hadiths if you like I can give you Proof From Quran and Sunnah insha'Allah.

[@MrAfzalaziz]

@@peanutbutter-bananashake. What I said is fact. Do not try to stop spreading facts which would be the gravest sin for you as well. Do not speak without knowledge.

[@zainabakhtar3329]

Yesss I do agree with u. The "majority" of people says it's mandatory and its sinful to not do that. And they gave their own 20-30 mins of explanations like how a man sees u with lust from the shape of your body to the beauty of your face...like it's so disgusting to listen sometimes. Surah ahzab verse 59 seems very clear as in the same Allah says "better for them so that they can be recognised and not be harrased" As per my understanding I see this as a solution for a particular situation. And in the verse it is mentioned "better" not "obligation" or mandatory". Like the surah noor starts stating that the verse are commandment and they're clear so we don't have any problem. (May Allah forgive if I make any mistake writing this) And in 31 I guess, Points are:- 1) lower our gaze Just like Allah mentioned to lower voices while taking to Prophet. This doesn't means to not talk to Prophet at all? No,right? And I want someone to explain the next verse coz I'm very confused about them especially about the term adornment.

[@asmookypooky]

so, accepting that the head covering was worn by arabian women during that time and that the quran in surah an nisa was telling women to extend that headcovering to their chest, why then is it not considered a sin not to do so ?? it is a clear commandment.

[@sajidhasan1745]

What he has said is the truth indeed! May Allah bless Dr Shabbir Ally

[@mohamedalfarra7455]

Salam wa alaikom. May Allah Subhana wa Ta'ala guide us all In Surat Al-Ahzab (33:59) Allah Subhana w Ta'Ala says "O Prophet! Ask your wives, daughters, and believing women to draw their cloaks over their bodies. In this way it is more likely that they will be recognized ˹as virtuous˺ and not be harassed. And Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful." The word, jilbab in this quran verse context should not be interpreted by the modern usage of the word. According to the Lisan al Arab (quintessential Arabic dictionary) jilbab in this context refers to the khimar or headscarf. This verse specifically states that muslim women wear the headscarf in order to be known and recognized as believing women and to be protected. Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 4481. The following version was narrated by Abu Dawood (4102): May Allaah have mercy on the Muhaajir women. When Allaah revealed the words “and to draw their veils all over Juyoobihinna (i.e. their bodies, faces, necks and bosoms)”, they tore the thickest of their aprons (a kind of garment) and covered their faces with them. Shaykh Muhammad al-Ameen al-Shanqeeti (may Allaah have mercy on him) said: This hadeeth clearly states that what the Sahaabi women mentioned here understood from this verse - “and to draw their veils all over Juyoobihinna (i.e. their bodies, faces, necks and bosoms)” - was that they were to cover their faces, and that they tore their garments and covered their faces with them, in obedience to the command of Allaah in the verse where He said “and to draw their veils all over Juyoobihinna (i.e. their bodies, faces, necks and bosoms)” which meant covering their faces. Thus the fair-minded person will understand that woman’s observing hijab and covering her face in front of men is established in the saheeh Sunnah that explains the Book of Allaah. ‘Aa’ishah (may Allaah be pleased with her) praised those women for hastening to follow the command of Allaah given in His Book. It is known that their understanding of the words “and to draw their veils all over Juyoobihinna (i.e. their bodies, faces, necks and bosoms)” as meaning covering the face came from the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him), because he was there and they asked him about everything that they did not understand about their religion.

[@enstinphilip3102]

Why don't people recognise these laws were made in the old days in religious books and during that time hijab is understandable but now the point of wearing hijab is not their since women have more rights than men now

[@abdirahmanabdikani9876]

From koranic point of view not wearing a hijab is sinful since it goes against the command of Allah period.....

[@SamSam-df9hy]

False where in the Quran does it even mention to cover the hair?? It legitimately only says to cover private parts

[@seraj240]

“It is not for a believer, man or woman, when Allah and His Messenger have decreed a matter that they should have any option in their decision.” [al-Ahzab 33:36] Allah SWT has commanded women to cover themselves and you are saying it is not a sin to not follow Allah's commandment. May Allah guide you and us. Aameen.

[@gozdea5548]

You still don't get what he is saying... the verse itself is vague. There is no definite argument about it. Since Arabian people were already covering their head (in which I have objection), he is saying additional order came to the chest area with the garment that they are already using (in which I have objection too). So yes, you can get the meaning of I should wear a headscarf in order to fulfill the order to cover chest according to Quranic way, but also this is also not necessary as well according to way it is mentioned. Because; there is no direct order to head to be covered and also head is part of islamic wudu parts (so it has the same status of hands, feet, face, arms ( till elbows)) For example; we know pork is haram and there are also delibarte sins in dringking, stones, arrows...etc. But dresscodes are not mentioned under these context.

[@gozdea5548]

@@انا_جامي_والجربوع_مرجئ show me the word "extend" in the verse🤣 Let me tell you, there is no such word meaning "extend", that is the interpretation/opinion of the translator. The verse is like this: vel yadribne bi humurihinne ala cuyubihinne "Yadribina" does not mean extend. It came from the root word d-r-b, which is also the same root word for hit, touching two things together, closely. bi: with Humurihinne: plural of khimar ala : over/on cuyubihinne: bossomes So correct translation "cover your bosoms with your khimars " When you same something is dumb, does not make the statement dumb. If you have counter statements, I am willing to listen. If you are calling something dumb without any reason, that makes you ignorant.

[@gozdea5548]

@@انا_جامي_والجربوع_مرجئ niqab never mentioned in Quran🤣🤣 Which surah which verse??? Did you mean Jilbab???

[@gozdea5548]

@@انا_جامي_والجربوع_مرجئ and you are telling me ignorant🤣🤣 Yes it is not about the verse, it is the "meaning", it does neither say nor mean anything about covering your hair or head to toe!!! The Quran talks about an outer garment (jilbab) and it did not gave any definition of the garment. Since there are no pictures of 7th-century jilbāb, nor any surviving garments, it is not at all clear if the modern jilbāb is the same garment as that referred to in the Qur'an...so my ignorant friend, read more!

[@gozdea5548]

Moreover, you also said "it not about the word dumbboy" 🤣🤣🤣 Exactly!!! But isn't the whole mandatory hijab advocates said because of the word khimar and jilbab we have to cover our head🤣🤣🤣 On contrary to you, they always say it is about the word!!! But yes, it is not about the word, it is the order. For instance: "O Prophet! Tell your wives, and your daughters, and the women of the believers, to bring down their outer garments. That is more proper, so they will be recognized and not harassed. God is Forgiving and Merciful." So the God orders women to be recognized and not harassed. Bringing down the outer garment is a methodology for women to be recognized and not harassed. And tools can change depending on the time, society, climate...etc Women wear garments appropriate for the society they are living in that will keep them modest and also recognized. Same goes the other one, cover your bosoms with your khimar. Khimar is the tool, order is covering the cuyub area, because they are not part of the description of "except what is apparent (illa ma zahera)" What could be apparent then? 5:6 explains that, the wudu organs: hands, feet, face, elbow , and HEAD! You may say, "if the God told us to wear khimar, we have to wear khimar (so the word matters now right🤣)" That's a fair remark. At 8:60 the God orders us to terrify the enemy with war horses (ve min rıbatil hayli). Try to terrify your enemies with war horses today smart(!)boy🤣🤣🤣

[@denaabuothman8842]

There is no obvious verse in the quran which talks about hijab

[@esraxtotorials3326]

Are you serious ? Read Surah Noor and Surah Ahzaab

[@nayara414]

Bismillah. For more on the Hijab issue, I came upon a 4 Part lecture on it delivered by Professor Khaled Abou El Fadl. I feel it would be beneficial for anyone who wishes to apply their intellect on the matter before drawing conclusions. I'd like us all to focus on more important issues of ethics and justice, and equality, and freedom that our deen promotes and is based on. What I see around us as a collective Ummah is far removed from these principles, because we no longer use our reason. May Allah guide us all to goodness and make us the best window to His way

[@haylobos8261]

You can't cover you chest with the headscarf. Headscarf is not a shirt. He is talking nonsense. There is no magical veils. Veils can't take you the paradise. That is idolatry.

[@JoaquimGonsalves]

Beautifully expressed. And to others, who wish to comment here without so much as simple logic, you're welcome to, but just take a second to see how unintelligent your words can sound. It doesn't cost you your life to forego your prejudice. It only costs us our ego. If you have nothing constructive to say, say nothing versus wildly jumping to conclusions.

[@haylobos8261]

@@JoaquimGonsalves They have been corrupted by the West. Headscarf, revert(born again), and don't judge, that is from Xtians. Convert or kill too.

[@gilangzaidan8454]

can you link the video of the lecture?

[@autumnleaf7953]

@@gilangzaidan8454 just search for "Khaled Abou El Fadl hijab" on youtube. It's a 4 part lecture

[@Foxie635]

It’s sinful to not teach your boys to not attack girls. Done

[@bismarehan3969]

I'm in university first year right now. I'm struggling with wearing hijab. I haven't worn like proper hijab since I was a kid..sometimes I do wear a hijab to university and sometimes I dont. When I do I feel like I'm not being myself and lack confidence. My friends judge me for not being a good muslim cuz I sometimes wear it and sometimes I don't. Somedays I feel like wearing it and other days I don't. I don't know what to do. I feel like I'm not ready for a full commitment to hijab yet. And certainly don't wanna do hijab for people who judge me.

[@-AszadHossainAkib]

Someday he will say no need to pray five times, because its not mention in the Quran

[@1eV]

True 😂

[@anjumshanaz2174]

Pls dont put words and accuse of someone who hasnt said what you claim. Its wrong to assume without proof

[@worldpeace8824]

Is it a coincidence that many religious people before Islam covered their head as well? Covering the head is a sign of modesty, not revealing her beauty to the public. It is not forbidden to not to cover her hair, but those who do are considered as the highest form of modesty. I see only non Muslims and 'women who like attention of boys' saying its degrading. I'm from a Muslim country, the Hijab is not a law but everyone wears it. If you do not like it, don't wear it, just don't go saying people who wear it, to not wear it.

[@reigasuoh]

+eshal idk ya damn straight

[@Pnsbcor]

It was a sign of class not modesty e.g there is a hadith when umar did not allow his slaves to wear hijab because they were not free

[@mertmitm]

Subhan-Allah, thank you Allah (s.w.t.) for such a wise and beautiful scholar. Dr. Shabir Ally is a very wise man, Subhan-Allah, but still extremely grounded and humble. Many famous scholars start losing theirselves in their popularity and strictly condemn, prohibit, allow certain things according to their opinion, which they sometimes justify with an over reliance on debated or even unauthentic Ahadith. They do it in a very patronizing manner as well. I think what Dr. Shabir Ally has said here fits very good: "People are not our servants, they're God's servants.". He has a lot of knowledge, but is still very careful with his sources outside of the Qur'an and has that intuition Allah (s.w.t.) talks about in the Qur'an. He is a true blessing from Allah (s.w.t.) and has helped me a lot, probably more than any other scholar. May Allah (s.w.t.) bless him and his loved ones richly in this life and in the hereafter and guide us to the right path.

[@peanutbutter-bananashake.]

Are You A Revert ?

[@elvisabazi2044]

Our prophet Muhammad a.s spoke about those woman who are uncovered and they take pride while going out in this manner, that they will not smell the fragrance of paradise and that they are the worst of women. Do we need to discuss this topic again ????

[@dekacchann]

Is that Hadith not talking about bodies? Women who are dressed and yet appear naked? It has nothing to do with hair covering from my understanding. It’s probably about wearing tight or see through or short clothing like western women do nowadays. A lot of Muslim women wear long loose clothing, are modest and don’t adorn themselves but don’t wear head scarf. I’m not saying head scarf isn’t mandatory but I don’t think we can put a woman who fully and properly covers the rest of her body and is modest but only shows her head with a half naked woman who fully exposes the shape of her body or even her whole body with see through clothes like todays celebrities do, in the same basket. Allah knows best tho.

[@SomeofThisSomeofThat]

Pre-Islamic Arabia women were already wearing hijab. BUT they showed much cleavage. All Allah commanded in the Quran was to use the hijab to also cover the chest. That is not the same as a command to wear hijab. To interpret that as a command to wear hijab means that any woman who wears hijab but doesn’t use it to cover her chest is sinful.

[@dekacchann]

This is what I also wonder. Women AND MEN wore khimars. Muslims and disbelievers. It was a cultural thing and also protected the hair from the sun and the sand. Quran was revealed to the whole world and not just Arabs. So I feel like if we had to cover our hair, Allah would tell us to WEAR the khimars in front of non mahrems and not display our hair and use it to cover the chest area too. Because even if women wore khimars, they didn’t always wear them. Now we have other means to cover our cleavage without covering the head.

[@bluecat7684]

@@dekacchannPlease don’t talk without knowledge, in the Hadith it clearly says the head must be covered.

[@mikayoshizaki]

The only scholar I know who says that the women back then were already used to wearing khimar back then and to dress modestly by bringing the trail of cloth behind to the front. Well said.

[@ABDULRAZAK-yd3ub]

I love Dr shabir ally the way he speaks with truth and stability even other people don't have this blessing I think!

[@rogiro6270]

Same

[@purrfection7777]

I've seen many sisters who wear hijabs and don't cover chest with it but instead they wear lose clothes which do not give any shape to chest area. Isn't that ok?

[@841-zainabshanafarook7]

yeah that's fine

[@peanutbutter-bananashake.]

ther a pl ay ll st "M u s l i m Women are the F u t u r e" Vlsi t My Chan nel then this person cha nnel called Sunnah

[@jax9574]

He has a very different view! But nice to hear his viewpoint anyway.

[@RobenArjen]

Headcovering is not imposed in Quran so it’s not grave sin if u don’t cover your hair but it’s a pious act to go extra mile to wear one, but our salafi brothers impose it when it’s not illegal

[@dandelion6617]

I'm muslim and want to take off the hijab because the quran never said to cover my hair. And I don't understand why men think hair is a women's beauty. Do most guys have hair fetishes? lol Edit: I will not be answering anymore replies because it has been literally 6 months and I am tired of it. And also wow 45 people agree? Nice.

[@yasminy.7243]

Zu Sh You know that the hair can change a womans face a lot more? and that it is much more attractive than a hijab

[@ullascheik5649]

кhαмliη εїз but the same can be true if guys wore hijab too

[@yasminy.7243]

Not Available Men have it harder than women to lower their gaze and women have more sexual attractions... The hijab is there to protect women and to let other people know that she is a muslim and not available for certain things. Men also have to cover themselves by wearing bright, long clothes. It is an order from Allah

[@dandelion6617]

I get your points to be modest and all but that should apply equally to men and women. Obviously a women should should cover her chest but so should a man because that part is attractive to most women. I always here that men should cover form there bellybutton to their knees or lower legs maybe. I was taught this at least. It isn't hard for a man to lower his gaze as it is for a woman to lower her gaze. Men and women both know what we find attractive we shouldn't make excuses for men to stare at a woman's behind during prayer. It is one of the disgusting points too make for a women not to be at the front with men. Why do so many people give men an excuse for being perverted. Maybe it is true but if so they need to confront it and do something about themselves and not confront it and live with it. Also much more men are having a fetish for women in hijab it is really disgusting. Me and both my sisters experienced it from believers and non believers. So I don't think hair is a sexual thing unless it is a strange preference.

[@yasminy.7243]

Yeah women are a hard test for men, but that doesn't mean that this is ok for them to stare.. It is still haram. But still Allah ordered us to cover ourselves.. As I know men are not allowed to wear tight and short clothes. I think you read about this topic and that you already know a lot about the reasons and hadiths, so I think that I can't change your opinion. If you don't want to wear it anymore, then don't wear it, it is everybodys own choice.. I'm not judging you

[@lwjo93]

Islam is a beautiful religion. It is unfortunate that Hijab nazis are pushing people away from Islam. References to ancient Arabic tradition are not meant to be interpreted literally (eg. slavery). You can dress modestly without a headscarf. Ironically you are attracting extra attention to yourself. These radical views will lead to fewer marriages of young Muslim women and a decline in people of faith. To wear it as a symbol of your identity or for political reasons is a different story.

[@virtualinsanity4446]

These scholars make it everything so complicated so people would ponder over them with ques and they make bucks out of people's stupidity. It's as simple as this, are men obliged to keep beards? NO, so are women obliged to cover their head? NO!

[@selyavi5779]

What about the second part of the verse of Noor, verse 60 where Allah says elderly women are not sinful if they take out their outer garments wothout making a display of their adornements. No one talks about surah an Noor verse 60. When you read it you realize that it is a sin for young women to go outside without their jilbaabs.

[@bluecat7684]

Literally he has no clue what he’s on about, the Hadith of asma bint abi bakr literally says only hands and face can be uncovered

[@oioloxo7282]

I think it’s clear that he said .. it’s important to cover our bosoms and with that being said not being a hijabi doesn’t make you any less of a Muslim. Not wearing a hijab can lead you to commit sins.

[@youssefamr8073]

No hijab is to cover all your body. And you’re less of a muslim if you commit a sin directly. Watch the video please again. It clearly got over your head. Stop adding your own wrong interpretations

[@TheQuran-TheSunnah]

Hadith حَدَّثَنَا يَعْقُوبُ بْنُ كَعْبٍ الأَنْطَاكِيُّ، وَمُؤَمَّلُ بْنُ الْفَضْلِ الْحَرَّانِيُّ، قَالاَ حَدَّثَنَا الْوَلِيدُ، عَنْ سَعِيدِ بْنِ بَشِيرٍ، عَنْ قَتَادَةَ، عَنْ خَالِدٍ، - قَالَ يَعْقُوبُ ابْنُ دُرَيْكٍ - عَنْ عَائِشَةَ، رضى الله عنها أَنَّ أَسْمَاءَ بِنْتَ أَبِي بَكْرٍ، دَخَلَتْ عَلَى رَسُولِ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم وَعَلَيْهَا ثِيَابٌ رِقَاقٌ فَأَعْرَضَ عَنْهَا رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم وَقَالَ ‏ ‏ يَا أَسْمَاءُ إِنَّ الْمَرْأَةَ إِذَا بَلَغَتِ الْمَحِيضَ لَمْ تَصْلُحْ أَنْ يُرَى مِنْهَا إِلاَّ هَذَا وَهَذَا ‏" ‏ ‏‏ وَأَشَارَ إِلَى وَجْهِهِ وَكَفَّيْهِ ‏‏ قَالَ أَبُو دَاوُدَ هَذَا مُرْسَلٌ خَالِدُ بْنُ دُرَيْكٍ لَمْ يُدْرِكْ عَائِشَةَ رضى الله عنها ‏‏ Narrated Aisha, Ummul Mu'minin: Asma, daughter of Abu Bakr, entered upon the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) wearing thin clothes. The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) turned his attention from her. He said: O Asma', when a woman reaches the age of menstruation, it does not suit her that she displays her parts of body except this and this, and he pointed to his face and hands. Sahih (Al-Albani) Sunan Abi Dawud 4104 Now decide yourself. Who to follow. Prophet peace be upon him or someone else.

[@nourmal1950]

I've heard a number of scholars discuss that the hadith you just used and how considering the number of people in the chain of transmission, it has a weak isnad.

[@TheQuran-TheSunnah]

@@nourmal1950 Shaykh Albani and others have proved it authentic

[@ddodipura]

That one is a mursal hadith

[@potato0269]

@@TheQuran-TheSunnah thats not even saheeh

[@TheQuran-TheSunnah]

@@potato0269 The Hadith is Sahih according to Shaykh Albani

[@seconic1639]

Thanks Dr. Ally for you comments, also thanks for the host.

[@milkycloud.]

I know so many people who wear the headscarf but then wear a really tight t-shirt with short sleeves like that makes absolute no sense but only Allah is to judge but then it pisses me off because they criticise me for wearing no headscarf even though the rest of my attire is loose and covered. I am inshallah going to wear the headscarf soon because I want to be recognised as a symbol of Islam.

[@sabanyboy9098]

thanks Dr Shabir, for giving us the ruling according to the word of Allah, and not the words of a million priests that all serve their sects and their paymasters.

[@nouheilab55]

I have a muslim friend who lives in France and you cant work with a hijab or go to school with it so she isnt a hijabi because she might not have a job or anything and just stay at home if she wears one she wants To wear it when she'll be Her own boss at work so she waits but she is sure that she ll wear it when she turns old so is it a sin or not ?She does anything she can she doesn't dress in a bad way she is trying to have a good personnality she fasts ... She is really scared to be punished or that it might be bad what she is doing right now so I am asking. Doing bad things to her one and only god is the last thing she wants to do .

[@IcecreamLeGenD]

The word hijab is not mentioned in the Quran, so basically it's just human interpretation. Women should dress moderate and in a respectful Way. You are free to wear it, but if you don't do it it's not a sinn since hijab is not an obligation. And after all every woman can wear what she wants :)

[@alexmikaelcowan]

IcecreamLeGenD no one of you people have provided evidence from the Qur'an and sunnah that it's not obligatory. Let me give you an insight on how modest Aisha Ra the wife and the prophet was. When Abu bakr and Muhammads were buried, she dressed normally In the house as they are both her mahram. But when Umar Ibn Al khatab was buried next to Muhammad, guess what. Aisha Ra wore the NIQAB in her own house! Not even the jilbab. The NIQAB. No saying NIQAB is obligatory but I mean look at the modesty of her. Umar is a dead man wallahi and she wore the NIQAB in her own house because a dead non mahram man was in the house. Don't go saying that hijab isn't permissable. Why do you think Allah says in the Qur'an, that when you ask a woman a question, ask behind a barrier. Don't even try to counter argument this at it is a clear deficiency in your Eman or a lack of knowledge. May Allah forgive us

[@missnobody6051]

alex cowan You haven't shown evidence either.

[@AbdulRasheed-gc5km]

alex cowan

[@peanutbutter-bananashake.]

The conditions of hijaab: Firstly: (It should cover all the body apart from whatever has been exempted). Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning): O Prophet! Tell your wi ves and your daugh ters and the wom en of the believers to draw their cloaks (veils) all over their bodies (i.e. screen themselves completely except the eyes or one eye to see the way). That will be better, that they should be known (as free respectable women) so as not to be annoyed. And Allaah is Ever Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful. This aayah clearly states that it is obligatory to cover all of a womans beauty and adorn ments and not to display any part of that before non-mahram men (strangers) except for whatever appears unintentionally, in which case there will be no sin on them if they hasten to cover it up. Secondly (it should not be an adornment in and of itself). Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning): and not to show off their adornment [al-Noor 24-31]. The general meaning of this phrase includes the outer garment, because if it is decorated it will attract mens attention to her. This is supported by the aayah in Soorat al-Ahzaab (interpretation of the meaning): And stay in your houses, and do not display yourselves like that of the times of ignorance [al-Ahzaab 33-33]. It is also supported by the hadeeth in which the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: There are three, do not ask me about them: a man who leaves the jamaaah, disobeys his leader and dies disobedient; a female or male Servant who runs away then dies; and a woman whose husband is absent and left her with everything she needs, and after he left she made a wanton display of herself. Do not ask about them. (Narrated by al-Haakim, 1/119; Ahmad, 6/19; from the hadeeth of Faddaalah bint Ubayd. Its isnaad is saheeh and it is in al-Adab al-Mufrad). Thirdly: (It should be thick and not transparent or see-thru) - because it cannot cover properly otherwise. Transparent or see-thru clothing makes a wo man more tempting and beautiful. Concerning this the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: During the last days of my ummah there will be women who are clothed but naked, with something on their heads like the humps of camels. Curse them, for they are cur sed. Another hadeeth adds: They will not enter Paradise or even smell its fragrance, although its fragrance can be detected from such and such a distance. (Narrated by Muslim from the report of Abu Hurayrah). Ibn Abd al-Barr said: what the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) meant was women who wear clothes made of light fabric which describes and does not cover. They are clothed in name but naked in reality. There There Ijmaa‘ (scholarly consensus) if the Face and hands Should be Shown or Not differences of opinion amongs the Scholars Allahknowbest. I take it that it should be covered up. AnyGood I Have Said is From Allah Any bad I have Said is from myself and Allah and he's messenger are Free From it.

[@bleef3069]

Hijab is mandatory. It's ijma since the time of the Salaf. Please if you don't want to wear a hijab just accept the sin and constantly make tawbah. Don't change a rule of Islam.

[@moth4953]

The level of logic used in this conversation is so mind opening

[@dounia3709]

Please answer my question, I am 14 can I remove hijab or will I go to hell. My parents force me to wear the hijab and I am in 9th grade USA and I am form Algerian origin please help. Will I go to hell fire. I don’t pray but I plan on starting once i don’t have to wear hijab. Hijab is keeping me away from allah, bc people stare and mock me which made me depressed and I am diagnosed

[@danadde]

Do not worry, you are not going to hell just because strangers see your hair. Allah promised he will forgive any sin, as long as you don’t commit shirk. Personally I believe that if it was that important, Allah could have made it very clear in the same ayat and said something like «always keep your hair covered, wear long sleeves, only expose your hands to the wrists in the public and your face”. But no, he only mentioned private parts to be covered. Anything else - is a subjective interpretation of men who wanted to keep their women wrapped up and hidden from a view

[@aisyahdelia8213]

@@danadde can u tell about hadith that said the woman awrah is the whole body except face and palm so it means we should cover our whole body except face and palm?

[@k-addictt6315]

Don't you think prayer is more important?Start praying..i am also starting..Hijab is just a cloth but prayer is something that connect us With Allah the Almighty spritually😊❤️So if u r not comfy with wearing it and suffering very much and now want to remove it then i think its alright cs Allah is the Most forgiving❤️Allah Hafiz

[@peanutbutter-bananashake.]

ther a pl ay ll st "M u s l i m Women are the F u t u r e" Vlsi t My Chan nel then this person cha nnel called Sunnah

[@valeriedhodson3014]

So not covering hair is an opinion that you can choose with feeling shame? I am more confused now than before. There is logical reasons to wear it and logical ones to not wear it.

[@zahednow]

Sister In Islam first is the Islamic rules (as per Quran & Hadeeth) and second comes logic. Watch these videos for better understanding on why Hijab should be followed kzbin.info/www/bejne/sJTdmIeaerONmZY kzbin.info/www/bejne/ipKXkp6Kd7ukptE

[@dekacchann]

Allah tells us to cover our beauty. And while we do not need to cover our entire body, the more we cove, the closer to Allah we are.

[@maseratiupgrades4363]

Using 'Himar' which can mean head cover to cover breasts does not mean that the Creator in Quran commanded to cover the head as well, but commanded to use a commonly worn head cover as a tool to cover the breasts . Neither does the Quran prohibit it. Only the covering of breasts is commanded. When willfully used a head cover can help to bring a woman closer to the Creator. But to oppress women who do not wear one because it is commanded by the Creator in Quran is false and wrong. This story of 'Hijab was thrown back to uncover breasts' is not in the revealed Quranic word of God. Hadith is hearsay science word of man misused as an abusive method of maintaining a false sense of dominance of weak men over even weaker women and weaker men. May the Creator curse the fabricators of God's word. The Creator in the Quran says that Quran is 'sufficient complete, perfected and clear' . Then it follows that the Hadith peddlers are idolators in the ranks of 'so-called' Islam who, in their blindness, claim Quran as a general rules giving reference book: that the Knitty Gritties of perfection of faith is in the historical hearsay recordings of what the prophet said and did. Hadith justifications include since Quran states to follow the prophet than we must follow him posthumously through Hadith. But if one really thinks, the Quran was not fully revealed when God instructs others to follow the prophet. So they needed to follow the prophet who if he deviated from God's will in action and words, God would cut out his jugular vein. When the Quran was complete, then prophet completely did his job. So Quran advises against seeking authority outside Quran (in it's complete form). Neither is Muhammad around and neither is there additional revelations of God to command reliance on apocryphal hearsay stories involving what the prophet may have said and done as an article of faith ( 'cover the breasts' in Quran really means cover the breasts, no more no less. Additional apocryphal details such as cover was originally used to cover the head and misused to expose the breast changes the whole meaning). The point of the Creator's words in Quran in this context is modesty. But modesty goals are twisted outside Quran to oppress women. In Quran, oppression is worse than slaughter. The other fallacy is that the more detailed the ritual, the closer it gets one to God. So we have in Hadith how to walk into a bathroom and how to walk out , how to hold ones arms in prayer and # of Rakats. Deviations from these minutiae are a means for weak people to oppress even weaker violators through frowning and humiliation which are distractions from connecting to the Sole Mover. So is Quran to be considered not the word of God for it's many ambiguities (five prayers a day, three prayers a day, remembrance of God is more important than prayer-all in Quran) ? Detailed ritual was used by the priests and anchorites on the people of the book as an unjust method of social control to establish intercession by humans to undermine the Creator's Supreme and direct authority over each creature as individuals. The Creator sent Jesus to restore that direct connection ('ask -the Creator- and you shall receive'; 'knock -on the Creator's door- and it shall be opened'...etc.). Now here we are in 2022 with the highly ritualized 'so -called' authorities extremely devoted to making a prophet (Muhammad) the center of their religion by hiding the necessary full light of Quran , calling it insufficient and thus 'crippled'. In the Quran, the Lord of all the worlds is center as we are not to make any distinction between the prophet/messengers. These hadith peddlers even go as far as to dis-allow image representations of Muhammad as if he is the Creator for Whom an image constitutes blasphemy for He (the Creator) is above His creation that cannot be likened unto Him. So these Hadith peddlers liken Muhammad unto Allah by claiming that he (Muhammad) is not to be likened unto creation like Allah is not to be likened and therefore no image of Muhammad can be made as well. The Hadith peddlers forbid an image of Muhammad because of the danger of worshiping him as a man-god. This does not justify the hadith peddlers worshipping Muhammad as a unseen God-god. In Quran you repeatedly read that the Creator guides Whom He pleases and that for whom the Creator withdraws guidance, there is no guidance. Here, the Hadith peddlers commit two sins: the first is to liken Muhammad to the infinite unseen Lord of all the worlds. The second is to, act as partners to the Creator by using this lie to prevent poeple from worshipping Muhammand. If the Creator decrees that people worship Muhammad as a god besides God, then no one can prevent it, especially by means of the first 'shirk' of associating Muhammad with the 'unseen' Creator.

[@thechoice301]

About the covering of hair: "As for elderly women past the age of marriage, there is no blame on them if they take off their ˹outer˺ garments, without revealing their adornments. But it is better for them if they avoid this ˹altogether˺. And Allah is All-Hearing, All-Knowing." Surah Noor, Ayah 60 Although covering of the hair is not explicitly mentioned in the verses Dr Shabir mentioned, these later verses talk about older women being allowed to take off their outer garment which means if you're not such a woman then you should keep outer garment on. Important here to understand here is that in almost all Muslim cultures, when women wear an outer garment or chaddar, they cover their hair with it always. In fact, in Urdu translations of this verse, it's explicitly mentioned that these particular women may uncover their hair. Further Allah knows best.

[@hershey1141]

Bro, translations can be wrong, that's why you read it in Arabic and listen to translations by scholars. And you said only the Urdu translation says that, that means someone changed it. And by outer garments it means the dress code that Allah gave to women. It means they can wear what they could normally wear within their family(shorts tube tops) outside, but it's better to stay modest, because(old age, etc.)

[@nightsky5037]

i don't get just why is some vague statements is referenced to make something a fard or wajib..

[@bluecat7684]

It’s very clear in the Hadith, no clue why he ignored that.

[@shafiq5047]

what if the dress is not showing body shape and you are wearing a turtleneck

[@Sarah-pj4vo]

This video can not be more required, especially for Muslim women born, raised and living in Western and other Non Muslim countries.

[@martynw9166]

No, it is not a sin; God is about love - we will be judged on our actions and deeds; not on what we wore or didn't wear in this world. It is feeble-minded to believe that an item of clothing - or the lack there of - can prevent a woman from entering Heaven. We are all responsible for our own sins - if a man lusts after a woman, it is his sin, not hers. Men should stop trying to deflect their shortcomings onto women. We are all made in God's image - we should be proud of the bodies He gave us.

[@yasminy.7243]

Martyn W They way you dress yourself counts to your actions, if Islam is in your heart, then you will start wearing the hijab after a time. You should do research on the topic of the hijab to understand it

[@martynw9166]

I have probably known the hijab and Islam before you were even born - my wife was Muslim - she left Islam 30+ years ago; I don't need to do any research on this topic.

[@UmarTahir]

Martyn W A man lusting is sinful? That is very unfair. If a thought can be a sin, well then every thing that Satan whispers to you would count as a sin for you which would mean you're sinning every minute

[@kalle0264]

Martyn W so explain in bible why it stands woman need to cover head or shave bald

[@kalle0264]

Martyn W but if woman clothing tight so here body exposé She is also sin because She is the reason too because She were attractive clothes

[@farhanmohammad]

it's not that one should cover only chest. Previous books which came to earth, torah and injeel, also had many teachings, and quran itself confirms the two books. people abide to those teachings and were used to cover heads, let alone left their chest. So in the revelation of quran it also made a point, that women should draw their viel(which is a head covering itself) over their bosom. It never said cover your bosom. hope you understand the meaning. Analogy: If someone is just covering their mouth and not nose with facemask, and you go and tell the person to pull your mask up to cover the nose too, should he be just covering his nose alone and not mouth?

[@kashfiaislam9995]

Wearing the hijab is obligatory but it is NOT obligatory for a Muslim woman to cover her stomach and back in front of her male mahrams. 🕌🕋

[@nisaakhan5568]

abyss her head was already covered listen to the video again for clarification. may Allah make it easy for you to understand

[@const9915]

thanks :) im a muslim and i struggle with this because its just hair, not the most important thing in the world, so i decided to wear loose clothing and some type of bucket hat or a hat that covers a bit of my hair bc like when i go to pe it gets really hot and i get a headache and im not supposed to take it off bc some boy might get attention of me?? if that were the case that means all the girls in my class would get the attention but they dont they are treated regularly and it is me that gets treated differently ):

[@AL-sh4ck]

May Allah guide you its not just hair it’s your Beaty you need to start wearing it as soon as possible Becuase it is mandatory I don’t wear it my self but do not say it’s just hair stugufrallah may allah guide us all Allah told us to wear it for a reason may allah make it easier for us all inshallah and speak more politely 🥰

[@AL-sh4ck]

Your disrespect 😟😟😟‼️

[@AL-sh4ck]

Any ways have a good day. ☺️🙏🏼

[@const9915]

@@AL-sh4ck im not being disrespect i can have a opinion if i want ♥ also this video said that it is not mandatory so watch the video please ~~

[@peanutbutter-bananashake.]

If The Video Said it's Not Mandatory Then there going Against Allah And The Messager and They need to Fear Allah. He is someone Not To take Knowledge From.

[@mariabiswas618]

It's okay not to cover hair because it's not our private part..We have to cover our private parts not our hair

[@potato0269]

you can do whatever you want bc u have free will but islamically speaking the hijab is mandatory

[@Shiningsnow]

The problem is in some places women are molested or harassed just for wearing hijab ( due to Islamophobia). 😢

[@AH-ky7xb]

Dr Shabir conveniently forgot to mention the numerous hadiths that back making the hijab or khimar and jilbab compulsory. How convenient. I don't think he gave a comprehensive answer. I find his answers for whatever reason try to cater to western Muslims so that they can somehow bend the rules of Islam to conveniently fit into western society. He did not even back his own statement. On one hand he states that the authority to make something haram belongs only to Allah. Then he states that not covering your hair is not a sin. On what basis did he make that assumption. His claim that the verse alludes to only women covering their bosoms is so lame. I'd like to ask him one question. Does Allah like to waste words? If the requirement for women was to only cover their bosoms. Allah simply had to say cover your bosoms. How women did it would have been left to them. The Quran is for all eternity, not just for women of those times (who he says happened to conveniently be wearing khimars) Allah clearly states -cover your bosoms with your Khimar. So then do that. There is no grounds for any other interpretation. Fine, follow what Allah says. End of Debate. Islam is the same practiced in any part of the world.

[@hbsblkk3842]

You're right Allah doesn't waste words, so why wouldn't He flat out say that not covering your hair is a sin? He is absolutely right in saying the authority to make something haram belongs only to Allah, it says it clearly in the Quran. He goes to say not covering your hair is not a sin using QURANIC EVIDENCE. Not once in the video did he try and make something haram, you are doing that if anything. Quran supersedes any Hadith whether you like it or not.

[@AH-ky7xb]

@@hbsblkk3842 you appear to be a novice so no point in arguing with you. It is the Prophet that qualified the statements in the Quran. There are many things prohibited by the Prophet that aren't in the Quran. So your argument is moot. PROPHET already stated women need to cover their hair. So it qualifies the Quran doesn't contradict it. And Allah doesn't preach according to you. Allah has already stated cover your bosoms with your khimar. If u can't understand what is clear n want to twist it's meaning that is your problem not Islam's. I simply stated what Allah has mentioned. You are the one saying Allah could have said this or that. Point is Allah didn't. What he has said is what is. If you can't stomach it not my problem.

[@mirzakadic9174]

subhanAllah, I don't know where this man is getting these things. There is no differences of opinions among ulema that wearing a hijab is fard upon women (strictly obligated), and leaving it is a major sin. Every time a women goes into public without hijab is a new sin, every single time. Brothers and sisters, please educate yourself in islam, so people like this don't educate you with this kind of "knowledge", which frankly I have no idea where he's getting this.

[@nightgaming466]

*Obviously it is a sin not to follow an Order of Allah. Allah doesn't need to mention how much punishment someone will get for not following which order.*

[@ahmedakhan1]

Allah is the only judge and He wll judge each individual according to their actions. No one can give the excuse that they were following someone else's advice. Each person has to make the decision of what is right and what is wrong according to their understanding. If through ignorance they sin, then Allah is most forgiving!

[@hittheslaybutton7285]

I want to wear hijab so bad but I live in a western country, they're very expensive When I was in 1st grade I'm 13 now my dad ordered hijab for me from Morocco my home country but now he's unable to so I don't know what to do 😢

[@ddodipura]

Can you please have more discussion about this again since it seems contrary to what the 4 imams of the islamic jurisprudence said (hair is awrah) and hence many people think of wearing it is fard?

[@ahmedakhan1]

The four imams were living hundreds of years ago, their understanding was based on what they knew at that time. The concept of awrah was a term of their own creation and had no basis in the Quran. Surely we have learnt much more today than what they knew. We have to reinterpret Islam and the Quran in light of the knowledge today. The scholars of the 12th and 13th century CE were not interpreting Islam according to the knowledge and conditions of the 7th century CE when the Prophet delivered Allah's message to humanity, but according to the knowledge of their times.

[@1eV]

@@ahmedakhan1 what knowledge are we talking about here? Shabir Ally only talked about the ayahs of the Quran which was also known to the four imams. Why do you think they all "failed" to understand tha "real meaning" of the ayah?

[@ahmedakhan1]

@@1eV The four imams may have been great scholars of their times but they were also influenced by the customs and beliefs of their times. You could well ask why did these scholars not oppose slavery when today everyone considers slavery to be inhumane and not to be practiced! Muslims now consider slavery to be incompatible with Islamic values.

[@1eV]

@@ahmedakhan1 well the same can be said about Shabir Ally. He's infuenced by the orientalists and western civilization and he's far from the true teachings of Islam.

[@zurathejoi]

I wear modern clothes. Like,jeans,hoodie,t-shirt etc. But these are not tight clothes bc tight clothes makes me uncomfortable and insecure. That's why i don't wear tight fitting clothes. So i think it's still modest?but i don't cover my hair tho

[@Youssef-wh8js]

Haram

[@potato0269]

if they're not revealing and loose clothes then yea its modest

[@pakistaniarmygirl3218]

@@Youssef-wh8js shutup stop sayingg haraam haraam

[@potato0269]

@@Closed0254 nope.

[@ishqnoor]

excellent and balanced explanation JazakAllah Khayr

[@matthoffman6962]

Not that I don’t agree because I do. But I find it hard to determine what should be followed unless it’s blatently said “this is a sin, you will go to hellfire etc”. Unless, we are all in agreement that if it doesn’t have a concrete output then we are not sinning. If there is we are.

[@AZ-ik1me]

I am a Muslim and am a proud Muslim But these days I am feeling like Islam is actually a little too extra for women in some ways Like I am okay with hijab and all But these days I feel like it's too much Why men only have to lower thair gaze?... Why are they not covered from head to toe tying their long hair in in the HOT I mean Islam does not allow women to tie their hair up in bun?... I mean why what's the logic? Even if it's a logic but why?... I feel exhausted while wearing a hijab with hair low And no one even can hear a women's voice?... Whyyyy?? I am strongly feeling like there's nothing for men but a lot for women I know it all about modesty and alll But I don't know why shaitan whispers are influencing me so much! What is a women supposed to do?... Wear a big cloth from top to low... Don't show eyes, don't breath properly, don't see properly, feel exhausted and then.... 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 Why am I bieng so disgusted I've never had this feeling before Ya ALLAH GUIDE ME🙏🏻😭

[@lyneea7924]

the woman's voice is not awrah, and actually men have more religious duties than women, but unfortunately society puts so much pressure on women and men pick and chose what they want to practice. im sorry that you feel this way. May Allah guide us all

[@k-addictt6315]

Yesss😭😭i also feel like this sometimes🥴

[@k-addictt6315]

@@lyneea7924 why putting pressure on women though and not on man😭😭😭Man are choosing and we are just being forced and judged wow🥺i understand that Allah told us that so we Dont get molested🥴but what about now wearing it or nor we r getting molested and when wearing we are also getting judged by society and when not wearing still the same..like why is society after us not after man..so in conclusion just let us live our life as we want pls as long as we are not harming others and being bad people😭😞i am so sick of this world..i wanna be free minded person😤and wanna just open this societies eyes🙂👁️👁️💪💪💪

[@peanutbutter-bananashake.]

Sister you should delete your Comment this is dangerous Mocking Anything from the religion intentionally or unintentionally Could take Someone out Side of the Fold Islam this going against Allah, Mocking Anything of The Sunnah Of Nabi Niqab etc. What You Just Called it is disgusting Please. Allah The one Who Created Us He's know what's best for Us. You do know what Islam Means Right : it is Submission To the one who Created Us, humbling oneself, and obeying he's commands and heeding prohibitions without objection, sincerely worshipping Allaah alone, believing what He tells us and having faith in Him. It's obligatory for every Muslimah to wear Niqab (Hijab as prescribed in Islamic teachings) in obedience to Allah and His Messenger, and so as to protect and maintain her honour, good conduct, religious commitment and chastity Hayah ie bashfulness, self-respect, shame, shyness, humility. Muslimahs Wear it in obedience to Allah. Not To Please No One But Allah. This Ain't A Competition. narrated that Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) said: The Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “Allah says: ‘Whoever takes a close friend of Mine as an enemy, I declare war on him. My slave does not draw closer to Me by anything more beloved to Me than that which I have made obligatory upon him, and My slave continues to draw closer to Me by doing naafil (supererogatory) deeds until I love him, and if I love him I will be his hearing with which he hears, his vision with which he sees, his hand with which he strikes and his foot with which he walks. If he were to ask of Me, I would surely give to him; if he were to seek refuge with Me, I would surely grant him refuge. I do not hesitate about anything that I want to do as I hesitate to take the soul of a believer, for he hates death and I hate to hurt him.” This hadith clearly and concisely highlights the way to become a close friend of Allah, may He be exalted, for the one who wants to be one of His close friends. Learn Who Allah Is, Learn Why You Wear The Hijab in the First Place ther a pl ay ll st "M u s l i m Women are the F u t u r e" Vlsi t My Chan nel then this person cha nnel called Sunnah

[@pritt-i3r]

I dont wear hijab I follow moral compass and quran value. Im happy Wearing modest as always that enough .

[@rimjhimkhandaker9832]

I have always seen people talking about how Muslim women should be modest and wear hijab but what about men? Is there no law for men in Islam? If there is then why don't we talk about that?

[@lyneea7924]

men have a dress code actually, but nobody talks about it :/

[@k-addictt6315]

@@lyneea7924 why🙂🙂Why we women face everything and man face nothing🥴

[@Lutestick]

Deviance is rampant. Becareful of the fitnah my brothers and sisters.

[@74If]

I wear a hijab 50/50 percent of the time and that’s fine

[@sibelkavak5587]

I want to wear hijab when i marry my future husband inşaAllah, then it will have more purpose for me because i already wear baggy and modest clothes not revealing any skin of my body.

[@zahednow]

I pray that you get the will & guidance to start wearing the hijab sooner than later, because there is no directive for hijab to be wore only after marriage. Also just wearing baggy clothes doesn't imply quranic hijab as you have to draw & outer cloth above your dress

[@sibelkavak5587]

@@zahednow OH MY ALLAHHH, i came back to this video because it was recommended and saw your comment for the first time and you're dua came true Alhamdulillah i started wearing hijab this Ramadan. Thank you for your prayer, may Allah bless you and ur loved ones😇

[@drgowharmajid8966]

I think we need more clarity regarding this topic , I don’t think it’s a complete answer . If Allah has ordered something which is mentioned in Quran is farz and not doing so is absolutely in contrary to the teachings of Quran and this means it will be a punishable sin .

[@farsinislam7882]

Assalamualaikum. This is a very confusing video to the people who have just started knowing islam...such short video to describe weather it is sinful or not to wear hijab is not enough...i recommend a longer and described video on this topic.....

[@Dieselz]

This person is not qualified to answer this.... nor is the position of the Majority of Scholars... this person has been teaching a lot of misconceptions to the Ummah.

[@nourmal1950]

maybe look into Khaled Abou El Fadl? He has a fatwa on this as well as a five hour halaqa series on the issue

[@zainabakhtar3329]

Why? Do u want add up words? Or the clear commandment with it's exact interpretations?

[@nadeemmir9303]

A deviation from the actual commandment when seen in the context. Bottom line is_ HIJAB is mandatory for Muslim women.

[@alishsplashes7209]

um so the problem with me is that Ive been always confused and i never did a "proper" hijab. It was an on and off thing. As i grew up not covering my head made me a bit uncomfortable sometimes in public places. When i started going to tuition i began covering my head for atleast 3 straight months i kept it then after sometime when i changed my tuition to another place i stopped covering my head. I think it was because i wanted attention astagfariullah or maybe people thoughts mattered to me that time. I still regret doing this. I began covering again then stopped. I thought not covering my head was OK BUT IT WASN'T. I WAS CONFUSED. I ASKED MY MUM AND MY FRIENDS and they always said "do it for yourself, do wht makes u comfortable" but this was not my answer? One of my friend said it's you're choice and not doing it is a sin. Not doing made me uncomfortable by those stares i used to get. I felt like not doing it made me an attention seeker. And whenever i told myself that not covering head is for myself it was just a lie. Doing it made me think about what other think. I was done w myself, i contemplated about it and came to a final decision. I'm gonna do hijab and that's it and I'm not going to remove it anymore. I'm gonna fight these weird temptations. I'm doing it for myself. I don't care how other think about it. I know it's awkward and i feel guilty about it. But now i hav much knowledge and sense about it. May Allah Guide us to the straight path.

[@Fayblues]

may Allah make it easy for you...I've been going through the same phasr

[@phiuzu5487]

Hello. May Allah grant you ease. If you're still facing issues, I'd advise to watch mufti abu layth's videos on hijab especially can one wear the hijab if it causes insecurity. I'd further advise to read the comments since they quote actual reason based evidence that hijab is not obligatory

[@hameedfs]

Disobeying Allah or his Rasool is a sin - this has been clearly mentioned at many places in Quran. If Allah says "do this", then better you obey. If you are confident of standing in front of Allah on Judgement Day and saying "I did not follow what you said but I am not sinful because...blah...blah...", then good luck.