'You're just a snarky guy': Judge pokes fun at Johnny Depp lawyer, court erupts in laughter

The judge in the Johnny Depp and Amber Heard defamation trial was hearing motions during the lunch break when she poked a little fun at Depp's attorney. An attorney representing TMZ was attempting to keep a former employee from testifying about a leak that Heard would be filing a restraining order against Depp. During arguments Depp's attorney made a comment about TMZ's reputation, which the TMZ attorney referred to as snarky. Later Depp's attorney apologized for the comment and the judge waved it off, saying "you're just a snarky guy," which lead the court to erupt in laughter.
Subscribe to LiveNOW from FOX! kzbin.info?su...
Where to watch LiveNOW from FOX: www.livenowfox.com/
Follow us @LiveNOWFOX on Twitter: / livenowfox
Raw and unfiltered. Watch a non-stop stream of breaking news, live events and stories across the nation. Limited commentary. No opinion. Experience LiveNOW from FOX.

[@MarleeCraig]

I find it hilarious that TMZ is going to great lengths to stop an ex employee from testifying, but has no issues publishing true or false stories themselves.

[@primrosetx9571]

It’s all about the money.

[@lmsteller9736]

Because AH sold copyright to TMZ - her team is frightened by anything “leaking” to TMZ - how else would TMZ get the video when AH took the video herself?

[@A1.Juni0r]

Fax!

[@denisemezynski8014]

Jury should Know Heards team dont want this info or Witness coming out. If all these so called Professional Lawyers & Doctors testified who work under NoN disclosures......how is a journalist higher up than Lawyers & Doctors and yet they ALL testified.

[@janelletanner-yellowman8688]

Da root of all evil... is money 💰. Enough said.

[@dialupdaddy5339]

For anyone looking; 7:38 is the start of the "snarky comment" 12:10 is where TMZ's lawyer says Ben was being "snarky" 16:03 is Ben apologizing for being snarky (judge makes her joke right after)

[@AtrociousNightmare]

Thank you very much :)

[@cathydenby2532]

Thank you headache listening to the bull crap 😂

[@krisszeld8149]

Not all heroes wear capes. Thank you for your service 🫡

[@JMHulme]

Thank you 😊

[@kannankichu1997]

This world needs more people like you. Have a great day

[@bigfish1676]

A refined woman of immense patience, kindness, and wisdom. She's everyone's role model.

[@patriciaselwyn799]

Exactly right, some hope that justice will prevail in this case

[@llisamichele]

Well said Big Fish 🐠

[@amymoquin8636]

Plus, she was awesome in Aquaman! 😳 Oh, you were talking about Judge Penny NOT Amber Heard? 😉😂 (For the record, I haven't even seen Aquaman🤭)

[@WoodysOpinion101]

She is also the cats mother... Lol u might want too credit the person you are talking about!!!

[@seanbrown9048]

She was nice; I would have called him an alcoholic, pathetic, burned out loser with very poor taste in women…

[@jackfrost9466]

This judge is like the understanding mom who's trying to resolve a quarrel between her two children...hearing both sides of the story from each child with no favoritism. Much respect to her.

[@gardnersa16]

Is that not the job of a judge?

[@jackfrost9466]

@@gardnersa16 Yes, it is. But, not all moms are as understanding with no favoritism. Similarly, not all judges are good judges like this one. I'm simply saying this judge is a good judge and I respect that.

[@lilyblossom5821]

Which is all the more impressive when one of those kids is a complete narcissistic psycho, I wouldn't have the patience she has with Turds team

[@jackfrost9466]

@@lilyblossom5821 Exactly

[@durgadevi7814]

I never saw the understanding mom who's not biased towards a child but I got to see this judge. Perhaps she would have been the understanding mom to her kids even. 🙂

[@alexpowers4388]

This judge sows the seed of hope in me for justice in the legal system.

[@joshuaallen5453]

Unfortunately, 1 judge is just that. And each is different. Each interprets things different. It's like the medical field also, you can get 5 Dr's. Opinions and you may get 5 different opinions. But I feel the same way, even if it's a naive way of feeling. It gives me hope just knowing their is atleast 1good judge.

[@lowkeylokii4205]

Well, civil case judges are typically less assholish than federal/criminal court judges

[@wesselbotha3928]

@@joshuaallen5453 like your negativity

[@jillionairess]

​@@joshuaallen5453 When did you ever get five opinions for any medical conditions you have ever had?

[@becky6360]

@@jillionairess hes just making a point the number doesnt matter.

[@stephenapineru1588]

the fact AH’s attouney at this point is still being instructed by the judge to turn on her mic on is insanely frustrating to watch! but also a testament to the judges patience

[@cappsginny699]

Insanely frustrating, really?

[@angiet6500]

@@cappsginny699 Yes, because the woman is an idiot. God knows how she ever got through law school. As others have said, did AH buy her from Woolmart?

[@iclaudius2534]

She's so calm and patient, has a very calming voice.

[@Timberjagi]

It seems like they randomly turn it on and off. Her job is beeing a lawyer, not a presenter focussed if the microphone is on or off

[@MitsuruXIII]

@@Timberjagi Not an excuse, you see Camilla has her hand on the button for the mic so she is ready to object. This is their JOB! Why tf are you defending her incompetence?

[@hawnborn7497]

Love this judge. She doesnt come off as arrogant or bossy like some judges. She seems down to earth.

[@quantomrizzics]

I get what you're saying but she's actually really tough. She just tries her best to use the death stare than her gavel. Like a stoic

[@samkelly8786]

I love the judge's reactions at 10:59 (when Elaine's intervene and she sounds tired of her, even JD smiled at it), 14:15 (when she comments this is not the first unusual situation in this case) and 16:10 (when she said "Well, your'e just the snarky guy!"). And Amber's lawyers team who interrupted her before going to eat lunch 🙄... I admire her professionalism and patience in his broadcasted and long case (with thousands of exhibits). I wish her goo luck with that 😂!

[@cosmiccomedy7394]

Thanks for the time stamps

[@yeppys]

THANK YOU TIMESTAMPS FINALLY

[@ziadajam5433]

My lack of patience appreciates your heroism

[@Dr.Aditya-Agrawal]

Thanks for time stamps

[@dazkaz15]

I like the judge. All that power and she is still humble.

[@alister101]

Humble and so nice

[@trollsnotwelcome7805]

Absolutely, education and qualifications don't make a professional it's all about manner, honest, humble and polite describe this Judge ❤️

[@THX-vp9fz]

@@trollsnotwelcome7805 its about intelligence

[@seonadmacleod139]

A sign of high intelligence and good breeding! She's not in this for the fame or money she is where she is because she has great knowledge and integrity. Things which are sadly lacking in many today.

[@CRAZYJONSO]

@@seonadmacleod139 Breeding lol! She isnt a dog

[@rasalghul9331]

The judge is very intelligent, considerate, thorough, and professional.

[@MorfsPrower]

Like a judge should be, but not all judges are made the same.

[@damonswanson3156]

Absolutely. I see nothing but integrity in this Judge. And she almost makes it fun! Common sense prevails!🤓

[@zulygirl4412]

@@MorfsPrower NO KIDDING! Your insight is staggering.

[@B_Bodziak]

@@zulygirl4412 Unnecessary

[@B_Bodziak]

@@MorfsPrower This is true, and many judicial positions, specifically those appointed not elected, have very little oversight.

[@afez7101]

It's refreshing to see a very humble ,smart , intelligent and extremely grounded Judge . Especially that it's being viewed live . She's Awesome.

[@ChickenJoe12]

“We’re concerned about the 1st amendment but we want to prevent an employee from speaking voluntarily” Yeah makes sense

[@vben2976]

TMZ and Amber’s team to prevent the truth to come out. Team Jonny.

[@IceeALatte]

This poor Judge! She has been so patient,soft spoken and kind throughout this trial. She deserves every ounce of respect!

[@doesntmatter4477]

Poor? Judge? No. Lol. She's in the elite of society she's just fine

[@Fusion991]

Beauty fades dumb is forever.

[@lsh7098]

@@doesntmatter4477 there are other definitions of the word "poor", English much?

[@Korcasandromedaa]

Nothing amazing that's her job the career she chose after the Marines.

[@martinnijs8317]

Correct observation , the real star in this trial is the judge. She runs a tight ship. Hope for her that Elaine learns to operate the mic before the trial ends... i would not have that patients with her...

[@Daecoth]

Unspoken rule of the court: When the judge makes a joke, YOU LAUGH!!!

[@emster716]

This judge definitely has my vote. She’s doing a great job handling this entire case. (And sometimes her facial expressions are HILARIOUS) when she hears some of these crazy witnesses 😂😂

[@rgober60]

I agree 💯 % but I wonder What she would judge as to Who is right or who would she say is a winner....maybe she can write a book after all this is done about the whole case and what she thought....That would be a book to buy!!!

[@pam_jackson]

This judge is fierce in her quest for justice. So refreshing to see.

[@zulygirl4412]

Unless she was fierce in justice for Amber.

[@olympiakallman3561]

My concern is the character of the female jury members - if they want to support a female or if they will really listen to the crap handed by Heard

[@cappsginny699]

The crap handed by Heard?

[@eddiemills6222]

@@zulygirl4412 : Oh, I don't think that will be a problem. After particular grueling "Amber testimony" one day, she was looking so sadly at Johnny, like a sympathetic Aunt.

[@essolunapapa]

I absolutely agree with your statement Pam, and it is something that needs to be well communicated over all media. She has been a model Judge in this case!

[@pedroportillo1585]

What I find absolutely hilarious is that almost every single woman involved in this case is an example of smart, strong, and independent woman, EXCEPT, Amber Heard 🤣

[@jp4431]

Don't forget the women on Amber's team. They're also exceptions.

[@teryancehorace3276]

Yeah Elaine is mid

[@monicasuelto4952]

@@teryancehorace3276 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@janineparker3041]

Whitney wasn't strong at all

[@Alexkpz888]

Yesssss! My thoughts exactly continuously

[@intrepidvirgo938]

A kind and patient judge with a sound mind filled with intelligence, wisdom and pragmatic thoughts.

[@wge621]

When I first saw her, I thought the judge was biased. After watching her more, I have immense respect for her and don't think she could have handled this case any better

[@JDGamingPR]

I absolutely love this judge. Firm, funny, respectful, she looks humble...I absolutely love her. Huge respect for your honor.

[@candidastelloh931]

I agree. I like her

[@-WingedPoet-]

Couldn't have said it better myself. 🙌🏻 🧐 We'll see what happens 🫠

[@cindyp1337]

My feeling about this judge in the beginning she was very slow to respond to objections. Secondly, she's leaving motions relative to the law up to the jury instead of making the decision herself, I find very strange

[@MA-zg2pz]

@@cindyp1337 why do you find this process strange? It’s pretty typical

[@blahblahblahaha]

This makes so much sense as to why he didn’t explicitly state it was Amber. The way they questioned him was genius. They got him to say it was Amber without actually saying it which would have lead to a separate litigation regarding revealing “anonymous” sources and still got the point across that she’s lying. Very well done.

[@valerieserrano1245]

Miley is staring into my soul…

[@blahblahblahaha]

@@valerieserrano1245 how Amber be looking at the jury

[@Brittany-410]

Exactly! You had to be paying attention and understand what he was saying. He said they only could get copyright if the person who filmed it give the clip to them. As well as saying amber filmed the clip. so only amber had copyright to hand over to tmz.

[@adelinaclonts7004]

@@Brittany-410 yep! A brilliant move by JD team. I watched it several times just to make sure I heard it correctly. I hope the jury caught it! This was a very winning point for this case!!

[@paull8397]

yeah she is in a pickle with this one, she cant open proceedings against TMZ for her being implied as the source or it will all come out in writing that she was the source and lied in court, this limits the damages that TMZ can claim against former employee who most likely broke some sort of contract divulging this stuff. implicates Amber and offers some protection to the witness.

[@lou1958]

Watched a lot of court cases and Judge Penney Azcarate is definitely one of the best I've seen. She is sharp, methodical, and completely in control of her courtroom. Just a little light searching, and I see she is a Marine. Very refreshing.

[@mariajaramillo1135]

Is the opposite from judge judy ! 😂

[@adic6515]

I'm a fan of this judge she has truly earned this position. People like this should run Whitehouse

[@lifesabeach8133]

The TMZ lawyer is talking down to the judge. Meanwhile the judge is standing her ground with patience, kindness, fairness, and good humour, backed up by a solid knowledge of the law. She is the true, quiet and steady star anchoring this case to reality.

[@reneemulder22]

Also that snurkey/snorkey comment omg as if that would change anything she handeled that good 🤗

[@superpantman]

He is not talking down to the Judge, he does not wish for TMZ, their reputation or actions to be drawn into this case as they have absolutely nothing to gain from it. He is making a case that the witness should not testify which any organisation would do in a similar situation. People get too caught up in thinking that everyone is there to help Johnny Depp win its hilarious to me.

[@dbs1013]

At least he addresses her politely and doesn't argue and talk over her though, unlike AH's lawyer. She's far worse.

[@reneemulder22]

Oh snarky it was 😂🙏 sorry from thé Netherlands i understand everthing but dont always know how to write it

[@nordquist52]

That's her military training coming thru

[@Crusty_Dusty_Eye]

In that recording he said, " And I will see you in F***ing court," and he did, and he blew it out of the park. You told the world, and it heard you

[@sandrarhine7600]

TEAM JOHNNY

[@emmasummers893]

👏👏👏👏

[@mandycote5662]

-is-

[@tiamieaton1952]

And we love him for it!!

[@camerong.6144]

Amber Heard will be known hence forth, as Scamber Turd. She solidified her name In immortality as a wilfull bed Pooper

[@Ambah818]

This is one of the best judges I have seen in a long while. We need more like her out there.

[@markraimo1283]

I am really loving this judge. She is unbias, firm, fair and kind all in one. It's refreshing to see, especially with all the corruption that plagues the justice system and government.

[@CF-ei5oz]

So not only was Kate Moss not pushed down stairs, Depp CARRIED her when she fell!

[@eveningstar6700]

lmao! it ended up being such a cute story

[@lady_karma369]

yessss and he remember her pain and crying ooohhhh soooo sweeeeet 😭😭😍😍😍

[@Ilene-pz8fp]

AH’s team did not want to hear ANYMORE!

[@MajorTom546]

Judge shutting down Elaine was satisfying to watch.

[@danielasanchezcortes4764]

Totally!

[@cute6friendssearch]

Yes

[@hude7360]

Yeah--after she reminded her to turn on her mic for the umpteenth time. OMG that woman...

[@yahussain1272]

Timestamp?

[@smellybearc7411]

She always looks like she’s about to laugh lol. I really like her.

[@MarceldeJong]

TMZ and journalism in the same sentence ... That's a laugh

[@penneyburgess5431]

JD was filmed without his permission, sold without his permission. TMZ had no business putting it on line.

[@TheBaumcm]

Yep, it’s clear when he says are you filming, and chucked it that he did not give consent. California is two party consent for conversations so I’d assume the same for video.

[@szz4058]

TMZ shoddy

[@RicStorm616]

So if JD wins this, will the next lawsuit be TMZ or The Sun 🤔😁

[@motherof1294]

@@RicStorm616 I hope so but I doubt it, I think JD will want to rest from courts for awhile after this

[@dknf4036]

@@TheBaumcm your assumption is correct, you can't video record people in private without their consent

[@Emerica.]

I like this judge and her sense of humor.

[@ramronquillo8756]

Bet it helps keep herself sane given the case so far. 🤣

[@eveningstar6700]

gotta have one! xD

[@amylarson3958]

I don't know how this judge has not run out of the courtroom screaming maniacally

[@VijayaBjoshi]

that means if she sides with Amber you will have nothing to complain

[@a_2502]

it's nice to see it haha. she's kind of funny

[@martindlee3902]

The judge has been so patient and considerate making the trial seem to be the most appropriate without bias

[@robertthomas4383]

When the lawyers where making there argument i didn't understand much of what they where saying but i am amazed at how easy it was to understand exactly what the judge was saying and how she addressed each argument the defense made, the judge is a star

[@mahfujakhushi4341]

She said that line at “16.10” You’re welcome 😉

[@mykitchenconnection]

Thank you so much!! 🙏❤

[@aQuietNomad]

Thanks 🤗

[@Not_A_bodybuilder]

God bless your soul

[@danielallan8310]

Thank you. 16:10

[@imalwayssleepy7997]

I was looking for this comment 😅 thanks

[@Adam.P]

never seen such desperation to stop a witness. they already know who leaked the video

[@Gargi11p]

Pd I Lq Lp I no

[@currentlysystem106]

Ms 💩 did lol

[@enithdominguez3509]

Exactly 🤣😂

[@katymcginn4644]

😒 WE ALL KNOW WHO LEAKED THE 💩😑 SHE CAN'T KEEP HER MOUTH SHUT 🤭

[@superpantman]

TMZ don't want to be drawn into this court case as they don't stand anything to gain from it. Any organisation would do the same if a former employee is testifying about company practises to aid a third party.

[@DirtySouth1974]

I absolutely am in love with the way this judge is running her courtroom 🥰🥰🥰... She is such a shining example of what a judge should be!

[@mybraineatseverything7404]

Someone please get this woman onto SCOTUS! We need her!!!

[@makadise]

Calling TMZ a news organization is biggest lie that amber didn't said

[@ssj2camaro21]

Exactly!!!!!!!!!!

[@solortega4225]

Exactly...they are so panic that all 💩💩💩💩💩💩 get bigger 🤣😂🤣😂🤣

[@mimiwilt6381]

Which is why she went to them. A real news organization would never have taken the story.

[@britzel71]

This judge is really something...a diamond in a system where we're seeing daily corrupt and bias judges using their political affiliations over their oath. Not that this has anything political but she seems truly honest and a honest judge doing her job.

[@anaromello]

She is a credit to her profession. Wish there were more like her.

[@kyliebaby1391]

She does seem to try to be as fair and balanced as she can. I think she genuinely loves her job and was really pleased she got this case so she could show no matter who the claimants are, the law is the law and she’ll be totally unbiased, as she would with any case.

[@jordyjohn2275]

That’s because she’s in Virginia and not a highly politicized state that places quotas over justice like Illinois or California

[@abc5228]

absolutely agree. she knows her job

[@Just_Cause]

Care to mention some Unbiased judges? I'm only asking that bcoz everyone in the chat seems to be so aware of flaws in the judicial system as if you guys have been personally wronged!

[@adaywithaleks6556]

I love how sweet but firm the judge is with a smile on her face.

[@likayee6247]

The Judge is remarkably polite and respectful to lawyers, very pleasant.

[@toothfairy430]

The term "rogue employee" is one used by corrupt companies who know they've wronged their employees and don't want to own up to it.

[@Anxiou5Panda]

They also love using the words, "disgruntled employee" lol.

[@coltonjones6273]

In this case it is referring to any employee who is/would be in breach of contract. It isn’t like a rogue bull who got off the farm.

[@SineN0mine3]

I don't think anyone was operating under the impression that TMZ is a legitimate journalistic organisation or an ethical business.

[@ALH535]

Watching Elaine's face darting back and forth like she's watching Wimbledon is a real joy.

[@sharonfox9962]

😂

[@angiewolflove4040]

Hahahaha

[@hukazhimomi4397]

😜😂😂😂😂

[@wahyuwulan8814]

🤣🤣

[@dianaowusu6182]

I have just had a whiplash just by watching her!!!

[@luckyleavitt809]

"Good Morning, your After!" 🤦🏼‍♀️🤣

[@Polo-gc1di]

It's not power guys, it's responsibility and she handles it with grace.

[@matwatson7947]

No it's power AND responsibility. She has the most power and needs the most responsibility because of it. Even the head attorneys cannot argue with the judge and if they do get admonished or overuled

[@ILuvBoysInDresses]

I appreciate that JD’s whole team, Ben himself included, all laughed good-naturedly at that quip. Meanwhile, Heard had no human reaction, because she doesn’t have a soul.

[@peanut9863]

Seriously; Amber is not a human being? No matter what; all involved are human beings. This is also a serious matter so not all might find it funny.

[@jessekittrell2946]

U can tell she’s so scared of showing even a smile because she thinks it will show she’s guilty lol. Watching her look at the jury with the little “I know it sucks we are here I’m sorry” smirk type look trying to get them to feel sorry for her and seem relatable. She’s been caught in so many lies its honestly getting pathetically hilarious.

[@kevingonzalez9944]

@@peanut9863 thank you for your clarification, I was almost convinced that he was being serious about her not being a human being, I almost thought she was an alien from another planet

[@Enhancedlies]

most telling out of it all hahaha

[@vfer5450]

@@kevingonzalez9944 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🏅🏅

[@jayesimond9301]

That TMZ ex-employee also has a 1st Amendment right to express his opinion as witness.

[@superpantman]

Yes, this is why he is allowed to testify, however, TMZ also has the right to object on the basis he is revealing company information and practice. TMZ don't stand to gain anything from this court case so of course they will object to anything regarding their involvement, good or bad doesn't matter.

[@jayesimond9301]

@@superpantman That’s a TMZ problem, they barked @ the wrong tree. If they didn’t want their former employee to testify about info he acquired while working for them, they should have leaned on him by enforcing the NDA he likely had to sign as a requirement for employment with TMZ. This guy knows he’s going to face some legal repercussions on that end. No doubt this witness thought of doing the right thing, and TMZ’s attorney did his job best he could for his client tho it was the wrong legal venue.

[@superpantman]

@@jayesimond9301 They probably can force action on him from an NDA in his contract. I wouldn't be able to start talking about former workplaces in court and their practice even if it was relevant to the case. Without the approval of my former employer I would be liable for repercussions although i'm not sure how damaging his statements are to TMZ so probably not too bad for him.

[@debkelley5955]

The judge is like, “I can’t wait until this case is over.” 🤣🤣

[@BeHappii1]

I love this judge!!! She looks so kind, gentle & soooo patient and she has a sense of humour too.

[@rowil3963]

She is looking at the TMZ Attorney “seriously? Are you undermining me and my knowledge of the law??”

[@laguest9667]

What minute is it?

[@rowil3963]

13:27

[@superpantman]

TMZ lawyer is making a case to not allow the witness to testify. The objection was noted but not accepted. TMZ lawyer was very respectful in my opinion and made a good case.

[@Sarablueunicorn]

Nothing special. The judge took note and explained in which grounds she would allow the witness to testify. You think all these lawyers are smartasses but they are not. This TMZ lawer asked if he could object and judge said because he doesn't represent any of the parties he could not object during the testimony but tmz can follow up in another case (like suing the employee). Today Camille asked several times if the jury could access the footage that has been streaming online. The judge was like "errr jury has access to EVIDENCE only: photos, texts and videos" not testimonies. She was going on and on like a teacher's pet asking for favors.

[@TheBaumcm]

I love that an outlet like TMZ is fighting for its right to publish unsubstantiated information based on sources that are as sleazy as they are.

[@sheisaMachine]

I know. what a joke.

[@xmarine73]

TMZ is not fighting for it's right to publish at all. They are fighting to keep their source(s) anonymous versus having them named, discovered, or otherwise admitted as a matter of evidence before the court and therefore on the public record. Basically they don't want it to be revealed that Amber was the source... because that's the absolute SLEAZIEST sort of source they could have (the activating party) for their release of this kind of information (seeking an RTO).

[@dtschuor459]

Same!

[@corbetthouse7654]

They are trash.

[@Boogie1904]

That’s why they need to be boycotted. They’re garbage.

[@Leanzazzy]

As I watch the case, I admire the judge more and more. She manages to keep the atmosphere light-hearted, yet serious and gives fair decisions after listening to both sides without any bias.

[@SylvainBellerose]

If Amber didn’t contacted TMZ then why are they so worry about what he’ll say?

[@worldwide2358]

The level of unprofessionalism Amber’s team keeps portraying is embarrassing!!!!

[@nougatbitz]

and so entertaining, I’m embarrassed to say… what a great court day anyways! Moss, TMZ guy, photo forensic guy, JD on the stand… 🎆

[@keriannedavidson6005]

at this point, are we surprised?

[@donniebunkerboi9975]

Nothing beats Amberturd lawyer OBJECTING to own question and then forgot

[@swim2kill]

@@nougatbitz dont be embarrassed. You are not alone this is entertaining for all of us! 😂

[@1RFB308shooter]

It's hard to defend someone you know is guilty... I think they know they are in a no win position, and just can't find the passion/inspiration to really put their best effort into this trial. Or they are just bad at their job. Either way Turd looses, maybe not this case, but in real life. I sincerely doubt she'll ever get another role again. And she will remember (for the rest of her life) I lost Johnny.

[@janekay2912]

Why and how did Elaine get away with talking over a judge the way she did?! So unprofessional!!!!

[@desireereyes9043]

She does this every day! She argues with the judge!

[@tersemerkhet4633]

let her argue it shows how unprofessional she is, Amber would be better off calling Saul.

[@barbaraturner200]

I don't understand that. where is Elaine and her bunch from?

[@marquezrosa2085]

@@tersemerkhet4633 lmao good one

[@kaywee4200]

Every single time she argues. She's the absolute worst lawyer in the world.

[@mariayazbeck7112]

I love this judge. How humble and polite. She calls him sir. How polite. Respect. How calm and well composed.

[@saelaird]

I think anyone who has seen any if this trial has an enormous amount of respect for the judge. Calm, measured, completely neutral, extremely professional and just a credit to the system.

[@buenavistadream]

Much respect to the judge.

[@jacobyrassilon]

I think that this judge has had her fill of Hollywood types and will be very glad when this case has concluded.

[@aname559]

The judge has all my Respect

[@Mystic_Libra]

I dont know why but I feel like I will miss seeing the Judge, Johnny's Lawyer's, and Mrs. Curry once all this is over.

[@Eener1000]

Word! I am so invested in this now, it's like a super entertaining show and all the characters are great fun.

[@riyamachado988]

Like after a series finale we miss all our fav characters except here it's real people with real lives 😶

[@merlin5420]

I miss Dr Curry, she is so pleasing to the eye 😎

[@tash17kids]

@@merlin5420 and the brain too lol

[@SurajSingh-go4pz]

DOCTOR Curry , aka hopefully, the next Mera 😍

[@TheTaxburden]

The judge definitely knows her stuff. If only all judges were this way.

[@anupamsircar111]

JD lawyers have really earned their fees in this case. Such thorough, professional, and sincere hard work are rarely seen anywhere in the world.

[@KrisTinna41]

There will never be shortage of Hollywood gossip. You'll be fine, TMZ.

[@estherloske1396]

🤣

[@heidilynns9207]

Hallelujah!

[@Scarred87]

Well they’ll have the Kardashians contacting them weekly with “go see’s” in the very least

[@LikeFenixBird]

I love this judge, she’s so nice and most of the time have a smile on her face, that doesn’t mean she’s not serious about the case. You can be strict and have a smile like her 💪🏼😊

[@murtazarizvi368]

she is like aslan from narnia. seems calm most of the time but is aggressive when needed

[@ants5845]

Yeah she's my Spirit Judge 💗🔥👑 lol. I am also friendly and nice but don't see that as a weakness...

[@litterbocks47]

Can you imagine if it had been Judge Ito of the OJ S Simpson trial?

[@paulaharlfinger829]

Yeah, I was thinking the same thing. I bet, if she is a mother, that her children really respect her. She is amazing.

[@ghersic8161]

"They have a beef, as it were." Really summarizes the entire legal process.

[@bobkmac]

"I object to this witness because he's devastating to my case" - lawyers.

[@ShirleyWhite2]

I pray the judge and the jury can see thru her lies. I would not and have not ever thought of recording or taken pictures of my parter at ANY time

[@EP3mentalist]

Evidence of ear shattering snoring is an exception lol

[@cordingkarma1139]

Well they recorded their arguments as part of their therapy

[@DarkBunnyLord]

To be fair they both did it and the purpose was largely do to drug use on Johnnys side and simply denial on Ambers. They’re consular recommended recording arguments since obviously they kept agreeing on things that occurred and they wanted to work on their relationship but the only way to do that would be if they could agree on what happened. Honestly thank god they did to because given how courts treat male victims of DV this case wouldn’t even be happening if Depp hadn’t gotten the audio of heard outright admitting she hit him.

[@dianedavis324]

I have never in my life and trust me I have been through something's.. Women in true situations don't want photos they want out or are too f up to see their way out.. This b is a liar and anyone who has ever been in the actual situation knows!

[@violet9853]

@@dianedavis324 Yes, sister. Have a wonderful day.

[@terretulsiak1400]

The only reason Amber should object is if Amber's team is the leaker.

[@JPBADD7549]

Thats exactly what they are trying to establish because she denied it.

[@leafybleu8814]

Yes, the only reason he's really here. Of course he's going to say 1st amendment and certainly that's important. I'm going with Ben here though. And.....Amber is getting scared and look how jumpy Elaine is.

[@daniellescott6701]

Yep you got girlfriend!

[@wezo2070]

BINGO!!!!

[@leafybleu8814]

Elaine bringing up Johnny being "violent" with the cabinets again"😄😂All they have left.

[@big5cats316]

And thank you Ben for assuring this. We all already knew she probably leaked it herself, but Elaine getting a burn after thinking she could outsmart a guy that had 20 paparazzi under him, was flat out a great entertainment

[@bhotism]

Homie in the back is falling asleep! My brother wake up🤣😂🤣😂

[@symeon5518]

I'm a Law student during finals season and these videos have been a huge help with my studying. Not because the subject matter has something to do with my courses this semester but it just gives me motivation when I watch this vids. Coming from a common-law country also helps because of the discussions about previous cases Edit: I didn't really expect the response I got from you people but thank you all for your wishes, I appreciate it

[@giuseppinafadi4899]

Symeon. I'm positive you will succeed. All the best for you, keep going. 🤞👏

[@symeon5518]

@@giuseppinafadi4899 thanks, I've been doing really well in all courses except one, but even thatone didn't go too badly. One more semester and I'll try my luck by applying for a scholarship. All the best to you too

[@PindakaasMetHagelslag]

Wishing you all the best! I am about to start my first year in Law School. Exhilarating and nerve wracking at the same time!

[@marlene8612]

Wishing you all the best!!

[@lllima432]

Not a law student but I learnt so much including the legal terminologies .

[@johnnycee5179]

This judge is smarter than all of them, man, she is good.

[@ssj2camaro21]

She does have the top position

[@vinny4411]

She is a good man

[@Mr.Eternal966]

13:27 This is the Exact moment you can tell the Judge have heard that BS before, she knows what they are trying to do and it's calmly waiting he finish until she eliminate that "illegal" intervention, man she's pretty good!

[@KadeemLiburd]

_"I'm almost certain he's not gonna claim its Ms. Turd"_ this didn't age well... That's exactly what he did; you can't predict what he's not going to say if your client is a compulsive liar

[@likematestopprocrastinatin3548]

I love how AH team always tells Johnny’s and his witness and anyone who comes for him to save the jury’s time but then look at that🤦🏻‍♀️

[@alistairrudolph5378]

lol l

[@hadenayers1268]

@@alistairrudolph5378 lol I

[@invincible7284]

It's TMZ'S lawyer who objected, and it's their rights too.

[@sorrybroo8303]

@@invincible7284 its not allowed lol😂

[@essolunapapa]

This Judge has really earned my respect regardless of the jury's decision in this case. She has been as knowledgeable, fair and professional as any judge I have ever seen before.

[@Iseoluwa]

I honestly love her!

[@teresajose2280]

How many judges have you encountered? I only ask because I agree with you however I’ve literally never met a judge or been to court. lol. But I think she’s unbiased and fair as you said.

[@good104]

This judge knows that this is a high profile case. It is being televised. No wonder the judge is behaving very professionally. Most judges are arrogant, obnoxious and unprofessional given that most of what they do or say has a broad immunity and almost no checks and balances.

[@_yuri]

@@good104 all cases being public wont hurt just saying

[@good104]

@@_yuri The rules are different in each state. Besides, it doesn't make a difference. Most judges are unprofessional. Try to sit through one case. And watch what I'm saying here.

[@sassj7417]

"You're just a snarkey guy!" Legend😲 My new go to phrase 😀

[@lovingmayberry307]

Amber's lawyer, Elaine, is writing down everything TMZ's lawyer says, thinking: "I wish i was that smart!"

[@patriciaacosta5420]

AH is shitting bricks because she knows she is involved

[@valeriaproductions]

I think she thought she could just sleepwalk through this and that everyone would believe her.

[@vant4u]

Goddamnit amber... Stop shitting everywhere.. she's like a cat ...

[@frumpusnumpus]

@@valeriaproductions I also don't think she anticipated the amount of attention this case would garner. She miscalculated every single step.

[@gulfportflamefighter4545]

That is gonna hurt 😢

[@cincyfanjunglecity9871]

well Amber did say , and they had it on tape , that no one , nor a judge or jury , would believe that a "man" was abused. Of course she thought she was going to win this. I'm so glad that she's on the losing end here. Even if Johnny loses the court case , he's still win overall. Hell have his good name back , and hopefully we'll see him in more movies like Pirates of The Caribbean .

[@happyrose6168]

WoW! This judge is handling this three ring circus with such respect and class. Kudos.

[@donnabarney640]

I can't believe everybody has not burst out laughing all day, everyday.

[@Bronnybronny]

I’ve never seen a defense team scramble SO MUCH just to get their “point” across…. I mean this is embarrassing!!!!

[@lmsteller9736]

TMZ using the term “journalist” cracks me up!

[@natashaphipps402]

Reaching, lmao 😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 she really doesn’t want this in because she knows she leaked it, that’s why heards team are fighting so hard to stop it 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄

[@SHALALATELOVER]

I love how we are all in agreement about how much we love this judge! ❤️ I hope she realizes how much people appreciate her! ☺️

[@amymoquin8636]

The ladies were the stars of this court drama for all the right AND all the wrong reasons. Judge Penny and Queen Camille have demonstrated intelligence, poise, class and kindness. While Elaine basically tanked her own career and embarrassing herself. I would feel empathy for her if she wasn't representing the most vile woman I've ever seen outside of a psychological thriller like the movie Gone Girl. That brings us to Amber. It's bad enough what she put Johnny Depp through but my loathing I have for her is on behalf of women who have been abused, murdered or disfigured by their life partner. She has basically spit in the faces of real victims and survivors. The same way she stole her former assistant's very personal story of her sexual assault and actually stole that woman's story and used it as if it happened to her. Disgusting. I think she has Munchausen's.

[@richarddavis8083]

Elaine along with her co-counsel still have their night court career....no need to feel sorry, they've had 15 minutes of fame, they'll just have to live with what they did for a fee (Did AH pay up front, or pledge a fee. Hope it wasn't a case of "We don't get paid until you do" That's not going to work out too well.) Money grabbers more often then not lose at trial. Hence the lawyers creed: "We never lost a case" We'll settle and take our 35% fee since since we're crappy at litigation and ĺose most of all our trials.

[@vickieparry3168]

She admitted TMZ has been Alerted already. She open the Door

[@yolandadesa250]

A thousand salutes n a standing ovation to this Hon'ble Judge who is excellent in her job who is honest, intelligent, sharp with immense legal acumen & unbiased to the core. God bless this Hon'ble Judge with abundance of health to deliver justice.

[@tiamieaton1952]

She’s a force to be reckoned with for sure! What an amazing, impressive woman!! If it wasn’t for losing a magnificent judge, we should put her in the White House!!!

[@cappsginny699]

*honorable

[@clovis-]

@@cappsginny699 not every tongue is english

[@lancheloth]

Aamiin

[@cassidydunn3218]

@@cappsginny699 *correct yourself and leave them be...smh

[@AnnexF]

I love this Judge! So intelligent, the lawyers trying hard to press their argument but the Judge puts them in their place!

[@Stubbla]

I'm sorry Ben... But that had me in STITCHES AHAHAHAH!!! '' Good morning, your after'' LOL

[@lloydmunga4961]

The fact that TMZ's lawyer is there proves one thing. He wouldn't be there if he didnt have to protect their source

[@Juliamay67]

The second he said TMZ has journalistic privilege, that should have been the end of it. Lol.

[@dhaa1973]

"Goodmorning your after...-uuh good afternoon your honor" 🤣 gold

[@adriennewong4020]

She's fair, patient, polite, has a very good disposition, gives an ear to all requests by both parties, very even tempered. EXCELLENT Judge ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

[@sp3lly]

Guy who is not a party to the case wants to know if he can object while witness gives testimony 🙄🙄🙄🙄

[@yessssiiirrr]

Lmao

[@destinationwaleswithskylar9575]

Lol

[@seguleubena5594]

Lol😀😀😀😀

[@ruthlavayen13]

😝

[@VarsshaC]

Why is he talking then?

[@flykitty9516]

I have a huge respect for this Judge! It's not an easy case but she really handles everything very carefully.

[@Korcasandromedaa]

well that is her job! That's what she chose for a career after getting out of the Marines.

[@marshamariner7897]

@@Korcasandromedaa 😂🤣😅💖🌹

[@Iamedsmum]

I could watch, and listen to, this Judge 24/7. Her humour, impartiality and knowledge is immense. Oh for a few Judges of her humanity here in the UK.

[@masomakhawari1498]

Vivu

[@masomakhawari1498]

Under

[@masomakhawari1498]

Vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvcvvvvh

[@masomakhawari1498]

Vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvcvvvvhv

[@cozmarine7771]

You can say that again. We’ve become more corrupt since Johnson and crew took control.

[@lalicortez2985]

The way she shooed Elaine off like a fussy toddler. 😂😂😂 I love this lady judge she's a national treasure

[@heatherwild350]

This judge needs a raise. So intelligent, patient and thoughtful. Love hearing her arguments.

[@jillharvey578]

or inducted into Sainthood

[@gulfportflamefighter4545]

She is paid pretty good already

[@truthbomber7628]

Hardly needs a raise. The working people need a raise.

[@heatherwild350]

@@truthbomber7628 so true...I'm with on that. Not a 1% elitist here. I am a true proletariat. Workers of the world unite!

[@sarahtaylor7737]

I’m sure she’s not needing money. She probably does just fine.