YT54 Surah Al-Kahf(Surah 18):Does God Sit on a Throne? Throne of Queen of Sheba.Abrogation in Quran

[@Choosensols2324]

Allahu-Akbar , i remember this was the first video from marvelous Quran i came across as i was watching quran 101 guess what happened? It sent series of shocks in my heart and mind which in turn gave me sleepless night. It forced me to take wudhu and start praying to Allah swt to guide me as well as giving me courage to get back and watch it. I remember it was 2yrs ago 2:00am. I Thank Allah swt so much for revealing all this through your effort and make me beneficiary of such a mind flourishing sweet knowledge.

[@afshanbaig2461]

Multiple views of the videos is very helpful in solidifying the information and slowly cause changes in the ‘schema’

[@sinamehrparvar]

Dear Dr. I wanna just share my experience as i said in previous episodes about what I experienced in my life after knowing the true essence of Quran and after accidentally watching one of your videos and starting to watch them all afterwards from the beginning to the end , My whole life changed , I literally experienced what ever you said here in this video and videos after this in my real life and how step by step slowly but surely my worldview changed and it came such a long way from where it was before knowing the methodology ... Now I am saying this as a person who applied this methodology , this way of thinking , this way of looking to the world in every aspect of your-life literally in everything you do or think about , We came to the truths of our world that where intentionally hidden from us and we were lied about even about the universe and the earth that we live in ... I just wanna say that this is the methodology for life , learn it from the Quran and apply it both in learning the truth from the Quran and make this methodology this way of seeing the world your life style , Believe me miracles would happen every day for you , Quran and the universe are one together , just follow and seek the evidence based knowledge as in the methodology and be patient , don't rush into conclusion in search of the truth and always ask god the source of all knowledge for the truth and guidance , then you will be amazed that how magnificently you will be guided every-time if آلله wills it. May everyone of us stand by the truth even if we are alone ... Thank you Dr.Hanny , before i watched this video I experienced it and now I really understands how god help us in our own subconscious through the Arsh in Quran through this video... And about the how can we help - we live in country ( I don't want to say the name here ) that People Just hate Religious and culture worldview rejects anything that contradicts what they think , so Because of this ( if you will ) I want to share with you via email the detailed obstacle that is in front of us in spreading the knowledge and get some help from you in how to approach and spreading the word , in other word their cognitive readiness and acceptance is not a in a state that would allow them to see the truth ...

[@acesaleem8934]

Yours is a mammoth task alhamdulillaah may Allah give you good health to continue doing this great service

[@peerallyshakeel8586]

People with crude or hateful comments should be ignored !! This is the best way to react because they are unintelligent people. Just say « salam and pass your way >>

[@ishqnoor]

Thank you! The knowledge you are sharing is destroying so many of my doubts, and building for the first time a thirst for and Love of The Quran, Alhamdulillah. May Allah reward you with His best rewards and empower you to continue spreading this crucial information, aamin ya Rab 🤲

[@MarvelousQuran]

AAmeen. Thank you

[@daintierhype4332]

Alhamdulillah, this is one of my favourite segment.

[@aarunsan2721]

I've come back to this segment many times and always learning new things. Amazing Intepretations as always.

[@sambacisse9537]

Greetings from Sénégal ( french speaker) This is the best interpretation of abrogation and Al arch i have ever heard. When we TANCHIROU FIL ARD with this concept it fits perfectly 😊 Thanks for sharing this ilm that change our worldview and allow us to have the proper understanding of some verses of the quran Allah bless you

[@baylatyqalifa4932]

Dr. hany i am very grateful to Allah, for my being part of this marvelous Quran channel, actually the meaning of the word عرش never sit well with me, it baffles me before coming to marvelous Quran yt, now by breaking it with different psychological meaning, the word عرش has been un shrouded as far to the هور, the scheme, framework, or mental constitution, weltanschauung all of these descriptions are enough, chritalclear, after known this i am now cleansing most of the erroneous stuff in my عرش thank Dr. Hany

[@gbeauty709]

Dear Dr, firstly I would like to thank you with all my heart for taking the time to share your knowledge and understanding with us. The content of these videos as well as your analysis and explanation are truly gems and it is such a privilege to see you explore the deeper meanings and more accurate interpretations. I would also like to make a humble request, if I may. I beg you to please complete an English translation of the whole Quran as that would be a true gift to the world. Many existing translations are tainted by the limited intellect and superficial understandings of previous translators, and so I really beg that you complete a translation for us as soon as possible as that would be a true gift for us all to be able to come closer to the divine. I don’t expect you to have time to respond to this message, but please accept my sincerest greetings, my deepest thanks and of course my warmest wishes to you for your comprehensive and meaningful work, which is a real treat for us!

[@MarvelousQuran]

you are most welcome! It's an honor to have people such as yourself part of our community in As-Sarh. Please keep making Duaa for us and for the ummah Regards

[@anwarulislamamin8921]

It’s like blessing from Allah Subanahu Ta'ala to listen such descriptions and commentaries of the Holy Quran in a new dimension. May Allah Subanahu Ta'ala guide us All in right path.

[@FA069]

Dear Dr Hany.. I am speechless with every new topic you are posting. I keep imagining how much hard work has gone to bring this interpretation. Definitely its not an easy and quick task. Must have taken years. Few years back when I was not so inclined towards islamic teachings but I was studying Management along with my IT job. I was introduced to the Organizational behavior and cognitive Psychology during the term. When I started getting interested in Learning Quran started to feel that Psychology is one of the field which really helps to understand quran. I am amazed how Allah prepared me with knowledge of Software Engineering and other subjects unknowingly. Now when u use those jargons it quickly clicks to me. You don't know how much I appreciate and Thankful I am to Allah that I found your channel. Will try my best to share these concepts in my near being and further to my capacity. Awaiting for your video about samawaat and ard which u touched. It has already made me excited to understand from that perspective. Thanks very much.

[@ShabnoorMaved]

Salamun alaikum, Thank you for enriching my quran recitals; I am already starting to notice a difference in them now.. Alhamdulillah.. Only a person who has very deep belief, great regard, great confidence for Quran will be able to understand the way you are understanding. masha'Allah.. May Allah swt increase you in knowledge and understanding.. The schema you explained is also somewhat explained in Ibn Seena's book qanoon, from a physiology point of view.. That whatever impressions/sensations/feelings that you receive in your brain through your eyes, ears, nose, tongue and skin gets stored or to say forms impressions/feelings in a part of the brain, then there are other parts of the brain that recollects/corelate, interpret and brings conclusions, the next time we see, hear, feel, taste, smell the same again.. The brain is designed in such a way that it receives sensations and impressions, subhan'Allah.. And anyway all light, sound etc are waves and vibrations at the end.. Its what your mother/guardian labelled these impressions when we were growing up. (We only pray that the mother understood the correct definitions of all the names first). Thats why also they say the first best impressions.. And today we have just that, .. the children are made stuck to the computers.. And the parents are made busy making money.. So the the thoughts are now infected, like you rightly said. Gone are the times when we used to have people like ibn seena .. Who memorized the Quran by age of 9 and he was one of the renowned physicians by age of 18.. And like many other great scientists/people we had in around that era, where a single person excelled in multiple fields... Thats one of the reasons why we need to protect with the Quran first, and that too with correct understanding to avoid thought infections.. Thank you and best regards

[@oldiswisdom5535]

Amazing! If you watch again and again, every time you will meet full of surprises. Thank you Dr Hany.

[@nooruladhabaharom8155]

al-arash "throne" has been subjected of heated debate amongst muslim scholar. some followers of the two thought (the derivative thought that Allah can sit on throne as per making similar to human) even accused of "kafir" to each other, making people divided . This explanation of the meaning has more depth. thank you.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Alhamdulillah

[@azadehamighi9608]

DR. Hany Atchan , I am speechless about your hard work and willing helping people like me finally understand the concept of The Quran by watching your video lot of my questions being answer . Thank you and may Alahh be with you.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Alhamdulillah

[@hassanmarican5741]

Mashya Allah, JazakAllah khair.Its the scales falling of my eyes from blinkered n unreasonable tafseer .

[@salihtaysi]

This is the most referenced video in your whole collection, so alhamdulillah that I keep coming back to it!

[@AMRB-999]

" Where I trip is where the treasure is " 👌👌👌

[@muhammadismaeeljaumeer7755]

I always had this question of does God sit on a throne as many translators does translate it that way. This session is very much enjoyed and learned by me. Thank you very much Dr Hany and May Allah (SWT) bless you with good health.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Happy to hear. Thanks

[@mohdazizmohdsaad2864]

throne is for the creation All swt dont need the throne

[@abinehdikra376]

(1:10:00) ...and finally the King follow the "millah" of Ibrahim A.S, and put it above the law of the state.... Such a beautiful lecture, Dr Hany! Jazakallaah tabarakallaah!

[@MarvelousQuran]

We knew you'd like. Thanks

[@abinehdikra376]

@@MarvelousQuran ...and then this led me to 2:130 - 133. Any chances to hear about those soon, Dr Hany?

[@MarvelousQuran]

@Abine Hdikra Please connect via email. You touched on something only the Muttaqoon would know

[@abinehdikra376]

@@MarvelousQuran InsyaAllah, Dr Hany. Thank you for allowing me to get in touch with you via email.

[@MarvelousQuran]

@Abine Hdikra You mean via email... Not "more personal level". Correct?

[@reazulabrar9187]

The Quran is open to research,analysis and hence for afresh understanding for years to come till endtimes apart from traditional tafsirs made some two hundred years after the death of the Prophet Mohammad (pbuh).The Quran is not limited to a person or a group of persons to explain it .The Quran is self explanatory.Anybody trying to interpret the Quran must conform to how Allah(swt) explain it.

[@umersanaullahbaigbaig1154]

This video has educated me greatly, previously, i used to question the Tafseers of scholars as I was not satisfied with their explanation of different Quranic Ayahs. The void was difficult to bear and i was longing to know what actually Allah is telling me in Quran. I believe that many of my questions are being answered in your videos. You have and are doing a wonderful and much needed service to the cause of spreading the correct way of understanding Quran. Allah's Quran is truly a master piece that only Allah can give to mankind. Being a non-arabic speaking person, your videos are the medicine for my incorrect understanding of Quran. Don't think i can ever stop listening to your channel. Thanks and Best Regards

[@abdulnasir4589]

Ma Sha Allahh, this session is indeed a treasure for those willing to be open minded and wholeheartedly ready to embrace the truth from Allahh

[@drmdzakariahmdali6677]

Alhamdulillah. Allah doesn’t need throne. 1 thousand year issue and dispute among Muslims settled.

[@Yasiin181]

It makes perfect sense, May Allah guide us to the right path.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Alhamdulillah

[@rabuanmantine8522]

Alhamdulillah, this new knowledge changes the way we understand the translations and tafsir

[@MarvelousQuran]

Alhamdulillah. Hopefully for the better

[@baqyway-starttounderstandt5680]

MasyaAllah. Alhamdulillah. Thank you for a very refreshing approach towards understanding the Quran

[@MarvelousQuran]

Alhamdulillah

[@studentofquran7508]

Alhumdulilah. Keep up the good work!

[@musahahmed8327]

It keeps getting Very insightful after every watch. Masha Allah ❤

[@jasbirbhag8908]

New insights making more sense. Certainly illuminate my arsh. May Allah guide all.tqvm. can never thanks enough for ur hard work.

[@sultrys2291]

Thank you again. As someone who doesn't understand Arabic and depends on translation, this is extremely great. I pray the tafsir of Al Quran will be going along this way in the near future. Amin.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Our pleasure! Plz remember the Request at the end of the video

[@PakistaniHomemakerInCanada]

I was driving while listening to this and the end part re the sama coming down through the valleys all of a sudden reminded me of neural pathways in our brains along which information passes! Subhanallah.

[@zubedamoosa9995]

Thank you for this treasure, May the Almighty help you in helping us learn more about this methodology Peace and blessings

[@MarvelousQuran]

You are most welcome

[@alhassanediallo966]

Amen yarabal Allamen

[@lexluthor5605]

Beutyful...I watched 2 times...

[@goodwordsonly]

This channel is full of treasures mashaaAllah. Thank you Dr Hany for the courage and discipline for continuing this important work. 🤲🏼 Rabbi zidni 3ilman

[@Jon-br2db]

Thank you soooo muchhh Dr. Hany for such a beautiful explanation and translation.❤

[@sivasrao3307]

Hello Dr., May I get the explanation of ayah completely Surah Al-A’raf: 54 & Az-Zumar: 75. Excellent cognizance and well explanation of Weltanschauung(3arsh). It made sense regarding the meanings of 3arsh = Weltanschauung, Shams = Source of illumination(Messenger), 3ardh = Scripture, Samaa = Layer of understanding, Ma’a = Devine Knowledge. Want to understand Qamar, Layl & Nahar, Sittha ayyaam, Malaaikath who are bringing & around the Weltanschauung in order to understand the complete ayah of 7:54 & 39:75 Thank you so much for your priceless efforts to preserve the Quran & Islam. May God protect & give you good health.

[@SarveshTalekar77]

It fitted so smooth!! subhanAllah

[@hashimahismail5272]

Alhamdulillah... Thank you for all the work that you are doing for the ummah, in the true understanding of the Quran

[@MarvelousQuran]

Alhamdulillah

[@affandi6969]

Mashallah. Awakened questions revealing hidden gems of interpretation. Thank you.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Alhamdulillah

[@Alliadt]

I don't understand Arabic. But my 'arsh' seems to fit more in your explanation of the holy Quran. May Allah keep the sanctity of Allah's verses by giving us all the correct mindset.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Welcome to As-Sarh my bro (or sis)

[@propertysensei4447]

My eyes are full of tears of joy by watching your presentation. Amazing, excellent , beautiful scientific explanation of what it was not clear to me. you made it a piece of cake mashaAllah. May Allah swt reward you the way he rewarded his messengers. Dr Hoori from London

[@MarvelousQuran]

We knew you would like it. Alhamdulillah Regards

[@davidvargas5277]

Alhumdullilah! Thank you Dr.hany once again for whatever you had to sacrifice to share this knowledge.salamun walaikum .I really needed this today.This is helping me.

[@rukeahallapiche4102]

This is my second time listening to get a better understanding. In Sha Allah I understand a little better than the first time. I may need to listen many more times. I don't speak or understand Arabic so I depend totally on translation. This lesson recall my course in psychology and psychiatry. I feel cheated with the original translation. I cannot understand how Allah can make a mistake and have to rectify the verse of the quran. Alhamdulillah now my concerns are answered . The quran is a book of knowledge not fairy-tale.

[@sulehria8341]

This was amazing.. I always thought there was deeper meaning to the word Arsh and this definitely has changed my Weltanschauung. Thank you for this wonderful explanation.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Happy to hear. Thank you

[@anggasugih5303]

syaikh... could you make explanation on suratul fatiha?

[@MarvelousQuran]

Insha Allahh

[@MrSaliheenm]

Extraordinary peace of work, again your are very beneficial person to me. Keep continuing the marvelous work which you are doing. Don't worry about the trollers. They are every ware. Ignore them. All these yes I used to say to the others that "Arsh" is Symbolic not Physical. Here you are explaining what that symbol really mean is. I agree, Alhamdu Lillah. My advice : Yes I downloaded all your videos. Please open a group in Telegram in case......

[@MarvelousQuran]

Alhamdulillah

[@izufami]

Lets change our arash today.

[@sheikhahmadmushtaq9406]

They have been reinforcing the irony of five senses rather transcending. Hence a physical Arush while it is just mental a belief system.

[@nassiriabraham7002]

Masha ALLAH, its just mind blowing if you can see between the lines, If ALLAH guides you none can mislead you and I pray to ALLAH to guide us to His Quraan. The early scholars as you can see they have not done their home work but only mislead us to believe none senese. they even made our life miserable by filling our weltenshchuung corrupted beliefs.

[@mohammadjavid3066]

It is obvious why people have objected these videos because they don’t know what the word evidence is

[@MarvelousQuran]

Since you seem to know, why don't you teach us what evidence means ACCORDING TO THE QURAN?

[@AbdulBari066]

Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh. Jazakumullah Khair for explaining these beautiful signs. It literally hit my mind. Every ayah is Soo interweaved with each other. Subha ALLAH!!!

[@MarvelousQuran]

That's the Quran operating on you like software

[@AbdulBari066]

@@MarvelousQuran INDEED!! ❤️

[@nasimaziz]

This gives another perspective to Sura Hud 11:7 - He is the One Who created the heavens and the earth in six Days1-and His Throne was upon the waters-in order to test which of you is best in deeds. And if you ˹O Prophet˺ say, “Surely you will ˹all˺ be raised up after death,” the disbelievers will certainly say, “That is nothing but pure magic!”.

[@mdnadeemkhan1768]

Alhamdulillah for the lights.......

[@EngineerF-94]

Salamunaalikum Dr. The way this produces a negation is truly astonishing. Is there a source where I can learn more about (the morphology of) creating such forms such as shown here i.e., nastansaq from Ansaq? Thank you ❤

[@shirazrehmani645]

Thank you for this very informative segment; I learnt a lot about the application of the methodology. One question: The "Certainty Principle" which forms part of the methodology; does this refer to the confidence we have in some knowledge for example in the reverence and eminence of Allahh SWT from which we come to the certainty that He would never imply a particular meaning of a word. Also to an action which cannot possibly be ascribed to Him due to His Glory and Greatness.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Yes, correct. Also, the certainty that the Quran is from Allahh, is complete, and is preserved... Why? Because the Quran itself says that. I know this sounds like a circular argument (to a logician) but it is not... If we do not start by accepting that every single aya is accurate, then there is no sense to engaging any part of the Quran. And there are several clear ayas that assure us of the certainty principle. Regards

[@oraclemedia9266]

I LOVE THIS!!!!!!! Thank you very much!!!!!!!!

[@majidsiddiqui2906]

Splendid lecture. Scary that not many others have analysed the language of the Quran this way.

[@MarvelousQuran]

@Imer Redzovic You are experiencing detoxification... A painful period during which a wayfarer realizes the size of the calamity that we have been suffering for 1200 years... Take time to grieve my brother. Allow this to sink in. Re-watch the last several videos to allow the Quran to change you like software ... May Allahh help us all! We have a lot of work to do!

[@majidsiddiqui2906]

@Imer Redzovic Hi. You may already know that many Quranic passages have duel meanings. The good Dr has highlighted just a few. I personally don’t think you have to reject one set of meanings to accept the other. Like you I find it hard to beleive that Allah would allow the ummah to be misguided for 1200 years. Also remember these quranic passages are not articles of faith there interpretation does not affect your islam (I mean the 5 Arkaan that make you a muslim) Most of the Dr’s atguments are really aimed at scholars and those that already have a good understanding of the history and context of the revalation. Me I listen and reserve judgment.

[@MarvelousQuran]

@Imer Redzovic @ Majid Siddiqui With all due respect to scholars, there are many people who are not scholars but are more ready to receive divine guidance. Everything we present in this channel will have no effect on someone whose Qalb is locked up, be it scholar or not. When it comes to Quranic stories, there cannot be dual meanings. Either you derive your understanding from the Quran, and learn the correct story, or you derive your understanding from corrupted sources, and the story you end up with IS WRONG!

[@majidsiddiqui2906]

@@MarvelousQuran Yes you are right. With regard to the stories documented in the Quran, there can be only be one true record of events. It would intersting to know from you why Allah has made it so difficult then, for what seems to me to be the majority of people, to make head and tail of certain parts of these quranic stories? I know we can point to possibly human lazziness but besides this there must be some wisdom in it.

[@MarvelousQuran]

@Majid Siddiqui Very good question... We answered it partially in this video kzbin.info/www/bejne/iZWafoOcfa2FgKs In upcoming videos we will provide a lot more details about the nature of the Quran and the specifics of the methodology... We have barely started, and this is a long term engagement. And I really, really hope that you remain patient and open to receive... I promise you, As-Sarh is REALLY worth it. Please watch this video kzbin.info/www/bejne/mZ-adX16lLKVrLc, this video kzbin.info/www/bejne/fpqQkpqqg7aUh6M and this video kzbin.info/www/bejne/eYSbqIhoqbxoppY , to allow the Quran to act on you like software, so that you could keep receiving insha Allahh

[@YeeHaaification]

MashaAllah. SubhanAllah. I am glad that Allah gives me the opportunity to stumble upon this channel.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Welcome! Plz watch other videos. Happy to have you

[@mohamedaslam3325]

Salamun Alaik ! Glad to hav found this channel. Amazing work Dr.Hany.. Eagerly waiting for more videos and explanations!

[@MarvelousQuran]

Salaamun Alaykum. Thanks for your comment. Welcome aboard. Plz watch the other videos, because they build on each other. Regards

[@shariqashraf1172]

WOW ! Alhamdulilah!

[@Yahya___]

Timestamps: 0:00 Intro 0:46 Important Points to Consider Before Proceeding 1:36 In This Segment 2:18 Key Term: Yusr (يُسْر) 6:45 From Cognitive Psychology 11:28 Examples of Frameworks/Schemas in Action 20:50 Does the QurꜤān Address the Concept of Framework/Schema? 22:42 Āya 22: 52 25:26 What is “أُمْنِيَّتِهِ”? 29:51 Examples of Concatenating Two Words into A Single Word 35:59 Āya 22:52 (Cont.) 37:56 Is There Abrogation نَسْخ? What About Āya 45: 29? 41:41 A Brief Lesson in Naḥuu (Arabic Grammar) 44:50 Āya 45: 29 (Cont.) 47:45 Āya 2:106 (The Famous Āya About Abrogation) 52:27 What About Al-Ɛarsh (throne)? 57:41 Al-Ɛarsh - Example 1 1:09:00 Al-Ɛarsh - Example 2-4 1:13:31 Al-Ɛarsh - Example 5-6: How Does God Provide Us Direct Guidance? 1:19:15 Al-Ɛarsh - Example 7 1:22:07 Gift - Āya 94:5-6 1:23:14 Why Didn't the Earlier Scholars Develop this Ɛilm? 1:25:22 How Can You Help? 1:26:53 Outro

[@MarvelousQuran]

Thank you very much. Uploaded

[@ilyassuri]

Remarkable work. Excellent narration so absorbing, thought-provoking and conclusive. Thank you Dr. Hani. Jazak Allah. It is good that English language is used for presentations in order to reach out to global audience. Please advise if there are additional tools that non Arabs can use?

[@nfaza80]

40:30 I believe the statement "Why does Allah NEED a record? Allah has perfect knowledge so Allah doesn't NEED records. Therefore, the 'record interpretation' is wrong." has downsides. What if I say this: "Did Allah NEED the Angels? Allah doesn't NEED Angels to do the tasks and Allah can take care of the world by Himself ('himself' in here doesn't mean gender, of course) alone. So therefore Allah didn't create Angels and the conventional interpretation is wrong." I believe that Allah doesn't need to need things to create that thing. Please elaborate on this. And also, I've read about hadith from Ibn Mas'ood explaining the size of Kursiy and the Arsh (narrated by Ibn Khuzaymah in al-Tawheed, p. 105; by al-Bayhaqi in al-Asmaa’ wa’l-Sifaat, p. 401). How do we fit the meaning of "weltanschauung" in terms of size of comparison to the Kursiy and the seven heavens? I really want to know the truth and don't have the intention to debate.

[@MarvelousQuran]

The video is clear. we are taking about a specific term misinterpreted by the interpreters Please watch the video again. You missed several major points. Clearly you have not watched the whole video

[@bornfreealways1199]

Thank you Dr. Very informative.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Welcome

[@ibnharun86]

Alhamdulillah and thank you!

[@theguidingbeacon]

Salamun Alaiykum, Dr. Hany, I pray that you are in the best of health, wealth, and content. Where may I find the content regarding the 4 types of Jannaat?

[@iancxxx]

Thank you for this detailed information so much to "unpack" so many mis interpretation in our mind to review and reform. May Allah SWT reward you greatly and grant you increase in knowledge and wisdom. May Allah SWT take away all misconceptions & misinterpretation of the Quran away from our collective understanding.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Aameen

[@greathope6433]

Thank you. this is real treasure

[@MarvelousQuran]

You're very welcome

[@yeyo4281]

Awesomee 💯

[@SA-sb7rt]

Salam Hard to understand 😓 Masha allah your knowledge Have to watch it again . May Allah reward you brother And yes......... will definitely download Insha allah

[@MarvelousQuran]

Thanks and welcome

[@moondvst4131]

Subhanallah

[@thanhcarmen4623]

Noted very well that Shariah law, law of God comes from Al- Arch (a system of perception, judgement, understanding, culture)

[@md.chandalikhan722]

ALHAMDULILLAH ALL TIME.❤

[@mohammadjavid3066]

It’s strange what hudhud said people are worshiping sun is true today majority of Muslims take Muhammad SWAS as sun and are they worshiping him?

[@ishtiaqmiraj1853]

Dear Dr. Hany, I think the Imams of the madahib and many other scholars especially late in Umayyad and Abbasid rules, started their scholarly career to interpret the Qur'an, not just to explain rules, regulations and legislations of Islam. They were torchered and thrown to prison whenever the rulers' weltanshaung got exposed and faced threats. I think many interpretations got burned and destroyed, so people who are raising questions about how come 1400 years!, they are missing these historical facts. And after Abbasids, everything started to fall apart for Muslims as a unified nation. Yes, there were more glorified times afterwards during Fatemids, Ottomans, Mughals but they weren't representing almost nothing from Islam. May Allah protect you and others who are striving in the same path.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Yes definitely. We never accused everyone of bad intention, or of even not trying. In this video, kzbin.info/www/bejne/n3uzYpKsraeNnpo , we clearly stated that, had any scholar veered off from the officially sanctioned line re. the Quran Tafseer, they would risk loosing their head. Literally. Alhamdulillah

[@ishtiaqmiraj1853]

Yes, accusing anybody will do no good.

[@jandajumper7660]

Alhamdulillah

[@jostnamane3951]

Salam alaikum Dr. Hany. Can you explain the Hadith that talks about GOD coming down to the lowest heaven every last third of the night, using your methodology? I have some ideas about what it means after watching your series on what 7 heavens means, but I cannot express it.

[@sheikhrishad879]

What is Kufr Dr. Hany??? What constitutes idol worship and what kind of idol worship is prohibited??? Please answer my questions Sir...

[@MarvelousQuran]

Check my private channel. There are hours of videos discussing shirk

[@umersanaullahbaigbaig1154]

I have one question. In this video you mentioned about the divine guidance coming down as rain and flowing and irrigating/correcting our cognitive understanding etc, Can we also take another commonly believed meaning that Allah is indirectly also education us on the water cycle?

[@aq_ahmed]

This is a big mental shift. Ok, by re-adjusting our weltanschauung and using Abrahamic Locution & Nesting techniques, can we come up with some explanation regarding the "Arsh" in verses 39 & 40 of An-Naml (chapter 27)? Because these verses seem to talk about a transportation of some sort of object in the least amount of time before the Queen arrives.

[@MarvelousQuran]

In the video, I said that the throne was NOT transported because it is not physical... I also asked you not to ask more about the transportation, because there is no transportation. But still, I will address your question... The one with knowledge of the book "figured out" how her Weltanschauung has been corrupted, by reverse engineering the book, i.e., reflecting on what concepts she could have misunderstood. "Nakkiroo laha 3arshah" means "figure out the holes in her Weltanschauung, so that we can show her the inconsistencies in it when she arrives", and that's why when she "saw" it, she said "It's almost it", meaning, you understand our Weltanschauung. etc, etc, etc... Then the fallacies in her Weltanschauung were explained, she exposed "her legs" and As-Sarh was presented to her by unraveling the Qawareer, and she became a follower of Sulayman... Kinda what we do on this channel, right?

[@aq_ahmed]

@@MarvelousQuran That makes sense Dr. The learned man was expert on the social and spiritual culture (Arsh) of those communities. When she was presented in detail the way they go about in life, she confessed to it. Very reasonable. Thanks keep the doing the good work. May Allah grant us all "yusr" in our endeavour.

[@MarvelousQuran]

@Abdulqadir A Ahmed (You changed your screen name to Sword of Allahh!!!) That "mental shift" you mentioned at the beginning of your comment above... This is the Quran acting on you as software... This is what happened with the Queen of Sheba.

[@khawajaumer2164]

Salamun Alaykum! You have beautifully done the linguistic analysis of Ayah 22:52. In my opinion, by extension it goes for all the people who are wishing/wished to get the knowledge through the Quran. As for messengers and prophets, Allah has clearly mentioned that He abrogated whatever Shaytan cast during this process. I always remain in fear of this Shaytan's/Human's interference that could disrupt my process of seeking knowledge from Allah through the Quran. What should a person do so that these casts could be nullify? Is there any way to cross check it?

[@moz2010ify]

Salaam Alaykum Doctor, jazakaAllah for your great lectures. When I you going to publish your English translation of the Quran? Meanwhile which translation/s are your recommending?

[@naimaamghar818]

Al7amdoelillahh Al7amdoelillahh Al7amdoelillahh!

[@khwajazakriya9769]

Salaamun Alaykum Alhamdulillah

[@elmernarrazid3160]

Yes indeed,the word of Allah is perfect..man's perspective is limited..May the Lord of the worlds grant us clear understanding.alhamdulillah..

[@aq_ahmed]

Native Arabs must be tearing their heads up!

[@MarvelousQuran]

Arabic speakers in general... Not just pulling their hair!

[@sultanmahmood6396]

I am curious why my Quran is spelled this way? Dr Hany . قَالَ ابْنَ أُمَّ إِنَّ الْقَوْمَ اسْتَضْعَفُونِ “Son of my mother, the people overpowered me, قَالَ ابْنَ أُمَّ إِنَّ الْقَوْمَ اسْتَضْعَفُونِ______________________________________________20:94 قَالَ ابْنَ أُمَّ إِنَّ الْقَوْمَ اسْتَضْعَفُونِي وَكَادُوا يَقْتُلُونَنِي فَلَا تُشْمِتْ بِيَ الْأَعْدَاءَ وَلَا تَجْعَلْنِي مَعَ الْقَوْمِ الظَّالِمِينَ 7:150

[@basrialimi6557]

Dr, I need the video about ardh, how it means a scripture in Abrahamic Locution. TQ

[@MarvelousQuran]

Plz watch kzbin.info/www/bejne/gqPbZK2ai7qWjZo

[@basrialimi6557]

Dr. What about Kursi, does it mean chair?

[@MarvelousQuran]

No. Insha Allahh we will deal with this in the future

[@baruasafi5880]

Mash'Allah brother. Keep it up.

[@ainaltair3217]

Yesss!!! We have been talking about improving our understanding and engagement with the Quran. Unfortunately, most people think that if they question, contemplate and look at it differently than the traditional understanding then you are a deviant. So, these days we see new movement where people go 'Quran Only'. I am sure there will be some limitations with it, nonetheless, they have made popular the new understanding of 'daraba' and 'hureen' as far I know. Slowly, but surely, InshaAllah will lead to a higher understanding.

[@azmans65]

Sitting on the throne -18min Abrogation ayat 25:52. Al-Arsh = worldview, mental constitution, weltanschauung. Thank you very much dear Brother.

[@MarvelousQuran]

Alhamdulillah... Good grasp... Remember what I asked you to do... Regards

[@ashrafalvee7382]

Assalamu'alaikum.I am confused. I am illiterate regarding these but sir, how can you disregard 1400+ years of scholarly tradition so nonchalantly? Whereas our Prophet ﷺ said that the Ummah will not agree on falsehood meaning the majority of the scholars will be right. Please clear the confusion. And what about the interpretations that came from The Scholar of The Ummah,Ibn Abbas رضي الله عنه himself?

[@MarvelousQuran]

Salaamun Alaykum my bro (sis). The more you watch of our videos, the more clear the answers will become. Plz keep watching

[@ashrafalvee7382]

@Imer Redzovic you are making kiyas on Allah,you are thinking Allah is like us,the humans.No! Allah is 'Unique'.There is 'nothing' like Him.Whatever tashbeeh we make about Allah other than what is in the Quran and the Sunnah will be Wrong. Allah and His Attributes are beyond our scope of imagination. Allah hears and so do humans.Does that mean He has ears and eardrums and organs like us? Of course not! So we affirm Allah's attributes according to what He and His Messenger ﷺ tells us.And that is called the belief in the Unseen.Barak Allahu fikum.

[@MarvelousQuran]

@Imer Redzovic In the video, we explained that "3ala" does not mean "physical upon." Upon that we used in our translation indicates "by", and therefore "His Weltanschauung is repaired by Allahh "by" the divine water that comes down from Allahh"... See for example, Aya 11:56: My lord is "upon" a straight way! Please follow up by email, and do not HIDE your questions within replies to comments, so that we could help you in the best way!

[@ashrafalvee7382]

@Imer Redzovic sorry brother,I could be wrong in understanding your point.I apologize.But you have asked that why would perfection need a throne.Allah is beyond any needs.He does not the throne.It is just another creation of His Majesty.This is what I am saying.You are subconsciously applying human logic to the Unseen.This throne,a creation of Allah Azzawajal is not like you see in this world.It is beyond our knowledge.That is why just be on the safe side.If we keep thinking about the Unseen Realm beyond what has been revealed,Shaytan will trap us with doubts.We will see Allah Azzawajal one day.Till then we should do what we are told to do.Our attitude towards these ambiguous verses should be like the Sahabas and they were the best of the generations.

[@yasfi5196]

@@ashrafalvee7382 I can understand what you feel, brother. However, I always consider this kind of 'new' interpretation as an another opinion or 'ijtihad'. As you may already know, there were different opinions regarding tafseer since the classical era of Islam and this is just another one.. And of course, leave the true meaning to Allah is the safer way. However, I believe that there are several interpretations that have been addressed to sahabah like Ibn Abbas ra. but actually those came from the israiliyat sources. And this is a fact.

[@Hatim_Khan]

Can you please correct for us the schema of Record-Keeping to understand the concept of KIRAM AL KATIBEEN

[@MarvelousQuran]

@Hatim Khan "Kiraman Katibeen" (from Aya 82:11) refers to the purified angels who write... The question is: Write what, and where? We answered this question in the video when we translated "Nastansikhu" = "We have been having others (i.e., the angels, or humans) strengthen all that you used to work (of terminology in your worldview)." Obvious, right? They are not keeping a record on behalf of Allahh. They are abrogating your own Weltanschauung...

[@cb30dm40]

jazakallah khair . i just want to ask that after listening your detailed explanation in light of quranic methodology can we relate the word عرش to the word شعور i dont know if this is an arabic word but in urdu we use word شعور as the mental framework

[@MarvelousQuran]

Masha Allahh. Very good observation... However, the two terms are not related enough to provide any evidenc. It's true that some Arabic gerunds with common letters are sometimes related in meaning, but this type of evidence is not reliable enough for our methodology Regards

[@yasinosmanfadal2705]

(هُوَ ٱلَّذِیۤ أَنزَلَ عَلَیۡكَ ٱلۡكِتَـٰبَ مِنۡهُ ءَایَـٰتࣱ مُّحۡكَمَـٰتٌ هُنَّ أُمُّ ٱلۡكِتَـٰبِ وَأُخَرُ مُتَشَـٰبِهَـٰتࣱۖ فَأَمَّا ٱلَّذِینَ فِی قُلُوبِهِمۡ زَیۡغࣱ فَیَتَّبِعُونَ مَا تَشَـٰبَهَ مِنۡهُ ٱبۡتِغَاۤءَ ٱلۡفِتۡنَةِ وَٱبۡتِغَاۤءَ تَأۡوِیلِهِۦۖ وَمَا یَعۡلَمُ تَأۡوِیلَهُۥۤ إِلَّا ٱللَّهُۗ وَٱلرَّ ٰ⁠سِخُونَ فِی ٱلۡعِلۡمِ یَقُولُونَ ءَامَنَّا بِهِۦ كُلࣱّ مِّنۡ عِندِ رَبِّنَاۗ وَمَا یَذَّكَّرُ إِلَّاۤ أُو۟لُوا۟ ٱلۡأَلۡبَـٰبِ) [Surah Aal-E-Imran 7]

[@muhammadayed231]

I think the interpretations you bring forward sometimes look ok but they don't fit everywhere. The Quran is in بلسان عربي مبين, so how come people have not interpreted the Quran in 1400 years? If you explain more about Arsh, some things don’t make sense at all, when you explained about the arsh of Sheba, why you didn’t interpret the conversation of Sulaiman AS when asking the people sitting in front of him “who will bring me her arsh?” One of the strong Jinn offered that he’ll bring before He stands up from his place and another having knowledge from scripture said that I’ll bring it before you blink your eyes, so the question is did Sulaiman AS ask to bring her weltanschauung? And when she arrived, He asked her أهكذا عرشك قالت كأنه هو, did she see her weltanschauung? Is it something physically seen and touched ? it’s not proper to put weltanschauung in the Quran. How you’ll explain ويحمل عرش ربك فوقهم يومئذ ثمانية and translate? And the weltanschauung of your Lord will be carried above them on that day by eight? وترى الملائكة حافين من حول العرش Translation of the verse And you shall see the angels encircling the weltanschauung exalting with the praise of their Lord

[@imambasit1732]

Salaamoon Alaykum, Please can you bring exposure to Quran (10: 2) w.r.t “samaawaat wal Ardh fii sitat ayyaamin”.. “suma istawaaa aela L Aersh”