zack snyder fans then vs. now

[@eyesack2007]

guys you can’t criticize this video yet, we gotta wait for the man carrying thing cut to release

[@LuisSierra42]

The Man Cut

[@gazem_3211]

​@@LuisSierra42Man?! Is he stouid?

[@tonolinus]

no amount of gore will save this video.

[@ChristianSandviknes]

The man carrying cut.

[@ultrabigfella]

It's so funny how this argument is said every time he makes a new movie. Eventually you have to wonder why every movie he sets out to make is so overfilled that every movie he makes has a Director's Cut.

[@icedcapplord710]

Zack Snyder fans in 2016: "You dont understand him" Zack Snyder fans now: "...I understand now"

[@MagusMirificus]

Could it be...all this time...*I* was the one who didn't understand Zack Snyder?"

[@CrazyEight-art]

@@MagusMirificusmaybe the true Zack Snyder was the friends we made along the way.

[@Dannwond]

@@CrazyEight-art in slow-motion.

[@TabalugaDragon]

Ah yes let's pretend like if he makes bad stuff now means he was always a bad filmmaker. Legend of the Guardians, Man of Steel, Batman v Superman(director's cut), his Justice League - are all decent at worst and phenomenal at best. He isn't my favorite director(Nolan is), but I'm grateful for the good stuff he did before. Attacking him now is like Cassie attacking his dad in And Man 3 "sure you did good before, but what about now?".

[@Empwuznal]

No way bro used Antman to make his point 💀​@@TabalugaDragon

[@merck__]

The best zac Snyder movie is the one that came out when you were 16

[@Cthulhuzohavaitfseh]

Dawn of the Dead and 300 still good.

[@davymugire8581]

How did you know that I was 16 when zsjl came out

[@Zer0effort]

So none of them😅

[@MammaApa]

So the music video for ZZ Top's World of Swirl?

[@Aencii]

I saw 300 when I was 16, so I think that counts.

[@joaquinm9148]

I can’t believe it’s been 8 years since 2016

[@ManCarryingThing]

its only been 4 years i think you're wrong

[@poposterous236]

hard to believe its been 30 years since man of steel came out mainly because its not true

[@LuisSierra42]

Man put 80s music to accentuate how old we are

[@comixproviderftw_02]

Time is fucked up, ain’t it?

[@OptionalBean]

Boyhood took 12 years to make! It's been 22 years!

[@Mrcryalot]

Zachary is objectively a director, just like how this is objectively a comment

[@Aencii]

One of the directors of all time.

[@Mrcryalot]

@@Aencii -moist

[@voltijuice8576]

That's why he is an "objectivist"!

[@JadeReloaded]

He is also a cinematographer now, practically.

[@XeriFemsomething-qg2py]

I objectively subjectively disagree with your subjective view that this is objectively a comment and not subjectively a holy text of a religion subjectobjtively not founded yet (in my opinion)

[@jonbovino]

It would’ve been easier for me to grasp the greatness of this video if there was ten or twenty more slow-mo shots

[@NexusKin]

I would've been able to grasp it if there were huge explosions, slo-mo shots, lens flair, and oversaturated colors.

[@starkillersneed]

@@NexusKin There was also very little gratuitous exposition so I couldn't understand shit

[@frostcore2214]

@@NexusKinplus if it was six hours long. That way we have all the time in the world to say the plot over and over again and waste slow mo shots

[@MachiavellianPenguin1234]

If you say Rebel Moon three times into a mirror, nothing happens. Because it’s a movie. Incase you forgot.

[@mrbooboohead157]

Most people forgot

[@ruleofoz2207]

I have done some research, and It is indeed a movie. I still need to do further research to proove that it's a movie that exists, however.

[@shytendeakatamanoir9740]

​@@ruleofoz2207Can a movie exists if nobody was here to watch it?

[@mynameisfoxxy6110]

Please do not ever put the words "Rebel", "Moon" and "three" consecutively ever again

[@yaygya]

@@shytendeakatamanoir9740 Existence depends on observation, so no.

[@nilzero5686]

I watched both Rebel Moon part 1 and part 2 and it's incredible how completely unfettered and creatively free Zack Snyder has resulted in "what if warhammer without camp, what if chronicles of riddick without riddick, and what if star wars without levity" thrown in a blender and played at 25% speed.

[@husker4life109]

Also what if the magnificent seven but not magnificent

[@phangkuanhoong7967]

i really doubt there was a blender involved. i think these movies are held together with duct tape and paperclips.

[@virtheon]

I don't even know what Rebel moon is about, but having seen the Snyder cut I know exactly what you mean by 25% speed. He has the unique ability to make action scenes incredibly slow paced and excruciatingly boring.

[@workinprogress5431]

I'm not proud of it, but you just tipped me over the fence into wanting to watch. I thought it looked like hot garbage, but that's the kind of hot garbage I'd sniff for the experience. Update: So I did watch Rebel Moon. It was such garbage that I immediately watched part two directly after.

[@leonardobroza6298]

It is so derivative that the closest thing i could describe it is as if Snyder found the script of that fake space opera movie from Argo and called it a day.

[@smugsneasel]

Before it was "Release the Snyder Cut" and now it's "Cut the Snyder Release"

[@jugem2849]

Lmaooo

[@gonzalo7591]

😂😂😂😂👍👍

[@CodeNameX001]

The funniest/saddest part is that he tried to do it again last December, but with Sucker Punch. He went around saying he wanted to make a director's cut and how the studio changed the ending.

[@GXpook]

Underrated comment.

[@cusinian]

Sadly there's still fanboys out there that want Snyder's edgy blood filled DC universe to continue and refuse to accept defeat.

[@hurinthalion5984]

The problem with Rebel Moon is that it relies way too heavily on its audiences knowledge of tropes that are done better in other media while not doing them uniquely enough to be interesting. So the whole time your going like "Oh its just like 7 Samurai, that looks like 40k, that's Star Wars, etc. that's space Catholicism, " and then when its over your left with something half decent but no substance of its own and its like what's the point? Then when it does do something unique its buried in 50 lines of exposition.

[@j.francisward1897]

Snyder excels at visually crafting a world, but not writing, he needs to get good writers

[@bretginn1419]

​@@j.francisward1897 And honestly, with Rebel Moon, I'm left wondering if he's actually good at that. Rebel Moon really didn't have any standout worldbuilding.

[@niccolorichter1488]

@@bretginn1419 Rebel Moon is really just worldbulding ideas trown around but never really given time to flourish and given us by the most long and boring exposicion

[@bretginn1419]

That's really it. It's bad, but not in a fun way. It's just a slog to sit through, because you're just seeing Snyder mashing stuff together and not doing anything else. Hell, I really want to know how he fumbled 7 Samurai the way he did.

[@theshlauf]

@@bretginn1419 Simple, he likes moments, not story.

[@Ana_Ng]

ugh now i can't even say i don't like zack snyder anymore cause then i have to deal with zack snyder fans agreeing with me

[@LDFrost117]

Well some of them, there's still a good chunk still holding to that burnt flag like victory is around the corner not realizing everything around them is nothing but old ashes now

[@massgunner4152]

Nah fam if you dig you will find the bodies buried on the hill

[@borisstoyanov3488]

It's okay if you don't like him. I was only a fan of his DC movies. Most of his other work is complete dogshit. I am so disappointed. He really can come off as pretentious, can't he?

[@CosmosStudios-ho5fg]

You just said it

[@TinNguyen-sw8uc]

What even is the appeal of zack snyder he made like 2 ok super hero movies not even Nolan fans are this obsesses

[@poposterous236]

Just wait, in 20 years these movies will be re-evaluated as the masterpieces that Snyder seems to think they are

[@LuisSierra42]

He's ahead of his time

[@poposterous236]

@@LuisSierra42 other movies need to catch up (by slowing down!)

[@arubinojr5670]

Todd Shadowsson once called Charli XCX forever the pop star of the future, or something similar, which means no matter how much time passes, she is never the pop star of now. Perhaps Zacharias Q. Synderemark is forever the filmmaker of the future, except I think Todd likes Charli XCX?

[@Shak2k11]

ughhh just like the hot garbage movies Disney are have been making. I can wait before people start talking about the Skywalker sequel as "masterpieces"

[@fpedrosa2076]

Time to admit I unironically have a huge soft spot for Sucker Punch. I don't think it quite works, too much 'have your cake and eat it too' energy, but it's also unique and I can tell it meant a lot to its creator, even if not all pieces fit perfectly together. I also watched it with the Japanese dub and I feel this improves that particular movie by 50%.

[@DavidTheJohnson]

I have to present an oral critical analysis on the Snyder Cut tomorrow, so this video could not have been released at the perfect time.

[@DrDiabolical000]

Sat verbal not oral. Else it sounds weird.

[@Xedlord]

@@DrDiabolical000 Only if you're weird

[@dubblebubbletoilandtrouble6646]

@@DrDiabolical000 🤨

[@DNeonLamp]

Who is forcing you? This sounds like a cruel punishment.

[@Abominatrix650]

Take care, man.

[@hiddensquid7048]

What a giver, he never scars!

[@Sanchewich]

You just scarred me with that word, giver… 2014…

[@rumo510]

An absolute Zack! He never Snyders!

[@ManOfTheWeek596]

Rebel Moon Part 6 will just be a single 2h slow mo shot of the characters walking

[@LDFrost117]

You joke but that's largely already what the first two are lol

[@onEmEmbErstudios]

Fun fact: If you put all the slow-motion parts in second Rebel Moon into normal speed, you will get a 10-minute movie

[@MichaelCravith]

Don't let the abdominal pain caused by talking about your favourite movie Rebel Moon distract you from the fact that Man Carrying Thing has achieved the state of non-aging.

[@MonkeySimius]

​@@ldawg7117What? Part of his video was clearly labeled that it was filmed in 2016. It is like he hasn't aged a day since then.

[@ldawg7117]

@@MonkeySimius goddamnit, I'm a fking idiot😆

[@MasterEth]

More like Bad Snyder

[@themutupoguy]

Snyd her? I barely known her

[@DisorderlyFashion]

"Snyder?" Ah, I love that guy! He makes great hotdogs.

[@Zso-VIII]

More like Bad Bad

[@salaali8918]

Wack Snyder. Wack Snyder, sir.

[@RussellB]

Zack Badder

[@krishnasaini-wq5pi]

and release the man carrying cut in square ratio too pls

[@joshuaizly5502]

With darker color hues and an extra 20 minutes of fake interviews with Brandon Sanderson.

[@milanhvozdik3379]

but it has to be at least 6 hours long

[@macalveyggg6552]

Man is grey edition

[@Erathiatw]

What going on with politics? Well, Admiral Noble has been dispatched on a mission of pacification from the Motherworld, who now reports to General Balisarius since the coup against King Athander...

[@FLIK510]

Let's go Noble

[@kashiichan]

​@@FLIK510Donna is the best Noble

[@TortugaMaritima]

I'm convinced Snyder fans are just Batman fans that spent too much time defending his vision and now it's too late to take it back so they just stick with whatever he makes

[@ironmaster6496]

🤣🤣🤣 that makes sense actually

[@LDFrost117]

They've been trying to sell both movies, even right now, as the Star Wars and Dune killers over on Twitter, it's amazing honestly, like they are actually unironically claiming this franchise will take over both of them as the big sci-fi franchise, this is like an abusive relationship where one person tries to excuse their partner and glorify them to hide the abuse

[@LDFrost117]

@tonimashdane33498 I can count at least 30 directors that make better movies

[@oreohunter7798]

Batman fans are no fans of Snyder, they’re more likely fans of the Punisher, the kind that has never read a comic book.

[@geiseric222]

From what I’ve seen the most die hard Synder fans from that time don’t give a fuck about Rebel moon and just religiously follow DC to talk about how Synder would have done it better

[@A1stardan]

They'll now say "Netflix didn't give him enough freedom, we have to wait for the original cut"

[@8bitdee]

“I've read reviews and I'm gonna wait for the directors cut of both films” Real comment I read on a Zack Snyder subreddit. These people are blind af

[@Little1Cave]

That’s insane. Rebel Moon being produced, directed, co-written, and even SHOT by Zack makes it his most unfiltered chance at being a filmmaker. There’s literally no excuse. Even a blind person can smell shit on the ground in front of them.

[@Raccocooney]

The direcrors cut gets a rating of 16% instead of the 13% like the original because that extra 45 minutes gives you about 30 seconds of satisfaction

[@julianseguin2748]

@@Little1Cave Nah, because the studio cuts really limited his film. He sucks at editing, that is a fact. But his version won't be hindered by the curbed violence or the lack of storytelling.

[@julianseguin2748]

@@Raccocooney Still relying on Rotten Tomatoes in 2024? What a sad life you have.

[@astrobat1638]

Even they hate Rebel Moon if you see more of the subreddit.

[@fool6078]

if zack snyder directed this it would’ve been twice as long just for a dramatic slow motion man’s stomach pain scene

[@eveninacrowdedroom]

One comment on the two Justice League movies that always stuck with me was: 'Both are like nightmares, just one ends faster'💀💀

[@benabramowitz18]

If Jordan Peele, Greta Gerwig, or the Daniels ever made something as bad as Sucker Punch, or set a franchise back years like with BvS, they wouldn't be given a blank-check mulligan for 8 years.

[@ComicGladiator]

Imagine thinking Jordan Peele hasn't just pooped out garbage for the elites to clap their flippers to.

[@Nocturne22]

@@ComicGladiator Your username tells us all we need to know about you.

[@hunterkiller1440]

If Michael Bay thinks he is Christopher Nolan, you'll get Zack.

[@mateoremedi4703]

the mcu is the prove that directors should have more creative control zack snyder is the prove of the oposite

[@LDFrost117]

You know what they say, truth is often somewhere in the middle, creative freedom is good... but clearly feedback and limitations are good as well

[@Fei-Chan]

Having more creative control from a director in MCU does two things. "Love and Thunder" and "GOTG 3". One is garbage, the other is a masterpiece

[@mateoremedi4703]

@@Fei-Chan i mean,waititi admited he made love and thunder for the money and just the money,i think the problem here was puting him in charge in the first place

[@1stCallipostle]

Creatives work best under limits, but not too much limits. When you let committees and the talent-questionable make movies, maybe limit them a lot.

[@svenbtb]

@@Fei-Chan Uh... masterpiece? That's kind of a stretch imo, it's just better than most other post-endgame marvel movies. But that's not saying much. Just by comparison it feels like a masterpiece lol

[@Sonicstriforce]

If someone *willingly* wants to change the subject to politics, you KNOW somethings up.

[@Robyn_007]

I can't wait for 40 minutes of slow motion to be added back into the director's cut.

[@EpicBeard815]

The idea that you had to watch Rebel Moon Part 2 for this video makes me weep

[@asturianix9820]

This is how I feel about his movies: -Visually amazing. -Dialogues written by a pretentious 15 year old edgelord.

[@thewitcherking937]

Yall have no idea what pretentious or edgelord means. They're dumb bullshit Buzzwords yall parrot

[@HerculeDevantrien]

Patrick (H) Willems has a good take about his movies: Snyder is a fine action director with a great sense of aesthetics, which has caused him to be hailed as a visionary, which in turn has incited him to bite off more than he could chew by trying to make "smart movies". But since he's just really a style-over-substance guy, that mostly translates as his movies ending up as edgy and vaguely pretentious.

[@thewitcherking937]

@@HerculeDevantrien it's a bullshit take. How are his movies edgy or pretentious? Yall parrot these bullshit claims so damn much.

[@Qwerds7]

The Snydercut subreddit is something else man

[@Finn_01]

"Why does my perception of time distress you so?" - Slow-Mo Snyder

[@KrishnaSaini-uf1cm]

Finally.. Man carried the thing for so long he decided to eat it. He is now: Man eating thing

[@ironmaster6496]

0:27 you nailed it with this, discussions with Snyder fans about DC would get really personal really fast 😂

[@ichthyovenator3351]

Love the way MCT finds a topic that I think is popular but have never heard of till the video comes out.

[@orpheusthepoet3149]

It's crazy to me Zack had a career to begin with. He was a music video director at first which explains his, well, everything really. He made a Dawn of the Dead remake with James Gunn but what really put him on the map was 300 and Watchmen. 300 was perfect for him as it was a comic with a simple story and great visuals that he just did shot for shot. Watchmen on the other hand, as Zack explained it, was something he did as he thought the usual superhero comic book things were for nerds and that watchmen was cool, and edgy, and dark and all he cared about was the violence, sex, and crude language. This is a stance that Alex Moore, the author of Watchmen and the Killing Joke, credits as why he doesn't want to make comics cause people end up missing the point. Again, Zack just did a shot for shot remake of Moore's comic but stripped it of subtext. This is a man who never should have been allowed to write for a story, much less be the lead creative for super hero movies. He is anathema to the very concept.

[@stevewalker6240]

Exactly. And for anyone saying he is good at visuals, no, he's not. It's Larry Fong (his cinematographer) that made his movies look beautiful. Since Zack don't use him again and instead making his own cinematography in Army of the Dead and Rebel Moon, his visuals have become so fkin bad and ugly, so fkin terrible. If you love visuals of 300, Watchmen, MoS, BvS, ZSJL, then praise Larry Fong, not Zack.

[@thewitcherking937]

What you wrote is complete bs.

[@julianseguin2748]

@@stevewalker6240 You're a moron for saying this. He knows what he wants for his shots. To deny this, is to deny any director in the world. That's like denying Nolan any credit for how Interstellar looked, or James Cameron for how Avatar looked. Snyder came up with the ideas and the visuals and the cinematographers brought them to life. That is true. But don't think he has no visual talent whatsoever, is the most petty, vindictive shit you can put out. You are a really sad individual for this.

[@johnotto-wl2yh]

@@thewitcherking937cope

[@Muaddweeb02]

ManCarryingThing became ManAteAThing

[@thegrimmarcher202]

Man ate his own words

[@jeffbezos3200]

*You’ve been permanently banned from r/Snydercut for saying something bad about Zack Snyder*

[@slacktivism05]

I still cant believe thats an actual rule in the subreddit 😭. Literally beyond parody

[@kade-qt1zu]

That is literal cult-like behavior WTF?

[@PiyushMaanDev]

"His only bad film is the woke one with all the females in it" literally a comment I saw the other day by a snyder fan.

[@ComicGladiator]

Outrageous! He made way more bad movies than just the Woke one with all the females in it.

[@wielderofthetriforce1934]

The Snyder fan to incel pipeline should be studied

[@Syno_Phobia]

Oh, you mean sucker punch 😅

[@mimorisenpai8540]

Ironic if they refer that to Sucker Punch who pretty much far from woke

[@davidfisher9252]

Zack Snyder never rebels, the absolute moon!

[@eldanx1184]

Imagine Zack Snyder directing Dune It would be the longest and slowest movie of the century

[@NexusKin]

Zack Snyder is who you get when you transplant Michael Bay's and JJ Abrams's spirits into Christopher Nolan's and Denis Villenueve's bodies.

[@DolphinsAreBetterThanHumans]

I played this at 0.25x to get the real Zack snyder feel.

[@MH5tube]

someone has never seen Legend of the Guardians: The Owls of Ga'Hoole and it shows

[@jlev1028]

That wasn't written by Snyder. Also, that movie was only okay. It's not a masterpiece.

[@doc8013]

​@@jlev1028nothing he's made has been near masterpiece level.

[@mommalion7028]

That is the only Snyder movie I like besides Wonder Woman 1984

[@doc8013]

@@mommalion7028 WW84 isn't a Snyder movie.

[@woodfur00]

I have and can confirm that Legend of the Guardians is in fact a movie

[@rasengdori13]

I still remember when weird nerds wanted to prop up Zack Snyder as an “anti-woke” hero, only for him to call out Geeks+Gamers in a livestream to disassociate himself with their hateful ideology.

[@kade-qt1zu]

That's the thing about Zack Snyder. As much as I hate some of his movies, I can't really hate *him* because he seems like a decent person. It's his cultish fanbase that everyone despises.

[@rasengdori13]

@@kade-qt1zu Unfortunately, if Zack Snyder was a woman making these bad movies, he would be harassed by these grifters endlessly.

[@kylekillgannon]

How fucking sad that is your basis for judging a whole person.

[@machinatingminotaur6285]

@@kylekillgannon if you come out and say "I suck I am the worst" I'm not going to bother investigating further. I'm going to take you at your word. Life is too short for me to waste time on terrible people. These losers self-select openly, and it's the only good thing about them.

[@kade-qt1zu]

​@@rasengdori13Facts. People like Geeks and Gamers and Yellowflash2 would probably start milking her for content.

[@jonolas1626]

Ironically enough, I loved Sucker Punch; his best movie alongside 300

[@seigeengine]

I really liked Sucker Punch. I also liked Watchmen. 300 was okay. Kind of boring, but w/e.

[@humanman9920]

​@@seigeengine300 was awesome

[@seigeengine]

@@humanman9920 That's also an opinion.

[@Jerry-yr1en]

80s: We will have flying cars in the future Now: People hating on movies for not being 100/10

[@FirstnameLastname-my7bz]

*cowardly people on internet dissing the one of the only genuinely nice people of Hollywood and vilify and strawman his entire fanbase as some sort of monolith simply because it is "allowed" by internet community which mainly consists of jerks and dishonest people, and worse

[@SPACE_BOOOOOST]

just wait until he really cuts loose and makes a movie entirely in slow motion

[@livingcheese2910]

Warner Brothers did treat JL and Snyder absolutely poorly, but people kinda missed the point of the whole drama and praised Snyder like some movie saint. He literally killed Supermans best friend Jimmy Olsen 1 minute after his first appearance without introducing him first as a "statement". A good director doesn't kill someones best friend without a reason. Especially if 3/4 of the movie watchers didn't read the comics and don't give a shit about him anyways. lol

[@HalJordan661]

And WB was right this hack can't direct any movies

[@thewitcherking937]

Not a hack. Sayung he can't director movies is complete bullshit

[@thewitcherking937]

He didn't kill him off to make a statement.

[@delivererofdarknessshoguno1133]

Wtf, why is this video moving so quickly? I had to lower the speed to be able to percieve it in a non-Snyder reality.

[@rd412]

Ready for The Director's cut!❤

[@knuckleheadwestwind3585]

“Whats the deal with politics?!?” -Bubsy

[@stuartbarron7117]

As someone who is genuinely a fan of Zack Snyder's work, Rebel Moon (and to a lesser extent, Army of the Dead) have me really concerned for the future of his career. Also, I like Sucker Punch... Make of that what you will.

[@A1stardan]

Don't worry, so far he's only failed upwards

[@edwardgyan7586]

it's sooo disappointing. i feel betrayed lol. i really thought he'd put out brilliant stuff after leaving DC. where is Zack Snyder?

[@BrownieX001]

He's always needed someone to reign him in and someone else to work on the script for him. His creative style has more potential for stuff like live action anime. Snyder Live Action Blue Lock when

[@brucechamberlin2545]

I think my favorite thing about this channel is the comment section.

[@lostmarble540]

if Zack Snyder was a cow his name would be Yak Snyder

[@borisstoyanov3488]

And if he was a duck: Quack Snyder

[@thedapperdolphin1590]

Even the trailer had egregious amounts of slowmo shots

[@creativezaara7823]

0:20 Man ate thing

[@professorwh042]

I watched this video while my stomach hurt, so I can say that the immersion factor was unreal. Bravo Man Carrying Thing, most pure kino I’ve ever felt.

[@SarcyBoi41]

I still see plenty of Snyder fans claiming the Rebel Moon stuff is somehow good but they always seem to do so with gritted teeth and their eyes looking in opposite directions

[@stanko00001]

People thought Snyder was the next Christopher Nolan He was actually the next Michael Bay

[@A1stardan]

Bay knows how to make a fun movie

[@1stCallipostle]

​@@A1stardanabout 50% of the time.

[@machinatingminotaur6285]

@@A1stardan wait really? I guess I'm not familiar with his stuff outside of transformers, which... well, you know.

[@macalveyggg6552]

@@machinatingminotaur6285check out The Rock, it’s got bays goofy over-the-top style but with an actual message.

[@HalJordan661]

Bay doesn’t pretend to be Christopher Nolan, Spielberg...he makes movies for fun

[@stevemudkip4701]

I'm a Zack Snyder fan and I'm waiting for the R-rated cuts of Rebel Moon. Loved the video! 😂

[@BigK13372]

This video is entirely inaccurate. Pretty sure Snyder cultists would defend Rebel Moon Part 2 as hard as they did with Batman v. Superman.

[@WhiteWolf496]

Its kinda funny how I see more snyder fans hating on james gunn for no real reason than I do snyder fans praising snyder.

[@urlhnd]

i have exactly no context for this. this is great

[@kfactor20]

There are still Snyder fans out there still thinking the Snyder-verse can be saved even though Gunn took over and has been filming a new movie that’s gonna launch the reboot universe. LET IT GOOOO

[@zeroconnection]

Oh the ravage of time.

[@j.albuquerque9274]

I remember them defending Sucker Punch with teeth and nails back in 16.

[@ComicGladiator]

And you freely admit this?

[@thatgamingkiwi1630]

Zack Snyder fans still aren't in modern times yet because they're stuck in slowmo.

[@DaxSchaffer]

I never mentally recovered from Watchmen. I remember angrily ranting about the movie with a friend of mine at the time (who had also read the comic) for 2 hours about how much it missed the point. It made me irrationally upset. And like, yeah, that's it. No one else gets a shot at making that movie now because it isn’t enough of a franchise to ever merit a remake. There are so many other directors who could have done the story justice, but we'll just never get to see a thematically competent version that isn’t mired by over the top violent action and slow-motion nonsense.

[@Crushanator1]

yeah, it's like he read the comics and thought all the characters were cool and good heroes instead of deeply flawed characters within a tragedy

[@DaxSchaffer]

@@Crushanator1 As soon as the Comedian's death scene at the beginning had a way too long "cool" fight sequence in it, I remember immediately thinking, "Oh no....is this going to be the whole movie?" 😰

[@LDFrost117]

@@DaxSchaffer I always described Snyder's Watchmen movie as "Watchmen if it had been written by Frank Miller instead of Alan Moore", scenes like that are why

[@phangkuanhoong7967]

yup.

[@A1stardan]

He read batman returns, a comic where batman breaks a gun in half and says" these are the weapons of a coward ", then he made batman use guns in the film 😅

[@NilesBlackX]

Still waiting for this to happen to JJ Abrams. Maybe eventually, one day, people will figure out that drawing a bunch of random threads that imply a master plan, with no actual idea for how they connect, isn't as clever as he thinks it is. Truly our version of Stephen Moffat.

[@orion5869]

I am looking forward to the man carrying things cut of this video, which will be two minutes long and much more grey

[@Solar_Eclipse53]

Man, you should make a compilation of all of your videos, maybe by each year

[@axt2]

It's really a shame Snyder didn't get to release Rebel Moon as a Star Wars film. It's really the only conceivable way Disney could bring that franchise lower.

[@Rslb7.]

Heh. I've heard nothing about the quality of Rebel Moon until now, and reading these comments makes me never want to watch it, except to laugh at it.

[@enotsnavdier6867]

​@Rslb7. It's actually 2 movies. One was released in December, and the other was released now. And they're both dreadful!!!

[@theshlauf]

@@Rslb7. It's not really a movie you can laugh at how bad it is. It's more like a couple hours of "this was done better in another movie".

[@doc8013]

​@@theshlaufI laughed several times at the dialogue. Then when the guy fell off the ship, that landing made me howl.

[@voltijuice8576]

@@enotsnavdier6867 Referring to "now" in the past tense was a gutsy move, you maverick!

[@verspin]

No! His movies are actually good you just need to watch the 56 hour ultimate director's cut version and it's great trust me

[@ishanpekamwar9633]

RELEASE THE MCT Cut!!!

[@AlexMartinez-cu4dw]

Man, i wish his FB fans would be like that, they still acting as if he's the greatest director a comic book movie has ever had. I feel sad for them

[@FirstnameLastname-my7bz]

He simply Is The best director of superhero adaptation in film. Especially if you familiar with source material in the first place.

[@Daniel-uy1sv]

​​@@FirstnameLastname-my7bzExcept that the only thing he adapts is panels without context

[@FirstnameLastname-my7bz]

@@Daniel-uy1sv other way around ,he is *only* director to accurately adapt original reason for Superman's secret identity (Superman #1) and his Batman intro in BvS is literally 1:1 towards Detective Comics #33 , for that Alone his films are the best adaptations since for the first time ever original core of these characters was retained instead of changed. No amount of lies from you will change reality.

[@manueleh2077]

Man carrying thing, i dream of bring a director, author and creator as well. I take courses of screenplay, i do theathre, i study character development, story arcs, filmaking, photography and all that stuff, because one day i dream that my movies and series will be watched wordwide, abd im terrified of the idea that i wont find a productor who is willing to give money to my project, im terrified that people wont like it. Then i see Zac Snyder and his Rebel Moon, and i think that if there are millionares who are willing to give money to produce a "TRILOGY" like that, then i say to myself that i've already won.

[@ernie39]

2016: his only bad movie is Suckerpunch 2024: his only good movie is Suckerpunch

[@JorganGJorgan]

This video was terrible, when are you releasing the directors cut that will fix everything?

[@repapeti98]

Still can't believe Rebel Moon part 2 came out recently. Feels like part 1 was released like 2 weeks ago

[@seigeengine]

I had literally never heard of Rebel Moon until this video.

[@thatpenguin9889]

Talks about Zack Snyder- EMOTIONAL DAMAGE😂

[@kevinirmiter3669]

You just don't understand, he's actually doing German Expressionism

[@SlurpyPie]

This video is unwatchable, I'm gonna wait for the director's cut.

[@redmii69]

Watch this video at 0.25 speed for the full experience (or at least the closest to the full experience until the Carrying Thing cut comes out)

[@davidtaylor142]

Rebel Moon is exactly as good as his earlier stuff too.

[@doc8013]

I think his Netflix stuff is significantly worse than his earlier work. 300, DotD. I've never been a huge fan of Watchmen but it's at least so much better than this.

[@davidtaylor142]

@@doc8013 those are all adaptations. His original work had always been bad. Also I personally hate DotD

[@Shak2k11]

@@doc8013 He can do an ok adaptation, bc its literally already done for him with a blueprint he just has to copy it to a screen. which just makes him a glorified cinematographer really

[@LDFrost117]

@@Shak2k11 But didnt you heard that Snyder himself IS THE BLUEPRINT? (Sorry, had to)

[@KenTWOu]

@@Shak2k11 Judging by his last three movies he shot himself, he's a terrible cinematographer.

[@djsuit95]

Zack Snyder is literally a director of our times. He makes movies.

[@comixproviderftw_02]

I’m just so sick of the hot takes, the contrarian views, the punching down, the blind worship, the controversies, and the rumors we have heard about this guy for the last DECADE PLUS. I hate how no matter what you say about him, it brings out the crazy in everybody. Not just the ones who like him, but the ones that hate him as well.

[@enotsnavdier6867]

How exactly has it brought out the crazy in the people who hate them? We're having fun making jokes about the terrible movies he makes

[@comixproviderftw_02]

@@enotsnavdier6867 Yeah well, tell that to the people who hated his guts back when he was in charge of the DCEU.

[@justinhurowitz70]

@@enotsnavdier6867I saw an article once that blamed Zack Snyder for his daughters suicide because he made Batman a bad guy

[@julianseguin2748]

@@enotsnavdier6867 You're either dumb or deaf, or both. There are people mocked his daughter endlessly. People who insist his movies somehow prove he's a fascist. They called him the worst thing ever to happen to DC. The haters are just as bad as the cultists.

[@bruh-pb5kr]

Man Eating Things never misses!

[@chepulis]

Hi, i'm a guy who liked Man Of Steel and Sucker Punch. What is this Rebel Moon thing tho

[@methos-ey9nf]

Zack Snyder Netflix movie.

[@charcharbug]

they really tryna pull the "I was never into movies anyway" card after this one

[@billbill6094]

People call him "a great visual filmmaker" when they're unable to find fault in your opinion on his movies, and that's not even true. 300 was a great looking movie, but if you'd read the comic you see it's because 90% of it was shot for shot from the comic panels. The artist was great at visuals, he just walked down the path laid out for him and put a 2000's video game piss filter over it. I'm almost certaim Rebel Moon has as much slo-mo as it does because people praised him for it in 300 not realizing they were there to show off the poses for the comic, so he assumed slo-mo was the ticket to success.

[@edwardgyan7586]

nah man, i think Sucker Punch is the indicator that you're wrong. that was purely his creation and the visuals in those were fucking sweet. they were orgasmic for the eyes. and what about Man of Steel? Several directors have said that his movies were inspiration for them. his recent movies are toilet, but let's give him credit where it's due.

[@farasbanas9564]

​@@edwardgyan7586 I think his movies visual detoriated heavily since he didn't have Fritz Lang as his cinematographer. Army of The Dead looks very bad and rebel moon is not much better

[@gabbifufuu5590]

Yall gave him so much confidence

[@stonehowl]

Don't worry MCT, although your videos also cause me excruciating pain in the stomach and feet I would never be ashamed of you :D

[@mylegalname9852]

The most part of this video is when the says "ok"

[@anonymous7434]

Snyder fans also voted ‘Army of the Dead’ as fan favorite movie, and it won… If they did that award again, they would 100% vote Rebel Moon. And even now it would still probably win 😂

[@bretginn1419]

Rebel Moon is a movie. That is the nicest thing I can say about it. If you want a better experience, watch Star Wars Episode 9.

[@andrijajankovic3865]

Nah, I'll watch Episode 1-6.

[@julianseguin2748]

Rebel Moon is better than any of the the new sequels. Sorry not sorry. Not saying it's good, but it feels like it's own thing, not a shameless copy and not an attempt to be something completely different.

[@bretginn1419]

@@julianseguin2748 No, it really isn't. Even Episode 9 was better and that's a complete mess in every way. And what do you mean, Rebel Moon tried to be different? Only thing it did was rip the serial numbers off of Star Wars, since it's no longer a Star Wars product, and replace it with bits from other series like 40K. There wasn't anything original, it was just a shameless copy.

[@onebear6504]

I find it kinda funny that my lecturer for a class on digital media showed a video about cinematography or something where Snyder's works are used as the bad examples

[@thewitcherking937]

That's immediately a shit lecturer.

[@FirstnameLastname-my7bz]

Makes sense why modern Hollywood is either dоgshlt or Zack Snyder inspired. Live action or animated. Doesn't even matter. As well as why MCU is in such disastrous state after stolen Snyder Plan ran out.

[@cybustermod]

Zack is shite since BVS “her name is Martha” scene. He is an overrated director.

[@eskewroberts7663]

As an ex-Zach Snyder apologist ... I'm sorry