The Wheels are Coming Off
1:11:59
14 сағат бұрын
GE 2024 - Reflection on Election
1:08:16
Eva Comrie GE Launch
1:21
3 ай бұрын
SILENCE KILLS: DOES ANYONE CARE?
44:32
Пікірлер
@brendem2701
@brendem2701 14 сағат бұрын
This is goin to be one hellova show on Sunday!!! ❤
@Ahsct25
@Ahsct25 Күн бұрын
How would an independent Scotland cope with a scenario in which pro-union parts of the country are annexed by rUK? We know Roddy supports this scenario in another country, so I'm quite certain he must have considered the possibility of an indy Scotland being much smaller than it's current borders.
@specialcandletrust6531
@specialcandletrust6531 5 күн бұрын
Another great broadcast keeping it real when all else just spin for self advancement
@alsoascot02
@alsoascot02 5 күн бұрын
Putin is a bully and bullies need to be stood up to. And the fighting in Ukraine is of course a proxy, Ukrainians are dying so we don't want to. Putin wants to rebuild the Russian Empire ask those who live in the Baltic states, Finland and even Poland about Russian goals. And here is the truth if Russia had more to offer those on its borders than domination, gangster government and corruption then they might have some credibility. To say stuff like NATO invaded Russia is at best not helpful.
@barrheadboy1684
@barrheadboy1684 4 күн бұрын
Drivel and completely wrong. Go back to 2014 and the Maidan CIA coup or keep lying
@alsoascot02
@alsoascot02 5 күн бұрын
One of the problems of AUOB (for independence) and getting folk out is AUOB isn't remotely that. I have chosen to attend multiple matches even if I am uncomfortable with Socialist Worker placards, (handed out by the usually collection of zombie zealots) and other parafinalia for fringe left wing parties I share littie with other than a desire for Scottish Independence. Scottish Independence is however not and cannot be allowed to be seen exclusively as some kind of left wing experiment or a stepping stone to a socialist Scotland etc. Apart from anything else such an approach cannot ever deliver the diversity of support needed to see a sizable majority in favour of leaving the Union. But left wing fantasy and idealism aside, I can live with those, even if my actual political views are not actually welcome under their banner. However the presence of Palestinian flags and effectively support for HAMAS at Scottish Independence rallies is beyond the pale for me. The multiple on going tragedies of middle East are imo not in the remit of the democratic Scottish Independence movement. The situation is in fact intractable and nothing said or done in Scotland can or will changes that. I can a will support the other democratic separatist movements of Europe and beyond, but Palestinisn goals are neither separatist or democratic. Sorry but I won't be attending any other AUOB events unless this issue is addressed. AUOB needs to be what is says it is IE a platform for ALL who seek Scottish Independence, by democratic means, it cannot be diluted by unthinking far left zealots or distracted by side issues linked to those same folk.
@barrheadboy1684
@barrheadboy1684 4 күн бұрын
You seem to fail to understand what the letters AUOB stand for!
@alsoascot02
@alsoascot02 4 күн бұрын
@@barrheadboy1684 Not me AUOB is supposed to be an umbrella organisation focused on Scottish Independence? An organisation with a broad political stance? Not a campaign for a future Socialist Scotland? If it is or just wants to be the latter then by definition it isn't AUOB? As I said I don't like much about outfits like the SWP but I fully accept they can be under a single Scottish Independence banner, they have the right to express their views on the matter, but that doesn't mean I remotely accept or indeed need to accept any of the other causes the SWP or anyone else under the banner want to promote. For me I don't see how Palestine fits AUOB for Scottish Independence l, primarily because the Palestinian cause is not a peaceful democratic struggle for independence. As I also said the Palestinian and wider middle East situation is in reality intractable and nothing said or done in Scotland can change that So in short waving Palestinian flags serves only to alienate folk who might otherwise be happy to be AUOB. Again demonstrating that AUOB is not interested in the ALL aspect when it comes to the supposed main focus IE Scottish Independence?
@roderickmacdonald7701
@roderickmacdonald7701 5 күн бұрын
Small people paid small amounts to give away our fortunes. Right at the end there 1:08:05 on. We've had our oil money stolen to feed Thatcher's fake revolution based on Scottish oil. And now we again sell our renewables for pennies that could have been billions to transform our country. BUT: do we think that if we had negotiated brilliantly and brought the 16B Common Weal estimated we could have won, that the monies so raised would not on some technicality or another just been siphoned off to Westminster, to finance another boom in the south? It would have been stolen, one way or another, behind legal fictions and smiling teeth that snarl. The only way to keep the wealth that Scotland generates within Scotland itself, is by independence. Any clever plan we come up with to generate money within the union, will be stolen by the union.
@zambotv8150
@zambotv8150 5 күн бұрын
"Buy your messages." It's great to hear Scots talk about politics In Scots
@kevinkevin-ug9po
@kevinkevin-ug9po 5 күн бұрын
What was her role at the bank of England? Nasty worker. Labour should tank in Scotland after this and Labour lies need shouted out.
@kevinkevin-ug9po
@kevinkevin-ug9po 5 күн бұрын
I knew years ago that the owner of Grangemouth would do this. Having a person put there by Thatcher tells you all you need to know.
@kevinkevin-ug9po
@kevinkevin-ug9po 5 күн бұрын
This fuel allowance is going to hit No and yes voter pensioners. I wonder how No voters will take it, will they still say the union is brilliant?.
@robertmunro5190
@robertmunro5190 5 күн бұрын
Roddy, how true Starmer can out lie every day, Starmer does it and knows he’s doing it, Boris hadn’t a clue half the time he spoke.
@robertmunro5190
@robertmunro5190 5 күн бұрын
The politicians changed at the last election, the civil servants are still the same.
@williemacbeth
@williemacbeth 5 күн бұрын
Are the Unionist parties Scotland, s AIPAC. Working totally for a foreign power.
@Mads1255
@Mads1255 5 күн бұрын
I think this lot are deluded…totally. Lies and makebeleive🤦‍♀️
@kencoutts2051
@kencoutts2051 5 күн бұрын
They will not wake up folks, they are settling ing for a second party in the rood out of office but still taking the purse. 🐼🐼🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
@kencoutts2051
@kencoutts2051 5 күн бұрын
Shona Robinson is not a qualified economist. She is a guard for the rich few. Blocking land reform, giving continued subsidies. 🐼🐼🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
@tenaciousv7611
@tenaciousv7611 6 күн бұрын
More and more we are seeing these evil shits getting owned. Do they realise the power of tech today.. or do they just not care? They believe they are smarter, better educated than us. If they were, then we would not be calling them out!
@tenaciousv7611
@tenaciousv7611 6 күн бұрын
Austerity is a political choice. We canny be skint if we can promise £30 billion to Ukraine for as lomg as it takes. As well as that climate funding for another country. That needs to be broadcast on the walls..Led By Donkeys Style. I bet that 'funding' is going off shore. Zelenskys a wee Nazi!
@blackislepeastoo
@blackislepeastoo 6 күн бұрын
The Ragged Trouser Philanthropists - great book. Unfortunately the land of milk and honey is an SNP chant too. Lies and liars, that's politicians - too true - The Fishwife, Matheson, Swinney, Flynn have all upheld that 'tradition'. I'm afraid devolution is 'dead' for at least 10 years, quite simply the SNP have had a very poor record - as a one issue party they have failed to deliver on it, in addition they can’t even balance that failure with a record of good results in government. Ferries that cost hundreds of millions and don’t operate, declining education standards, free university tuition but only for the few and that’s decreasing, declining education, health and local services along with increased levels of taxation affecting internal and external investment and projects such as the A9 continually delayed. Couple that with a party that continually lies, gaslights and blames anyone, including Thatcher, for all their failures. The latest gaslighting, claiming they can't pay winter heating for pensioners because of 'Westminster' when in fact the winter payment was in the outline budget back in 2023. The reason the North Sea is such a successful petroleum producing producing region is because of kimmeridge clay. This source rock has not been proven to exist west of a Scotland, any estimates of 'trillions of barrels of oil' is entirely speculative. 61 companies own North Sea oil and gas licences; most of them are publicly listed and many pay their taxes in chosen locations; 1/3rd are privately-owned and therefore less transparent and a handful of owners are state-owned enterprises from China, Russia, Norway, Korea, the UAE and the USA.
@ThomasBoyd-x3x
@ThomasBoyd-x3x 6 күн бұрын
Awesome thanks. Italy doing better than United Kingdom yes Thomas.
@karolorkisz-f5y
@karolorkisz-f5y 6 күн бұрын
inspiration broadcast in these times of gloom and negativity.
@ThomasBoyd-lo9si
@ThomasBoyd-lo9si 6 күн бұрын
Awesome. Italy support Scottish independence politically. Upfront policy politically Thomas Pietro Boselli Italian Italy Republic 🇮🇹🇮🇹
@127cmore
@127cmore 6 күн бұрын
I love listening to Eva's passion and anger 😠 😡 at the current events. ❤❤❤❤❤
@patbannan442
@patbannan442 6 күн бұрын
Pity you guys aren't running the snp
@TheKapeeteeleestPeeg
@TheKapeeteeleestPeeg 5 күн бұрын
🇬🇧 Secret Service running the SNP
@sn4rff
@sn4rff 6 күн бұрын
that was excellent, thanks very much.
@evacomrie-oy7cp
@evacomrie-oy7cp 6 күн бұрын
thank you, a pleasure to do, though I look forward to the one when we celebrate the independence vote and exchange ideas and plans for our newly independent Scotland.
@ronaldmccranor87
@ronaldmccranor87 6 күн бұрын
Labour aren't worried about winning the HR elections cos they are going to close it down. Mark my words.
@briankelly7370
@briankelly7370 6 күн бұрын
Starmer is not aligned with the US. He is bought by Israel. As they are.
@ronaldmccranor87
@ronaldmccranor87 6 күн бұрын
Well said Phil 'Grangemouth' it's all about Free ports. Owned by Black rock and the deep state. EU will not except new members who have corporate owned Free ports in their counties. Another problem for independence.
@ronaldmccranor87
@ronaldmccranor87 6 күн бұрын
Hi everyone waiting here on a wet Isle of Lewis
@doncar9
@doncar9 6 күн бұрын
It was great meeting three quarters of the regular team at George square yesterday, such lovely people!
@johnstuart7244
@johnstuart7244 7 күн бұрын
The occupied six counties. I have heard some crap in my time. 881 votes. Lol!
@johnstuart7244
@johnstuart7244 8 күн бұрын
881 Votes Eva. I've never laughed so hard. Yes, reform got short shrift, just like Eva. 🤣. As for you Quinan, economic case? You're even more deluded than Comrie. Barrheadbraindead. 3% is not "way over". Its also a fantasy figure. As for the Claymore, as a pathetic little man I doubt very much if you could even lift one, let alone take it to Westminster. Which is a threat of violence, is it not?
@specialcandletrust6531
@specialcandletrust6531 10 күн бұрын
Excellent program, just a shame the SNP ain’t listening and get off Scot Free by simply being incompetent as we get exploited then thrown into poverty
@graemeross1998
@graemeross1998 11 күн бұрын
On Corbyn no chance English folk now are all heading to Reform
@barrheadboy1684
@barrheadboy1684 10 күн бұрын
You wish
@graemeross1998
@graemeross1998 10 күн бұрын
@barrheadboy1684 I don't wish and you just have to look at what people are saying already. I just wish someone would stand up and remove us from the union
@graemeross1998
@graemeross1998 11 күн бұрын
I think the SNP is totally infiltrated now they are just useless
@graemeross1998
@graemeross1998 11 күн бұрын
But the Scottish Government don't voice out that GERS are rubbish they just stay silent. This is a massive issue
@graemeross1998
@graemeross1998 11 күн бұрын
Scotland needs to either get out the union or shut HR down as its a waste of money
@graemeross1998
@graemeross1998 11 күн бұрын
How come you listen to someone like this they speak sense but in parliament they act like idiots
@graemeross1998
@graemeross1998 11 күн бұрын
SNP don't listen to the voters, tbey don't even listen too its members. And they never accept responsibility it's always someone elses fault
@graemeross1998
@graemeross1998 11 күн бұрын
Scotland is let down by politicians north and south. The SNP are a waste of space and are not interested in independence
@ThomasBoyd-lo9si
@ThomasBoyd-lo9si 11 күн бұрын
Matthew Smith computing Lecturer Age 60 Thatcherite appointment yes he vote Tory in 1983 uk general election Thomas. He worse Richard Cook and Duncan Mcphee Lawyer yes. They survived it Thomas. Richard Cook super rich he Eastwood conservative. You talk Duncan Mcphee Lawyer and Richard Cook Thomas they alright Thomas.
@ThomasBoyd-lo9si
@ThomasBoyd-lo9si 11 күн бұрын
She Nicola sturgeon friend yes Thomas. Martin sellner Austrian like in Scotland yes Thomas.
@ThomasBoyd-lo9si
@ThomasBoyd-lo9si 11 күн бұрын
She prejudice to English people Carol Monaghon yes. She Anglo Irish Catholic. Her marriage real no Thomas.
@sandieknudsen9794
@sandieknudsen9794 11 күн бұрын
However, Mr Neil - the Scottish Government are NOT allowed to reduced income tax levels for anyone (that's just one of the poisoned chalice that we were handed on devolution). The land reform group have worked out that if landowners in Scotland were charged an appropriate land tax, we can scrap council tax altogether for everyone. I agree that offshore licences MUST be reviewed urgently.
@barrheadboy1684
@barrheadboy1684 11 күн бұрын
They can indeed reduce the taxes
@sandieknudsen9794
@sandieknudsen9794 11 күн бұрын
@@barrheadboy1684 I stand corrected, Roddy.
@MARINA4163
@MARINA4163 12 күн бұрын
Reform policies are very good ones. That is what is getting them votes. Look at those policies on tax.
@MARINA4163
@MARINA4163 12 күн бұрын
Does Alex Salmond listen to this? Will someone post this to him.
@MARINA4163
@MARINA4163 12 күн бұрын
Phil for FM!
@UnifiedPAIN
@UnifiedPAIN 12 күн бұрын
Scotland should stand for children's rights. What is this celebration of brokenness? Winning freedom? You are either free or you are not. What do yiu consider a Nazi? My children have been abducted to Poland and Scotland does not just ignore but will assust abusers. No independence strategy is needed when the streets and towns are polluted to this extent. Hope in a broken system? Can we meet and speak. Aren't you all sick of the feminist agenda thats broken our councils? Councillor'never changing as its all a conteol mechanism. Bringingup winter duel paymentsthe literacy of knowledge is sickeningly void. This is Scotlands voice. Memphis-Misraïm nonsense believing you can fix and move forward, this is delusional. government need to learn to govern? Realism is lacking here.
@barrheadboy1684
@barrheadboy1684 11 күн бұрын
This makes zero sense perhaps a native language speaker could rewrite it for you
@UnifiedPAIN
@UnifiedPAIN 11 күн бұрын
@@barrheadboy1684 which part makes zero sense? I wamt answers to what is actually going. Any brother Patriarch or Master could not be mistaken by any of the words used so who are you to question a valid sensible question? Take care, and I hope we all speak sense soon.
@MARINA4163
@MARINA4163 12 күн бұрын
Andy Wightman is brilliant. Such a shame we don't have him now.
@sandieknudsen9794
@sandieknudsen9794 11 күн бұрын
Eh? He's still alive, is he not?
@MARINA4163
@MARINA4163 12 күн бұрын
There is no doubt that Nichola was able to mobilise people BUT she sold out to the blob. That is what brought us down. It was a coup. Internal regime change.
@MARINA4163
@MARINA4163 12 күн бұрын
It is utterly ridiculous to suggest President Putin would ever even for a second contemplate invading the UK. Why would he for heavens sake! This is a propaganda statement of the deep state. We need to get back to neutrality as a policy.