Does anyone else find it strange that Aule compares his relationship with Eru like that of a child with his father as though such relationships already exist?

Does anyone know how Morgoth is feeding his hosts, given they spend all their time underground?

How many chapters is there of this book ?

Such a great chapter.

I really appreciate you showing maps and portraits. It makes the story much easier to follow, with it's preponderance of names.

31:32 Dior thinks the Silmaril energy might have burned out his parents. [immediately puts it on] bruhh 🤦‍♂️

I audibly gasped when Túrin killed Beleg in the dark. How tragic!

Just noticed these recent downloads & this one was very enjoyable, interesting & good narration.

Nice pictures

My middle name is Elrond Halfelven. Its actually on my birth certificate. I have a brother Thorin.

Such an interesting story. Not a gripping read though lol.

I like the "Noah's arc" story how one family was saved at the end of Numenor

The Ainulindale ---Tolkien's creative process!

We you get your ass kicked so bad that you literally never leave your house again. Fingolfin really had the last laugh.

This is an amazing job I just have one request… that you write the names on the screen of people, places or beings so we can see how they’re written 🙂

I honestly don't think that people realise that middle earth is only one part of a much larger world. Middle Earth is just one continent, in the same way that the European continent is referred to now. It is unfortunate, because so many more stories could be made regarding the world that Tolkien created. From what I can make of it, this entire work, is a remake, a reimaging of real myths, like King Arthur and his knights, and Atlantis, all roped together into a new story.

Where is P22-24 I was looking for the War of the Wrath section

My second favourote chapter, my favourite is when fingolfin gets pissed and goes to duel morgoth, my third is when Hurin kills like 150 dudes in a last stand

This was a beautiful reading of a beautiful book. Thank you for all the time you spent doing this 🙏

Dope

Eonwe is such a coward lol, he was so scared to do his job and hold him accountable himself that he actually sat there and told Morgoth’s right hand to just escort himself back to Valinor at his own leisure 🤦🏻‍♂️

What a sad chapter. I love the Silmarillion, but it breaks my heart every time I read it. Silmarillion and Children of Hurin just devastate me. Thank you for these audios. I’m typing this with tears streaming down my face. Again, Thank You!

"Eru, Arda is Dumb." - Aulë

Thank you so much for uploading these files. I have been looking for Silmarillion physicl book for years but it is still not available in my country and I could not be appreciated enough to have found your audiobook ^_^

Lol, Avalon...Cheeky bugger

Oh man, I feel silly. The Light of Eärendil- it didn't click for me until he showed up against the Dragon fleet. And then I swear, I totally didn't get teary eyed at all! 🥺✨

Day shall come again... I didn't expect to cry...🥺

I love listening to the stories of primordial Arda, and the ages and ages before even the lamps were around

Well hello my friend, Im so glad to come back and see how this has been gathering momentum. I was just thinking how this is much better use of your brain and time than say watching the rings of power, which honestly feels more like satire or a comical adaptation of Tolkien´s work. I remember coming upon your videos as I searched for Martin´s Shaw audiobook to accompany my reading, when you only had this and maybe Vlaquenta uploaded. I loved your videos so much because they saved me effort hehe, as when reading The Silmarillion I always have like maps of middle earth oppened, geneaologies, and all sorts of supportive materials to keep up and remember all the content being discussed in the text. Anyways, good stuff man, i look forward to rewatching your videos now that the whole Silmarillion is up, cheers.

My elder scrolls and osrs characters have forever been named Turin, or tulkas

I tell ya, if Mandos says something, bank on it.

Is this the full book? Or are there missing parts? It says 6 missing or hidden videos so, just before I start. Just wondering

Cant blame Manwe, bro has 0% evil in him the ever forgiveful one ^^

Feanor...You Fool

Perfeito. Melkor tocou funk durante a 9° sinfonia.

I believe that this story about a hapless chap and a psy-op dragon and some accidential incest is the one that is most influenced by The Kalevala (runes 31 through 36, the Kullervo cycle).

The fact that the Valar blatantly cheated by calling on the big brother to help against Ar-Pharazon is such a downer.

you probably tired of hearing this, but thank you! Started this today at work don’t think I’m gonna be able to stop till I finish

You have to wonder why they didn't just live further south. They literally made their Kingdom right on morgoth's doorstep needless to say leaving valinor probably wasn't the best idea

Is the full book in this audiobook?

I just found this. Thanks for doing it. I just rewatched all of LoTR extended editions, the Hobbit M4 fan edit (google this it’s great), and season 1 of Rings. Needed to refresh my silmarillion knowledge because that show is a bit trash.

I wish they made a real tv series or anime out of this fine book. No woke, no diversity bs just pure talent.

Thanks

Thanks

Noldor brothers might have started off with that bloody in the exile, but now they cleaned up those Dark forces. Of course, having so many skirmishes with the Orcs made them so good at fighting them. We laso see that Manweh was the one stationing Eagles everywhere, even establishing a bird hierarchy. Seeing a young Glaurung is interesting; it makes it cool to see a lizard breathing fire, retreating from arrows, then come back as a planetary threat.

Great job with the artwork adding visuals to the audio version...nice!

What an amazing journey! Thank you for this, you made this book much more understandable and I got chills as I read the last words! ❤️

Wow

This is the happiest story of the Silmilrilon

Thanks