Is cEDH Better After the Bans?
46:29
Top 10 cEDH Commanders | August 2024
1:04:30
Top 10 cEDH Commanders | July 2024
1:07:58
Top 10 cEDH Commanders from June 2024
1:40:38
Top 10 cEDH Commanders from May 2024
1:09:16
Пікірлер
@Meowmeowmeow41
@Meowmeowmeow41 4 сағат бұрын
#freenadu
@Crustgg
@Crustgg 11 сағат бұрын
Build shorikai on a podcast!
@TheKidsDaaaaad
@TheKidsDaaaaad 11 сағат бұрын
From what I understand.... Everything dies to removal unless you play Etali and then who cares, cast it again.
@akosimikeee
@akosimikeee 11 сағат бұрын
I think there should be kind of an exception with magda for the criteria being the average person since pretty much all magda players are specialists.
@jessebechard7512
@jessebechard7512 16 сағат бұрын
I completely agree with Cal's take on Yuriko. There are 4 Yuriko players at my LGS and I'm just not ever seen it do much besides dwindle away at life totals and then lose.
@Dubbios
@Dubbios 21 сағат бұрын
The fat guy on the left is the most famous worst player of cEDH... And his opinions are as good as his record.
@joshbarr810
@joshbarr810 Күн бұрын
2c sisay?
@Cepaceous
@Cepaceous Күн бұрын
How about Jund Rog?
@annienonmouse
@annienonmouse Күн бұрын
I hope only Yuriko wins tournaments from now on just to see Cal go insane
@maxalexa2
@maxalexa2 Күн бұрын
Post BAN SiSaY dEcK tEcH PLZZZZ
@andrewkelley6039
@andrewkelley6039 Күн бұрын
I feel like I have so many toes in different decks right now. Might need to cut some toes off and really only focus my toe into one deck right now.
@Nooorrriii
@Nooorrriii Күн бұрын
Honestly the reason I continue to play K’rrik even though I have access to 99% of the meta in foil and or foreign foil is exactly said in this video. Like you guys are shitting on it (and thanks for the shoutout) but I can post good numbers on it, like sure I play RogSi, I can play TnK, I can pick up TnT, but winning on K’rrik vs any of those decks just feels way more sweeter because K’rrik is absolute trash tier. I just can combine my table talk, meta deck building choices, and know my windows… plus I want to use my Russian foils of stupid black K’rrik staples lol.
@jamesgreenwood1703
@jamesgreenwood1703 Күн бұрын
Based take
@Nooorrriii
@Nooorrriii Күн бұрын
@ I’ve played a lot of the meta decks and done well but it doesn’t scratch the itch and just feel like I’m playing the same shit 90% of other people are playing and it doesn’t feel as satisfying.
@TheMindSculptors
@TheMindSculptors 15 сағат бұрын
I will have to change my rating because I like genuinely think the deck looks like an A when you play it. But that also is part of the whole Great players can elevate decks things too. Respect tf out of you 🫡
@Nooorrriii
@Nooorrriii 9 сағат бұрын
@@TheMindSculptors I try! It’s very hard and honestly I have the mentality of being patient and finding a window and also if K’rrik dies I’m all about winning without him. I won round 2 of The Boil 2 without ever casting him.
@maxalexa2
@maxalexa2 Күн бұрын
Post Ban Sisay Deck Tech PLZ
@BrashM
@BrashM Күн бұрын
There are always going to be new or lazy players. But I think tier lists should look at the ceiling over the “average”. And to that point I believe creators underestimate what the average cedh player looks like. It’s Ccccccedh. C for competitive, not casual.
@MOSTLYxTOAST
@MOSTLYxTOAST Күн бұрын
47:42 worth noting that Malcolm + glinthorn combo works through Orcish Bowmasters because of the way Glinthorn’s abilities are split up, you’re able to keep activating on top of each bowmaster trigger to go off again. Also I’m glad you mentioned blood moons in Malcolm Kediss because I think they’re criminally underplayed in that deck.
@maxalexa2
@maxalexa2 Күн бұрын
POST Ban Sisay Deck Tech PLZ
@wiesegamez7219
@wiesegamez7219 Күн бұрын
I wonder if they’ll do Rocco
@BrashM
@BrashM Күн бұрын
Talion has seemed even stronger since the bans
@BrashM
@BrashM Күн бұрын
Cal is just mad that Magda is better than Tivit 😂
@bensawmiller3005
@bensawmiller3005 Күн бұрын
I have mixed feelings on the Shorikai takes. i for sure agree that humility gets too much emphasis, i think people see a non creature commander and instinctively go to humility, which on a base level i understand. Where I disagree is with calling it not a control deck; as Ian said, Shorikai is great at winning the game eventually, it can set up these layered engines that end up digging you like 8-12 cards deep in a turn cycle, all while being able to hold up interaction, and kind of just sit on these draw engines for many turns. Synergies with the keys, maybe unwinding clocks, and then most notably all the nutty draw engines in UW, i think the optimal way to play it is to just be the one getting more advantage than everyone else, combined with some stax pieces and tons if interaction. But don’t play humility
@TheMindSculptors
@TheMindSculptors Күн бұрын
I feel like that is almost more akin to like Lantern Control which like. Technically is a control deck, but I feel like that is fundamentally different than traditional control. Or the third option is I have just been arguing semantics (which is likely 😂)
@bensawmiller3005
@bensawmiller3005 Күн бұрын
⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠@@TheMindSculptorslantern control is a pretty perfect comparison and i wake up every morning and miss that deck in modern. i think you’re so fair to say Shorikai plays differently from the Talions and the Tivits in that it doesnt do the classic control plan, it just sort of plats very well into longer games perhaps
@jasonsommerfelt9541
@jasonsommerfelt9541 Күн бұрын
What is the correct way to build Shorkai?
@bensawmiller3005
@bensawmiller3005 Күн бұрын
I have had success building it as control, i commented a whole essay about it, but you want to put yourself in a position where you are just out valuing the table. Play all the manifold key effects, which work great with shorikai and of course the one ring, play all the rhustics mystics, and sentiels, maybe unwinding clocks. You want to set up a position where you are just able to sit on tons of card draw, maybe stax the game down with avens, cursed totems, grafdiggers, dranniths, etc., and just grind better than everyone else while interacting
@adambuetow
@adambuetow Күн бұрын
Im curious to see part two!my krark brain only watched krark-saka. But going to finish the rest now. I really think krark-si has equal or more to offer than its krark-saka storm counterpart, so maybe it makes part two once we get to the 3 color pairings🤞 Great vid as usual
@williamtrauthen5173
@williamtrauthen5173 Күн бұрын
I was playing the air trumpet army eulogy before I saw your ranking for Niv Mizzet Parun lol. I have been a niv pilot for years, and 2 days after the bans and play testing, I took it apart and turned it into Stella Lee. The mana pips are just too intensive to get Niv out early for any explosive wins that Stella or krark/sakashima can achieve like 2 turns earlier and more consistently.
@maxalexa2
@maxalexa2 Күн бұрын
SISAY post ban deck tech plzzz
@morsdraconis
@morsdraconis Күн бұрын
Poor Niv.Sad my baby is so dead we're playing bad cards like Geode Golem and Lotus Bloom tech with Goblin Engineer/Welder/Whir of Invention to get Niv into play by turn 4 on average. It's a more consistent deck, but WAY less explosive compared to Jeweled Lotus and Dockside being unbanned. Maybe I can hire Ian to make a working model of the deck.
@jmandelli
@jmandelli Күн бұрын
Yuriko is a real deck Cal sorry to tell you!
@sergioperez2771
@sergioperez2771 Күн бұрын
Real bad.
@sergioperez2771
@sergioperez2771 Күн бұрын
Real bad.
@dvdpekard
@dvdpekard Күн бұрын
I'm a Talion main and I've strayed from the "traditional" path. Turned it into a more Aggro deck, to accelerate the clock on my opponents life points. And I only interact to stop a player, I let everyone play out, and they eventually kill themselves through life loss and my Combat Damage.
@BudgetPubStomper-lr7nh
@BudgetPubStomper-lr7nh Күн бұрын
Shadow of mortality is bad in Yuriko because all it does it 45 damage to the table.. and, also,. Sheoldred is a good cedh card 🤔 Love you bud but that maybe doesn’t check out,
@jonaingo29
@jonaingo29 Күн бұрын
54:00 Splinter Twin was unbanned in Modern today 😂
@VictorBenitez-k7v
@VictorBenitez-k7v Күн бұрын
splinter twin reference and its unbanned today in modern
@maxalexa2
@maxalexa2 Күн бұрын
Post ban sisay deck tech PLZZZZZ
@jacobdavis9424
@jacobdavis9424 Күн бұрын
Perfect. I'm trying to pick a new deck. This will help, thanks!
@dominicyanez7960
@dominicyanez7960 Күн бұрын
Ob deserves more love! I do agree with your points bad players should stay away. But when piloted correctly ob can grind through 3 blue decks and all of the interaction.
@Uri6060
@Uri6060 Күн бұрын
Super hyped to see this as I always think decks more than the top 10 are interesting af so thx abunch <3 (Just recently watch 2021s)
@ChrisDavis-tt1dj
@ChrisDavis-tt1dj Күн бұрын
Yuriko, let’s go! I was that guy that won a tourney last month. Agreed the new Kaito is great. I think the reason we don’t play Top and Scroll Rack anymore is because of our greedy manabases. I am only on 27 lands plus a few MDFCs. Swapping out Scroll Rack or Top for 2 additional Stax or Control pieces will often buy us time to push through to the late game. I will usually mulligan aggressively against turbo decks like Rogue/Si or combo. Every other deck in the format is a pretty even match for us in my opinion.
@kaneschepperley9205
@kaneschepperley9205 Күн бұрын
No scroll rack?
@kaneschepperley9205
@kaneschepperley9205 Күн бұрын
Congratulations 🎊
@ChrisDavis-tt1dj
@ChrisDavis-tt1dj Күн бұрын
@@kaneschepperley9205 Thanks
@WolfLink64
@WolfLink64 Күн бұрын
Yeah what the host on the left side fails to mention is that Yuriko is still basically a 2 color Tymna who's gonna pressure your life total and cheat on commander tax. Doesn't that count for anything? That is plenty of reason to consider being less colors, and you get to keep the two best ones.
@LateTeens709
@LateTeens709 19 сағат бұрын
I agree. It's way better for yuriko decks to be on Nullrod than scroll rack and top.
@ethanhickle2929
@ethanhickle2929 Күн бұрын
I never thought I’d hear Kirk Cousins and Urza in the same sentence 😂
@ChrisDavis-tt1dj
@ChrisDavis-tt1dj 18 сағат бұрын
@@ethanhickle2929 Same. I was thinking Ohio State chocked against Michigan recently, but we won’t talk about Clemson v. Carolina either. Sorry Callahan 😀.
@ethanhickle2929
@ethanhickle2929 Күн бұрын
I’m excited for this!
@natty1115
@natty1115 Күн бұрын
Tier list yess
@TheHorriblificDR
@TheHorriblificDR Күн бұрын
First, to spell first correctly! Victory was achieved today.
@andrewajumper2
@andrewajumper2 Күн бұрын
Forst
@andrewajumper2
@andrewajumper2 Күн бұрын
Can’t believe tatyova was tier 1.
@malcolmb2019
@malcolmb2019 3 күн бұрын
Love to see some of the deep tech getting some light shone on it. Martial Paragon hits that surprising spot and fills a particular niche really strongly
@jacobburrows311
@jacobburrows311 4 күн бұрын
17:07 Shhh dont tell the devs, but you can enter any value for tournament size in the URL and it works.
@impendio
@impendio 4 күн бұрын
>tymna ban The salt lmao
@Master_Spliff
@Master_Spliff 5 күн бұрын
How does someone win 7 rounds in 14 turns??? Does no one hold up interaction anymore??? That sounds like a dream for my Magda deck.
@spykeborg6
@spykeborg6 6 күн бұрын
Automatic option was streamlined to 60 and 100 but you should still be able to filter edhtop16's participant count by editing the url.
@TheMindSculptors
@TheMindSculptors 5 күн бұрын
Annoying i have to edit the url to get the results. Thanks for the tip! That helps a lot!
@guimartgon
@guimartgon 6 күн бұрын
Offering to algorythm Jesus 🙏
@Wavy_hashira
@Wavy_hashira 6 күн бұрын
Glaaaaarb, I’ve been jamming Glarb in some Spelltable leagues, looking to do some tournaments this upcoming year with my build, I’m on a Hermit Druid build which has been a lot of fun
@BrianRoss-d9f
@BrianRoss-d9f 6 күн бұрын
When talking about what cards people are running in tournaments, it’s important to remember that some tournaments are no proxy. I played in SCG Columbus and helped ruin the winning percentage for Kinnan, but also was missing about 20 cards due to not owning them.
@Master_Spliff
@Master_Spliff 5 күн бұрын
Why tournament organizers won't allow proxies is beyond me. We don't have that problem here in Arizona. This is the most expensive format besides vintage, no reason we should be forcing players to spend between 1K-5K per deck.
@KarenSmith-z4h
@KarenSmith-z4h 7 күн бұрын
Love the podcast, as always, but Cal, you railroad Ian so many times on this one. I don't think you mean to, but you cut Ian off at least a dozen times. I can't imagine what it's like to try to maintain the momentum of a podcast, so what does my opinion matter, but just wanted to share that feedback. Love what you all do!
@your_priscylla
@your_priscylla 7 күн бұрын
My recent tier list I made was basically “S tier is most 4c midrange piles, A tier is like 10+ decks, B tier is everything that is sooo close to A” I love this meta so much