Good video… I can’t believe we’re doing an autopsy on a $10 knife. I can’t believe a $10 wore out…I would take that POS back and get my money back and go buy a bench made for $175 which will last forever…😩😩😩
@victorguerin52525 күн бұрын
I dumped all my knives. I only carry these budget gems now. Im free. And love it
@photobooknet6 күн бұрын
thx
@bboyshr68 күн бұрын
Great review, thanks! I love the Para3 in s45vn for of edge retention and sharpenability.I am curious would the new Para 3 in magnacut hold a fine edge longer and would s45vn hold it's working edge longer. I presume that Spyderco will do magtnacut justice as they nailed the heat treatment on their stuff so far. Any chance you might be reviewing it at some time?
@bboyshr68 күн бұрын
sorry, I just saw the Spyderco Mule test in magnacut and it does seem a little better than s45vn but not by much. However that was @62hrc, and I saw claims that the Native 5 Salt is already @64 hrc, so it makes me wonder where they landed on the new para 3
@Outpost_766 күн бұрын
That's hard to say without testing any to see where they ended up. They do vary as well so one may be 62 while another is 64.
@daveg44009 күн бұрын
Dude, it’s a ten dollar knife. You’re acting like you just dissected a Spyderco and came across cheap QC issues. It’s 10 bucks, not 250. It didn’t ask to go viral. The fact is better than most other 20 dollar knives is why people went googly. Still worth ten bucks. But it really is a buyout clone that is amazing.
@SirPraiseSun12 күн бұрын
what about machetes in 3cr13? is it okay if its made well? quality steel machetes and axes get expensive.
@Outpost_7612 күн бұрын
I should do a video about that. I needed a chopper while states away from home and bought a cheap one. It's a 3cr13 deal that was cheap and it's still doing fine. I still use it on my land too see what the limit is.
@gregblake276412 күн бұрын
Four years later and I had to vigorously sharpen my M4 Super Freek 8 times before I got down to the good steel.
@Outpost_7612 күн бұрын
It's too bad because it's a great design.
@lionknives313 күн бұрын
Hey G, if you are member of the Millie group on Facebook, i posted a video 2 days ago with my Rex 45 Native Chief. I shaved a steel nail almost to the half and nothing happened. It's still cutting phone book paper without hang Up. Did the same with k390 some week's ago, and k390 took some damage. Rex 45 earned my respect. Greetings from Austria Europe
@Outpost_7612 күн бұрын
I did see that video you posted, I enjoyed it. The Rex 45 I have at 67.4 is much better than the softer 65.5 Rex 45 I have. I'm going through some edges on each now to do a video comparison between the two.
@miaminarc14 күн бұрын
Hey triple "F" for 9.99$ there's no issues with it !!! (triple f, fat-fingers-Freddy) . And trim you nails.
@GeeSpell15 күн бұрын
I am considering getting a knife from Roman in either S390 or Vancron. I don’t believe I ever saw you post a polished edge Vancron test but from your usage which of those two steel would you lean towards?
@Outpost_7612 күн бұрын
Either one will do well, both were close in testing. Let Roman know what your use will be and he will set you up.
@GeeSpell12 күн бұрын
@Outpost_76 yeah I figured there wasn’t much difference but I wanted to see if the fine edge Vancron for some reason was much better than the S390. I was looking to get a high hardness tough slicer since I have a Nitrobe77 Turbo already which is great but sometimes the thick blade stock doesn’t feel great when I do something like light food prep when I’m out with my toddlers. Also, I’ve had the edge see some deformation so I wanted to get something higher hardness with more toughness for better edge stability.
@athappyhiker15 күн бұрын
If you have average sized hands and you don't use your knives to carve metal with... this knife is da bomb for a larger folder. The Triad Lock system is rock solid and does NOT loosen up as the knife wears in; its design keeps it locked tight. Besides the pocket clip being a bit too large, and the jimping cuts not going all the way through the lock bar (like they do on the Cold Steel Ultimate Hunter), I really like this knife. I have the UH as well and it's a great knife too; lighter, thinner handle, 90 deg. spine (which the AD10 does not have - which is a minus if you want to use a ferro rod with it), and has more open grip room/design. But the AD10 is a smoother action to open & close if that matters to you, it has more heft to it for deep cuts if needed, and is theoretically stronger b/c of the liners. I get that these youtube vids are over-the-top and often border on what most would consider foolish abuse of a knife, and are done for view counts and to show what a blade is capable of in the extreme, but keep in mind what YOU would be using the knife for 99.9% of the time and if it represents a satisfactory tool for you and a good value. For $100 - $150 both the AD10 and the UH completely meet those standards.
@brianc001916 күн бұрын
How’s TRM’s magnacut?
@Outpost_7612 күн бұрын
I haven't had any to use or test yet to be able to have an opinion.
@Michael-dj4iq17 күн бұрын
Over all good smooth action. Chippy reprofiled, nailed a continuous bevel. I can get mine scary face shaving sharp. But unfortunately chippy steel. To hard , I think rc is maybe 62 63 not enough time coming off the heat treat. But still a great user friendly knife! Deer skinning fool. Just don't touch bone.. 3v is the best I have all the high end knives . Bark river 3v is bad ass!!!
@Michael-dj4iq17 күн бұрын
Mine I can get deadly sharp. Reprofiled the blade convexed, still chippy
@stevenlachance857618 күн бұрын
I’ve given away a few shuffles so now im feeling better about it.
@HighCRI18 күн бұрын
I’m glad to see those results! The Shuffle II was my first knife from a reputable brand and also the only knife I’ve had where the steel performance was noticeably shitty even as an average person. I loved the knife otherwise so I may have to pick one up again.
@Obsidian-One20 күн бұрын
So how come i can't look up test results anymore? Ive been watching you for years and now i can't see the results anymore? I was about to donate a knife, but not if i can't lookup the results!?
@Outpost_7620 күн бұрын
The Google sheet was lost and I'm slowly making a new one.
@Obsidian-One20 күн бұрын
I guess im going to have to go through all your videos and collect my own data. Because ive been watching you for years and now i can't even look at the results!? I was about to donate a knife, but not if i can't even look up the results!
@drouleau21 күн бұрын
Looks good to me (and just ordered a Manix 2 in SPY27 last night actually). Not really paying much attention the steel snob comments below, but this does exactly what I'd want.....holds an edge for an acceptable amount of time but is super easy to bring back. That's what you want in a knife you're going to use. I never use any of my "good" knives to break down cardboard - that's what I have a cheap utility knife for with disposable razor blades (that I have in bulk which I'll never run out of in my lifetime).....so for most day-to-day normal usage that people do (opening Amazon packages, fidgeting, fondling and cutting themselves), this steel should be just fine.
@mikafoxx271722 күн бұрын
If it's from Walmart, it's a GreatValue.
@mikafoxx271722 күн бұрын
Wow, for ten bucks that competes pretty well with other cheap knives. Is it hard? Usually D2 can't be heat treated to less than about 60, thankfully. Not very durable but hell, its good enough and chrome carbides can be sharpened on ceramic unlike vanadium or tungsten carbides, which are harder than the stone.
@mikafoxx271722 күн бұрын
The best steel is the one with the best heat treatment. If you want a great knife, get a custom from someone that knows how to get the most out of steel, but spiderco very rarely disappoints, unlike benchmade or others. Either stick to cheap knives like mora, opinel, civivi that get the job done, but spiderco or a custom for the best heat treatment.
@merrickx23 күн бұрын
This thing is kinda nice to have a small, sturdy beater. I think I paid like $7 for mine.
@spocker2223 күн бұрын
Had one of these in 8cr... Same results
@bazzzker23 күн бұрын
There are talks in-between sharpening community that you should use coarser finishes with low level steels. Could you test something like 40 deg, 80/63 microns(180-200 grit)?
@mikafoxx271721 күн бұрын
40 degrees, ouch.
@bazzzker21 күн бұрын
@@mikafoxx2717 full angle. 20 per side
@Outpost_7612 күн бұрын
I work in a 15 dps coarse finish and see how it compares.
@bazzzker12 күн бұрын
@@Outpost_76 thanks
@ct236824 күн бұрын
Damn, even bad m390 doesn't do much better than that.
@patrickvanovermeeren451324 күн бұрын
That is pretty nice for that steel !! Thanks for the testing and sharing !!
@Keith_the_knife_freak24 күн бұрын
Nice 👍
@N2EWSRadio24 күн бұрын
I just bought one of those (that is, it just arrived). It's handy. Very slicey factory edge. My S&W is garbage.
@joshuabriggs711424 күн бұрын
Interesting result. Looks fairly thin behind the edge for a budget utility knife.
@thaknobodi24 күн бұрын
Ive handled a few newer budget kershaws and the hollowgrind ones are civivi levels thin bte
@Outpost_7624 күн бұрын
I do have an old Shuffle that's 5 years old or more that I now need to test and see what the difference is.
@nitrotmann24 күн бұрын
Looking forward to the testing. I like those cjrbs.
@jamesd492324 күн бұрын
If you're gonna wait years to review something no need watching your channel.😂
@timbo437424 күн бұрын
It's good to see you making these testing vids again G! I'm sure that the budget buyers will appreciate this run!
@kroodle824 күн бұрын
Smith snd Weston makes some tacky knives
@thomasrobarts239925 күн бұрын
Glad you did this dodged a bullet in not buying it.
@Outpost_7624 күн бұрын
Its too bad because it's a decent knife outside of the studs and geometry.
@machinaexmente272925 күн бұрын
Scraping the bottom of the barrel here...
@Outpost_7624 күн бұрын
Most was donated or given. I will agree most of these I wouldn't carry.
@cicerolaska25 күн бұрын
Mainly want to see the red/black caldera. That last knife curious to see how it handles for being so cheap. Also how do we enter the give aways?
@Outpost_7624 күн бұрын
The giveaway ones will be in the videos for edge retention testing.
@ct236825 күн бұрын
Really want to see the arrpm9
@tombrown468325 күн бұрын
Im looking forward to those videos. I don't have any of those but considered buying the Caldera. I'm curious about the performance of low cost knives.
@Outpost_7624 күн бұрын
The RPM9 should be up next week once the other new example gets to me.
@floraly8829 күн бұрын
Fine edge means that it's still shaving, right?
@Outpost_7628 күн бұрын
Yes
@floraly8828 күн бұрын
@@Outpost_76 Alright. Your channel showed me that I'm definitely doing something wrong. I get a good razor edge but it's gone after only a few cuts (the working edge stays for a long time tough). And I always thought it's maybe the steel or heat treat but now I saw in your vids that even cheapo knives hold the "fine edge" for many cuts.
@ThirdoptionJCSUАй бұрын
My is extremely sharp and stropping very well.Much better than s35vn and s30v for sure.
@ThirdoptionJCSUАй бұрын
K390,Cru Wear,K294 are just great.
@ThirdoptionJCSUАй бұрын
I have problem to sharpen my Kizer in 4v. Any idea how to sharpen 4v?
@Outpost_76Ай бұрын
What are you using to sharpen it now that isn't working?
@ThirdoptionJCSUАй бұрын
@@Outpost_76 diamond stones
@ThirdoptionJCSUАй бұрын
@@Outpost_76 No matter how I've tried it just doesn't get to the shaving sharp level
@dewetrobertson1752Ай бұрын
Can you please make a video and rank the steels you have tested would be very interesting thanks
@Outpost_76Ай бұрын
I'll put the data together and see how I can make it into a video that doesn't take up too much time.
@maurice-iu4dnАй бұрын
who is kurt and where can i find the hrc data?
@drmodestoesqАй бұрын
I guess you could replace the bearing ring with a bronze washer. It would make it harder to open and close....but it would be more robust.
@duckpwndАй бұрын
The fact of the matter is that this is an amazing knife and one of the overall best knives ever created. For only $10, you're getting a knife that's 95% as good as anything that Benchmade sells. Thanks to their brilliant innovations in manufacturing and supply chains, Walmart has brought the consumers an amazing and extremely high quality knife at a bargain price.
@Outpost_76Ай бұрын
This knfe isn't high quality or even quality. It's exactly what it is a 10 dollar knife. The bearings knurled the liners and that alone takes any quality out of it. For D2 the heat treat is a little above average. After that it goes down hill fast and shows why the price is low.
@duckpwndАй бұрын
@@Outpost_76 We'll have to respectfully disagree on that. I know that if I was going to be dropped off in the wilderness and only given one knife, even if money was no object I would still choose this Ozark knife. I think that most people who aren't biased or loyal to a particular brand would agree with me.
@cody3078Ай бұрын
Have you ever tested any Chris Reeve Magnacut? I’d love to see that