Пікірлер
@NathanielMiller
@NathanielMiller Сағат бұрын
Trivia: the alien in the tube was played by Doug Jones. The bullet trains were actually in the first episode. They chose to change the uniform to match the ship, rather than the ship itself. Changing your password every 90 days has always been stupid advice; the industry has finally come around to that and official guidelines have (mostly) been changed. It's far more important that you use different passwords for each place you need one [disclosure: a lot of my job is IT Security] The unknown noise sounded a lot like a zipper in the dryer. RIP, Patti Yasutake (actress who played Nurse Ogawa). She died a few weeks ago. The guard was turning away because he was withdrawing into the tram car. I never thought he moved to shield Max, either. Remember that Gideon couldn't hear the whole "I know where to find it." That was all in the alien's head. How the plague works will be explained later. It's not as simple as first suggested. The whole "trust me" bit was definitely a writing tool to build dramatic tension. The best explanation I can offer is that Eilerson wanted to check with the doctors that the guard would survive long enough for the plan to work, THEN told Matheson. Decompression doesn't happen quite that fast; the end-effect would be...ugly...but not explosive. It definitely wouldn't happen the way they show, but they also couldn't show what would actually happen (either because of effects limitations, or TV decency rules). Your blood will boil away, and your eyes will pop out of their sockets. The idea was supposed to be that Wells was running to the airlock to try and get into a suit (like on the other ship they transferred into one person in the tube), but found someone already in a suit and transferred to him because it was faster. I can't recall if Dr. Chambers is military; she may be a civilian. 65 Starfleet is ridiculously officer-heavy. Even a Ford-class carrier, which for a ship is very officer-heavy due to the air wing, only has 508 officers vs 3789 enlisted. P.S.: Brent, hope the hurricane didn't affect you too badly.
@ianstopher9111
@ianstopher9111 4 сағат бұрын
Speaking to the way the doctor talks to Capt. Gideon. My wife is a civilian in the military but due to her responsibility for budgeting in her area, she is accorded a measure of respect. She would not undermine the chain of command when lower ranks were present, but the Chief of Army had a nickname for her, and she was allowed to use his nickname. There is a different level of formality.
@la_scrittice_vita
@la_scrittice_vita 4 сағат бұрын
Love your attitude, Brent. Enjoying it for what it is, not trying to make it into Citizen Kane like some fans or being a bored, pretentious asshat because it's not.
@wrorchestra1
@wrorchestra1 4 сағат бұрын
The Triluminary is the one Sinclair used in the chrysalis device. It's keyed to his DNA. This is a pre-destination paradox. They chose him, the Great Machine made the device for him to use, he goes back with it and becomes Valenn, they use it to scan him after his capture and it reacts to his DNA. They chose him as commander of B5, he ends up on Minbar, goes to B4 and takes it back on time - the cycle completes. It also reacts to Delenn because she is a descendant of Valenn and so shares some of Sinclair's DNA.
@OMAROMAR79
@OMAROMAR79 19 сағат бұрын
65
@theknave69
@theknave69 19 сағат бұрын
Jeff: "The body needs all the parts it has." Me: "What about the appendix?"
@kairo_47
@kairo_47 10 сағат бұрын
The appendix has a useful function in the immune system. But the body can work with a slightly weakened immune system, just like it can work without a finger or tow. So "needs" in that sentence is relative, I guess, depending on how you define it.
@MoOrion
@MoOrion 19 сағат бұрын
Surviving vacuum. Pressure difference: Divers experience "the Bends" when they rise from the higher pressure depths of water to the lower pressure surface too quickly. The quick reduction of pressure causes their blood to boil. The same thing happens when exposed to vacuum. But the pressure difference is only 1 atm... it isn't very much. Divers experience a much greater pressure difference. So you won't explode as your body is strong enough to contain your internal pressure. But you will swell. And your blood will boil... as in the Bends. Useful consciousness: You can't hold your breath... the air in your lungs will be pulled out of you... and then your lungs will work in reverse to pull gas out of your blood. When airline planes depressurize at altitude the passengers have about 20-30 seconds of useful consciousness to put on the oxygen masks. That's basically the same as being exposed to vacuum. You can survive longer than you can remain conscious. I would say about 1-2 minutes maximum.
@MoOrion
@MoOrion 20 сағат бұрын
you know... I think it's possible you may be a bit over stating the "paint by numbers" nature of this... because you've seen versions of this story... that came out after this. I, myself have seem many versions of this... but as I sit here thinking about it... Every one I can think of came out after this. Can anyone think of an example that came before this? I wonder where the inspiration came from... could this be close to the origin of the trope and not a paint by numbers version?
@terryhopkins1466
@terryhopkins1466 23 сағат бұрын
Why did Wells become the spokesperson? How about this? What is transfered is the same alien essence that contains everything about the species, but it doesn't replace the personality of the new host. It combines with it, so the resulting entity is part the original. That part includes personality and existing skills. So Wells, as the consumate surviver and manipulate, who among the rest of the converts would be more qualified?
@oenrn
@oenrn 15 сағат бұрын
Also, you don't cast John Vickery for an episode and then give him just 2 lines. That would be a waste of an actor.
@bekkers29
@bekkers29 Күн бұрын
Did anyone else see the ending coming from the second the doctor said the dude was brain dead? There was zero reason to keep his body alive except for the plot contrivance.
@RCanadian
@RCanadian Күн бұрын
"I will meet you in the Mutai,' 🤣🤣🤣.
@dominicburns-k8f
@dominicburns-k8f Күн бұрын
Sorry am I wrong but isn't episode 3 the well of sorrows? This is episode 8
@hornorsilk2901
@hornorsilk2901 Күн бұрын
there are many watch orders -- and they are following one given to them
@dominicburns-k8f
@dominicburns-k8f Күн бұрын
@@hornorsilk2901 got it thanks
@dll_Rhemuth948
@dll_Rhemuth948 Күн бұрын
I always thought this episode was just a parody of Star Trek. The overacting of John Vickory as he stumbling to the airlock, reminded me so much of Kirk. Way too much overacting, way too much old sci-fi tropes. It was a parody of Star Trek.
@dll_Rhemuth948
@dll_Rhemuth948 Күн бұрын
Gideon had mag boots on. Because remember in one of the first episodes with Sheridan, he was walking out to the edge of the spiky things on the end of Babylon 5 just so he could get some air. Gideon was a explorer ship captain, it would follow that he would have access to such boots.
@dll_Rhemuth948
@dll_Rhemuth948 Күн бұрын
When the alien exploded, a shape came out of the flames… Was that similar to the one that was on the USS Kopernikus in the long dark?
@dll_Rhemuth948
@dll_Rhemuth948 Күн бұрын
JMS is so determined to reboot B5, I wonder why he hasn’t thought of rebooting Crusade instead. B5 was pretty well complete…Crusade, definitely not.
@TheCrazyPlayer
@TheCrazyPlayer 21 сағат бұрын
I’ve been saying something similar.
@oenrn
@oenrn 15 сағат бұрын
TNT likely holds the rights to the show, and won't be selling those anytime soon. For the same reason Fox will never sell the rights to Firefly: if you cancel something prematurely and someone else manages to make it a success, it'll make you look stupid.
@la_scrittice_vita
@la_scrittice_vita 4 сағат бұрын
B5 was the story he wanted to tell. Crusade was junk food. It never anything but a deal he made to get season 5 on the can without studio interference. It was a receptacle for all if their dumb ideas to make it more like TNT's Trek. It's nothing. If you like it, be like Brent. Enjoy it but recognize it's empty calories. There is nothing of value to save.b
@thekc1701
@thekc1701 Күн бұрын
You're not supposed to like Eilerson. He's basically the Rodney McKay of Crusade. I suspect, like Rodney, there was a plan to soften him over time as a character arc, but since the series was cancelled, it never came to pass.
@saberstrike000
@saberstrike000 Сағат бұрын
I also saw him as a proto Rodney. Especially in Rodney's early episodes, he has a lot of the same toxic mannerisms. I think beyond the the fact that Rodney had the screen time for development, he also got constantly slapped down and proven wrong by the people. He was a jerk to. Max doesn't get a lot of that and comes more across as a somewhat necessary evil
@jasonmchale2030
@jasonmchale2030 Күн бұрын
Email sent explaining the history of my screen name! Too funny to hear the first attempts at saying it but by the end, you both got it right! "Done Drah Doll!"
@sarahlipman7337
@sarahlipman7337 Күн бұрын
65!
@flyingfiddler90q
@flyingfiddler90q Күн бұрын
I hope you can start doing 2 of these per week, because 15 years is a long time to wait until the end of Stargate...
@lunnunis
@lunnunis Күн бұрын
65
@Thraxis
@Thraxis Күн бұрын
breaking out the initech mug for Lumburg
@alvincura
@alvincura Күн бұрын
The reality is that regular password changing is a good practice.
@kairo_47
@kairo_47 10 сағат бұрын
Nope, it's not. It leads to people using weaker passwords overall so they can remember what their "current" password is. At least that's what security specialists have been telling me over and over.
@alvincura
@alvincura 6 сағат бұрын
@@kairo_47 that is true. When password complexity is not enforced.
@kairo_47
@kairo_47 6 сағат бұрын
@@alvincura From what those experts tell me, it's always true. The kind of "password complexity rules" we often see are also a bad measure for how guessable they are.
@alvincura
@alvincura 6 сағат бұрын
@@kairo_47 I'm not sure that this is really the right place for a deep dive discussion on the topic, or even worse a debate. But perhaps we can leave it at positing that, the guessing of a password is less efficient of an exploit than using a captured password. And from that, let us similarly posit, that passwords are captured all the time. Hence why it is good for them to be changed regularly with complex passwords. Finally. Perhaps we can posit or ponder that security is achieved through inconvenience. That if a system is hard for an authorized user to use, it is even harder for an unauthorized user to use. This is where pass keys and bio keys and multi-factor authentication mechanisms come into play.
@kairo_47
@kairo_47 5 сағат бұрын
@@alvincura Both of your assumptions sound true but are not really correct according to what I hear from security experts. But yes, here is probably not the right venue for discussing that.
@BennoWitter
@BennoWitter Күн бұрын
You saw who is doing the science advising for this? It's NASA JPL.
@la_scrittice_vita
@la_scrittice_vita 3 сағат бұрын
They're insufferable when they think their grasp of scientific concepts overrules the actual scientists consulting. "The consultant must have been at lunch" is why I can rarely finish one of these episodes.
@Unicronsupreme
@Unicronsupreme Күн бұрын
The big mouth scream is a reference to invasion of the body snatchers.
@shellock2592
@shellock2592 Күн бұрын
How much better would crusade be if rescored?
@stuartwald2395
@stuartwald2395 Күн бұрын
In a vacuum, a human body would not "explode"; it has greater durability than that. Within that first minute (until you pass out early on and eventually die within 2 minutes), you will have capillaries rupturing all over your skin surface (so lots of hematomas and relatively minor exposed bleeding), followed by heating within the body (lots of gas bubbles) and freezing where the air and fluids are leaving the body (from evaporation). A person would also start to lose control over bladder and bowels, and muscles would expand and seize up causing further blood pooling.
@superlaser8559
@superlaser8559 Күн бұрын
My read on the alien suddenly knowing about a cure is that we're just hearing their internal monologue. We haven't seen them use telepathy and they're trapped in a body that can't physically speak, so Gideon can't hear it anyway. I think it was just a way to add a teensy bit of overall plot spice to an otherwise pretty standalone episode.
@waltermc3906
@waltermc3906 Күн бұрын
The last words/thoughts of the alien were pretty damn important.... "... I know what you are looking for. I can tell you where to find it." The alien knew how to find the cure to the Drahk plague.
@MattLathrum
@MattLathrum Күн бұрын
Or was it just desperation to live?
@robertatkinson4968
@robertatkinson4968 Күн бұрын
A good friend who was in charge of the reactor on the sub told me to read Blind Man's Bluff to understand submarine culture, have you read it and do you agree? Did you have a nick name? He had one, the called him Budda, because he was the keeper of the Great Machine.
@Chetverikov
@Chetverikov Күн бұрын
Captain's Mast is the Navy term for an Article 15: Summary Non-Judicial Punishment. Max penalty of an Article 15 varies by the rank of the officer issuing the penalties but maxes at demotion to E-1 (if E-4 or below) or two pay grades if E-5 or above, forfeiture of up to 1/2 of pay and allowances for up to three months, 30 days confinement/brig time, 60 days extra duty, 60 days confinement to barracks when not on duty,
@Petrosman
@Petrosman Күн бұрын
You know who Eilerson reminds me of a lot? (slight spoiler for Jeff) McKay from SGA. And yet McKay over time becomes a fan favorite. You're supposed to hate Eilerson, but over time I'm sure we would start liking him.
@simongiles9749
@simongiles9749 Күн бұрын
It's interesting to see Medusa Cascade's responses to Eilerson. She used the JMS Recommended order (that pushes this one to the end), and following that you can see how the layers of Eilerson are peeled beck from "annoying berk" to "okay, I can see *why* he's an annoying berk". (I actually rather like him. He's a bit like Avon from Blakes Seven. Or Jaime Lannister.)
@patrickelliott2169
@patrickelliott2169 Күн бұрын
Was pretty much going to mention the same similarity. But, McKay got a whole season of SG: Atlantis to redeem his character. If he had remained a one off, or just occasional annoyance in SG-1....
@oenrn
@oenrn 15 сағат бұрын
He also reminds me of House: he's the jerk that everyone can't stand but people put up with because he cuts through the BS and gets the job done, and is damn good at it.
@Petrosman
@Petrosman 11 сағат бұрын
@@patrickelliott2169 like Lucius, yeah, would have been bad. And it's annoying too, cause they got a very good actor for that role.
@neilbiggs1353
@neilbiggs1353 Күн бұрын
I think one of my favourite moments of a character being more than they were initially presented as was Landry Clark in Friday Night Lights. He never stopped being a bit odd, a bit naive about the world and stuck in his own perceptions, but he went well beyond being the kind of joke side-kick he was initially presented as
@TheFireMonkey
@TheFireMonkey Күн бұрын
65 ... there was an outro?
@TheFireMonkey
@TheFireMonkey Күн бұрын
Oh, the first 8 episodes are the add on - episode 9 was the original first episode before the execs got involved. BTW - do you want to know anything about the Telepath War? If not, I shall stay silent, but if you would like a bit of info, I'll be happy to give the little bit I know.
@TheFireMonkey
@TheFireMonkey Күн бұрын
I think that Kevin was very intentionally a stereotype for a good reason, the whole point to him was to first let the audience [a 90s audience that is] react to him as that stereotype so that he is discounted and seen as useless, so that when he actually turns out to be very important it hits the audience. He was there so that JMS could try and move public perception about the LGBTQ community forward in a positive way. To do that, though, required first starting where the majority of the 90s audience was starting because you can't change people if you don't first connect to them.
@TynamM
@TynamM Күн бұрын
Yep. JMS specifically said that characters like this usually turn out to be just one more obstacle to overcome, and he deliberately wanted to subvert that trope and make him helpful to solving the big problem.
@TheFireMonkey
@TheFireMonkey Күн бұрын
the body doesn't explode because it is only 1 atmosphere difference - you are thinking more deep ocean where there are many atmospheres difference - except deep ocean is reversed since the outside is higher pressure so you implode. But when exposed to hard vacuum, you don't explode - though after a short time your blood, etc, will start to boil. The science is actually not bad [I watched a detailed breakdown of the science of a bode in hard vacuum done by a NASA scientist talking about Total Recall, which also has this kind of situation] - oh, and the time factor is 1.5 minutes to 2 minutes in hard vacuum.
@charlesmaurer6214
@charlesmaurer6214 Күн бұрын
Decompression from one atmosphere is not as severe as you think. It is far worse with divers with the bends with many times the decompression. Freezing, bruising and some blood boiling are the main factors. Eyes may want to pop and lungs may collapse but if air is restored in a few minutes most issues can be treated in short order. Oxygen loss is what kills.
@TheFireMonkey
@TheFireMonkey Күн бұрын
When given the choice between fighting or "making them someone else's problem" - Gideon was more a soldier than a politician.
@TheFireMonkey
@TheFireMonkey Күн бұрын
the alien is more like a virus
@TheFireMonkey
@TheFireMonkey Күн бұрын
Jeff - @ 30 minutes, you just managed to counter your own stand. When the government set up a meaningless response to 9/11 it was to help calm the public - it was a waste of money and all that, but it WAS what the government did. Same thing here - so what they did IS exactly the thing the government would do.
@TheFireMonkey
@TheFireMonkey Күн бұрын
Didn't you see the changes in the look of the ship? They changed the Gunmetal Grey to Battleship Grey 🐒- actually, any changes to the ship would take more time, producing the new uniform, or rather a sample uniform, would be done pretty quick. I honestly don't remember, but if they do change the ship, we wouldn't see it in this episode.
@TheFireMonkey
@TheFireMonkey Күн бұрын
That scream was just like in the 1978 Invasion of the Body Snatchers when the pod people identify a real person - so much so that I think it was done as a nod to that. I haven't seen that movie in a long time, but I think the scream might actually be the same - certainly the super wide open mouth is.
@simongiles9749
@simongiles9749 Күн бұрын
RIP Donald Sutherland 😢
@ianstopher9111
@ianstopher9111 4 сағат бұрын
That was my first thought. The scream was a nod to the 78 Body Snatchers, followed by the pseudo-Bennings (The Thing) making the alien raw in the snow.
@simongiles9749
@simongiles9749 Күн бұрын
I'd say Gideon's solution was both classic Sinclair (trick them) *and* classic Sheridan (blow them up) at the same time. Consider that this episode was written as an insert to explain the uniform change between the (original) red and grey uniforms and the (TNT mandated) black uniforms, and it's not half bad, managing to slip in some classic SF tropes on the way. Not as inverted as is often the case with a JMS script - the alien mind force thing was still fundamentally malevolent.
@bidders71
@bidders71 Күн бұрын
65!
@hornorsilk2901
@hornorsilk2901 Күн бұрын
TNT and their uniforms.... a lot of the story was JMS ridiculing TNT and their demands. It's not the only time in the series.
@neilbiggs1353
@neilbiggs1353 Күн бұрын
It wasn't the only time he has done this. Now they've seen the whole of B5, has anyone shared the Julius Schwarz Lecture that JMS did with Jeff and Brent? It's a pretty cool talk, and about 43 minutes in, he goes in an issue he had working on Real Ghostbusters, and how he made an episode called 'Janine, You've Changed' which is a pretty strong prelude to him ridiculing execs in his scripts! won't share a link, but this is the final bit of the address of the YT video watch?v=OMNtVURpLzM
@simongiles9749
@simongiles9749 Күн бұрын
​@@neilbiggs1353One thing I do remember from the JMS Usenet messages is how the exces tried to soften Janine's character, even to the extent that they didn't like her having angular glasses frames in case "sharp objects would scare the children"!
@neilbiggs1353
@neilbiggs1353 Күн бұрын
@@simongiles9749 Yeah, he brings that up there in his usual sarcastic fashion. It's an interesting lecture, thought the Q&A section was largely forgettable from what I remember
@lordpuki1375
@lordpuki1375 Күн бұрын
The uniforms were the primary reason that episode order is so screwed up. JMS had originally planned to start the series with the crew already assembled and on mission, and the ST uniforms were the original designs. After a half-dozen episodes had been shot those uniforms were replaced with the far more practical military-style black uniforms. The problem was, TNT decided that they needed a pilot episode to start the show off, and wanted them to use the new uniforms creating a continuity issue. JMS wrote the uniform subplot to explain why the show starts with the black uniforms, change to the ST uniforms for a handful of episodes, and then return to the black ones.
@kalzar26
@kalzar26 Күн бұрын
"The needs of the many" always rings the same as politicians and tyrants using the phrase "For the greater good." to me. I think the reason they used such a generic name as Unobtainium (besides the sci-fi nod) was to show how generic and interchangable the thing they were after in Avatar. It wasn't a specific thing, it was a mindset of "We want/need it and can take it."
@hornorsilk2901
@hornorsilk2901 Күн бұрын
I still say, if you like TKO, you need to see its prelude, Arena.
@hornorsilk2901
@hornorsilk2901 Күн бұрын
I think this episode shows how much Crusade was going to be a mix between B5 and SG1, and it allows for more SG1 style humor in some of its stories.
@NathanielMiller
@NathanielMiller Күн бұрын
From what I've heard, the uniform change was forced on them by TNT. JMS planned to have a massive "laundry accident" on the ship for S2 and go back to the other uniforms.
@simongiles9749
@simongiles9749 Күн бұрын
Except it was the other way. The red/grey uniforms are the original design and where you see them, you see the episodes with the least TNT interference. TNT wanted the black uniforms. For some reason. At that point it feels like meddling just to be dicks.