21 күн бұрын
2 ай бұрын
4 ай бұрын
5 ай бұрын
5 ай бұрын
8 ай бұрын
8 ай бұрын
9 ай бұрын
10 ай бұрын
11 ай бұрын
Жыл бұрын
Жыл бұрын
Жыл бұрын
Жыл бұрын
Пікірлер
@searl1 Сағат бұрын
Just curious... is "Lau" the correct pronunciation of the word "Laos"?
@CarterOnConflict 44 минут бұрын
It is. For some unknown reason the French added the "s." No one in Laos, Thailand, or Southeast Asia responds to "Laos" other than officials dealing with foreign entities. The country (PDR - Peoples Democratic Replublic of Lao), the people, the language, are all "Lau." Thanks for asking.
@andersfant4997 8 сағат бұрын
Extensive, balanced and interesting. Maybe the US should not have honored the Geneva accords. Troops in Laos could have shown China, Russia that America was commited in the region. Reduced exposure and dependence of the Hmongs (less casulties). The trajectory of the Vietnam War would have been very different, no Ho chi min trail-as you discuss, no Tet, no need for a Lam Son 719. Lima site 85 could still be in use🙂 but now monitoring China. Laos is today a puppet to China, this could have been avoided. One can object to many things in Thai society, the lack of real democracy, how the old guard dont accept the young generations hope for a more transparent, equal society. But the difference with Laos (and Cambodia) is huge. Western infuence has been a path to success.
@CarterOnConflict 2 сағат бұрын
@@andersfant4997 amen Anders on the difference between Laos and Thailand, and that is THE key point folks should know. Western influence versus the communist debacle that has left Laos a poor colony of China. As always, I appreciate you watching and your thoughtful commentary.
@user-bu7fx8ly6v 13 сағат бұрын
Another outstanding video sir!
@CarterOnConflict 13 сағат бұрын
@@user-bu7fx8ly6v I always enjoy hearing from you - thanks for watching!!!
@packrat76 Күн бұрын
Great story. Have you considered seeing if someone versed in audio could help you out? It sounds like your talking across a room. A fellow enthusiast might help you out for free.
@CarterOnConflict Күн бұрын
@@packrat76 thank you for your recommendation / as you clearly know, audio is always my challenge and I am continually seeking to improve. I appreciate your comment and watching my videos.
@andersfant4997 Күн бұрын
Regarding "Most decorated..". Some claim Colonel David Hackworth was the "most decorated" soldier during the Vietnam war. A very interesting man. Respected by nearly all soldiers, and he made men out of boys (not loved by everybody though- apparently there was a contract to frag him?). He started Tiger Force-but took no responsibility for what later happend with the unit. He understood the soldiers need for emotional and physical recreation, and organized places for this. He called a spade a spade about how the war was handled- thats why ne never became a General. I have seen many interviews with him. An inspiring, likeable man who died of cancer, as so many did (agent orange?). Did he inspire Robert Duvals character in Apocalypse Now? Who knows🙂.
@CarterOnConflict Күн бұрын
@@andersfant4997 I always enjoy reading your comments Anders. I did not know much of the detail you provided on Hackworth, so thanks for sharing. I know he wrote one book (two?) and I read it. And…ha…yes, took care of his soldiers needs. A man who deserved more than history - and the Army - gave him. Thank you for watching the videos. Paul.
@rl64rl Күн бұрын
Well done, Dr Carter. Thank you.
@CarterOnConflict Күн бұрын
@@rl64rl Paul here - thank you for watching and commenting. I hope you find other videos on my channel you will enjoy.
@NiSiochainGanSaoirse Күн бұрын
Even worse, the US agencies even ordered us servicemen to KILL American pows when the rescue teams found more pows than they expected when they arrived to rescue them. They then abandoned their American pows to the viet cong. Why ANYONE volunteers to fight for a country that would sooner murder you than rescue you is beyond me.
@CarterOnConflict 18 сағат бұрын
Thank you for watching and commenting. Yes, there used to be solid evidence what you say is true about the murders. Shameful is too light a word.
@GeorgeMcMillanIII Күн бұрын
FYI, I am posting this link to a map of the old airfields in SE Asia during WW2 I believe. The map is dated 1961, but the airfields would have been there longer. I use it to find the old remote airfields discussed in your videos. https: //blogs.loc.gov/maps/files/2019/08/SE-Asia-Mapblog.jpg
@GeorgeMcMillanIII Күн бұрын
Hansen's story at the end was riveting. It reminded me of when we evacuated Kabul in August of 2021 when we left the Afghan National Army Guards at the Embassy. They couldn't return to their homes because the Sunni Pashtun Taliban had already moved into the outskirts of the city in the days prior. I just know the LNs that I worked with for years and left behind were going to get slaughtered right after we all left.
@CarterOnConflict Күн бұрын
@@GeorgeMcMillanIII wow George - poignant story there. What a tragedy, Thank you for sharing with us.
@GeorgeMcMillanIII Күн бұрын
@@CarterOnConflict And I posted the website of the old airfield map again. Most of the airfields in SE Asia would have been dirt runways. https: //blogs.loc.gov/maps/files/2019/08/SE-Asia-Mapblog.jpg
@GeorgeMcMillanIII Күн бұрын
I am binge watching trying to catch up! Great work again.
@CarterOnConflict Күн бұрын
I always like to hear from you George - thank you. I appreciate your channel support.
@danielpierce8326 2 күн бұрын
Dr. Carter, Thank you for these videos. You have preserved a piece of history that has gone unnoticed and will never be taught to future generations. I served as a crew-chief on a C-123k Candlestick at NKP in 70-71. I forwarded these videos to a mailing list of 130 veterans and have received a lot of responses from my AF guys that served in that theater of operations while the government denied our activity in Laos and Cambodia. Your chronicles on the Ravens is greatly appreciated!!!
@CarterOnConflict 2 күн бұрын
@@danielpierce8326 Daniel we owe a great debt to all of you who served over Laos that has yet to be paid. I know of the candlestick missions / so dangerous, like everything over Laos. God bless you and your veterans, and I do appreciate sure you sending to a mailing list / wow, I am truly honored and flattered. You probably have noticed that I have two Raven videos - the second one they just talk - and several videos on Laos. I hope you enjoy them all. Thank you so much for your kind and gracious message, I am honored and humbled. Paul
@danielpierce8326 Күн бұрын
@@CarterOnConflict Yes, I watched them both. Thanks for all your hard work.
@CarterOnConflict Күн бұрын
@@danielpierce8326 I appreciate your support to my channel Daniel, thank you very much.
@JamesODay-ul9ob 2 күн бұрын
The photo with the caption "The Trap" looks like a CH-3 at channel 99 which the 21SOS resupplied on a regular basis with drinking water. Located near Mukdahan south of Savannakhet on the Thai side of the river
@CarterOnConflict 2 күн бұрын
@@JamesODay-ul9ob James, thank you for adding that detail! If you look closely at the thumbnail I credit the guy who took the pic - it was a commander at NKP and his son submitted the photo. I always wondered where the photo was taken and you may have answered that. Thank you sir.
@JamesODay-ul9ob 2 күн бұрын
@@CarterOnConflict Channel 99 provided TACAN support over central/southern Laos replacing Muang Phalan TACAN Site ( Channel 77) in Laos which had been over run. It was in a small depression in the hills with a finished helipad. Technicians working and there and defending the site had surrounded the area with trip flares which would be set off by the rotor wash when we landed to resupply them. There was a constant threat of infiltrators/sappers crossing the river and attacking the site. Thai gunboats and ground troops patrolled the Mekong around NKP and surrounding area also looking for infiltrators coming in by boat and helicopter
@CarterOnConflict 2 күн бұрын
@@JamesODay-ul9ob this is a piece of history lost but now we know, thanks for posting this. I am others had no idea. Now, I’m guessing most of the time these sappers and infiltrators were unsuccessful. But can you give us a sense how often these infiltrations occurred and the result?
@JamesODay-ul9ob Күн бұрын
@@CarterOnConflict I was there in late 1972 and there had been sappers killed at Ubon by Thai forces before that. I remember seeing photos of the dead sappers laid out with their heads/hands cut off. NKP was more defensible and was surrounded by jungle on most sides. There was also motion sensing system buried in the ground surrounding the base. The 21SOS flew two missions on most nights with security police and a starlight scope they mounted in the door of the helicopter in place of the right side mini gun. These were orbits of the base at around 300-500 ft at random times. One mission was before midnight and another after midnight. Depending on how much motion was detected the security police command center would vector us to an area of fence line to investigate. They could also request us to drop illumination flares. It also wasn’t unusual to pick up bullet holes while flying approaches in to NKP in day light. When flying near the Mekong at night we had a frequency to contact Thai forces but they were difficult to understand.
@BenjaminRowe-hc7uo 2 күн бұрын
These guys have the largest set of brass one's,"low and slow" really exposed to ground fire in small unarmoured Cessna's, Very Brave Pilots."LEST WE FORGET"!🎖️🇺🇲🇦🇺🫡
@CarterOnConflict 2 күн бұрын
@@BenjaminRowe-hc7uo Benjamin, me thinks you were close to - or in - the action as well. Appreciate your watching and comments.
@BenjaminRowe-hc7uo 2 күн бұрын
A lot of gallantry medals were overlooked or never even acknowledged because the govt sent the boys "over the fence", absolutely disgusting that these soldiers many"spec-ops/c.i.a/s.o.g macv/Lrrps etc"were never recognised for their bravery "above & beyond",R.I.P to the boys who never made it home,and "welcome" home to the one's who did make it.I thank you all for your service "Lest We Forget".🇦🇺🇺🇲🎖️🫡
@CarterOnConflict 2 күн бұрын
Well put Benjamin. Thank you for watching and commenting. I hope you find other of my videos useful.
@immortaltyger1569 2 күн бұрын
Dr. Carter - thanks for helping to preserve this little known history, we viewers are in your debt.
@CarterOnConflict 2 күн бұрын
Thank you sir for watching and commenting - your support keeps me going. I appreciate you watching my videos.
@benquinneyiii7941 2 күн бұрын
Lemay said if the Japanese had won he would have been tried for war crimes
@CarterOnConflict 18 сағат бұрын
Yes sir….i have that in the video as you know. Thanks for watching and commenting.
@vanmalaphongsavan1331 3 күн бұрын
, Thank you Dr. Paul T. Carter for the truth of the facts. you're the best media history details... Talk to you soon..
@CarterOnConflict 3 күн бұрын
Well you really appreciate that - thank you for watching and commenting!!!
@tommypaget2294 3 күн бұрын
Is chemical warfare against the Geneva convention for war? Just curious.
@CarterOnConflict 3 күн бұрын
As I understand it, in 1925 many nations were a signatory in Geneva against nerve agent gasses. The U.S. was not a signatory. To my knowledge CS gas violates no treaties - it is used by police and military forces around the world. CS gases are used by police against one’s own citizens during riots and such.
@bill2066 4 күн бұрын
Jeez, Carter. YOu need to update your profile picture!
@CarterOnConflict 4 күн бұрын
But ALL of my photos are ugly. Any suggestions?
@jgood9810 4 күн бұрын
Another great piece of work. Thanks Doc.
@CarterOnConflict 4 күн бұрын
Thank you for watching - tell your dad I appreciate his service. Those vets didn’t get the honor they deserved, as you well know.
@tommyford-xv7lw 4 күн бұрын
and they ask us to trust them has anyone been held responsible???? this is sad and sickening my heart goes out to the families of the p.o.wsan m.i.as
@CarterOnConflict 4 күн бұрын
Not a soul been held responsible. Even worse - if it can get worse - this happened in 1918. We abandoned POWs then. I did a short video with original film and pics on them. POW/MIA Part II: The 1918 Russian Expedition kzbin.info/www/bejne/d2S8eoiafKeXfpo. Thank you for commenting and watching.
@tommyford-xv7lw 4 күн бұрын
your welcome. they've most likely left soldiers in every war we've ever been in.oh thanks for the link✌🏻
@CarterOnConflict 4 күн бұрын
@@tommyford-xv7lw you know, I think so. Sadly. Thank you!
@GeneHamner 4 күн бұрын
Paul: Once again you have recorded a story about a true act of heroism. Phil Conrad deserves a Medal of Honor for all that he did, without a doubt. Keep these stories coming. Gene Hamner Nail 68 Raven 12
@CarterOnConflict 4 күн бұрын
Gene / thank you so much for watching and commenting!
@connexmarket7687 4 күн бұрын
Hi. Do you have any aerial photos of Pattaya in the 50’s and 60’s ?
@CarterOnConflict 4 күн бұрын
I don’t, but I haven’t searched for any either. With your question, I bet some exist. If I come across any, I will remember your post. I will let you know…I am curious myself. Thank you for watching and commenting.
@jgood9810 4 күн бұрын
My father was a gunner on a AC130 gunship stationed in Ubon and Korat Thailand from 68-73. He wasn't credited with all of his combat missions until the mid 1990's due to the secrecy of operations in Laos and Cambodia. He flew over 300 missions in South East Asia,, mostly they flew truck interdiction along the Ho Chi Min trail nightly.
@CarterOnConflict 4 күн бұрын
Thank you for sharing that. Too many servicemen were not duly rewarded for their service since it was in Laos. I appreciate you watching and sharing.
@jgood9810 4 күн бұрын
@@CarterOnConflict Thank you, these are all stories that need to be heard. I just found your channel while looking for content on pows left behind in South East Asia. After watching your video on that I subscribed, now I'm watching everything you have made. Thank you so much for helping preserve these almost forgotten pieces of US history.
@CarterOnConflict 4 күн бұрын
@@jgood9810 comments like yours is why I do this. Without you and others, I certainly wouldn’t. You keep me motivated. I appreciate your subscription and watching. I have some good ones coming up too, so….thanks for making my day.
@CarterOnConflict 4 күн бұрын
@@jgood9810 oh…you may have gotten to this one already, but our 1918 POWs is a very sad story as well. Under 18 minutes, I have original film and video: POW/MIA Part II: The 1918 Russian Expedition kzbin.info/www/bejne/d2S8eoiafKeXfpo
@CarterOnConflict 4 күн бұрын
POWs: The Documented Cases of POWs Left Behind kzbin.info/www/bejne/j3O7qGN7jb-lb7M
@grant209 5 күн бұрын
At 11.03min into your video showing the two CH-3's on the ground, if the Road in front is todays Route 23, you can see the river and bridge pilongs of an unfinished bridge to the rear of the CH-3's battle site, which might be Route 23's river crossing today, which would put the battle zone 200m North West of the current Route 23 bridge river crossing as you indicated at the end of the video
@CarterOnConflict 5 күн бұрын
This is very helpful, and I think you are correct if we go on the assumption - I have - that the bridge piling today is at the same location as it was then. But I need a sanity check. I really appreciate your help. Thanks for watching and commenting.
@mayandick 5 күн бұрын
As a former Team Leader for a Lrrp Group , (1967-1968) with a primary mission of looking for captured Prisoners of War staging areas along the the Ho Chi Min trails. Where Prisoners would eventually be moved to Hanoi or other camps. Our success rate was dismal. Never saw any camps. The only success was finding one loss GI Grunt who was abandon by his Platoon. My personal thoughts were regular GI's where just tortured and killed, while Officers were kept as bargaining chips. Now with this information of our Politicians abandoning our Service Men even John McCain it makes one sick..
@CarterOnConflict 5 күн бұрын
I’m honored to hear from a LLRP. Thank you for sharing your experience with us. And for watching. McCains actions are one of disheartening and disbelief - yes, sickening. I did a shorter video with original film, on our 1918 left-behinds kzbin.info/www/bejne/d2S8eoiafKeXfposi=oHvL7ZzTcI4zPB6N. I’d be honored if you watched.
@user-dz3et8lj4o 6 күн бұрын
Hello Dr. Paul I attended the CEC General Meeting today in Chiang Mai. I was fascinated by your abbreviated brief. Since my first adventure in S.E. Asia in 1975 (as a private citizen who did not serve), I have been interested in the Thai/Viet/Lao/Kampuchea dynamic and how that has impacted the evolution of the region from the early dynasties to today. I hope someday I can attend one of your 50-minute presentations on the same subject. Per your invitation at today’s meeting, I am contacting you to request the 2 pdf publications that you presented on PowerPoint: “Boundary Concepts And Practices in Southeast Asia” and “Boundary & Territory Briefing.” If I’m not mistaken, you also mentioned that, if requested, you would send all that you have that can be shared related to your brief today. Yes, I would like you to do so. Would you be doing so via the CEC or privately? If privately, what do you suggest is the best way to give you my contact info, as I would never do so in a public forum such as this KZbin communique.
@CarterOnConflict 6 күн бұрын
Thank you so much for attending, and your note - I’m glad you enjoyed it and please call me Paul. Email me at [email protected]. I’ll email you those two PDFs plus the Martin Stuart-Fox pdf on the French in Laos. I hope you find some videos on here that you enjoy and next time we meet please introduce yourself. Thank you again.
@user-dz3et8lj4o 6 күн бұрын
Hello Dr Paul, Today I attended the CEC General Meeting. I was fascinated by the abbreviated brief you presented. Since my first adventure in S.E. Asia in 1975 (as a private citizen who did not serve) I have always been interested in the evolution of the Thai/Lao/Viet/Kampuchea inter
@thao3456 7 күн бұрын
The USA is 100% to blame for the death & destruction in Southeast Asia.
@CarterOnConflict 6 күн бұрын
North Vietnams invasion of both Laos and South Vietnam didn’t play a role? The Hmong, the Lao fighting for their lives against communism? What about the 900,000 Viets who gave up everything and went south in 1954 to escape communism? The over 250,000 Viets who died at sea escaping communism. Laos is a failed state, Cambodia almost is, and it’s taken south Vietnam 50 years to be able to compete with mighty Thailand who was a U.S. Ally. Communism. Bad choice. Clearly you don’t know much history.
@user-xp3fu3pe7u 7 күн бұрын
Another informative video, Paul. I'd not read about Operation Junction City, implications for the HCMT and Xepon. I'll reach out for the article. Hope Mr Conran receives his Medal of Honour and Charlie gets in contact with him soon. Thanks again.
@CarterOnConflict 7 күн бұрын
Adrian, as always, I appreciate your support. I’ll follow up with you…
@Capnclogs 7 күн бұрын
Why do you think after 50 years they still want pows. It needs some billionaire to fund a mission, of ex special forces.
@CarterOnConflict 7 күн бұрын
I would suspect all of the POWs have passed on by now, so now it’s just a situation of the commies saving face and not admitting they had any. I don’t suspect there is much evidence anymore in existence to support there were POWs to begin with. It’s just been too long. Just my thinking. I appreciate you watching and commenting.
@Capnclogs 7 күн бұрын
@CarterOnConflict yes probably in their 70s /80s , no work left in them lads, Shame . I just wish US could of found one. But if like over in UK, I don't think the last generations are all that bothered 😕
@Capnclogs 7 күн бұрын
@@CarterOnConflict Stand down soldier...duties done.
@CarterOnConflict 7 күн бұрын
@@Capnclogs oh boy Capn, young folk in US too concerned with their TicToc to worry of such. I appreciate you fellows watching this Yank channel. I appreciate our Brit cousins. You’ve been solid.
@TheVigilant109 8 күн бұрын
Very interesting. Many thanks
@CarterOnConflict 8 күн бұрын
I appreciate you watching and commenting, thank you.
@kongvang2658 8 күн бұрын
Soo many of us lose lives. Family, village, relatives. And till today we're still known for being refugees or illegal immigrants and still send to communist country where it await death or tortured from prosecution because of involving family from the war. And thank you Dr. Carter for making it clear for the world to understand the history of the hmong.
@CarterOnConflict 8 күн бұрын
Many of us know what great Americans the Hmong are. You have made America even greater. Thank you for all you have done.
@NavyDocHM3 8 күн бұрын
I've just recently discovered your channel and really appreciate your in-depth research. Many channels dealing with military history attempt a deep dive into the mythical “rabbit hole”, (and usually get lost) but you seemed to have found a detailed map! 🙂 Outstanding job, Sir! I'm looking forward to watching more if your presentations! John “Doc” Lykins NREMT-Paramedic (Ret) Former US Navy Hospital Corpsman
@CarterOnConflict 8 күн бұрын
John, I really appreciate you saying this. When a guy of your obvious background and knowledge likes my channel, then I know I am doing the right things. I believe my video making is getting better, and as you were a paramedic you understand precision. I think I have 37 or so videos so you keep going - it keeps me running. Thank you again Doc.
@johnclarke6647 8 күн бұрын
I think Kings Mountain was actually the turning point in the Revolution War. I had relatives in that battle. My 5th GGF, Capt. John Tomlinson was in all of this being in the SC Militia. He was the son of William Tomlinson a big Virginia and Kentucky land speculator. He later moved to GA after the war and became a First Family of Georgia.
@CarterOnConflict 8 күн бұрын
Nice pedigree! Thank you for commenting and sharing. No doubt Kings Mountain was significant to the changing tide of the war.
@johnclarke6647 8 күн бұрын
@@CarterOnConflict capt. John led the last charge at Eutaw Springs. He served under the Swamp Fox. It was the last battle in SC. We also won it.. I descend from 16 RS- my wife from four.
@CarterOnConflict 8 күн бұрын
@@johnclarke6647 maybe you have, but a small book or something similar - genealogy - to pass to your kids would be great!
@johnclarke6647 8 күн бұрын
@@CarterOnConflict they already have copies of my PAF, so they know everything that I know. They have their mothers information, too both she and .i descend from Norman knights I also descend from the Celtic Earls of Athol.. She is First Family of America. I am First Family of Virginia and Georgia. My degree is in history and I did not get it from an online diploma mill, either. It took me ten years and a war to get it.🤪
@craigcook1571 9 күн бұрын
Politicians are scum. They wouldn’t give him the MOH to hide their BS
@CarterOnConflict 7 күн бұрын
Yes sir. And thank you for watching and commenting.
@TADAMS-zt4zz 9 күн бұрын
Outstanding video, great story... thank you Dr. Carter for for your latest efforts!
@CarterOnConflict 9 күн бұрын
Thank you for your editorial improvements of the video Captain!
@MissionsinLaos 9 күн бұрын
I've been there 3 times but didn't know the history of the helicopter. Maybe next trip Chris C. and I can try to find LS 300.
@CarterOnConflict 9 күн бұрын
Wow, I hope you can find it! Thanks for watching the video and commenting.
@jetholcomb1 9 күн бұрын
I wonder if most people consider Greene that eras Patton. I say this because of his ability to adapt and get it done not the prettiest but, got it done.
@CarterOnConflict 9 күн бұрын
Well what are your thoughts on Greene? I am not a subject matter expert, rather a storyteller, so I like to hear other folks thoughts. I’d like to hear. And thank you for watching and commenting.
@NathanDudani 10 күн бұрын
Main chunk starts at 8:32
@CarterOnConflict 10 күн бұрын
Thanks for watching and commenting Nathan
@pollydor07 10 күн бұрын
LS-235 code name we’re used in Laos . My hills on ATTAPEU plateau Bolovens area of PAK SONG code names PS- 38, PS-72, PS-165 last hills I stayed up there for 3 months and got wounded 1970
@CarterOnConflict 10 күн бұрын
Thank you for your comment and that history. God Bless you. Thanks for watching and commenting. When did you stop fighting, what year?
@patrickyoung3503 2 күн бұрын
I hope you didn't suffer to much on your return . I've only the best wishes for you & all who served . No our & Respect . Lest we forget .
@Photograph1974 10 күн бұрын
The War was won in the South. No question.
@CarterOnConflict 9 күн бұрын
Thanks for watching and commenting.
@andersfant4997 10 күн бұрын
Regarding "milk run", interesting terms for more challenging things during the war, and correct me if I am wrong🙂 But "customer, spicey mission, hot soup (homemade napalm)" and my favourite- "hard rice"? cheers.
@CarterOnConflict 10 күн бұрын
Anders, a couple of those are new to me - thanks for sharing (Spicey mission and hot soup). Once again, I appreciate your channel support. Always enjoy your comments.
@andersfant4997 9 күн бұрын
@@CarterOnConflictI was wrong, I think "sporty mission" was the correct Air America term for a challenging mission... "Hard rice" was an euphemism for a weapon drop. Always enjoy your videos on different topics👍.
@tommcclelland119 10 күн бұрын
Once again Paul, you’ve made a masterpiece. Thank you for sharing your work and expertise. Us old Veterans appreciate you. All the best!
@CarterOnConflict 10 күн бұрын
Tom, I always appreciate your support to my channel. Thank you for watching and commenting, as always.
@airmackeeee6792 10 күн бұрын
Yet another great video Dr. Carter! 👍👏 I was wondering if you've ever read the account of the FIRST TIME Americans fought the Vietnamese? It was on July 31st 1861! 😮 en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombardment_of_Qui_Nh%C6%A1n#:~:text=The%20bombardment%20of%20Qui%20Nh%C6%A1n,States%20forces%20under%20James%20F.
@CarterOnConflict 10 күн бұрын
My goodness I did not!!! I will go there now, thank you for sending!!! And of course for watching, always good to hear from you.
@CarterOnConflict 10 күн бұрын
Just read it - thanks for sending, I love learning new things. Thanks for the education.
@jeffbangkok 10 күн бұрын
Thank you. Another very interesting video.
@CarterOnConflict 10 күн бұрын
Jeff, I appreciate you watching and supporting my channel.
@laoadvtours3479 10 күн бұрын
I'm glad we stopped there, Paul... Always wondered how it ended up there...
@CarterOnConflict 10 күн бұрын
Thanks to you as the tour guide, you brought us and we appreciate it.
@falcon5215 10 күн бұрын
I don't know how you find all of these incredible stories of bravery and committment but I'm thrilled that you do. I saw this content this morning and, since it's my birthday, I'm taking it as a birthday gift!! Thank you, Andrew McMahon
@CarterOnConflict 10 күн бұрын
Happy birthday Andrew!!! I always enjoy seeing your name, your posts. I really appreciate them. I hope you have a wonderful birthday!
@briancooper2112 10 күн бұрын
Research.
@CarterOnConflict 10 күн бұрын
@@briancooper2112 thank you Brian. I see your post is a reply - when I first saw the word “research” I thought maybe someone was calling me out for a misspelled word (lol) research. I do have those sometimes. Thank you for watching and commenting, I always appreciate it.
@patrickyoung3503 2 күн бұрын
It's a shame to be e only one Birthday Greeting on FB . A very Happy Birthday to you Andrew . Enjoy your day .
@williamhughey6875 12 күн бұрын
DO YOU THINK WE ARE STUPID AND DONT KNOW THAT ALL OF THESE SOUTHEST ASIAN COUNTIES WERE FRENCH COLONUES PRIOR TO WWII KNOWN AS FRENCH INDO CHINA?????!!!!! AND THAT WESTERN NATIONS TRIED TO HELP FRANCE REGAIN VIETNAM BUT FAILED. THEN WE WENT UNTO VIETNAM AND ADJUSTMENT COUNTIES DURING THE 1960S. YOUR RHETERIC IS VERY MISLEADING AS YOU FOCUS ON WESTERN SUPREMACY RATHER THAN THESE NATIONS BEING FREE ON THEIR OWN.
@CarterOnConflict 10 күн бұрын
Thank you for watching and commenting William.
@crispusattucks4007 12 күн бұрын
This documentary is a marvel of modern mapping! You must change your surname to Paul Cartographer
@CarterOnConflict 12 күн бұрын
Crispus, were it not for you, I would not have known of this feature!!! Thank you sir.