Пікірлер
@bernym4047
@bernym4047 10 сағат бұрын
I agree, the composite and enlarge canvas module don't belong in a raw file editor. Good demo of CE module. Thanks.
@philsmith774
@philsmith774 Күн бұрын
Thanks for providing the raw files. It really helps me follow what you do, plus I can try "what if Andy did this instead" type scenarios e.g. using sigmoid rather than filmic for example. It's a great learning aid.
@jhmnieuwenhuis
@jhmnieuwenhuis Күн бұрын
Thanks Andy, great stuff!
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury Күн бұрын
Cheers Hans
@ifell3
@ifell3 Күн бұрын
Funnily enough, I've just deleted Darktable, now I will have to reinstall it.
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury Күн бұрын
Out of curiosity, what did you delete it in favour of ?
@ifell3
@ifell3 Күн бұрын
@@AndyAstbury well I never really used it, used rawtherapy a little bit more and watched more of your videos on it. So I guess it seemed more intuitive. I opened up darktable and the interface/panels just looked flat.
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury Күн бұрын
Rawtherapee is very good, but in all honesty, the multiple module instance and module masking capabilities of Darktable, make DT the vastly more flexible application. As a Rawtherapee fan for about 5 years, no one was more sceptical of DT than me. But it only took me a few days to realise that DT offered me A LOT of answers to the many shortcomings of RT. I still bemoan Darktables absence of a capture sharpening module a la the one in RT - which to me is the best in the business. I also dislike DT's lack of ability to use dcp profiles. But I learned to use DT to get around these problems, one way or another, and if I had to dump one of my FOSS editors it would be RT if I'm honest.
@ifell3
@ifell3 Күн бұрын
@@AndyAstbury I'm thinking I should new start watching your 101 videos on DT. I know you can plug RT and DT into gimp, I'm wondering if you could almost do the same with plugging them into each other. But I would highly doubt it. I guess with your videos the DT Devs might get the hint.
@emrg777
@emrg777 Күн бұрын
Nice video Andy. Two quick tips might be when doing a mask such as your insect to maybe try to use the details mask slider. The second is that there is a curve for saturation to select based on chromaticity.. It can target and indicate the areas that eill be impacted...
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury Күн бұрын
Thanks Todd, much appreciated, as I always seem to forget about the details slider. I really have problems visualizing the CZ masking if that's what you are meaning.
@Eigil_Skovgaard
@Eigil_Skovgaard Күн бұрын
Apparently it's a one man's job to manage the manual, and a rumor talks about a lot of last minute decisions, e.g. the tool Overlay changed name to Composite, all delaying the release.
@danielspenner3683
@danielspenner3683 Күн бұрын
In the end it's exactly the same module as the now obsolete color zones Module, except it works in linear RGB. However the effect on colors is more responsive than in color zones. It's a useful ingredient to the scene-referred workflow.
@SteveKaluski
@SteveKaluski Күн бұрын
Cool
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury Күн бұрын
Forgive the callout placement errors at around 13:00 and 21:00. I have not looked at the canvass extension module because, to be honest, there are far easier and more intuitive ways of doing this job in other software. As for the composite module behaviour, perhaps it IS for producing FAKED double exposure type images; the lack of module documentation just leaves us in the dark
@danielspenner3683
@danielspenner3683 Күн бұрын
What is fake about exposure blending, when it just reproduces, what the eye could see on location?
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury Күн бұрын
I said DOUBLE EXPOSURE - that's not exposure blending. But I'm not actually sure the module is working as intended on my mac installation; so hopefully the module documentation will clear the question up - once it arrives.
@Giles29
@Giles29 Күн бұрын
I can see a couple uses for this, but GIMP actually does this better - though if the module is improved it may be easier to use this than going over to GIMP.
@danielspenner3683
@danielspenner3683 3 күн бұрын
What I just realized: combining this function with the new overlay module means, that now we can do exposure blending within darktable! This is really getting me excited!
@danielspenner3683
@danielspenner3683 3 күн бұрын
Wow! I have already been working with darktable for a few years, but I didn't know THAT option! Great, thank you.🎉
@robscott9312
@robscott9312 7 күн бұрын
Great explanation of both Denoise and edge sharpness. Thank you Andy again
@boredgrass
@boredgrass 8 күн бұрын
Darktable allows you to make many pretty adjustments on your photos, but it doesn't allow you to save the result because it doesn't like that files have names... In 24 years I have used in 24 years I have used a lot of programs, some a lot more complex than this one, none fell so on the nose even leaving the door... The existence of file names shouldn't be a problem for a software. That makes we wonder what else problems darktable has, but I have no intention to find out...
@dolfosasso9493
@dolfosasso9493 9 күн бұрын
Grazie Andy per i tuoi video su Raw Therapy sono stati illuminanti!
@andrefouche8725
@andrefouche8725 9 күн бұрын
Good video but your blaspheming of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ is not necessary.
@graphikeye
@graphikeye 10 күн бұрын
I'm confused how the mask determines which part of the image it is working on. Maybe I missed it. Is it the placement of the mask within the frame tells the Raw which areas to pick up? Thanks.
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury 9 күн бұрын
It's the placement of the adjustment spot itself that defines the colour range that will be selected. The transition and shape detection controls take care of the edges, and the graduation controls define the gradient area. When you consider that other software approaches graduated filters in a much simpler manner, the RT method is complicated and far less obvious - this is what happens when 'coders' go mad and there is no oversight of their work by people who live in the real world!!!
@ThreeDogg3
@ThreeDogg3 14 күн бұрын
andy i need personal assistance with a project of mine
@jakinmusu8995
@jakinmusu8995 15 күн бұрын
Can anyone help? I've been trying to follow step by step but when I go on show mask literally nothing happens.
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury 9 күн бұрын
Have you actually POWERED UP/TURNED ON the Colour Toning module itself?
@dmitrymyshkov811
@dmitrymyshkov811 18 күн бұрын
No matter what I do in the “Darktable” app, the output is “Lara Croft”))) - some kind of “high-quality 3D image”. The Rawtherapee app is much better for me. The output has a balance between quality and! (which is very important) <content>.
@GaryParris
@GaryParris 19 күн бұрын
You can do all that in GIMP and or Krita.without the need for a mac with photoshop
@GaryParris
@GaryParris 19 күн бұрын
Hey andy, theres a guy who develops for Inkscape who is implementing CMYK, his youtube is Martin Owens, he needs information from people who use CMYK.
@swansong007
@swansong007 23 күн бұрын
Times must be hard at LEE. They must be desperate to save 4p on every filter holder sold using 12mm bolts
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury 9 күн бұрын
Even harder for them now I've stopped using their filters!!
@MrScientistguy
@MrScientistguy 27 күн бұрын
Could you do a video explaining your workflow including things like cataloguing, culling etc?
@dmitrymyshkov811
@dmitrymyshkov811 28 күн бұрын
On wolves, excuse me, it's easiest to experiment. Snow, animals, mountains. Have you tried showing examples on portraits of people? Many approaches immediately come to light. Thank you anyway!
@santiagopalacios28
@santiagopalacios28 Ай бұрын
Great video, thanks.
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury Ай бұрын
You are welcome!
@dmitrymyshkov811
@dmitrymyshkov811 Ай бұрын
We’re talking about the raw tab. For some reason, I don’t have the “demosaing” tools in it. There're a raw white points and a dark frame only.
@noadsnexus9762
@noadsnexus9762 Ай бұрын
Hi Andy, did you activate "Reflect black level in tone curve" to achieve this excellent validation values?
@Robert-mj6un
@Robert-mj6un Ай бұрын
Hello and welcome. I want to thank you for all the RAWTHERAPEE videos they are amazing. I have a question why version 5.10 saves JPG files only in 96dpi resolution? 5.9 saved at 300 dpi, which was suitable for printing. I have a problem how to change it. Thank you for the tip.
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury Ай бұрын
Hi Robert. With regard to jpeg resolution, my installation is saving at 300ppi (not dpi, as dpi a print resolution), so I'm struggling to answer your question.
@Ithinkimobee
@Ithinkimobee Ай бұрын
You give me Bob Ross but funnier vibes
@Ithinkimobee
@Ithinkimobee Ай бұрын
I love your energy
@laracroft8
@laracroft8 Ай бұрын
hello! I cant open the link, do you have a more recent one?
@daylight-owl
@daylight-owl Ай бұрын
@andyastbury Thank you very much for answering my question with this video. It's tutorial channels, in particular yours, that make RawTherapee a viable choice as far as I'm concerned. I really appreciate it. P.S. And thanks for the correction - You see the dust on the sensor, not the lens!
@jockstewart8793
@jockstewart8793 Ай бұрын
Thank you so much, you have sorted out a series of problems for me in one go!
@user-wn5ok1fn3b
@user-wn5ok1fn3b Ай бұрын
Спасибо Вам . Здоровья .
@ununu242
@ununu242 Ай бұрын
Fantastic, thank you so much for the dcp files!!
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury Ай бұрын
Glad you like them!
@erkutturkel3378
@erkutturkel3378 Ай бұрын
Many thanks Andy, you are great Man....
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury Ай бұрын
No worries!
@HugoRodriguezLab
@HugoRodriguezLab Ай бұрын
Interesting point of view, thanks What's that DataTransfer Software you're using to display the curves? Is that a commercially availble software?
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury Ай бұрын
It's the software that comes with Sekonic meters.
@HugoRodriguezLab
@HugoRodriguezLab Ай бұрын
@@AndyAstbury Thanks!
@gimp079
@gimp079 Ай бұрын
I am just starting out and so i am doing my own research into lenses, software etc. I was using On1 editing (and its brilliant) but after watching your Darktable videos i am set on Darktabe as it seems to keep me involved in the editing process. My only one gripe is that i have not got software to focus stack....could you recommend something please especially if its an add on to Darktable ?
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury Ай бұрын
I think Hugin does a focus stack plugin that will work in DT for windows and linux - it slso does exposure blending and panoramas too, but doesn't play nice on Mac (at least on mine!).
@benoittissier58
@benoittissier58 Ай бұрын
Is there an equivalent to the "done" button ? Almost every time I move my mouse, I accidentally change the crop. Drives me crazy.
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury Ай бұрын
Sadly, no. It's a frustration I know! Leaving cropping right to the end of your process, and moving around the image with the navigator is the only real answer that I know of.
@KevinMarlow_uk
@KevinMarlow_uk Ай бұрын
I find your worked tutorials terrific with good pace and explaining the way to achieve the goal. With your help I have been able to 'restore' some older photos, even though they are jpegs. If you have any tips on how to get the best from the resize tool to enlarge old photos for display on an HD TV, that would be amazing. I've had some success but I'm sure there is more RT could do if only I knew how.
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury Ай бұрын
Use the crop tool to change the aspect ratio to 16:9 and Lanczos to upsize the shot if needed.
@bernym4047
@bernym4047 Ай бұрын
Excellent and very useful video. I did wonder when reusing the brush mask in other modules, why you did not simply use the raster mask? Another issue: this procedure becomes very cpu intensive after a few brush strokes so not recommended on older, slower machines. Compressing the history stack does improve it though. Thank you.
@alanwilson1982
@alanwilson1982 2 ай бұрын
Thanks Andy for clarifying all these options. I submit images to picture libraries. They require 8bit jpegs and always in the Adobe RGB 1998 colour space [obviously all images going to print]. dt refers to Adobe RGB (Compatible). Is this the same thing? Thanks again for all your informative videos, Best regards Alan.
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury 2 ай бұрын
Hi Alan, I sub to stock sites, always jpeg, and always in the sRGB colour space, which is the correct colour space for jpegs. AdobeRGB1998 has a gamma curve of 2.2, which is better for for 16bit files but is too contrasty in the shadows and highlight for 8bit images with only 256 levels per channel. The sRGB native gamma is a hybrid gamma curve that only AVERAGES 2.2. This way, your jpegs look better, basically.
@alanwilson1982
@alanwilson1982 2 ай бұрын
@@AndyAstbury Thanks for your time to reply Andy. I supply to only two agencies, one in Germany and the other here in SA. Both their submit guidelines stipulate 8bit and Adobe RGB and in photoshop, as u know it's listed as that. I'm trying to use darktable but it's listed as "compatible" and I wondered why. Anyway thanks again Andy 👍 best Alan.
@marter001
@marter001 2 ай бұрын
Hi Andy, thanks for the video, its very helpful again. For me it looks a bit complicated: while you fiddled the tonecurve, i just switch on the negative-film tool for removing the spots (may be adapt exposure for to find them) and then switch off the negative film-tool. Anyway, the perfect result counts, not the way how to get there. Pls go on with your great tutorials!👍
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury 2 ай бұрын
Good point, but the Film Negative tool will not reveal them all, as it doesn't move contrast around. Using it with a small to medium curve shift would do the job a bit better.
@AlessandroDiCandia
@AlessandroDiCandia 2 ай бұрын
Hi Andy thanks for your video. I want to ask you if is possible to move the crop selection if this is in a wrong position. I hope you understand my question.
@AndyAstbury
@AndyAstbury 2 ай бұрын
You mean repositioning the Crop? Easy, I can't believe I didn't show it in the video! Hold down SHIFT and left mouse button - this should give you a hand tool, so you can move the crop around the image to get the best composition.
@AlessandroDiCandia
@AlessandroDiCandia 2 ай бұрын
@@AndyAstbury thnak you so much....working flawless