Only Jisoo needs it

I will say that Hiyyih has improved a lot since Girls Planet. She definitely wasn't ready for debut when she did, but she has improved. I will also say that Vocals like Ailee, Hwasa, Wendy, and Ken are such anomolies. They simply can't be matched. Seungmin and Han from SKZ, Lily from NMIXX, and Jongho from ATEEZ are definitely extremely strong vocals and I expect them to become pretty damn legendary among their generation, but for upcoming generations and idols.... I don't know.

5:45 and she ATE that

I think for the first txt one, they didnt sing live alot cus its a cover

I agree with most of this, but I don't agree with Bahiyyih. She has a soft lovely voice and she's good at dancing.

1. Taeyeon 2. Tiffany 3. Seohyun 4. Tiffany 5. Sunny 6. Sooyoung 7. Yuri 8. Yoona 9. Hyoyeon

(My opinion) i think enhypen is singing fully live frm what i see on tiktok and yt and no they dont just sing live 35 percent or smth i think they sing live(mostly). But sometimes they can lip-sync but they dont do that always maybe like 25 or 20 percent. Also they did covers of songs for iland and they didnt sing just to lip-sync!

I NEED MY JETI BACK😭😭😭

Your comment on sm is so funny i'm crying 😭

sin ofender, estos programas deben ser creados por personas que debieron de haber sido humillados, violados y que brutalmente sus padres nunca los quisieron. Por otro lado, todos los artistas del mundo, deberían acordar que ante preguntas o indagaciones a su intimidad, respondan siempre igual, si es un artista, debe decir, "lo tengo igual que todos, colgando y peludo" y si es una artista debe decir, "la tengo como todas, profunda y peluda", de esta forma se deja claro que ellos no son santos, pero tampoco van a dejar que cualquier programa creado y dirigido por enfermos sexuales, vengan a dañar su equilibrio de trabajo.

Now we just need AI characters with total auto tuning , and not even need to pay for real people. That will be when I check out of Kpop. I hope and pray that EXO never fall into that hole.

Rosé sounds the same !! Like more better in live !!!!

また…エアリスに会いに来る…。

Coming to this video late but it does have me thinking about the recent furore over bad encore stages and how seriously people take the vocals shown there. And that it's probably because we so rarely hear idols singing 100% live in shows. When even proven vocal powerhouses are made to perform with deafening backtrack more often than not, I guess we are just that starved for vocals that encores are all we can rely on in a way.

Proud of SKZ. Now in 2024.

Honestly. I think if you give your opinion of groups, you should give an opinion of all the members of the group. If not, your opinion is biased and it isn't reliable. Sorry but👎

Aeroth - cloud - sephirot . Is the main character . The other is cameo. Fact*

I used to like to watch K-pop live performance, seeing their singing skill improving slowly and becoming more and more stable. But nowadays it’s all pre recorded, there’s no fun and excitement in watching live performance anymore

5:34 he should get braces

I’d honestly rather have my idols have voice cracks and a little unstably then not live cause the vocal imperfections prove that their live but “fans” think it’s bad so they hate on them

Damn, despite the insane amount of time spent in many of those annoying minigames, the story of this game was awesome, can't wait for the 3rd part...

Aerith deserves a ending with Cloud, i know alot of player based and lore wants Tifa and Cloud but come on Aerith also deserves a ending with him how she was fighting for him

26:16 ate

sorry that I'm commenting so much btw, I'm trying to get my energy out. ADHD+hormonal insomnia is one hell of a combo. I barely sleep and so watching old ass videos like this about survival shows can help me get my energy out since I fucking love kpop survival shows and have loved them for multiple years and even instrument changes now lmao

25:37 deadass I think they were singing live, you can hear wheein go flat in some parts, It's barely noticeable behind the loud ass backtrack but wheein was definitely singing at least a few lines unlike the others.

24:18 took me so many damn years but I just realized she breathes in between... I was so hard on myself back when I was a kpop cover artist because I couldn't do it in one breath and to this day, I still have the ability to do that full rap in one breath.

23:12 kinda sounds like light autotune but knowing bom it could just be her live voice. when she gets to sing in the small range in that part she actually has her strongest/most comfy vocals there.

20:28 nowadays groups are allowing those glitches into their title fucking tracks, I'm so done with bad kpop mixing oml

19:17 her dancing is stunning, I did dance for 10 years in the past, and I can proudly give Yooa the title of kpop's most underappreciated main dancer

I'd rather see a group lip sync then use live AR atp. If you can't sing, just own it. add on to this, literally but in the final round where you say it sounds like a single track it normally is that. mainly because they want to fake it being real... sigh

Oh My Girl seems to use a lot of live AR in all their performances that I can remember. I hardcore stan them but they always sound robotic. Lovelyz does way better live, just like mamamoo.

14:55 me too bom me too. its hard being a well trained vocalist and using autotune 🤕

Honestly part of me thinks lovelyz did this shit on purpose because they wanted to elegantly call out mnet for staging all the performances, but it ended up backfiring on them.

4:02 ugh finally someone says it. I hate mixing my own covers because my vibrato always gets in the way!!!

2:40 EXACTLY

1:26 listen, as a lovelyz ult, even I was embarassed for the queendom lipsync but the fact that this whole show was edited honestly made it fairer imo just because none of the girls were incredibly skilled. queendom 1 however shoulda been fully live bc mamamoo sounds better live.

Great editing

Variety shows are supposed to be fun but they really pushed it here, I see SNSD always laughing at shows but they look real angry here

literally bring back live singing cause I don’t pay to see concerts just for it to be the whole backtrack

those mans are too much bro i don't know how jessica was capable of being that calm with them and tiffany can be really scary i wouldn't want her to be mad at me

The moment Sephiroth speaks here, his first line is already leagues worse than George Newbern's delivery 😂. He sounds so...bland! Newbern's Sephiroth has a tinge of cockiness/teasing to his voice. Like, you can hear him wagging a finger at you just by his voice alone. It's not over the top to the point of arrogance, like Genesis, but it's noticeable. I miss hearing that. He's also quite sultry and I feel like his new VA is scared to go there and lean into that. Let's be honest, depending on who you ask Sephiroth ranges from a little bit gay to a lot a bit gay 😅. You can't have lines like, "On your knees. I want you to beg for forgiveness," or the amount of times Sephiroth has gotten up close and personal to Cloud and whispered in his ears and not wonder if maybe this character wasn't designed to be straight, lol (also, his clothes. Exposed chest in a military that until very recently has only been shown to have men? And why was he shirtless in his final battle with Cloud?! 😂) Speaking of which, he also *really* likes to say Cloud's name. And lastly, and I've not confirmed this, but I heard that supposedly, Sephiroth in Japanese speaks to Cloud the way a wife would speak to her husband. Again, not confirmed...but it would make a hell of a lot of sense. I feel like somehow, Newbern was able to vocalize all of this in his performance of the character, all of his little nuances.

Kyunhyun siempre me ha caido mal por esto, aun despues de tantos años siempre me molestara q el solo por "entretener" no le importaba hacerlo a costa de sus amigos y colegas

I’m glad Tiffany stood up

The fact: We all know NMIXX can sing live and stable bc i attend their fanconcerf 2 times soo yeahh They can do better than this

Hey !!!

rick gomez just sounds way better than caleb pierce as zack. george newbern is also the perfect voice for sephiroth. caleb makes zack sound like a wimp. and tyler makes sephiroth sound like an edgelord.

2024: This is good singing...

somi😍

Actually could hv left all performances live. I am very sure it will all turn out ok. But then that’s was the decision of the TV station.

I watch Queendom 1 and I find all the contestants are very good and put up good performances. Apart from the edited Queendom performances they are all good singers.