100 DEVS Make a GAME without COMMUNICATING! (1-25)

[@Blackthornprod]

Merry Christmas guys! Learn how to make your FIRST GAME during the holidays with our free course: www.gamedevrocket.com/create-your-first-game

[@DangerLover-qe6gu]

Thank you sir 😊

[@LubsiRednuhts]

Merry Christmas to you too :)

[@Fostero7]

Ok

[@xaius4348]

At this point, may as well do a "365 devs make a game without communicating over a year" challenge

[@LubsiRednuhts]

@@xaius4348 yes and give each dev the whole day to work on it so that they have more time to either work all day or just a couple ours

[@Zappr]

The people who dedicated their slot to fixing bugs and little quality of life improvements are the true heroes. Amazing job everyone!

[@loenk2651]

For real. Some people get too caught up in trying to add their own new systems, but people improving what's already there are the ones truly making the game fun.

[@bonniechannel]

That's the first steps for the game, it is when you have to trial and error stuff, it's the beginning, it's the last devs who have to polish the game, when first ones tries to shape it

[@somerandomchannel382]

NGL. People was joking around until Binary Lunar. He just "Oh OK" - made a complete game with wizard texture and great start menu. WOOOOW!

[@Greatcelestialkaligo]

@@loenk2651 like that one guy... Wishbone I really don't like him.

[@masonnasty8596]

@@loenk2651 Unless their version of improvement is changing something already functional like a 3d rendered hand instead of the cool sprite one that matched the essence of the game.

[@calebmcnevin]

"I can walk into my bullets, so stupid. Also, to the developer who made the ice level, it's shit. I deleted it and replaced it with a different level that's basically the same and doesn't match the ice theme. I also removed the charm of the 2D pixel art style." Bold strategy Cotton...

[@epicsavagebros7400]

It didn’t work out

[@apexgaming9769]

Bro actually ruined the project with his slot. game was on track to be better than some triple A games before he came

[@savarnelson9379]

@@apexgaming9769 To be fair, the parry mechanic is cool.

[@alexgptb5276]

@@savarnelson9379he stole it from ultrakill lmao

[@apexgaming9769]

@@savarnelson9379 valid still ruined the art style and animations

[@ofres5651]

The first hand art style was so much better it made the game have character

[@nooseloverr]

fr

[@filiflo]

nah its a meme at this point

[@soccerlilypad6363]

Bro for real

[@spacepiratee215]

Agreed

[@shinyless]

definitely

[@alex_the_polyam_dev7911]

Wishbone: So I changed the hand and terrain *Everyone dissaproove*

[@TOPHATGAM5]

8:25 “U guys want too see the cool new hand I made” everyone: GIVE THE OLD HAND BACK

[@victornguyen1175]

I like how after Wishbone changed several things for no reason, everyone's changes just completely stopped being motivated by the aesthetic.

[@marcelburdon9795]

yeah, the aesthetic was fueling creativity, he made it generic

[@szczypior2714]

who's wishbone

[@szczypior2714]

okay I see now, what a dumbass

[@szczypior2714]

I hate it when one person ruins everything in those videos

[@TreatMySoul]

​​@@szczypior2714this guy 8:14

[@Weedsm0kr79]

“Look at this cool new hand I made” Everyone:NOOOOO! NO DONT DO THAT!

[@vaelxn]

I feel like in these challenges they should save previously used assets in a folder. A later dev even tried to copy the style of the heart for a hand and didn't like his result. The perfect hand already existed, but was thrown away because some guy wanted to use a weird cel shaded voxel type hand that didn't fit the aesthetic at all

[@GDnobrain]

Fax

[@Owenfilms-no9kt]

yes the new hand was badddd

[@ri-guygames8052]

The old one was unique, the new one was just plain and generic

[@ri-guygames8052]

Also, the new one doesn’t fit with the pixel art theme.

[@kris123o]

Imagine how cool it would be if next year you managed to get 365 devs, each get the game for a day and we only get to see it in the new year.

[@gildedwyvern2510]

They would make the greatest game of all time and then at the very end everything would be scrapped by one dev and completely ruin the project :)

[@ImcoolIpromise]

Yeah release one part a day for the year

[@alexw9309]

They could use version control like git and every dev could push his changes at the end of the day. So u could revert the project to every old version from the whole year.

[@ashokawho6327]

366 this year to come I think

[@0ver1de89]

progress report each month

[@RuinedMessiah]

(Haven't finished the rest of the video) DEV 6 MAKING THE FINGERNAILS CHANGE COLOR WITH THE MAGIC IN USE WAS SMART ASF

[@marvellucent5843]

yeah, you should stop at dev 6, the hand was disgusting

[@Casual_guy1234]

Removed, next

[@beYOndd]

Saw a new video dropped today and realized i missed this one and man. Wishbone dropped the ball here, to call the other devs work shit and then make even bigger shit. That's actual talent. I spent more time reading these comments then watching the video. okay back to the videos lol

[@Stickguy101]

Bruh 💀 There's always that one dev who calls the previous work shit, then makes an even shittier change and calls it a day. I am genuinely surprised how Blackthornprod hasn't implemented the "Don't remove, innovate" rule into these challenges.

[@sugabopp]

yeah and like someone said before fixing and cleaning code is different than removing or completely changing gameplay/graphics from others

[@lolofriend4701]

its bc it makes us comment lol

[@Stickguy101]

But there's no way that's the intention because, at that point, Blackthornprod is just purposely enabling developers to make poor decisions due to lack of ruling, which results in them being hated.

[@elissaforte]

But they didn't remove anything. The hand is still there, it was "improved" (In my opinion, both look terrible but that's subjective)

[@almondyum214]

@@elissaforte Terrible? Just because it is pixel art doesnt mean its outdated or trash. The pixel 2d hand: gives an identity to the game, and actually looks charming The 3d goofy hand: looks out of place and g e n e r i c

[@Ivoryskulls]

In my opinion the first hand design shouldn’t have been changed…it made the game unique

[@officialnoonon]

Without having seen the video yet, are they still changing previous established key components and nobody says anything? Hmmhmm

[@Voltraxfr]

he just deadass deleted the cool art hand and added a low poly dogshit hand model that didnt fit in, after that he deleted the entire map. wtf? @@officialnoonon

[@videobeast5548]

@@Voltraxfr is that the same guy who added a completely random mini-game into the spaceship game? The other devs did an awesome job of incorporating it into the larger game, but he clearly had no plan and just tried to throw a wrench into the cog of the project. Haven't watched it yet, but I hope he doesn't just try to ruin it again.

[@robotmaster4515]

I'm like 100 percent sure that he wanted to add a parry mechanic but then realized he couldn't replicate that pixel art style for a parry so he just made a new hand altogether. Should've either abandoned the parry or just made it an obvious placeholder and left it to a future dev to make the art. Real shame that the unique arm got replaced by yet another generic "low poly" arm. Same with the map, I think he's a cool dude and I don't wanna hate him cause I feel like a dev always gets dogpiled in these videos and I don't want that cycle to continue but alot of what he did stylistically really changed the style of the game. Sure the ice map wasn't the best but it had a clear aesthetic same with the hand. And he changed them to a more conventional style that might "look better" but it made the game lose a lot of its charm and look generic which is in my opinion is worse than looking "bad" while having clear stylistic intent. Hope he learns from this and does better next time cause he didn't seem like a bad dude. Just made a foolish mistake

[@tuna5305]

​@@Voltraxfr It's funny how he whined about the ice map looking like shit (even though it didn't) but then all the stuff he added looked ten times worse.

[@rookrac7068]

Bro casually deleted the iconic hand and the sick ice map

[@JD-wv1yi]

he'll casually ruin every single video because they won't ban him and they won't change the ruleset either

[@zizgor9510]

the loss of the pixelart hand is just devastating

[@thiccbaron]

Maybe it would be better to have some guidlines? I get it there are none so every dev just thinks what's best for the game in their opinion.

[@naolidecomisso4108]

Well at least he added a perry and a mana system, that was cool

[@shirowano]

​@@naolidecomisso4108what is a perry? Or maybe you meant to write parry?

[@ImmaSayKOOHWIP]

So Wishbone Games is the reason I am stopping this video at the 08:30 mark. That hand change ruined the entirety of the project

[@mr.randomguys7629]

The hand came back in the second video.

[@jaygallagher9195]

did you watch the next part after @mr.randomguys7629 told you the hand came back ?

[@Kev.NTheLich]

One of the first times I've almost loved every single update to the game, except the changed hand sprite

[@RenderingUser]

and the ice level removal that sucked

[@Wolfdeholycow]

@@RenderingUser couldnt agree more

[@magesticwafl]

I love adventure time

[@gforce7431]

Join the project and fix it yourself 😊

[@magesticwafl]

@@gforce7431 we’re you the dev, if not, chillax ma homie bromie cannalonie

[@lewted6617]

Ah yes, that ice level looked so bad! Let me just delete it and replace it with a flavorless green terrain. Oh and I’ll also change the unique art style and replace it with some shite 3D hand 🙄 look guys I’m so creative and innovative!

[@IceWolve67]

Men, Wishbone kinda killed it for me. The hand design was *the* feature of the game, and he turned it into a generic 3D game

[@almondyum214]

Agreed

[@supasem]

also he tried to turn it into ultrakill

[@ogpandamonium]

All he did was make the hand worse and make the level worse

[@almondyum214]

@@ogpandamonium he called it bad too.

[@Andre-vt4np]

Dont know if he is trolling or he has so much love for low poly games

[@Uniown]

it hurt to watch that hand get removed

[@Kipp274]

There's always that one dev that literally goes "No offense, but that's shit and I'm going to make everything really incohesive 🤣" However, the low poly hands are probably way easier to work with instead of sprites in terms of animations

[@icslush]

Shoutout to wishbone for an impressive amount of regression in such a short time

[@bortimer96]

100% agree. I don’t think I could’ve done a worse job if I tried

[@thatokperson]

True lmao. Worst part is if he just did the fix rather than try to force his mark on the game it actually would have been a helpful change

[@johnsai4074]

the thing is, he literally would have been fine if instead of scrapping what the devs before him had made he just added. like the parry system is very cool, it reminds me of ultrakill

[@coderaven1107]

Dont overlook the fixes (player could walk into bullet), the manameter, animations and the parry! I didnt even notice on first watch, because I was pissed of by the hand, and the map :/ He did a lot in that hour and dont deserves the hate for the unfitting hand imo.

[@brett9721]

​@@coderaven1107 nah the hand was extremely unique and added alot of style scrapping it was a huge mistake

[@nathanhollow0]

How did Wishbone insult all the other developers while making the game worse? What an absolute talent

[@JD-wv1yi]

yes hopefully they ban him and all devs like him so the next episodes aren't ruined. we have to wait a while for these videos, they take time to make, all for them to be ruined every. single. time.

[@bortimer96]

@@JD-wv1yitotally agree. Please dont invite him back

[@Maxdude27]

He made it better

[@tossover6490]

@@Maxdude27 Obvious bait

[@travv88]

what time are they in the video?

[@Voltraxfr]

Wishbone just deadass ruined whatever the game had going for it, the cool unique artstyle that suited the magic them well.

[@ax3I]

fr

[@NathanRW]

Yeah I hate to hate on people... but I was scratching my head at everything he did (I guess the reversal ability to gain mana was cool). Especially changing the hand to be 3D when the heart and enemies were still 2D... talk about an interesting decision. Then again when you're 1 of 100 people you want to do something to stick out, and with only an hour it's not like you can really make THAT much of an impact (without removing stuff lol)

[@lamezorlord]

@@NathanRW Dunno man - "sticking out" because you left a turd in the middle of a freshly made bed isn't a good thing. If your efforts shit on a previous dev, feels like you're kinda defeating the purpose of the exercise.

[@XxZeldaxXXxLinkxX]

@@lamezorlord johnny depp is that you

[@benbilbro516]

Idk about ruined man lmao, it’s just a hand art change. I bet the next 75 devs change it as well, let’s calm down now

[@FreemanFilms]

Dude, even the devs at the end are all complaining about what wishbone did…

[@Casual_guy1234]

Changes hand Removes ice map Refuses to elaborate Leaves

[@NeraLocrian]

every time there is 1 dev that removes/replaces existing things instead of creating new things

[@loekverhagen4166]

R.I.P Ice level

[@itsAaron]

Its called scoping

[@Riv3rz]

*cough* wishbone

[@weepingwalnut]

@@itsAaronthey’re prob talking about the dev that changed a bunch of the visuals for no reason, which wasn’t scoping.

[@ryanpallesen3569]

scoping is not a thing in this kind of challenge - scoping is when you talk about features and make sure you don't take up too much time. removing someone's work and then replacing it with your own while also calling it ugly is not scoping. it's inefficient and mean. the closest thing to "scoping" would be the devs who started a feature and then hoped someone else would notice it and flesh it out for them, or if any of the later devs decided to try and add new features and overhauls when they knew there wasn't much time/people left to finish it off. @@itsAaron

[@xerodeus2337]

One of the most frustrating things is when devs don't try to "build on" to what was already started and instead just do a massive rip/replace - like the original hand. Like its fine if something is obviously a placeholder (and maybe future videos there can be some way to indicate what is intentional vs place holder) but its unfortunate this happens in every one of these.

[@onman14]

What's funny is that he changed something that looked finished into something that looks like a placeholder

[@kylesturgeon1272]

timestamp

[@onman14]

​@@kylesturgeon1272 8:13

[@justs4471]

I love that every dev and comment is not a fan of the hand replacement😭

[@tttttttttttttttp12]

Hopefully they see these comments and bring it back

[@bonniechannel]

I am fan of it, hope to see the health and mana bars replaced with the left hand to match the style, while i hated that stupid heart covering half of the screen from the very beginning

[@Voxelgd]

@@bonniechannel simple, make the heart smaller. and the style already got set up as retro pixelated.

[@bonniechannel]

@@Voxelgd No one heard of mixing styles? can't mc be a wizard trapped into a 2d world?

[@Voxelgd]

@@bonniechannel it typically doesn't go very well, but yes.

[@OgBobby42]

7:44 florian for the win adding a bunnyhop system on purpose for player entertainment is good development 😂

[@Zimiyz]

Never let wish bone cook, he can’t💀

[@scarlett-v01d]

Might be more Burnt than Cooked

[@crunchybagelsalad]

The ice stage and the hands were my favourite parts 😭

[@Ankokudsura]

Both swiped by one dude 😅

[@etetgg1364]

fr

[@bloomypeach6168]

they each got only an hour, so that almost deletes all their contribution too and doesn't add anything new to the game...

[@raphael-beats]

@@bloomypeach6168Tf was this supposed to add to the conversation

[@clover3916]

@@raphael-beats They're saying that, by deleting those assets, they practically just removed MOST of a Dev's work.

[@videobeast5548]

Shoutout to the devs who decided to use their time to fix background work. We may not get to see all of your work at the end of the game, but it wouldn't function half as well as it did without any of y'all!!

[@AIAdev]

RT

[@robotmaster4515]

Bro those devs are actually the backbone of these projects. It's because of those brave devs that the other devs can do the fun stuff.

[@hemlock_hbr7845]

Agreed

[@videobeast5548]

@@robotmaster4515 Exactly, trying to get a game to work when the foundation is broken is next to impossible.

[@danqzq]

Thank you 🥹

[@fluffiddy6515]

Never let wishbone cook again 😭

[@justarandomstranger1]

Dang, i hate the changes but i hope the man is doing fine mentally considering how the entire internet is cooking him right now💀

[@etetgg1364]

I'm sure he's fine.@@justarandomstranger1

[@koppy82]

@@justarandomstranger1 "entire internet" bro r u high?

[@tttttttttttttttp12]

​@@justarandomstranger1def not the entire Internet but they're absolutely looking at this comment section and dying inside so that's a plus

[@coderaven1107]

But Wishbone actually added a lot! The bugfix (player can walk into bullet), the manameter, animations and the parry. I didnt remember them because I was pissed of by the hand, and the map, but he still made those in 1 hour, which is crazy impressive imo!

[@michaelwolf1377]

Dude that removed the ice map and the cool hand art legit just shit on the whole project and left.

[@Constellation-Creative]

Fingers crossed our armor and item drop mechanic makes it to the final version 🤞 great job, all! This one was a ton of fun to program on.

[@3TheHunter3]

Petition to bring back the old 2D hand arty style in the next episode!

[@edisonarango]

And the ice map!

[@memelord9232]

i support this

[@memelord9232]

wishbone was rude and added nothing good to the gmae

[@FireFighter-b.001]

@@memelord9232 Well he did make bad changes and said bad things but fixed some bugs and the parry sistem looks kinda cool

[@memelord9232]

@@FireFighter-b.001 tru

[@m4ximili0us9]

Wishbone literally making the game worse killed 90% of the excitement I've had

[@godofsadness]

whoo

[@greedy_mf]

ong, i will remember that name to know which games to avoid in the future

[@thaddeus1519]

lol what a weird L take, guys trying their best in a short amount of time, don't think that means you need to boycot his games@@greedy_mf

[@mosquitodaddy]

dude this guy sucked hard haha

[@ryanlight9579]

Can you add time slot? I can’t find it in the video

[@DualWielded]

I will name my firstborn child after AIA for his contribution to this game

[@AIAdev]

👀

[@Hawksfarm]

Thinking about submitting an application to work on the game just to put your hand design back in 😭

[@flycraft8282]

Whats up @DuelWielded love your game

[@domeen0gt895]

@@Hawksfarm dew it

[@seapickels9087]

Whats his real name

[@jreamy21]

@3:49 "I always wanted a game which is Battle Royale, but magic. So like PUBG, but Skyrim." Cries in Spellbreak.

[@Jollofmuncher2000]

boy he would've loved spellbreak

[@Dethcat12]

Before any dev is brought into the challenge they should be taught the most basic tenet of improv: "yes, and..."

[@tadhgconroy8631]

Don’t ever let wishbone cook again

[@danqzq]

It was super fun to be a part of this epic challenge! R.I.P ice level ☠️

[@kamioodev]

And he called it shit aswell. It was so much better.😭😭

[@Vox777]

The ice level needs justice

[@Undeadred914]

Bruh why you change the hand

[@danqzq]

@@Undeadred914 it wasn't me lol

[@apasten0818]

AND WHERE'S FIRE?

[@TwiggyMC]

Love how he said each dev gets an hour yet they drop the facade entirely bit by bit and just start telling us they really get 3 hours XD

[@ShiningDarknes]

Honestly, would be more interesting to see a project by 100 devs that each get a day's worth of time (that is to say a working day so 8-12 hours).

[@TwiggyMC]

@ShiningDarknes it would but I was looking forward to a chaotic mess of a game from only an hour at a time

[@ShiningDarknes]

eh, 100 hours is basically nothing in dev time. I think allowing devs one working day each would lead to far more chaos. After all, if they are not allowed enough time for creativity to guide their hands towards chaos there won't be much chaos. Gotta give time for the intrusive thoughts to win.@@TwiggyMC

[@friedrichdergroe6361]

I think they just noticed after a few Devs an hour just wasn't enough to see what the game may be about and then also add something

[@sdaniaal]

They probably start with 1 hours and get more time the further the project goes on... they can't do all that work with just barely an hour of viewing, testing and coding

[@kingkraken9878]

The guy changing the ice map for grass got me furious

[@coreywright5394]

I'm absolutely in love with this project idea! I would do anything to see more/learn more/or even be apart of future projects!

[@Sitskier123]

Yep I think we’re all in agreement…Wishbone completely ruined the unique art style that was going by adding something completely out of place for no reason. Basically moral of what he said was “I didn’t like the other art that was done so I did it myself” when he had never done a day of art in his life. Hopefully he didn’t fully delete the old hand art in the project file and it can come back at some point but it seems like with the ice arena he made his over the other and deleted the old one, so I’m assuming he just deleted the old hand design completely for his ego.

[@macun8424]

deadass all he did was waste his time chancing assets that needed no chance when other devs were adding and moving the project forwards or fixing bugs

[@bonniechannel]

@@macun8424 He made a placeholder for 3d hands to move the project forward

[@harrasika]

​@@bonniechannel but he didn't need to add it. The 2D hand already worked well and looked good

[@bonniechannel]

@@harrasika Really? So what should devs do? Add nothing? You can't just stand in place and hope it works, you have to try what you fell better to make progression, that's what making stuff is all about, any dev can be criticized this way, for example I hated this cringe sprite pretending to be the "mouse" Game from the very beginning

[@harrasika]

@@bonniechannel Devs should implement actual useful features, not replace things with objectively worse alternatives. You are one of the very few people here who actually think that the 3D hand fits the game more than the 2D hand, thus you're objectively wrong. It's okay for devs to try new things, it's not as okay to remove other people's work and replace it with worse things.

[@prophetgproductions]

pontypants did nothing in that hour. true game development right there

[@justarandomstranger1]

guy had 3 hour i believe and choose to do something you learn on day 1 and hope everything will just work. Wishbone saved that guy's ass by being hated by the internet more💀

[@personwhohasayoutubechannel3]

The guy afterward was worse. Just shouted out his shit like we need more ads

[@quintonsmylie5584]

@@justarandomstranger1 bruh, ponty gave it direction by giving it a title. sure he could have done more to it but idk, i dont think its fair to hate on him for it. I don't think it's fair to hate on wishbone either, but his decision to change some of what the previous game devs had done as opposed to adding onto it (not to say he didn't add onto it) just felt like a non collaborative decision to me.

[@gumpty831]

@@quintonsmylie5584 slapping a suggestive title on a game, so that it becomes what you want, isn't game development. At this point he's just a viewer like us💀💀

[@DiegoHernandez-ud3cz]

You still need to add the rule that 1 dev shouldn't be able to delete stuff from other devs. The ice map and the hand got changed for no reason.

[@Justheretowatchvids365]

They have to delete things to improve the game. Otherwise things can get buggy real fast. I think they saw it as an upgrade rather than replacing but I’m sure a future dev will fix it due these comments lol

[@ElectricIro]

@@Justheretowatchvids365 Improving and cleaning the code is one thing, but replacing ideas and visuals is another

[@invis_potion]

I feel like it should follow improv rules with the "yes and.." method that way creativity is expanded on and nobody's work gets out to waste

[@rob-rendell]

Perhaps it could be based on where they are in the sequence. Devs in the "early phases" of the development are told not to delete stuff, but late-phase devs are allowed to clean things up to make the game coherent.

[@moocowp4970]

​@@ElectricIrothey're arguably the same I think, just people don't see the difference. If you write some code and I delete it and rewrite it so it does something slightly different that's sort of the same as if you make some art and I delete it and redraw it to make it look slightly different. At least in my opinion they're equivalent. But I agree with the general premise that people should be thoroughly encouraged to enhance/build on top of, rather than remove. I guess in people's defence sometimes it is hard in these rapidly-developed games to determine what is placeholder and what was intended to be in the final game.

[@MrhibyeTV]

0:54 "I created a nice warm, spicy desert" literally dirt and 2 ferns 😂

[@xlJASON]

Pontypants was describing Spellbreak! Rip tho. Devs stopped working on it and pulled the plug for it.

[@Mr_Katman]

I liked the old hand more then the low poly one it fit the aesthetic way more and the ice level looked amazing meanwhile the grass one that replaced it was also pretty good wish both got to exist tho

[@markmckenzie5343]

Dual Wielded is honestly the best for these. He always thinks about the people before him and those coming after. Plus great creation skills, both in games and his video production style.

[@Hawksfarm]

lol AIA adding his damage system so he can have 98 other devs bug-fix it for him 😂😂

[@AIAdev]

Now I just need to get my hands on the fixes…

[@segoul7725]

​@@AIAdev That's genius holy shit💀💀

[@sal_strazzullo]

The fix: git revert a73fc87

[@epzilon5847]

​@@AIAdev bro's mind gaming us🤣

[@theswamps6589]

@@AIAdev HHAHAHAHA! that. is. hilarious.

[@tuzzxd5800]

99 DEVS make a game, 1 DEV just change everything mid creation.

[@FG-vp6id]

Wishbone is such a partycrasher, never let him cook again dawg ☠️

[@midnigh7x]

3:50 "I always wanted a game that was battle royal, but magic"... You just described Spellbreak

[@gaver3453]

My thoughts exactly

[@Vertically_standing_bread]

By the way battle royal is spelt royale. I can see the confusion since the game dev also spelt it wrong

[@tommans3125]

plus bro literally spent 1 hour in creating a main menu that shitty that should only take 15 mins

[@SmellLikeDoritos]

wishbone unironically almost made me stop watching the video lmao

[@Will.Henderson]

same, except not almost

[@crownisclown]

SAME!! Like no offense but literally why would you make a 3D low poly hand in a pixel art styled game.. also it's just really ugly in general

[@tinybabybread]

lmfao I stopped at that point as well and skipped to the end. I was ready to invest my time into the vid, too before that part I go to the comments and see I definitely wasn't alone

[@ShiningDarknes]

Now we all know who to unsubscribe from and click "don't recommend this channel" when it pops up on our home screens.

[@PrimeTime0]

@@ShiningDarknesjust because he made a shit decision? hes a really good dev and was great in the newest competition video

[@oakleymayhead]

I do agree with everyone else that the swap of the hand texture/ ice world was a shame, but this is definitely a strong start! Looking forward to seeing how this progresses!

[@Jayteezaman]

@3:45 "a game that is battle royale, but magic" Yeah that game was called Spellbreak and it flopped super hard they had to shut down the servers. I thought it was really fun and had lots of potential, but they flooded their servers with bots to try to make up for the lack of players, but this made the remaining players not want to play anymore because 9/10 players in a match were actually bots that had the AI pathing of toddlers

[@johnzblewski1777]

The game pontypants wants already came out. It was called spellbreak. It flopped so hard it was shut down in literally 6 months

[@sichfromTX]

i was hoping someone said this

[@jonthenamelessproject99]

As someone who does a lot of theatre. There is a rule in most improv (Improvised) games or warmups we do called "Yes, And" which basically if the person you're with says something like "You burnt the pie" you don't go "No I didn't. It's completely fine" because you're doing what's called Blocking which is where you disregard or don't allow someone's idea to progress, Instead you would go "Yes I did.... And I also heard some meowing near the oven earlier as well" which contributes to the joke. This is something that I see happening quite a lot in these X amount of Devs make a game challenge but there's always someone that sort of just steps all over other peoples work to do their own thing as opposed to contributing it. Whether they realise it or not is irrelevant but it happens often on these videos and it really gets in the way of both an enjoyable video and most importantly the collaboration of these developers who took time out of their day to participate in this challenge. It's a hard thing to regulate as sometimes changes are needed, sometimes cuts are necessary or sometimes redesigns are needed but there needs to be some guideline of sorts that prevents Devs from removing things. Especially the Ice Level which didn't need to go. There's 75 more Devs on the way who could've made use of that and might make use of it if the files are still there. It's a shame because I really enjoy this concept of video but it's just getting so hard to enjoy them when stuff like this happens and having seen the comments from previous videos I know I'm not the only one.

[@bonniechannel]

Replacing things is a part of progress, you can't just stand in place and hope things work

[@Riko-un8ys]

@@bonniechannelTry to say things within a certain context. Because now you’ve added absolutely nothing to any conversation.

[@bonniechannel]

@@Riko-un8ys I added more than you did

[@knightofcarrion7358]

@@bonniechannel no you added nothing.

[@bonniechannel]

@@knightofcarrion7358 If you don't know how progression works, it's not me who you should cry about it

[@shinami3758]

Wishbone: So, I threw out the entire aesthetic of the project and made terrible replacements because the originals looked like shit. Oh, yea. The throwable feature in the ice map was a casualty of my changes. So, we have unprofessional behavior and unnecessarily removing assets. Yea, I think "innovate, not remove" really needs to become a rule for these projects. The only reason I kept going through the video was to see if anyone threw out Wishbone's work in turn. Sadly, they did not. Here's to hoping someone adds a hub world like the tower in Gauntlet Legends and brings back the ice world.

[@CrammyCram]

12:13 I love how this guy didn’t completely change the model to fix a problem, he just retextured the already existing textures slightly to make it more visually appealing.

[@xelzp]

I love how much pontypants contributed without him the whole game would've collapsed because of how much he added

[@kitsune.u4ea]

what a cool video idea, i really hope no one messes with the ui or art style

[@Caroline-g7x]

this is a great video, though, to show all the unique artist that are out there so happy you got to do this

[@peterplayz52]

Dual Wielded is the funniest guy every time you invite him. Please keep doing so. It's always a highlight

[@peterplayz52]

Also Wishbone is the sorta guy that kinda ruins these otherwise stellar videos for me. He added one thing, while destroying the aesthetic and shitting on the previous guys. As a point of contrast Dual Wielded does this much better. Instead of removing or replacing he just adds his own ideas and lets other people work on ideas he "ignored"/just didn't touch. His criticism at 13:16 perfectly matches my thoughts

[@belzedk]

@@peterplayz52 It such a crazy contras to someone like Globox, who went in and just fixed stuff.

[@daviddoesdev8304]

I'm also not a fan of the 2D hand turning 3D, but I am a huge fan of the namecard animations changing from a 2D hand to a 3D hand to keep with the hand's style in game. Probs to the editor (I can tell it's you, DualWielded x)

[@nuggy9597]

“Take 0% less damage” damn that’s such a good piece of armour

[@NightcoreDemon]

I love how the second person to touch it completely ignored everything you did and just basically started from 0 again

[@monkeycorpz7982]

Wishbone games was removed from the timestamps and the bio that's so funny lmao

[@soop3r872]

No way😭

[@beYOndd]

He was probably getting flamed lmaoo

[@fluffiddy6515]

💀

[@MaciekRodriguez]

Dude literally saw the pixel art style, saw the enemies, saw the map, and decided to ruin the already made amazing hand sprite. I swear to god it bothered me so much throughout the video, without that guy the game would have been perfect.

[@EKUL34]

Wishbone needs to learn what "yes and" is and also what ice is

[@IceWolve67]

I hate how there is ALWAYS that one guy that decides to do the opposite of what the rest decided. Wishbone really seems like a donkey

[@V14.official]

I mean no one communicated

[@emmecalvert6691]

​@@V14.official That doesnt excuse the fact that he removed and replaced a couple people's work that when he finished was mediocre in comparison. He didn't even try to imitate the artstyle. He also called the map sh*t when it didn't look bad, it once again was an art style choice that he chose to think was inferior. He has a huge ego. Its considered very rude to remove someones work. They should definitely ban the guy or have a talk with him about respecting another person's work.

[@V14.official]

@@emmecalvert6691 Like I said There was NO COMMUNICATION the devs have to rely on there own ideas. He probably had a different thought proccess then the other devs.

[@emmecalvert6691]

​@@V14.officialI will agree with you that its good to bring in your own ideas and is the point of the challenge. It also is important to BUILD OFF existing ideas not strip them away, what he did is completely remove 2 developers hard work.

[@V14.official]

@@emmecalvert6691 true but i guess thats the beauty of not communicating with each other and goes to show how communication is very important to make a consistent game

[@okayboozy]

I pray one of the next 75 devs changes the hand back

[@sinnombre973]

the guy who make the enemies desing was soooooo cool, it change the game but for the better, really nice.

[@JshorterVideo]

It bothers me how wishbone talks trash about previous devs everytime he is on one of these videos. He's like that one kind in class that acts like they know everything but they really don't.

[@Gatrehs]

Just put him first instead.

[@mandarkian]

Yes and then their changes were crap anyway.

[@yousefsekhri425]

The first hand design was way better, and fit the rest of the game. Wishbone games just removed it because he had no ideas to contribute.

[@thatokperson]

Exactly bro ran out of ideas so he defaulted to making it more like the games he usually makes.

[@SoChair-cy7ki]

you can make the hand into a piece of turd and it would still look better.

[@XxZeldaxXXxLinkxX]

wishbone came in like a wrecking ball

[@omiddoesnotomit9320]

I was about to comment the same thing

[@idontwannatypeaname]

really did wreck it all

[@vulturecorpse]

man there is ALWAYS that one creator with main character syndrome who has to ruin the previous work. Y’all know exactly who I mean

[@teldrynsero6791]

Whoever changed the hand kinda goofed it, the 2d art was so cool and defo fit the ui and map artstyle alot better.

[@greghenderson460]

Whenever something cool is replaced with something else it hurts my heart. Also the mixture of 3D and 2D is jarring, 3D boss, 2D enemies, 3D landscapes instead of 2.5D, 3D hand replacing 2D hand... aghhh!

[@dnsjtoh]

The heart killed me, it was so ugly the entire video.

[@kasane1337]

@@dnsjtoh True, Cruelty Squad's HP bar is much better.

[@unspi554]

The nail art color depending on the power type was a very cool ideo loved it hope to see it back on next batch of dev x) !

[@badyherz]

Yeah that was such a cool idea. Loved it. I'm weirdly sad about, that this person just deleted it..

[@The_Goobler]

The second hand makes the game look so cheap I am enraged

[@Diana2112Gaming]

100% think changing the hand was a mistake. The nails representing spells was such a neat touch.

[@dylanherrera5395]

I love how 90% of people are just hating on wishbone for that change, and im all for it

[@GingerNingerish]

This was such an awesome experience to be a part of. Loved seeing how it carried on and people trying to commit to the pixel aesthetics. Interesting about the hand change. I did see them still in the asset folders when working on it.

[@Orionhart]

Same! You were right before us-- thanks for sending such a functional version 🙏

[@GingerNingerish]

​@Orionhart Yooo, your guys addition was awsome. Glad I didn't break it haha.

[@justarandomstranger1]

there is hope haha

[@ridderrowan3987]

8:37 man shits on the map while his hand design is way worse 🤡

[@animatheo5779]

Man I was left angrier from this vid man, the 1st hand was so much more readable and unique

[@joethealiensoon]

Wishbone sounded like such a headass too so jarring

[@animatheo5779]

@@joethealiensoon true

[@burgerwizard910]

This is how Infinity Ward and Sledgehammer Games made Modern Warfare 3

[@cookies_r_cool2526]

Bro I can't even watch these videos without getting mad asf at the devs 😭

[@LubsiRednuhts]

Wow, you really scaled it up for this one. I appreciate all the time each of these devs put into making the game and recording it solely for our entertainment. Thank you

[@sapientunderground]

"solely for our entertainment." Yeah, not like they're actually made to market a product or anything.

[@LubsiRednuhts]

@@sapientunderground they have sponsors yes and they get their main income from views and likes that require people to find their videos entertaining. So yes, it is a very big deal to them that they entertain us

[@Vox777]

The ice to grass and changed hand sprite was so sad : (

[@asukiWAN]

the guy who made it from 2d to 3d hands and changed the world is lame for that tbh.

[@gandalfgrey5779]

i love how there was the occasional dev that just wanted to polish the game up a bit lol.

[@vecremser2226]

Definitely needed a "only innovate" rule. Everything was going fine until Wishbone decided to revert others progress in place of his own.

[@picklenickk22]

I think that every dev did a great job, but I am not a fan of the contributions from wishbone. The ice arena was pretty nice, and I would’ve appreciated it not being completely deleted. Also that 3D hand just looks so out of place.

[@nullone3181]

100 devs make a game without communicating? Finally a behind-the-scenes video on the making of Starfield.

[@badyherz]

The first hands were so much better. Why do people just delete stuff instead of adding on whats already there.. Also I loved the idea with the nailpolish representing what spell you have equipped. Idk if a game already did that but it's an amazing idea. Very sad this person just deleted it. Maybe they should add some basic rules, so stuff like this doesn't get lost. Idk if that would go against the idea of the video, but I think so much cooler games would turn out. And people have to learn to adapt/get out of their comfort zone, wich is always a good skill to improve on.

[@julianrossi7607]

Just came to comment that the first hand pixel was beautiful and that Wishbone just made me dont wanna keep watching the video but then i saw that theres lots of comment about it... i can rest now