The Combination Poncho Tent?

Рет қаралды 3,451

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 62

@bensanford9146 8 ай бұрын

As a modern Army light infantryman, I can testify how full circle we have come. When I first joined the army, they were still issuing the green snap together Army shelter half. If you’ve not seen it, they are a canvas modern(ish) pup tents. Anyway, we only used them in basic training. After that in the field on a non-Tactical bivouac, many of still set up our ponchos as Civil War style pup tents. The ponchos are even designed to attach together to form a larger tent. Newer soldiers, are now issued the tarpaulin. Which is just an improved, slightly larger version, without a head slit. But most of us veterans prefer our good old army poncho.

@josephgonzales4802 8 ай бұрын

Interesting, I'm a 11B from the early 80s when we were issued the shelter half, poncho and wet weather gear. 🤔

@dimezrecon 6 ай бұрын

Yeah, my poncho got torn, went to DX it, they tried to give me the new Tarp. I straight up refused to sign for it, lol. They gave me a poncho after awhile.

@woltews 8 ай бұрын

the central problem of the combination is that you generally need in camp when it rains both a set up tent and personal waterproof clothing and by combining both into one item you will lose one to get the function of the other , if you just issue each person 2 combinations then you will likely have an unesisarily heavy shelter and also a poncho that is not optimal for it use as it must also be a shelter meaning the troops now carry more weight not less

@standinthedoor1944 8 ай бұрын

Hey brother this is super solid content. Idk why your video popped up in my feed because I don’t study the civil war very often but what caught my eye is I do basically the exact same thing on my KZbin channel but for WWII Airborne. Amazing job using original documents and photos to promote a more accurate historical base for living history all the while presenting in a what that in honoring a respectful to other people. Presenting fact and calling out historical inaccuracy but in a way that motivates people rather than just tick people off. We honor them by wearing what they wore and carrying what they carried! Liked and subscribed! God bless and keep crushing it!

@11thovc 8 ай бұрын

Thanks Standinthedoor1944! Glad we randomly showed up in your feed! My son watches your content since he is a huge WWII guy! lol.

@standinthedoor1944 8 ай бұрын

Oh nice! Hope he likes it.

@rjohnson1690 8 ай бұрын

The weight of a waterproof blanket and shelter half is so negligible, That combining them is kinda pointless. Plus not having rain gear after your tent is set up would kinda suck. Having a truly waterproof tent would be awesome though.

@11thovc 8 ай бұрын

Definitely agree!

@josephgonzales4802 8 ай бұрын

I also agree.👍

@tomhenry897 8 ай бұрын

Never packed one have you

@phillipsmith21 8 ай бұрын

Every grunt in the modern military carry both but occasionally we used the poncho to pitch a tent because the tent was in the rear and we got stranded out over night or were just in need of shade.

@sandpounder3443 8 ай бұрын

Ounces make pounds my dude

@johnking6406 8 ай бұрын

Actually I think Mr. Day was probably way ahead of his time

@garycollins8518 4 ай бұрын

I did civil war living history for years . Carried shelter tent half and rubber poncho both worked ok on the march

@sirfox950 8 ай бұрын

Was the song really that necessary? 😅

@arfyego0682 8 ай бұрын

Definitely

@simeondarke201 8 ай бұрын

this is typical of the heads of the Quartermaster dept and the dept of Ordinance who would deny soldiers good equipment because the inventor pissed them off. A classic example of this was the WW1 refusal by the dept of ordinance to adopt the Lewis gun because the head of ordinance had a feud with Col Lewis

@kimnenninger7226 8 ай бұрын

Way more interesting than I first thought that this subject would be. I have one of those two part green canvas tents from WWII(?) That I got from a surplus store. We bought it for when we would go on point to point rides on our horses. The tent looks like it would sleep three men or two fat ladies, two dogs, and two wet saddles. It was really cool except it was too heavy for us to carry. I think each side was 2.5 pounds. Which is a lot if all of your gear can only weigh no more than 12 pounds. We are not soldiers but we had to be totally self contained like a soldier might have to be. We each had a firearm and small amount of amo, boots for our horses, large utility knife, canteen/water purifier (we ended up chucking these), and a fire/soap kit. This crap was almost 12 pounds itself. We had to dump the canvas and buy plastic lined table cloths for the two horses and us. These were the greatest. To bad they didn't have plastic back then.

@giantskunk 8 ай бұрын

Once being a reenactor shopaholic, I picked up a reproduction of one of these several years back. I use it as a poncho most of the time. However, when the pards and I build a shebang, it is very handy to button into a conventional shelter half piece for a little extra room.

@davidborn5857 8 ай бұрын

The Day tent/poncho was found in the kit of a North Carolina Infantry soldier in 1863 or so. A good friend of mine David Urbanski saw and took detailed notes on this piece. The neck opening had a blue corduroy covering.

@rjohnson1690 8 ай бұрын

Was that the May grouping?

@joshuathomas8529 8 ай бұрын

Fast forward to the 1960's and the poncho tent was wide spread issued. The ponchos my dad was issued in the 80's and 90's could be snapped together to make a tent. The same design of ponchos were still being issued when I was medicaly retired in 2018. I must admit that I never did snap.my poncho together with another soldier to make a tent. I did this with a multicam poncho and a woodland poncho just to prove it possible. I would be willing to do it again and video it if thers enough interest.

@peterstadlmaier3107 4 ай бұрын

McClellan: Will your Poncho work as a tent? Mr.Day: Que Sera, Sera!

@robertschultz6922 8 ай бұрын

This was a really great idea and unfortunately was just a loser of politics. The quartermaster department should have been more worried about giving the troops the best possible product rather than being hurt by how the invention was originally presented. How many other great ideas were scrapped because some bureaucrat didn’t like the inventor or was more impressed by some one else rather than the actual product?

@michaelpeters7044 8 ай бұрын

The Soviet Red Army used them for years. They were cotton weave with wax melted in to make it water proof. I think they were called plash. It woren as a cape, hooded poncho, tent half.

@lesliepaulkovacs6442 8 ай бұрын

The problem lies with the situation of Standing Guard in the Rain vs having a Dry Place to rest AFTER Guard Duty. Set up a Poncho Tent, then tear it apart for Guard, then rebuild the Tent? Carry two Ponchos? Or a Shelter Half and a Poncho?

@leoscheibelhut940 8 ай бұрын

The biggest problem with the combo poncho tent is that when one of the tentmates is on guard during rainy nights part of the tent disappears.

@vaquerojoel2026 8 ай бұрын

I think it would have been a great idea. Though not having rain gear when your tent was set up would be an inconvenience. The modern military poncho is a combination shelter half and poncho though it is intended as an improvised shelter.

@bruceblunt2969 7 ай бұрын

Minus the rubbarizing it sounds a lot like what most European armies would be issuing in the Great War and beyond. Mr. Day was a head of his time.

@Idahoguy10157 3 ай бұрын

Under the old Army’s bureau system the Chief of Quartermaster Corp was not obligated to obey General McClellan. Army procurement was as Byzantine then as it is now.

@mikeoyler2983 8 ай бұрын

I think this is an interesting aspect of McClellan's army reforms. He did consider types of equipment that could have made the army more efficient. Ultimately, this was probably was not the best piece of equipment.

@sandpounder3443 8 ай бұрын

It worked for the soviets and germans later on. I wonder if they got the idea from Day somehow years later

@richardross7219 8 ай бұрын

The common enemy in all armies was the quartermaster. 50 years ago, I had to bamboozle our qm to get what i needed.

@chrishastings2665 8 ай бұрын

McClellan: I don't wanna Me: that's probably what he said.

@josephgonzales4802 8 ай бұрын

I rather be dry both inside and outside the tent. Then just inside. Also its a pain in the you know what to have to take down your tent because it's raining. 🤔

@andydaniels3029 8 ай бұрын

Unless I just don’t know enough about the processes of canvas shelter manufacture in the time period, it would seem like the vast majority of moisture-related issues could be handled with relative ease regardless of whether the canvas was cotton or linen-based, and more so if there was a seasoning process in the manufacture of the canvas; I’m thinking in the scope of the 90-98th percentile of moisture-related issues, although I have no idea at all about whether or not it was indeed part of the process. Beyond that even, if a shelter half was given to further waterproofing efforts on individually-based preferences by a soldier (as I understand such wasn’t done as part of the manufacturing process of the shelter half), it could veritably stand up to virtually all moisture-related issues given period waterproofing techniques without adding a significant amount of weight to the shelter half. Considering all of that, it seems almost redundant to have a combination item for such a purpose that may not necessarily be ideal for either purpose when just a little extra DIY with the original item might in fact give you a superior item for the purpose intended without adding much more of a burden to the soldiers.

@tomhenry897 8 ай бұрын

Did the same thing in the army Shelter halves leaked so much Especially in heavy rain

@jeffreyrobinson3555 8 ай бұрын

I wonder at the usefulness when one of the guys would have to go stand guard in the rain, and took a third of the tent from his buddies

@vinceb4380 8 ай бұрын

They should be issued to every Veteran living on the street today.🇺🇸

@christopherevans2547 5 ай бұрын

Considering most modern military’s issue some type of combination poncho shelters I’d say he was ahead of his time.

@josephgonzales4802 8 ай бұрын

Yes,I have. I have both a shelter tent and a rubber blanket. 😏

@CalumMacNeil-qb6wp 8 ай бұрын

THE RUBBERISED PONCHO IS GOOD 2 TO EACH SOLDIER. BUT THOSE BEARDS LOOKED A FIRE HAZARD.A PAIR OF HEDGE TRIMMERS WOULD BE OF HELP.👍

@Buck1954 8 ай бұрын

Turned off by the Taco Bell Interuptions

@MrSheckstr 8 ай бұрын

Once was enough…..

@charlesmurphy7712 8 ай бұрын

That , taco hut interruption was very intrusive and distracting with your lesson on this product.

@11thovc 8 ай бұрын

Charlesmurphy7712, thanks for letting us know! When making this episode, we couldn't stop singing the song and thought it would be a fun insert at parts of the video. Sometimes we just have to have fun with our videos! lol. Thanks for letting us know thought!

@bensanford9146 8 ай бұрын

Disagree. Thought it was cute and creative.

@charlesmurphy7712 8 ай бұрын

@@11thovc your welcome , once or twice would have been great and laughable.

@MrSheckstr 8 ай бұрын

@@11thovc the Tasting history has a recurring gimmick whenever hardtack is mentioned, but it is less than a second in length has no music and does NOT have a jump in volume…. This is just so out of place for a civil war era , or post civil war era video. Also, this is the first video of yours u have scene, if it leave a bad taste in the mouth, it will make me less likely to want to watch more. Meanwhile i do not see its inclusion enticing people to watch other videos

@arthurvarady7258 5 ай бұрын

Megs was just cry baby hurt because they skipped the quarter master chain and he felt he wasn’t included in the buy out because he couldn’t throw his two cents in. Things never change, ain’t it the truth….He He He.

@jillatherton4660 8 ай бұрын

👍

@militaryhomes6292 8 ай бұрын

Its not a great idea. If you're on patrol and your tent is already up you have to make the choice to take it down or go out without a Poncho. Also everyone else sharing your tent isnt going to be happy if you want to wear your poncho.

@dimezrecon 6 ай бұрын

For the win, haha

@GrangerGangster 8 ай бұрын

I thought the combination Pizza Hut and Taco Bell bit was hilarious. It really represented the absurdity of the times and highlighted the perceived government money grab that entrepreneurs see during wartime. Sure, it can be claimed that a combination Pizza Hut and Taco Bell is what the consumer needs, but I mean, do (did) we really? Kudos to Meigs for squashing something that was unnecessary and was just going to encumber the government with more junk with the sole benefactor being the inventor/contractor, who I’m sure didn’t have any sons serving in the field.