2024 SAG Nominees REACTION!!

TWITTER:
/ expert_oscar
/ withbrotherbro
LETTERBOXD:
letterboxd.com...
letterboxd.com...
DISCORD:
/ discord

[@axr7149]

The funny thing is that no matter which of the 2 POOR THINGS guys gets the Oscar nod, that person will tie the Supporting Actor nomination Oscar record.

[@chrisf5828]

Wasn't Walter Brennan nominated for supporting like ten times?

[@axr7149]

@@chrisf5828 Nope. Only 4, but won 3 of those. 7 men tie this record at present (including Brennan).

[@chrisf5828]

​@@axr7149Thanks. I knew he had all the supporting actor wins and assumed he had a Bette Davis or Meryl Streep sort of ratio of noms and wins.

[@shinesartorius]

If they both get in, It will be the seventh year in a row there has been two supporting nominations from the same movie

[@jacksmith2417]

My first thoughts upon reading the nominations were: “We’ve got an entertaining reaction video very shortly”.

[@tarynwilson1223]

I had the same thought!

[@poett8875]

I’m conflicted because I’m not crazy about the nominations, however I do like how it really shook the race up. Makes the Oscar’s more difficult to predict.

[@kheirbasileus2126]

Takeaways: -Huge for The Color Purple to get into Ensemble. -I think DiCaprio gets in at the Oscars. -Poor Things takes a hit after winning Globe. -Barbie might win here. -Oppenheimer the clear favorite for Best Picture.

[@rhythmoriented]

Nice summary. While Poor Things will continue to be fighting uphill to beat the above and below the line juggernaut Oppenheimer, there should be absolutely no surprise that a fantasy/sci fi-premised film misses ensemble. In addition to The Shape of Water and LOTR as BP’s missing the cut, the list is long.

[@blacktoad2425]

lmaoooo, 4 of these ended up being wrong....

[@nyctophilex7]

Past Lives and Anatomy got nothing. :(

[@dollarsaurus01]

Ruffalo not being nominated is truly shocking and outrageous. Maybe his best work ever. Also surprised to see DiCaprio left out, not that he needs the recognition but I do think Flower Moon is some of his best and most uncharacteristically subtle work ever. As for Melton he was always going to be a long shot imo. But he’s just getting started and has his whole career ahead of him. One day he’ll get his recognition

[@WaterHazard86]

Willem is truly being Dafoe to his co-star Mark Ruffalo.

[@Cinemadiction]

Good job

[@tashkenty]

I think it’s sentimentality, lots of actors love willem and his body of work. Hope he gets the Oscar finally

[@Eternelspotlessmind]

I truly loved Defoe's acting in Poor things!! Mark Ruffalo was amazing as well!!

[@teamrainbow7674]

Surprised to say that I’m hoping that the Oscars are more in line with the Globes than both the Critics Choice and definitely SAG

[@KikeNavarrete68]

The reality is that members of SAG vote in the Oscars (the acting branch is the biggest in the academy) and the people who vote in the GG and the CC not

[@Christina-yc4dn]

Agree

[@daniellepereira7255]

Also the comedy vs drama split gave the GG just more opportunities to recognise movies and actors

[@girlboss3426]

​@@KikeNavarrete68which means the problem is the american actors while the solution is more International voters.

[@manantial773]

Not a good comparison, Globes have 49292 more slots than SAG.

[@TheHoundisdead]

Starting to really get worried about Melton’s chances at even an oscar nom :(

[@shaktincredible]

he's this year's Paul Mescal or Kristen Stewart I think. finger crossed he will be nominated at Oscars!

[@pb.j.1753]

@@shaktincrediblePlease stop insulting Kristen Stewart like that.

[@ejm6460]

I have a feeling he'll make it in. The performance is hard to deny

[@happybirthday6130]

no he will get in #trust

[@pb.j.1753]

@@ejm6460denied.

[@legendlover91]

Going through the five stages of grief for Sandra and Greta 💔

[@ReggieWilson-gm5dl]

And Fantasia

[@sadronweasley]

The cat noped the f outta the chaos lmao SAG noms are a mess

[@christopherscottcarpenter]

The most shocking thing for me from these nominations was the omission of Leo - it was smart of you boys to predict he would be in the fungible slot. He just seemed like part of the awards train this year, but he has definitely been campaigning more for Lily than for himself. The five here are all good options, though. A sad development, but a right one.

[@TheFilmAutopsy]

Super stoked for Sterling K Brown, he is such a beast of an actor, love to see it

[@angelsilva7207]

Yeah, fr, he has great range. He can be the friendly, loving family man in This is Us. A hard, serious, no nonsense father in Waves, a desperate and hilariously deluded priest in Honk For Jesus and the character he plays in American Fiction, who imo, was the best part of that movie. I need to see my man in some staring roles

[@christopherseeman3301]

The zoom in at 4:27 had me howling with laughter

[@TheCatIndeed]

I think for supporting actor, we’re gonna have RRR (Ryan, Robert, Robert) one of the Poor Things boys, and who the hell knows what’s happening with #5

[@pb.j.1753]

Dominic Sessa hopefully

[@dan0617]

pulling hard for Charles Melton

[@girlboss3426]

I really want Charles but i'm thinking in colman domingo now

[@TheCatIndeed]

@@girlboss3426for color purple?

[@pb.j.1753]

@@girlboss3426Colman Domingo in supporting actor? Not rather lead?

[@nikolasheinz]

The Golden Globes have the best noms of the awards season so far

[@Eternelspotlessmind]

Maybe i am a minority but Melton did not impress me. I am not surprised he is not in!

[@pb.j.1753]

May December getting snubbed completely is my jam

[@coffeysr72]

Strangely, I think this confirms both Poor Things boys are more likely to get in than Melton, Sessa, or Brown at Oscar.

[@tonyg76]

The Poor Things boys and Brown could all get in. Brown might coattail Wright.

[@leckard4]

I do wonder why Melton seems to have everyone's attention more than Sessa. Dominic was in way more of his movie and was just as good as Melton. Melton had a few good scenes, but that was it.

[@emz3444]

Sandra Huller not getting a nom is craaazzzzzyyyy

[@seankoontz4235]

Jeremy Strong not getting nominated for Succession was more shocking than anything in the film categories

[@pb.j.1753]

I am sad Holdovers did not get into Ensemble

[@eddistasio644]

poor things out means oppenheimer is likely the best picture winner

[@andyanderson3628]

I still have hope that Sandra Huller gets nominated for the Oscar. Her performance blew me away. But it is hard for a foreign actress to get in.

[@kevinanderson1196]

Only came here to see the Charles Melton snub reaction. Love it!!

[@TheHannahcast]

I so knew SAG would do Nyad. Benning and Foster are never getting the Oscar, but I knew SAG would love Nyad. I got 5/5 for Lead Actress. Also, I'm tucking in Color Purple. If SAG REALLY loved it, Fantasia would have been nominated. As is, it's just going to be Babylon, House of Gucci, and Bombshell all over again.

[@oscarshmuck5416]

Foster is a lock.

[@RobertBurns71405]

Foster is near locked for the Oscar, Benning I agree on though

[@alexwest5258]

What are you talking about? Annette and Jodie made great performances in Nyad, they deserve it, if they get the Oscar nomination, it’s gonna well deserved

[@FalSetiawan]

Greta lee being out is so fucked up.

[@joeyhollywoo]

Such an amazing year for movies and SAG gives Nyad TWO noms?!? Oof 🙄

[@markburns1990]

Out of hundred movies released… I’m sure another picture could’ve gotten a nomination for “Stunts” over Barbie

[@Lanosrep]

There were 99 stunt crew members on Barbie. It's a good thing if the stunts are invisible, it means that they were integrated seamlessly into the film. Good nom

[@markburns1990]

@@Lanosrep It’s called share-the-love. One movie doesn’t have to get everything! It’s a wasted nomination.

[@marcochen9117]

@@Lanosrep so mitchell please enlighten us as to what stunts that were in barbie were sooo good? Liked the movie, but getting a stunt nomination over a good amount of films seems outrageous.

[@chrisf5828]

The nominations are made by a committee of actual SAG stunt performers and coordinators, not the general membership. You need to get out to LA ASAP to explain their jobs to them.

[@yeahiagree1070]

@@Lanosrep was the "invisible stunt" in barbie that really seamless and not-at-all tacky car advert in the middle of the film?

[@DarrenGD]

It will be a miracle to get Rachel McAdams in now 😢

[@HaydenReviews5]

It's still possible. I hope she gets in too

[@DarrenGD]

@@HaydenReviews5 🙏🙏🙏

[@kellifranklin9872]

Possibly a BAFTA nomination, but I don’t think an Oscar nom for her.

[@HaydenReviews5]

@@kellifranklin9872 Not a BAFTA. The BAFTA's released their long list for the awards and she didn't make it.

[@kellifranklin9872]

@@HaydenReviews5 Thanks for letting me know. I haven’t seen that list yet. I appreciate it!

[@seankoontz4235]

Supporting actress is fun to predict. Randolph, Blunt, and Brooks are the three locks and then the other two slots could be anything

[@ejm6460]

I still want Moore to make it in

[@seankoontz4235]

@ejm6460 Actually think Cruz will probably get in (showy performance + got the SAG). So that leaves the fifth slot. Moore is 50/50 but I can see the Academy wanting to nominate her again. If Foster misses the BAFTA, then I think she’s J. Lo in Hustlers

[@7exAnimo]

Please someone explain to me 1. How is Lily Gladstone a lead? 2. Why is she a favourite to win at the Oscars when she had like 5 lines and a really forgettable performance overall

[@viantzpradz4771]

Ten years ago in 2014, Leo nominated for Golden Globes, but not nominated for SAG, and then he got nomination at the Oscars, and i think history repeat itself in 2024...!!!Don't worry Leo still got in this year for sure...!!!

[@seankoontz4235]

He will get BAFTA for sure. They love him

[@poitier32]

@@seankoontz4235well aren’t you shocked 😭

[@angelsilva7207]

Teo Yoo not being nominated for anything is some bullshit

[@singstreetcar5881]

All of us strangers The iron claw Both films snubbed

[@jacktilley7299]

Huller not getting nominated is embarrassing

[@_joshstanford]

sag had me rooting for them all year just to do this. smh

[@abhiezibran9654]

Probably the worst from SAG in years

[@TheFilmAutopsy]

I do wonder which actors will surprise at the Academy Awards. I feel safe predicting Cruz now since she has proven an Academy darling getting in with Parallel Mothers recently

[@pb.j.1753]

She got in with Parallel Mothers without any precursor nominations. Now she has SAG for Ferrari so it would not be a surprise at the Oscars anymore. Maybe Aunjanue Ellis in Origin becomes the surprise this season.

[@seankoontz4235]

@pb.j.1753 It’s too late, they’re releasing Origin January 19

[@pb.j.1753]

@@seankoontz4235it had a qualifying release in December so it was eligible.

[@HunterHuiet]

Here are my initial thoughts on the nominations. Charles Melton missing in Best Supporting Actor was not a surprise to me because I had feeling that it was a good chance of that happening. Sterling K Brown being in the Best Supporting Actor category at SAG was a delightful surprise. As far as Leo not being nominated for Best Actor, I have mixed feelings about this. The reason why I had mixed feelings about this was due to the fact that I did not rule out the possibility of them deciding to go with either Colman Domingo or Barry Keoghan over Leo. Was it a bad call, yes. Was I surprised about this decision, not really. The biggest shocker besides Sterling K Brown getting in for Best Supporting Actor was Poor Things not being nominated for SAG Ensemble.

[@jonathanvelazquezph.d.2719]

I never had Poor Things in Ensemble, but I was expecting Air just because of how much they love Viola Davis

[@poett8875]

Poor things hasn’t gotten anything for ensemble tho. Missed CC, and didn’t even make the BAFTA longlist for casting.

[@HunterHuiet]

@@poett8875 Then do you think it still gets in for Best Picture at the Oscars?

[@Sad__House]

​@@HunterHuiet Of course

[@LeHuy-hs2db]

No Sandra Huller is so sad

[@geobrad7]

You have a recurring editing issue in your videos where you cut off the bottom of your graphics, often leaving off an entire line of text.

[@evah1928]

Love your sweater Brother Bro

[@da96103]

I am waiting for the 2024 Andrea Riseborough.

[@evantheawesome1]

I feel like it seems pretty clear that Leo is missing noms because he has made it abundantly clear he has zero interest in the awards this season. The extent of his campaigning this year has been exclusively supporting Lily. Same with Marty.

[@ht6743]

They really snubbed Ruffalo!🤯Feels like Hirsch over Dano, Hinds over Dornan, and Dench over Balfe. A slay for Dafoe though.

[@rachelwolfe7370]

I’m sad about Sandra and Charles!! Your cat is like see you guys lol

[@aameyadevansh4246]

5:25 lmao they did it wrong after trying thrice😭

[@Coco81218]

I have a feeling Cailee Spaeny and Dominic Sessa will get surprise Oscar nominations.

[@ladym2864]

YES YES - American Fiction. The best film of the year!!!

[@jramz5176]

Melton is dead in the water for Oscar now, I still think Ruffalo will get in and maybe with Dafoe

[@paulluk7515]

Not really, the voters may make amends after finding out this ridiculous list

[@singstreetcar5881]

Nah, he is still getting in.

[@tonihagan6330]

You can read about what stands out in the actor nominees written in NYTimes magazine. Example: Best Theft of a Movie: Ryan Gosling, “Barbie” For an audience to leave a movie theater convinced that one actor has pocketed the film implies that something went wrong, that a movie that wasn’t about that character became about the actor playing that character. Famously: Anthony Hopkins and his almost 25 minutes of screen time in “The Silence of the Lambs.” And now: Gosling - controversially, for stealing candy from a Barbie. He goes so hard at the joke that Ken is supposed to be telling on men: Strength is weakness, coolness is lame, knowledge is ignorance, twinkle is shadow. You watch Gosling’s face for some sign of a wink, but he is committed. He could have played Ken as an idiot. But the comedy of the performance, the danger of the part and perhaps the point of the movie is that the actor playing this narcissist has installed in him a soul. Read the full story here, which includes nearly two dozen awards, as well as video clips that can elucidate the picks, even if you haven’t seen the movies.

[@MrStGeorgeIllawarra]

I'm fine with Leo being out and De Niro in. De Niro gives one of his best performances in ages. Leo was mid at best.

[@moviemaniac14]

Top 5 Films that should've been nominated by SAG but were not: 1. Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret 2. The Iron Claw 3. Saltburn 4. May December 5. Past Lives

[@cssomeone]

0. The Anatomy of a Fall

[@Missjunebugfreak]

All of Us Strangers,Anatomy of a Fall, The Zone of Interest and Past Lives all being snubbed just doesn't sit right with me.

[@davidv8564]

Then become an actor, get into SAG so that you can vote.

[@izach28]

@@davidv8564 daddy chill

[@nxssa7272]

cant believe the golden globes had better nominations than sag

[@anettep6678]

Past Lives robbed here

[@Bluebox87]

LOL at Nyad getting nominated for those horrible performances. That's hilarious,

[@itsybitsy999]

I thought Foster was great in it. Bening... not so much.

[@chrisf5828]

I was surprised by Barbie for stunt ensemble but I understand that there is a panel of stunt people who make the SAG stunt nominations and they probably know a lot more about the Barbie production than I do. It is like Oscar shortlists. The actual professional vfx people probably liked Oppenheimer as a movie. They left it off the list because it has less challenging fx (practical and digital) than many perfume ads. Meanwhile, Spiderverse made the shortlist. I do not understand exactly what vfx means in the context of an animated movie but they do know. I can disagree with their choices and often do, even strongly, but I cannot sensibly act like the problem is that these idiots simply dont know anything about vfx. They are vfx professionals. And if a panel of stunt people picked Barbie they had reasons beyond liking the movie. They are not looking to disresoect or anger their fellow 7,700 SAG stunt people.

[@ejm6460]

I'm so happy about Colman Domingo in "Rustin"! An extraordinary performance!

[@antoniodjordjevic9493]

Cruz could really be like Bates for Richard Jewell, only one got SAG one Globes, but both are veteran actresses playing baity real life figure with tone of Oscar clips, in a no one cares film directed by a beloved director for old voters.

[@itsybitsy999]

That's a really good comparison, certainly something to think about.

[@makotocarolin]

First tuck-in of the season let's gooooooo

[@davidmckesey7119]

Annette Benning in nyad was God awful. Turned it off after 20 minutes

[@mxaxr_]

I can never take this award show srsly. Always go the WORST choices!!!!

[@kleins-v7v]

I respect them for going the anti-woke route and leaving out Charles Melton but they’re STILL doing the Gladstone stuff and for what????

[@blackguyofthesouth2161]

Not even close

[@jonathanvelazquezph.d.2719]

Charles Melton is looking very weak after missing here and at BAFTA.

[@goofrider]

Every award voting body has different sensibilities, otherwise they'd all have the same noms and it'd be pretty boring. SAG tends to want to elevate underdogs or reward veteran actors who don't often get acknowledged. It's not a critics body, it has 160k+ actors and most of them have normie tastes. They aren't cinephiles.

[@ali3n.sup3rstar]

@@kleins-v7vwhat

[@nicoleann0703]

I loved their reactions here and of course the return of Brother Bro's awesome sweater.

[@antoniodjordjevic9493]

May December is really on a shaky ground. No Bafta and no SAG is concerning cause those two unlike BFCA and Globes are industry votes, much of who also vote at the Oscars. Melton miss in not that surprising and im not sure he will make it at the Oscars cause his performance becomes impressive only if you watch the whole film, and i can see many voters just turning it off after 20 minutes. PLus he is an unknown and Todd Haynes films, the ones that were more Oscar friendly (Far from heaven and Carol) also underperformed. May December also offers a trio of very unlikable or annoying characters plus add the fact that the story is based on a very controversial topic, that all will turn off a lot of voters. I personally really wish they get nominated, especially Moore who gives a much more complex performance than half of the actual supporting actress contenders.

[@markburns1990]

Honestly… who’s Charles Milton? 🤷🏿‍♂️ (yeah… I’ll google, eventually)

[@itsybitsy999]

I switched out Mulligan for Barrino yesterday. I can't believe Ruffalo didn't get in, that's crazy. I still think both he and Dafoe are in for the Oscars, Banshees and Billboards-style.

[@GareBare90]

Cat and choices...

[@MrStruggle]

These were worse than the Golden Globes lol no Melton, Ruffalo, Huller or Lee. It makes me sad we might miss out on a Melton nomination considering he gave the best performance of the year imo

[@RB-.-]

Melton didn’t deserve it. Wasn’t even better than Julianne Moore. RDJ put him to shame.

[@jonathanvelazquezph.d.2719]

Melton is looking very weak after missing here and at BAFTA

[@eddistasio644]

melton woud not beat rdj anyways

[@paulluk7515]

​@@RB-.-Didn't deserve it? R U freaking kidding? He's won a handful and nominated in almost every critics awards!

[@RB-.-]

@@paulluk7515 Gosling & De Niro better

[@Tomy_Yon]

I'll have to re-watch this, first for watching the kitty and then for the actual content. 😊

[@jonathanvelazquezph.d.2719]

😿

[@baraka92]

The cat was like “No Melton? Bye!”

[@jonathanvelazquezph.d.2719]

😿

[@hellodomo]

I purposely didn't seek out the noms in order to enjoy this wild ride with you both! What a hoot!

[@ali3n.sup3rstar]

Goodbye Saltburn & May December?

[@debbiemcnamara7059]

Actors pick who is nominated for the Sag awards.

[@zeyneperatalar9216]

Poor Things supportive actors dilemma is Belfast mood! Defoe is gonna get the Oscars I feel like last two years show the proof of it

[@mengzhang435]

Where is Sandra huller？

[@antoniodjordjevic9493]

Since SAG AFTRA merge not a single foreign performance was nominated in leading categories till this date. No matter how much buzz and Critic wins they had.

[@luisdav2697]

4:27 It seems that the NYAD logo brought bad luck

[@viantzpradz4771]

We all really want Glenn Howerton get Oscars Nomination in Blackberry for Best Supporting Actor...!!! He gave wonderful performance...!!!

[@AllGreyEverything]

I thought Ruffalo was a miscast. It felt like they were casting the Mark Ruffalo of ~20 years ago based on the script (who calls a man of that age and his rugged looks "a pretty idiot"?) and his accent work, even in a movie full of iffy accents, was incredibly distracting to me. Dafoe or even Youseff would be on my ballot before him.

[@soil80]

Saltburn is such a lazy movie. Glad it didn't get anything.

[@RB-.-]

2nd best movie of the year

[@callum8147]

This is a classic case of the alphabet advantage we see at the Emmys where names higher up in the alphabet benefit from the voting system of just checking off 5 names with no ranking. American Fiction, The Color Purple, Bening, Brown, Dafoe and Cruz get in while people like Ruffalo and Melton miss.

[@lunabirdlove]

Annette Bening has made an enemy out of me. The first tuck in of the season haha seeya Air!

[@davidv8564]

Why? What did she do to you?

[@waynedexter]

I think the subject matter is really hurting “May December”, sadly

[@ScientistsReadingWorld]

I was waiting for this for SOOO LONGG!!

[@NathanielAhart]

To answer your question, no!

[@tml184]

Shouldn't the channel be called Oscar Experts. There are 2 guys here.

[@KevinZeph]

congrats on crossing 50k!

[@therev435]

unsubscribed

[@robfuzz]

Can anyone explain the difference between SAG voting and Oscar voting? Do only actors vote for actor with Oscar? If that's the case and all actors are SAG members wouldn't the SAG winners completely mirror the Oscars?

[@Awardshq]

The fact that Cooper is in and Scott is just fucking disgusting

[@Missjunebugfreak]

In a perfect world Andrew Scott would be getting awards nominations instead of Cooper. I hate that he's being ignored by SAG.

[@sexydirrtymoney]

Barbie in stunt category???....you gotta be fcuking kidding me! 👀🙄

[@chrisf5828]

That nomination decision was made entirely by stunt personnel. They may know more about it.

[@megancarroll]

@@chrisf5828exactly!!

[@Mike-s6s9t]

I know NYAD is a bit cringe, but the acting is genuinely good - they are fair nominations.

[@carlosatausupa8429]

JOHN WICK CHAPTER 4 *JOHN: YEAH*

[@98LucasFG]

Imagine American Fiction wins sag ensemble and then upsets at the Oscar just like CODA… I would hate that

[@coffeysr72]

"America Ferrera is dead" what? She has just as many precursor nods as her competition (Pike, Cruz); only Moore has more nods, and her movie isn't looking at double-digits nods on Oscar norming like Babrie is.

[@kellifranklin9872]

Are y’all going to do a video when the BAFTA noms are revealed? Please do!

[@jesusangelespinosasalgado9430]

0:47 😂😂 GLORIOUS!!! Btw... Weren't the DGAs noms today? There's nothing

[@goofrider]

It's out now

[@haniigg]

Not realy surprised about Charles Melton not getting in Hollywood hates young male actors lol