#21: Jay Debunks Dr Ally on the purity & efficacy of ZamZam water!

Last month I uploaded a video on Pfanderfilms about the ZamZam well, since I’ve been zeroing in on Mecca.
Since then many of you have sent me a video recording done by Dr. Shabbir Ally and and his daughter Dr Safiyyah Ally, concerning the great efficacy of the ZamZam water.
Dr. Ally suggested that the water for the well came from surrounding mountains, as well as from rainwater, and that it was this water which fed that 2 million people living in Mecca, as well as the 2 to 3 million pilgrims who came to Mecca every year, coupled with the millions of bottles of water from the ZamZam well which was transported around the Muslim world and sold in their shops, found in almost every Muslim city.
And who provided this water? According to Dr. Ally it was Allah himself. Since it was he who provided the original water in the ZamZam well when he miraculously created it for Hagar and Ishmael, it is still he who also continues to provide the water for the whole Muslim world, so that it will never run out.
What’s more, this water is pure, it’s holy, and it harms no one. In fact, Dr. Ally continued to suggest that if used with prayer it can also heal people, providing that we know that Allah himself is the one who provides the actual cure.
Jay debunkes much of what Dr. Ally is saying in his video by first of all showing a graph put out by the Ministry of environment, water, and agriculture in Saudi Arabia in 2020, which showed that the sources of water for the major cities in Saudi Arabia came from desalinated plants, 27 of them, situated on the shores of the Red Sea in the West, and the Persian Gulf in the East.
The city of Riyadh received 64% of its water from desalination plants. Medina was dependent on 95% of its water from desalination plants, while Mecca was dependent on whopping 98% of its water from desalination plants situated in Jeddah, on the Red Sea; completely debunking what Dr. Shabbir and Dr. Safiyyah were saying in their video.
As to whether the ZamZam water was harmful, Jay pointed to a number of old newspaper articles from the 1800s and the early 1900s which showed just how dangerous the water from the ZamZam well really was:
1881: The Standard Newspaper ran a story on November 18 mentions that 300 people died from cholera which came from the ZamZam well, and the rest of the pilgrims were quarantined. It became so bad that Turkish officials, when inspecting the ZamZam well, noticed it was full of sewage which had filtered into the well from the surrounding city contaminating it and causing a cholera epidemic. The officials suggested giving those who were affected mint lime juice and coffee. If that didn’t work and they began to vomit, they were then left to die.
1901: According to the Chicago Tribune, April 14, the ZamZam well was referred to as the "water of death". Sewage from Mecca was filtering into the well, and pilgrims were filling their bottles with the water, some of which had excrement in it, which caused bubonic plague to break out.
1902: The Birmingham Evening Dispatch on March 7 mentioned that because of the water from the ZamZam well a Cholera epidemic broke out, and 110 people died.
1912: The Chicago Tribune on December 27 mentioned that a Cholera epidemic broke out in Mecca, due to the ZamZam well, and 1,714 people died.
1914: The Calumet News on January 7 mentioned that 44,671 people had to be quarantined because of another Cholera epidemic because by the dirty water from the ZamZam well.
1915: The Star Press on February 7 mentioned that Mecca seems to be an eternal and permanent abiding place of Cholera, due to the dirty water.
1920: The Brooklyn Citizen on February 2 mentioned that another Cholera epidemic occurred due to the brackish water of the ZamZam well.
1930: Finally, according to the Brooklyn Daily Eagle, the city of Mecca, which was notorious for its pilgrimage epidemics, had its first year where there was no Cholera or Bubonic Plague cases. And the reason? According to the Brooklyn Daily Eagle, this was because of new hospitals, dispensaries, and Western medicine, as well as new desalination plants which had just been built in 1926.
So the purity of the water, and its cleanliness, had little to do with the god of Islam, Allah; it had everything to do with Western medicine, and Western desalination plants.
Shouldn't someone maybe tell Dr Ally and his daughter this?
© Pfander Centre for Apologetics - US, April 5, 2023
(71,160)

[@Martin-lv1xw]

I feel like Shabir Alli was hired to destroy Islam from the inside🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@ilonkastille2993]

Islam is built on propaganda . Shabir is just doing what all of them have to do , if not it would never have survived. Now, it may be that many people don’t accept the story like before.

[@user-ye5fx3ep1l]

Go back and watch, he is laughing at the viewers. 😂😂😂 Come back Home , Folks, to our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ of Nazareth!!! Amen 🙏🏾

[@pr7049]

The Read Sea desalinated water miracle😌😌😌

[@karenthompson1337]

I was looking forward to this!! Excellent Dr. Jay.

[@ishtarlew598]

Zamzam water, from the Red Sea. 😂

[@aaabrams1889]

MUST I SHOW YOU PROOF... That the Zam-zam well is 20 feet from the Kaaba?

[@ishtarlew598]

@@aaabrams1889 you are very funny. It is impossible for the little well to supply millions of litres of water and there are massive pipes taking water into the ZumZum well and back out again. The vast majority of the water they sell started in the Red sea and into a desalination plant.

[@ishtarlew598]

@@aaabrams1889 also very funny is how Hagar was running between mountain that are more like little hills of rock to find water, when it was only a couple of metres from the Kaaba where Abraham threw her out from.

[@aaabrams1889]

@@ishtarlew598 YOU SEE HOW STUPID YOU ARE to believe a LIAR like Jay....Abraham DID NOT throw Hagar out while living in Mecca next to the Kaaba AS JAY THE LIAR told you...😅🤣😂 THERE WAS NO MECCA YET!!!😀 Hagar and Ismael was commanded by Abraham TOLD BY GOD to let them go into the wilderness....and they wondered there till their provision was finished - them Hagar ran between the 2 hills, Safa and Marwa to look for passing caravans for help while Ismael was under a bush - then the angel came and gave them the Zam-zam well. A passing caravan from Yemen (Jurhum Arabs) came to ask for water in exchange for provision. Some stayed and gave protection to Hagar and later Ishmael, married a Jurhumite woman, Rala bint Mudad ibn 'Amr ibn Jurhum ibn Himyar ibn Qahtan. Abraham returned when Ismael was already married and then only built the Kaaba on the foundations of Adam.

[@billshepherd5090]

Yeah moslems never think anything through

[@charlieseisun5667]

I feel sorry for Shabir's daughter. So innocently gullible of her father's misinformation.

[@-BigIi-]

Me too. I feel sorry for those like her; but I suspect many of these guys have thought about the claims of Islam and see problems with it. But what can she do, without it being life-threatening, her dad is the well-known Shabir Ally after all.

[@defenderoftruth3212]

@@-BigIi- .... Zam Zam is pure and holy. The German doctor and the Japanese doctor have already made a study of the Zam Zam water. The German doctor compared it with the German water, and found out that it contains enormous energetic field that the German water. Then he mixed a droplet of the Zam Zam water to a container of the German water, its energetic field becomes equal to that of the Zam Zam water. Two doctors had already that the Zam Zam water is pure. Jay Smith is only manifesting his jealousy. -10-29-23

[@ScammedbyFolrentinaConchas]

150,00 litres a day normally .400,000 litres a day is delivered by truck to the prophet's mosque during religious times.

[@bobfisher1909]

They are building big storage water facility above Mecca so it can be delivered with gravity pressure.

[@MAX-tw3qz]

These religious Flintstone folk should call it Bam Bam water.

[@InNazareth]

Dr J. Smith you are a living legend. Your name has been written in history with golden words and your work will be benefited by the generations to come.

[@aaabrams1889]

JAY THE LIAR - jealousy makes you nasty.. Lets go with your story that Mecca had NO WATER and the 30 feet Zam-Zam well was only mentioned in the 9th century (according to you😆) •Where there is a desert, there’s no water •Where there is no water, there’s no food •Where there is no food, there’s no people •Where there are no people, there’s no towns •Where there are no towns, there’s no cities •Where there are no cities, there’s no civilization •Where there is no civilization, there’s no history! SO TELL US - Mr Idiot, face-fuchsia-tongue-out WHERE DID ALL THE WATER ALL OF A SUDDEN CAME FROM IN THE 9TH CENTURY? And the food🍇🍞🍔 and the people 👨‍👨‍👧‍👧👩‍👩‍👦and the towns 🕋and the cities🕌🕍🏙 and the history🕰? IT ALL POPPED-UP - Must be another Miracle!!!😅🤣😂

[@muhitspeaks7846]

All his video is fake

[@InNazareth]

@@muhitspeaks7846 it does mean that if you expose lies of a book you are fake instead that book which is being exposed is fake.

[@defenderoftruth3212]

@@InNazareth ... Zam Zam is pure and holy. The German doctor and the Japanese doctor have already made a study of the Zam Zam water. The German doctor compared it with the German water, and found out that it contains enormous energetic field that the German water. Then he mixed a droplet of the Zam Zam water to a container of the German water, its energetic field becomes equal to that of the Zam Zam water. Two doctors had already that the Zam Zam water is pure. Jay Smith is only manifesting his jealousy. -10-29-23

[@joannedovey9710]

Amen🙏 to our Living Water

[@amirhidic165]

Islam is the fastest growing religion in the world by converts especially Christians

[@JesusSaves4Life]

What did Jesus say about the living water? Later in John 7: 37-39 Jesus once again speaks of living water, saying, “'Let anyone who is thirsty come to me and drink. Whoever believes in me, as Scripture has said, rivers of living water will flow from within them.' By this he meant the Spirit, whom those who believed in him were later to receive.

[@amirhidic165]

@jesussaves4147 so how you know what he ment he could of said spirit and not water why do you Christians put words in Jesus mouth and don't follow what he actually said like for example he said I go to my father and your father my god and yoir god ?? So je had a god also he got circumcised on 8th day of his birth and you Christians don't he said don't eat pork and you eat pork he said I my self can't do nothing without my father permission and Jesus didn't know the hour and you say he's God???

[@defenderoftruth3212]

Is there dying water?

[@valkyrie3493]

​@@defenderoftruth3212yes. It's called the zamzam water.

[@haryo7988]

Thank God, finally there were western who cleansed the zamzam dirty reputation, with no intervention from their allah.

[@alonzoharris9049]

There is no western theology. All technology is stolen from other ethnicities and countries. They fly in the best scientists from the Middle East. 🤣

[@snoraida29]

OMG. Thank you for sharing this. My worldview of my cultural heritage have totally shifted .

[@sattaurnikki]

Please don't use those three letters! It is disrespect to God! 😮😢

[@Eesa_is_the_Messenger_of_Allah]

It really only takes a quick Google search to debunk what this pro comedian is saying.

[@dqschannel]

Great video as always.

[@MO51MARRIED6yrAISHA]

This video should go viral in social media ❤✌️!

[@ravinderchahal2391]

Amen brother. ❤👍♥

[@alonzoharris9049]

The trinity beings three gods goes viral.

[@garybowings1538]

​@@alonzoharris9049Alonzo Harris worships Muhammed (PBRB).

[@ravinderchahal2391]

@@alonzoharris9049 Allah the three gods is viral.

[@louisecordier9428]

@@alonzoharris9049 without lies, Islam dies.

[@KenadoCC]

America provides Zam-Zam with long pipes from big plant.

[@R-rr1]

😂😂😂

[@alonzoharris9049]

America is a land of theft. All technology is stolen from outside the country. All scientists are foreign. They invade countries and steal their resources and knowledge. Let’s not forget that the technology in America stated with The nazis that we’re getting shelter in the new land America.🤣

[@Buymeacoffee294]

Zamzam water gives you a zumzum brain

[@R-rr1]

😂😂bro

[@aaabrams1889]

ZAMZAM WATER BRINGS DEAD FISH BACK TO LIFE kzbin.info/www/bejne/eqeye5ePgJl-kJY

[@charleswillie7036]

Agree till now Muslim's still believes the miracle of zam zam water.😂

[@aaabrams1889]

@@charleswillie7036 We do...YOU GOT NOTHING and NOTHING to show... Where is the miracle pool at Bethesda?

[@dudeduderinoduderino9689]

I laughed when you showed us where the zam zam well water comes from and yet they still believe it is holy and from allah...Thank you Dr Jay Smith for your video's...Great work keep it up.

[@aaabrams1889]

So how did the Zam-zam originates?

[@thearmouredsaint164]

@@aaabrams1889 the argument is not that the zam zam well didnt exist. what doctor jay smith has proven with facts and evidence is that the zam zam well can not sustain the arabian populace with "pure" drinking water, thats why the saudi crown has hired the bechtel corporation to build aguafires and desalination plants to fill the needs of the populace with clean and drinkable water.. muslims have been lied to for 1300 years about the islamic narrative of the foundations of islam😩there is zero historical evidence that muhamad was ever in mecca or medinah, as dan gibson has shown with plenty of evidence to prove his point.. without lies islam dies🥵

[@bongy1974]

@@aaabrams1889 Like most wells do, but it's irrelavant, one well can't support a city. Try and use your brain

[@carolusmalleus1243]

@@aaabrams1889 What lies?, the well that God opened up for Hagar was nowhere near Mecca but well within the boundaries of the land of Canaan, the idea of Abraham coming all the way down to present-day Mecca is fictitious and exaggerated. Quranic history and geography are all man-made, faulty and defies all logic and common sense!!!

[@blakebronte1544]

@@bongy1974 ….Okay, bright spark!

[@sheikhboyardee556]

Sorry to hear this as I was planning to visit the graves of Adam & Eve.

[@guizehshalom.stephen6844]

God bless you Dr Jay Smith. I thank God for His grace over your life.

[@miltonbradley4249]

I wonder what the total number of deaths would for the 50 years the News carried theses stories Thanks again Jay for excellent content and GOD BLESS YOU, YOUR FAMILY and Team

[@Eesa_is_the_Messenger_of_Allah]

Poor misguided thing. Did you know the third cholera pandemic was brought to Mecca by Muslim pilgrims from India? Did you also know that cholera was already a worldwide outbreak in Europe, Africa and Asia way before deaths from cholera were being reported in Mecca? Also, multiple other Zamzam samples were tested to verify the 1881 sample test by Edward Frankland and no cholera was found. If Zamzam was really impure and infested with cholera then Mecca would’ve consistently seen yearly outbreaks of cholera every hajj season ever since the time of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, plus by the locals drinking from the well, but obviously that was never seen. Even in this video, Jay Smith had to skip decades in between to find any reports of cholera outbreaks from Mecca which shows it wasn’t yearly. You’ve been duped by Jay Smith.

[@AustralianChristianFascists]

Cholera comes from water. The reason there are no earlier newspaper articles is because of the lack of technological communication was well as the lack of modern medicine to diagnose cholera.

[@AustralianChristianFascists]

The locals drank the the water from the aqueduct.

[@mattkdk3097]

BBC report also said that Zam Zam water is very dirty, after tested some of Zam Zam water in Lab

[@R-rr1]

😂

[@tommynoblethecouncilofheav4657]

Not ZamZam water , Con-Con water

[@ghsense2626]

It's Holy water, you can buy some in many shops.

[@tommynoblethecouncilofheav4657]

@@ghsense2626 🤣right next to the 🐪P no doubt

[@ghsense2626]

@@tommynoblethecouncilofheav4657 You have not drunk the water, how can you make a comment? You will feel the energy once you taste zam zam water. Very different from your fluoride water you consume

[@tommynoblethecouncilofheav4657]

@@ghsense2626 from sea water 🤣🤣🤣🤣🙊🙉🙈🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@karenthompson1337]

@@ghsense2626 A sweetner is added to the water.

[@coolbuddydude1]

If zamzam water was unlimited, they wouldn’t need a pump. It would be jetting out of the ground like in the Hagar story.

[@aaabrams1889]

That why Hagar said ''Zam-zam''.

[@coolbuddydude1]

@@aaabrams1889 Yes I know. That's funny about it. The water level dropped. Therefore it is not unlimited.

[@aaabrams1889]

@@coolbuddydude1 The water level became LEVEL, that's why it did not overflow and caused a river...

[@coolbuddydude1]

@@aaabrams1889 LEVEL? you mean buried deep in ground. That's why they need bring in desalinated sea water. It's a ridiculous story.

[@DanielApologetics]

Great video

[@hamsterbox4732]

Ally just sounds like parents well knowing, but not admitting, that there is no Santa Clause, but still keeping the kids believe in Santa. YOU SHOULD NOT TREAT ADULTS LIKE THAT, IT WILL BACKFIRE. Thanks Dr Ally for making more Muslim run away from Islam.

[@craigmatchett6953]

They must put the dead fly into the water (the same fly that has the disease) 😂

[@R-rr1]

😂😂

[@chinedurommy4281]

True to purify the water

[@jasonsimms4238]

Remember, you have to dunk both wings into the water.

[@seanmacsweeney2985]

The only historical building found in Mecca while building foundations for new buildings was a ottoman fort from maybe 13-14th century

[@aaabrams1889]

You forgot that there's a Station of Abraham when he built the Kaaba.

[@springheeledjack9652]

So the zumzum is a sewer?

[@AustralianChristianFascists]

pretty much!

[@ravindramorey5433]

Cholera was rampant in most of the pilgrimage sites in indian subcontinent and in Mecca also and old medical books have mentionned though in today's modern book the infectious disease like cholera are not described in details. But occasional outbreak of cholera epidemic in Mecca are mentioned in medical literature.

[@aaabrams1889]

Cholera was rampant in Europe and America as well - the source of the cholera in Mecca was Indian pilgrims who brought it there.

[@alexanderthegreatoz5945]

​@@aaabrams1889Muslims from India, not Indian pilgrims.

[@Eesa_is_the_Messenger_of_Allah]

@@alexanderthegreatoz5945​⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠ Same difference. Jay Smith wants us to believe Zamzam was causing cholera when cholera was already present as a global epidemic at the time, sweeping cities all across Europe, Africa and Asia. As for the 1881 sample by Edward Frankland, it’s been disproven by multiple other independently tested samples by Ottoman chemists which showed no cholera in Zamzam. I feel so bad for the people who are falling for this comedian Jay Smith. 😂

[@mithunkhare6133]

​@@aaabrams1889share proof??

[@aleksakovacevic3350]

⁠@@Eesa_is_the_Messenger_of_Allahyes because I’m sure ottoman chemists are completely truthful with in how they checked show me an outside source

[@karenthompson1337]

Hmm. Sounds like they forgot to dip the fly’s ‘other’ wing into the earlier well.

[@kaysadek5012]

Thank you Dr Jay so much for this important and valuable information about zamzam water I was a Muslim for over 25 years and I never knew that we always thought that zamzam is very pure, holly and healthy from the beginning until now. U R great Dr Jay thanks again 👍

[@defenderoftruth3212]

It is pure and holy. The German doctor and the Japanese doctor have already made a study of the Zam Zam water. The German doctor compared it with the German water, and found out that it contains enormous energetic field that the German water. Then he mixed a droplet of the Zam Zam water to a container of the German water, its energetic field becomes equal to that of the Zam Zam water. Two doctors had already that the Zam Zam water is pure. Jay Smith is only manifesting his jealousy. -10-17-23

[@user-cn6df3vh6d]

Dr jay hasn’t done enough research of his own testing the zam zam water is very pure he takes his knowledge from news papers has he even tested the water ?? Dnt be fooled by him & loosing ur faith in Allah

[@dewibulananakdewa]

This is a very interesting finding on zamzam well. Can we get the pdf copy in the class? Lin Si

[@truthforalltube]

Wonderful!

[@joejoe9979]

Absolutely correct 💯, a lier main focus is to lie everything until you deeply believed. Belived them in blind. Thanks DR jay

[@jaswantsingh9287]

Thank you Thank you.

[@C-Note_Staxs]

They lie which tells you they know there cult is a lie smh 🤦🏾

[@user-ri8hd4bo8k]

Could you provide links or source to all the news articles mentioned in the video above ? Thank you .

[@b34t7355]

Love your work Jay. It’s a lot to take in and retain. As Allah calls himself the greatest of deceivers, his adherents are not far behind him. GOD bless

[@chrishoff402]

If drinking ZamZam water was harmful, Bectel would get sued into the ground.

[@sheikhboyardee556]

No, desalinated water is pure at the source. As it flows down the pipes to the well & in the well it becomes tainted. I discovered this when I lived in South America with leaky & broken pipes. It purified at the plant but picks up impurities as it flows.

[@ahler3973]

Gbu Dr

[@drittenberry1]

Thank you Dr Jay

[@Aaron_S]

What a miracle!

[@malvernh2060]

Has anybody taken an official bottle of the ZamZam water and sent it for chemical analysis. I think this might provide evidence to debunk this obvious nonsense. Perhaps, Dr Jay, you could organize this?

[@taecart8083]

It is now desalinated. Where is your brain.

[@joseywales3789]

​@@taecart8083 , where's your brain? How do you remove the salt out of red sea water? reverse osmosis! This has the effect of removing every microscopic particle down to the micron level. Therefore the natural minerals found in natural springs are not going to be present in the zum-zum water. There's going to be a huge difference between the two waters.... One will be obviously from a desalination plant that has been through the reverse osmosis system and a real spring water will be full of minerals... Purely Natural!

[@malvernh2060]

@@taecart8083 Try to keep it adult and not use insulting terms... it doesn't progress any argument you think you have. We all know that it's desalinated, but it is speculated that there are taste and other additives; these could be analysed, indicating origins of those chemicals and processes that could provide further evidence for it's "unholy" storage tank origin, rather than a Muslim stated underwater aquifer.

[@taecart8083]

@@malvernh2060 how do you keep the discussion sane when people are brainwashed

[@malvernh2060]

@@taecart8083 We can't stop people from being illogical or incoherent, especially in KZbin comments. All we can be responsible for is our own behaviour, which hopefully is level-headed, factual and doesn't respond to provocation. If a reasonable message doesn't get across, that can't be our fault. Ultimately there is no point in flogging a dead horse; that's a waste of our lives. Just don't get drawn into those promoting negativity, because that's just what they want for attention.

[@truthseeker7951]

We should call it zHARM-zHARM water 🙃

[@jeromemausling6324]

Yet another top class dismantling of the standard Islamic narrative Jay.

[@dhardhirdruha6916]

Thank you for exposing pislam 🙏

[@sheikhboyardee556]

Plagiarislam. New name for Islam.

[@indicmelodies11]

Could I get the link to these articles?

[@stevemartin6267]

...and no one has ever been recorded as having become unwell from Lourdes water. But, that is miraculous.

[@b.kodzoofori1491]

If you have facts, you DON"T have to BELIEVE! Thanks Dr.Jay!!!!!

[@defenderoftruth3212]

If you want facts, ask the German doctor and the Japanese doctor who studied the Zam Zam water. Jay Smith don't know the Zam Zam water. -10-27-23

[@Kumarapwmss1989]

​@@defenderoftruth3212 like pagan allah🐷

[@mannyhabib2867]

Alhamdulillah Jay, thank you for the information-Jazakallah!

[@aaabrams1889]

Jay is taking you idiots for fools😅🤣😂 Tell him to show the evidence that the Zam-zam water was the root course of Cholera.

[@TingTong2568]

​@@aaabrams1889 mostLAMES are the fools here because believe in this BS

[@GizmoFromPizmo]

As an aside, when I was a kid, my mom got hold of Lourdes water. Lourdes water comes from a Catholic pilgrimage sport in France, I believe. (It's a Mary Queen of Heaven (Isis) thing.) Religions like Islam and Catholicism and even Buddhist religions have these pilgrimage spots, which are pretty big business. Fortunately for Christians, there are no holy places, special holy people, or holy objects. In the kingdom of God, all that stuff is gone. The Holy City, the New Jerusalem will one day be on the New Earth but until then, we're free from hajj sites. Thank God for Jesus!

[@aaabrams1889]

YES - ADMIT YOU GOT NOTHING😀 NOT evens the Real Jesus as you are worshipping LUCIFER who imitated the Real Jesus.

[@AustralianChristianFascists]

The New Jerusalem is Christ's Church, the Catholic Church.

[@valkyrie3493]

​@@AustralianChristianFascistshe catholic church is a heretical institution that centre's worship around Mary. There's nothing remotely Christ-like about it.

[@euanthompson]

So let me get this straight. The reason that there were issues with Zamzam water was not because there were issues with the water, but because some unknown, unnamed company that wasn't the Zamzam water somehow managed to get hold of the Zamzam water and accidentally added impurities, even though the water is tightly controlled and only one company is allowed to bottle it. Go on Shabir, pull the other one.

[@mahmoodali1533]

Some times paying attention to what was being said and doing little research may unlock the mystery, Sometimes small companies buy big bottles from Saudi Arabia Zamzam company and then those companies rebottles the big bottle into smaller bottle. Opening big bottles and powering them in small bottles if not done probably may cause contamination. Hope that helps.

[@euanthompson]

@@mahmoodali1533 seriously. And you believe that some unnamed company in the west spent lots of money on poor quality water when there is lots of fresh spring water in Europe, decided to rebottle it for some reason rather than leave as is, and was not set up correctly for food hygene? And the Zamzam company didn't have a huge problem with this and didn't get it in every news paper that it wasn't their bottles that contained arsenic despite having Zamzam company lables. Sure. By the way Zamzam company water is illegal in the UK for commercial sale specifically because it doesn't meet food safety standards. It was smuggled in. From the original article as well "These showed high levels of nitrate and potentially harmful bacteria, and traces of arsenic at three times the permitted maximum level, just like the illegal water which was purchased in the UK." As I say. Pull the other one.

[@mahmoodali1533]

You said it yourself it is being smuggled to Britain, then how in hell that something is smuggled and you still claim it came from Saudi Arabia? Something smuggled then it is sure nobody knows it is origin. And, actually, I have friend in Britain who have store there and he told me,actually, Indians are the one who are working on this scam. They smuggle water from India when they return from India in their vacation, and then the bring with them some bottled water from India smuggle it and try to it sell as Zamzam water that came from Saudi Arabia. the report on the bbc is actually in itself suspicious. BBC did not send one of it is expert to Saudi Arabia to bring samples by himself, but asked some pilgrims to bring water from Zamzam and who was this pilgrims God only knows whether he was a real pilgrims or some Indians scammers who scammed the BBC. BBC if it was serious then simply it could have sent one of it is own Muslim reporter to Saudi Arabia to bring water samples and it could have documented all the step it took to get the samples till testing it and how it tested it and who tested it, not just dubious and obscure sources that nobody knows anything about him. And yes bbc could. Documented hot it get the samples. There are a lot of western who are not Muslims claimed to be Muslims and went to umrah to Saudi Arabia and documented the trip and you can find them on KZbin. BBC did not write a scientific paper all it did it said asked obscure pilgrims to bring to them sample from Zamzam now whether bbc did or just lying. Only God knows and for that the Saudi authority did not even try to respond to them because what they did simply was unscientific.

[@aaabrams1889]

ZAMZAM WATER BRINGS DEAD FISH BACK TO LIFE kzbin.info/www/bejne/eqeye5ePgJl-kJY

[@OrpheusXL]

What Shabir Ally actually is saying when he tells us that it's the kind (level) of belief which heals is: If it does not cure you, it's your fault, because you have a deficit in belief. This is, what all sects tell their followers to keep them going: If it does not work, try harder, pray longer, do more prigrimages, spend more money, drink more ZamZam water.....

[@aaabrams1889]

HERE IS A SCIENTIST ON ZAMZAM kzbin.info/www/bejne/rIKtqImKg6ena5Y

[@ferrykar9819]

'Western technology is the miracle from Allah!"😂

[@azedinebenammar4339]

Science and technology are the result and work of human efforts in trying to find solutions to their daily lives. It's not the property of Western man. Just read about previous civilisations.

[@ilonkastille2993]

When did this water start appearing?

[@1stcenturymessiahunveiled94]

Hi Jay , I appreciate your videos about Islam. I just have been wondering for a few years where your accent is from. Is it Dutch ? Greetings.

[@cricketlovers5735]

Zamzam water is only provided to people inside masjid ul haram and pilligrams and in limited quantity , but whole saudi arabia out side the masjid ul haram gets water from refined plants .

[@seanrathmakedisciples1508]

Shabir knows that Jesus is God’s provision and mercy for all mankind but they refuse to receive their forgiveness and salvation and eternal life.. The Muslims have no savior and are trying to earn their own forgiveness. Both books agree that Jesus is the hero and it’s the Lord Jesus who is returning to the Mount of Olives near Jerusalem. Even Muhammed himself has no assurance of forgiveness of sins and eternal life Sura 48:1-2 ❤

[@aaabrams1889]

LUCIFER GAVE YOU THE ASSURANCE that your sins are forgiven by a human-sacrifice and this is totally Satanic at its core...drinking the blood and eating the flesh of the victim.

[@arieltellis458]

It is sad that despite actual proof of the current source to replace the problematic and polluted zam zam they still try to find ways and means to justify that it is pure well water. It boils down to a loyalty to believe what was told to them and defend it at all costs including the risk of misleading their very own folk rather than guiding them to the truth even after seeing the evidence before them.

[@danielharp5883]

His daughter doesn’t believe his words.

[@kidxcrush1]

if it’s rain water in a desert why would it not dry up before becomes a well that replenishes it self, humans built the earth and control the rain to fill it? or is it a miracle of creation that there’s a small oasis well that refills continuously without asking in the middle of a desert

[@ImCarolB]

Shabir Ali's reduction of using modern medicine to an act of faith is disturbing. It would encourage many people to equate needed medication with using Zamzam water and camel urine + faith.

[@Eirexeyes]

At 03:58 Just as she was about to ask the first question, it seemed like she rolled her eyes...

[@Frst2nxt]

Didn't John get wonderstruck at the sight of Mystery Babylon in the middle of the desert? On the other hand, the Zumzummim were defeated in what is now Jordan.

[@joseywales3789]

*"WITHOUT LIES, ISLAM DIES!"*

[@martinekanji8537]

😂😂😂😂

[@dhardhirdruha6916]

Absolutely

[@reynoldthemagnificientthun463]

Subhanallah

[@adeyemostephen1986]

Read the Quran It never said it cures

[@ephesus2312]

​@@adeyemostephen1986 You ment the satanic verses. No thanks

[@peterjackson2625]

It is quite simple really. There is plenty of water close to Mecca. It is seawater. Nowadays it is practical to desalinate sea water in the quantities needed for the population and the annual "pilgrimage". It is cheap to produce and Saudi Arabia makes a vast amount of money, selling at inflated prices to the "pilgrim". Just as the Nabateans did with their natural sources of water centuries before them. Many years ago, I worked at company on Tyneside, that built desalination equipment for places like Abu Dhabi.

[@joek8948]

I always find it amusing when serious educated adult try their darnest to explain the obvious absurdities of 1slam.

[@larstell]

Allah showed up 1924.......in Egypt..

[@stephenchienjo3283]

yeah! a couple of hundreds years later!

[@Chandransingham]

Very interesting insight into the water supply/civil engineering aspects in Mecca. Perhaps this is for a serious study. MSc or PhD or post-Phd work. Also trace other archetypes of holy waters. eg Lourdes water & baths where a BCC programme revealed how French Muslim ladies do volunteering work in the ladies section of the baths probably inspired by Surah 19: Maryam (Mary - Mother of Jesus). I wonder if Shabir Ally and his daughter are getting carried away with the usual allegorical and metaphors implied in the Quran. All down to Allah which is the Arabic word for God. Bible was there before the Quran. In this age and time how can things be squared up ?

[@AustralianChristianFascists]

The miracle of Lourdes happened in 1858, long after the Quran. It is not a dogma that Catholics must believe the Lourdes waters are miraculously healthy, but it's also prefraced, that its miraculous, as not everyone is cured, God miraculously cures if it is according to his divine plan. Different than the muslims claim, that the healing of the zamzam water is based on how much faith you have. I.e. if you don't get cured, it must mean you don't have much faith.

[@JohnDoe-hr4xj]

If you have no knowledge everything is a miracle.

[@mrbaab5932]

During the greener Sahara period when Arabia was greener too was this when Mekkah was founded? Also 2% of the water of Mekkah that is not from desalination supports 80,000 people that would make it a larger ancient city.

[@toddbeamer6131]

There is absolutely no evidence for mecca in the 7th century or earlier. No evidence under the sand, no contemporary descriptions by pilgrims or merchants from the neighboring empires, not on any contemporary maps from the 7th century or earlier, nothing.

[@salancy3279]

❤️💐🙏👍👌

[@chrishoff402]

I would argue that drinking water from the well of Buda'a would be harmful, but not the ZamZam well.

[@ottomais]

Well of Buda'ah,,the water with high quality 😂😂😂

[@jamalbaraja6130]

A Japanese professor and scientist discovered special miraculous features in zamzam water. His video is available in you-tube.

[@SiberianGravy]

Without lies Islam dies.

[@Thor-Orion]

So I really like Dr James Tabor’s work on the Dead Sea Scrolls and Qumran. The zamzam water is about as pure as the ritual immersion pool that Qumran used that gave everyone stomach worms and other nasty stuff. Qumran and the other desert communities in the Holyland were super inhospitable and they were nowhere near as awful as the Hejazi was/is in terms of aggressively non-life-sustaining.

[@Guztenify]

Dr. Ally out there looking like a muslim Mr. Bean😂

[@tavioka6243]

Basically he said the ZamZam water is like a tylenol. Sometimes it works sometimes it doesnt. Lol

[@ExposingFalseDoctrines]

Many Qurans or Hadiths? That says water is always pure?

[@rogerdodger8415]

Amazing how there's a parallel between the magical properties of the Zumzum water and the Catholic Churches holy water.

[@pixelatedjoe]

What is the parallel?

[@rogerdodger8415]

@@pixelatedjoe Both faiths believe that there are magical properties to the water. Google "Uses of Holy Water Every Catholics Should Know" and read up.

[@rogerdodger8415]

@@violetsplace524 Read my comment again. It says "properties". No one mentioned drinking.

[@rogerdodger8415]

@@violetsplace524 Ok. Now that you have educated yourself on Catholic holy water. Watch this video AGAIN and listen carefully to what is *claimed* (not that I believe it) for the Zum Zum well. THEN you'll have your comparison. Also... Look further down in these comments for someone named "dudedude" See wat he says.

[@valkyrie3493]

​@@rogerdodger8415you're not very smart. One has to to with actual consumption. The other is symbolic for cleansing and renewal.

[@FeremoRacumu-ci8ec]

I believe that the lady who was taken by her father to Mecca but was healed when Jesus healed her after she returned to Pakistan wrote her story in a book called : The torn veil . Another muslim lady who was healed by Jesus wrote her slory in a book called : I dared to call Him Father . Both very inspiring books .

[@alwafaasbvchannel]

Sir When will you convert?

[@valkyrie3493]

To what? 🤔

[@Kumarapwmss1989]

Get lost with pagan allah🐷

[@jsilvanus240]

Come and drink of CHRIST,the living water..

[@aaabrams1889]

Is this when you have to go on your knees😅🤣😂

[@valkyrie3493]

​@@aaabrams1889your mum will know a lot about going down on knees, son of Muta. 😂

[@rockzalt]

Shabir also had to clarify that the water itself wasn't like medicine. Are there no stories to be found in the Quran that can be used by an Islamic academic to explain this from a theological point of view?

[@charlesstepp2083]

What's the difference between mormons and muslims?

[@valkyrie3493]

Violence.

[@WayneDomingo-Sambrano-xe4ff]

Love your work Jay you and David Wood are doing some serious damage to Islam God bless you brother shalom.

[@tomtaylor6163]

Olympia Beer used the slogan “It’s the Water” too…..

[@nielsbruun8046]

:) The miracle of number 19

[@janwind5795]

Read John 9 carefully. Then decide if you are still blind and wish to remain blind or if you wish to receive healing, to see and to live through the immeasurable power of the Son of God, Jesus the Christ.

[@davidbassey693]

With all these data on the death toll and the hygiene status of the zam zam well, Islam really do seem to have a very short memory.

[@grizzlybizz7305]

Wouldn't Hagar have a better sense of direction if she was headed back to Egypt after Abraham faithfully did as God said and he made Ishmael a Great nation too. I just can't see her heading to Mecca when it was a wasteland that she maybe knew that also so she would go toward Egypt in the west.

[@aaabrams1889]

God's plan was to make that ''wasteland'' the centre of the earth. kzbin.info/www/bejne/epnWdIGMj6moZ8U

[@wlan246]

I have heard that "ZamZam" gets its name from the Pool of Siloam, from John 9, where Jesus cures a man of blindness. "Siloam" → "Zamzam" The author of the Qur'an has a long track record of mis-hearing names before transliterating them; e.g., "Amram" → "Imran".

[@OrpheusXL]

I heard it comes from hebrew words for "Stop!" Stop1", which Hagar is said to have shouted out, when the water starts running. Why she should do this after she was seeking for water for 7 days? Allah knows best.

[@bobfisher1909]

@@OrpheusXL It was zome zome which means stop stop , it changed to zamzam. 'Well of the Kaʿba', a dry well inside the Kaʿba reputed to have been used as the treasury of the Kaʿba and as a place for religious offerings in pre-Islamic Mecca and Zamzam merged at some point with stories concerning the former being adapted to feature the latter. noun with the adjectives Arabic: زمزم, romanized: zamzam and Arabic: زمازم, romanized: zumāzim which are onomatopoeic denoting a dull sound stemming from either a distant roll (of thunder) or a guttural sound emitted with a closed mouth by animals or people, however meaning either 'an abundant supply. So not even close to SIN, stop stop in Arabic قف قف qif qif - “halt!, stop!, whoa!” So Hagar did not say zam zam. 'Zamzam' comes from the Arabic verb 'zam' meaning 'gathering' or 'enclosing' like building dam walls to trap the water. What is the origin of the word Zamzam? The water kept flowing and Hajar said :”Zome zome”, meaning "stop flowing" and thus the water was named Zamzam. Ibn Abbas reported that Prophet Muhammad once said: “The water of Zamzam is good for whatever one intends (while drinking it) this was the new name they gave it. Now when I look up Zome zome it comes from Zulu or isiZulu as an endonym, is a Southern Bantu language of the Nguni branch spoken in Southern Africa. It is the language of the Zulu people, it means dry dry, so the standard Islamic narrative got very confused telling their story. So, was Islam Hagar come from south Africa? I think I stick to the bible it makes perfect sense. I have read how the people pre-Islam times use to travel to this gathering place from all around to trade stuff and worship their many idols (hence the many idols in this dwelling) as one without fighting each other on this market trade event, like a big carnival, maybe they traveled over by small boats to trade with those on the other side. Don't know if it true just something I read somewhere. They also use to dance naked around it pre-Islamic times. So maybe it was there as a festival place where all those who need to trade can do so safely. Just a theory, then came Islam who claimed it like they did with everything. Might be why they used their Hagar from south Africa that said zome zome. Be great to find out just who and why they gathered at this spot.

[@OrpheusXL]

@@bobfisher1909 Yes, that's quite interesting. As far as I know, stop means qaf in Arabic. At least it is used like this in the Moroccan dialect and can be found on traffic signs as well. qif qif means (in Morocco) "the same" or "similar".

[@azedinebenammar4339]

Yes, he got a Noble price in Littérature! Come on, be serious!

[@wlan246]

@@bobfisher1909 We have all "read how the people pre-Islam times use[d] to travel to this gathering place from all around..." That's one of the "facts" that the Sin Sifters are bringing into question: all evidence points to the Red Sea trade routes going up the coast of _Africa_ instead of the Arabian peninsula-which means all those stories that we have all read about trade routes through Mecca were/are fictional.

[@anuradhakadam7907]

There is powerful testimony of one Pakistan lady whose father took her for miracles from her paralysis. Obviously it didn't happen, but then she was visited by Jesus Christ of Nazareth and healed her and she left the house to.beba christians. She was a powerful lady , she came to America and served the Lord.

[@Ghredle]

You have to admit that Dr Shabir Ali is a Gentleman and he does genuinely debate, he is several leagues above some others

[@stingray4980]

A gentleman LIAR!🤪

[@serenakaur1131]

Yes,he's also leagues above others in lying...lol

[@stephenchienjo3283]

@@serenakaur1131 lol he's got a lying tongue!

[@almilligan7317]

So Abraham, the father of the faith, a prophet, threw out the child of Promise and Hagar? What’s wrong with this picture?

[@MrHankchu]

Too bad MO had very little faith or didn't say his prayer when he ate the poisoned lamb.

[@sandhiyudha5658]

Islam is equal with Deception + Stupidity. What an awesome explanation Dr. Jay!

[@faisaltawakim1577]

zamzam water was not for stupid people and brainless, they'll get drown once they drink it even a small cup. jay smith drinks urine .

[@AsamHussain]

Ismail and his father Ibrahim build the Kaaba together after hajara passed away Kaaba was not there on that time

[@coltonconner782]

Sea water (tap water)

[@tavioka6243]

Im frm the Pacific islands im in my early 30s & after WWll there was a cholera outbreak on my island so i would say during the war the disease finally made its way in. Fyi we were first under Germany & then by Spain but they ddnt really have anything to do with us. They nvr came to make us speak Spanish or German or whatever they just nvr came to live with us lol. We were still simply living with nature. Then came the Japanese & when they attacked Pearl Harbor thats when the US came in & got rid of the Japanese & a year or a few months after that we had a Cholera outbreak for the first time. Now let me tell u this as a Pacific islander. We rely on springs & rain water. We nvr thought about rain water catchments because we had rainfall all year round & this would be like in the 1950s or whatever. These stories are passed down to us frm our elders. It will nvr be forgotten & today even during the Covid Pandemic my island nation was one of the very last places on this planet with no Covid positive cases to this day. We closed off our borders before it even made its way over & during those times of the cholera we were still closed to the land as our ancestors were but the war broke out.

[@Sunil-wi4yw]

Zam zam is pure, but the rasool took bath is severe..