A Suit About A Suit

The plaintiff canceled a tuxedo rental at the defendant’s shop but didn’t get a refund, so the plaintiff is suing. The defendant insists the plaintiff only put down a deposit, and deposits are nonrefundable.

[@nonamenogame101]

It's crazy how she knew he was a cop because of his entitled behavior

[@scotthewitt258]

For me, it was the tacticool pants the second he walked in. Either a cop or a Barney.

[@galegibbs5946]

That's why she ruled in his favor because he's a cop

[@christopherramon-reid9841]

YES! I was goin to say that! I’ve seen her sniff out the profession of other litigants in different episodes the same way!

[@MrLamigra1337]

You do know that this is a TV show and the judge knows all the details in advance right?

[@raeneal3825]

​@MrLamigra1337 True! They also fill out a questionnaire asking other personal info. The litigants have no idea that what they're telling also tells the judge what kind of person they MIGHT be.

[@confidentialp6292]

If the plaintiff ever pulls you over you better have your phone out to record. He seems like the type of cop that would write anything he feels on a police report

[@xonx209]

Pulling out a phone may get you shot. The cop would say I thought he was pulling out a gun...

[@ruemcbride-eads4656]

Dashcam with two way camera and audio would work it out

[@confidentialp6292]

@@ruemcbride-eads4656 you know cops turn all these off on and on on their own right?

[@wvrjl]

​@xonx209 - It's saved a lot of people. Have the phone out BEFORE the cop comes to the window, or have a dashcam. More often than not, it has saved people from excess violence, and lying cops.

[@amandanicole7449]

She cracked me up calling him out on his career 😂😂

[@Wendy-yg8yu]

A really good example of the law. Blatantly lies when he said he didn’t ask for cash.

[@travis8665]

Rubbish.

[@Lh-wq5gc]

Obviously he didn't lie he said he asked for the cash after being told that it could not be refunded on the card and the video proved it was exactly as he said so what lie?? What's ridiculously hilarious is when people claim oh they lied but apparently didn't watch the video or listen to the case.

[@Wendy-yg8yu]

@@Lh-wq5gcry listening again. The cop said he went in with the card and statements. The defendant said the plaintiff had nothing. He walked in there expecting to just get a refund. If don’t have the card how else are you getting a refund except cash! When the defendant said about the cash, and the judge asked the cop, he stumbled about whether he asked for cash. He knew he was caught and then admitted. He is a liar and expected the judge to believe him. Listen closely as he talks fast and mumbles when he gets to that spot. It’s easy to make a judgement when your not really listening.

[@Lh-wq5gc]

@@Wendy-yg8yu no way you're wrong.. first of all your reply has not a thing to do with your saying he is a liar 🤣🤣🤣 he admitted he asked for cash after and the video shows it but I need watch it again ok...the first line out of the defendants mouth in the video proves he saw the new card even judge Milian didn't pick up on that obvious fact with the new card on the counter....the video clearly shows him asking for a refund he had the new card not the old one when he was told he could not receive it on the card because there was a discrepancy with the numbers on the cards he asked for cash...... I'm not going to argue with you I am just pointing out facts that are verified in the video which you weren't paying attention to CLEARLY

[@QS0924]

ijust love the way Doug always blatanly disses everyone on their handshake. 😂

[@irenestrmnss4331]

Celebrities are too high up to touch ordernary folks hands. But I dont want to touch strangers hands either, but shake hands when introduced and meet nice people. It s polite and the right thing to do. Can wash my hands soon after

[@skywarp528]

Plaintiff is not that bright, scary how he is a cop in public

[@BeKind2AllKinds]

Cops are notoriously stupid.

[@vivianpatton5692]

Cops R Not known for their high IQ .

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

Almost like it's a prerequisite for the job.

[@MrAlienmagnet]

A cop that doesn't know how to get evidence but holler. lol What a putz

[@iamthomasgreenman]

Admits he “should have had the numbers” at the end but spent 10 minutes in court arguing “he gave him the right numbers.”

[@BobBlumenfeld]

"Oh, you're a cop!" Yeah, cops are trained to take control of situations and that sounds like what this plaintiff was trying to do. Unfortunately for him, he didn't have a legal way to force the plaintiff to yield control to him.

[@buffalowill2789]

"id rather not say.." that was enough to know that dude thinks hes gods gift.

[@mikesteele05]

If he thought that, he’d be proud to tell the world. He just didn’t want to be discriminated against because the judge doesn’t like people who have his career.

[@RichardSmith-my1fj]

How she knew he was a cop is amazing.Sharp lady.

[@namnack]

She knew he was cop before he stepped in there, people. Don't get too excited.

[@34stzoo]

1:15 As a father and a man if my son changes his mind at the last second to attend an event, he's held responsible for any and all financial obligation! I will NOT fight on his behalf for his mishaps. It's called raising a boy into a man! If the situation was out of my son's control and he made every effort to correct the mishap and couldn't, then and only then I will help.

[@scotthewitt258]

Unfortunately, it is clear this "father" is teaching the wrong lesson....

[@arizflowerchild]

I wouldn't make the son responsible for anything beyond the deposit cuz paying extra was the father's foolish behavior

[@galegibbs5946]

I agree

[@amandabrown6565]

I mean he changed his mine and didn't want to go. It happens and I wouldn't make my child pay. The mom gave $20 and then the dad took it upon his self and paid $169!! He was going to get his money if he would have showed the card, paper work or something. All of this happened for no reason and the child shouldn't be held accountable.

[@eloahnon4952]

Exactly, I was looking for this comment. Too many adults raising children to be unaccountable adults.

[@shellwilliams6306]

Sometimes i just wish she'd let people FINISH their sentence/statement 😳

[@travis8665]

Its a time thing. she doesn't need to know more than she does. she doesn't need a story. Its about what the law says.

[@hey-you7]

​@@travis8665everyone has the right to plead their case in court. If she was a real Judge she would have so many appeals against her because of it.

[@shellwilliams6306]

@@travis8665 I agree, BUT...c'mon....at times she spends more time saying she's the daughter of a contractor, she has two daughters, that she'd never put up with a time limit of such. If she'd just LISTEN sometimes there actually might be important facts that she missed out on....that's all I'm saying 🤔😳

[@grassfedcharlie]

“WAIT BUT HOW DID YOU KNOW???” “OK BUT WAIT WHAT DID YOU THINK WAS GONNA HAPPEN???” “CAN U WAIT?? I CANT LISTEN TO U AND LOOK AT THE EVIDENCE AT THE SAME TIME !”

[@JayseGreene]

Oh ffs, just dispute the charge and let the bank deal with this Herman.

[@OddlyRelaxingSounds]

All he taught his son was to not honor a contract, whine and moan and b**ch until you get what you want.

[@BCNeil]

I bet the dad is the reason the girl didn't want to date the son. She wanted nothing to do with her boyfriends family.

[@travis8665]

Maybe,.. at least till her home got broken into or they needed a cops help after an accident.

[@BeKind2AllKinds]

@@travis8665Lol. No, thanks!

[@scotthewitt258]

"Deposits are non-refundable" You deposited the full price, officer.

[@scotthewitt258]

Am I the only one still waiting for someone to hand over their phone with the WRONG vudeo cued up?!?!?

[@emilianoadams9499]

I fear for the community he’s a cop in

[@scotthewitt258]

"Oh, you're a cop." Plaintiff nods slightly.......

[@lorimontijo5184]

This one gave me a headache 😩 lol

[@TRugmr78]

I absolutely love Judge M!! Ahhh you're a cop! and just moves on... like damn!!

[@loveyoutube2177]

Something about this cop doesn’t set well with me.

[@JeremiahLOsborne]

This is crazy. I can't believe these two guys got all this way. Two stubborn guys that didn't want to give in to the other one without one breaking the rules and the other one holding hard and fast. All it took was a grown up to come in and give each little boy equal time with the football.

[@justvincenturb]

oooorrrrrr the plaintiff could've... yknow, come back with the receipt like how a typical refund works.

[@JeremiahLOsborne]

@@justvincenturb obviously, the defendant didn't need the receipt. There was only one credit card charge on that day for the amount that the plaintiff is suing for, and the plaintiff knew what the credit card number was on the paper. That's proof enough. And seriously, over $120? I can understand if we're talking about thousands of dollars out of someone's bank account, but this is very petty. Like I said, one guy wanted to break the rules, and the other guy wanted to enforce them to the absolute furthest he could.

[@minhduong1484]

@ahLOsborne The plaintiff didn't give the credit card number when he wanted the refund was the issue. In the plaintiff's own video, the defendant said he needed at least the last 4 digits as verification, and the plaintiff refused to give him that. From the defendant's testimony which the plaintiff does not deny, the plaintiff wanted cash back. From the defendant's standpoint, a guy comes in without a receipt and an attitude and wants cash refund on a credit card purchase but does not want to give the credit card number as verification. What would you do if you were a shop owner? Instead of giving him 4 numbers, the plaintiff sued. The entire suit might have been avoided if the plaintiff just gave the defendant 4 numbers.

[@jameskeller3547]

His kid probably was stood up 😂

[@langstonwalker1618]

Part of me is surprised Five-0 didn’t pull out a taser or his service weapon. It’s not hard to get documentation of your old credit card number. In the age of phones and apps that’s bafflingly simple. Only a total moron would have asked for cash on a credit card transaction.

[@Mocharocks9966]

It was funny because he never mentioned calling the police because I was shocked he didn’t seeing how he acted in court and then we heard why 😂😂

[@momoboolman8820]

What gets me is that it was prom and the plaintiff came in paid the whole thing for the suit, and expected a full refund/ or any refund, 5 days later when that suit was probably already almost done...!!??

[@de4700]

I bet that the amount was paid for by the ex-wife and he is trying to pocket the money.

[@TedraChanel]

The way she drops ppls phones is crazy.

[@MommeeMadre1]

I often pay in full for things like this so i don't have to stand in line on the pick up. But i have a good receipt. Never had problems.

[@gan-ban6083]

Lady out there with Harvey- that is not your color lipstick. 😮

[@karensmith6815]

He shouldn’t b working for the most criminal state ever foh lmaoooo

[@ginao4706]

The defendant reminds me of uncle fester lmao

[@wvrjl]

"I said, 'Here's the card...'" No, you gave him the NEW card, which has a different card number (clearly, his credit card was hacked, and his new card, of course, had a different number). I don't believe that the refund will go through because that card was canceled. It doesn't matter that it's the same account because the purchase went through the card. What the plaintiff SHOULD have provided is documentation from the credit card company showing: 1) Card A (whose number matches the receipt) was canceled (it doesn't matter why), and 2) Card B (the new card the plaintiff has) was issued to replace card A. The defendant tried to tell the plaintiff that, but he wouldn't listen. That being said, the defendant's receipts are ridiculous. The customer's name, and name on the credit card should be shown on the receipt.

[@cassandra6710]

People are so petty

[@qveensirah8242]

I disagree with the fact that the judge doesn’t understand refunds. In public service you have to have the form of payment you used and the receipt. Anybody can come in and say they need refund just to get money for free, I’ve seen it multiple times at work.

[@tinasung3814]

They had to hear it from JM say "You are BOTH JERKS"....they could have been besties too since they are so similar in temperament.

[@cierrafeliciano9447]

Plaintiff came through that door about his business looolol

[@tbecker97204]

It's the teenage son's fault for backing out on the Prom. (No, it's NOT his fault!)

[@romansbottom]

Knew he was a cop because of how entitled he was. All he had to do was bring his old credit card why waste time coming to court.

[@PugFairi]

Why would he say he’s a cop? What’s the point of hiding it ?

[@audiodynamixBagzz]

She could smell he was a cop haha, wonder what that smelled like

[@nettejones8276]

The plaintiff is in law enforcement but can't read nor prepare evidence. That scary. Then his excuse is I was rushing at the last minute. Dude! You're the one who decides when to file the case. SMH then he sits there Underoath and lies directly to the judge. I would have dismissed the case for perjury. He's definitely not the sharpest because the video was on the defendant's side, not his😂

[@mandylynnhoff]

Because I said so!!! 🤦🏼‍♀️

[@Hatokirei]

Lord, if that putz is actually a cop, he's not a good one. He didn't even bring the card into court for the lawsuit and he clearly made up his own story about what happened. It's always funny how people remember EVERYTHING that help their case but conveniently forget what happened after the camera was rolling.

[@34stzoo]

12:40 Dude, he kept asking for the last 4 digits... And we all know you told him you are a cop and he didn't care.

[@nunyabiz6925]

Hmmm. It goes with eggs?! Just kidding 😂

[@roxannejones2237]

Milian is such a .....she always attacks the plaintiff smh

[@wvrjl]

No, she doesn't. She makes them get to the point. Only SOME things are material to the case. If you want to see an attacker and a . . ., watch Judge Judy.

[@lady_of_mayhem_]

Gotta Love the Entitled way Some Cops Act…..

[@Begotts]

I like the defendant’s attitude. And he was right the whole time. I feel the cop thought he could walk right in and get what he wanted because he’s a cop…idk maybe not.

[@Destyni123]

When they are talking abt their daughters and sports at the end, what did the second daughter do? Road crew? Rowwed crew....?

[@Janedoe-22]

Id be soooo embarrassed if I was the plantiff

[@ruefullysage]

i feel bad for the defendant bc his business is gonna get some bs from the cops for this.

[@Rae2492]

People talking to Harvey, vote..scary..are they not listening to question?

[@jenniferbart3060]

He shouldn’t get anything back.

[@deniseedodson1938]

I watched the episode on t.v. today 7-21. People's Court signed off for good? May I say something stupid?? NO - THIS CAN'T HAPPEN. I know there will be reruns and other media to watch the show. HOWEVER, I am 74 and retired. My 1:00 p.m. IS for the People's Court. With all the horrible changes going on in the world my constant good feel is the People's Court. I am sad today. There is nothing that can be done .......but no.....Leave the People's Court intact. My great- grandmother's group is very unhappy.

[@GrenadianAmerican]

Just two sunburn men 😊

[@NovaDexter]

This judge is so biased. She decided the case by the time they walk in.

[@irenestrmnss4331]

A crooked cop, playing

[@LoayMatar]

I don't understand how he got a refund when on the receipt it says that deposits are non-refundable.

[@virgo7956]

Me either; unless he agreed to give it to him.

[@cosmo6180]

Okay….so why were they there? (Court)

[@16MedicRN]

OMGAWD Judge: What do you do for a living? Plaintiff: I'd rather not say. Judge: Oh, you're a cop (deeep inhale) 😂😂😂 Judge, BTW, former prosecutor 😉

[@TRal55]

12:03 "I'm surprised he won!" Doug the hallway guy is such a simpleton. He thinks that if the Judge gives one side a hard time, then that must mean there's no way they're going to win. His brain has no ability for nuance or complex ideas. For example, when he tells people who won, "Congratulations." It's like, they didn't just win a prize, they got a judgment for what they already lost. Limited thinker.

[@dreamnull1964]

I literally hate every time he talks. All he does is insult those who lose each episode. Seriously don’t know why he’s there.

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

LoL no. Doug uses nuance and subtle sarcasm very well. He can be a real savage too cutting down smug litigants when needed. He's a pro.

[@TRal55]

@@lukerinderknecht2982 When? He always asks the same very basic questions. "What did you think of what the Judge did?" There are times when he asks questions that was already brought up in the case, so it's clear he doesn't pay full attention. He has no ability to ask the litigants more personal, deeper questions that don't get covered in the case. He sucks at his job. I really hope they don't bring him back in the next iteration of this show

[@dreamnull1964]

@@lukerinderknecht2982 he’s a pro asshole

[@aureliemorren7983]

I am not amused by Doug. I find it so rude that he turns his back when people offer a handshake, and yet he feels free to stroke/touch people's shoulders/arms whenever he wants. It's like he is saying "I can enter your personal space anytime without permission, but you can't enter my personal space under any circumstances." Very arrogant and rude.

[@emilydutes8272]

All that for a hundred bucks? Idk if I'm not petty or too lazy. Seems like way too much work for a hundred dollars. Unless u just wanna be tv

[@gsuscan1]

Shouldn’t a cop be more physically fit?

[@linkdx245]

Be lost the 20 his wife put down as a down payment

[@WonderingHead]

Thé dad is so shady

[@RC--900]

This cop has issues, I pray for anyone pulled over by him

[@Spritel4]

Judge jumped too soon and spent time trying to make a simple case look more complicated that at is. Rare, but apparently, it happens. Painful backpedalling in actions. Verdict for a sh!t show.

[@billyjohnson9166]

Most cops are dishonest

[@diamondstarr3392]

a cab

[@BREEZYM6015]

I'll sue for $1.69. 😂

[@VoyeurOfMisfortune]

the way she was like Phock you you're a cop

[@the-CanadianBacon]

Y’all are wild. The defendant CLEARLY says he wants proof it was hacked YOU DONT NEED THAT. The last 4 numbers shit doesn’t even matter. Here? We can return your money to any card! It does not have to be the same. For this reason alone. So why there are they so strict? The defendant is a liar and didn’t want to give his money back

[@scotthewitt258]

So, his papers DID have the wrong card number......

[@inthemouthofmadness5910]

Both litigants acted like two three year olds on video. It was like two children fighting over a damn toy. On a different note, the son should pay because he is the one who backed out. If I had kids, which I never will, I would definitely make my kid pay!!

[@Web19814]

Why do some cops never want to say they are cops?

[@travis8665]

They put a lot of people in jail. That would do it for me.

[@bernadettebeatty3899]

A cop hot head

[@JeremiahLOsborne]

Must have been the foul odor of rotting bacon in the air.

[@KrazyVideoChick]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 🐽

[@misunderstoodpisces6342]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@virgo7956]

Not rotten bacon😂😂😂😂

[@brianvalley5223]

I admire the plaintiff, however, if he'd provided the documentation when he went to the business, it all could have been prevented.

[@BeKind2AllKinds]

You admire a hot headed cop with no integrity?

[@stephaniehowe0973]

Yeah Law requires businesses to refund to the original method of payment. Now at my job my credit card has been canceled fraud. I confirm they continue to do business with that bank.

[@alfonsorodriguez6739]

That guy is a nightmare customer. The defendant was right not to give him anything back. He changed his tune when he heard cop.

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

All of this because of some stupid angsty teenager 😅

[@leonidasspyropoulos849]

I would expect from a cop to handle this better. Cops are trained to socially interact and figure things out.

[@christopherchance4860]

what did you ever get that idea from?

[@leonidasspyropoulos849]

@@christopherchance4860 bad and good people are in all walks of life. Do not be biased against all cops, most of them are really good people doing their job.

[@BeKind2AllKinds]

Why??? 😂

[@offbalance7]

I smelled bacon once he walked in.

[@travis8665]

Got a record have you?

[@offbalance7]

@@travis8665 nope. Educated. Unlike you clearly. 🤡

[@s.s.linebeck5536]

Of course he's a cop.

[@reignbeauxxx]

❤❤❤❤

[@TuesThruFri]

Why do proms even exist? I was in high school a few years ago and I don’t know a single person who actually went to our prom and this was a massive high school.

[@craZbeauTful]

It doesn't matter if he has the card or proof it was hacked. Just fucking refund it the acct still be credited. Judge and defendant are decrepit 🙄

[@wayneblackwwell6439]

All this BS over &100...welcome to America.

[@Miss_Cherry]

Of course its NYC. They argue just for fun.

[@heidicrimmings9615]

Hmmmmm Ok, Adrian...here we have a case with 2 Caucasian gentlemen...I can't wait to hear ( read) your take on this. My take??? When actions are dictated by an over large ego...too much testosterone with nowhere to go...🤔🤔🤔

[@16MedicRN]

LOLOL 😂 He's famous now. He likes it (or she).

[@ChelseaNicole94]

@@16MedicRNinfamous 🤣

[@bjohnson1149]

I can't say what I'm thinking 😁😁😁

[@JeremiahLOsborne]

That man's living rent-free in your mind.

[@16MedicRN]

@@ChelseaNicole94 true!

[@jonathantyner171]

11:53

[@cmoranchel1]

Y'all hating on the cop but ignoring the fact that the business owner could have handled this a lot better. Cards get lost/stolen yet other businesses have managed to refund customers without it getting to this point

[@Ellie80681]

But didn’t his son want a suit and cancelled?

[@virgo7956]

​@@Ellie80681 The entitlement and not taking responsibility for not going. I went somewhere and they said no refunds and that meant no refunds!!

[@tamaradiax3929]

Lmao , Your a cop

[@franklesser5655]

Ridiculous to rent clothes for an event.

[@mikesteele05]

Guys wear tuxedos to proms and most won’t wear one again until they’re in a wedding. It would be a worse investment to buy a tux for an 18 year old who likely won’t fit into it by the end of freshman year of college.

[@adrianknight1406]

Milian just yells shouts and interrupts the entire time yet these folks continue on dealing with the disrespect. Idc if she's the judge or not. It's wrong no matter the profession.

[@JeremiahLOsborne]

Bro. She was yelling at a white cop. I would imagine you would be celebrating, holding a parade down times Square.

[@nicklebaby]

If you think Judge Milan is disrespectful, you've never seen Judge Judy.

[@scotthewitt258]

She usually interrupts because she asks a specific question, and litigants tend to go off on tangents, because they do not want to answer the actual question.

[@rosej5029]

​@nicklebaby I'm surprised in the over 25 years JJ has been on, there's ONLY TWO episodes I've seen where people walked out the courtroom in the middle of the episode bc they weren't going to take JJ's 💩. But they come back when JJ reminds them, the show will only pay for plane ticket back home ONLY if they behave.

[@rosej5029]

For real. JJ has literally called people idiots and has made fun of, the usually underemployed/unemployed unattractive cheating boyfriend/husband, that two females are suing each other over while he's sitting there. JJ is savage!

[@peekaboots01]

The plaintiff is cute. I'm glad he won. Thank goodness. 👮‍♂️I love the judge. She's so smart and beautiful 👩‍⚖️

[@George-mf5hq]

🤮

[@kareengold5514]

You must be the plaintiff’s fake page to be commenting this 😂

[@superduperkid3143]

The store owner was not a jerk. Why the f did she call him one?