Amber Heard Testifies in Defamation Trial | HasanAbi reacts | Johnny Depp v Amber Heard Day 14

[@pinkmenace6836]

i don’t think she did herself a favor making the whole testimony so theatrical and dramatic. i know all testimonies are rehearsed but to a jury it’s gonna sound insincere. like it looks like she’s auditioning for a part

[@env0x]

she actually toned down the theatrics a lot here, compared to her speeches in the UK (when she was winning). the "brave survivor" role she plays way more overacted and dramatic than her "scared victim" shtick. this is just pathetic. like she can't even cry no matter how hard she scrunches her face to try and make tears come out.

[@evanjuleen]

Johnny's lawyers opening statements said that she was going to put on the greatest act of her life because they have no other evidence. Looks like she is.

[@tellmesomething2412]

@@env0x What I find weird about the case is, after losing the UK trial & divorce case, the evidence was found to be augmented, but that gave Depp the right to appeal, and he lost that too. Like, how bias are these courts? Edit: &, why are they bias?

[@guardry1605]

It lines up with the first psychiatrists opinion of her over-exaggerating alot of aspects. She just comes out as disingenuous when you look at the the testimonies we've already had proving some of her points as lies e.g. "I didnt punch you, I hit you" & "you're never meant to hit anyone"

[@blue-calla]

@@env0x lol, exactly. Her act was so transparent, especially how she kept including irrelevant details (e.g., the material of JD’s shirt, her dog stepped on a bee, etc) and saying “I remember” to make her testimony seem truthful, like she was recollecting. I wonder if her new PR rep got her a crash course in crying on demand last night.

[@teetee996112]

Funny how Amber perjured herself by lying about the beginning of their relationship, her testimony is the opposite of what she said last time too. Amber really made it a point to shame men crying, how disgusting. She talks about not being a fan of Johnny yet had his pictures all over her walls? Last case she says the abuse happened months in, now suddenly it's from the beginning? The moments of abuse she alleges don't even match up at all.

[@blue-calla]

Exactly. I think you’re referring to the trailer park incident where her story started out as JD only destroyed the trailer, then she added him threatening the friend, and now she added the cavity search, lol. Also, in looking back at her UK depo, when she testified about the incident where she punched JD (“you didn’t get punched; you got hit”), then he hid out in the bathroom, then she tried getting in and scraped her toes then kicked the door into his head - I noticed she told 2 diff versions of this story within minutes of each other, and neither were the truth. First she said she was in a room that JD was trying to get in; then she said she & JD were in a room together that she was trying to escape. Meanwhile, she was on audio from years prior, admitting to the truth. Lol. I wonder which version she’ll tell today.

[@blue-calla]

Oh my mistake, you were referring to the very beginning of their relationship (i.e., when he was “grooming” her 😉). She’s told so many lies and multiple versions of the same stories that it’s hard to keep up. 😄

[@j.t.1086]

The thing that really gets me is she's describing his addiction as if that in & of itself constitutes abuse. Vomiting & passing out doesn't make him evil, half her descriptions are of him in a health crisis. Making that all about herself, using that to vilify him, it makes my skin crawl. Very consistent with her having personality disorders, tho.

[@bamsgirl12345]

What's even worse is that it's been documented and proven that she's also taken the same drugs, with Johnny. She has her own addictions but makes Johnny the bad guy.

[@Tyttebaer]

A bit late but i've been watching the case the last few days and i think they use his drug addiction stuff to make Johnny's storie unreliable. He wouldn't be able to remember because he was so drunk of full of drugs that he passed out etc...The fact that she cries several times throughout the trial and immediately stops when an objection comes in makes her so untrustworthy.

[@vanessak267]

hasan saying johnny depp isn’t that great of an actor is wilder than him saying america deserved 9/11

[@professorpancakes6545]

Well, obviously... the first statement isn't true.

[@cynthiap.2573]

america did deserve 9/11 but johnny depp is an amazing actor

[@chiablum1453]

Hasan is full of himself. First he needs to stop shoving his mouth with food & talking at the same time. Hasan wish he had half the class Johnny has.

[@BareBandSubscription]

Hasan only watched his mid-tier Tim Burton work, apparently lol. I don’t understand how you can suggest the man who played Ed Wood, Whitey Bulger, and Captain Jack Sparrow isn’t a brilliant actor.

[@dowlernatasha1396]

Hasan is out of touch with reality sometimes but what is worse his followers who are mostly kids or grown men/women with skewed view of the world.

[@thedeathofreason]

You can't really call it "her truth" when literally every word she's spoken about JD and their relationship has been not only lies, but she's directly contradicted previous statements she made in the UK trial and has thus perjured herself. Perjury is not anyone's truth in any sense of the word.

[@nine9nine9]

WAIT WHAT? omg that's so good for JD, hope they caught it! How did she perjure herself?

[@emm8357]

@@nine9nine9 I’m assuming that on cross, Johnny’s lawyers will do the old “your testimony today is…” then bring out her previous depositions/trial testimony to highlight inconsistencies

[@nine9nine9]

@@emm8357 I'm praying, they absolutely failed to do that with Hughes

[@Room-xi6nb]

LoL...her truth is not necessarily THE truth.

[@thedeathofreason]

@@nine9nine9 not to mention that she mentioned Kate moss, and a lie about JD pushing her down stairs that Amber made up. Which A was lying and B violated the agreement to not bring previous relationships up so that means JDs lawyers can both question her about her ex she abused and was arrested for, but they can also call Kate Moss as a witness for rebuttal, and Kate Moss has repeatedly said how amazing JD is, how much she loved him, and how sad she was when she ended their relationship. She's had nothing but good things to say so that will further hurt this lying histrionic abuser's credibility.

[@Xosidhe]

She gives me Jodi Arias vibes in her testimony. Trying to be 100% innocent, like she doesn’t know how the world works, acting totally bewildered in her description of the fights, as if we didn’t hear the audio of her abusing and manipulating him.

[@luciusisdead]

THIS!! I literally rewatched Hasan’s Jodi video the other day and i was like “damn the vibes are wackkk” I also rewatched the one about Jennifer Pan too; she also gave me AH vibes

[@taylorjane9503]

As someone who has worked very hard to properly deal with my BPD I feel like her explaining a lot of the instances especially the Australia part, felt more like her emotional reactivity needing to match what happened. Growing up I did this a lot, I would feel very wronged and hurt but feel like no one heard or understood how strongly I felt I was wronged so I would lie about things to have the story match my emotions since I was unable to admit that my illness was causing these feelings not reality. (It’s not easy to admit that you have done things in the past that has hurt others but to stop the stigma that people with personality disorders are just bad people we need to talk about why it happens and how to help others with it.)Bringing it back to Amber’s testimony- the stories I would tell sound very similar to hers which leads me to think that she was very hurt and offended by everything that happened in Australia and she reacted very aggressively and for that level of aggression she needed to come up with a story to justify it because people with cluster b disorders also have a very hard time admitting fault.. it also could be why she keeps saying “it’s stupid” or belittling it because her brain is still having a hard time justifying what happened so she detaches from it by belittling it.

[@llamaczech]

Alternatively, she told the story in such a way to trigger people's past reactions so she's telling the truth because they told the truth. I'm gonna go with the psychologist's explanation of how this fits with BPD/HPD (she tested positive for both) rather than an anecdote.

[@emm8357]

I’m confused - she explains all the drug taking in Hicksville then later talks about another incident where she says “it was the first time I’d taken drugs with Johnny”. Didn’t she already say she took drugs with him in Hicksville?

[@nelsonzayas7514]

I agree. She contradicts herself a lot and seems to have oversimplified a lot of the situations. Shes basiclly doing the yada, yada, yada bit from Sienfeld

[@JesusChrist-dv2zu]

i don’t know how hasan is gonna say johnny depp isn’t a good actor

[@skybear17]

fr that made my jaw drop

[@Rawsclaws]

Right!? He’s such a good actor some movies I’ve watched I didn’t even realize it was him till the credits! Convinced he was just projecting lool

[@soumia117]

hes a himbo what did u expect

[@lesleykaychoreography2918]

His performance in “What’s Eating Gilbert Grape” is incredible.

[@dowlernatasha1396]

Remember hasan calls anyone who disagree with him a racist, a transphobe, a homophobe, or a bigot. So that explains how close minded he is.

[@rswife777]

He looked at the lawyers when he spoke, she looks at the jury, so transparent.

[@worldview6218]

Actually not a good strategy. As someone who’s sat on a jury before in a veryyyyyy long drawn out case most of us want to use the time a witness or defendant is testifying to look at them and gauge their reactions and observe them on top of listening to what they are saying and when they literally stare at you at least for me it feels very creepy or I guess I should say intrusive because then it almost feels awkward trying to do your job in observing them. That’s just me anyway but I can’t imagine any juror like being thrilled that they are just making full eye contact with a complete stranger their entire testimony and personally I think it’s just much more powerful when giving the testimony to respond to the lawyer asking the question and only occasionally during very specific moments in the testimony to make eye contact with the jury.

[@teetee996112]

@@worldview6218 exactly it feels like someone telling you a fucked up campfire story.

[@MrForbiddenSin]

​@@worldview6218 Because responding to the person asking you the question is natural. When you speak to the jury, everybody knows it's to influence them. Also not looking at the person who questions you is much better for lies to pass through. You break the line of eye contact etc. so it also limits the reactions of questioning person and the responder. They would have a more genuine reaction to their questions/responses if she would look at the lawyers, as they both have information about the topic and sometimes just small face expression can determine a lie.

[@vallreign]

They also objected every time Johnny would say He/She implying hearsay constantly.

[@pavkal6603]

But her lawyer before asking any question says “tell the jury” … it’s the lawyers strategy

[@EquineWelfareAndBehavior]

She can’t describe the pain of being held down and punched in the face. Makes it really hard to believe it happened. I can remember and still feel every traumatic injury I’ve gotten in my life. The only injury she says she felt was the headbutt but JD’s side makes sense with her diagnosis on that. It’s frustrating because if she was abused, I want her to just tell us what happened. But this whole extraordinary storyline she concocts, especially the Australia incident, just takes away all her credibility.

[@8BitZ0mbie]

She was in a rotten relationship and she tried to profit off of it. She also seems to be an ugly person and is willing to put on a terrible performance to try to ruin a mans life. At least depp just told his story. He didn’t try to ham it up for public sorrow. She has been caught in innumerable lies, got 14 million dollars, and still thinks she deserves more. She has no evidence for her claims. In fact, her evidence is in contradiction with her story

[@reagannix115]

I feel like it's a little sussy that she said the lawsuit is the most painful thing she has ever gone thru, remind me again, isn't she claiming to have been savagely abused by Johnny? Feels like that would be more painful of an experience if it really happened

[@Ripcraze]

she has probably been killed like 5 times by now, must be horrible. At least from the stories she has told us... No one would survive these fights against a stronger opponent and walk out injury free every time, insanity.

[@R_A120]

She is testifying to the entire world in real time accounts of domestic abuse and rape, accounts that will be recorded and be available to view forever online, with the full knowledge that no matter what she says their will be countless people who will forever see her as a cartoon villain Sounds pretty brutal to me

[@bodman1]

0:15 Lawyer: "Now, why are you here?" Heard: "I am here because my ex-husband is suing me for an op-ed I wrote." It's so ridiculously funny that she says that within the first few seconds of being on the stand after the defense tried so hard earlier to get the case dismissed on the notion that she DIDN'T write the article...

[@arr165]

Lmao, I didn't even catch that, she's so lost in the sauce

[@ProjectileGrommet]

@@arr165 lauced in the sost

[@isabelleshoe147]

I think she said it again later too! she's a fool

[@minopoke]

The defense tried to say she didn’t write the title of the article - that was written by WashPo. Everyone knows she wrote the op-ed itself and no one is debating that.

[@bodman1]

@@minopoke Wait really? I thought that almost hour-long back-and-forth arguement for dismissal between the parties was Heard's team arguing she didn't write the article, but that someone else wrote it and that her name was attached to it. You're telling me it was all to do with the mere title of the article?

[@michelelindor]

The Mad Hatter, Gilbert Grape, Sweeney Todd, Johnny Crybaby Walker, Grindelwald, Edward Scissorhands, Ichabod Crane, Whitey Bulger… this man has a PLETHORA of good acting roles and is overlooked because he’s a *character actor*. Hasan…. Dude… Did they not have blockbuster in Turkey growing up?

[@AK-jm1sc]

But...he acts exactly the same in most of those movies?

[@michelelindor]

@@AK-jm1sc ……. No he doesn’t.

[@tbohn10]

@@AK-jm1sc hes not ryan reynolds

[@bravo561]

@@AK-jm1sc Crane does not act the same Edward Scissorhands

[@calebkent6706]

What do you mean by “character actor” is that like a “method actor”

[@Rawsclaws]

I don’t think Hassan realizes how prominent Johnny Depp actually is because?????? I could easily name 5 movies he’s in. He’s very versatile and I’m just gonna assume he’s only seen Pirates 💀✋🏽

[@evanjuleen]

He's literally one of the biggest movie stars in the world, even before Pirates. He's up there w Leo Decaprio and Brad Pitt. I agree w you completely.

[@megsztr]

Exactly from the top of my head I’d say Willy wonka, alice in wonderland, scissorhands, that headless rider movie

[@MrForbiddenSin]

He is the actor which allowed Tim Burton to jump from animations to movies. Edward Scisorhands was the carrier starter for Tim as full lenght producer.

[@finalflash98]

DOnny Brasco!!??? willy wonka!! like cmon. Im by no means a johny depp stan but these movies are iconic and the roles couldnt be more different.

[@anapaulapedro7025]

Right, when ppl mention Alice in the wonderland, I think of the live action, that movie is so iconic, he did great as the mad hatter

[@manuelpatino7863]

She's such a terrible actress, no wonder they made the psych go before her.

[@MrForbiddenSin]

2:30:45 She had a bond with his kids xD ... Yeah mocking their mother, harrassing their father. This is literally the boat trip after which JD daughter wrote a letter to him that she hates AH

[@TheMcBeefy]

I can't believe the shit Aquaman must be going thru. Also, for an actress playing a waterbender, Amber sure has a hard time bending some tears out those crazy eyeballs

[@tbohn10]

DC is having a rough time. Good thing flash is destroying their universe before the actor got this ball rolling too. Good excuse to drop everything if need be

[@21jd_]

warner bros in general. fantastic beasts 3 made the least money of all hp movies

[@muhammadkhan2439]

Theres a reason why johnny has been casted in currently every pirates of the carribean, is because he was basically born for the role. Cant imagine anyone else in that role

[@MrForbiddenSin]

Jack Sparrow carried the movies. Was the only character that was recognizable from the PoC series. Orlando Bloom is the main character but nobody gives a shit

[@MaMastoast]

@@MrForbiddenSin I actually thought Orlando Bloom did a pretty good job, but you're right, Jack Sparrow obviously stole the show.

[@anapaulapedro7025]

Johnny drank a MEGA pint of tea

[@enatyung8397]

‘This is being weaponised by incels’ YES!! This. Not ALL women are liars etc and those takes are deeply rooted in misogyny

[@nogb8367]

you sound like the same incels who cry not all men when you're crying not all women when the script is turned

[@cassondralynch6342]

You can't expect incels to not be fucking insane. A woman could sneeze and they'd take issue. Fuck those dudes. On the bright side and speaking as a woman, the metoo movement moved the pendulum a little too far and now it's going back a bit. Makes sense and needed to happen.

[@BareBandSubscription]

You people realize that women like Amber Heard are a major reason why misogyny even exists in a progressive, first-world society in 2022, right? Who cares if incels are weaponizing this? Radical feminists weaponize the worst of men, too. It isn’t any more or less pathetic and wrong. Get real, for Christ sakes.

[@rosietales]

@@b.d.a.8719 Unfortunately, if you're not following this case, you will think she is the victim and JD the aggressor because the media only releases news about Amber being a "victim" aka telling lies. Even here in my country the news are in favor of her.

[@JaseekaRawr]

Lol it says there's 6 replies, but only one showing 😆 I guess the incels found your comment, but YT censored them. Nothing of value was lost lol tbh 😬

[@montselech]

Mort Rainey (Secret Window) Edward Scissorhands Ichabod Crane (Sleepy Hollow) William Blake (Dead Man) Joseph D. Pistone (Donnie Brasco) Gilbert Grape John Dillinger (Public Enemies) Just to mention A FEW of Johnny Depp's best roles WITHOUT Captain Jack Sparrow.

[@LebonezLive]

Don't forget Sweeney Todd

[@montselech]

@@LebonezLive I didn't, I didn't mention it bc I know a lot of ppl shit on his singing and ending... I love that movie and his singing, also I just meant to put a short list not like every role he has played. 😊

[@hallycavallone4452]

@@montselech sweeney todd is my absolute favoriteeeee movie. People either love it of hate it. I have never meet someone that said thats movie was just ok.

[@evanjuleen]

Yeah don't forget us theater nerds. 😅 Corpse Bride and dark shadows too.

[@dimwitdove3813]

my guy literally made his debut in one of the most iconic horror films of all time and has one of the most iconic death scenes of all time. like, hasan what????

[@djtoxicdhg]

The reason why they were asking her all these absolute lay up softball questions 99% of the time was strictly so people could feel attached to her get to understand where she's coming from And to potentially Woo over the crowd even though it has literally nothing to do with the circumstance at hand but the circumstance at hand like no one needed to know what college she went to Nobody needed to know what she used to do for a living Before she became an actor no one needs to know that she used to do charity work It's all just a bunch of stuff to make her seem like a good person when she's clearly not.

[@bsimms583]

It's a direct examination, your attorneys always ask you softball questions. Your own attorney isn't going drag you through the coals.

[@Snarl_Marx]

Cross examination is where it really gets fun!

[@jokersmith9096]

Every important witness gets background questions to make sure the jury knows more about them

[@boots1622fan]

why didn't they object to that? w depp it was 'hearsay hearsay hearsay' but not once did they call her on relevance...

[@JaseekaRawr]

Seriously, there's *no shot* she was doing soup kitchen every morning in her high school days 😆😆😆 the liesss lmaooo

[@YouMeWeUsHere]

As someone who studied law, one thing our professors always told us to look out for when it came to descriptions of DV, is tone, expression, and detail. Especially detail. When explaining what the ab*se consisted, usually a survivor gives the detail what the *pain* felt like. i.e., The heat and/or the sting , the pressures and/or numbness, the static, ringing in their ears, the smell and tastes of fluids if any around, etc. She kept saying she didn't remember any of those things, and that was a red flag in itself. As a DV survivor myself, I remember every single moment and all those sensations even years later. Her testimony and all the minuet details she constantly throws in her narrations are strange, and the way her lawyers question people are so often disingenuous. This case is so wild, and I'm gonna be so interested in seeing what jurors come forward and speak about this once it's over.

[@YouMeWeUsHere]

I also wanna say, I do believe that Johnny was absolutely emotionally abusive to her when he wasn't sober and as fed up as he could get, but rarely, if ever, physically abusive to her. Dissolving herself of almost every bit of wrongdoing and framing it as this fragile young minded soul who fell for the millionaire monster who beat her on a regular basis instead of taking accountability for her wrongdoings is damning and a horrid tactic from her lawyers to lead with. There's so much that could be said about this case, but there's never gonna be a way to cover every base of it because it will continue to develop even when it's over.

[@YouMeWeUsHere]

Also also, another key point in her narrations. In most DV cases, survivors tend to speed through the explanation of the violence perpetrated on them because of the difficulty of the memory and the desire to get it out there so they're not forced to keep reliving it. Her slowing down numerous times, and still not expressing what physically senses she experienced is once again a red flag. Johnny did admit that he destroyed the trailer that night in this court case, but the details she added are hella dodgy.

[@DaleSmith816]

JD not even looking at her the whole time and the trial means a lot to me.

[@Mydogslove2laugh]

If he did he could be accused of intimidation

[@DaleSmith816]

@@Mydogslove2laugh Truth. Look up Janine Driver, she reads body language and she is the Owner & President of the Body Language Institute. She did some of Amber testimony. We all know shes a bad actress.

[@tbohn10]

Thats what you took away from this? Lol

[@Mydogslove2laugh]

@@tbohn10 no, but it was brought up by the fabulous Emily D Baker who I am watching the trial with.

[@Mydogslove2laugh]

@@DaleSmith816 I will.

[@CrimeaRiver]

1:20 - "This is the most painful and difficult thing I've ever gone through." More painful and difficult than regularly being beaten and abused by an insane partner, you say?

[@bodman1]

You don't say... 🤔

[@MourningCoffeeMusic]

Objection, hearsay

[@davidknevel2898]

It is more painful to relive trauma in front of the world, than it would be while you're rationalizing it happening in real time.

[@glamourousbox8168]

@@davidknevel2898 yea but she has done it before? in the UK trial and keeps talking about it I get she could have trauma but also I think somhing physical would hurt a lot more

[@tbohn10]

@@MourningCoffeeMusic sustained

[@christhornycroft3686]

Johnny Depp has given some excellent performances film wise. Don Juan De Marco is great, but it’s basically him playing himself. Gilbert Grape, Ed Wood, Finding Neverland, all top notch performances. And that doesn’t include his goofy character roles like Scissorhands, Pirates and others. Pirates is hardly his best performance. Before this trial, I had forgotten how many great roles he’s had. Obviously it matters more if he assaulted someone, but the guy had no prior history of violence or abuse. She does. You don’t go from being an angel according to all his exes to a violent monster at 58 unless you have dementia and if her lawyers can prove that, fine. To hell with him if he’s smacking around and sexually assaulting women. But all the evidence points to her being the abuser.

[@teetee996112]

Sweeney Todd, Charlie and the chocolate factory, and corpse bride too

[@thedeathofreason]

@@teetee996112 Charlie wasn't that great. People leave out fear and loathing too often. One of his best performances. But he loved Hunter S. Thompson personally so it's not surprising.

[@teetee996112]

@@thedeathofreason understandable it's not everyone's cup of tea, it's a very odd retelling and somehow is the closest to the book, I wanna know wtf Ronald Dahl was on while writing it

[@lyd5398]

I have the jabberwocky tattooed on my arm because of his role as mad hatter.

[@virajmhapsekar2977]

How does everyone forget Rango?

[@GratefulDave93]

Whenever I’ve seen others do psychedelics and MDMA, not me, but others in a group - the baseline is a cuddle puddle. But Amber is seriously implying JD wanted to break a girls wrist and attacked her while taking these drugs??

[@cassondralynch6342]

Cuddle puddle lol. Cute. And you're so right. You could give Ted Bundy shrooms and he'd probably be like, do I really wanna be a killer lol.

[@CaptainSuspenders]

Long term drug abusers have like broken brains, esp opiate addicts. Not saying it definitely happened but it's not unheard of.

[@Allah_Snackbar]

lol, when I take MD the last thing I wanna do es being violent xD

[@cassondralynch6342]

@@CaptainSuspenders We're not talking about all drugs. Not all drugs are created equal. Psychedelics in particular have healing effects on the brain and MDMA is fine in moderation and can also be therapeutic. That's why there's medical clinics for both.

[@johnd3687]

@@cassondralynch6342 it seems like you might misunderstand drugs, and the effects they have on the brain.

[@baconboi5316]

im sorry but ive never gotten rocked and gone "man this floor is fuckin nasty" like what kind of reaction is that to getting hit i understand shock but you focus on getting hit and trying to get back up or hit back you dont sit there and just think about the floor

[@emalover16]

That damn dirty carpet 🤣

[@99RedRedfake]

Exaggerated though her testimony may be, it is actually a pretty realistic depiction of reactions to abuse. It matches up with the kinds of recollections from actual abuse victims. It is called dissociation. If this is all a complete fabrication, which is possible, she did do her research.

[@baconboi5316]

@@99RedRedfake yeah I’ve dealt with it and disassociation is definitely helpful at least it was for me but I never focused on anything I always just went to a zone of nothing but that definitely could just have been a specific to me thing

[@99RedRedfake]

@@baconboi5316 So sorry to hear that! But for sure, everyone reacts differently. Her testimony is credible, even if likely untrue. I have heard similar stories about wall paint and weird smells.

[@baconboi5316]

@@99RedRedfake if she didn’t put so much of her acting career into the testimony I would believe it but there’s so much against her especially with her trying to downplay her importance and make it seem like Johnny had so much power because there is so many tapes and evidence pointing against it

[@adithimenon4984]

Well, it's more than that. He has the ability to play characters that are odd and obscure, and he does it well. Not just Cap Jack Sparrow, he's versatile. If you haven't watched What's Eating Gilbert Grape, Sleepy Hollow, Edward Scissor Hands, Sweeny Todd, or Alice In Wonderland.

[@andyvargas7142]

Or chocolat

[@markantrobus8782]

He cried. He's crying. Her delivery is forced. Lacking depth. You feel safe with Johnny's testimony. And feel bluffed by her. If you have ever experienced a bluffer and BS artist you recognise the vibe in Amber's testimony.

[@JaseekaRawr]

Fr, her vibe is just... Way off. It's off-putting. She's a "BS artist" lol, in more ways than one. 😆

[@milesfurther4395]

I think she’s trying too hard because she’s nervous, not a crime

[@TheNinjapancake14]

Super weird to see most of the comments getting mad at Hasan for saying Johnny is a bad actor, considering the contents of the video

[@Dione9000]

My issue is that she says she knows no one is supposed to hit someone and yet she was arrested and charged with DV in the past and is on recording saying she hit him and she wouldn't cheat on him but she slept with elon idnt understand how she can lie and we have recordings

[@cctomcat321]

Chat: "Objection! Sustained. Overruled. Sidebar. Guilty! Speculation. Hearsay! Bailiff. Briefcase. Disregard. In my chambers. Stop beavering the witness. I rest. We could totally be lawyers."

[@philipfrisk805]

I'm a broke-ass retired college writing instructor, who worked part-time, temporary gigs for some 37 years. I'm in here. You have got to love Hasanabi Piker: socialist, down-to-earth real, highly intelligent and educated, and a tremendously appealing personality. And he is hilarious.

[@dawasherpa8342]

This post-trump era has been sorely in need of comedy, thanks Amber😮‍💨

[@carolinecoy3164]

she just said, I was walking away, he slapped be around the face, then I turned to look at him? huh. how did he slap her across the face if she was walking away though 🤣🤣

[@MourningCoffeeMusic]

I love that whole point to this testimony is to do damage control for her character while further defaming Johnny. It’s kinda funny that this is a defamation lawsuit and Amber is using her time for further defamation.

[@bladesqueen5201]

the best defense for defamation is proving it to be true; its the default defense unless you don't think you can prove it.

[@skybear17]

IVE NEVER WATCHED PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN, HES A GREAT ACTOR IN EVERY MOVIE IVE SEEN OF HIS WTF😭😭😭

[@politicsplant]

same here, never watched it and he’s one of my favorite actors lmao 🫠🤣

[@scoobertmcruppert2915]

Debate perverts that actually read = Lawyers

[@pinkcatacombs]

LMFAO

[@bravo561]

I’m really trying to parse out whether this is the misogyny that’s been indoctrinated into me my whole life( I.E. not believing victims) or whether she’s just THAT bad at lying. Cause this shit is CORNY

[@frogdrug8282]

Well one thing I can say confidently is abuse victims dont go around saying they’ll donate the money they won, from their abuse case, to organizations that help victims of abuse & then not donate it to said organizations. Keep it to yourself & go sleep with a billionaire make him donate his own personal money to cover it up

[@noellethomas2589]

As an unironic man hating lesbian, I also think this shit is corny lmao. She's bad

[@skeleton1337]

@@frogdrug8282 good point lol

[@Ak1996feb]

Bro she is just bad actress.

[@MaMastoast]

If anything I think we're more likely not to believe Johnny on that account since we're taught that men are aggressors and women are victims, especially in these sorta situations.

[@tylerhackner9731]

I don’t feel bad for amber at all

[@marcelcjr9313]

I don’t either, Johnny too

[@LosFace24]

Johnny is a has been actor who took in another mentally unstable human being. These are rich people problems

[@tabycat273]

"he's not a perfect victim" is right on the money!

[@888claimthisenergynow]

shes not a perfect victim either tho

[@llamaczech]

Ok, but you'd have to be real stupid or wilfully ignorant to not recognise a high profile case of someone lying about abuse and piggybacking the MeToo movement to bring her into the public eye (she set herself up as an ambassador for domestic abuse ffs) would be damaging to the credibility of other women coming out against high profile abusers.

[@Luvumj2]

I loved him in edward scissorhand, Gilbert grape, Benny and Joon, Sweeney Todd.. Chocolate. I think he’s a great actor. Stop putting down people.

[@ColieBear18]

I love Benny and Joon. I feel like no one ever talks about that movie

[@CChissel]

The Rum Diary movie is okay, but the book is fucking great. I read it about 15 years ago and still remember almost everything in it, definitely worth reading if you enjoy Hunter Thompsons work.

[@chickensalad7199]

This!

[@iammyself7885]

She's trying to portray sadness but it comes across more like her being annoyed. The facial expressions she's doing look deliberate and last longer than they would in reality. There' no flushing, no tears, no snot running. There's lots of tiny details she adds that don't matter in what the big picture is that she's trying to portray, and it's indicative of liars to exaggerate and to include needless details. She's faking this so hard. In the meantime Johnny is sitting there hiding his face and tries to wipe tears away with a napkin quickly because he's of course embarrassed to be crying and sad to be listening to her accusations

[@MaMastoast]

I dunno if JD was crying or just had some kinda allergy or something, because he seemed entirely fine at other times. But yea she's clearly acting, and not well. All her expressions are so deliberate it's pretty darn cringy. As you said, she's trying to contort her face into troubled and upset expressions, but there's no reddening in her face, no swelled eyes, nothing.. Also note her cringy choice of words tha often sound like they're from a bad movie script.

[@Maryyeung12894]

Not once did she actually cry? There’s just so much heresay normally I’d be inclined to believe the woman but there’s a lot of actual evidence on Johnny’s side and a history of abuse from Heard.

[@CChissel]

And she has contradicted herself from the time in her UK court testimony, several times.

[@bigdaddypapsmear]

Please reconsider being inclined to feel one way or the other. Women act like this way more than people realize. Most women are also way better at manipulation than most men. Hasan mentioned he has been through something similar. I have too. Likely some of the men in your life have too.

[@macdaddy_mattie]

@@bigdaddypapsmear everyone has the capacity to be an abuser. I’d argue instead of gender, behaviors should be examined to determine likelihood of abusive tendencies

[@tellmesomething2412]

Exactly. Unfortunately, the defense can't find all their evidence to be admissible in court.

[@cctomcat321]

If she did cry, people would be saying she's faking, hamming it up, "white woman tears", etc. Not a defense of her, I'm just saying I don't think it would have played well, either way. Or it would have garnered criticism, either way.

[@DumbMonsta]

Jhonny Depp is not a great actor is the worst take Hassan has ever made

[@gypsylee333]

I think his worst take is his trans women in women's sports take. "Who cares about women's sports anyways? I don't so I don't care if it's ruined."

[@goobadoob]

He and Will have had even worse movie takes on Fear and Malding.

[@DumbMonsta]

@@gypsylee333 Oh I agree with you he didn’t even try to make an argument 😂😂😂😂 he just “Well me like trans women soo they should compete yeah thats the take!”

[@gypsylee333]

@@DumbMonsta exactly! I don't get why trans women can't compete with the cis men, that's who they have more in common with physically- which is what matters in sports, not feelings. Everyone knows they're trans anyway if they compete with women. There's no valid reason they can't play with the boys. Sorry for the tangent lol that one gets to me. Also Johnny is awesome I had the biggest crush on him in Crybaby.

[@DumbMonsta]

@@gypsylee333 well remember that after taking horromones they lose physical strength so they end up kinda en between Male and Female physical strength Its a weird situation to be in to be honest but Hassan isn’t even trying to solve it

[@MrForbiddenSin]

Looking on how much AH is documenting she has almost nothing... that is actually telling a lot... JD "was the abuser", the abusers do not usually gather evidence like that... especially if you're the person that wanted to end the relationship multiple times and just GFTO. In the presented scenario and he has much more, photos, recording, texts, medical records of her abusing him, if we took the narration that he was the abuser he would need to dig out staff that he never would need or never thought he will need... While she was the abused one and she has almost no proof? Even the police was testifing against her. They are rich, they have cameras all over their mansions, private secuirty, paparazzis sleeping in the bushes and nothing? Even AHs manhating energy psychologist admited that AH was hitting JD.

[@tcurry1531]

Amber is telling the story of Johnny walking out on her abuse, she takes everyones sad stories and makes it like its her own story.

[@MourningCoffeeMusic]

According to all her former partners it’s something she’s always done.

[@tbohn10]

She verbatim quoted JD in parts of her testimony, it didnt feel genuine to me.

[@CodeeXD]

Didn't she also quote a bunch of movies and is copying people's hairstyle and dress further proving she's got bpd

[@MaMastoast]

@@CodeeXD I don't know if the direct movie quotes thing is true.. I can understand why people would think that thought, since she's speaking very much like a movie monogue..

[@boots1622fan]

She kept playing the "I'm a woman" card and then says "Men don't cry" like, excuse me, who is the sexist here? Saying men crying is weird. I bet she fully believes that shit probably why she thought she was justified in beating him the whole thing is just like. her weird toxic masculinity thing she's putting on him, getting all mad that he doesn't hit back. ugh

[@BlueRidgeBubble]

Misandry is as real as misogyny Left wing thinkers just use a hierarchy of oppression to color their thoughts But I do not think that ideological crap necessarily colors actual real life, it couldn't Ideologies create ways of looking at the world that justify their beliefs

[@boots1622fan]

@@BlueRidgeBubble Please don't act like it's real leftists supporting Heard. We don't claim radfems.

[@BlueRidgeBubble]

@@boots1622fan Unfortunately, ya do

[@boots1622fan]

@@BlueRidgeBubble I don't. Not supporting victims goes against feminism point blank. Gender roles are the only reason she's getting away with this. not to MENTION the harm she's doing to lgbtq women who have also been harmed by women.

[@williamcozart8158]

Johnny was good in Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas Hasan. I mean the drugs he was taking to do the "method acting" thing were doing the majority of the "acting" work for him there.. but hey, he was good at doing those drugs.

[@CChissel]

Well, he did live with Thompson for about a year, so you can’t not get good at doing drugs when you’re with Hunter S. Thompson.

[@williamcozart8158]

@@CChissel Thompson hated Johnny 😂

[@williamcozart8158]

@@CChissel Imagine living with someone who's studying your every movement and impersonating you for a year.. I'd hate em too probably.

[@thedeathofreason]

@@williamcozart8158 wtf are you talking about? Literally every piece of dialogue and record ever between the two indicates they had a bizarre, but deep friendship. Thompson used to call Depp in the middle of the night just to talk to him. Thompson didn't 'hate' JD.

[@williamcozart8158]

@@thedeathofreason Yeah I know they were actually friends but Thompson said a bunch of times that he hated Johnny after he lived with him. You can hate friends and still be friends with them.

[@wincocinco12]

you don't have to be a fan of jonhhy depp but to say that he isn't a good actor is just a lazy perception of him to have .

[@cassondralynch6342]

It's a poor one and so is his assumptions that he's this insufferable, toxic partner. Alright, dude.

[@allier1867]

i do like your take on this. While I do want JD to win, he might not tbh. I actually do think some, if not many times JD had moments of reactive abuse. he is only human and reactive abuse is a VERY REAL thing.

[@davincineptune]

Naw please, that logically doesn't even make sense. So she can do 1000 things to him and he only had to do 1. Nope, sorry that's a load of bs.

[@allier1867]

@@davincineptune I'm not saying I agree with how unfair it is. but 'equally abusive' is not a real thing. 'reactive abuse' is tho.

[@BlueRidgeBubble]

@@allier1867 Then it should be a thing, there's a weight to actions A thousand grains of sand will always weigh more than one You cannot, on any intellectual, claim that grain of sand is the same as the thousand If the single instance of abuse were extreme, sure But it does not appear to have happened that way She cut off the tip of his finger lol

[@emilylhirsch]

when Hasan said name 5 movies i named 20 johnny is a tier 1 actor

[@R_A120]

Since 2011 all his movies apart from Pirates where he is the star, have flopped at the box office, and all those movies including Pirates got mid tier to awful reviews

[@gypsylee333]

She's so fake acting during that part where she says he gave her a cavity search 🙄 OMG she just wiped her eyes when there's no tears! 😂

[@bofadeez8480]

2:15:30 Tbf my uncle has had severe drinking problems and would hit me regularly. I used to just tell my mom he would act funny instead of the whole truth because I was scared. So her saying "not towards me" could've been her trying to downplay his aggression because she loves him and is scared to tell the truth/make him look bad. Not saying 100% but speaking from my own experience it's just something to think about.

[@awesomeguyat7771]

Defecation trial

[@offthebooktv3646]

Bruh he trippin johnny is in alotta great movies as the lead, gilbert grape, blow, fear n loathing, public enemies hes crazy good

[@megsztr]

Forget Johnny, Amber, the witnesses, attorney… I WANNA SEE THE JURY’S FACES WHEN THEY REACT TO THIS SOAP OPERA😂Like are they buying this shit or rolling their eyes like the rest of us

[@worldview6218]

Lmao man she’s such a liar. She testified that when filming kissing scenes there is a professional courtesy not to use tongue and all this other nonsense and she then testified that during that kissing scene jd grabbed her face and kissed her and used tongue and all this other bs, but just out of curiosity I went and took a peek just to see if she was even remotely credible and looked at the kissing scene in question and it’s LITERALLY the exact opposite of what she testified to lol. She is the one almost awkwardly at first slipping tongue and she was the one who grabbed his face.

[@MrSparklytuxedocat]

Is there a clip on KZbin?

[@nine9nine9]

WAIT really?!?

[@ultimamage3]

Sauce?

[@franknstein5376]

I mean, even if he did they could have easily done different cuts for that scene and the director could have chosen another where it didn't happen. Anyway all of this is so fucked up: on one hand she has been proven to lie again and again, and to have been abuseive towards Depp. On another at least some of the incidences she described (like in the plane) occured, and that type of sexual assault would be a monstrous thing to lie about...

[@ciellouise8153]

they probably filmed multiple takes of this

[@efrainlagunas]

1:00:46 ... well I forgot this little golden nugget of Amber Heard admitting she finds men crying "It's weird" and says it in the most toxic aggressive manner she could. For crying out loud, she practically snarls it out. More and more, Dr. Curry seems to have called it. I hope on cross examination they question this because this could be the real cause as to why Amber went from idolizing Johnny to seeing him as garbage.

[@Virgox222]

24:30 I almost cried laughing at has response to the chatter hahahaha

[@sophiea6917]

but hasan, you went ridiculous for a second there.. like, name 5 roles/ movies with JD, you just like Jack Sparrow... Edward Scissorhands, Willy Wonka in Charlie and the Chocolate factory, Tarrant Hightopp in Alice in the wonderland and the sequel Alice throgh the looking glass, he did Chocolat, Finding Neverland, he was the voice of Rango, Victor in Corpse Bride, he produced the movie Hugo, he did the wolf in into the woods, he was in murder on the orient expressed, starred in the 1st and 2nd fantastic beasts and yes, he did 5 of the 6 pirates of the caribbean (and these are the famous ones)

[@MaMastoast]

I think that list of roles demonstrates why he probably shouldnt be considered a great actor. Is Jack Sparrow amazing? Absolutely, but the rest of the performances you mentioned aren't all that impressive I think... He's rarely if ever bad, but I don't think he's a top tier actor in terms of acting talent.. He's very charismatic of course.

[@sophiea6917]

@@MaMastoast oh I didn't say whether he was talented or not... Nor I expressed my opinion on the matter.. just saying, it's not like he only did one character... And yes, I would say the characters he enterpreted were very extravagant and well written and he brought them to life with his performances (also because he's charismatic and genuinely funny)... Am I saying he could do every character because he's a very skilled actor? I wouldn't go that far.

[@ReddCinema]

HASAN DOES NOT MISS ❤️

[@Jonnyisspurlock]

Other than his take on Johnny depp literally only being jack sparrow, let’s not forget he was Willy wonka, the mad hatter, Edward scissor hands, many main characters in Tim burtons animations, let’s not forget the Kevin James classic TUSK, I am just beginning. It’s clear Hassan is wrong here.

[@SteezySteve760]

He misses every day

[@brycemedvin8765]

Okay buddy I love Has but that's just wrong

[@TheNinjapancake14]

21:26 Hollywood people really are the theater kids that get money

[@HokadoKong]

I absolutely love that she was trying to pull a Depp at the beginning but it sounded so insincere that I thought she was trying to pull a Rittenhouse

[@silentstormshadow2755]

I used to be in the “it’s mutual abuse” party, but the more info that comes out and previous recordings (including the insane deposition she did in 2016), the more obvious it is that Amber is the aggressor here.

[@PlebianGorilla]

Sweeney Todd, Edward Scissorhands, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, Pirates, Alice in Wonderland, The Secret Window, What’s Eating Gilbert Grape, Blow, Crybaby, Transcendence, The Tourist, 21 Jump Street, etc. I’ve seen him in a lot of stuff, and I always enjoy his characters. I definitely consider him a talented actor. I think Hasan just hasn’t seen many of their films and projects that onto others. But I also am a simp for Johnny 😂 part of that is BECAUSE he’s a good actor, though.

[@zuribeboo1329]

I like how her lawyers are trying to prove how she didn't write the op-ed when the first few sentences are literally " my husband is suing me because of an op-ed I wrote" ok so did she not write it or what 💀💀she just made herself unreliable in that moment

[@victoriaisamermaid9938]

First amber chapter : ”Dirty Carpet and an Old Mans Tears”

[@tellmesomething2412]

Man, I'm confused, because there's too many lies, and possible truths.

[@vanniee_]

Hey, I gotta disagree, johnny is a really amazing actor. Five movies that you should watch in which his acting was more than exceptional other than pirates. Edward scissor hands Alice in wonderland Sweenie Todd Secret window Sleepy hollow Bonus: Dark shadows There are so many more great movies he's been in and I didn't include his voice animations.

[@Valkyraw]

Jesus i cant watch this. Hasan has so many issues. He cant concentrate on the video. He doesnt pay attention and then says "I dont know what to say about it." If he does a reaction to it and wants to give his opinion on it, he should focus on it and not on something else.

[@d33pseacreature]

she always looks up at johnnys like she’s trying to see his reaction

[@MaMastoast]

She's constantly scanning her entire audience, it's part of why it feels like she's just straight up acting.

[@judityrezendes7244]

Top 5 Johnny performances as an actor 1. Jack Sparrow 2. Edward Scissorhands 3. Sweeney Todd 4. Willy Wonka 5. The Mad Hater (Honorable mentions) Rango

[@bewarethefishwives4131]

Not going to lie, having been in an abusive relationship this is making my throat clench up. This behavior is very much on point

[@SuperLazyllama]

I have a question about the picture of the Bruise on her arm. In that same incident she says she was hit in the face multiple times. But her fact didn't even look red. Even if it doesn't leave a bruise getting hit in the face will definitely make you red.

[@franknstein5376]

Not for long or a lot, depending on the hit though, so it depends

[@SuperLazyllama]

@@franknstein5376 sure if it if just one hit . But she said multiple times. You are going to have some amount of lingering Redness. It's just a little suspect that for someone who records and documents as much as she does. We basically never see a video or picture , that fully backs up what she is saying. Edit : just wanted to add. I don’t think this is some kind of smoking gun or anything. I want to hear out her whole story , but it’s just another inconsistency.

[@tellmesomething2412]

@@franknstein5376 She's taking pictures after every "physical incident," recording conversations during every argument and reporting to therapist at the first given chance, but you think she waited to take the picture after being "beaten"?

[@MrForbiddenSin]

Those bruises look like somebody would grab you by the arms to make you stop throwing punches. If he would pin her the bruising would be not present on the side of the arms but on the front and/or back. If the bruises are located on the sides that means he pinned her arms to her body to block her flailing.

[@franknstein5376]

@@SuperLazyllama Yeah I see your point, I was talking from personal experience (doing combat sports) but was not taking into account also that she is much lighter than me skin tone wise so it would show more easily on her. Her problem is that even if these incidents happened, between her previous lies, the evidence of *her* abuse towards Depp, and her obvious tendency to embellish her recounts she is incredibly difficult to trust. I don't know though, it's just that I can't even imagine completely making up stuff like this (especially the sa, which was horrific), so I automatically give her the benefit of the doubt

[@poisonive45454]

Johnny is a great actor.

[@lostnconfuse2009]

Apart from the slaps this woman described my previous relationship. Physiological abuse is abuse. After a while I became reactive abusive. You can only push someone so far before they start pushing back

[@nGUNNARp]

if you find yourself identifying with amber, get help

[@Grrrld]

21 jump street, Edward scissor hands, what's eating Gilbert grape, Charlie and the chocolate factory, nightmare before christmas

[@Whatever-ew4ti]

There's no way this is gonna look likeable to the jury

[@tcurry1531]

She was head over heels in love with Johnny's money.

[@a-a-rom]

sometimes when chat interrupts a thought Hasan is having to be shitlords it's really annoying, like at 1:05:30 , Hasan was just making an excellent point (starting at 1:05:17 ) that he doesn't like the idea of a perfect victim, that he doesn't like the expectation of needing to be a perfect victim in order to be taken seriously as a victim, is interrupted by a shitlord chatter making a highlighted comment just to say his opinion doesn't matter, completely derailing the whole thing, which was an excellent point being made.

[@esfesfaeffaefawfwf5828]

For anyone not to be on Johny's side at this point (If they've actually payed attention to the case) is honestly obserd..

[@MaMastoast]

I think you can sit anyone down her have them watch her testimony and they're realise she's lying.. I mean she's simply not a very good actor.

[@hellitself8448]

She knows she won't be able to provide physical violence, so she goes for the psychological one. But, she is just destroying her credibility, like how in the hell would u care about your feelings while ur allegedly life threatened.

[@markantrobus8782]

The repetitive phrases give her away. Also "y'know... y'know" she even shakes her head in a "no" when affirming a negative

[@AlicEknowsBest1]

U want me to believe someone like Amber, who, btw, DID NOT EVEN DISCLOSE all of the contents of her phone?? Only what suited her case

[@markantrobus8782]

A jar... A jar... An actual vintage jar. She also did coke according to her therapist.

[@markantrobus8782]

If she had used less emotion. Or drained her delivery of emotion. She might be convincing. And she keeps repeating key phrases.

[@HaloJumper7]

Me whenever I hear Amber Turd: What a liar, dude. **In Hasan's voice**

[@andyvargas7142]

What a weasley little liar dude

[@Room-xi6nb]

The ol' soup kitchen defense. Such do gooder. Much sainthood. Let us canonize her. 😆

[@gagirl1231]

I'm glad Hasan took time to mention how triggering this is for those of us who have experienced abuse. This stuff she's describing is exactly how my mom would treat me when I still lived with my parents. The shifting goal posts she mentions during arguments that make you feel insane really hit home.

[@wynoglia]

Lol right off the bat soup kitchen brownie points

[@markantrobus8782]

"I laughed. I just laughed. I laughed. I laughed. Kind of laughing still"

[@Hypnobong]

Solidarity for all those cabinets out there ✌️

[@robinperini9260]

If she lies about any abuse then you have to discredit all of her testimony! Period!

[@evanjuleen]

😕 Unfortunately for us this is not a criminal trial and 'beyond a reason of a doubt' doesn't apply. If the jury believes that any one of her claims of abuse is valid they could choose to vote for her. They could say if she was hit once she's a battered woman. (🙄ugh gross, I don't think they will, I'm sure society will get her.)

[@cctomcat321]

You need to watch House and learn 3 things. Everybody lies. Everybody lies. Its never Lupas.

[@thelittleleb8037]

he was drinking A LOT of tea *sigh*

[@vallreign]

Johnny depps what’s eating at Gilbert grape and jack and Jill opened my eyes on how serious autism and obesity can be. Great performances way before he did Jack sparrow. Tom Hanson 21 jump st also had serious drug issues brought to my attention. I would highly recommend watching any of those, he is very talented.