How to Make Best-Ever Sweet Cream Ice Cream | America's Test Kitchen

[@PSquared-oo7vq]

It's hard to believe that an extra 24 hours in the freezer makes a difference with those freezer canisters, but it really does. Every time I've failed to get a recipe to churn properly, it's because I only chilled the canister for 24 hours. It's really worth the time.

[@rufusred44]

The Breville Smart Scoop, currently on sale for $399, cools the bowl as the ice cream churns, no need to freeze it in the freezer. You still have to make the custard or ice cream base.

[@matthewwaterhouse9925]

I just keep the container in the freezer at all times. Then I don't have to think about it.

[@firehorsewoman414]

@@matthewwaterhouse9925 Me. too. I have the one on my KitchenAid and it’s permanent home is in the freezer

[@austingwatson]

this is why i got a churn with built-in compressor / freezer. plus i can churn batch after batch, not just one a day.

[@Thi-Nguyen]

When I was a kid, one of my favorite memories is my father making fresh peach ice cream. We would go picking peaches, and when we did that, we KNEW that we were in for peach ice cream sometime in the next week. 🤤

[@tsawy6]

Stone fruit contain plenty of pectin too, which is great for stabilising icecream!

[@Thi-Nguyen]

@@tsawy6 yep! I’ve yet to find any peach ice cream that comes even close. I can’t seem to make it like my father did either, and I use his recipe. Guess it was that extra love that made the difference. 🤭🥰

[@lizm4557]

You should share your peach ice cream recipe! Sounds so yummy!

[@MildredGlutz]

Never heard of sweet cream ice cream before but it sounded so good I made some today. I couldn’t believe there was no vanilla in it. I watched the video several times looking for where I might have missed the addition of vanilla. Didn’t find it, lol. Turned out delish!❤

[@normp3273]

Usually at state fairs you'll see sweet cream ice cream. They are delicious!

[@incog4654]

COLDSTONE CREAMERY sells sweet cream ice cream.

[@kathleenray1827]

Went into the freezer totally full. Comes out with a couple scoops missing! 😂 I can relate! 😂

[@rickyzayshley9686]

Just made this recipe and it's a bonafide hit. By far my best attempt at homemade ice cream. This will be my go-to forever.

[@cloudyview]

Powdered milk - the only way to get more milks per milk! 😄

[@BeautifulKittenOfLove]

Some sweet cream ice cream and some sweet sweet Dan....perfect Sunday.

[@paulgdlmx]

I have been making ice cream for 60 years and this is exceptional, seriously. The flavour and texture are simply the maximum. Thank you whoever developed this recipe.

[@ChristianSouthernGirl]

I have always loved soft serve consistency on real ice cream. I actually usually let my sit and soften up a bit before I eat it. Watching this video made me realize it's because my granddad would make homemade ice cream at home and we always wanted some before he put it in the freezer. It just looked too good not to eat it right away!!!!!

[@Tray8729]

Dan! You are the best!!!✌️

[@UncleDavesKitchen]

I have an ice cream freezer with a compressor so it's ready to churn at any time. I make a lot of ice cream. I pretty much use a similar recipe as this but often will add 5 egg yolks to make frozen custard, too. I play with the add ins, vanilla and spices.

[@jvallas]

Do you cook it?

[@bigboldbicycle]

I always add egg yolk to my cooked ice-cream base, so am a bit surprised there's no egg in this recipe. Egg acts as an emulsifier to bind water with fats, as well as thickens the mix, not to mention adds richness to it.

[@UncleDavesKitchen]

@@bigboldbicycle if you add egg it's frozen custard not ice cream.

[@robertcounts5300]

I have been using this: Ingredients: 5 egg yolks 2/3 cup sugar 1 cup half & half or light cream 2 tablespoons butter 1 cup whipping or heavy cream 2 teaspoons vanilla but I will try Dan's!

[@pashawasha47]

I really like how skeptical Bridget looks at the beginning 😂

[@jvallas]

People with an aversion to corn syrup: there's corn syrup and there's high fructose corn syrup. The latter is what you want to avoid. And those who don't want cornstarch - why? Cake flour has cornstarch. Powdered sugar has cornstarch. What is its danger that I don't know about?

[@pobrien864]

Carbohydrates! A far better choice is allulose for texture and avoid the carbs that contribute to type 2 diabetes. Guar gum, locust gum or xanthan gum are far healthier choices for thickeners.

[@bethanywashington1243]

@@pobrien864he is making a recipe that HOME cooks will make they said that in the first couple of seconds of the video. They said home cooks multiple times. What type of home cook had guar gum at home. If you are going to be special ordering all these you may as well buy store brought diet icecream. It would be cheaper. It’s an icecream recipe this is not a health food and if it’s that concerning of every ingredient then just don’t make it.

[@pobrien864]

@@bethanywashington1243 I am a home cook and I regularly stock my pantry with xanthan gum and allulose because over 50 years of overeating carbohydrates means that I no longer tolerate them at all. And what you don’t realize about ‘diet’ ice cream is that the manufacturers have cut out the fat and replaced it with…. carbs that will in fact make you fat if you consume enough of it over time.

[@jvallas]

While I'll probably stick with the ingredients in the recipe, I do appreciate you giving me the information that I can consider in other cooking. Thanks.

[@pobrien864]

Carbohydrates- they all break down into glucose. HFCS is metabolized by the liver and is a major source of the current obesity epidemic.

[@samirhazlehurst8806]

Great tip about the freezer bowl. I will try that. I prefer to save some cream for when the mixture has cooled down to get some uncooked cream flavour, but I don't know if that really makes a difference.

[@SerenitySharesStuff]

Thank you Dan.

[@ArielK1987]

The best song in everyone's eye's. Is the ice cream truck when when drive into your neighborhood.

[@RH-wj4rz]

Ah, a trip down memory lane.

[@gailgodfrey768]

HI, Y E S. !!!!!

[@jvallas]

I actually captured a recording of an ice cream truck way back in the early internet days, just so I could play it every now and then and add it to photo slideshows. It's such a nostalgic thing!

[@lizcademy4809]

I heard the first one of the year today ... playing the chorus of Woody Guthrie's "Union Maid", of all things!

[@kmg7708]

Super silky creamy ice cream. Loved it! Rich vanilla flavor without adding vanilla. Would love to know how to adapt this to be a chocolate sweet cream ice cream.

[@juneshweta]

Sounds like an interesting recipe! When do we add vanilla? Thanks.

[@jeffreywhitaker5154]

This looks delish!!

[@mikiewifnoe360]

It is funny how your temp tester is always exactly at the temp you guys want.

[@brendafain9962]

That thing is super accurate. I bought one and happy I did. A bit pricey, but worth it.

[@CantankerousDave]

They did a q&a years ago explaining that it’s “helped” in editing.

[@jvallas]

Do we really want to sit and watch it rise or fall to the exact temperature?

[@lizcademy4809]

Editing tricks ... just like the "hot" item they pull from the oven never has steam rising, and neither do the pots on the stove.

[@sailormercuryLSR]

Experienced cooks/ chefs have a second sense about these things. In high school my brother was a kitchen hand at a small Italian hole in the wall place that did 50%+ of their business on pizzas. Within 4 months of working there my brother just by sight and smell could tell the precise time things were done and what temp they were it was crazy. Even if I was making a stir-fry in a wok he could read the food better than I could. FFWD 25 years and now he can't hold a candle to me in the kitchen but there was a time when he was amazing.

[@Am56]

Nice Thanks friend

[@keithhepworth4934]

Makes a quart. What’s everyone else eating?

[@gailgodfrey768]

HI, O K !!!!!!!!

[@spellmadam2947]

Exactly

[@HeatherValentineMsFoodie]

Yummy can’t wait ❤❤❤

[@brt5273]

When vanilla is just tooo exotic 😂😂😂

[@jvallas]

Ohhhh right, now come there isn't any?

[@thekahnman]

@@jvallas because vanilla sucks - this recipe is 10 million times better than vanilla ice cream

[@theresaswift9365]

Can you replace the sugar with monk fruit sweetner and sugar free simple syrup for the corn syrup?

[@theresaswift9365]

@sandrah7512 ok thank you. I can't have the sugar or corn syrup for medical reasons so I will skip this.

[@isdeirinnme]

@@theresaswift9365I think I’ve seen monk fruit syrup before? If you can find a sugar alternative but in syrup form it would be worth the experimentation. Just check the ingredients to be sure water wasn’t added to create the syrup product. The syrup reduces the water content and therefore the ice, vs a granular/powdered sweetener that would need to be dissolved in water.

[@GenRN]

I want to try it with Allulose.

[@Strictlybusiness79]

Can you add maple syrup in place of corn syrup for a change in flavor? And liquid nitrogen instead of an ice cream maker? I know they are two very specific substitutions but wondering if it would still work.

[@VeryEvilGM]

I've eaten liquid nitrogen ice creams, and they're super smooth because it turns the ingredients cold so fast, thus minimising the crystal formation.

[@Strictlybusiness79]

@@VeryEvilGM yes, I have had several times as well. Usually the recipes I have used have been eggs. Wondering how this particular recipe with corn starch would work

[@VeryEvilGM]

@Strictlybusiness79 I'm just guessing that swapping from corn syrup to maple syrup would change flavour, yes. But texture wise I have no idea what would happen, maple syrup seems bit more runny compared to stiff corn syrup.

[@sociopathmercenary]

Liquid nitrogen always works. I think you'd want to reduce the maple syrup to get more moisture out of it first

[@bufar]

Maple syrup usually can't be swapped for corn syrup 1-for-1 but you can probably try other ratios until you find what works best

[@LARKXHIN]

glad to see a thumbnail where it doesn't look like Dan is about to burst into tears

[@alan11121959]

Has anyone tried using instant starch like Thick It (common in healthcare) in place of cornstarch? That would replace the cooking time and keep the ingredients cold.

[@vinalipatel]

Actually I have. It works the same. Also vanilla custard powder will work as well.

[@frankpeter6851]

My local health food store sells guar gum in bulk. a quarter teaspoon of that will do the same thing with no heat.

[@brt5273]

​@@frankpeter6851 I prefer guar gum rather than cornstarch. It's readily available these days...no longer an exotic ingredient for the home cook.

[@TheBluestank]

Can one just use all half and half instead of milk and cream?

[@IunaIia]

I've made ice cream in school with half and half and it was fine

[@Punkydoodle007]

I make ice cream with 2 cups half n half and 1 cup almond milk. I also add a few egg yolks.

[@gailgodfrey768]

HI, MUST GET ME A CUISART, AND SOME ICE CREAM. THANK YOU.

[@SunshineMichelle]

I would love to know if the people at her farmers market are using powdered milk and corn syrup.

[@FabricFest]

I wish someone would tackle a Ben and Jerry’s style non- dairy ice cream video!

[@stephenkorab6456]

A request: it'd be helpful to compare 'sweet cream' ice cream to what came from dairies 60 yrs ago. Also, please explain how corn syrup and high fructose corn syrup differ.

[@sociopathmercenary]

High fructose corn syrup has concentrated fructose. Corn syrup isn't this sweet.

[@stephenkorab6456]

@@sociopathmercenary Did some searching. Seems they are not the same. Regular CS is glucose, while high fructose CS is further processed to include sucrose. HFCS leads to insulin resistance, and is not available in stores' baking aisles. The better ice creams, and the 'old fashioned' ice creams boast of using cane sugar, not corn syrup. I would like to see ATK make an 'all-natural,' Old-Fashioned ice cream. Still don't understand what sweet cream ice cream is supposed to be! 🤔

[@astrid703]

@@stephenkorab6456 It isn't flavored with vanilla, so all you taste is the dairy.

[@stephenkorab6456]

@@astrid703 Thank you !

[@leeevers8976]

Yummy!!!

[@liindawgg]

I see Dan I click.

[@jvallas]

I didn't understand what was meant by sweet cream. Is that just whipping cream?

[@ramrod132]

Sweet cream is the standard term for ice cream made without any flavorings, including vanilla. The only flavor is the cream, sugar, and salt.

[@jvallas]

@@ramrod132 Thanks - I saw sweet cream yogurt mentioned the other day, so it doesn't seem to be about the ice cream, but the cream itself.

[@kendelljackson8357]

Any issues reconstituting dry milk for the milk portion of the recipe?

[@BrettVano]

That’s an interesting question. I would just speculate that you’ll be missing the fat in the ice cream texture that the whole milk provides. May not be that bad, but I can’t say. :)

[@sociopathmercenary]

They make powdered cream too

[@isdeirinnme]

I assume by reconstituting you mean mix the milk powder with water. That extra water can contribute to more ice: gritty texture, harder to scoop, etc. The point of the milk powder is to have milk sans water > ice. You could just use regular milk, but you end up with the same issue of ice content.

[@davep4101]

Can I make this if I don’t have an ice cream maker?

[@davep4101]

They won’t answer, they never do. So why put out videos if you can’t get a question answered. Oh I know, to get people to but their books and subscribe, no thanks.

[@slr4172]

@@davep4101 You never get an answer whether you subscribe or buy their books.

[@davep4101]

@@slr4172 another reason not to spend any money on them.

[@jvallas]

We have to just hope the community that watch these might have someone who can answer these questions, because ATK won't. (Edit: check online for "ice cream recipes without an ice cream maker." I suspect this recipe would work with one of those methods.)

[@sociopathmercenary]

I make ice cream with a KitchenAid mixer and liquid nitrogen 😇

[@GenRN]

Has anyone tried making with Allulose instead of sugar?

[@Starrgazed]

The REVEAL !!!! 🤪

[@WifeDesignLife]

You’re turning into the #GreatBritishBakeOff with your innuendos… “take our top off” 👀

[@jesuslovesyou919]

Dan The Man again cha - ching

[@DonnaWoodnorth-ez2hh]

Vanilla?

[@rasheedaelahie9935]

I like ice cream without eggs and corn syrup

[@gretecifuentes8539]

No vanilla??

[@stevo-dx5rr]

Is it better not heating the cream? I have heard it reorients the milk protein, perhaps undesirably.

[@jesuslovesyou919]

Dan do u have a decent ice cream recipe using a food processor or nutribullet ? Please 😃🎉

[@jvallas]

For mixing the ingredients, or for actually freezing it? (I'm thinking of the fro-yo I make with mine, but you have to start with quite a bit of something frozen. Maybe you could freeze some of this mixture in ice cube trays???)

[@spellmadam2947]

5 days!!😂😂😂😂😂

[@neuroflare]

It's funny watching people who don't know the difference between HFCS and plain corn syrup lose their mids. I hope none of y'all like PECAN PIE

[@rockys7726]

Just reinforces how much sugar is in Ice cream. I make my own mango ice cream at home with coconut cream and mango pulp. Not as creamy as dairy but just as tasty and lot less sugar.

[@timthompson8297]

Boy, it’s hard to find mango or peach ice cream.

[@exchangestudent2]

The ninja creami is great for this too. I just put mango in the bowl and freeze. When its rime for the creami I add a lil bit of room temp water and spin on sorbet 2x scraping the sides in between.

[@rockys7726]

@@timthompson8297 make your own. It's easy.

[@timthompson8297]

@@rockys7726 Except I am RVing in the desert and have limited space at present. But it’s a good idea.

[@timthompson8297]

Excellent suggestion.

[@armageddonready4071]

I made ice cream with cream from a organic Vedic dairy, no sugar required.

[@darylgonzalez646]

And I am sure it tastes so amazing…., get a life

[@marcpeterson1092]

I have tasted plain cream when making whipped cream. Way too bland. I would definitely add some more flavor to this.

[@timthompson8297]

Think I’ll just buy a pint of Haggan Daz

[@TundieRice]

Too bad “Haggan Daz” doesn’t have a plain sweet cream flavor, so you’ll probably be disappointed if you try to compare anything that Häagen-Dazs makes with this recipe!

[@justingall9823]

I just tried this recipe and am not a fan. It's way too thick, I can tell there is corn starch in it, and sticks to my mouth instead of melting. Did I do something wrong? I followed the recipe exactly and watched the video during the process.

[@naliniganguly649]

Dan specifies it should be not fat so any other kind is out of the question right ?

[@joanies6778]

Just for the dry milk part.

[@bigmommaal]

The freezer shelf life is a lot shorter than I anticipated-why is that?

[@gabelstapler19]

It will grow larger crystals, which messes with the mouth feel. After 5 days it doesn't go "bad", just not as smooth and creamy. Without the stabilizers they add in, "real" ice cream will grow larger crystals almost overnight.

[@oldmanfigs]

We are ready for xan gum!

[@ramrod132]

It seems like a good recipe, but I really wish they would measure by weight or at least also include the weight measurements. Ice cream requires well balanced ratios to still be creamy without not reducing the freezing point so that it becomes soup. Things like milk powder are fairly fluffy, so getting an accurate volumetric measurement is a problem

[@askthepaperclip]

Just made this, and I think it's actually TOO smooth? The texture is unnaturally smooth to the point of being almost gummy. Great flavor though.

[@kevinjohnston4923]

I tried this but I wasn’t a fan of the powdered milk flavor. I’ll be sticking to egg-based ice cream.

[@bearaballew3258]

I add nonfat milk to my gelato

[@austingwatson]

no vanilla. hmmm.

[@yourgooglemeister6745]

Milk powder? Corn starch? Corn syrup? No eggs? What kind of hack recipe is this?

[@randywaterbury9893]

I didn't see any vanilla go into it.

[@joanies6778]

Evidently that's how it's made, but I will be putting vanilla in mine.

[@frankpeter6851]

This is supposed to be "sweet cream" flavored

[@jvallas]

@@frankpeter6851 What does that mean? I've never heard of sweet cream. Is it whipping cream?

[@sociopathmercenary]

​@@jvallasCream + sweetener = sweet cream

[@lizcademy4809]

@@jvallas Sweet cream as opposed to sour cream. The term comes from the time before refrigeration, where soured milk, cream and butter lasted longer, and "sweet" cream was a delicacy.

[@WastrelWay]

"Non-fat dry milk powder"

[@dianadambrosio1]

And the whole beginning of this recipe, I thought this was going to be something with all the added ingredients, powdered milk, etc., that it would be out of an ice cream maker. Yay !! And then they added it to an ice cream maker ?? If you have an ice cream maker, it's cream and or milk, sugar, vanilla, eggs maybe ...And that's what the ice cream maker is for... hmmmf

[@marymylan1846]

I liked the creaminess but don't care for the flavor. My husband took one bite and threw it out. I can tolerate it with a healthy dose of Hershey's syrup. I think the dry milk flavor is too pronounced.

[@mbh3004]

As if that would last 5 days in the freezer 😅 🍨🥄🍦

[@EvanisioSantossales]

This is perfect in the my country!, Becouse here it's lot Hot!!😊

[@bettyt3471]

My recipe is so much easier and it doesn’t get icy or hard

[@Friedbrain11]

We made ice cream when I was young. Had a hand-cranked ice cream churn. Used half cream and half whole milk with some vanilla(the real stuff) and a little sugar. Made the best ice cream and no yours is not ice cream. It is a caricature of crap.

[@armandsant1143]

You lost me at corn syrup

[@itsonlybrad2278]

Homemade ice cream shouldn't need starches or stabilizers or odd ingredients to reduce iciness. I'll stick to milk, cream, sugar, and eggs, thanks.

[@jvallas]

A little touch of vodka is good.

[@mrbear1302]

If they're just gonna use the same bad ingredients that are in the stuff at the store. I'll just go to the store. Much faster and easier.

[@ramrod132]

You could reduce or remove the corn syrup if you up the fat or add another stabilizer like egg yolks before you heat it. The store bought ones generally have stabilizers in the form of gums which aren't particularly healthy things to be eating.

[@RavnHood]

Why not just use a Creami?

[@YouTube_can_ESAD]

I’m going too… Will try this recipe this weekend.

[@margaret1321]

I found a recipe for sweet cream on Pinterest that called for an ice cream freezer. Used the Creami and it turned out great!!

[@jvallas]

Because not everyone wants to buy one.

[@margaret1321]

@@sandrah7512 I love mine! I put a can of Dole Tropical Fruit in it and it comes out creamy and feeling very indulgent 😋

[@normrubio]

i don't like the idea of the corn starch/syrup

[@lostinmuzak]

Just watch. Don’t eat. Live longer. Try plain yogurt. May be the Greek yogurt occasionally. Put some nuts and fruits in it. It’s amazing. Full cream ice cream is so old fashioned.

[@mymuse111]

Although I love ice cream but Corn syrup 😮,,,Gross that is poison for the body.

[@CarlRRogers]

I love your guy’s recipes but I really wish you would offer alternatives for people trying to avoid corn syrup…

[@theoriginalbridgetconnors]

What's wrong with corn syrup? Dan didn't say use high fructose corn syrup, which is a totally different item.

[@virginiadaneke2362]

Are you avoiding high fructose corn syrup? I am. This syrup is not the high fructose stuff.

[@FierceMice]

​@virginiadaneke2362 why? Fructose and glucose are both sugars that provide essentially the same coloric burden. Fructose is processed in in the liver but if you are eating so much Fructose that is an issue, reducing your sugars is probably more important than reducing Fructose.

[@Tsyras]

@@theoriginalbridgetconnorsthey can’t tell you beyond they saw some clickbait article about HFCS and now a tiny fraction of regular CS in a recipe is scary to them.

[@bethanywashington1243]

You still gotta add the sugar anyways may as well add the corn syrup.

[@ProvocateuAstrology2]

No one eats corn syrup any more

[@sapat664]

I use it in all my pecan pies.

[@ProvocateuAstrology2]

​@@sapat664Dangerous

[@CantankerousDave]

Corn syrup and high fructose corn syrup are entirely different things. They’ve explained why tons of times.

[@jvallas]

There's the good kind and the bad kind.

[@sociopathmercenary]

​@@ProvocateuAstrology2 There's nothing wrong with corn syrup.

[@PR0TECTI0NIST]

Corn syrup in homemade ice cream? No thank you. I can buy corn syrup ice cream at any supermarket.

[@bettypang4971]

Sorry…5 tsps of cornstarch? The cooked mixture was super thick and gloppy! 😮not that liquidy custard …. Did anyone try this recipe really?

[@Critter145]

Corn syrup? Seriously?

[@chaeburger]

Yes. He's not using high fructose corn syrup if that's what you're worried about. Regular light corn syrup is just a different form of sugar and is perfectly fine. It has a lot of properties that table sugar doesn't. You need it to make a lot of recipes the best they can be. Like ice cream and pecan pie. Don't like it? Don't make this recipe.

[@thaisstone5192]

@@chaeburger Excellent point. People who make posts like that pretend to be food snobs.

[@coolnewpants]

Why not. Corn syrup is not the devil as some hyperventilating folks seem to think it is.

[@KenS1267]

@@chaeburger Regular corn syrup is useful in any number of recipes. You can use a small amount to prevent sugar from crystalizing in caramel, a trick I've used for many years. It works in frozen desserts to lower the freezing point, keeping it from being rock hard, but not being cloyingly sweet.

[@Tsyras]

Have you ever had an original thought, or do you just spew clickbait garbage to everyone who will listen?

[@EdwardArmstrong-y3f]

No corn syrup .!!!🤬🤬🤬

[@maxrobertson9008]

Why????

[@frankpeter6851]

Oh brother... yes, I agree. You don't want to be guzzling corn syrup soda pops every day. But in homemade applications, it's fine! Now shut up, and go eat a piece of pecan pie.

[@jameshobbs]

WTF is sweet cream ice cream?

[@one-thiird]

ice cream without any flavorings in it

[@jameshobbs]

@@one-thiird thanks! Is this some new trend?

[@Jupiter0ne]

I have no idea, but I'm guessing it is unflavored ice cream without the eggs. No thanks.

[@jameshobbs]

@@Jupiter0ne so like frozen pudding?

[@masstwitter4748]

Only ever had it in Italy (called fior di latte) and it’s delicious - been looking for a good recipe!

[@polaniecj]

You lost me at corn 🌽 syrup. Nope!

[@BB_Ninergirl478]

If you think corn syrup is bad, wait until you hear how toxic social media is!

[@gkunz3]

You lost me at “ corn syrup”. Please no.

[@jameshobbs]

Fahrenheit 😂

[@SpotofTeaPlease]

Corn syrup and corn starch? Gross. 🤮 If I want to have ice cream with unnecessary garbage, I'd do store bought. Hey ATK, you forgot the guar gum and carrageenan. It's enough to have sugar, which already isn't good for you.

[@nancycy9039]

I’m sure this is delicious, but corn syrup is extremely hazardous to our health.