And The Perfect Disc Golf Putter Is...

[@joem8496]

watched the whole series. subscribed.

[@FrogFishLeezerd]

This bracket idea was genius and I think you guys made a heck of a great video. Thanks for doing what you do and sharing it with all of us!

[@ryansuter4424]

Thank you guys for a thoughtful video episode🤩

[@danielcoburn2979]

I am a noodle arm and use Atom’s in all plastics. The electron soft is under stable up to proton which is over stable. I love how flat the Atom is.

[@theOcean41]

In my humble opinion there are 2 putters that are head and shoulders above the rest when it comes to a throwing putter and those are the Axiom Envy and the Discraft Luna, no doubt in my mind.. Best putting putter is the one that feels good and works for you so there is no one answer... For me the best feeling putter that I putt with is the Kastaplast Reko in K3 Plastic. It's beadless or has a mico bead that you don't even notice, it's shallow, it's comfortable in MY hand, the K3 plastic is amazing and prob the best baseline plastic in disc golf, and it's stable enough to be reliable but it's not too stable.. The cherry on top is it's availability! I fight with the urge to recommend the Reko only because I don't want it to get popular and be sold out everywhere like the Luna is! Haha! So yeah, The Reko is trash, don't try it, TRUST me.. 🤣

[@paul.etedder2439]

The winner is the Luna . The Luna can handle more torque thrown hard and in the wind it holds a line better . My top 3 is Luna Luna and Luna . A beginner should throw a Luna because learn with the best .

[@marcopineda._]

Let’s goooooo Disch!

[@KingLuwee]

Challenger OS is a cheaper alternative to the Luna. Thanks for the breakdown guys.

[@johntardibuono625]

Need to add the Jokeri; Maiden and Berg as well as P2 for a real good bracket. Also nice job with the entire run of videos, switching it up as well good touch.

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

Thanks John! Will try to get our hands on those discs in the future!

[@nolancampbell2527]

Based off the breakdowns I think the atom should be placed second since none of them liked throwing the Penrose.

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

This is how the votes worked out. Best throwing: 1st Luna 2nd Atom 3rd EV-7 Best Putting 1st EV-7 2nd Luna 3rd Atom. So by nature of the vote we decided to put the EV-7 in the 2 slot.

[@jeffogan3912]

You guys should check out the Reko by Kastaplast! It's my favorite throwing putter

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

A lot of people have been recommending the Reko. We are definitely going to try that out in the future! Thanks Jeff!

[@austin316nc]

Love my lunas . Great videos guys

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

Luna Lads for life

[@Mr.SpocksBrain]

I liked the concept though. I was missing some kastaplast discs and the allmighty P2. To be fair, Lona's are awesome! Never thrown a Penrose but they are one the way. Was never into MVP. Well done mates

[@mrcordell865]

After watching this video and the previous three (I had just bought a practice basket) so I went out bought 3 Atoms, Lunas, and Wardens (beadless judge) After a few weeks of putting from 5 different spot 22'-25'(2 flat, 2 uphill, 1 downhill) keeping a running tally with a scoring system I came up with, the warden jumped out but after a few weeks and 200ish putts most days the Atom was hands down the winner. In hindsight I wanted the atom to win, Nathan's tee shot on the 3rd hole of this video (hole 8) is what made me buy the Atom and it just felt more comfortable in the hand, so comfortably probably had something to do with it? The atom was my first Mvp disc now other than a Berg, Zone, Justice, and a Popcorn from clash disc I bag nothing but Mvp/Axiom.

[@matthewbreneman691]

I switched to the Luna this year and will never go back. No other putter has come close to me for putting and the only thing that rivals it for throwing is the P2

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

Team Luna!

[@iroironman9115]

I am Happy buy Luna bedor your videos. Nice suprice

[@5whiskey5]

I love the Atom. I have 4. 👍

[@mrcordell865]

I started putting with the atom due to this video I bought 3 just after watching it now anytime I buy disc, if they have it in 173g I add one to my practice putting collection. I'm up to 8 in electron medium and 3 in the soft

[@5whiskey5]

@@mrcordell865, I hear ya. I prefer the Cosmic Electron Soft for putting. I have six with one being retired as it was my first ace disc. I cycle through my five others to beat them in evenly. I have a Proton Atom for approaches.

[@mrcordell865]

I haven't thrown the atom in Proton yet, but I'm throwing my atom more and more. Probably even more than my envy, I did have three envys in my bag but I took the prism plasma out and left with either Electron soft or firm and eclipse. I tried the Glitch in that spot, hated it, put a spin in the bag, never threw it. Now the berg is taking that spot, I'm no berg fan boy but at least it does something no other disc in my bag does, but I could see a Proton Atom in that spot. I'm not a big fan of the Proton plastic, I wish they molded in neutron or even better the neutron soft.

[@5whiskey5]

@@mrcordell865, my preferred plastic for Atoms is soft so I use the proton for the durability.

[@donaldsimpson26]

I love my atoms in the firm electron plastic. Great for putting and really good approach disc very neutral disc which is what I want in a putter

[@derrickdigiulio4027]

"Lets see how this flies on a scoober line." *Throws hammer*

[@TheGhman87]

This is probably the best course in NC. Good players can smash the course and beginner players can play it. A must play if you're in NC

[@MegaLaban12345]

The P2 is the best. There.

[@NxtPh3n0m]

4:35 "lets throw the EV-7 on a scoober line" Proceeds to throw a tomahawk

[@jeremypittman732]

Yea also just seemed to biased seeing how they ended up with there own putters

[@InfiniteGTO]

I was thinking the same this.

[@JoshJackson13]

That atom looks good for u Nate as well as the Luna as a thrower for Eric dylon looked good putting the 7\11

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

The atom was a dope disc. It was a crusher of a putter!

[@justwondering1926]

Pilot putter here It’s very neutral straight flying but has some finish in neutron You guys might be impressed with it I want to try a Luna though

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

Thanks Just Wondering! We will definitely try to check out the pilot!

[@Imillmav305]

my ev7 is my approach disk, i feel it has a lot of float witch is good for my style. witch is beginner lol. i putt with a westside shield, but i love how the roach feels in the hand. and i really want a big z luna with the lady . great putts this video ..shoutout me (Michael)and my brother (Zac) in the next video!

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

Thanks IMillMav305! Yeah the Big Z Luna is so hard to find, but it flies great! I find i have to run up to get it to fly how i want it to because its a little more stable than the base plastic Lunas!

[@eoghana315]

Keystone & Envy gang...and sometimes Polecat.

[@gasstationsushi1999]

Patriot is by far my favorite course in the area…even if it is horribly managed. But ready for that midrange ranking

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

Patriot is top notch man, I agree! Stay tuned!

[@GonjaGoat]

Try the pig and the magic and rainmaker

[@johntardibuono625]

How about a bracket for Mid ranges ? That could be cool, dont"cha think ?

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

I think that would be sweet! Stay tuned! ;)

[@Bobbytrees]

What about the chainsaw?

[@patbell6789]

Luna gang! What mic do you guys use?

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

We use a Rode videomic Go directional microphone.

[@drewg3087]

Best putter is properly emac Judge for me then MVP Envy coming in 2nd and the Innova KC Pro Whale 3rd.

[@AlexWood66]

Was the nomad in here?

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

Nope, this series came out a few months before the Nomad was released. But we are doing a video on the Nomad soon!

[@RollTideJD]

The judge got shafted!!!

[@JsmithSmith-qi3pc]

This guy is correct

[@camychron]

I throw the Luna(big z) and putt with the warden If the Luna wasn’t $20 vs $9 warden I would get like 5 more. But as a semi beginner I would rather spend my money on midrange~>Driver than putter. However when I need to channel the spirit of the 5x I putt with the Luna and pretend I’m good at disc golf.

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

hahah totally hear that Cameron! I definitely pretend that i have Paul like abilities but am always quickly put in my place when i hear the clank on the top band.

[@nickbryant2318]

I putt with a mcpro aviar

[@finhunter1433]

Foot fault on the step putt of a lifetime ev7 lol nice putt tho

[@AYE-BE]

Was anyone else confused why they had someone jump out of a tree in the intro?

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

Nathan and Eric were confused too...(From Dylan)

[@GiantSFaithfuL]

Are you guys anti Innova?! The Rhyno is one of the best putters of all time!

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

We were just working with what we had in our box! We use it in our approach video though!

[@GiantSFaithfuL]

@@DeepRootsDiscGolf oh ok. Fair enough!

[@johnshepherd6925]

Dude I wanted to like this series. But it was really predictable. I thought in the first video that the final 3 would include the Luna and EV. I also thought no way Nathan's going to allow Dylan's Judge go further than the Luna or EV. I imagine you worked hard on this but the bias was real.

[@DeepRootsDiscGolf]

Thanks for the feedback John. We are bias and we tried to be transparent throughout the series about this being imperfect and flawed. We are human, and thus there is no way to prevent bias unless you are brand new to disc golf (even knowing a pro throws a disc creates some bias). Bias aside though, it's worth considering that the Luna is the most sold putter on the market and has sustained that title for a while. No doubt we have to contribute a lot of that to the Mcbeth effect, but at the same time if it wasn't a great putter there's a lot of people that would not continue to buy it and you'd see it fall back on the list. That hasn't been the case. EV-7 on the other hand is a putter only company. They make 1 mold of putter and do it well. If they weren't in consideration for a game changing putter they wouldn't really have a business model. In summary, we recognized from the start of the series we were bias and were transparent about that and while it might be predictable we picked 3 fantastic putters to be in the finale. We'll be back with another 9 hole play through today. Thanks again.

[@mmmxlaser]

Where's REKO?

[@ChadSolberg]

Im not even gonna say it... but you know what I would say....

[@ChadSolberg]

p.s. i dont live in your area(so I cannot buy it from the shop) but i want that atom... so purdy

[@ChadSolberg]

p.s.s. I only have a jawbreaker luna.... and i hate it..... maybe I just have a bad one.

[@hughbonus2227]

The Luna is most definitely the WORST putter. The cost is higher than all others, and the first time you hit a tree, gravel, or the metal basket...your disc is now damaged to the point it will never feel the same $20 for one throw is what you're saying is the best putter of them all. For example, only $15 for a soft or firm electron MVP Ion and you can throw it wherever you want without getting damaged The Luna is so brittle it makes it trash in my book

[@Troydizl]

Roach

[@dlaw555]

I saw no P2 and clicked off of the video.

[@austinmeade7150]

Discrap

[@bearman1258]

P2's are the only way to go. Everything else is bologna

[@joshkiefer3222]

I feel like if you had good form or were 1000 rated I would trust your opinion more

[@willhowarddg]

Agreed

[@willhowarddg]

Still a good concept though.

[@joshkiefer3222]

@@willhowarddg the concept wasn’t bad and these guys were having fun, I just think that it is misleading and could have been done so much better

[@willhowarddg]

I agree with what you are saying.

[@ryansuter4424]

What level player is more likely to watch and benefit this video? More likely a player who isn’t a 1000 rated putter. It makes since that when selecting a putter based on someone else’s views you want their skill level to be closer to yours not further apart?