Are Ramayana and Mahabharata Myths?

[@sadhguru]

Listen to The Sadhguru Podcast - Of Mystics and Mistakes Are Ramayana and Mahabharata Myths? Full episode link : podcasts.apple.com/in/podcast/are-ramayana-and-mahabharata-myths/id347854569?i=1000621206076

[@shuklasujeet]

The guy in the middle is that dhobi they were discussing who questioned sita's purity...He is still questioning it today...

[@rudramahadev22]

True Same stubborn mentality is alive after thousands of years

[@gaurav13151]

Haha

[@kannavsharma2]

Kal ka show

[@syyyyhnnnnmm.....jjhhghh]

😂😂😂

[@bhaskarbhattacharjee4018]

Exactly. Progeny of that dhobi

[@akashmendon7850]

Tobe honest im 27 yrs old.. And till now nobody explained me the Ramayan way the Sadguru explained ..

[@letslearn8813]

That's why they're Sadhguru, the legend. 🙏

[@ajk452]

Exactly

[@therealwarmonger]

He knows how to communicate with today's young generation. Today's youth have a lot of arrogance and ego.

[@EthanCruise]

Maybe you have also never found the right person to explain it as well.

[@VikasSingh-yw3lp]

I didn't liked the thing lord ram did with sita in the end TILL NOW, but the way SADHGURU described it, it just changed the whole view of mine. I really want other people to know about this.

[@Trademm]

This is the greatness of this culture, Imagine someone questioning Muhammad's insecurities in Saudi or Iran or Pakistan.

[@kushsareen6752]

Ambarish Lowsarwar they’d be sentenced to death under the blasphemy law!

[@Yash1999malviya]

bhai ye to khatarnak baatein hain !

[@punitpatel4449]

Ye thought mere dimag me bhi aya

[@gouthamnagraj5445]

Who cares for Muhammad after all 😂😂

[@jamunadevichandramouli8667]

Exactly correct

[@ketuue5333]

Ramayana is very complex to understand. It becomes more clear as you age.. :) You get to see a whole new meaning to the same things which were in front of you since the beginning!

[@srivasthavapippari2924]

Well said

[@chaitanyavasamsetti8177]

well yeah, BUT THE QUESTION WASN'T IF RAMAYANA was HELPFUL.....BUT SHOULD WE have blind faith in these scriptures

[@GauravJain108]

this is so true, Ketaki!

[@jitendradalavi9175]

Very beautiful thoughts 👏👏

[@keralasuperpower7778]

They would be converted by the time thier brain gets aged

[@sandeepharidasan6155]

We’ve inherited Rama’s qualities of being tolerant, respectful and patient. That’s his legacy 🙂

[@dishachakraborty2184]

You really think that? All of this nations citizens have it?

[@sandeepharidasan6155]

disha chakraborty A major chunk of our population has the above said Rama’s qualities after all we are his progeny.

[@sharathsh9987]

@@sandeepharidasan6155 Doubt.

[@sandeepharidasan6155]

Sharath SH Doubt, questions, confusion all r part of this culture like Sadhguru says....coz all the aforementioned are pathways to knowing more.

[@sharathsh9987]

@@sandeepharidasan6155 I meant I doubt the claim you made that we inherited the above mentioned qualities. Not that I have doubts.

[@prathamdogra8445]

This is what happens when you read the history and translations by Britishers who didn't digest the fact that anything can be older and more prosperous than the Biblical age of 2000BC.

[@fartinIutherking]

Bible is purely mythological. It says earth's only 6000 years old and we all know that's not true.

[@rairadio7119]

Forget British history books. Explain vanar sena, man with 10 heads, flying chariots - how is that history. That is a work of fiction. And fiction can be inspired by history. So the correct term is fiction inspired by history.

[@theodre0896]

Toddler Disemboweler ikr

[@snehasingh8802]

@@rairadio7119 because people couldn't translate Sanskrit and the metaphors. They took it literally and showed. If so many years back someone thought of chariots can fly..... If technology was not there.... He thought of that humans can fly.... And Ravana has 10 virtues. Don't take everything literally.

[@robertsarran7034]

Stupidity is subjective... those moderator were not forced into it by the English...

[@Megh72]

I feel people our age are so egoistic that we can't even have a debate . "Moving on" "moving on" If you question, have the patience to recieve an answer !

[@VishalMaurya]

Its not our age , its they

[@sajeewakalamba1796]

It can not be ego. They just don't allow anybody to escape not answering their question whatever the status of the person who answers.

[@TheDobermannnn]

@@sajeewakalamba1796 Anyways they were destroyed peacefully.

[@sajeewakalamba1796]

@@TheDobermannnn Sadhguru once bragged about Indians developed culture of seeking against Europeans culture of believing by destroying the one who questions. Modern Hinduism prefers that Europeans way of dealing with questions now ?

[@hiteshgogia1828]

Krishna told this to guru Dronacharya : acharya Yadi prashna karna hi ho to uske uttar se ghabrana nahi chahiye

[@dhanshriable]

The problem with our generation is more towards negativity in everything and not to have patience to listen. When you bag of mind is already full with garbage there will never be place for anything else. Hats off to Sadhguru for being so calm and having patience to explain the same thing multiple times. 🙏

[@seeker7090]

the main problem of today's youth is that they talk about facts n logic in everything

[@avinashdesai4192]

Aa

[@AshishMaithil_Life]

the biggest negative of being from IIM/ IIT is this EGO.... they are not grounded anymore! Fortunately now all

[@chaitanyavasamsetti8177]

THE QUESTION ISN'T IF THE RAMAYANA IS GOOD OR BAD.......BUT IF WE SHOULD HAVE BLIND FATE OVER IT

[@KannyValentine]

It's not our generation. Its just a bunch of people who want to feel special by being a leftist and saying certain words to offend somebody to everybody.

[@jacknap1marshall792]

Seriously my view for ramayan has changed today, when he mentioned that Ram being a king walked for 1000 of kilometre for his wife.. I respect Rama thankyou Sadguru 🙏🙏

[@suyogkhadilkar]

3000*

[@anshulhandoo4571]

Marshall Ram ji was the avtar of Bhagwan Vishnu...

[@mahotsavkumar1278]

3000* KMs bro

[@Alpha_Rigel_Cassiopeia]

3000? Seriously? 3000??!!

[@ordinaryperson1902]

Monkey flying without WINGS is Mythology......No Monkey without WINGS could fly or communicate with human...

[@hemantroy2498]

The Middle guy he is more dangerous than “Manthara” in Ramayana

[@HowToBLazy101]

Hahahaha 🤟 🤣

[@_Autumn__leaf]

haha

[@pradeepratgali2073]

😂😂😂

[@dheer33]

He's surpanakha reincarnated !

[@raghav1308]

ahaahahahahahahhahahahahhahahahahahah

[@086pavanmannava9]

The way they sat in front of a great sage tells us how educated they are

[@TheRakid]

He is sadhu not sage😂😂😂

[@Moon-kq7hu]

@@TheRakid sage means sadhu, philosopher

[@lakshyagrover6379]

A sage would just laugh and move on

[@TheRakid]

@@Moon-kq7hu sage is person with great knowledge....sadhu is a person who is free from worldy pleasures ..😂😂😂

[@TheRakid]

@@Moon-kq7hu let me enlighten you ...Both are different things and I know difference between them...And I also know hindi😂😂😂

[@monalizasingh5175]

Nation's history is different from literature wow amazing answer by sadguru ❤️🙏🙏

[@chaitanyavasamsetti8177]

yeah I just saw a guy with 10 heads the other day down the street and I also saw a giant just casually sleeping like a slog ....totally telling the truth

[@metaphoricallyalive8109]

@@chaitanyavasamsetti8177 you watched the whole video yet could not comprehend even half of the essence that it carried

[@adarshsatam4462]

@@chaitanyavasamsetti8177 would you know,if he did existed

[@chaitanyavasamsetti8177]

@@adarshsatam4462 i wouldn't say there weren't but at the same time i wouldn't believe it blindly that they did exist Even if i believe they existed i wouldn't blindly push it on other's the belief that they should also just trust they existed

[@deshbhakt450]

@@chaitanyavasamsetti8177 I know During your birth God Deleted the Brain part of your Body

[@DancingDreams9]

Hatsoff to Sadguru...to handle arrogancy by patience....this is known as wisdom :)

[@medlearning6224]

Archana Mane the ramayan they are talking about is 500 year old written by Tusidas. In Valmiki Ramayan UTTARKAND (where ram puts sita into fire etc) is not there. Even things like Humaan ji flying with mountain is not written in Valmiki Ramayan.

[@DancingDreams9]

Matter is what we learnt from the history...no matter whether such character were there or not...that only Sadguru trying to explain...Ram is character who guided how to live life with problems...it's just like one artist draw a beautiful picture...n people appreciated that art by full of joy... people never investigate whether such image exist in real or not....

[@VSM101]

@@DancingDreams9 I am sure Rama existed the archaeological evidence is slowly revealing so much.

[@Seeker.6]

Seriously 🙏🙏👌

[@Omni_Shambles]

Sadhguru has no proof. He is an ignorant fool who's mind is closed to the truth.

[@steawartpereira9198]

Even dhobis of that time had rights to question their king about his wife... That's the greatness and level of tolerance in sanatan culture for u...

[@manitiwari9233]

Doesn't holds true for today's scenario of India.

[@kalakartist]

Dhobis never had rights. It just makes for a good story.

[@competativeprogramming7480]

@@kalakartist democracy itself started from india. Raja bharat choose a eligible guy from his prja and give them throne where he had 9 son. Go and read like a human not like a man who wants prooved wrong others.

[@kaml5619]

But no one has it now!!

[@yash_nirbhavane]

Sadly that tolerance has been lost in time...

[@ShantanuSP]

They don't have questions. They have agenda...!

[@preethishetty6179]

Shantanu Pimpalwar exactly I totally agree . A questionnaire must have a open mind and a inquisitive mind to know and learn . But he is asking just to prove his point . Not to know . But to prove a rigid set of ideas .

[@sanjitpanda7704]

Exactly

[@Pradeep-ix6dj]

So true!

[@chaitanyag.8415]

True

[@shubhamjoshi4961]

Right

[@Whatever-zl3jd]

Despite getting this golden opportunity to talk to such a knowledgeable soul, I really feel envy how some people end up debating, instead of learning more...! ✨

[@harshgoyal8988]

Watching this video I clearly understood what 'padhe likhe gavar' means

[@harshineevaja1513]

🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥👀

[@apdt936]

Correct

[@spritual_soul177]

😂😂

[@dexter5679]

What is means, brother? Tell in English

[@ashishtiwari8034]

It means educated fool

[@amolsw]

Advice for today's youth : *if you can't make it to IIM the don't feel upset. IIM also have these type of students*

[@jkjake9214]

And advice for today's youth : don't try to send your child to IIM. And if they ask why just show them this uncles 😂

[@marianatrench1850]

@@jkjake9214 😁🤣🤣

[@AKM_Diary]

😝😝😝😝😝

[@letslearn8813]

@@jkjake9214 Too good 😂

[@rishavkumar9284]

Your comment won my heart 💓

[@sarangpawar8822]

Sadhguru is the epitome of wisdom... The amount of patience he has is incredible

[@medlearning6224]

Sarang Pawar the ramayan they are talking about is 500 year old written by Tusidas. In Valmiki Ramayan UTTARKAND (where ram puts sita into fire etc) is not there. Even things like Humaan ji flying with mountain is not written in Valmiki Ramayan.

[@Seeker.6]

True👌👌🙏🙏

[@pulz1191]

Sadguru is correct. Till today Marwari language in Rajasthan and Bhojpuri language of Uttar Pradesh are spoken, unwritten languages. Still spoken very widely,even though media calls it "Hindi Heartland" because that's the written language. In fact many people in the extreme rural parts even today don't know Hindi... When the hear people speaking in Hindi they say "Key Angrezi bole bhayo".... meaning what's this English language that you are speaking. And till today the Raghuvanshi descendants are few of the many kings and Royal families of Rajasthan

[@bhashuvbr]

He is a man of Wish dom and not wisdom.

[@NaaneVinu]

I myself had these questions in my head for so many years. I asked many people these questions but never got convincing answers. Now I got it cleared. Well said.

[@prahladpai4952]

The fact that Sadguru explains everything with so much clarity only deserves a lot of respect.

[@chaitanyavasamsetti8177]

THE QUESTION ISN'T IF THE RAMAYANA IS GOOD OR BAD.......BUT IF WE SHOULD HAVE BLIND FATE OVER IT

[@TheDuketube]

@@chaitanyavasamsetti8177 did you watch the whole video?

[@chaitanyavasamsetti8177]

@@TheDuketube yeah i did.... Did i misunderstand anything.?

[@adarsh.chhetry251]

@@chaitanyavasamsetti8177 blind faith is something killing people in the name of God for 72 angles in heaven.

[@chaitanyavasamsetti8177]

@@adarsh.chhetry251 that may be extreme but even in this case it is somewhat ignorant to just reject completely what others have to say and insult them for something even you can't confirm

[@chetanchandrashekar3306]

I bow down to Sadhguru's patience in taking time to answer the manner less illiterates 🙏 Not a second I see Sadhguru loosing his temper in the whole argument. You are truly a mystic 🙏

[@shivprakashmishra5126]

See that's what Ram is all about. No matter what life throws at you, even these kind of egoistic students, you should be calm, joyful and do what is needed.

[@naughtydust]

Why should he lose his temper. Here everyone should take the opportunity to question any one and thats our freedom in or democracy. I am once again proud of my country and people being educated enough.

[@RahulMishra-vc6ke]

@@naughtydust he is not at all asking question for knowledge. Just after passing ignorant and ridiculous comment on shree ram she said let's move to the next question. That simply means he just wants to demean shree ram and sadguru. And freedom of speech doesn't include demeaning others.

[@vandeindia5955]

Jai Ho, these people will not understand because power of sacrifices prabhu did, is beyond their Vivek, jaane soyi jinu janayi..jane tumahi tumahi ho jayi..

[@ravindraalajangi3918]

Educated arrogant illiterates

[@signaturespecialist]

What's the point of asking questions if you have already made up your mind? ;)

[@soumendraphukan2679]

True

[@NatarajSubramanian]

I agree. I feel sorry the guy (the moderator) for a wasted opportunity.. Because, my guess is that, with an unbiased mind he could have received so much from such an interaction with Sadhguru, who in my opinion is a very great man.

[@pulz1191]

Sadguru is correct. Till today Marwari language in Rajasthan and Bhojpuri language of Uttar Pradesh are spoken, unwritten languages. Still spoken very widely,even though media calls it "Hindi Heartland" because that's the written language. In fact many people in the extreme rural parts even today don't know Hindi... When the hear people speaking in Hindi they say "Key Angrezi bole bhayo".... meaning what's this English language that you are speaking. And till today the Raghuvanshi descendants are few of the many kings and Royal families of Rajasthan

[@lazypecek]

What's the point in answering if you are not willing to understand the questioner? ;)

[@shocky5940]

@@lazypecek he answered preety well but the questioner seemed unable to digest the truth! ;)

[@zalaabhay7119]

Thank god my parents raised me very well ❤️

[@zalaabhay7119]

And thobies are these

[@parvsingh1934]

that why you cant get to iim

[@patil4128]

🚩❤🤟

[@johnabraham4556]

Sadguru Ji- Such a beautiful way to express the character of shree Ram and why we worship him and call him The Lord Ram. Very nicely eplained. It attracted me more towards Shree Ram.... 🙏

[@Userx0909]

Then watch 'Valmiki Ramayana' series by 21Notes.

[@Rajat_007]

They don't want discussion to gain wisdom, they want to win a "DEBATE". Education is not equal to Wisdom.

[@AnkitKumar-zu7cn]

Well said Bro

[@parikshit_deore]

Clearly! well said.

[@ordinaryperson1902]

Monkey flying without WINGS is Mythology......No Monkey without WINGS could fly or communicate with human...Ramayana is mythology.....

[@cheeku40]

@@ordinaryperson1902 take the Tesla car and showing it to kings 300 years ago think that car has life and it’s a new creature cus it moves on its own

[@ordinaryperson1902]

@@cheeku40 You comparing Tesla Car to Hanuman is funny.....One is technologically developed (Tesla Car). The other (Hanuman) is a character in a story. He can fly without wings because he only exist on pages of books.

[@aritra3551]

They listen to reply not to understand, when you listen to understand you have knowledge when you listen to reply you have argument.

[@jaynimje3790]

Well said!!!!

[@marcusscott4024]

well said.

[@mchittaj]

Excellently said, thy are not willing to listen and understand wat happend thy just want to argue

[@rakshandanalawade8547]

7 habits of highly effective people

[@thefirst3762]

Well said

[@kiranmuni5230]

Goosebumps , this is real every one has to understand about lord rama. Sadhguru you made me realize who is rama what he did, why he did ..seriously why people is thinking beyond and going excess in to lord sri Rama character deeply. Can we imagine us in any one of his life phases and estimate ? Definitely no body in this universe can do what he does and hence he is god and everyone haz to worship .. ji sri rama

[@kritisingh3536]

Seeing all these students from top colleges,, making me doubt the education system.

[@supernovabristol9468]

With all due respects... it's not education system to start with... it's *qualification* system... think ! That's why these kids are talking the way they are talking... specially the one in the middle... 🙏🚩🕉️

[@cloudyy5228]

Me being a student of school, I have never learnt about my history in history textbook!

[@k.goswami126]

@@cloudyy5228 true dat.... Me too

[@cloudyy5228]

@@k.goswami126 yeah it's truth

[@swapnilsharma1010]

anyways than why are you bellow them ?

[@kagstro1822]

"The story is not taken for its facts rather for the truth" 👏👏🙌🙌🙌

[@ShivaKumar-ei1th]

Sadguru at his best, logical, sensible & articulate, as always. Great.

[@sameersardar]

This is amazing.... I was looking at those guys' faces and how they were clueless... We are in society where we are trying to reinterpret our holy books.

[@sitalsitoula6536]

Asking question is a good thing. Reinterpreting and trying to figure out is also a good thing. It's just that these guys don't have much experience in these type of conversations.

[@sameersardar]

@@sitalsitoula6536 exactly

[@drtrimurthy]

Look at last guy's sitting style , that's difference between literacy and education

[@silenttalk5825]

whats wrong with that?

[@sinjun468]

@@silenttalk5825 there is certain way to sit when U sit in front of guru that's what indian culture is about. Don't get westernised. And see their mannerisms so egoistic.

[@silenttalk5825]

@@sinjun468 Just tell me first this, what if you go and sit like sadguru in any UPSC interview? Anyway one should always sit in a way they find it comfortable to their body, which means a way which doesn't cause any unwanted stress to a body unless the way of sitting is completely unethical, moreover it should not be the point how they are sitting but it should be like how they are listening to the words of sadguru. Also lemme tell you one thing when we see someone is wrong, we try to find everything wrong in them, their sitting style, their foot position, their way of seeing everything, and you should change this mind since you seem to follow the words of sadguru !

[@sinjun468]

@@silenttalk5825 upsc is professional interview this is more of intellectual talk U should know the difference. And when it comes to posture I do yoga and none of them is sitting in correct posture. And thirdly when U sit Infront of elders especially when U are sitting infront of guru there is certain mannerisms. We indians are taught respect guru, parents and many sadhguru's interviews with westerners I have seen them behave much more humbly then what these indian students are behaving.

[@sinjun468]

@@silenttalk5825 and these students are neither professional or humble in their way of approach to sadhguru's answers.

[@THEUNDERCOVERMONK]

Rama created an Utopian state in the history of Humanity . It was known as Ram Rajya. It can't be possible without trust of common people. He did everything to gain the trust of people. This is rare even in a Democracy. . Secondly, Sita lived a dignified life in the the ashram of Valmiki. Nowhere it is mentioned that she was resentful and hateful towards his husband. She was an accomplished Yogini by the end and attained Mahasamadhi on her own. She was celebrated for that also. . Thirdly, Rama when went to take Samadhi in Saryu River , she was chanting Sita's name. As she became an inspiration for Rama. ..

[@medlearning6224]

Dark Matter the ramayan they are talking about is 500 year old written by Tusidas. In Valmiki Ramayan UTTARKAND (where ram puts sita into fire etc) is not there. Even things like Humaan ji flying with mountain is not written in Valmiki Ramayan.

[@ChitranjanKumar12345]

@@medlearning6224 सही बोला आपने

[@ŕóśĥáń-3002]

RAMA- the definition of the ideal man. SITA- the definition of the ideal women. that's what my small brain can understand.

[@krishnanb.s.5581]

Every Character in Ramayana is an ideal person even the Ravana had certain characters worth appreciating

[@ruparelpinky]

Sadhguru, I understand and accept your answers to the questions made except one.. the last question made by the third guy was - What about Ram's responsibilities as a husband? And the promises made to his wife? What is well-known for any Raghuvanshi is "Praan jaaye par vachhan na jaay.." Where did Lord Ram fulfill his promises made to Seeta? There could have been a way out to convince the Kingdom people as well as his own personal beloved..?? Please respond..

[@sachinkhiste8747]

No amount of evidence will ever persuade a fool - Mark Twain

[@aakashmasane7326]

This can go for both sides

[@vedantjoshi4698]

@@aakashmasane7326 no because , sadhguru is relying on evidence but that guy is just saying things according to his own perspective.. see video carefully

[@aakashmasane7326]

@@vedantjoshi4698 ok

[@dhruvin4441]

@@aakashmasane7326 go and study in IIM. Our culture is not like western culture. We r spiritual we gave yoga to the world and 3 chuthiyas questioning about maryadapurushotam shree ram. Librandu culture is bad for our nation

[@onkarsharma4362]

So true

[@nir_raw]

Very Well Explained ❤️❤️❤️ in just 11 minutes about Shri Ramchandra ji .... Deeply touched.. Jai Siya Ram 🙏

[@upadhyayrathiraj1518]

Sadhguru just killed that guy "First let us kidnap her" 😆😆😆😆

[@varuns5666]

😂😂

[@lordloneshadow7572]

I love how Sadhguru focuses on his learning from history rather than the latter's accuracy. And he gives a very good message, even bringing in humor with respect to the Ramayan. That's how our culture has been and should be. Not jailing someone because he humorises ram or ramayan.

[@mayankindian3750]

😊☺️❤️Sadguru is cool person 🙂😁😄

[@lisatui3527]

This really hit me hard. The guy in the middle is talking but don't even know what he saying. How would you know what a King has to deal with????? All respect and love to Rama❤💛💚🙏

[@ksasidhar2980]

I might not be a leftist, but I simply disagree, saying that something is absolute truth and blindly following it, I believe that Ramayana and Mahabharata are both stories told to understand the large volumes of wisdom and thought that many generations of sadgurus and Rishis have gained throughout their lives. Think of it as explaining a child about something with a background story. Saying that some thing is true history but having Inaccuracies in them will just blur the definition of what history actually is. I think these epics should be peices of literature, rather than facts

[@thrilokmoriya7429]

@@ksasidhar2980 literature is not taken as seriously as history. You know what i mean. More over if you cannot say it is absolute truth, you also cannot say, everything is myth. Maybe it was a story, also maybe it was inspired from someone.

[@ksasidhar2980]

Chaitra Kini I agree to some extent that Rama is still a god to all. But there is simple understanding that Rama is an incarnation of Vishnu in tejayug, I think that Rama shows how exactly someone as pure as Vishnu would face the situation present as in Ramayana.

[@ksasidhar2980]

Sai Bharghav Movva yeah exactly

[@ucantcme1851]

@Facts with surya but he was not a simple man

[@movieseries1635]

Even though I studied ramayana in my tenth standard i didn't apply it in my life but facing everything hardships and being cool and nice is not an easy thing I realised it now . everytime when you read ramayana one will find something unique from great book🙏

[@pratikagrawal8742]

I can't even judge present day human beings, this middle guy is judging RAMA. Just wow.

[@MrWadimann]

Pratik Agrawal rightly said .

[@user-gu8ue7ku2b]

@Nilin Jacob Because u can clearly see the way he is questioning , he is not interested to seek knowledge . He is not interested in knowing . You should question to seek and not to argue

[@iamKK3]

If stupidity had a face - middle guy 😅

[@shwetasingh6036]

He is a _____

[@ruhaanchopra8878]

what is the problem in judging Rama?

[@amanramani1616]

Middel guy is like a topper who will do anything to prove himself in front of teachers

[@amoghnath3330]

that's the whole point of this programme, to have a constructive dialogue and put forward their opinions

[@Jaechhetai]

@@amoghnath3330 yep

[@goldenheart7794]

Putting opinion with ego 🙏

[@denishgurung377]

Comeon just look at their face and dress their nerds who finally got a chance to get highlighted

[@aaryansetia9093]

@@amoghnath3330 but there is a certain way to express opinions which should be done respectfully considering who they are talking to Sadhguru who is many things but is elder to them

[@nivieb9]

This is clearly "agenda" based. I love the way Sadhguru takes their case, LOL.

[@law-AbidingCitizen007]

Very true. You hit the nail.

[@tears2392]

Yes they are working for propaganda and are government-aided

[@devanshubhatt5467]

True

[@narayanamnithyanandaswarup2415]

Here to disturb the 333 likes, don't mind me

[@ketanshinde1768]

Absolutely true.. left agenda..

[@Daredevil311-g9l]

This is the difference between knowledge and wisdom. Anyone can read something in a book but it takes insight to know its true meaning

[@writenbygarima]

The way Sadguru corrected "It's History" 🔥

[@ordinaryperson1902]

Monkey flying without WINGS is Mythology......No Monkey without WINGS could fly or communicate with human...Ramayana is mythology.....

[@imwhoknocks579]

Definitely not history

[@kattar_hinduz]

JAI SHREE RAM 🚩🚩🚩🏹

[@shivanshsharma72hh]

@@ordinaryperson1902 you dont know about siddhis

[@ordinaryperson1902]

@@shivanshsharma72hh You do not know that a monkey cannot lift a mountain and fly......

[@aasthashrivastava4644]

I used to think like these guys for sometime, taking the events literally instead of understanding the essence of the story. The main thing is we worship lord Ram as a god and you have hard time accepting that a god can do anything wrong. If we try to view him as a king who faced so many hardships, it makes more sense that he did what he did. This video has changed my prespective, thank you.

[@apoorvakapoor3709]

Sacrificing everything for his people is a different thing but setting a wrong example is totally wrong too. By doing so, it sets an example in the society for women that they must prove their chastity, even if they are not at fault they can be punished and they must sacrifice. It is not equality! A better example would have been to leave the throne altogether but not setting women for such a patriarchal society, but to actually fight it! So the guys here are asking very valid questions but they didn't get any answers, they moved on to the next question. Moreover, if you've read about Hinduism, it teaches us to question, to understand, to discover and not to follow anything blindly, and it gives people the freedom to believe or not!

[@shivkumar-ge9yy]

Same here

[@Magnatec_tank]

The concept of god in Hinduism in itself allows for God to have flaws and exhibit the follies of a common man.

[@aanchalfinwoman]

Ram ji aur krishna ji me spsa pehla antar yhi hai ki Ram ji insaano ki trh jiye they aur Krishna ji bhgwan ki trh. Dono hi vishnu ji ka roop hai. Ram ji ke janm se ye bhi seekh milti h ki insaano ka jeevan kasht dayi hota . Sb ye wala part ni smjh patey.

[@DolphinSneeze69]

I enjoy that the gods in hinduism are very human

[@Suryapoosarla]

middle guy for some reason hates ram so much....he already decided ram is bad and anybody says othewise is a fool....

[@vijubabu3685]

Yes as if lord ram did something to his family he is showing his hatred.

[@shocky5940]

@@vijubabu3685 he might be srilankan 😂😂😂

[@vidyaonline007]

Anyways hw takes Rama's name so that span of time he is just thinking rama and ramayana aso sita . Anyways let's take the point that to be in the thought of rama and sita is going to bring us fortunes

[@kingromeo51]

Yes ram is bad, and doesn't exist

[@OkiOkiMataara]

Hate is great love that this screen world of today is stopping, but i saw it was love :)

[@priya21096]

Literature is different history is different Bang on 🔥❤️

[@earntalktime3145]

There are over 1,00,000 characters. How can you create a gospel out of it. Just wow❤️ Sadhguru wow❤️

[@chaitanyavasamsetti8177]

well, Bhagwat Gita came out of it...did it not?

[@earntalktime3145]

@@chaitanyavasamsetti8177 Yes Gita is a part of Mahabharata

[@snipeplayzftw837]

@@chaitanyavasamsetti8177 Nope, that came after Rama's time

[@taravarma519]

This clearly shows that no matter how great a person is, there will be people to question their actions and motives.

[@kalakartist]

And there should always be. keeping power and influence is important otherwise we end up with power hungry chuts like modi and trump

[@ordinaryperson1902]

Monkey flying without WINGS is Mythology......No Monkey without WINGS could fly or communicate with human...

[@badassguy9856]

@@ordinaryperson1902 No where it is mentioned that monkey flied.. Do prove me otherwise stop insulting Ramayan

[@avicr4727]

@@ordinaryperson1902 many things destroys and are made with time just because you havent seen it dosent mean it does not exist(for example just 100 of years ago if you had said to someone that you can talk to a person 1000 kms away he would have said similar things and that its impossible).

[@VamsiKrishnaReddyLazyTraveller]

Crossing your legs and pointing at the direction of others, especially elders, is arrogance. Period. May it be Sadhguru or anyone.

[@rameshraja1193]

They felt they come from Western, even Western people now days know how to sit respectfully...

[@NoobMaster-or2jf]

There is no problem with that. Sadguru does not seem to have a problem. Then why do you have to find one?

[@anjukalita8467]

Exactly

[@iamKK3]

Absofuckinlutely True... & if stupidity had a face, it would look like the guy in the middle 😅

[@tingle2323]

Difference between knowing own culture and followin western culture.. otherwise u will see how many ppl sit properly in front of elders

[@streb6]

Respect to the three students as well as Sadhguru. It is admirable that the students were able to freely put forward their thoughts ideas and challenge some aspects of notions in Ramayana. ❤

[@pallad17950]

feel like there is certainly some malice and an intent to malign Rama’s character. Regardless of what the students’ motives are though, their questions were quite critical and probing! So, these questions together with Sadhguru’s insightful yet patient responses, elevated my devotion and reverence to Lord Ram 🙏🏽

[@tingle2323]

Their thoughts? Already made up thoughts?

[@ramanansanthiralingam8078]

What is not mentioned in this discussion is that Sita chose to leave Rama after being questioned by him. The south indian version is more in depth. Sadhguru didn't touch on that subject because the three young intelligent gentlemen didn't understand that Rama loved Sita than most people, if any loved their spouse. However, Rama is the embodiment of ideal rulership, the ideal King who sacrificed everything for his people, even his love. You can find fault in this, but at the same time you can find tremendous virtue and suffering. Jai Shri Rama 🙏🏾

[@sepanjangjalan6087]

that’s what 4th hokage did for his village, he was sacrificed his life and his wife to protect his village, entrusted his son by putting the kyuubi inside his child body that he knew in the future his son become a hero for the village

[@apoorvakapoor3709]

Sacrificing everything for his people is a different thing but setting a wrong example is totally wrong too. By doing so, it sets an example in the society for women that they must prove their chastity, even if they are not at fault they can be punished and they must sacrifice. It is not equality! A better example would have been to leave the throne altogether but not setting women for such a patriarchal society, but to actually fight it! So the guys here are asking very valid questions but they didn't get any answers, they moved on to the next question. Moreover, if you've read about Hinduism, it teaches us to question, to understand, to discover and not to follow anything blindly, and it gives people the freedom to believe or not!

[@narasimhakishan2711]

@@apoorvakapoor3709 But, isn't leaving the throne would amount to indirectly accepting that his wife was not chaste? It's just a matter of karma. Everyone is liable to the fruits of their own karma. Even Gods are not exception to this rule. Had Sita listened to her brother in law and not crossed lakshmanrekha, she wouldn't have faced all those.

[@pavanswaroop1712]

@@apoorvakapoor3709 Here you are bringing in genders. I bet if Rama was a female, she would have done the same with her husband. And also you are comparing the sensibilities of those times to ours? Why are you picking only this aspect? There are countless noble aspects of those times that we do not follow in today's world. Our discussions all span from what was written. Had we had a narrative from Rama himself as to why he did what he did do we have the proper right to question his actions. But we dont now do we? That is what Sadhguru is saying. Rama does not gender discriminate. It is out of the question. Had Vishnu been born as a female in physical form, he would have done the same thing. This is my idea of Rama. Ofcourse everyone would have their own idea.

[@snowflake1458]

@@apoorvakapoor3709 but didn‘t he learn from that? I saw or read somewhere that he felt guilty and apologized. Isn‘t that also a teaching to show us that we need to trust our women.

[@BGandhi005]

With due respect to IIM or any other institution... I am a normal graduate from Mumbai university... But I can bet my vision is much better with clarity of the fact that I am not driven by the norms of society who wants individuals to be down always... Grow guys Grow 🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@omkardesai6807]

This was really a great explanation of Ramayana I've ever heard. I bow down to you Sadguru for this phenomenal explanation. I would like to hear the entire Mahabharata and Ramayana from you. 🙏🙏😊😊✨✨

[@renuhiralall6223]

Sadhguru, so blessed to have you in my life, how blessed are the people around you. Distance makes me so close to to you my GURU. Planning to live among your presence. Let this happen but even now I am among you , distance does not make a difference, but it will be great to be in India close to Isha .

[@viithalbhat9413]

12:10 For the comment from that 3rd guy, "he also had a personal life and should not have left her in such condition". I would say even in today's world also there are numerous such cases around that people sacrifice their families for their duties. Like one in merchant navy can't come home for at least 6 months, or in army, or in any defence service and put their lives on risk. Or say the respectable doctors who have put their lives on risk fighting corona virus outbreak they also would have family issues for sure, but you all see still how it goes like, they could have also ran back or left towards their personal interests, but they are standing tall and I am proud of them. They did it on a one level he did it on other level and that's it. Ram being a king was nowhere bound to his duties if we take it in other angle, but he still thought of his people first and considered his concern towards them as an act of duty. He was not like the rulers of the current generation. He was different that's why he didn't thought about his family first and thought all about his people. And that's why we admire him and rest why is superbly explained by sadhguru ji himself. You must understand this.

[@marriagedance8657]

Really sensible comment!

[@thedeadman5528]

👌👌

[@keshavsikdar9284]

At last a sensible and logical comment. Kudos.

[@abhishekpal7291]

Beautifully put together 👌

[@snehasony5525]

Awesome bruh

[@NitinSharma-ly9so]

The guy in the middle is an example of how different our interpretations of something could be

[@informationocean4428]

This is the classic example of difference between Literacy and Education

[@mr.memedovski5976]

There is that long travel of 💟 "through moist and fog" and new 🌼found light Namasté and with Angels always🌈

[@kitty87888]

The ramayan has life lessons. We should learn lessons from it.

[@VADAPAV001]

Middle wala kab samjhega🤦🏿‍♂️

[@tirthshah1580]

We should have the same debate on Muhammad and his life.

[@MrPANNAJI]

Then gone case.

[@patel6785]

You want to live or not😂😂

[@akshaygaikar4595]

Bhai..tu bana video...Koi aya to Gand me talwar dalenge... Jai bhawani Jay Shivaji⛳

[@MrPANNAJI]

@@akshaygaikar4595 Correct. Love you bhai.

[@alyamin3949]

@@akshaygaikar4595 ajao

[@Xwap]

Arguments for arguing's sake ... These 3 IIM "scholars" make this video unpleasant to watch. Sadhguru had lots of patience with the middle one.

[@himanshukundalwal6758]

सतगुरू महाशिवरात्रि उत्सव

[@PANKAJKUMAR-lb5dh]

Really loved the interaction. yes its not a myth but our history

[@davidannderson9796]

I may add something: Sita herself was a Queen and knew that she too had responsabilities to the people of the Kingdom. Rama knew that Sita knew that it was her responsability as Queen to put the good of the Kingdom first. That was part of what she agreed to when Sita married Rama and became Queen. As the daughter of a King, Sita would have grown up from early childhood learning this. It was not just Rama but Sita as well who agreed to do this for the greater good of the Kingdom. For this purpose, Sita figured out how to prove her innocence to the people. She figured that out herself, not for herself, but for the greater good of the kingdom. Sita too knew her responsabilities. And Sita had made those responsabilities the purpose of her life, all her life, just like Rama did. Sita did this willingly, as a Queen to her people and as a hero, not unwillingly as a victim. She did it for her people as a good Queen.

[@smileysmileking]

Exactly! For her Agni pariksha she set the fire herself, proving it was her decision

[@testprofile1840]

exactly

[@rakeshkutti1667]

May those three assoles see this comment 🤣

[@ashishgoyal7897]

Yep. But unfortunately our Ramanand Sagar sir never showed Sita as a hero. But always showed Sita as a victim. Never showed how Ram sacrificed his everything to enhance the praja. Ram Rajya was the best period in history where everyone was prosperous. To achieve that a king has to be like Ram.

[@seenu2323]

Wow man 🙏🙏

[@satyam3993]

Yogi ji wants to know the location of the guy in the middle.

[@komal3715]

😂😂😂😂😂😂 good one

[@komal3715]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@perugugopalakrishna2396]

😂 😂 Tc diladega middle guy ko university se

[@rajeshkurichiopalli3051]

Bhai literally iima likha hua hai like what a weird joke

[@missionIITJEE-lz3go]

@@rajeshkurichiopalli3051 aap chronology samajiye

[@youthf7c343]

"You don't have to manage that war today" apt response to MBA students 😂😂

[@bennitomussollini66]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😁

[@YashuCosGaming]

Sir, if you follow sadhguru's teachings, please refrain to include every MBA student with the person sitting in the middle :)

[@sakshamshukla105]

🤣🤣🤣

[@confidential303]

are these unintellectuals MBA'ers ???? OMG please, locked them up for the rest of their lives...they should not walk openly and speak freely..this is terrifying thought.

[@Meme-vs8dz]

What an amazing answer from Sadhguru 🥳🥰

[@AnuragKumarThakur29]

*"This is just a question of poor memory"* WOW! I REALLY LIKED HOW HE USES HIS WORDS.

[@muditgarg9039]

Random guy: Rama was insecure. Vibhisan:eske paate pe baan mare prabhu.

[@pratyushkumarshrivastava3609]

🤣🤣🤣

[@paritoshjha28]

😂 Op

[@harshsomvanshi8963]

XD

[@IncantationByAanchal]

@Mudit Garg - This is epic 😂🤣

[@tushitis]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@thesatvikbahaley]

Didnt know IIMA had intellectually challenged quota.

[@AshokKushal]

🤣 🤣 🤣

[@rajivnaik3380]

Absolutely!!

[@manubelongtoyou]

more druggists thr

[@anitapandey495]

🤣🤣

[@krishnakalavacharla8866]

Best comment i have read in years!!!

[@artliteraturemusic1152]

I loved the way Sadguru explained. Thank you ❤

[@ashmit6492]

Literally No one can answer with so much perfection Respect from deep inside my heart

[@MrAdityasangar]

The Guy in middle proves how a little achievement makes him such an absurd that he could question sadguru out of his own limited intellect.

[@entertainment4787]

Why can't we question Sadhguru? We definitely can! He was trying to prove his point.... It's more like a debate.... rather than a question and answer session! Neither Sadhguru nor us were alive at that time... so we all can question him!

[@deepanshurathore9661]

@Saloni Pandey 🔥🔥 great replied kl ko yeh Apne parents SE bhi prove mangenge ke yeh inke parents hai 😂😂

[@rajatchaturvedi2589]

@Saloni Pandey 🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@entertainment4787]

@Saloni Pandey Accha isliye padhai likhai nahi kiya? Taki Ram aur Sita mata ko bhakti dikha sako 🤣🤣XD

[@letslearn8813]

@@deepanshurathore9661 Correct 😁

[@tirthshah1580]

Only in India can we debate and question our gods so openly and publicly like this.

[@bhaskars1987]

Well you can question Hinduism and Buddhism anywhere.. Try doing it about prophet or son of God..

[@AnkitKumar-zu7cn]

And some intellectuals say "India has become such an intolerant country"

[@bijaysenapati6455]

Because we are not believers like other we are seekers ..

[@prachingupta4780]

Of course because our culture permits it Even arjun questioned Krishna

[@prathit7541]

That's a good thing. We should be proud.

[@urbnctrl]

Fun fact. The first Anime I ever saw as a child was the Epic of RAMAYANA! ❤ Greets from Amsterdam

[@kapilyadav4399]

This is what ego does, when you get in a top B-school who start seeing yourself greater than god with your limited intellect and knowledge

[@ordinaryperson1902]

Monkey flying without WINGS is Mythology......No Monkey without WINGS could fly or communicate with human...

[@mr.cherrykim9897]

@@ordinaryperson1902 where are you from ?

[@ordinaryperson1902]

Your comment is what happens when you believe in mythology as History. If anyone questions that then people like you start insulting them that they are arrogant rather than listening to them. People like you will listen to Sadhguru about God because he says what you want to hear. You will also believe that a Monkey God can increase and decrease in size because it it written in a book.

[@mr.cherrykim9897]

@@ordinaryperson1902 your comment is what happens when you don't understand my question , i only ask "Where are you from?". You should say your country name which most people will answer in that way.

[@ashishkc8223]

@@ordinaryperson1902 but the flying monkey is not a big thing,the main thing needs to learn is how much he invested towards his idol or something and how much loyal and decent he was to complete the work 🥴✌️

[@aradhya1712]

Hats off to Sadhguru for being so corporative and discussing it in depth. Where as he knows that there's a simple answer to all of the questions.

[@Traveller-95]

Until you want to hear what YOU WANT to hear, you won’t accept the truth that is clearly hanging there. Ultimately, what matters is the truth and moral taught through a story.

[@shivanisanyamsharma]

The moment when honourable Sadhguru said , ' You're taking these things literally ... ' ❤ Such a brilliant and informative person. He has knowledge! Dhobi = Common Man.

[@dwaipayandutta2227]

Interviewer *Loses the debate due to lack of knowledge* Also Interviewer : Let's move on .

[@letslearn8813]

Correct 😂

[@saikirancolourfullpalette]

FROM TIME STAMP 13:47 TO END ...... I LITERALLY CRIED SIR ... JAI SRI RAM

[@rahulchawla6256]

Their questions feel more like an agenda. If you can't accept other's answer then why ask the question?

[@komal3715]

Right ye mann bnakar aaye the ki aaj to hum jitenge par pala bhi pta to sadguru ji se bechare😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@letslearn8813]

@@komal3715 correct, 😂 bewakoof IIM wale

[@nithinsrinivas5749]

If the person you are asking the question to doesn't make sense, that's what you do

[@nirmitkadakia6812]

Its called swinging for the fences...these guys are trying to achieve their 5 mins of global stardom by trying to criticize their own culture

[@PoojaPatel-lv2nj]

Because we want know about it. But the answers didn't satisfied ME.

[@SanaatanSatyaHai]

Thank you, Sadhguru Ji, for your remarkable patience and grace. The ability to listen to such misguided or nonsensical statements and take the time to respond with thoughtfulness and clarity is truly beyond words. It reflects your unwavering commitment to enlightening and guiding others, even when faced with challenging or provocative viewpoints. Sadly, the presence of anti-national sentiments is a growing concern, particularly within some educational institutions where impressionable minds can be influenced. Your efforts to address these issues with wisdom and rationality inspire many to look beyond divisive ideologies and work towards unity and progress Jai Sri Ram 🏹🛕

[@earthspirit516]

The middle boy is treating the Ramayana as if it's a daytime serial!

[@siddeshwarprasad]

right!

[@rahultambe5328]

Look at that guy's attitude. He is not ready to accept what Sadguru is saying..

[@46vedantshetty64]

Siddeshwar Prasad because he is wrong sandguru does not have proof it is just his belief

[@46vedantshetty64]

He can’t tell a story book as a history unless he has proof

[@timepasstp9256]

@@rahultambe5328 Because Sadguru wasn't convincing enough

[@anuragsahu1437]

It can happen only in our culture that some random guy can question about the decision of Lord Ram ! ?? He thinks himself as the maha-mantri of ayodhya. 😂

[@karthik7486]

Actually that's the beauty of our culture. We can question and debate everything. But some idiots now have become so rigid that it's a disgrace to Hinduism

[@shivansh1998]

@Roshan Sengupta where did you read that?

[@Onizukaash]

@@shivansh1998 Maybe from madrasa

[@shivansh1998]

@Roshan Sengupta culture is based on some beliefs and philosophies. Where have you read that questioning everything is the basis of our culture.

[@sgtghost141]

@@shivansh1998 I suppose you are wrong. You have fully not watched Ramayana and Mahabharat. It has been for ages , in our culture people ask questions and a Guru answers their question philosophically. But yes , asking questions and disgracing the culture are two different things and Nobody likes those kind of person who disgraces somebody's culture.

[@rakeshmahto3536]

Seeing these students reminds me of myself that how ignorant and egoistic I am or was. I can relate to them and I also regret of being myself in that category. But I'm learning.

[@technobug4858]

+1

[@saibhaskar3116]

Are you also from iim's

[@ayyappanpillai1769]

Both for questions as well as agendas Sadguru is straight forward with smart answers,my pranams.

[@Charan_Teja33]

Most Unluckiest Girl in the World is the wife of Middle Person..Such a Sadist🤣🤣

[@Vaishnavnairajith]

He can always marry an atheist

[@paritoshjha28]

@@Vaishnavnairajith still she is unlucky

[@charlesfernandes2521]

hahahah ....u genius

[@Charan_Teja33]

@@charlesfernandes2521 🤣🙋‍♂️

[@adyyy00]

What if he is single..

[@meerakrishnan1586]

Namaskaram and Pranams to Sadguru for being so patient and humble with the arrogant full of pride and attitude boys who do not even know how to sit in front of a saintly person...

[@umasuppalapati5073]

Exactly

[@Pradeep-ix6dj]

The guy in the middle looks so insecure!! When he said Ram is insecure.. I ROFL 🤣

[@pavanandagiganapati8179]

This kind of intellectual discussion needs… Sadguru always had cakewalk….

[@abhisheksikarwar9805]

''adhura gyan , hoshiyari kaa saman'' the middle guy shows us

[@pranjalmishra_11]

A Big Salute To Sadguru To Tolerate These People So Patiently If I Would Be There Mene to Us Bande Ka Sir phod Dena Tha 😂

[@atulpandey6394]

That's why he is where he is?

[@bhavanishshetty520]

Same here

[@Sonali_d_p]

Me too

[@rajeshshastrakar2240]

Exactly. I would 🔨🔥🔥🔥

[@kaushik-cy6vo]

Ramayan and Mahabharat are not at all fiction or fairy tales... They are real . Even after more than 8thousand around years to ramayan evidence s can be still found... Even after getting destroyed by invaders and ppl it is still present... Even after so many natural disasters ... Proof of Ravan airport,ramsetu,ram janmbhoomi,place of Rama and Sita marriage place, the floating stones ,the rameshwaram temple,foot prints of Hanuman ,the mountain sanjeevni buti , The place where Ravan kept sita, Lord Hanuman's birth place .. All are present Even today... And scientific and logical claims also suggest that hanuman ,a monkey can be a human and can marry a human too So think before saying . The kurukshetra war place,place where krishna gave Arjuna Gyan is still present ,krishna janmbhoomi,place where krishna defeated the naga is still present,dwarka , I kashmir their is a place where a utensil given to bheem is still present.... And many more... Mahabharata and ramayan are not myth.. So jai shri ram 🙏🏻🕉️

[@7wik.satwikguptadev]

I am glad and lucky I never went to IIM to become one like them.......🙏🙏🙏🙏❣️🚩🕉️

[@invisible9578]

These institutes don't make people so... It's just what kind of people these Institutes get..

[@aureliano_37]

IIM ahmedabad is shite anyway

[@gayatrigurav4542]

Thankgod i am raised so so well by my parents ❤️ thankyou sooo much to my parents ❤️ forever grateful

[@manishpatil8769]

After reading the comment section, the middle guy be like, "Main MC tha jo usme gya"😅😅

[@anshuuu9708]

Trueeee

[@letslearn8813]

😁😂

[@sachindhanvade3881]

👍

[@veeruchauhan9176]

Ab se wo bhi jis kisi se milta hoga bolta hoga Seetaram Seetaram

[@vaibhav2000100]

@@veeruchauhan9176 🙏😅👍

[@bhavikvora6377]

I want to ask to the middle guy, what you want to hear? Idk why he's even asking when he doesn't want to know.

[@ishitasrivastava5923]

I AM LITERALLY VERY SORRY FOR THOSE TWO BOYS .. MAY LORD RAM GIVE THEM SOME BUDDHI

[@tanishqsinghbajwa4542]

I am sorry for u

[@truthboi400]

@@tanishqsinghbajwa4542 i am sorry for your mother

[@tanishqsinghbajwa4542]

@Chota Pandit wish Ur grandmother used precautions

[@isaacnewton7424]

@Tanishq Singh Bajwa my hands are itching.

[@_..-.._]

But for them it's all myth.