Arthur vs. John - RDR 2 | Who is Best?

[@Aband0ned_Bread]

Funfact: Johns deadeye is the same sound as in rdr1

[@Redemption360.]

Thats hawe its supose to be

[@מיכאל-כורנל]

It's cooler

[@WillMcConnell-hv4xd]

Ya the same

[@samashpubgnew]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/a5XCpH9oj795p8U

[@Branel756]

@@Redemption360.yes but it s just a small detail which not everyone notices

[@Someunknownrandm]

Fun fact: As you get through chapters the clicking of the clock becomes faster. So the clicking sound is faster in chapter 6 than chapter 1

[@AdotTooTactical]

That ties into my comment

[@SIEGTHEGOATFRFR]

Not everythings about you bud​@@AdotTooTactical

[@JayK60]

@@SIEGTHEGOATFRFR😂

[@DeadMeat991]

@@SIEGTHEGOATFRFR His point stands, though.

[@SIEGTHEGOATFRFR]

@@DeadMeat991 I'm gonna eat your meat

[@AdotTooTactical]

The clicking of arthurs dead eye is a clock slowly counting down how much time he has before he ☠️

[@TheGermanReichtangle]

Bro 💀

[@AdotTooTactical]

@@TheGermanReichtangle you prolly think I’m joking around it’s literally proven the devs themselves said it

[@TheGermanReichtangle]

@@AdotTooTactical no it isnt and I said "bro 💀" not to say your wrong but like thats messed up lol

[@AdotTooTactical]

@@TheGermanReichtangle it actually is and mb there’s a lot of people that’ll say anything on the net

[@UJHHYHG-jd3sk]

​@TheGermanReichtangle it is the ticking only starts playing the second you finish the "a fork in the road"

[@baron4119]

Man i remember my first time playing RDR2 and first introduced to Arthur and i was like "Who's this jackass? Where's my man John?" Until the later chapter i am starting to know his character even more and then final chapters i can see Arthur's final moments to make amends for what he did from the early chapter. I cried so hard in his final ride to the camp and left everyone behind so that John and the others could escape. Rest in peace Arthur Morgan, you truly are a good man.

[@BlaZe92]

❤️❤️

[@Sianessie]

I hate both of them

[@flerc729]

He murdered an entire town

[@Jim_crawley]

@@flerc729him and his gang in storymode

[@MeMyselfandMyPonies]

Man same I was so pissed I couldn’t play John and over time I grew to love Arthur so much man it still hurts watching him die 😭

[@Adnani_]

😂😂😂😂😂I remember Arthur joking when he said to John, "You seem worried because we are so close to the water." 🤣I became an Iraqi celebrity

[@justsomedude7747]

Lol where did he say that ?

[@Adnani_]

@@justsomedude7747 At the beginning of the game, I think the first or second camp

[@gamingghost212]

@@Adnani_ 3rd chapter

[@SomeGuyIn2241]

can't herd, CAN'T SWIM

[@troy242621]

"Oh don't you start."

[@antouf8322]

Making short hair to John is a crime against Humanity, cowboy !

[@BlaZe92]

😄

[@alieldeenahmed60]

Beard on 10 is even a bigger crime

[@alieldeenahmed60]

I like to make him just as rdr1

[@Phantomjoeseph]

@@alieldeenahmed60real

[@BeatleHarrison]

Short or long hair doesn’t make a difference lol, he’s still gonna look like Arthur

[@RuHanSolo]

Everyone knows "Marston can't swim"

[@EmpoleonElMejor]

*Tommy Vercety has joined the chat*

[@SpuddyWesker]

bigowl also says dogs cant look up

[@FootballEditz20245]

*Toni Cipriani joined the chat* If you wanna know true scroll down Its becouse of rdr1

[@dasarimusic]

😂

[@nightmarepegasus4141]

Yeah true 😂 But everyone knows he's the quickest learner, if at any point of the story he had to swim, he would have made his way If dutch and hosea were good parents, they would have taught him to swim John would understand how to swim, learn in a very few time if he wanted to

[@retrostoatgaming6936]

Keeping both eyes open for aiming is actually a valid (and in some cases superior) shooting method. It allows better depth perception and can help with retaining better focus on the situation. It can also help prevent you from aiming too low or too high. Shooting with one eye on the other hand, can prevent distractions, make it easier to make out distant details and prevent double vision. Typically single eye shooting is used by snipers, novice to intermediate shooters or hobbyists. Professionals, SWAT teams and many soldiers in the military tend to employ shooting with both eyes. My guess on why Arthur uses both eyes is because he was taught how to shoot by older members of the posse. Some of which were former military (like Bill Williamson). Arthur's father was also an outlaw, so it would make sense that Arthur probably had better teachers. John may use one eye for his shooting because he'd formerly been an orphan, and was probably mostly self taught before he had been adopted into the gang. Of course, both methods have their advantages and disadvantages, are both valid and sustainable, and at the end of the day whoever shoots straightest won't typically depend on how many eyes you use.

[@wolwiderlegends2340]

For me, your comment might be the best and most informative one I have seen in this video. Thank you for writing it.

[@Javier.Escuellaa]

Yeah I came to comment somewhere that I was taught to keep both eyes open during USMC boot camp. Might as well put it here

[@lil_jackgamez8992]

That's actually really cool I had learned about both growing up The first was my dad when we went hunting for deer and the other by my grandpa that was a vet in the Vietnam war.

[@daddybego]

It makes me feel drunk, idk how Arthur does it.

[@nightmarepegasus4141]

​@@daddybegoit also depend of the person, not everyone has the same vision, eye focus, some people have an eye "superior" in term of vision ( i don't know how to explain lol). So you can train with both eyes open, maybe you'll be better at it, but as the main com said, none is better than the other, they are just slightly different

[@guacajanaitor2099]

maybe the sound of the dead eye has a meaning. Example, Arthur's dead eye is a timer meaning the time he has left to redem himself before he dies of TB, meanwhile John heartbeat means he has something to fight (a reason, like his family)

[@AdotTooTactical]

Ok so you basically said what I said but made it much more complicated

[@guacajanaitor2099]

@@AdotTooTactical i wrote this without reading your opinon lil Bro, the world doesn't revolve around you, and don't you have anything better than do? Jesus, i just gave my opinion

[@AdotTooTactical]

@@guacajanaitor2099 I actually do I just comment on everyone’s replies on my free time but hey that’s your opinion and also I never said the world revolves around me I just said my opinion just like you mb your panties got in a bunch about it didn’t know a simple comment would hurt someone’s feelings so much

[@crostirsterqi3065]

@@guacajanaitor2099salty over nothing

[@gabrieldurr5254]

@@AdotTooTactical nah, yours is just more simplistic

[@SleepyjoeOG]

Arthur’s deadeye use to jump scare tf outta me when I’d accidentally used it 😭

[@Cent4rion]

Low honor sound managed to once jumpscare me when i placed a saddle on a horse stolen from grays during the fine joys of tobacco

[@Auxiliary542]

Did you know: the clicking for arthur is a clock and its to symbolise he's running out of time being alive and the heartbeat for john is supposed symbolise John's family and how no matter when he is thinking about his family

[@Zamandu]

Where did you get this information? Or is this just your headcanon?

[@Auxiliary542]

@Zamandu I got it from the actual game because as Arthur it's a clock and as john it's a heartbeat

[@Brother-Dorkins]

Arthur’s deadeye is foreshadowing that his “time” is almost being up

[@LikeIverson3]

@@Brother-Dorkins that’s why the clocks ticks faster as u develop through the chapters

[@LikeIverson3]

that’s why the clock ticks faster the further u get through the chapters

[@sussyreincon1515]

Ngl the clicking sound is really cool if u think from a perspective where Arthur was so skilled that he knew when his focus would end

[@notalwaysseriousorsilly]

its also the fact his sickens lets him know when his time will end which is also because the clicking speeds up every chapter

[@zyyn1197]

@@notalwaysseriousorsilly The clicking sound only has to do with the focus time, it has nothing to do with the life

[@Flayre01]

@@zyyn1197 youre absolutely wrong, the ticking of the clock increasing in speed through each chapter is a representation of his imminent death, along side the clock, there will also be a heartbeat that plays either louder to not at all based on your honor level, the heartbeat sound plays the same way for john as well, everything about deadeye says something about the state of the character in this game, from its animations to sounds, in terms of animation in low honor a white line starts deadeye left to right and the opposite for high honor

[@zyyn1197]

@ test it before copying and pasting

[@thecouldntbe]

"Orthor" - Dutch

[@marlonvega4223]

I have a plan

[@Goofygoober_509]

@@marlonvega4223”HAVE SOME GAWD DAMN FAITH”

[@cristianc.6048]

@@marlonvega4223 we need money Orthor!

[@toddkennedy1329]

-Datch*

[@superslime3523]

did you just say you committed tax evasion? i thought i raised you better son 🤬

[@SerSerington]

I met Roger Clark IRL once & he was the nicest human being on the planet. In his honor, I always stop my playthrough before the final mission of Chapter 4 (the Guarma trip trigger) & keep a maxed out healthy Arthur for free roam.

[@Rockingchairdreamer]

Yup I’ve a chapter 4 save

[@giovanebaggio2943]

My theory on the deadeye sounds: Arthur has a clock-ticking sound symbolizing his perfect timing for each shot (one nano second more and you’re dead) while John has heartbeat sounds for each shot is based off his survival instincts. Arthur draws with intentions to kill while John draws with intentions to survive

[@lolpeakaboo]

No Marstons sound is because thats the normal deadeye sound from the first game and arthurs is a clock because he is going to die soon

[@nightmarepegasus4141]

Cool theory i have to say

[@jdv8412]

Spot on theory my guy!

[@brandonwhite142]

less than 1/3 sec draw time is actually wild

[@brandonwhite142]

@intonerfive No. Actually there's not lol not in real life anyways. A 1 sec draw to first shot is standard. 3/4 sec draw to first shot is considered quick. !f you have a 1/3 draw to first shot I can almost guarantee its gonna be a miss

[@blackblaze4830]

@@brandonwhite142 look up world fastest quickdraw and quickdraw competitions its just a few minutes and you can see people going below 1 second

[@anthonyernst999]

​@LSBFRYSX If you count deadeye, then they have an unnatural speed and accuracy, which is impossible for anyone in real life

[@blackblaze4830]

@@anthonyernst999 ?..why you counting a game mechanic in real life? also have you seen the world fastest quick draw guy can shot 2 bullets in 1 secod if thats the closes of a dead eye you can have

[@anthonyernst999]

@@blackblaze4830 All of Red Dead 2 is game mechanics.

[@mattiabiasco867]

High Honor's Dead Eye: White line starts from right to the left. Low Honor's Dead Eye: White line starts from the left to the right.

[@justmekyle_55]

Hadn't noticed that detail before

[@mattiabiasco867]

@@justmekyle_55 It probably means something. The right side should be the righteous/benevolent side. The left side should be the dark or "bad" side.

[@ibraheemshuaib8954]

​@mattiabiasco867 In plays, the heroes usually come from the right and villains come from the left.

[@TheDropoutBear]

What white line

[@mattiabiasco867]

@@TheDropoutBear When you activate Dead Eye, a white line can be seen on the screen that turns the screen yellow.

[@Sam.Matt.3699]

I really love this video, the way that John is in the desert and Arthur is in the mountains, keep up the good work

[@MichaelJesmer]

I appreciate that you actually compared them in the game world using the game physics. Every other comparison video I've seen has a short clip then blasts this generations dubstep while scoring them based on random stats

[@BlaZe92]

@@MichaelJesmer ❤️❤️

[@ransomdekafenya2584]

Just the swimming shit alone is like playing GTA backwards starting at San An. Ridiculous. 😂

[@donovanbowen5146]

You did John dirty with the swimming test

[@bmsuperstar1]

That's like measuring who died first. It's just not fair. I don't like Arthur anyways.

[@estephens4483]

There is always something extra about this game you never knew like I had no idea that arthur keeps both his eyes open when aiming and never honestly realised both of there deadeye's sounded different, Just when you think you know everything it keeps surprising you its amazing

[@luckybynn5788]

I just noticed in my most recent playthrough that the doctor in Valentine is Jim Boy Calloway's cousin. And that Lenny is trying to help Sean learn to read. And that gang members going out for guard duty will react if you aim a gun at them. That one was pretty funny because it was Sean and he said "Who goes there?" or whatever and by the time he got close enough to actually see me I was scoped in on his head with a rifle and he lurched back and went "Jaysus!"

[@kydengarrison7898]

John's dead sound the same as rdr1 and he shuts his left eye cause he is blind in his left eye from the wolf attack

[@brodylowe5443]

Pretty sure he closes his eye for better shooting accuracy, not because he’s blind in one eye.

[@WillMcConnell-hv4xd]

Ya

[@badsie1]

His eyes are both open in the unused animations, its not really that deep considering ...john doesnt have.... his own body, animations exept walking, his hair texture is arthurs, changed eye colour, his face shape arthurs etc.

[@czahnnunh2263]

@@badsie1i heard he has a ton of unused rdr1 looking animations that were made for the epilogue, doesnt he also look more like his npc self in 1.00?

[@badsie1]

@@czahnnunh2263 in that version its a little better but barely, not to rant but i feel rockstar should have spent more time on the epilogue, as John's character is very off for being 4 years away from rdr1 and he doesn't even have his own model basicly... theres one image i saw where he looks like an ogre an actual ogre and another one where he has clean shaven face and long hair and looks like... some ghoul... I think the only animation which is used is his walking one but i dont remember if its correct, i know when he vomits they use arthurs voice line, even tho he has his own recorded.

[@r_apt_ure]

Arthur Morgan in my opinion is without a doubt the best video game character ever, never before have I become emotional over a game until RDR2. Roger brought him to life like no other.

[@tenki_]

Arthur’s Dead Eye sound being the ticking of a clock to symbolize he’s racing against time is **chef’s kiss**

[@zyyn1197]

So he's been racing against time since the first mission? Even before he got sick?

[@MilkyGames17]

It looks like Arther has both of his eyes closed. Bro doesn't even need to look

[@HafidzMurshidie]

I loved that John not being able to swim is originally a limitation of the first game, and I'm glad that they brought that back in RDR2 with a convincing narrative purpose.. And making Arthur can swim and John can't in the same game is just another level of top notch detail..

[@astonedwalrus4183]

If you keep both eyes open while aiming a gun and train enough to do it it will GREATLY increase your ability to spot movement in foreground and a whole bunch of other pros, but it takes a lot of practice and training.

[@oioi-h5b]

rdr2はほんとに面白くて感動した。大人になってからゲームに感情移入したのはこれが初めてだし多分これからもない。それにゲーム達成率100%にしたのはgtaivとこれだけ。

[@maxb8695]

Cp77 made me feel the same way if you’re looking for another one

[@User-12947I]

Yeah 😢

[@alejandroangulo327]

That of the dead eye.. Actually has differences depending of the honor you have If its low, no heartbeat

[@daddybego]

Arthur taught John everything but swimming

[@user-hx6gs9rq7u]

He didn’t teach John anything. The game never says Arthur taught John

[@daddybego]

@@user-hx6gs9rq7u No but he obviously did, the game doesn't have to tell you something for it to be true

[@Oknahidwin]

@@daddybego no he didn't they joined the gang at around the same time

[@MyNameIsOzymandias]

John in RDR 2 feels like modded skin of Arthur. Wish Rockstar paid more attention for John's model.

[@LO0IC]

well to be fair, you only play as him for a short time of the story, if you dont keep playing after you beat the story

[@MyNameIsOzymandias]

@@LO0IC There are many side missions even after you complete the story.

[@LO0IC]

@@MyNameIsOzymandias really? for me after i beat epilouge it was just the mayor mission

[@MyNameIsOzymandias]

@@LO0IC There are still some missions left if you didn't complete them as Arthur. And this game is so deep, I feel like I can still do many things. I still play it even though I completed it 100%.

[@LO0IC]

@@MyNameIsOzymandias Yeah, but i wish there was more stuff you could do than just explore after you beat the game, cause even though exploring can be fun, it can be annoying when theres no clues as to where something is.

[@maszynista7642]

John's Dead Eye sounds are exactly the same as in the first game

[@WillMcConnell-hv4xd]

Ya

[@hydratedpanda8518]

The fact that John can’t swim genuinely hurts me whenever I need to cross any body of water

[@A_horrible_name]

It’s a great detail that John has one eye closed because he has a bad ete

[@MrGreytones]

in the us military you are trained to keep both eyes open while aiming this could indicate that arthur was in the military for a period of time

[@KingKloudy]

Don’t worry John, I can’t swim well neither. 😂

[@fr_thatkid]

YOU COULDN'T SHOOT A FART OUT OF YOU'RE OWN ASS!!!!

[@lame-o420]

should also consider that in rdr2 epilogue/postgame John was more or less a skin over the same model they used for Arthur, so Arthur Morgan is and will always be the OG

[@Zombotanik]

Arthur Deadeye is perfected by training (Ticking sound, like Arthur is counting each milisecond) John Deadeye is just him doing what comes natural (John is just doing everything he feels he needs)

[@PalmontCity4life]

-Mr Bell? -uh yes? -Mr Van Der Linde sends his regards

[@sudburyshore]

I'll always have more of an attachment to John even though I love Arthur. John is my guy all the way. He had such a heartbreaking story.

[@Napsta_Blooky]

by the way the dead eye is the same for both, it only changes because of Honor. Low Honor and High Honor has different Dead Eye noises.

[@mehshutup3041]

Wrong, JM's deadeye use RDR1's deadeye sound effect.

[@mehshutup3041]

wrong, J hon marsfon

[@darkknightenberg]

wrong

[@Jorgetrois]

Que mentira

[@Sadrany]

wrong

[@RealGhostface-y9b]

Actually,if we're being technical,Arthur's draw is 2 ms faster than John's,which matters a lot in the wild west

[@rus778]

their draw time is literally the exact same

[@Nierr1]

Thats a very high quality video! love the editing

[@Illkeepherinblack]

I love john's deadeye sound more, cus when i hear the ticking as arthur it is so uncomfortable😭

[@Snake_eyes0]

Yhea to me John's just sounds better

[@fafflytailslogisonicuite104]

In terms of comparison, RDD1 Joh marston was an epic student , he followed Arthur's steps perfectly when it comes to being an epic Gunslinger. It's also fun seeing people comment theories about both character's dead eyes sound, when deep down, Marston's dead eye is just the same sound from the first game.

[@MonkeySensei619]

John aiming with a single eye could be because of him being blind in one of his eyes (he hints at it in both games and has outfits in rdr1 which have eyepatches on his blind eye)

[@mariadelmarydetectivejose152]

Good video👍 I am Subscribed and like

[@Malevolence460]

I am comment number 1000 :D - I wish John had his own set of animations and such

[@xBegGaming]

Me too

[@bull_mang]

Cool video❤️

[@Whiteboyawesome-s1u]

The reason John only aims with one eye is because when he’s actually blind in the other from the wolf attack which is also why he wears an eyepatch on the one outfit in rdr1

[@ashishmohare7863]

Itna detail bhai… thats why we love this game ❤

[@ItsMrs.Marston]

I have another theory that the reason for Arthurs ticking sound when deadeye is activated is because of the small amount of time he has to react quickly and draw his gun out on his opponent, whilst Johns sound of a heartbeat means that he must keep his composure during a draw.

[@Pindeckoo1]

Its actually theorised that the clock is arthur's time left alive due to TB

[@fr_thatkid]

@ItsMrs.Marston "i have to use my rizz" Abigail Roberts...i have big D

[@zyyn1197]

@@Pindeckoo1 This is the fake that everyone loves to believe

[@lowang9708]

I love john, i like the man he comes right after he witnesses how his friend died helping him, he made sure Arthur died for a reason by chasing every last one of them but most importantly imo was the fact that he started taking his father duties seriously and raised his family.

[@zale029]

Team Arthur | √

[@omglol8425]

Both are the same, except one is more badass and the other is a better written character

[@xavierforsyth7350]

Arthur is more badass but yeah John is much better written.

[@Snake_eyes0]

​@@xavierforsyth7350John is both in rdr1

[@anthonyernst999]

​@omglol8425 I feel like they both are well written and badass. The main difference is the compassion a high honor Arthur feels for people. John is more coldhearted

[@omglol8425]

@@anthonyernst999 yeah I don’t even know why I made that comment. I don’t even see it that way

[@Aalpha7.]

Amazing 🤩

[@UmbralAzrael73]

They're both incredible

[@Leenie280]

Not gonna sub but very good vid. Keep it up than maybe

[@BlaZe92]

I appreciate it

[@johnny1o1]

Looks like arthur keeps both eyes closed 😂😂😂

[@Arleyszj]

Joder que buen vídeo lo veré mas de 2 veces

[@overnightavenger1470]

I enjoyed playing as John more

[@fr_thatkid]

W

[@Baleboss69]

Ya same here even tho it ain’t rdr1 John

[@marcohodac8324]

Finally a good comparison and not just an amout of subjective scores

[@thejumpropeninja9820]

ah shit guess i am playing it once more

[@sennanmp]

you should never stop playing

[@William11987]

hell geah bro everytime you stop playing rdr2 arthur will slowly come out of his grave and he will come to your house at night while you're sleeping and he will eat your ahh.

[@sennanmp]

@@William11987 bro WHAT

[@Jacob-ux8io]

I didn't know Arthur and John had different Dead Eye sounds till now.

[@giovellymatondang9977]

sounds at dead eye different depends on your honor

[@youngcityking6017]

Naw, that last one. Sent a shiver down my spine. It all makes sense now

[@dudown_1631]

Arthur > RDR2 John John RDR1 >>> Arthur

[@Mr.OrganStealer]

Facts bro 💯

[@NateS917]

Nah

[@StudioPencill]

Fr

[@Mr.OrganStealer]

@@NateS917 Cope

[@Hexstared]

@@NateS917 yuh huh

[@stevo1110]

Bro the fact that John closes one eye while Arthur keeps both his eyes open is such an amazing detail.

[@Negetive-zero]

Arthur best ❌ John best ❌ RDR2 best ✅

[@arianbahadori9454]

عالییی😂😂❤❤❤ولی یوسف دیگه rust نمیزاری😓

[@Rip_van_winkle-rdr2]

Erm yeah I can't swim...

[@VRimpressions]

@Rip_van_winkle-rdr2 John Marston you're finally here I've been waiting for ya you damn fool

[@Rip_van_winkle-rdr2]

@@VRimpressions oh um abijail was yapping again..

[@UltramateSL]

Supiri machan ❤

[@BlaZe92]

Thanks bro! 🥰🥰

[@andrewchatmon]

Hi

[@BlaZe92]

Hello

[@JustKidding908]

Good afternoon

[@MdAnan8536]

​@@BlaZe92Damn.... Didn't know you were chill like that

[@NFC369]

John : "so, do you think I'm an idiot?" Uncle : "No!!, I know you're an idiot!" So the winner is Arthur

[@Faritshorts285]

Hello

[@BlaZe92]

Hey bro!

[@drfabulous2804]

I always like John better. RDR2 doesn’t compare to RDR1 in my opinion.

[@samzony]

LOL

[@balajik2681]

If you play as Arthur you would know it

[@drfabulous2804]

@@balajik2681 elaborate?

[@Andrewtate200]

That's why you are a blind fanboii in my opinion 😂

[@drfabulous2804]

@@Andrewtate200 maybe I just have opinions that differ from yours. Try not to let that blow your mind.

[@kindmusician333]

I love most things about Arthur more including the Dead Eye sound

[@HyagoGabri-sg4gf]

John marston in rdr1 ☠️🥶

[@Star_x618]

RIP Arthur Morgan 😢😢 RIP John Marston 😢😢

[@Notthatracisttbh]

I feel like the deadeye sound is a testament to their skills in deadeye. Arthur's is slow and quiet enough that you could hear his watch ticking while John's is significantly slower and quieter causing him to hear his own heartbeat.

[@Amin-w2g]

it's 6 years i'm playing this game and i know i'm not the only 1

[@enelanonimato6704]

actually Arthur's dead eye varies depending on honor, you can hear a heartbeat in high honor but only the clock on low honor

[@SoggyDoritosmemes]

You did John dirty with the swimming one💀💀💀

[@mr.legend3531]

POV: Thomas Shelby joins the chat Arthur and John are my fooking brothers

[@SorchaSublime]

The fact they remembered that there was no swimming in RDR1 and actually took swimming away from the player in the epilogue is great

[@U-A660]

Bro causally roasted John on that second one and thought we didn’t notice.

[@matthewmcmillan1835]

Arthur's dead eye is a clock, as it shows his limited time left of life. Where as John's is a heart beat, as he has a family and feels love.

[@Zachvang2]

Arthur’s experience with guns is really impressive for a gunslinger,he can compete to other legendary gunslingers.his eyes are always open,shown by as an experienced gunslinger.

[@Genyuine]

I really wish they didn't cut corners and remove all of what made john unique. Everything from his build to his actions when you control him was originally supposed to be akin to how he was in red dead 1, but because they wanted to rush the game that basically shrunk arthurs model down, stuck johns head on it and called it a day

[@HeistheA]

HOW COULD YOU ?!! Not shooting Micah while being in front of him with a gun is the worst sun ever !

[@filipflidr2654]

Never realized how similar they are

[@sfa1010]

Arthur is a real sniper, they close the eye the aren’t aiming with when they sight in, then open it up again for peripheral vision.

[@thebankich5662]

Bro you forgot to compare their drawing/painting skills

[@Imafraid-5f1]

Arthurs dead eye becomes faster and faster as the prologue/story continues representing his time that's about to end. Johns dead eye represents his life that he wants to live with his family.

[@BlackLvng]

The ticking sound represents Arthur’s time ticking away, meaning how long he has left, it gets faster as you go through the chapters. The heartbeat represents John’s family and his love for them.

[@GraysonBougas]

The QuickDraw was unfair. John had a Mauser pistol, and Arthur had a Schofield revolver. But I guess this means that Arthur is faster because if they both had Mauser’s Arthur would win

[@COINTO55]

Also, Arthur’s walking animation is way better then john’s

[@archiestanfield9733]

I think the reason John closes that eye is either a detail he had in RDR1 (I’ve never played it so tell me if he closes his eye) because the swimming thing transferred to RDR2 because in RDR1 they didn’t want the player to explore outside the map closed off by water, but another reason he closes his eye might be because he’s blind in it, because when I’m the mission with Javier when you rescue John, his eye is bloody and looks like it’s badly injured to even missing, so it’s probably just that scar

[@alejandromartinjimenez7332]

BEAUTIFUL VÍDEO 😍😍