Band-Maid / Secret My Lips + Band-Maiko / Secret Maiko Lips REACTIONS | Metal Musician Reacts

[@TheChampOfMedium]

Honestly loving reading the responses on this one guys... ya'll are the best.

[@trolleewang2672]

give me a paypal link so I can send you money$$$!!!

[@trolleewang2672]

BTW did you know this is the only band maid song that has MISA singing? The howl at the beginning of the video is actually MISA

[@jerithchaos]

Dude you need to check out waggaki band. They play nothing but this style of modern rock with traditional instruments together. And they ate fucking awesome

[@ricecharles]

"I can't even deal with these people!" Champ's 2020 slogan.

[@curtisrrobles7885]

I'm not a musician but I have learned so much listening to your explanations and breakdowns of Band-Maid's music. You have fine tuned my ears to the little things. Your reactions are just as fun as watching Live Band-Maid videos. Thank you. FYI in the beginning of Secret Maiko Lips Miku's writing translates to World Domination.

[@tbod119]

I've been playing bass now for 25 years and the fills Misa throws in all over the place makes my brain implode

[@sheldoncooper8199]

@T Bod Check her Bass Playing on Endless Story its her Best

[@tommcfall1274]

I AM A 68 YEAR OLD JAZZ FUSION PROG ROCK DRUMMER WHO SAW ALL THE GREATS IN THE 70'S AND 80'S BUT BUT THIS BAND IS SO FUCKING INCREDIBLE. AKANE CONTSTANTLY AMAZES ME AS SAKI MIKU MISA ANDS KANAMOMANICHO

[@sheldoncooper8199]

@@tommcfall1274 Yeah and they get better and better cant wait for January 21 th for their New CD.

[@alxvdark]

Non musician here: I hear the complexity in the song-writing, but as you point out specific moments, it helps me to listen more closely. You've also helped me to understand the chorus/verse/pre-chorus/bridge/transition elements of a song, which I have been a bit sketchy about (beyond chorus and verse). I definitely get more out of the music as a result of your reactions, so thank you. :-) Also: stop the video when you have something to say. If I just wanted to listen to the song...I'd go listen to the song (again)!

[@razor1uk610]

You said what I've thought,, and said it better than myself, you write exactly what I thinking/feeling.

[@johnnylaroux9517]

@@razor1uk610 ...and not only that, but also that what he exactly wrote reads as right, as well......

[@peripeteia7]

Same here, pointing out the specific moments and the techniques they use has helped me realize why I like them so much and appreciate them even more. And yes, stop the videos by all means. I too would just go and listen to their songs if I wanted to listen to them uninterrupted.

[@hernanuliana9111]

Before the covid forced me to work from home and have more time to "waste" in KZbin, I think all reaction videos were useless cheap dollar cashgrabs. Well, I was wrong. I mean, a lot are useless cheap dollar cashgrabs, but some teach me how to listen more carefully to music. You're one of the best of them my friend, thank you. Plus, I discovered two of my new favorite bands, Band Maid and Maximum The Hormone, and the wonderful world of japanese rock. (Edit several hours latter) I feel bad for my commentary. It's totally fine search for an extra buck doing reactions, specially in the times we're living. It's totally unfair call them like I call them. Maybe I don't like their reactions but I'm being hipocrytical because I often defend the people who try new stuff, even if they are terrible at the begining, and I don't know their history. Damn catholic education, love your brother and all that stuff.

[@crapstirrer]

Still true if it's just a guy bopping his head along with the music. But stick a musician or music teacher there and you'll learn something new.

[@DanielDiRezze]

there are "real" reactions with people knowing what they are talking about (whether they like or not BM)... and they are those who need views. And BandMaid is a easy way to make more the 2k views. Sad but true. A+

[@TheChampOfMedium]

Dont worry homie, I knew what you were saying.

[@nussekuddenxxx6564]

You might be the only reactor I don't mind pausing in the middle of a riff, solo or transition. Don't know why. Respect!

[@mickypinestraw7866]

That he sounds like he knows what he's talking about helps... but then he usually goes back and replays it over again. A lot reactors will just pause it, say something stupid and then just un-pause. 'Spacebar Blah-Blah Spacebar'

[@carrickglover9777]

Did you notice... Miku has re-written the lyrics into traditional Japanese (Kyoto dialect)

[@johnnylaroux9517]

What self respecting uni-lingual Anglophone would not have picked-up on that?

[@TheChampOfMedium]

Not even a little... shame me.

[@Kevin6059]

Okini for pointing that out.

[@minobu75]

You are absolutely right, also totally change the sound of the lyrics of the song, greetings.

[@thatguyjay42]

Yup, and Kyoto (Gion) is famous for Maiko and Geisha. Its fun hearing the difference when they are doing kansai-ben.

[@hiamp2k10]

This actually came before Domination. But you may have already known that. I never really thought about how the solos were pretty much the same but yeah. Since they are the greatest band on earth I can forgive it. And yeah I think I like the Maiko version a little better too. As for Band Maiko, ya gotta do Gion-cho next. Another beautiful video and a great song (not a remake). Oh and I don't think you've done YOLO yet....would love to see you do that one....shocker, it's another killer Band Maid song. And Endless Story and Daydreaming and Choose Me for that matter. Damn you haven't done Rinne yet either! Make sure you do the MV on that one and not the truncated live TV version. That one's gonna knock you on your ass. Love seeing your genuine appreciation of this mind-blowing band, thank you. When you have friends in real life who have pretty much lost their passion for music and can barely be bothered to give ANYthing a genuine listen, it's nice to have people like you around to share in the greatness and truly appreciate just how important and special these magical ladies are.

[@Slippy6582]

Yeah... Band-Maid is doing Band-Maid stuff... This was just an april fool for the fans. They named themselves Band-Maiko on social media etc., released this AWESOME video and said: Yeah, we are now Band-Maiko. It wasn´t the last time they did it, because their fans LOVED IT SO MUCH! They even asked if they could tour as this band, but they said the clothes are very heavy and uncomfortable, it´s not possible to rock out in these outfits. STILL... What an effort for their fans, we love them, they love us... That´s how it should be!

[@armynurseboy]

I had heard they did Band-Maiko versions of some songs when they played in Kyoto. Sans the kimonos of course....

[@fastskipper777]

@@armynurseboy Yes, they did. And we will never see it. Japanese follow the rules and never record on their smartphones.

[@crapstirrer]

Happy Birthday MISA.

[@MrBryanwithay]

Currently my favorite band, bar none. I grew up on "classic rock" and if this band would have been around in the late 70s early 80s they would have melted faces off. Gene Simons would have signed them and had them opening for KISS until KISS ended up opening for Band-Maid. Rush would have partied with them (Geddie Lee and Misa would be talking shop although Misa would probably pound a bottle of Jack Daniels with Michael Anthony) Akane and Neil Pert would talk shop and have a contest to see who can beat the metronome for timing and Eddie Van Halen would be getting Kanami into trouble. Saiki would probably slap the shit out of David Lee Roth and Miku would probably come up with new ideas with Gene Simons on how to entertain the audience...

[@razor1uk610]

@Bryan ^^ and that is a effing understatement, well said and one of the funniest yet could've been true if in that alternate-time scenario.

[@scottmcgregor562]

There would be a rush to sign this band. In the 80s Prince would have also been rushing in to work or produce Band Maid.

[@rickwagner-]

Kanami had help in the studio adding the virtual traditional instruments, but she composed all of those parts herself. She mentioned that she learned a lot getting hands on in the studio with this version. Miku rewrote the lyrics in Kansai-ben (Kyoto area type of accent and phrasing). That's the traditional dialect used in the old Capital of Kyoto, identified with Geisha culture. The other members were blown away at what those two accomplished.

[@OtobokeGaijin6218]

Kyoto can't be "identified with geisha culture" because there aren't any geisha in Kyoto. In Kyoto they're invariably referred to as "geiko". They're "geisha" in Tokyo, and Tokyo's geisha culture and Kyoto's geiko culture are different in various ways, including dialect, terminology, manners, and customs. (Some other cities have similar entertainers and use either "geisha" or "geiko", but Tokyo and Kyoto are the largest centers.) "Kansai-ben" (more properly "Kinki Hogen", though they don't entirely overlap) is the general dialect of the Kansai region, and the Japanese refer to Kyoto speech, which is a sub-dialect of Kansai-ben, as "Kyo-kotoba" or "Kyoto-ben". When they talk with their customers, geiko and maiko will use standard modern Kyoto speech, but there are many expressions unique to the geiko/maiko culture, some of which go back 100-200 years. The language used in Kyoto when it was capital is somewhat different from modern Kyoto speech, and some of the geiko/maiko expressions originate in the old language, but basically geiko/maiko, wherever they're actually from, use the modern Kyoto dialect. Akane speaks in Kansai-ben, being from Hyogo Prefecture, and Misa would have grown up speaking something similar, as she's from Okayama Prefecture. The Kansai-origin musicians tend to bond when they're in Tokyo. Mikio Fujioka of Babymetal's Kami Band, Akane, and Midori of Lovebites, to mention three, hung out in Tokyo.

[@ontaka5997]

Back in 2018, as an April Fool's Joke, Band-Maid announced that they have disbanded "Band-Maid" and started a new band called "Band-Maiko". Maiko is an apprentice geisha in Kyoto (the old capital of Japan). So instead of dressing up in maid outfits, they dressed up in kimonos and wore maiko makeups, and released an MV with a rearranged version of "Secret My Lips", where Saiki sang in the Kyoto dialect, and traditional Japanese instruments were added. At the time, they did it just as an April fool's joke but the next year, they released a new song on Aprils fools day "Giyon-cho", and a mini-album with 6 re-arranged songs with Japanse traditional instruments added. According to Kanami (the lead guitarist) in an interview, she added "sampled" traditional instruments with the help of an engineer.

[@dusterrant9332]

Honestly as someone who isn't a musician, I really almost never noticed bass before this band. Its what I really love is, if I really pay attention, I can pretty much pick out each instrument and what they're doing(Miku is still hard for me pick out sometimes). Its kind of why I love this band so much, is that I can really just appreciate which each member is doing.

[@DavidMISAMISAMISACook]

Easiest way for me (as an absolute no nothing about musicianship) to tell Miku from Mincho is Miku plays with a lot of distortion (very crunchy) on the Zemaitis whereas Mincho usually plays cleaner on her PRS

[@mr4lergia]

I dont know since when but they they put guitars Miku-Left Kanami-Right. So for me taking right headphone worked fine

[@DaElfer]

its not just about noticing what each of them are doing in the background. Its how masterful they are at blending everyone's parts together as a whole.

[@toshimatyu6654]

In Japanese, the language of Tokyo is the basis of the standard language. There are many other words called dialects. Most of them are understandable, but there are some dialects that are difficult to understand, such as Okinawan language. The Kyoto dialect has unique intonation and words, but it is easy to understand. Maiko's words also have their own characteristics. If you listen carefully, you can see the difference in the lyrics. I'm in Hiroshima, but Hiroshima's language is considered violent. There is also a famous movie about the yakuza in Hiroshima.

[@Jed-qi8wo]

Thank you for the information!

[@sacluvsBM]

Kyoto dialect is considered guttural. That means it is the language of the street. It is not considered proper or formal as a means of communication. Or another way of looking at it is Kyoto dialect is the language of the common man and not the upper classes.

[@ShikataGaNai100]

@@sacluvsBM 近畿方言 Kinki-hogen. I love the Kansai-ben dialects. In fact, my favorite insult in Japanese is the Kansai-ben, "Aho." Fun Fact - In the anime, Azumanga Daioh, they gave the character Osaka a Texas accent in the English Dub, mimicking her Osaka-ben accent.

[@jacobusderottmann1000]

@@ShikataGaNai100 - interesting. Can you tell the literal meaning of Aho? In 3 different Native American languages, "aho" has 3 meanings/usages. www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Aho

[@toshimatyu6654]

@@markimarkitup It is full of Kyoto dialects. Syo-mohen　: boring Ansan　: You Seyakara　: That's why　...etc The ending of the sentence is also a unique way of saying it. For example ~ Dosu.

[@tommcfall1274]

Kanami wrote the Japanese instrument parts and they were added by her on computer, She is a fucking musical genius. This was the best April Fools Day present ever in 2018!!!!! And how about Akane going gorilla drums in a kimono?????? Also Akane has a legendary appetite and this is a running joke in a few of their MV's thus the scene where she chows down while the rest of them stare into your soul!!!

[@theTaNKisnowhere]

Mate, this was everything I wanted to say. Now I don't have to. Thanks for saving me the time. :)

[@bartyslattfast]

She actually eats DURING shows in the middle of songs, has a little snack box.

[@starocean6013]

Thank you and I agree she is a genius be well

[@jeffersoncosgrove1910]

@@bartyslattfast I saw someone say that, forget holding onto your beer during a show, he saw Akane wipe out a plate of food in Munich, all while playing Domination.

[@crabuki1273]

YEEESSSSS. Re: what we hear. I consider myself fairly well musically educated, if not in practice. Sometimes I hear a BM song, or a Nightwish some, that I've listened to 100 times, but this time it happens to be quiet at just the right time, or I'm listening slightly better, and I'll hear something that makes the song brand new again. Dude, we WANT to hear you talk about the music. We could just listen to the songs / vids on BAND-MAID's channel. I mean, we do that, too, but we're HERE specifically to hear what you think. It's YOU that's the hook. Probably most of your vid to vid audience is transient. Jagovs who bitch about "too many pauses" are here for the band, and the band only. They won't grow your channel. It will grow by you sharing parts of yourself, and your knowledge, and the things you hear that maybe we don't, that gets SUBSCRIBE clicks. That means taking the time to talk during the song, which also conveniently keeps the vid from being taken down. Win win!

[@GaryHolloway-810]

I just happened to be re-listening to Champs B-M reactions & I come across your excellent comment. Giant Crabuki you really do have skillz. (And a bit of a Champ fan-crab crush) lol.

[@cembor]

So as much as you mention Kanami's shredding in this song it is really Akane's drumming and Misa's bass lines that drive this song. Misa's playing on this song is sublime and adds sooooo much atmosphere to the song. Gives just that little bit of darkness to pull the edge off of pop-punk aspects. I have to tell you, having stood in front of Misa on the rail for 3 shows and watching her play this song... just amazeballs. She's my favorite musician on the planet right now followed closely by Akane.

[@s0l1ta1re7]

You just KNOW that this was Miku's idea. An April fools day prank where they changed their website and ALL of their online profiles to say that they were no longer Band-Maid, but now Band-Maiko, Miku re-wrote the lyrics for this to be in the Kyoto dialect and had Kanami have a play with the synth to add traditional instruments to an already existing song. THEN, because the fans loved it so much, the following April fools day, they released an EP with several songs re-touched the same way, and an original (Gion-Cho).Oh, and of course, all done in the Kyoto dialect.

[@sacluvsBM]

Their first release for Revolver Records, the self titled Band-Maiko, consisting of seven previously released Band-Maid tracks was released on April 3, 2019. Only two songs have been released on April first and only Secret Maiko Lips had the April fools day changes made on two western social media platforms. So it is fair to say that only the initial release was April fools and only for the west. The average Japanese citizen would have little to no idea of what April fool's day even is. And when you get right down to it only one song has been written for Band-Maiko. Gion-cho. Hate to break it to you. They don't celebrate Christmas in Japan, either.

[@Riku-Leela]

Akane is so pretty too and omg her hair is incredible too 😭 I can't focus well enough

[@falkarios2944]

I've listened to this song dozens of times, but I never noticed Kanami shredding during the chorus until you pointed it out. My mind has been blown. I also never noticed how similar the solo sounds to the one in Domination.

[@chrisdodson2025]

couple of notes for context. -The traditional instrument that is heavily featured is known as a shamisen. The closest we have in the west would be a four string banjo, but instead of finger picks they have a large pick. -also featured is a koto which resembles a harp in the style of a lap guitar played with fingerpicks. Played more like a harp but it uses the musicians holds a bridge that varies the key almost like a slide guitar. -there is a traditional drum played that is most likely a taiko warm drum, but I didn't get a look at it to make sure. -pronunciation would be "Secret Mike-O Lips" It's a play on words. A Maiko is a geisha girl in essence but that is specifically what they are called in the Kyoto area. -the shamisen and koto are instruments that Maiko's are trained to use to entertain at parties and they are also known for playing games with their customers and their guests as depicted in the video. -this video was originally released on April Fools Day as a well executed prank for their fans. The Maiko dress is a subversion of the maid gimmick and is the closest thing to a maid cafe they had in yee olden times. -the white face paint was used because when Maiko's were in fashion, they primarily entertained in the evening in low light and the makeup gave them a flow and allowed their patrons to see how pretty they are in relative dark. -the yodeling sound you heard in various parts are traditional sounds used in Kibuki theatre and were used in plays regularly. Sorry for the long comment. Hopefully this is helpful. For more examples of traditional Japanese instruments mixed with some metal themes check out Wakaba Band. If you would like to hear some Chinese flavored metal with traditional instruments and throat singing combined with serious heavy metal, check out The Hu.

[@mermaidmelodies1492]

Oh, now THAT is a genius play on words coming out of China, - The Hu! (For all the "Boomers" out there - lol!)

[@minchomania]

This popped up on my recommended so I went back and binge watched all your reactions before watching this. I love seeing people first react to Band-Maid. Damn dude you are one of the best reactors out there. I have hard time fully understanding my love of Band-Maid and putting it into words. You have a great way you can describe all their different parts(punk, jazz, rock, metal, pop, whtatever) and putting it all together. I am like how you are one of the only reactors that has praised Miku a bunch, but you still haven't seen her strut her stuff all the way! You might have a hard time finding them on youtube but you need to do Time from the Shibuya Live DVD and Rock in Me from Zepp Tokyo Live.

[@TheChampOfMedium]

Thanks homie, I appreciate that!

[@fastskipper777]

I always notice the things she does in the background. I was in the high school orchestra. That's why I love them so much. The string instrument is Shamisen (a three stringed instrument - guitar like) and they also have traditional drums, Koto (13 stringed instrument) and flute (shakuhachi) in the background. They are singing in Kansai (Kyoto) dialect (they changed the lyrics for this song) - Miku loves Kyoto - she changed all the lyrics. And this video was for a "April Fool's Joke". Yeah, an MV to do a joke.

[@razor1uk610]

There's also the small hand drum, _Ibone_ I think it sounds like it is called - going just by memory alone.

[@wolfrage21]

The band maiko version of the song was actually an Aprils fools joke I believe, but it was loved so much that they did a few more songs as Band-Maiko, also the string instrument you heard is called a Shamisen, there's a wind instrument in there too I think, I think its called a Shakuhachi! The taiko drums in there too sound epic! Love it! Would highly recommend listening to some Wagakki Band for more some traditional instruments mixed in with the more modern ones.

[@crapstirrer]

Kanami never stops working.

[@boomstick900]

Or shredding

[@RogueBipolarDemon]

Honestly, watching you and some other Musician reactors has trained my ear to listen for what you're talking about in the back like MISA's contributions to Band-Maid.

[@pitamaid]

KANAMI has added five traditional Japanese instruments. 三味線 (Syamisen) ... 3-string guitar 尺八(Shakuhachi) ... Bamboo vertical flute お琴(Okoto) ... 13-string floor-standing stringed instrument 太鼓(Taiko) ... Japanese traditional drums 篠笛(Shinobue) ... Bamboo transverse flute

[@bishopsteiner7134]

As for noticing... I tend to listen on some studio headphones, and while I would not call myself a musician, p0layed enough to grasp the basics... but have also listened to jazz, classical, metal, etc for decades now, so I tend to pick up a lot (also have very very good hearing thank goodness) but folk like you and Chase Carneson always point out details that I still didn't catch. That said I usually listen specifically for the bass and drums first, being my passion. But you guys do a great job of educating me on what I am hearing.

[@davidtsang4949]

The “wagakki (Japanese traditional instruments)” parts were composed by Kanami, and it was produced by her with her DTM (Desktop Music=PC music) system, and then, it was mixed and recorded, while she was closely working with the Band’s rec/mix chief engineer. Check out “Gion-cho” by Band-Maiko where all most all, except rec and mix, was done by Kanami and the Band. As far as truly focusing on each of the instrumentation, I think I didn't really do that until I started watching these reaction videos that were done by actual musicians. I love Rick Beato's What Makes This Song Great series when he breaks down the music.

[@stevehall5128]

On that note...does anybody know if Beato knows about Band-Maid? It just seems like he'd *love* them, but a search on his channel turns up nothing. I just found out he's a huge fan of one of my other faves, Swervedriver, who musically have a lot in common with the 'Maids: hard rock but not metal, catchy melodies, intricate guitar parts....

[@stonefaction]

@@stevehall5128 @Steve Hall I mentioned them in comments on one of his videos (might have been "is rock dead") but to no response. Maybe we need to start dropping a mention in there every few videos see if we can pique his curiosity about them. I too reckon he'd love them...but it's getting him to push the door open in the first place that is the harder part.

[@stevehall5128]

@@stonefaction I wonder if "Wonderland" might not be a better first taste for him than the usual suspects of "Dice" and "Domination"; he's less about hard & fast technicality than overall musicality compared to a lot of the reactors. Unfortunately it seems unlikely he'd be able to get hold of the master tracks for his usual WMTSG breakdown, but he did do it with Swervedriver just using their album tracks.

[@stonefaction]

@@stevehall5128 I don't think there's any song that would be a bad choice as a way in for him. He likes his rock music, particularly 'classic' rock, appreciates great playing and isn't averse to pop(py) 'hooks'. I'd be shocked if he didn't like them once he'd heard them. It's getting him to check them out in the first place that might be the hardest part.

[@rmdcade1717]

So is Kanami playing shamisen and flute for the track, then? I've been trying to learn more about the production and recording of this track. Where can I find out more about it?

[@domchevskimiroslava7964]

Secrete Maiko Lips was what got me into Band Maid! Ain't easy creating music that harmonise traditional instruments and modern instruments that beautifully like this song... They're the real deal man!

[@jlcsr9163]

Those visuals are insane, their beauty just went up a 1000 percent.

[@chan894ify]

I’m not a musician but I was a drum tech for Babylon A.D., a hard rock band that was kinda popular during the late 80’s early 90’s, I like to think that I have good ears when it comes to differentiating all of the instruments, I used to walk around the bars, venues to listen for acoustics and would comment to the band about either turning up or down their instruments, what I’ve noticed about BM is that you can hear every instrument loud and clear with some variances depending on venue and mixing but overall with BM you can hear everyone distinctively!

[@waynetubr]

I am the person your talking about. My musical intel starts and ends with "doe, ray, me, " in the "Sound of Music." I know what I like, just don't know why. BM definitely has a distinctive sound I love. Truthfully, just don't know why. From you and other ytubers I gather the rymiths they play are definitely the top of the game. But, any one of them is a stands alone "game changers" it is the way they play together that is the "game changer". Truthfully all I know is I enjoy the hell out of this band.

[@waynebenedict4609]

I've always beed a bass fan, so I listen for it. But with. Band-Maid, it seems every time you listen, you hear another layer to appreciate!

[@johnnylaroux9517]

Roxy Music - Mother of Pearl, live at the Apollo, 2001........iBelieve that you would enjoy that as well, Wayne.....

[@David-yt6kp]

I am not a musician, but have been around them my whole life and have done soundboard work, so yes I do notice all the little things in the background. Also, I cannot verify this unfortunately, but I'm sure I have read somewhere that Kanami used the same notes in Domination as she did SML on purpose, but I don't remember why. Someone else may be able to fill in the blanks. Excellent react as always. Thanks for doing these two together. (Put The Dragon Cries on your list for down the road.) BTW, Kanami composed, Miku did the lyrics with the addition of the different Japanese dialect.

[@da4762]

The characters at the beginning of band maiko video reads 世界征服 (せかいせいふく) or "sekai seifuku" which loosely translates to world conquest/subjugation. So I think you have a point!

[@David-yt6kp]

@@da4762 I think you just nailed it. I knew I had read something along these lines, but couldn't remember what. Thanks! Hopefully Champ actually reads through his comments this time.

[@kitaway]

Japanese traditional instruments, you can see that in 17:39. 琴(Koto) like harp with Kanami 尺八(Shakuhachi) like bamboo flute with Miku 鼓(Tsudumi) like small drum with Akane 三味線(Shamisen) like three strings banjo and big pick like spatula with MISA

[@borntraitor289]

where is the ceiling for this band.. this song is already a masterpiece(sharing an album with Puzzle and YOLO), but they've continued to just smash songs out of the park.. not by doing what they've done - but better, but by continuously evolving and going in different directions with their sound. 2-3 more months folks.. curb all expectations. bedroom hobbyist musician here.. i hear the interesting bits, but i am terrible at forming coherent words/thoughts about them. watching breakdowns like this helps a lot.

[@Beldizar]

Non-musician here, I don't tend to notice the things you point out but subconsciously enjoy them. Part of the reason I like your reactions is because you point them out and help me understand what I'm hearing.

[@mr559]

(In regards to Secret My Lips) Not a musician, but as a graphic designer...I can relate to the fact that everything have to exist as a whole. Music comp, visual comp...all of us are aware of the same thing. This was the song that made me realized how good they are at composing and respecting each others' space. This song has a build up, it let's you breathe with those jazz chords. THE BEST PART is Miku and Saiki switching out at the ending. It makes you appreciate that Miku can really sing, and Saiki has that voice. They really know how to compliment eachother and they do it perfecfertcly thoughout the albums.

[@tomaztruck6]

This was the best 20 minutes I have ever spent on YT, thanks Champ! I love this song too, you have to do Gioncho next.

[@jonaschang1872]

Secret Maiko Lips is probably the only place you will hear the voice of MISA. Band-Maiko I think was originally conceived as something of an April Fools joke that sort of blew up, if you notice the two Band-Maiko songs both come out on April 1. The instrument you're hearing in the background at the beginning is a traditional Japanese instrument called a shamisen, you also notice the traditional flute in the background as well. Might be some taiko drums in there as well.

[@wanderleyjesus6772]

flute is called shakuhachi

[@shaunpendenza3080]

Keep the band-maid reactions coming, and stop and rewind as much as you need to, it’s great to hear and watch someone who knows what they are talking about explain things with such enthusiasm👍🏻👍🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻

[@rmdcade1717]

I'm not a musician, but I know enough to be able to pick out moments like the ones you highlight. I still learn plenty from musicians' responses, and when it comes to Band-Maid I learn the most from you and Chase Carneson. Probably because you both pause the video to talk about it in depth. Keep that up, please. :) I really believe the only competition Band-Maid has is Band-Maiko. Luckily they only take the stage once a year, or else they'd put Band-Maid out of a job.

[@mickyart]

So great... love watching a proper reaction to these two babies "Secret My Lips"/"Secret MAIKO Lips" and someone catching almost all of whats going on. I love the music, this is one of my fav songs (both versions are, the MAIKO CD is a goddamn pearl, something really really special), but I also love their sense of humour, and I mean all of them... MISA's "oooooooooooooh" starting off the song, Akane's face hitting the tambourine(?), MISA's thigh marking the beat (so rock'n'roll cool and contrasting with the whole traditional thing going on), Akane eating her noodles (as you pointed out) and some point you have Akane's little smirk while drumming ( 20:36 )... really love what they done here. "Secret My Lips" was already a awesome song and they just gave it a different dimension (and probably meaning too...) ... This is great double reaction BUT... now you really need to react to the ONLY original song from this mini album: "Gion-Cho" ( kzbin.info/www/bejne/q562pWqlgrqAmdU ) ...and see yet another episode of Akane's Noodle Addiction, this time during the sort of tea ceremony... You have to!! ... anyway, loving the reaction so far..still got 5 more minutes to watch...

[@joaquinjulve7814]

Band Maid's songs are complex, very creative and with details. There are things you don't notice without good headphones. Interestingly, every time I hear them, I discover new elements. Best regards from Chile.

[@malditobast]

The instrument in secret maiko lips is a shamisen and also this is the perfect oportunity to ask you to react to Wagakki Band

[@ricklarsen7189]

God I love this bands. Great reaction. 🤘

[@stevehall5128]

Congrats! Many across the land of KZbin have begged for reactors to do this doubleheader, but I think you're the first to come through. I think there's a parallel with your point about non-musicians having difficulty picking out musical details, in Miku having re-written the lyrics in the Kyoto dialect for the Maiko version, which unfortunately is lost on us non-Japanese speakers.

[@roynishapati8426]

Absolutely my fav song of theirs - just brilliant! But i cant decide which is my fav version. Also agree that visually this vid is just stunning (although you should check out Gion Cho mate - its even more impressive!) And really interesting what you were saying about picking out things as a musician. Not long after I started learning guitar and bass i started hearing songs I'd listened to for years in a whole new way. If anything that just enriches the enjoyment of it tho, because now i can really appreciate the talent of the writing and musicianship a whole lot more. Thanks for doing both versions of my favourite Band Maid song! 👍😁 - now do Gion Cho! You will not be disappointed! 👍👍👍

[@falagar4567]

Finally! It was worth the wait. Honestly, I would be hard pressed to name a single thing that I picked up on my own without somebody else bringing it up. Thanks to people like you and Chase I've been getting better at it, but not by much. The instrument that you kept mentioning is called a Shamisen, it's the one MISA was holding. Speaking of Shamisen, now would be a good time to recommend Wagakki Band, "Homura + Akatsuki no ito" is probably a good choice.

[@SPERanger]

I almost never notice the bass unless it’s like super prominent (RHCP). It’s impossible not to notice MISA though which I love. Honestly some of my favorite things in your vids is when you point out what miku is doing. I’m always so mesmerized by kanami’s lead that I don’t always hear miku. But when I finally notice it just makes me love the songs more.

[@tigertide55]

Dude... we ALL act like that when we hear their songs. All. Of. Us. You MUST do Real Existence Live. Trust me!

[@bartyslattfast]

I second your recommendation. It is a rocking fun, song.

[@crapstirrer]

Yes. That was Akane. The joke is her appetite (for which she has a reputation). Maiko are apprentice/junior geishas and out of politeness, geishas will wait for guests to eat first (and Akane didn't).

[@me262talon2]

Just guessing, I would say their fans are very particular in what they listen to and appreciate the details also.

[@GaryHolloway-810]

You're right Talon. Just cos I can't play an instrument doesn't mean I can't hear the intricacies that each instrument is playing :)

[@sacluvsBM]

@@GaryHolloway-810 And just because l am mediocre on guitar doesn't mean l can't do the very same. We obviously, for the most part, really like what we hear. I don't think it is really necessary to understand the finer points of wine production to appreciate a very fine vintage. After all we are all Maidiacs for a reason. I think that reason can be distilled to we have all found something of value with these ladies that, unfortunately, is rare to nonexistent with just about every other popular music act from wherever on the scene today. Of course, l can't speak for Gary or Talon (like that would stop me from doing so) but l think the three of us are mostly in agreement with the above pronouncement. Sacramento loves Band-Maid. Yes, we do.

[@charcolew]

I hesitated at the idea of a 20+ minute reaction video, even to my beloved Band-Maid. I'm glad I watched it all the way through. Very entertaining and informative, as well as very personal and insightful. More, please!

[@cokeglas]

Musically bankrupt here, I think you and a couple of others are really good at picking up on the little things that are going on and I love it. As much as I enjoy watching others enjoy BM, I prefer a bit more focus on what they are doing. I do notice (try to) all the little things they are doing. I wish their mixes were a bit better/clearer sometimes. At first I didn't notice Kanami wailing away until I saw her crazy fingers but it's very much in the background. I like to see if the reactors are noticing things because there are so many things worth noticing, so please keep it up. It's almost a waste to not stop and appreciate their songwriting.

[@Outfrost]

The traditional Japanese instruments you can hear are shamisen (strings played with a percussive pluck), koto (harp-like horizontal strings), shakuhachi (end-blown flute; could be another flute though, I'm not 100% sure), and taiko (drums; probably the large ones, odaiko; heard particularly well during the bridge). The band also translated the lyrics into the Kansai dialect, specific to Kyoto and Osaka among others, Kyoto being known as the centre of geisha and maiko ["ma-ico"] culture, where it is still active today. You should check out Wagakki Band, a group well known for blending rock & metal with wagakki, traditional Japanese instruments :)

[@snakewhisperer1]

I admit it, I repeat licks during solos more than Kanami does. And hey, she more than makes up for it shredding through the chorus. Excellent reaction!

[@stealthcabbie1336]

I'm not a musician. I piss fart around on the guitar a bit (Fender Strat, a "hot pink" Gibson Epiphone Flying V and a Yamaha C45 acoustic) and I hired a Tascam 4 track for a weekend and did a really crappy 4 track tape/cassette back in the day and I took music in high school, so I would say I am musically inclined. And yes, I did notice all the things that you are raving about..... and my reaction was fairly similar to yours. Thus is why I'm a huge Band-Maid fan. Man..... Your spot on with the 2 solo's. Never thought about it before (which is why your the practicing musician and I'm the hack). All I can say is maybe "creature of habit"??..... eh?? If I'm not mistaken Kanami wrote Secret My Lips and then added the traditional instruments for Secret Maiko Lips. As for general Band Maid songwriting..... Kanami writes a song with guitars, drum and bass..... not too sure on vocal melody. She works with Akane, like, can you play this? or, what do you think about that??. But with Misa, Kanami is like.. "do what you want. I trust you." Next reaction has to be Band Maiko's Gion Cho. I actually like this better as it is a Band Maiko original, not a cover.

[@gerardcahill5823]

this is still my fav Band Maid song - so many changes in one song and the harmonies at the outro are brilliant. Great reaction and interesting points you brought up.

[@Glenner7]

Great reaction. I`ve watched it at least 6 times. I subscribed and liked - what more can one do???

[@JuanSan66]

BIg thanks!. That were the best 20 minutes of the day. I don´t have any musical education or ability and I need time and repetitions to catch all the subtle layers of Band Maid, but I think this makes their music more remarkable. You can enjoy listening to their songs and discovering new easter eggs much time after the first emotion, It´s like an awesome journey with the girls. Listening to your explanations makes me discover new things, apreciate it!!. I think I'm not wrong if I say that a band like this deserves an analyst like you.

[@markmathewssgbcpenaltyboxs6389]

I am so non musical but the first thing I noticed about Band-Maid was the bass line, that Misa was not just a background filler but playing as intricately (complex?) as a guitar. That is what sets this band above the others is they all just are masters of their instruments and do not just play simple, steady beats but are what I call.."busy".

[@Kevin6059]

I totally agree with what you're saying - just wanted to point out thought that "busy" is often used as a bit of a criticism in the musical world, sort of meaning "lots of notes but detracts more than adds" musically. Band-Maid's playing is more active but in a way that adds to the music, which I know is totally what you meant - I'd just avoid the word "busy" around musicians.

[@markmathewssgbcpenaltyboxs6389]

@@Kevin6059 Thank you I will.

[@falconsooner]

I never really noticed before but since watching your BM reactions I listen for it a lot more and enhances my enjoyment of the song

[@Brandonmtlhd]

It's surprising to me how you made no mention of Saiki's vocal lines in this song. The melodies she employs are absolutely phenomenal, particularly during the verses. It's tough to not get distracted by the musicians. I get it. But I think Saiki really stands out here.

[@vmoore6]

Totally agree Brandon. Others songs where Saiki is phenomenal : wonderland, yolo, daydreaming, glory, domination, don't you tell, play, alive or dead, and above all, alone!

[@bartyslattfast]

@@vmoore6 wonderland, about us and page keep me sane(somewhat).;)

[@tremapar]

The full MAIKO EP is fantastic. Every song is elevated wonderfully. I can't stop listening to it

[@glenkelley6799]

Great breakdown and just thoroughly enjoyed your analysis of the two songs. Your first question about how non-musicians listen to music and specifically B-M, I'm somewhat musically inclined, played piano and baritone as a kid in school, but nothing after. I do have a pretty good ear (hard to hear a lot of cymbals now due to age and a misspent youth). I do listen for the bass as that's what I can pick out the best, but I generally listen to most B-M songs at least six times, first to hear the whole song, then the other five times trying to listen to each member. But I don't have the experience that you have and that's why I look forward to your reviews to help me better appreciate just how really great these ladies are. Looking forward to your next review.

[@GaryHolloway-810]

Hey Champ, whadya mean "Look at her face she's fu**ing beautiful"? How would I notice something like that, I'm not a musician.🤣

[@johnnylaroux9517]

Put the Cat back out and get some sleep, eh..... TTYTomorrow?

[@GaryHolloway-810]

@@johnnylaroux9517 I was supposed to be away this weekend but a major lockdown hits the UK today (Fri) so who knows?

[@curtisrrobles7885]

No holiday for you??

[@GaryHolloway-810]

@@curtisrrobles7885 Only for the weekend but pubs are closing, no social gathering allowed. I've got some beers in just in case. Lol

[@johnnylaroux9517]

@@GaryHolloway-810 :( her miniscule qeii shall rue a near day.....

[@weilima9316]

Yeah it would have been interesting to hear this before Domination because the song was written and released before Domination. Love and appreciate your reaction and explanations as usual.

[@ethangospodareck]

I'm a mediocre musician. Drummer. I don't speak music but I do tend to have a good ear for well crafted and technical music. Noticing the little things and the complexities, and Band-Maid is a #1 example of those types of groups who truly understand what they are doing.

[@kakkoishonen]

The two songs are different BTW. Secret My Lips was written with standard Tokyo japanese lyrics while Secret Maiko Lips was written in Kyoto dialect.

[@COTTERO]

I am not a musician, but since I discovered Geezer Butler thirty years ago, I always make an effort to listen to the bass lines, but in the case of Band-Maid the presence of Misa in the mix is ​​very obvious. P.S. I really enjoy the way you are passionate about these girls' music.👍☺

[@vdctube8966]

Cannot count how many times I listed Secret My Lips and Domination but I never noticed that they have the same solo until you pointed out in this clip. Glad that I subscribed to your channel since the very first watched your reaction.

[@leers1877]

As a non-musician, I really appreciate these technical reactions. When you point something out, I can pick it out on my own from then on. And it's all these intricate little details in B-M's music that makes it so interesting to me, just can't get bored of any of them. Aside from the genre hopping of course. Btw, if you really like the blend of the Japanese instruments, try Wagakki Band. I actually got into B-M from watching WB's Homura+Akatsuki no Ito. Well I clicked on it because Beni in the thumbnail looked cool, then the shamisen and shakuhachi (banjo like and flute like instruments) really stuck out for me. So I decided to check out other Jrock/metal bands. Of all bands though, I like B-M the most, they're just so much fun. Not just in the music, but in everything they do. Like this whole Band Maiko thing. And looking for easter eggs in their songs. And their stage interactions. And their interviews. Or their blindfolded practice session (Blind Maid?)

[@Ephem13]

As someone that hasn't actively pursued or practiced an instrument in 25 years, what I notice is no one in this band just does things the easy way.

[@tommcfall1274]

Just want to add that as a snob picky as fuck about music musician I really love your Band Maid reactions. I don't subscribe to any reaction channel because I really don't care about any other band these days. I had given up on most new music until I found these musical goddesses two years ago

[@michaelsicotte1543]

Thank you so much for this reaction awesome man. I’m a non musician and thanks to you and and another reactor Chase Carson he’s out of the UK you have expanded how I listen to music and what I can pick up on now and appreciate the skill and talent that it must take to create a song like SML and then change it to something different I’m in awe. And then just turn around and create another one and another I remember Misa saying got almost no sleep wile recording their last album she had base lines running in her head it was play a gig next day recording all that tour. And now a new album coming out in January COVID hasn’t put these girls on hold much. Thanks again Champ you pause as much as you want and explain away we love it. Peace man and have a damn good dae😎

[@bishopsteiner7134]

aight.... DOO EET...... glad to see ya back with the Maids and in a better mood than the last time. Seemed like you were ready to punch someone before the last one.

[@pencilfreak81]

Since listening to these ladies I do recognize the "little things" they do in the background or the amazing bridges they create. For me as a pure fan and not a musician I think there are 3 reasons for it. First, Misa and Akane on the bass and drums are more present than their counterparts in most other bands today. Two more elements they (can) use, which brings me to reason #2. You said it in your first reaction to them. Their individual talent in playing and songwriting. I mean, there is no weak element in this band. Each one of these women is great at what she does. In most interviews when asked about how they create their songs the answer is, that Kanami creates a demo and then every member creates their own part in the process and gives their input before the final touches are made. I think there aren't many bands today who use every "trick" or skill they have and put it into the one song they are creating at this moment (keyword 'mass-production' !?). And the third and at least for me the most obvious reason is, that I concentrate more on the music and single instruments because I don't speak Japanese. When I'm listening to their songs Saikis voice and the lyrics are there but I don't pay attention to the meaning of them. I try to find a translation afterwards.

[@bradmenpes809]

Music was once a large part of my early life so I do have some understanding of the complexity of what's going on in Band-Maid songs but what really blows me away is that I pick up something new everytime I listen to their songs again. This is why the live versions are so appealing to me - not just because they are virtuoso on their instruments, but because they are always playing with every song they have written ... new parts, new intros, new outros, solos, battles, and so on. They are the most creative band I've ever heard and they keep striving to make what is already perfect even more perfect. Imho, when they play acoustic versions of their songs, the beauty of their music really is showcased. Their gift to the world is wonderful, joyous music.

[@darkchiron]

I'm not a musician, and I have to listen to their songs a few times to catch everything. There's so much going on it's hard to get it all. Like you mentioned Kanami is just shredding the entire chorus, but they put her more towards the back so it's harder to notice. Plus, Saiki and Miku's harmonies in this song are just so incredible I get hypnotized by it. I do agree that the Maiko version is better to me. And the ladies really are gorgeous in the video.

[@armynurseboy]

My 2 favorite parts of the song: Shred solo to jazz bridge to hard breakdown and the outro. There are no crowds sounds because although the video is made up of live concert footage, the audio track is the studio version of the song. There WAS a live video version floating around before, but it didn't survive the studio purge.

[@starocean6013]

Because its band maid !!! Plus your reactions are so great just the way you are the way you do thank you so much and as always may the maid be with you

[@markdzima]

One of the reasons I like watching reactions from musicians is that they point out things I'm not musically sophisticated myself to notice otherwise.

[@jasonnord785]

Awesome reaction! I'm not a musician. None of the stuff you highlight is obvious to me. But it makes me happy.

[@cactustactics]

Y'know the ~other~ solo in Domination (the one after the first chorus) shows up as the main solo in another song on the album, "Spirit!!" I thought that was weird, because I mean this is a band that doesn't even like to repeat itself in the same song, so I figured it was some kind of callback / motif idea connecting them. Definitely feels like there's something going on!

[@syermizieismail7303]

From somebody who listen to Wagakki Band almost religiously before, I'm so thrilled how Band Maid incorporated traditional Japanese Instrument in this song! You and me literally have the same reaction man! Check out Wagakki Band Homura + Akatsuki No Ito Live if you have time. Cheers

[@RevStickleback]

My favourite line is the one that goes "(Japanese)(Japanese)(Japanese)(Japanese) Secret room" I think I never want to know the context of that lyric. What I do want to know is how they shot the final scene of the Band Maiko version, on an empty Shibuya Crossing. It must have been about 4 am.

[@tmcmehan]

When it comes to B-M, I question anyone who can’t hear MISA’s bass. The level of freedom she has within their structure is so unique that it really stands out. Like I’ve always said, this band has a lead guitarist AND a lead bassist. Both sounds are so prominent in their music.

[@reese1203]

Champ you can do what ever you want. Great review . Smiling the whole time.

[@ShikataGaNai100]

A Maiko is an apprentice geisha. This was an April Fools release. And, the Akane ramen gag is one of their standard memes. The tsugaru shimisen is the traditional instrument you hear. Fun Facts: Miku is from Kumamoto. During her solo, Kanami has Kyoto Tower in the background. MISA isn't barefoot, but is wearing tabi and geta, which make her even taller (Wearing 2" geta would make her right about 5'9").

[@chrisegbertky]

One of the best reactors on the planet. I've watched your reactions over and over. My preferred way to listen to BandMaid is with a articulate and enthusiastic friend. Thanks!

[@RLB9844]

As A non musician, I never noticed the "background" skills until I started watching your channel. After seeing you point things out, now I can notice and appreciate all that they do. Thank you. LOVE BAND MAID!!!

[@ricecharles]

Champ, this is one of my favorite Band Maid songs, can't wait to see your thoughts!

[@gtr7409]

Nice reaction! Based on Secret my lips, sounds such as shamisen and Japanese drums are added in an arrangement. Not only that, but it's difficult if you don't understand Japanese, but the lyrics have been changed to Kyoto accent. If you enjoy the fusion of Japanese instruments and rock, I recommend the "和楽器バンド-Wagakki Band". Please try Wagakki-Band!

[@starocean6013]

OK rewatching this love your channel I've watched all your band maid reactions great OK now maybe you can help me understand the early years when miku was not as polished rythem guitarist how hard was it for kanami to compose the songs she wrote or the considerations she had to make for her because she is absolutely awesome

[@p.ayebasco6645]

I’ve been waiting for this song combo reaction for so long!

[@markmark6378]

Great job Champ! Never noticed the solo being the same, Nice catch! Not a musician myself, but grew up hanging around a guitarist and his band mates, so he kind of taught me how to listen as opposed to hearing. So Yea, I actually can tell what makes Misa such a great bass player! And I just want to say again the Akane is just Explosive!!! Now, in the pre chorus, it sounds to me that Akane is completely matching Misa's bassline with her bass drum,yes?? No?? first time it happens is at about 4:18 or so.

[@carldevries9108]

I will be completely honest with you. As a non- musician your analysis of their song structure DEFINITELY!! makes me enjoy them even more. Before you I was like "sounds good, me likey". Now I notice the background stuff way more and it is effing awesome. Keep doing your thing, it is appreciated.