Why I LOVE and HATE the Tudor Black Bay 58

Visit our website: barkandjack.com
Check out NEW STRAPS: barkandjack.shop
The Tudor Black Bay Fifty Eight felt overrated, over-hyped, which is why I didn't buy it initially. It seemed like too much of an obvious watch to buy. But here is why I love and hate the Tudor Black Bay 58. I will be selling my Rolex Submariner because this is possibly the best dive watch.
I thought I'd wait a few months before doing this video as I didn't just want to do another unboxing video or first impressions. I wanted to live with the watch first. Get through the honeymoon period.
#Tudor #BlackBay58 #Scotland

[@BarkandJack]

Check out our nylon and leather straps: barkandjack.com

[@cubex68]

For me Snowflake hands is a trademark Tudor design. I'm glad they kept it.

[@spencer.watches]

I like the hands, I just wish they'd kept the Snowflake markers.

[@joechino9022]

Snowflake hands? You meant that square looking thing?

[@glenbuyer8738]

Exactly, buy something else if you don’t like it.

[@joechino9022]

Yea.. it looks odd to me.

[@SJCB27]

Joe Chino Well said, Joe. Looks nothing like a "snowflake". Glad it's not just me!

[@reniersoto6257]

"I don't buy watches that everyone hypes up" - Has had several Rolex models and is a self admitted Rolex fanboy...

[@thegraciefighter102]

And now has the hyped up white dial SMP

[@user-uz3qf6fn9m]

Was literally about to comment this 😂

[@jmoz]

HEADSHOT

[@zerominuseleven]

Boom!

[@Andrew-yy2ye]

He's like Harrison,you have to drink everytime they either say seamaster or explorer 😂😂

[@Xminor79]

For me, this is simply one of the best looking watches ever made.

[@MrPanz3r]

I think my biggest take away from this video is... Visit Scotland!

[@BarkandJack]

Haha. It is a stunning place, when the rain stops!

[@thefollandgnat8628]

I live in the Lakes, and like the Highlands it's the rain that makes the place. A day of sunny showers is much more visually appealing than a day of sun. Enjoy the snow next week, not sure it'll reach us.

[@qchang09]

Mine too. Looks like a great place to explore. I like the BB58 but I actually got a no date ceramic Sub this year, so not looking to get another diver....for NOW

[@Ben-j-king]

Had mine since June 2019 and the honeymoon period is yet to fade. Love everything about it.

[@alifaras693]

It has no day/date tho :(

[@Ben-j-king]

@@alifaras693 I’m all about that symmetry hahah!

[@gustaflembre4191]

Want it so bad

[@sidneyt1016]

Hey Ben King...any concerns with the anodized bezel? Does it scratch easily and any knowledge of it fading in direct sunlight over time? Do you know by any chance if Tudor can change out the bezel for a new one and what the cost would be?

[@paul--b]

The bezel insert doesn’t scratch easily as the edge of the bezel and the Crystal are raised so most objects you hit will bridge between those points rather than touch the recessed bezel insert. It is unlikely to fade any time soon unless you leave the watch out somewhere that often gets direct sun. They can be replaced for a few hundred dollars.

[@TheJohnnyViewer]

for me the decision was quite obvious: I wanted an entry lvl watch, which offers maximum for the price. I love divers and vintage watches so when I saw BB58 and how versatile it is, plus in house movement, rolex quality without beeing a rolex.. decision was quite clear. I am very happy with this purchase.

[@brillman]

Adrian mate, your editing and photography skills have come such a long way since the channel was in its infancy. Its awesome to see the progression. Me and a friend save your videos until we're together just so we can binge watch them. keep up the amazing work. ☕

[@BarkandJack]

Thanks so much. I really appreciate you noticing. 🙌🏻

[@LesterLovesWatches]

The only time I remember the faux rivets is when a watch vlogger reminds me of them 😂

[@robertsullivan4773]

It's like the Helium escape valve on my Seamaster. Same thing love the watch. Oh Date windows too. They never bother me but everyone bitches about them.

[@LesterLovesWatches]

@@robertsullivan4773 I blame the macro lens.

[@robertsullivan4773]

@@LesterLovesWatches So true, 95% of the imperfections they catch the owner would never see.

[@abrahammstein2497]

Completely agree on that! 😂

[@DTL0VER]

Well said. Same

[@TheRunningManZ]

I don’t get how you can “hate” the hands of your watch and own it. The main function of it is to tell the time (obvious I know), so every time you wanna tell the time you have to look at something you hate? Not for me, I couldn’t do that. I quite like the Snowflake hands. I’m really interested to hear about your no date sub. When you bought it and shared the vid I think I remember commenting that it was too similar to your Kermit and it was competing with both that and your Explorer for wrist time in a similar space. It seemed a weird choice. However that’s the thing with watch collecting over time we all buy a watch and then change our minds, I’ve sold a few that I’ve picked up within a year or so. Sometimes when you own it and have it for a while you realise it doesn’t get the wrist time it should and so it’s time to move it on. I still feel like this Tudor is very much competing with your Explorer as a daily/monotone/versatile watch. That doesn’t make me right though, we all like different things. One versatile monotone watch is more than enough for me. If you have a watch collection, you need versatility less, you can have a few different watch styles and splashes of colour wherever you like. One sensible watch that can be worn anywhere and dressed down is enough IMO. A collection of monotone watches leads to dull choices in the morning when choosing what to put on (to me).

[@TheRunningManZ]

@@alevansebel I can’t help laughing when people keep a straight face talking about luxury watches as tools. I’ve never seen a builder use a £2.5k shovel. Of course expensive machinery can be involved but only where expensive machinery is needed. They me be homages to tools of the past but they are luxury items that aren’t the best tool for the job at all. Justifying a purchase because your luxury watch is a “tool” genuinely perplexes me. What bullshiter came up with this in the modern era? People who want tools should have a G-Shock. Anything much beyond that then accept you’re buying a luxury watch and stop kidding yourself and just enjoy it!

[@doyboy1000]

The snowflake hands is the whole point of the black bay

[@Mikey-pq4zf]

FRIENDLY FRIENDLY

[@Mikey-pq4zf]

Love your content man

[@jikwangneo]

@@alevansebel i think Adrian needs to do a comprehensive video on the 'rivets'. i have no idea how faux rivets cheapen watch. Is it because its faux? or is it because of the rivets themselves?

[@markhopkins8338]

I have a BB58, and I don't find it over-hyped. It's a perfect size, with a great movement, great design and a great price. I wear it as my every-day watch, but I also love its luxury feel, the fact that will hold its price, and - moreover - the feel of the bracelet over-rides the issues with the rivets.

[@michaelriera6277]

Do your really have an issue with the rivets? I think they make it unique and different from the typical oyster bracelet.

[@markhopkins8338]

@@michaelriera6277 yes. They don't have a function and look a little silly. I am probably going to change to a rubber strap.

[@michaelrimmer338]

Can understand the criticism on the faux rivers but can’t get my head around a lot of people’s dislike of the snowflake hands. They’re part of Tudor’s history and almost like their signature. Each to their own of course but it has always puzzled me.

[@fjlbanks]

My problem with the hands is that they seem to me incongruous with the rest of the dial on the Black Bay. On the Pelagos and vintage snowflake Submariners with their square hour markers, however, the snowflake hand looks excellent.

[@davemilne2484]

Initially hated the snow flare now love them. Different from all other watches and best for visibility if diving.

[@curtisgoodnight]

I don't mind the look of the snowflake hand, I'm bothered by the execution. When I pay $3k+ for a watch I want hands that have some depth. A slight curvature, some facets, or any other thing that gives them a bit of dimensionality and a higher end look than a $300 watch.

[@mihaiserban9434]

My problem with it it's the fact that isn't pointy; visually it seems unfinished and reminds me of a stump. I know it seems foolish, but I just can't see it differently no matter how hard I try.

[@dstfno]

@@davemilne2484 You don't really need the snowflake hour hand while diving, it's the minute hand that matters.

[@kurtmarion2799]

I sold the BB58 in April to help fund my house down payment. I re-bought it 3 weeks ago and haven't taken it off despite "better" pieces in my collection. I love this vintage look with modern use ability!!

[@fjnixxy1579]

Spent a long time researching a first “luxury” watch and each time came back to the Black Bay 58. When I saw it in blue ordered on the spot and absolutely love it!!!

[@technologist1412]

I love the BB58, I love how easy it is to tell the time, because of the snowflake hand is so drastically different than the minute hand. The colors are perfectly new, yet antique feeling. Red triangle adds a little panache. The only critique I have is there is no (on the fly) micro adjustments. I plan on getting it, hopefully in the next 12 months. Kudos on the video!

[@carloc8763]

I absolutely love the watch and I have massively fallen in love with Tudor, mainly thanks to your very objective but overall positive reviews of the GMT and of the BB 58 Harrods Ed. For me, Tudor is keeping alive the spirit of Rolex from 15-20 years ago. I hope they don't lose it as well.

[@greggomes9192]

First of all, just love the format and setting of the video. It’s 100% different than any other video talking about watches and the backdrop is gorgeous

[@Genegenedtb]

I've had my BB58 for over a year now and I love it. I have smaller wrists so the 39mm case is perfect for me. I too don't like the snowflake hand. I got it because of the styling and the trigger was the in house movement. Incredible movement. Great vid as always.

[@MagWatchTime]

Great review as always, I need to get out on them hills. I also walked away from the hype and turned down two 58 blue’s from the AD. Eventually picking one up 2 weeks back , and must say this thing grows on you , looks great it’s comfortable, and strap options never end. Such a pleasure to own and think your money is well spent for what you get back. Get one and enjoy.

[@aprilmayjoon]

i love watches. ive watched this video multiple times. the voice over narration, intonation, editting, cut scenes, drone fly overs are all stupendous and hard to believe you are doing this all yourself. Great channel that is very very very underrated relative to the subscriber count. Teach me your ways!

[@BarkandJack]

Wow. Thank you so much. 🙌🏻

[@zoobee]

dude we need to talk about the aesthetic levels of your vids. this was beautiful. what a groove you're in production wise

[@Bugster987]

I’ve had one 2 years now. Still like it and don’t have a problem with any of the negatives you point out (rivets, hands ect). I knew it was my kind of watch at launch and time has just reinforced it. And I agree with the micro adjust are a bit too widely spaced and could probably do with a 4th hole.

[@1watch2watch3watchmore5]

I saw someone on Instagram who added a 4th hole. I know it’s risky, but if someone is skilled, I’m sure it would help.

[@Bugster987]

@@1watch2watch3watchmore5 yes I seem to remember seeing on a forum someone had an extra hole added. I don’t think I would risk that and just put up with it. Some form of Tudor glidelock would be perfection.

[@chriscon8463]

I just bought the blue one. I love it, but have the same thoughts as you regarding the micro-adjustments. I’ve got a 1/2 link en route from Uncle Seiko that I hope addresses the issue!

[@Bugster987]

@@chriscon8463 Looks OE and should solve any problems with fit 👍

[@SL-xy5pn]

Can we just take a moment here to acknowledge the amazing videography?

[@BarkandJack]

Thanks buddy. 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻

[@Joacimbylehn]

The outdoor shots, the crisp video quality, it’s in a league on its own in this video. Well done. Oh, and I love the BB58, but I’ll save up a bit more for another watch instead.

[@johnseeger9083]

Adrian, another brilliant video! I appreciate the conversational tone. It is as if we were out hiking and started talking watches. Thanks! JR

[@MrRea112]

I still don’t get all that hate for those rivets. They’re a homage and blend in with the retro look of the watch perfectly.

[@Gramercy_Stiffs]

I think it's because they're not functional. A tool watch shouldn't have superfluous ornamentation.

[@josueherrera5049]

Personally I like it, gives it a rougher look and ofc it’s a throwback to the vintage look. How it should be.

[@pammoore8963]

I LOVE everything about this watch! More than I ever imagined I would. It’s my favorite out of a great collection that includes much more expensive and exciting pieces. I actually ended up buying the bracelet later and falling in love with it. I don’t even notice the rivets. Super comfortable. Perfect weight! When I put this watch on, it feels amazing! It has me selling off a few pieces of my collection that I just don’t wear anymore. 😁

[@budhajek6279]

Because of all the negativity of the bracelet, I bought one on the leather band, and then ordered the strapcode bracelet for $110. Bracelet gets here tomorrow, hope I didn't make a mistake.

[@pammoore8963]

@@budhajek6279 I did the exact same thing for the same reasons. The Strap Code bracelet is OK, but I eventually ended up biting the bullet and buying the Tudor bracelet. It’s awesome! Perfect weight. Super high quality! I spent another $800 for that bracelet. So painful! Taught me not to listen to the naysayers.

[@budhajek6279]

@@pammoore8963 O No!!! I should have waited and got one with the bracelet.

[@budhajek6279]

@@pammoore8963 one more thing, I do have a strapcode on my SKX and don't mind it at all, I hope the Tudor one is as good.

[@pammoore8963]

@@budhajek6279 The Strapcode bracelet is fine! I’m sure you will enjoy it!

[@editname2181]

I bought this watch a couple of years ago I wanted a watch that I could wear everyday even at work “Im a carpenter” I also have a rolex datejust but I only wear it when going out for dinner or wedding’s “special occasions” I really believe that Tudor brand needs to step back from the David Beckham's and Lady Gagas and focus on being the working man’s Rolex again! That’s why I bought a Tudor and I thought and still do believe that the BB58 is their current and best watch. Especially if you like the smaller watch designs like myself the 58 reminds me of the the Rolex submariner that Steve McQueens wore with his blue t-shirt holding a coffee such a casual look but that man has class! I did sell my Tudor BB58 for a pelagos and regretted it straight away luckily the person I sold it to was a friend and I managed to buy it back after a month never selling it again! It’s got scratches and scuffs on it now and I love it! just looks fantastic! Real working man’s watch!

[@uploads9493]

Love the new music, fits the amazing scenery! Easily the best cinematic watch videos on KZbin, way to go Adrian!

[@BarkandJack]

Thanks so much. It took me ages to find something that worked. 👍🏻

[@MattCrofts19958]

I truly adore my black BB58. The gilt, the way the sapphire distorts the view of the dial slightly around the edge, the clasp, the vintage lume and the exposed crown. The rivets don’t bother me at all, but Adrian is dead right, when it’s on your wrist, you don’t see them at all. It’s an amazing piece for the price point. Don’t be put off by the talk of wait lists. I went into an AD who I haven’t purchased with (although I have bought from their group) on the Wednesday afternoon. I got the call 24 hours later on the Thursday and collected another 24 hours later on the Friday. Incredible everyday wearer.

[@boatdetective]

Adrian- These types of vids demonstrate that you are thoughtful and unbiased in how you discuss your watch "journey". You're also perfectly honest when it comes to sprooking your own straps- nothing wrong with that.

[@BarkandJack]

Thanks so much Jonathan. That’s why I went down to just doing one video a week. I want to take my time over the content. Thanks for watching and have a great weekend. 👍🏻

[@marius2971]

It has been a long time since I've seen a video in a quality like this, just excellent. Thanks!

[@ride-paddle-repeat]

Came for the watch but stayed for the AMAZING scenery and editing. Adrian your production game has stepped up massively which is a great value add to this channel. Content is on point but the visuals match the quality of your content too.

[@BarkandJack]

Thanks so much. 🙌🏻🙌🏻

[@AA-hi6os]

Scotland is stunning and those late autumnal/winter colours are a perfect backdrop to an aesthetically appealing watch.

[@defenstrator4660]

See I don’t care about this whole “fauxtina” stuff. I like the colour. It’s warm and legible. The movement is great, accurate, and once I bought my Snowflake I discovered how handy it was to have a watch that you could just slip on after three days, so that’s great as well. To me the only thing missing is a date complication.

[@bernardwadding]

It’s not really a fauxtina on the bb58, more of a custard colour lume

[@YtseJam16]

If you want fauxtina, take a look at the latest Bond watch. Borderline tacky IMO. I’m with you on this watch, and think it forms a part of a coherent colour scheme rather than appearing aged.

[@joshua-johnwheeler4722]

I got mine within a matter of days of you getting yours, so it's been very interesting watching you progress through the last few months with it. So far, our feelings on the watch seem to line up pretty damn closely!

[@mikodavid3384]

Enjoyed the style of the video (though you have done other outdoor videos as well) ~ I guess I found the interspersing of footage quite seamless! Anyway, always appreciate your honest reviews Adrian! Keep it up!

[@NicholasCFranklin]

Love the 58, and think particularly the black and gilt version will age superbly due its funkyness. Its got alot that people have been clamoring for (smaller size, no date, etc), with enough unique design elements the snobs will turn noses up at (gilt dial, snowflake, rivots) that keep it interesting and worth talking about. The blue version just doesn't have the same charm (imagine if they had kept the red triangle on the blue one!)

[@Hervey.Abotsi]

That small detail would've made the blue one my grail watch.

[@VegasMilgauss]

Great honest insight plus an amazing backdrop.

[@jeffreylang9812]

Love the location and videography. It’s way more entertaining than someone standing at a jewelry counter. Thank you for the extra effort.

[@richieoakley3215]

Really enjoying the videos - the straightforward, honest reviews are great

[@Podcastage]

I saved for months to get one, but the AD just said “you just can’t buy one. No waiting list. Nothing. You can’t buy it.”, I guess it wasn’t meant to be because I hate the idea of buying grey market or used and paying more than MSRP. That just hurts me so.

[@w1nky77]

Keep checking on the internet , I got mine a month ago , they do come in stock at jewellers , you just have to be quick.

[@matepara]

@@w1nky77 Jomashop? Very available there...?

[@w1nky77]

@@matepara just depends if you’re comfortable with the grey market, I personally wanted to get mine from an authorised dealer, but jomashop are supposed to be good.

[@matepara]

@@w1nky77 interesting. I didn’t think Jomashop would be considered gray market. They may not be authorized dealers but they do have a pretty big reputation in terms of watches

[@w1nky77]

@@matepara They’re grey market because they’re not ADs, doesn’t mean they’re not good, but you don’t get a manufacturer warranty.

[@AndrewEthanZeng]

On the wrist for a few months now, after a full year on the waitlist, and without a doubt worth that full year wait.

[@greiganderson81]

Great video, love the on location style. You obviously bagged one of the few good days for it as well so kudos. I like the BB58 but for the same reasons as you stated the Pelagos feels more robust for me personally. Still lovely watch to have and it does look great on pretty much every strap combo I've seen so very versatile.

[@alphaviet6428]

You missed on few key elements of this watch. This watch was designed to be worn on the NATO strap. The NATO straps are made in-house using special technique. The bezel teeth was designed specifically for French military. The crown is bigger compared to 41mm version. This watch is simply amazing.

[@willeng1997]

I received my BB 58 three weeks ago and I am in love! Great video as always Adrian!

[@BarkandJack]

Congrats Will 🍻

[@francos3469]

Holy moly that Ben A'an looks like a great place to visit. Stunning.

[@raymondkieffer]

Great thoughts on the BB58, and more scenic videos please - really enhances things. Well done.

[@Somemjf]

I was in the market for my first serious everyday watch. Was on the list for a submariner, found it to shinny looking and large case. I really started liking the older subs with smaller case, faded bezels, Matt dial. But after researching vintage subs would not make sense for an everyday wear.. My local rep showed me a bb58 and wow, love everything about it. Right now I have it on a green rubber b strap. Loving the color combo.

[@carlhipperson3807]

Had the 58 for around 5 months now and it still remains one of my more worn pieces in my small collection. I definitely could live without it but ultimately don't have any intention of selling her either. Its a great simple go to piece imo that can serve any occasion. Rivets are shit tho and no micro adjustment can be an arse.

[@tim462]

Those Shots of the watch on the table remind Me of Hodinkee „a Week on the wrist“ :)

[@lisabradley9288]

Thanks Adrian for the fantastic content you produce really appreciate it. Personally I love the snowflake hands! Though I do agree with you about the bracelet it needs improving in certain areas. Also love how versatile the black version is in regards to how good it looks with different straps. Your photography is improving too 🙂 Stunning scenery how long was the hike to top?

[@colmwoods7535]

Bought mine in Dec 2018 and have only gone to love it and reach for it more and more as the time has passed... if anything the rest of my collection struggles to compete. I find it a lot more versatile on the black leather strap I picked up on Hodinkee, but like many commenters there's not much else I would change - love the warmth of the fuaxtina and the rose gold touches, and I haven't found a more size-appropriate sports watch for my everyday life.

[@Brajin1]

It’s a cool watch, it’s on the smaller size for my wrist size. I opted for the larger black bay black. Love that watch!!

[@gadd10]

Absolutely breath-taking scenery.

[@Billeh556]

Love these outside vids and absolutely beautiful background Adrian!

[@harrylk2729]

Great review as always, these videos are worth waiting a week or two for! I have a BB58 on order, currently sat in the AD for collection - even more excited to collect it now!

[@robertm.9633]

Dislike the faux patina, faux rivets, gilt markers. It’s a lot to overcome. Though, I’m a big fan of the size, which is hard to say about almost all divers these days.

[@davidhall4968]

The hour markers color, not white.

[@robertm.9633]

@DieselPower You're right, once I looked again.

[@Miginath]

You are definitely differentiating your channel as more of a blend of watch passion and lifestyle. Good work.

[@BarkandJack]

Thanks Chris. 👍🏻

[@DeadReckoner]

Man, you nailed the lighting in the talking head sections outdoors. Nicely done, as always.

[@rexleung6674]

Another awesome vid Adrian - love the breath taking scenery

[@AlexMcClenaghan]

Gorgeous content 👌

[@BarkandJack]

Thanks a lot Alex 🙌🏻

[@jonathanl2748]

Faux rivets, just like fake exhaust or fake engine sounds on a car, are terrible decisions on the part of a manufacturer. With that said, I’m deciding between the one shown and the Black Bay Blue.

[@reecemesser]

Get the blue, the black is trying too hard to look like an old classical watch whilst it's still new. That put me off immediately so I'm getting the blue one with the strap.

[@RyanGazling]

Content quality is just going from strength to strength. Lov it! I own a 58 and have my own set of gripes - alas 'the perfect watch doesn't exist'

[@crazeephill]

Love the black bay 58. Really appreciating the beautiful scenery. Beautifully filmed and edited too. Top work Adrian x

[@petermulhall2564]

Such a cool watch,I personally think it's so much better looking than a rolex sub🤷🏻‍♂️

[@trevillyan5515]

How?

[@petermulhall2564]

@@trevillyan5515 everything about the BB58 looks better to me than a sub,no crown guards,way more to the dial,the bracelet looks nicer,basically everything IMO

[@trevillyan5515]

@@petermulhall2564 I see. I have a sub but I've never seen a tudor in person. Ive always wanted to compare the two

[@Motormouth...]

The whole point of this watch is making a diver that is as close to the original Snowflake Subs from the 1970s-1990s. It is the same size, has the Snowflake hands and attitude. The biggest thing is the change in size, both height and making it 39mm. The biggest deal is the size. The faux patina is not for me, I'll stick with the two Tudor Subs I have, a better bang for buck.

[@wicked-witch-of-the-west]

I want to like this watch, but i just can't. Especially not over the newish Tudor GMT

[@wristpresence___]

I wish I could afford a vintage Tudo Sub from the 70s to 90s. Which one do you own? Aren't they in the £7k + price range at the moment?

[@aedale1]

@@wicked-witch-of-the-west The GMT has a date change problem.

[@stuartcole4845]

What fauxtina? Do you mean the slightly off-white lume? Hardly fauxtina...

[@Motormouth...]

@@wristpresence___ I have a mid-1970s blue snowflake and a mid-90s Submariner with regular hands. I did buy them a long time ago and you are correct the prices have gone way up but still a better buy as they will continue to climb in value over the years. Also, you can get them serviced pretty much anywhere

[@robboyer6448]

Great review and beautiful photography / videography!!!!

[@chrisbiancofiore1012]

Great video Adrian! I’m a Tudor fanboy, I just got my first a few weeks ago which is the GMT and I put it on a Bark & Jack grey nato. My AD called me just a few days ago saying they got a 58 in, sadly I had to pass because I couldn’t do both right now. I’ll get it one day, glad you’re enjoying it. Love the honesty! Keep up the great work.

[@sunildaniel1838]

I bought one and found it totally underwhelming. Luckily it’s popularity allowed me to move it on easily

[@alifaras693]

Im kinda on same boat.. bought navy blue around 3 months ago.. total wrist time is only 5 days.. im lazy af but when i gather my strength will sell it.

[@patrick7228]

Had the same experience with the Submariner

[@MagWatchTime]

Had the same experience with a Rolex explorer , sometimes it just doesn’t click with you. 👍🏻

[@MrMaxc6po]

@@patrick7228 me too, flipped it for the navy58 and cash in my pocket, but honeymoon has faded away as well. Great all-rounder though.

[@Valera_Scotland]

Tried it on at an AD... just seemed very "tinny" and I didn't like the shade of metal. It's odd. Just didn't speak to me . Just shows how important it is to ignore hype and try try try....

[@caymangts2327]

Bought the blue, it’s close to perfect for the price point, but not as nice to wear as an Rolex explorer.

[@walkerb1734]

Curious as to why you say it’s not as nice to wear as a Rolex Explorer. I personally own both and find the BB58 the better all around watch. Would love to know why you feel the oposite.

[@markwolfson2023]

I think Tudor did a great job on the watch, and the style is part of their great history. When I wear my Tudor GMT, I am always thinking about their history. To me, that is what makes Horology worth it! Adrian, your 58 will last a couple of lifetimes, that is what Tudor is all about.

[@jason_jay3868]

thoroughly enjoyed the video. Watch shots, location shots, music, all very very nice

[@andrewwheeler8591]

Don't like the rivets, doesn't micro adjustable on the fly, hate the snowflake hand, why on earth did you buy it for? If I was spending my money I'd need way less negatives to pull the trigger. Everyone to their own I guess 🤷

[@morgandavies9984]

I bought one of these this year (on a strap, not a bracelet) and I love it. It's incredibly comfortable for a diver, the power reserve is everything it promises and the at-a-glance legibility is great. It has become a go-to ahead of my Speedmaster FOIS (which has a rather uncomfortable embossed design that digs into the wrist over a day's wear and a rather over-pronounced case front). 39mm is perfect if you have tiny bitch-wrists like me. If I was aiming for a one-watch collection at sub-£5k, even possibly sub-£10k, this would be a very serious contender.

[@owenlawton3226]

Brilliant intro and drone shots, especially that one at the end!

[@BarkandJack]

Thanks a lot Owen. The one at the end is my favourite too. But it was a little too wobbly to use during the video.

[@paulscanlan]

Great video, Adrian! Loved the change of scenery. I got my 58 a few weeks back, and am still very much in the honeymoon phase. I will say, I have the same issue with the bracelet, in that i can't get it EXACTLY how I like it on my wrist, which wouldn't be an issue if there was just one more micro-adjustment. That being said, in this cold weather I'm able to wear it with ease, and its very comfortable, but in the summer months, I'm going to have to put it on the rubber or something.

[@davidhindle594chemicalman]

I hate the hands with a vengeance, and I do not like the winder to big, apart from that not to bad. Would I buy one no, I would probably go for one of the new Omegas, I do love the snoopy.

[@simonmayes3374]

Too. Basic English pal.

[@djorgen]

Its nice watch for sure. But also a bit boring imo. Feels like they've forced the vintage style a bit too much. Not tool-y enough?

[@liammcintosh833]

Great video, from content, to editing, to camera quality. Proper well Adrian

[@davidhost7133]

Stunning scenery, great information. And a nice watch. I've even thought about adding one to my collection. Might have to take a look when things calm down again.

[@Tone_Jammer]

Do not sell the no date sub! Seriously you'll regret it forever.

[@antoniojd]

To avoid the same predicament, I went with the BB58 blue... and that watch is very impressive. Different than the black but a great watch nonetheless. I will sell my Sub no date eventually, though. Mine is the 114060... the maxicase bothers me some. Adrian has the 14060M, which to me is the last of the great Subs.

[@PalletAuctions]

@@antoniojd I'm on the waiting list for a bb58 blue! Have you enjoyed yours?

[@Tone_Jammer]

@@antoniojd I'd never sell a rolex (unless I had no choice). They're just too expensive to buy back these days if you regretted the sale.

[@simonmayes3374]

Don’t sell the no date Adrian. Every watch enthusiast should have one.

[@antoniojd]

@@PalletAuctions I have to say it's been 2 weeks of delight and fun. I hesitated before buying it because the black was on my buying list for 1 year... and I finally pulled the trigger on the blue because I already had a no date Sub. I guess if I didn't, I would have gone with the black. I had to look at what I already owned to avoid redundancy. The black is a great watch! Classy, classic, versatile... Man, it's the perfect first watch (or first diver) for anyone starting a collection. But don't discard the blue just yet based on this. This watch is a total different piece, even if it is similar to the black. For example, if the black is "classic", this blue one is "modern". I dare to say they are so different that both can easily take a spot in any collection. I know it's crazy, but that's how I see it. Anyway... enjoy your watch! it won't disappoint you.

[@johnharrison8747]

Sold mine after six months just didn’t like it enough especially the snow flake hand made it look like a novelty watch, great show Adrian.

[@edwardwevik8674]

Thanks for the wonderful review. I’ve been shopping the Black Bay 58 for 2 years and this review put me over the top. I’ll have my Black version for Christmas. Thanks again. I’ll be on the website looking for more straps to wear with it.

[@watchmebuildit]

This was a great video - great length, great perspective, great footage. Thanks

[@DCTag]

You can’t hate on the snowflake hands....it’s literally their identity.

[@KB-vf4gz]

So true

[@DrIstoris]

Ech.. its maybe a good watch, but I hate the Tudor’s hand too much to ever consider buying it :D

[@d.o.3967]

Lovely scenery! Please continue to produce such videos! Love the style :)

[@Chris_BQ]

Spectacular videography, mate! Keep the outdoor videos coming! I generally love my BB58, however...I too struggle with getting the bracelet sized correctly for a comfortable fit! And it is starting to become quite annoying. Why Tudor hasn't included a half-link is beyond me. I am even considering to part with it, its always either to tight or too lose... shame

[@gyang333]

Think it's definitely a strong overall package but it's overhyped. But then again, so is every Rolex sports watch as well.

[@michaelfierman3256]

I was just binging The Crown on Netflix all night and saw a lot of that Scottish countryside ( Balmoral) ...was actually thinking how lucky you are to live in such a magical place.--- it does seem odd that you hate the snowflake hands but that isn't a dealbreaker. Aren't they something of the signature of it?

[@1watch2watch3watchmore5]

Great video and change of pace with the scenery. Thank you for your “after the honeymoon” review. I’m in the engagement period (on order, waiting to arrive from AD) lol Initially I didn’t care for the snowflake hands, but have grown to quite like them. The faux rivers are so minor, they don’t bother me either. Like you said, you don’t notice them when wearing. The micro adjustments do have me worried when I size mine. Hoping for a good fit. A quick adjust clasp and classic oyster bracelet would be a huge improvement though. Great content again. I’ll head over to check out your B&J straps as soon as mine comes in. Your mocha leather is calling my name.

[@chinwengkeong]

What a fantastic video. Great post-honeymoon perspective. And... Epic film-making there man. 🙌🏼

[@faizalhakim3772]

For me the 58 feels it’s trying too hard. But still a fab looking watch.

[@BarkandJack]

Yeah I completely see that too.

[@thehetman86]

Diver in mountains, next time go diving with Alpinist :)

[@morfius85]

Adrian, I’m the “first guy”. I got my Bb58 black on the bracelet. I think that it’s a great all rounder. It’s my daily with the explorer. I just find them really cool and sometimes even better looking than a lot of the more expensive “better” ones. Loved the video. It’s a more “natural” video and again the videos we like. Just you chatting up with us about watches. Love the view and congratulations on the Channel! Cheers!

[@kingflum]

Your words ring true - I basically just laughed it off because of the hype. It’s so difficult to assess how much you actually like something, when there’s mega hype surrounding it. Useful to hear your thoughts. Thanks bud.

[@jeffreylang9812]

I actually would love that look in the 41mm case. For me 39 just feels to small.

[@Jay-xr3sb]

The problem with the watch is the way the case is shaped, look at it from the side and its just a slab or metal with long lug to lugs, the 41mm wore like a 42/43mm. The diameter is only one factor. Lug to lug, case shape, dial size and and height all factor into the wear.

[@jeffreylang9812]

@@Jay-xr3sb my current daily wear watch is the Sea-dweller 43mm 50th anniversary and I love it. Size works for me. I would add the Tudor more based on the looks if they made a 41mm that looked like the BB58. I agree it wears larger than its size but I have the wrist for it.

[@Jay-xr3sb]

@@jeffreylang9812 fair enough, skinny wrist gang over here.

[@highdesertforester]

Love the size and the gold indices and hands. Hate the snowflake hands.

[@mikejenkins6904]

Yeh, snowflake hands need square indices.

[@highdesertforester]

@@mikejenkins6904 My problem is that I absolutely love the Rolex 6538, the original James Bond watch, and the BB58 is almost a copy except for the hands. I sometimes toy with the idea of getting one and replacing the hands with mercedes hands.

[@mikejenkins6904]

@@highdesertforester I think the charm of the BB is there, but when compared to the Pelagos or Snowflake, I just can’t get along with the combination of those BB hands and indices.

[@lemmontree1]

Damn, love the outdoor video! Do more of those! Beautiful place you got there!

[@BarkandJack]

Thanks a lot buddy. I plan to do more like this. At least one a month. 👍🏻