Barstool Pizza Review - Papa's Tomato Pies (Robbinsville, NJ)

Dave finally gets to Robbinsville, NJ to review Papa's Tomato Pies, a bucket list pizza place and we get a lesson from the pizza maker in the back on what makes it a "Tomato Pie"
Download The One Bite App to see more and review your favorite pizza joints: onebite.app/do...
Follow on Instagram: / stoolpresidente
Follow on Twitter: / stoolpresidente
Check out Barstool Sports for more: www.barstoolspo...
Follow Barstool Sports here:
Facebook: / barstoolsports
Twitter: / barstoolsports
Instagram: / barstoolsports

[@gordtron]

the crunch in the crust on the second go almost gave me tingles.

[@kennethforeman1400]

I got moist!!!

[@dylanthaler5923]

Definitely made it move a little

[@ChaseAcheck408]

yeah I'm full chub

[@mfeliciano671]

N he said he woulda gave it a 9.1! That’s big!

[@DarthBalsamic]

Me too.

[@patlynch3464]

That's pretty cool that Mike only works there, but he goes above and beyond to try to make the place look as good as he can. That's a hell of an employee! Great job Mike!

[@kevincorso7929]

I mean he’s probably the general manager but yea.

[@intellivisionmaster7999]

He likely takes home a large “Tomati Di Pizzaioli” or whatever it’s called every night on the house for a decade. I would love my boss too!

[@BeachJedi101]

For a pie not his style, 8.3 is an insane score. 👏

[@Bucelcpsdr]

He gave it a 8.9 afterwards

[@DefeatLust]

@@Bucelcpsdr 8.6

[@gregansbootstrap5352]

@@DefeatLust it was 8.9

[@DefeatLust]

@@gregansbootstrap5352 9:06 8.6 is the official score. 1 bite, everyone knows the rules

[@BaronVonBielski]

@@DefeatLust I can’t stand people like you. He literally gave it an 8.9 said “I gave it an 8.3 and an 8.9 so we will say official score is 8.6” you’re finding issues in the smallest of things hence why 8 people liked his comment and 1 liked yours. It’s hilariously sad how badly you felt you needed to correct someone who wasn’t wrong. Never said “official score 8.9” he just mentioned the 8.9 and you responded with “no 8.6” even though the 8.9 is in the video maybe seconds before the time you linked. How does it feel going around being this much of an insufferable idiot?

[@Courtneyemily91]

Coming from someone who has gone to Papa's with my family and has been served by Nick personally for decades, it is truly the best pizza I've ever eaten and the taste has remained consistent to this day. It opened in Chambersburg, Trenton or the "Burg", which is where Robbinsburg comes from, and it is definitely a bucket list place for any pizza lover. You can tell they have such pride and passion for their pizza and it shows.

[@nickysindora6952]

Same here best pie ever growing up in the Berg was amazing not the same now but always loved the mustard pie

[@skwirrlmaster]

Nice history lesson! I've wondered about the sign and never asked.

[@VideosYesVideos]

2 years ago. If this was today I would guess a 7.4 - 7.8 tops

[@skwirrlmaster]

@Salerno Was the pink and green dye out of your hair, go buy a garbage slice for 99 cents and take the other dollar in your pocket to get a bj from the toothless crackhead behind the dollar tree in Journal square. No taste having transhippie trash

[@skwirrlmaster]

@Salerno my sister looks way better in her lingerie than you do tucked neatly into yours.

[@manifestyourlife7]

The crust looks/sounds amazing.

[@MonsterMetalManiac]

It crunches like a potato chip ! Lol.

[@logannuts91]

Shut the fuck up

[@colegarthwaite5633]

@@logannuts91 lmao u mad bitch

[@Name-el9ps]

Yea good sounding crust 🎶

[@skwirrlmaster]

It is.

[@wapierce]

One Bite, sponsored by Pepsi: “Would you guys like something to drink?” “A water would be great”

[@gunneroffroad9850]

*We all know DAVEY LOVES COKE* 😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤😤

[@gunneroffroad9850]

@my name is DRAKE I wish I was a weekend warrior. Was active duty. 06-11 injured in Iraq my 2nd tour. I was a Sawgunner in 4-1 AD from Albuquerque originally. But Thanks for the comment *DRAKE* you make really catchy songs. 😂

[@inertiaspinner555]

A-gunner uPP

[@armandr1613]

Does Aquafina count?

[@binger4me]

lord knows all

[@henryishere7]

3 different scores. Everybody knows Pres breaks his own rules.

[@utecastronoova863]

Hes confused, coming down from his coke binges. Positive vibes only.

[@EricShina]

Well his rule is 'one bite' sooo.. lol

[@Blag_Cog]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/eYGoqHR3a6xnaKs Check this one out. This is the REAL rule breaker review. Edit: This is another barstool review lmaoo. Don't worry im not trying to plug a fire mixtape or something.

[@mackm3875]

It pays to be The Boss.

[@khennigs]

@@Blag_Cog thank you so much for the tip, that review is fucking classic

[@jayb657]

One baby sip of Pepsi, everyone knows he's a Coke guy

[@JohnDavis-of3di]

Gold!

[@mannygallotta1452]

That was great !

[@mr.w1129]

Cocaine

[@brandongarcia2688]

Jay B I needa get on his cocaine diet if he was as fat as he was before! I’m as far as he used to be lmao

[@utecastronoova863]

Nah hes in rehab now.. thats why the positive vibes only shirt.

[@unwelcomemotivation]

he's legit disgusted with big mikes extreme talent and unlimited knowledge of pizza.

[@charlesrocks]

Stevey Irwin I noticed that too. Big Mike is a fuckin stud. Pres couldn’t hang.

[@mat.b.]

this is the correct answer

[@AustinHopkins2]

One below freezing day, everyone knows it’s only a matter of time until pres wears th woman’s jacket.

[@PeterKKraus]

It was 33 in western Ma today. I was sweating doing some work outdoors in a 90s Starter jacket. Open front.

[@CleveTime]

@@PeterKKraus specify team on starter jacket please

[@PeterKKraus]

@@CleveTime Whalers

[@PeterKKraus]

What difference does it make? I have another that's an Orioles jacket with the boring bird logo on it too.

[@CleveTime]

@@PeterKKraus makes no difference the devil's I the details. Or in this case the Whalers

[@polak551]

Sign: Oldest tomato pie in the USA Prez: Yea this is oldest tomato pie in the world Looks at sign: yea

[@emknight84]

@patrick howard from South America my dude

[@stephencox7671]

This is one of the first pizzas that makes me wanna take a trip to try it. Checked every box I could tell just by looking at it

[@Jeff-uq7iu]

Was working on project near there, its top tier pizza

[@nickdiaz6766]

I live like 10 minutes from there. Both Papas and Delorenzos are worth the trip, best pizza in America.

[@sevaactivated8184]

nick diaz Facts Me too.

[@matthewm4336]

@mikedoesseo My pizza neva hurt a nobody

[@carns518]

Just got home. Made the 45 minute trip from Marlton after watching this. Killer pie. Grabbed a mustard pie with sausage to-go as well.

[@Buzazu]

That crunch on Big Mike's pie sounded like it was made by a professional sound engineer in a studio, not by biting into food out on the streets. 7:45

[@DirtyJohn12]

Really wanted to see Big Mike’s reaction to the news

[@PatrickGoddard]

There is an undeniable sense of well being I get from watching these reviews. I hope I can get out to the east coast sometime to try a few of these places.

[@bigbrytunney8753]

i live about an hour from this place, but just tried it today because i had a job not too far from it in Trenton. It's definitely different than what i'm used to, the tomatoes are the star of the show of course, but the pie was exactly like he described, light and crispy and when u bite into it, it stays together and doesn't fall apart. I was a pig and ate it right in the parking lot like he does. It's delicious and i would recommend it strongly. Need to try DiLorenzo's too!

[@buckjohnson135]

If you folks ever get a chance to go to Papa's I highly recommend trying their mustard pie too. Sounds weird but it's amazing. Plus their red cream soda on tap is great.

[@nathanbarnhart7823]

Not going to lie, both of those things sound gross I will take one of each yolo

[@csl110]

@@nathanbarnhart7823 mustard is amazing when cooked on meat and bread.

[@nathanbarnhart7823]

@@csl110 still sounds gross, still will give it a shot

[@greg7712]

@@nathanbarnhart7823 It's incredible and you need to try it

[@civilseeker]

I love their mustard pie! When I first moved to the area I also thought it was gross, but when I took that first bite I was amazed!

[@NoeticInsight]

9.1 is the real score, everybody knows the rules.

[@ML-mq7zq]

Never closed more than one day in 107 years. Until rona. Everybody knows the Covid.

[@jakeforce6125]

Dave, thanks for donating to veterans with PTSD. This veteran appreciates what you did.

[@РичардНорз]

He fought war for us! Ww2

[@Appaddict01]

Ричард Норз *youus

[@superman04p]

Thank You Sir..... This country seems to have forgotten that EVERY freedom that we have and enjoy today is because of service men like yourself that gave more than most today can even fathom. So from someone that KNOWS and is extremely appreciative ... THANK YOU !!

[@MultiJejje]

@@superman04p Wtf are you talking about? He was serving your countrys establishment and military industry.... some sick oil war like your government always does. And people are thanking these guys with their dick up... he did nothing for you. Vote better leaders so you wouldn't have to go wars. What a sick culture

[@intellivisionmaster7999]

👍🏻

[@kevinkirk6276]

“So hot and fresh out of the oven R.Kelly we don’t want to talk about him” 🤣🤣🤣

[@Appaddict01]

Prez really says some funny shit sometimes.😂

[@skimanfree1073]

@@Appaddict01 Who is R Kelly?

[@dipmalyagantait4716]

Same Girl, Same Girl​@@skimanfree1073

[@AJ-is5ut]

Me and Big Mike made pizza together and were taught by the same man. He just passed away. Rip Tony Gervasio, they don't make them like you anymore. 👍

[@TrevorTheLever42]

Dave, your life lessons are so powerful. Thank you for imparting you’re wisdom upon me

[@norwegianblue2017]

Living in California for 50 years, I can say that the best pizzas out here are like average pizzas back east. You guys have it good in that department.

[@deanstanley2125]

Same although I've been out west for a shorter, I do miss good pizza and bagels. NYC water makes the difference in the crust and a California tomato is nothing like a jersey tomato

[@Kment011]

I've had 3 different 9's (Difara, Sallys,Pizza Regina... as well has Halftime Pizza if you count that lol), and that second pizza he gave you looked equal to or better than any of them! The crunch was unreal!

[@bgold9]

4 chews per bite, everybody knows Pres is coming down off a coke binge

[@fez_xyz]

Pepe Silvia you cant eat on cocaine mate 😂

[@ltfelts]

Fez he said coming OFF a coke binge. As in he probably hasn’t ate in 2 days and ran out of coke lol

[@chicagojonesy]

@@fez_xyz yes you can. It's just sucks really bad. But if you're at the office and everyone expects you to have a piece of that fucking birthday cake, you man up and take it down and hope you're numb throat doesn't make you vomit in front of your coworkers.

[@riproar11]

You are sick fucks.

[@bgold9]

HolySnackPack there it is

[@adamd5340]

Even when I make homemade pizza from scratch... I take 1 bite and give it a score... No trash pizza in this house haha. Love the vids Dave and Frankie.

[@OneCrayGuy89]

One crying ginger, everyone knows Pres low balled that second pizza.

[@nolanmendoza3643]

Josh Leyh I felt like it shoulda been 9.1.. didn’t go into the 9’s because it was too aggressive of a jump from the first pizza? Cmon!

[@QuinnOConnor]

Anyone that knows pizza can tell you that was at least a 9.2 just by lookin at it.

[@nolanmendoza3643]

Quinn O'Connor I think I gotta up my pizza game

[@QuinnOConnor]

@@nolanmendoza3643 lol, that wasn't a shot at you, I didn't even see your comment till now. It was a shot at Portnoy.

[@eismndmsoaidhndmsm]

Quinn O'Connor I’m a regular at papa’s, can confirm they put out consistent 9’s. Just gotta ask for it well done, its like crack

[@zinzanman]

I drive regularly from Maryland to New Hampshire and back with my wife to see our kids in College. We've picked off most all of Dave's top rated places, some multiple times. We just hit Papa's again (third time). Man, this place is ridiculously good. Thin, crispy, perfect cheese blend (guessing it's a blend). We always get one plain cheese, we've tried their Mustard Pie (don't knock it until you try it, good as hell), and this past time tried their "Italian Stallion" white pie, topped with sausage, broccoli rabe, and garlic. It was fantastic.

[@BillHicksADH]

Haha he’s almost annoyed at how good the fresh one is

[@ryanromandia8223]

I need to go to the east coast and try these pizzas. That crunch on the second pizza damn!

[@benjaminnwarren1]

The awesome cook with the glasses: "No,no,no You dont understand. Eat it". True pizza guy! Love him

[@TheIncredibleOne628]

You know they're getting a high score when Pres goes into full retard stare mode for 3-4 seconds before scoring it..

[@Xxsnipes079xX]

One “getting kicked in the balls” reference, everybody knows that Pres likes CBT

[@michaeltschuertz]

i think he is a switch. he goes in all dom, but for the right guy, girl, partner he is the happy sub any day.

[@ras124]

Hey, whatever your're into

[@tylerveal9814]

Prez getting soft with overly high reviews lately - must be on the take to make up gambling losses

[@CleveTime]

Yeah exactly I'm a dentist and I been drilling a shit load of healthy teeth to cover my losses. So I can relate.

[@roybhame2824]

Papa's really is very good though. Probably one of the top 5 in the state. Been there a few times.

[@BounceHeaven]

You aren’t correct or welcome with such lies

[@hughes3947]

The ginger angel... beautiful sentiment Pres, warms the heart of pizza guys everywhere 😇

[@chrisrusso835]

When I do my monthly bills I now have to add in around $80 cause I watch these and then need pizza...

[@louzer2566]

Honestly this pizza looks better than that 9.1 the other day

[@EaglesFan4Life17]

It is.

[@geoffrobinson]

I've been to both places. Angelo's is legit awesome. So is Papa's. And so is DeLorenzo's (which should be reviewed shortly). The Trenton-style tomato pie is just a different style. I like DeLorenzo's the best.

[@EaglesFan4Life17]

Angelo’s is good I tried it but papa’s is a lot better... I thought Angelo’s was good but didn’t think it was worth a 9... delorenzos is better then both of them tho... been eating that pie since I was a little kid when they were in Trenton .

[@geoffrobinson]

@@EaglesFan4Life17 Angelo's grandma and Upside Down are incredible. And their sandwiches are great. I agree DeLorenzo's is the best pizza I've ever had.

[@joem13yearsago73]

Yea but he took more than one bite. So fuck off

[@TheRulebritannia7]

Damn Louie C.K. really fell off the wagon after getting cancelled

[@danlivni2097]

LoL

[@Appaddict01]

Fell off?!? He’s a pizza king, now.

[@NoFaceChase]

That looks like the most superior pizza ever. I’m going to go there for sure

[@foleyfoley849]

“Ginger Angel” 😂😂

[@basementbomber]

In many NY neighborhoods, that's called a "reverse pie". This was a great video. ALWAYS order a pizza WELL DONE! I don't like oil added to pizza. The cheese usually produces enough.

[@skwirrlmaster]

The cheese on this one is subtle. Tomato is the star.

[@GodKingButters]

You know you’ve watched a lot of pizza reviews when you can base Dave’s score off his facial reaction 😂

[@brinkee7674]

Did Dave try the Mustard Pie? It's very popular in that area and is a local delicacy. I never tried it so I can't say but have had a regular cheese, sausage n mushroom and a pepperoni it was great. Worth a trip for sure.

[@bobbygorbett536]

Props to El Pres for helping out the kids.

[@fitfogey]

That second pie looks and sounds amazing.

[@easymoneysniper73]

Prez go to DeLorenzo’s tomato pies in Robbinsville

[@anthonyfreda1040]

William Gerity he did the other day - watch for review tomorrow

[@9SecondStreetMustang]

I thought this was that place?!

[@stiperaddaraddaraddamiocic9708]

The one in Hamilton is better 🤷‍♂️

[@anthonyfreda1040]

Stipe Radda Radda Radda Miocic on Sloan? Stopppppppp

[@stiperaddaraddaraddamiocic9708]

@@anthonyfreda1040🤷‍♂️ rville burns their pies man

[@ChuckD351]

Like the interview with the head guy

[@anthonyrazo1351]

"break his little ginger heart" had me dying!! hahahaha

[@the_whistling_jay]

I’ve had all the NJ pizzas on the top of your list and for me the Tomato Pie from Papa’s is the best of those. Most flavor for me. My favorite pizza parlor pizza is Mancini in East Brunswick.

[@Salukis40]

One R. Kelly reference, everybody knows we don't want to talk about him

[@jeffreyjewell75]

Chicago Sports Radio we are pissed.

[@kalppatel9409]

One Pres who can’t say “Papa’s” correctly, everybody knows the rules

[@Paul-oh4fe]

pup uz

[@TheSweetswed]

Davey out there changing lives. That big ginger got him all soft lol Good for him though getting the 2nd one in there and done his way. Respect Ginger Bear

[@AntonSolo]

The whole "Robbinsburg" is a play on words to honor the store's original Chambersburg location.

[@robertlee4172]

That Philly tomato pie got me curious now. I used to buy these .10 cent squares out of the refrigerator case back in the 70s from a local Italian baker. COLD PIZZA. It was friggin' good.

[@BoomSkwad47]

That's it

[@largemale8129]

church pizza the wops call it

[@miket9732]

I can't stop watching these reviews!

[@jimbeam6730]

Prez: Thats how i like it Ginger angel: say no more

[@markheithaus]

That looks like the style I prefer. It just looks fresh. I had a pizza like that in a small pizza place in a small town in Italy, and everything just tasted like it came straight from the farm. And surprisingly cheap. But I would like to try the style he praises at its best.

[@Ahenkel36]

Now everyone will be saying let me make another, rookie falling for that scam!!!!!

[@kenhaywood1452]

That looks so good, love NJ !

[@b.p.2914]

Mike really knows his stuff...no wonder the pizza is so delicious!

[@James-ci5ql]

When I’m hungry, but I don’t know what to eat I watch Dave rate a pizza and then I know

[@petepete9831]

One cream pie everyone one knows pres loves receiving them

[@MrVigilanti]

Pres is changing the pizza industry - thinner and more crisp. One bite at a time.

[@snicklefritz4209]

Looked like a damn good pie

[@stevenlaflash9759]

I agree I want to to try it and no lines🤗

[@albionrolltime7189]

I used to work at Amazon in Robbinsville. There was nothing but cornfields and it was 2 hours away from North Jersey where I lived. I couldn't handle the commute. Now I going back down there cause that pizza looked spectacular.

[@euro20049]

One granny pizza shop, everybody knows Pres loves it there

[@evre2881]

You’re the only person I’ve ever seen been in an advertisement before their own video.Baller.

[@johnchase4408]

That Sounded Amazing! That chewy crunch got me hungry AF.

[@joefigueroa8809]

The crunch sounds amazing

[@Lilsushi352]

Im glad Louis at least landed SOME kinda work after the scandal

[@HomeAtLast501]

I've been making pizza from scratch at home for 20 years, and there is no question that cooking a pizza VERY well-done, so the cheese is deeply brown, is the best. My go-to pizza place in Cincinnati ---- I request that they make it well-done, and it is so much better that way.

[@intellivisionmaster7999]

I really don’t like it that way. I want the cheese fully melted with orange/brown spots throughout… meaning it’s just starting to hit “well done”. Otherwise you lose the flavour of the cheese.

[@HomeAtLast501]

​@@intellivisionmaster7999 To me it tastes more "gourmet" to have the cheese strongly browned. It's richer. But, I do understand where you're coming from. The place I get pizza, occasionally they brown it so much that some cheese will get black on the edges, and they offer to redo it, but I prefer it that way.

[@petarmolnar14]

When I saw the pizza, I said straight away 8.6. Hahah funny how it turned out to be correct score in the end.

[@thelivetable]

Italian Touch in Cranbury, NJ

[@danmcclellan2451]

I wonder if Dave has ever tried making a pizza at home ? And tried to make it exactly how he would like it ? I know he doesn’t have a lot of kitchen skills but hey who knows 😂

[@jdmaine51084]

That crunch at like the 7:45 mark nearly blew my speaker Frankie

[@SauceySauce81]

the guy offered pres a drink and he didnt ask for a pepsi lol

[@lightspeednate]

missed opportunity to improve his endorsement deal.

[@skwirrlmaster]

The only have RC lolol

[@michaelcozzini5252]

Saw big hearted Mike 3 nights ago. We said hello n happy New Year! New glasses. Mustard pie rocked as did the margarita. Manicotti dinner was out of this world with manicotti that tasted like the pasta was made in store. Meatball parm sandwich also was very good and don’t forget the bruschetta; like no other. 9.3 🍕

[@scottyp2505]

“Pupups “

[@hiiikyle]

that second pizza almost made me fly out to NJ

[@caseyquinn9282]

“I’m not gonna tell him we’re combining the scores”. I died.

[@unscarredmusic]

Grew up in Chambersburg, home of Papa's and DeLorenzo's(both of them). Papa's was always my favorite. All 3 are fantastic. I would recommend getting it extra crispy.

[@JamaaLS]

That pizza looks so damn good

[@joepmurray]

Prez - get to La Villa right across the Delaware River in Morrisville, PA for absolutely RIGHTIOUS Tomato Pie. Modest appearance, but leaves New Haven wiping tears.

[@jarebear7192]

One "Papuss" Pizza, Everyone knows Dave is dyslexic.

[@Slash687]

Fried his brain with coke and adderall

[@sarahbeth1983]

Hey at least u know who he is but he probably has no clue who u r

[@Slash687]

@@sarahbeth1983 I'm just happy I've got a couple of functioning brain cells to rub together

[@sav22rem22]

@@sarahbeth1983 Unfortunate last name

[@sarahbeth1983]

@@sav22rem22 yeah no shit

[@jasonhatez3287]

Got 2 pies tonight. Dave is spot on. Had a piece in parking lot better then contis. Then when I got it home tasted totally different.

[@senghunter1010]

I think I might try me some of that Tomato Pie.

[@theroguetomato5362]

Papa's used to be in Chambersburg, NJ, which is where I used to get Papa's tomato pies. I prefer De Lorenzo's by a small margin, but Papa's was amazing. They both drizzle good olive oil on the pies, which makes them even better.

[@Mtdmpls]

One guy breaking his own rules, everybody knows he's off the wagon again.

[@TheJaiNetwork]

I love Brooklyn Boy’s Tomato Pies in Edison too. Maruca’s on the boardwalk in Asbury Park has good Tomato Pies too. It def needs to be hot and fresh out the oven. When I bring a tomato pie home it’s just not the same

[@alexwilson3101]

"let's go outside, let it cool off.. it's not because i don't want to score it in front of the guy" *takes one step outside and takes a bite 2 seconds later*

[@intellivisionmaster7999]

100%. The man walked out and took his bite immediately.

[@wingsfan118]

Great explaination/story by that dude.

[@ECWJoe]

Wish Dave had tried the mustard pie from Papa’s....would have been a 9.3 at least!!!!🍕

[@johncampbell9107]

Mustard pie? Can you describe what that's like? I never heard of a mustard pie 😅

[@ECWJoe]

@@johncampbell9107 mustard is placed by crust underneath the cheese and sauce and then cooked.

[@johncampbell9107]

@@ECWJoe I don't know if that sounds disgusting or interesting

[@Typicaltony777]

I appreciate the timing of the uploads

[@nikkistixx9750]

Wow usually when a place gives Dave another slice made “fresh” It’s right most of the time might drop the score. In this case the score went up. Way to roll the dice!

[@alanincentraljersey]

I was there for lunch today, September 8, 2022. Maybe they upped there game since Dave was there, but today was 8.9 to 91 easy.

[@karlniemeyer1006]

Did the cook get Dave’s consent before pulling the pie out of the oven

[@throwingsparks]

The crunch on the 2nd pie sent me straight to Mapquest........Bucket list City!!

[@WeHaveNoTalentSorry]

Somebody needs to teach this guy the difference between "Homey" and "Homely".....

[@Bc-mp8qy]

Always gotta hit papas fresh, the mustard with sausage is the specialty