Batman the Doom That Came to Gotham: A Comic vs Movie Comparison

[@thenerddesk111]

Just to clarify a few things: I definitely overstated the whole, guns and killing thing towards the beginning, and the few times I mention Gotham by Gaslight, I’m not trying to put that story down.

[@richardabia9735]

@@thenerddesk111 it's TOTALLY fine...I know. Gotham by Gaslight is really Great ! Even though you're not,...Some people are very nasty and obsessive about Batman (a fictional person by the way) using guns or killing or whatnot in certain stories. They Always make a huge deal about it. Really annoying. Great video and God bless you !!! Both versions of Doom that came to Gotham are top notch. I LOVE Knight Green Arrow !

[@FriendlyBatDoom]

Batman and Lovecraftian cosmic horror mysteries are made for each other. It allows him to be at his finest as a warrior and a super genius polymathic intellectual while keeping him close to his roots as the world's greatest detective. I love this comic and film. If only a version of the adaptation of it was set in modern times.

[@RyanG0899]

Modern times are nowhere near as good as period piece settings. Batman stories need to be set in this time period more often.

[@terofrito]

Batmant City of Madness is a Lovecraftian present day story and it's very good.

[@BNK2442]

With Arkham Asylum being taken from Lovecraft...

[@Trashmantrash]

It isn't Cthulhu, The Lurker at the Threshold is actually Yog-sothoth, a different god from Lovecraft's writing, who appears in the short story "The Lurker at the Threshold."

[@noir-214]

When Green Arrow in comic talks about the things he's hunted I think he mentions Gorilla Grodd I kinda wish that was in the movie

[@thenerddesk111]

I must’ve missed that, but that sounds sick!

[@danielramsey6141]

What sucks about His fight with Poison Ivy in the Comics, is that SHE KILLS him off So Quick! She grabs his neck and snaps it! Talk about waste of potential! Thankfully this movie corrected that error! And honestly it’s all the better for it since the Emotional scene that comes after really highlights how guilty Oliver feels about all of this.

[@jeggsonvohees2201]

As far as killing goes Batman's rule applies moatly to human or sentient beings. Monsters or undead are generally fair game.

[@WTFreak-jk]

Damn, I never really noticed that or payed attention to that. Thanks for that buddy!🎉

[@unevenstreets1182]

Based on how well done this video was I thought you’d must have done hundreds of videos in this format. This was very good and I really enjoyed it, great work.

[@thenerddesk111]

Glad you enjoyed it! Thank you!!

[@hategoes2way345]

The lurker at the threshold is more like Yogsotha not Cthulhu. A significantly more powerful being than Cthulhu and knows all, sees all, and is omnipresent

[@thenerddesk111]

Ah, yeah my Lovecraft knowledge isn’t what it used to be, thank you.

[@BarberShave19]

It's Iog-Sotha, not Yog-Sotha.

[@caviddoish]

Jeffery Combs also played Dr Herbert West in the Re-Animator movies which is a HP Lovecraft adaptation and is also the name of the doctor who looks at Two-Faces disease in the movie! Just some fun interconnectivity between DC and Lovecraft :)

[@BarberShave19]

He was also in the movie "From Beyond", another Lovecraft adaptation.

[@Thor-Torpedo25]

I read the comic book first and didn’t even know there was a movie until I saw this video, thanks for letting us know about it. Great video by the way, really well put together.

[@thenerddesk111]

Of course dude, making these videos is gonna be fun.

[@eur0be4t3r]

To be fair the movie came out last year

[@mixednarwhal]

This was a very well put together video that did good at keeping me who clicked on the wrong video interested throughout the whole video. I know other people have commented similar things on other small channels but I thought your channel was bigger and more well known just from the video itself. I hope your KZbin channel does great and that you always enjoy what you upload.

[@thenerddesk111]

Thank you so much, that means a lot, I’ve been working at this stuff for a while and I’m glad I’ve gotten as far as I have, hope you achieve your goals too!

[@sunsetman22]

holy shit Howard Hamlin as Two Face! I think that would be an excellent live-action casting

[@jadedmillion8991]

Having recently watched The Amazing Screw on Head's pilot based on Mike Mignola's comic. It's such a shame they didn't use his art style in this similar to that. Heck I would've taken even the Hellboy animated movies style while watered down still encapsulates the angular sharp style Mike is known for. And that's not to say the movie is ugly, I just wish these animated DC movies would look more distinct from one another more often and change it up. Good vid.

[@thenerddesk111]

Thank you, and I agree for sure, art style could made this movie way better.

[@majordisaster]

As someone who also enjoys comparing adaptations to the thing they're based on, you did a great job, looking forward to seeing anything you come up with next

[@thenerddesk111]

Thank you!! I just actually released a comparison of Old Man Logan, the Wolverine book!

[@dr.ninjake]

David Dastalmachian actually does a ton of weird DC stuff, he plays some minor villains on Gotham & the Flash and even voices the Flash in, of all projects, the RWBY x Justice League movies

[@thenerddesk111]

Similar to Alan Tudyk in that way then, but I have no clue what RWBY is 😂

[@dr.ninjake]

@@thenerddesk111 it’s an anime-influenced web show that’s been running for a while now. The studio that produced it, Rooster Teeth, got bought by WB, they made some crossover comics, then adapted them into movies in the show’s style, then WB closed the studio. They’re not great watches honestly, but I’ve kinda got a soft spot for ‘em, they’re effectively time capsules from DC animation’s lowpoint and Rooster Teeth’s downfall and a neat little blip in DC’s history.

[@thenerddesk111]

Ah, ok. That’s pretty cool, even if there weren’t all that great, cool to see unique stuff like that.

[@JAGL1728]

My mate, we need more videos like this, showing more of your book shelves and showing us more comics

[@thenerddesk111]

Working on one as we speak 😉

[@the.sketch.projekt8851]

What I don’t really like is that The Doom That Came to Gotham has its own batsuit with it very much feeling from the era of the 1920s but for the movie, they opted to just use the Gotham By Gaslight suit.

[@Sewage_water]

This is so Mignola.I just wish it was in his art style

[@thenerddesk111]

Me too, at least his writing was there, and pretty on point.

[@Thepopcornator]

Harvey tossing Batman his coin as his last act before death is the ultimate sign of respect.

[@pickedceasar1216]

Still not a fan of them killing off the two robins in the beginning for pure shock value

[@ShockwaveFPSStudios]

Never heard of the Doom that came to Gotham until now.

[@vanyadolly]

My only issue with the comic was not allowing other characters to shine and how rushed the story felt. I wish they'd gone for much longer run, because it's such a fascinating world.

[@Noir_Man]

I enjoyed the video. Definitely subscribing

[@thenerddesk111]

Thank you so much!

[@propane_salesman]

Jeffery Combs was a good pick for this movie. Not just because of his prior work within DC, but he's also most famous for his roles in horror movies based off of Lovecraft's writing, like Re-Animator and From Beyond.

[@thenerddesk111]

I did see a lot of that in his credits when I was researching, he’s such a unique actor in my opinion.

[@darkknightfan7520]

Great elseworld story, proving that Batman can work in any scenario & setting. I think the film is criminally underrated, one of the best dc animated has made in a long time! But I get way it wasn’t talked about since the animated movies haven’t been mindblowing for a while.

[@michaelreynolds6710]

13:54 he also played scarecrow in the new batman adventures

[@danielramsey6141]

What sucks about His fight with Poison Ivy in the Comics, is that SHE KILLS him off So Quick! She grabs his neck and snaps it! Talk about waste of potential! Thankfully this movie corrected that error! And honestly it’s all the better for it since the Emotional scene that comes after really highlights how guilty Oliver feels about all of this.

[@AnvilPictures]

I’m actually going to be directing a short film that I wrote that’s based on the King in Yellow. Who makes an appearance in the background as madness slowly seeps into the main character of the story. I’ll start production after the summer.

[@thenerddesk111]

Best of luck to you! I’ll be sure to check that out.

[@pkroninverse7307]

I really thought that I will hate this movie but I loved it

[@Sluggwurth]

I saw this trade at my local library and was interested. The art being almost like Mignola’s art but not by him kinda trips me out 😂

[@thenerddesk111]

I get that, he’s got such a unique pair style

[@gilgy4626]

Really like this video essay content, hope you haven’t given up on animation though

[@thenerddesk111]

Oh definitely not, I’ve got a few things planned in the works coming out eventually.

[@ianyoder2537]

Honestly this movie failed as both a batman adaptation and Lovecraft adaptation. If you want a better DC vs eldrich god story, I'd recommend Justice League New Frontier. Yes it's more of an homage to the entire DC universe but the and the eldrich god takes a back seat for most of the story, but what little time spent on it is used rather efficiently.

[@thenerddesk111]

I honestly haven’t read new frontier, so I’m interested to see what you’re referring to.

[@ianyoder2537]

@@thenerddesk111 It's a movie not a comic. I'm a movie guy who occasional watches comics recaps to stay mostly up to date.

[@thenerddesk111]

Ah ok, I’ll be sure to add that to my list.

[@Acekuando]

Good video! 😊

[@bigsmonk1025]

holy fuck, I clicked on the video, only to look down and be shocked at the low view count. your quality is very high bro, you'll get good views easily.

[@thenerddesk111]

Thank you man, I appreciate that seriously

[@SmitzPNK]

I'm tired of the joker! I think the penguin of Mr Freeze is way more interesting

[@thenerddesk111]

Riddler has always been my favorite.

[@ghostwarrior3878]

I hope you do something like this for Justice League the New Frontier and its adaptation.

[@thenerddesk111]

Maybe! I just did one on Wolverine and then the next one will be dc again

[@cameronmeder166]

Could you do a video like this on crisis on infinite earths animated and comic

[@entropias_gonos]

You forgot Dastmalchian's best movie, Late Night with the Devil. Here I am with a request. There is a comic, a comic which has been adapted into a movie and later into a game, all three being wildly different from each other. It's a weird beast, but... I'm nothing if not hopeful. Pls do compare WANTED at some point.

[@thenerddesk111]

I’ll look into it, I’m not sure I have the format down well enough to tackle three different versions yet, but I will keep it in mind for when I do.

[@entropias_gonos]

@@thenerddesk111 thanks. In all honesty it's a pretty different beast. The game especially might not fit in at all, I'm just mesmerized by some of the adaptation decisions which want into making it. The whole thing is a weird early 2010s mess.

[@thenerddesk111]

@@entropias_gonos it seems different, definitely something to challenge myself with.

[@rickodaddy6355]

They do say Cthulhu in the movie haven't read the comic

[@WHATIFHORROR]

You should do this with “brightburn” great video btw 🔥

[@thenerddesk111]

Thank you, but does brightburn have a comic it’s based on?

[@WHATIFHORROR]

@@thenerddesk111 yes I believe it was was inspired by a dc Halloween special called “bump in the night” featuring Superman but I could be mistaken

[@thenerddesk111]

I’ll look into, thanks for the recommendation!

[@danielramsey6141]

God, Brightburn sucks 🙄

[@Zekrel]

When I saw the trailer I thought the movie would be a total lackluster letdown so I put it off for a while. When I finally watched it today, I was stunned at how good it was.

[@sahilhossain8204]

Lore of Batman the Doom That Came to Gotham: A Comic vs Movie Comparison | Video Essay momentum 100

[@flintson2268]

No guns in the movie version? That was the best part damnit

[@thenerddesk111]

lol, no unfortunately

[@danielramsey6141]

I didn’t care. The Action still hit hard.

[@1001johny]

Next check out Batman Soul of the Dragon. Same voice for Batman here first voiced Batsy there. I think it's great.

[@thenerddesk111]

I’ll put it on my list!

[@EddAnders2005]

Now gotham by gaslight

[@thenerddesk111]

At some point I’m the future for sure

[@ksiaa814]

Eh about batman killing I mean when batman started off in the 30s he was killing people without remorse so it'll be fitting for that time period. The batman no kill rule didn't take effect until more modern takes of batman.

[@shubhpatel619]

Wait there was a new animated movie????

[@thenerddesk111]

Yes! Came out mid 2023 if I remember correctly.

[@gamerzilla6113]

What do you think about upcoming Hellboy: The Crooked Man movie?

[@thenerddesk111]

Not very well versed in Hellboy material, I’d probably look at the Ron pearlman movie anyways.

[@emperorsean1]

He doesn't kill in either version

[@thenerddesk111]

Yeah, like I mentioned in the video captions I definitely overrated that point, I originally just wanted to talk about his gun use.

[@robertopopkivich5466]

What's wrong with the cat can someone tell me the name here?

[@thenerddesk111]

The cat?

[@robertopopkivich5466]

@@thenerddesk111 hp Lovecrafts cat

[@thenerddesk111]

Oh, I’d just look it up, I can’t exactly say it.

[@thesmilyguyguy9799]

:

[@SHDW-nf2ki]

0/10 Batman shouldn't kill

[@burnsvillebatman]

I'm ngl, I don't fw elseworlds Batman that much. That's just me tho I prefer a modern day Batman doin regular Batman things but I do appreciate that they will use him in such different ways for other readers and viewers

[@thenerddesk111]

I respect that, elseworlds Batman can be really confusing sometimes.

[@richardabia9735]

1:49 Gosh. Imagine people getting offended because a fictional character uses a gun ....oh wait ...