Battle of the Bulge, Animated - Part 1, The Assault Begins

[@TheOperationsRoom]

Play Enlisted for FREE on PC, Xbox Series X|S, and PS®5: playen.link/theoperationsroom Follow the link to download the game and get your exclusive bonus now. See you in battle!

[@stevenclark8225]

Thank you

[@dudududu1926]

Forgot this game existed.

[@Greatwealthgentleman]

Great game

[@CBB-dg9jy]

@@dudududu1926 I've been playing for almost a year, this is what I asked for in BFV but didn't get.

[@dudududu1926]

@@CBB-dg9jy You asked for predatory monetization?

[@username-tv6uw]

"His artillery support would never come". Glad to hear some things never change.

[@edmondlau511]

FDC was probably too busy playing cards and smoking cigarettes

[@jacksoncross9265]

yeah, but with a force 4% the size i dont think he needed it

[@RobinTheBot]

Knowing the entire offensive could have been stopped with some less cowardly tankers and some less useless artillerymen is frustrating. Like... Why do they think the Germans are not likely to try a desperate breakthrough? Obviously they would...

[@arts6821]

Probably the worse feeling during combat, asking for help but being denied it and knowing without it you’re going to probably die.

[@edmondlau511]

@@arts6821 when the final approval has to be from a guy in a TOC miles away from the fight, that’s what happens.

[@ChamonixHouse884]

Indy and TGA crew combined with the operations room is everything I’ve ever wanted.

[@elektrotehnik94]

[@jacobwaddell6075]

Big facts

[@PripyatTourist]

Yeah, I'm fan-girling over here myself! 🥳🥳🥳

[@wlpxx7]

It's legendary. Such a solid vid

[@greyedgamer]

Would you please explain who Indy and the TGA crew are?

[@freedomhq4075]

The level of effort and the rate of posting this channel has given in the last month is like shit a full blown established docu studio couldn’t do themselves. Incredible

[@LaurensPP]

Well, the visuals are extremely basic and do not even come close to representing how it happened. This was reasonably fitting for the Battle of Mogadishu, but for the Battle for the Bulge or Iwo Jima it frankly does not make too much sense. I still enjoy it though.

[@More_Row]

@@LaurensPP that's not a fair comment. While "basic" it's way more than what you usually get with coverage of the battle of the bulge. Would like to see you make something like this less "basic" . And still watchable. Basically, get a life.

[@christiangallien3730]

Both of you guys should chill

[@LaurensPP]

@@More_Row For the strategic view/scale I think it's fine. For the tactical I find it a bit silly though.

[@jpnarino]

@@LaurensPPhappening

[@TheOperationsRoom]

I hope you all enjoyed Part 1, Part 2 is already out!

[@candowe4926]

nice

[@jamesknight1587]

Whoooooooo!

[@charliedaood444]

Yoooo. hype

[@CWallace268]

You are the 🐐

[@adambutler3266]

Part One demolished, must secure part 2 at 7 😂

[@Thevc3podcast]

First Iowa Jima, and now the Battle of the Buldge. Plus you got Indy? Man this channel is killing it! Thank you for the top of the line content.

[@extrahistory8956]

What's with the sudden burst of Iwo and Bulge content? First Jesse Alexander and the Real Time History team make videos on these and now this channel. Not to mention the crossovers, Indy, Jesse and Drach have all collaborated with each other before, and Jesse is Indy's successor in The Great War channel.

[@crabmansteve6844]

Iowa Jima, the potatoes will never taste the same after that offensive.

[@redswift31]

@@crabmansteve6844 Wrong state that's Idaho...

[@lg-0297]

@@extrahistory8956 I think it’s because military history has sort of become “mainstream” since Russias invasion of Ukraine. The fact this has hundreds of thousands of views already proves that. There are FAR more credible history KZbinrs now than ever before. Add the fact that WW2 and it’s battles are always going to be talked about and you get a bunch of history channels covering the same topic. Which isn’t a bad thing at all. The people who made fun of me a year ago for always studying history are now watching these kinds of documentaries, themselves. More demand = more content.

[@extrahistory8956]

@@lg-0297 Oh I ain't complaining at all. I'm extremely proud of what the history side of KZbin has been able to achieve over the last few years.

[@Kubakaiser]

I love how this goes all the way from strategic to tactical overview. From whole countries and armies, to single soldiers, buildings, vehicles and foxholes.

[@Bokator2]

12:17 seeing all the flags pop up like that while the prisoners are slaughtered and have no where to go is pretty harrowing

[@rameygardner4782]

Makes me angry

[@Oscar-ds2vb]

should've stayed on your side of the atlantic.

[@TOXICDUB1]

The US stopped taking prisoners after this aswell. War brings out the worst

[@Tom_Cruise_Missile]

@@Oscar-ds2vb Germany got what it deserved in the end. Should've stayed in your own country.

[@TheKsalad]

@@Oscar-ds2vb Germans still lost the war lmao, cry some more Fritz

[@Sunday_fits]

The scene of the massacre was done well and was everything you described chilling and rage inducing

[@Oscar-ds2vb]

lol

[@guerillagorilla4423]

@@Oscar-ds2vb What?

[@doncolor3473]

@@guerillagorilla4423 maybe he Like to point Out, that the "masacre" is questionable.

[@Chuked]

@@doncolor3473 it was still a war crime, no point in attempting to say any different

[@doncolor3473]

@@Chuked thats what i ment, ist is not so save that it was one. There is an interesting Doku about it called "Über Galgen wächst kein Gras". kzbin.info/www/bejne/jmjbm5-JnMSCgdk Long thing short, the pow was Shot because some start running after Piper was leaving and told the pow to wait for the Infantry because he had not enough men to guard them. The following Infantry saw running soldier and Shoot. I don' t say that this Version is true , but at least questionable. Anyway , there were two more massacre that should be mentioned . The Wereth and Chenogne. Anyway, I don't want to reduce the Work of this Channel here but there are often more than one point of View 🙏🏻

[@justonemori]

Thank you for mentioning St Vith. Most documentaries are all like "the Bulge started on the 16th, the 106th got railroaded.....Bastogne!". The defenders that held the town for 6 days before being ordered out by Monty earned a Presidential Unit Citation. My grandfather escaped across the bridge at Vielsalm very early on the 24th as part of the last group out, Task force Jones. The 82nd Airborne blew the bridge soon after. Never forget!

[@jackthorton10]

Never Give Up, Never Surrender! Airborne all the way!

[@Shaboomquisa]

my great great uncle was general sink of the 506. then col sink

[@SantaClaus-kk8zr]

Dunno if you'll see this but my great grandfather, rest his soul, was in the 82nd. He fought his way through Normandy, Market Garden, and then served in a multitude of places including Bastogne briefly. He never spoke much of it though, but I do wonder if he was a part of that in some way. All I have of him now is his pump shotgun from when he hunted, and a handful of photos.

[@justonemori]

@@L_Train I'll be sure to read that. My current favorite book is "Loss and Redemption at St Vith" by Gregory Fontenot. He has a couple long discussions here on youtube about the book, good stuff.

[@L_Train]

@@justonemori cool I just looked him up and realized that I've listened to a couple of his talks on desert storm. Didn't know he wrote a book I might have to check it out.

[@overlythicc4773]

The recent uptick in videos both in quantity and quality have been astounding, hats off to the whole team behind these productions!

[@briankorbelik2873]

I'm an old geezer now, (67 before this month is out), and I've been fascinated with WW2 history since I was a kid. This video is great, and the way the facts are presented make my history loving soul, tingle. Thank you! I worked at a major telephone company and while doing so one of my co-workers turned out to be the son of the top Seargent in the entire 101st Airborne during the war. He told me some of the things his dad had told him about being surounded in Bastonge. My co-worker was named after General Marshall, head of the then version of the Joint Chief's of Staff.

[@frankieM_]

"Let them come" Man, Bradley really ate his own words there

[@jordansamson6071]

History shall remember him was being a tremendous ass.

[@Jagonath]

Well I mean technically he was right. But you're certainly more right than he was.

[@bobmillholland6345]

I think the Bradley quote needs some context here. While admitting intelligence failure at all levels, he surmised reasonably that the Germans were planning a spoiling attack to blunt the Allies push toward the Reich. He, along with Ike and Monty took a calculated risk in a lightly defending the Ardennes in favor of keeping pressure on the Wehrmacht reeling from the Normandy breakout.

[@unofficial_ai]

Indy showing up put a huge smile on my face. What an amazing collaboration! Thank you for that

[@cd5927]

My grandfather, Leon Wikoff, was in the battle of the bulge near the Ardennes. He spent 3 days hiding in a wine cellar with his squad surrounded by Germans. It's amazing to see this battle in such detail.

[@quaygrass6212]

Oh, you‘re not bsing. He died in 2003?

[@teller1290]

My late uncle was cut off with one squad mate for several days. My uncle, big outdoorsman, killed a dear with M-1 finally to eat, despite risk. No one knew where they were for sure in the chaos. They were almost killed early on due signalling to "an American tank" by waiving something overhead from a distance. But the tank column was German and long-range m.g. cracked overhead in the branches! They successfully fled and his until somehow hearing or spitting U.S. forces.

[@visassess8607]

With a name like that I thought you were gonna say he fought for Germany

[@cd5927]

@@visassess8607 Nope, Wikoff is Danish, not German. Plus he was an American born citizen at that point.

[@cd5927]

@@quaygrass6212 More like 1993. I was too young when he died to remember having met him.

[@patrickazzarella6729]

Hearing the Panzer 4 Ausf. H's side skirts actually be effective against HEAT warheads when they were designed against AT rifles is actually amazing. Never heard of this encounter before.

[@nyssfairchild2244]

It's effectively spaced armor. Additionally the rockets seemed to be coming in at a rather steep angle, so there's also that. Either way, it's interesting how despite not being designed for it, they worked regardless.

[@scarsofhonor6333]

Every little helps with armor, a glancing hit to a helmet is better than a glancing hit to the skull, even if it was designed for shrapnel.

[@jackthorton10]

Better you are protected, Better Chance for you to shrug off the hits, and return fire

[@calebr908]

Ya it cant penetrate unless the angle is good and the contact is a specific distance from the armor. Thats why people use things like slat armor etc.

[@steved5495]

If the rocket is coming in straight enough, the side skirts actually improve the penetration, because stand-off distance wasn't understood at the time. It also depends whether the rockets had the pointed nose or the rounded one. The former had a greater chance to slide off where the latter would detonate.

[@jiraph52]

The realistic map and topography is a huge step up in quality and really adds to the viewing experience. Good work!

[@collaborativelearning1]

My sentiments exactly, thank you!

[@mathewm7136]

Great video and thanks. Cliff Claven Trivia: "Bulge" was the only offensive were the Germans did not use Enigma in both the prep and offensive. Because of this, Allied CMD wrongly assumed that the Germans had discovered their ability to decode and therefore the Allies stopped using it for the remainder of the war.

[@sjonnieplayfull5859]

*Enigma. Ultra was the code breaking effort

[@mathewm7136]

@@sjonnieplayfull5859 Thank you. Correction made. As to why Enigma wasn't used for the Bulge has never been factually determined. But many theorize that: As OKH would broadcast all Enigma messages on the same freq for all military forces (minus naval), army cdr's would often use it to monitor the orders for neighboring commands. Therefore (as the theory goes), AH and OKH feared that by using Enigma, the Eastern commanders would have discovered the massing of men, armor and logistics in the West while they were fighting just to survive each day on the Eastern front (quote "Crosses of Iron" heroism was now an everyday occurrence for most.) and would have, at minimum "Blown a flippin' head gasket" or, at worse, just capitulated. So OKH used landlines and direct curriers to coordinate.

[@jimrobinette1036]

Didn’t need to as necessary commo was all via courier for plans transmission and realtime coordination was via landlines within Germany itself.

[@TJ24050]

Earnest Hemingway’s account at the end describes the situation perfectly. My grandpa was an MP and said they went through every non combat unit and picked every other man for 4 weeks of infantry training and they were sent up as reinforcements. The morning he was waiting to move up to the front a LT pulled up and pulled him for traffic duty behind the lines. He said he never knew why he was spared, but that he thanked god.

[@shlomomark2275]

The actor Charles Durning was among the few that survived the Malmedy massacre and carried a fellow wounded soldier to safety. He recived a Silver star for his action in the war

[@TheBismark117]

"We are paratroopers Lieutenant, we are supposed to be surrounded." - Captain Winters.

[@maryholder3795]

Love that comment by Captain Winters, it was spot on.

[@hobojakobo]

10:30 One of the most understated strengths of the allies, specifically the US- logistics. To be able to react that quickly and move that much men/material to the front is incredible.

[@SStoj]

Or the opposite Soviet feat of moving all the men/material away from the front.

[@hobojakobo]

@@SStoj absolutely. The Soviets were successfully moving entire factories hundreds of miles to avoid the German advance. Pretty amazing.

[@lyndoncmp5751]

The Germans also reacted very quickly to Market Garden. Nearly all of the German armour that fought in Market Garden wasn't even in the Netherlands when the paras were dropped. These armoured units were quickly sent in from Germany, in some cases over 200km away such as the Tigers of Kompanie Hummel in Beielefeld and 400km away such as the King Tigers of Abteilung 506 in Ohrdruf.

[@looinrims]

Literally everyone talks about it, what do you mean ‘understated’

[@goxyeagle8446]

US lost 80,000 men during German counteroffensive, weak Germany after 5 years of fighting

[@timberwolfe1645]

Yes!!!! You mentioned the most important Unit in HISTORY!!!! So Proud of LeBouck and his original RECON Platoon, defending thatr ridge forever@!!!! True heroes

[@danseegmiller2452]

It's a story I've heard so many times, but feels so dramatic watching you narrate all the pieces. Thanks again.

[@icygaming20]

The Indy Neidell collaboration was unexpected lol

[@alitlweird]

They did that on purpose! 🤘😆🤘 *EasterEgg!!*

[@failtolawl]

Yea almost ruined the whole video, luckily he didn't have much to say

[@icygaming20]

@@failtolawl wtf, indy is awesome

[@camg6400]

@@failtolawl Bah! Indy is the best, you are the worst my friend

[@failtolawl]

@@camg6400 yes I'm well aware his internet persona is so enticing to many

[@vvvppp6021]

First Drachinifel and now Indy Neidell, man keep those collabs coming!

[@TheOperationsRoom]

More to come :)

[@Roberto-tu5re]

I am enthralled already in the first minute. How you put this together not only with facts and entertainment is beyond me. Please keep up the good work.

[@bossaudio12]

First minute is an ad

[@Roberto-tu5re]

@@bossaudio12 Correct maybe I should have dumbed it down for you to the definition of the first minute of the actual video.

[@nathaniellazo5912]

The Battle of the Bulge, this is going to be an amazing one!! Keep up the top quality work guys!!

[@oasis1282]

Very true

[@icygaming20]

The work you guys put in is insane! Great work

[@williamwells6468]

My grandfather was in the 28th Division. He said the day the battle kicked off was one of worst days of his war and he went through the Hurtgen Forrest and the Normandy campaign.

[@IceBreaker.22]

Well done! As a belgian living 30 miles from Bastogne i say thank you for your work.

[@tB3o3tR9o9]

belgium is lost^^

[@randomlegionary9399]

12:30 The mountain of flags is somehow tame and respectful as a sign of death but just horrifying to see so many

[@Nickdamamurray]

One of the most underrated things about this channel, is the music in the backround

[@robinsonsstudios]

Fun fact, the schürzen on the Panzer IV were initially not designed to protect against shaped charges but against anti tank rifles. That they offered protection against bazooka and the likes was a welcomed side effect

[@gotanon9659]

They did not offer protection against bazooka it actually helped the bazooka penetrate better much to the shock of the germans.

[@onyxdragon1179]

They did not offer protection against bazookas, they actually made bazookas even more effective! There was an issue with bazooka rockets were the fuse would have a delay and it wouldn't always be set as the rocket hit the tank, resulting in the rocket shattering or bouncing off the tank. With the shürzen, the rocket fuse would be set off as it effortlessly sliced through the sheet of metal, just in time to explode as it made contact with the tank and cause maximum penetration/damage! It only protected effectively against anti tank rifles (to which surprisingly the Panther had a vulnerable spot), if they didn't fall to pieces just from travel.

[@NoMoreCrumbs]

Really nice effect with the larger overview map zooming and filling in to the individual battlefield maps

[@jeremy5602]

The bit about Ernest Hemingway packing a Thompson to return to the front made me laugh so hard. Randy Feltface gave a very fast, short, and summed up biography of his life in one of his shows and that just fits right into it. What a gigachad.

[@brandonferretti9907]

Love the purple monster. Especially his most famous part of buying a bookshelf of Gumtree

[@Vodgepie1]

Seeing battles I’ve read about in detail from this point of view just adds so much to my understanding

[@user-njyzcip]

I did not expect to hear Indy here, this is a crossover we needed

[@NVRAMboi]

Possibly the best (quality, production, research) effort yet. YOU NEED A MILLION SUBS!. THANK YOU

[@colbyphillips7039]

Indy from Time Ghost is voicing some of this! Awesome!

[@Mrcookieonyt]

My great grandfather fought in this battle. Thank you for taking a close look at it and sharing this story.

[@Bootneck-RMC]

Superb animated re-telling of a part of this operation that not a lot of of people had heard about. Looking forward to part 2.👍

[@TheOperationsRoom]

Part 2 is already out 🙂

[@shane1489]

I’m glad people like this take the time to chronicle these events. Very important.

[@PhillyPhanVinny]

My 2 favorite WW2 channels working together is just amazing! The Operations Room Channel has been skyrocketing up the list of historical war channels because of how great it is!

[@hillbillystacker]

My great uncle Granville H Brewer was in the 393rd 99th Infantry Div. He was killed in action on Dec 27, 1944 in the Battle of the Bulge a long way from home in Eastern Kentucky.

[@justandy333]

If you havent seen Band of Brothers I seriously urge you to see it. Its a HBO production, 10 episode series covering the 101st Airborne's Easy Companies involvement. Including their involvement of the battle of the bulge. I can't give it enough praise, By far and away the best series or film alike I've ever seen. IMDB has given it a 9.4/10. For one I agree entirely.

[@lyndoncmp5751]

Its overrated. Id rather watch Frasier.

[@TheGrickler]

Ending is boring. Like last 2 episodes are about a car accident. But it is peak ww2 film

[@justandy333]

@@TheGrickler I agree, it just fizzled out at the end. But that's how it happened. Many soldiers were stuck in Germany as an occupying force with nothing much to do and couldn't go home because they didn't have the points required. You say boring, I say realistic.

[@danando2]

​@@lyndoncmp5751it's overrated , I rather watch big bang theory

[@lyndoncmp5751]

@@danando2 Only children watch Big Bang Theory.

[@marctravismba]

Thanks for this. My grandfather fought at the Battle of the Bulge.

[@MrWolfstar8]

Great visuals and having Indy do a cameo was awesome. Love your channel

[@williamcastillo2312]

Hell yeah bringing Indy over for this was awesome

[@calebmitchell6870]

The quality of understanding in your videos is going exponential! Thanks for the hard work!

[@merten0083]

My man Indy showing up to narrate, I couldn't believe my ears. I'm so thankful that he explained The Great War so well to me and is here now.

[@contrapasta2454]

The operations room has been running wild lately. I LOVE IT.

[@ramal5708]

I can't wait for Patton's 90 degrees wheel offense to rescue the 101st Airborne guys at Bastogne, although those Paras didn't need any rescuing.

[@maynardburger]

Really fantastic stuff. These animations really explain things in a way that words just rarely can.

[@TheBigJohnson]

Always great content. But having Indy narrate some of it, and having Drach do part of the Iwo videos we’re gravy. Thank you as always!

[@cybehr117]

Love to listen to this while I work. Thank you for your amazing effort and shout out to Indy for his amazing presence in the military history community.

[@itaphil]

Thanks for creating this. I especially appreciated the animated maps to accompany your narrative.

[@scettybagle5552]

Indy!!! Omg 😲 my two favorite channels just casually collaborated?!?!

[@SaneGuySports]

Wow this is EXCELLENT! Thank you Ops Room for your first rate production, visuals and storytelling.

[@coolguy2715]

These are top tier content on KZbin

[@avnut5517]

NICE collaboration! This is how I wish I learned about these battles in school.

[@TheFriley4]

There is a book I read about Lt. Bouch's platoon called "The Longest Winter". If you found it unbelievable that none of the 18 men died in that outnumbered fight, get this: all 18 of them lived through brutal POW conditions to the end of the war. The details of the book are great too, I believe there were first hand accounts from the Germans who were there who were astonished at the Americans tenacity and marksmanship. They definitely thought they were engaging a much larger force!

[@L_Train]

Yes! I just posted about this book all over this comments section. The audiobook is actually on KZbin if you search for it. The Longest Winter by Alex Kershaw

[@Precooledtrout]

joachim pieper himself stormed into the cafe in which they were being held. screaming at all of his officers and asked why they’d been held up for a whole day, they responded saying an entire division was in the woods, it was only his platoon. what makes this even better is they traded captured german “memorabilia” to a mechanics and armourers for every man to get a fully automatic m1 carbine, 30 caliber machine guns, and a willy’s jeep with sherman frontal armor slapped on the front and a 50 caliber mounted in the center also have sherman armor covering it. the fat electrician made a video about him and his platoon recently, you should check it out!

[@beefwich]

This whole series is so amazing.

[@MyBlueZed]

I very much appreciate your correct pronunciation of place names. Publishing part 2 quickly adds to the feeling of urgency of the Allied response. 👍🏻❤️🇦🇺

[@stephenrodwell8125]

This, along with the Iwo Jima series is next level!

[@amarlatte1211]

This and the iwo Jima series are fantastic. I have always loved your videos but this is on a whole 'nother level. Amazing job!

[@Nat3ski]

Your recent mini series focusing on individual actions has been above and beyond! Excellent detailed narrative and illustrations. Absolutely top quality!

[@TheBenghaziRabbit]

ugh i didnt want this to end! GOING TO PART 2!!!!

[@mike6252]

These animations give me a lot of nostalgia for the Close Combat Series. Especially for the Battle Of The Bulge addition. Excellent work as always!

[@sdinvt]

Hell yeah, Im so excited for this series.

[@bolobalaman]

This battle put the slogan *We are airborne , we meant tobe surrounded* to reality

[@Luis-be9mi]

“We’re paratroopers lieutenant, we’re supposed to be surrounded” - Dick Winters Band of Brothers Or my personal favorites when I was in the 101st: “If we’re not surrounded that means we missdropped.” Or “We’re paratroopers, we ain’t happy until we’re surrounded!”

[@bolobalaman]

@@Luis-be9mi That’s awesome. The line i heard was actually a airborne unit line whenever you click on them in Company of Heroes lol

[@asianbandit4054]

Two episodes in one day and one of the most interesting / last throw of the dice for Germany, campaign of ww2. God go with you sir.

[@minime9990]

Guys, smacking it out of the park with number of uploads, thanks so much for your time, effort and passion. Big love

[@FirstLast-di5sr]

Indy!! I love seeing some of my favorite history channels collaborating! Makes already great content even better!

[@emperorfloch]

Operations Room you are dropping heat after heat! 🙌🏼 Please keep these videos coming 😁

[@aliud9904]

Dude you shoulda heard me when Indy showed up Loved his WW1 series

[@StinkyPinky3000]

I love these guys! I really hope you get an award for all this incredible content.

[@MrBellsa61]

I was NOT expecting Indy Neidell's voice, this is an extremely pleasant surprise.

[@exposethenwo6491]

My great uncle was at the Battle of the Bulge. He was separated from his squad about 30 minutes into the attack and had to hide for a few minutes in a half frozen pond to escape detection from a German squad that was in the area

[@sirbillius]

The WW2 in real time series just reached the Battle of the Bulge, so I guess I get to watch these again.

[@fakecubed]

This is why you always treat prisoners of war and civilians of the enemy nation or liberated friendly nation with the utmost respect and dignity. You want your enemy to feel comfortable surrendering to you, you want civilian populations to give you no resistance, and you want civilian populations to assist you instead of assisting the enemy. There's examples on all sides of every conflict in history committing atrocities, but the side that minimizes theirs and punishes soldiers who commit atrocities instead of encouraging them, is the side that will generally have an easier time during and after war.

[@jtgd]

The collab we didn’t expect or ask for, but was a good surprise!

[@georgesakellaropoulos8162]

One of the key points of this battle was the resistance of the engineers at Trois Ponts. This stopped kampfgruppe Piper's advance in its tracks.

[@jackthorton10]

Engineers… Defenders with not guns but tools, a scary thought considering they know how to wreck just about every bit of infrastructure, bridge or not with just few well placed explosives

[@georgesakellaropoulos8162]

@@jackthorton10 If I remember correctly, they had two 57mm antitank guns and a bazooka, plus some mines that they used to very good effect.

[@jackthorton10]

@@georgesakellaropoulos8162 Nothing more fearful than a band of men with a bit of luck, the tools of the trade, and a determined grit to send the enemy a proper wake up call that they are no longer in the right

[@questionmark05]

Beautiful animations and bloody awesome collaborations. Thank you!

[@EchosTackyTiki]

Last time I heard someone reference Hemingway it was in a boring manner. Now I find out he strapped up a Tommy gun and ran to the Ardennes to be on the frontline for the Battle of the Bulge. He's a cooler dude than I thought.

[@docvideo93]

Those opening days of the Battle of the Bulge are full of stories. One story was from the rushed in reinforcements in 1947's book "Company Commander" from Charles B. McDonald where is his company held up German units at Elsenborn Ridge on five charges until the sixth broke up the whole company. One of McDonald's men would receive the Medal of Honor for covering the unit's retreat. The whole book "Company Commander" is excellent.

[@insertnamehere6659]

Will you ever do a video on the behind-the-scenes of these documentaries? Everything is very well researched, and I would love to gain some perspective on how much effort is put into each one.

[@contrapasta2454]

He has a secondary channel, The Intel Report.

[@Paras_Pertti]

Greetings from Finland! 🇫🇮 I love this series, it is so detailed and shines a light on some lesser known engagements of the operation. Amazing work!👍

[@Demun1649]

Really great to hear Bastogne pronbounced correctly, unlike in "Band of Brothers", "Battle of the Bulge", and other American films. Well done.

[@specialopssoldier1]

who cares? let people say it however they want karen

[@JunHector]

@@specialopssoldier1 What are you even on about?

[@muadddib]

I always thought its just more a reality that most soldiers did neither speak french nor german, hence they pronounced it the way that made sense to them. And even if you knew better, it would probably have been better to just stick to the name everyone could understand.

[@Demun1649]

@@specialopssoldier1 `You Trumpanzee cult-worshipping Servants of Satan are a breed apart. Left behind by the pre-Neanderthal.

[@Demun1649]

@@muadddib Yup, the constant cry of the under-educated, particularly that strange place between civilised Canada, and civilised Mexico.

[@scoutmaddoxg]

From a former US Marine... your channel is second to none.

[@paladinbob1236]

I am glad that you mentioned that some of the american soldiers had been in the hurtgen forest[what a blood bath that was]....as a Brit , i was kinda contemptuous of the american effort here..believing most units pretty much incompetent....its only abit older when i started to read books about the battle...that i learn[particularly after reading books about the battles around hurtgen forest] that some of the divisions that had been hurled into that battle, been decimated hurled into german defences with in many cases , massive losses and several morale loss and then had been moved to a "quieter area" of the front, and most of their considerable losses had been made up[in some cases] with green recruits.....when this onslaught had been unleashed upon them...its always worth a deeper look before you condemn a fighting force to more accurately understand the stresses and strains upon them

[@georgeau2523]

It's amazing how single individuals have so much impact on history, for better or worse

[@moodyrick8503]

*The height of incompetence ;* Having your entire battle plan rest upon your soldiers ability to steal fuel from the enemy, is a whole other level of stupidity.

[@Eric-kn4yn]

No choice fuel shortages

[@moodyrick8503]

@@Eric-kn4yn No choice ? It was 100 % Hitlers "choice" to go forward without enough fuel.

[@stun_resist_s]

Great to hear Indy N.!

[@ogedaykhan9909]

I absolutely love your work! But I would love to see some time and date in the video as sometimes it is hard to follow how long an offensive takes.

[@andyhoffman2666]

Thank you for excellent detailed video of Battle of the Buldge. A great synopsis. Such sacrifices!!! I'm recommending to others.

[@Newie69MK]

German Falliscrimjager units: We're gonna take that position. Lieutenant Lyle Duke: Yeah, no. Not today. US GI: LT! They outnumber us 22 to 1! Lieutenant Duke: Then it is an even fight!

[@iain-duncan]

These are really the pinnacle of ww2 battle history. Absolutely INSANE resource

[@chardaskie]

One mans gut feeling could have been one of the only things that kept the bulge from being a breakout

[@scottgiles7546]

Might to have something to do with why he was named Supreme Allied Commander.

[@kassthered8452]

Nah the germans were running out of fuel with or without Patton. They would never get even close to their goals either way...

[@chardaskie]

@@kassthered8452 Ah yes the master historian KassTheRed he knows for sure what happened and would've happened

[@guerillagorilla4423]

@@chardaskie Yes. Haven't you heard about him before?

[@Kriegter]

Seeing the warcrimes being committed was actually a shock