Before Your Eyes (Full Game No Commentary)

#NoCommentary
≡ Want to support the channel? You can do so by:
- Become a Member of the Channel on youtube: / @joshiball
- Sending a Superchat whenever i am Streaming.
≡ Social Network Links:
- Twitter: / joshiball
- Twitter: / joshiballvids - Only video notifications
- Twitch.tv: / joshiball
*Are you a copyright holder and feel like this video violates your copyright, please PM or email me and i will remove the video.

[@ivmonke]

Ngl his Dad is the best person there

[@Ethan-uf4wq]

fr

[@Ethan-uf4wq]

@Rome Fortunato idk maybe

[@rafaelalodio5116]

He is great dad

[@shamrawq5283]

He’s the voice of Grizzly from We Bare Bears!! I knew his voice sounded familiar

[@kinuit]

The part where we learned about the true life of Ben and how it really went had me crying the whole way. I'm not even kidding there wasn't a second where I wasn't bawling my eyes off and I still am.

[@kmrx8820]

Bro I cried so much my nose started bleeding lol

[@kinuit]

@@kmrx8820 oo I've never had a nosebleed before! Are you ok? 😂

[@idkhonestly7163]

@@kinuit It's probably fine, doesn't ever hurt for me at least

[@michaelwolf1377]

Right

[@cwalle7369]

​@@kmrx8820 Nose bleed while crying means that you were so distraught that your blood pressure in your entire body raised so much it increased the pressure in your head and it popped a capillary in your nose as a result of your emotional response. Now that. Now that is intense.

[@kathleen904]

the last 10 minutes hit me like a ton of bricks

[@lourilin]

you gonna carry that weight

[@berimbaueletrico2573]

I didn get it

[@christianarroyo1403]

Damn, so the whole art career was just his imagination. Everything up until the liar birds starting chirping was just a lie. He died young and just imagined that whole other life.

[@obamaprism1277]

I mean, that’s the point of the Game. Instead of dreaming of a famous and perfect life we will never achieve, we have to look back and see that we already had the best life possible.

[@w0bblegum347]

i think he told the story he wrote about the one he gave his mom

[@obamaprism1277]

@@w0bblegum347 exactly

[@whitesgonecool2467]

And that was just a lie

[@lourilin]

spoilers

[@tateh_4449]

I cried 3 times during this, The cats and the Cayotes (sorry if spelt wrong), the mothers funeral and lastly when the dad wants to try and remember the mothers presence in the room so he can feel that she is there again. All around my favourite game of all time! Thank you for uploading. :,)

[@bluefield086]

What about the love note from chloe? or the ending where the mom is and puts us at peace?

[@lourilin]

me too!

[@gamebowl]

İ hate cayotes they killed the cats in our backyard too.... Why do they have to exist... İ hope all cayotes get hunted down one day İ hate them....

[@rex2813]

"why he's smiling like that?" "he must be somewhere that he likes" that line at the end hit hard and the song of the final

[@pink_destiny8332]

*6:25** I'm pretty sure that's foreshadowing the eleven years Benny spent alive and how he made it into the afterlife or sum*

[@NibblyBitz]

1:11:06 is the agave tree 11 years onwards. I never noticed until you mentioned this :)

[@youaresomethingstrange9253]

it took me a hour just to realize the birds say liar when they caw

[@IchBereueMichSelbst]

WHAT HOW TF DID I NOT CATCH THAT

[@cognitivelydeficient4866]

I do not want to have a staring contest with the person playing this.

[@LocalAC130]

Same, bro is the champion

[@ehlistuh5081]

SPOILER! (not really but) my friend made an interesting observation! listen to the last sentence of what his parents said after you close your eyes. then, go back and listen to the 3rd and 4th sentence when he visits his memory for the first time.

[@jalenluorion]

Was it “somewhere he likes” and the “tree dies after 11 years to make something beautiful”? I don’t see a connection between those.

[@dinahmite6038]

5:25 if anyone wants the timestamp

[@dinahmite6038]

And 1:35:04 for the second timestamp

[@jalenluorion]

Ok wow I get it now. That’s a really good observation.

[@madskillzy2k]

Memento mori. that is the over all theme of this game. in fact the symbols for it are everywhere in the game. the skull, the wilting flower in the vase, and the hour glass can be seen everywhere. it means remember death, and its a complex concept that inevitability of death brings beauty and purpose to life and that we must live every day to the fullest as death grows ever near and this game captures that concept fully perfectly.

[@alienpizzaparty9996]

My boyfriend sent me this and I didn't think I'd cry but oh God this game hit too close to home for me, something about it reminds me so much of almost my entire life so far. I've never cried so hard at a game

[@Bird-dt4ss]

I cried way more at this than any other piece of art, and I really hope that the devs make another game like this.

[@Uhflower]

Man it's sad to think how much he had wanted to get better and be something and instead he died that night and even the gatekeeper couldn't listen to anymore

[@mint3465]

Man, that wolf guy needs a hug. I like him. Edit: Call your mother

[@caspianlarson7153]

I didn't think I would cry at this tbh,,,, I was completely wrong

[@Helixprotogen]

Man that hit me hard. I was like, but his life wasn't that sad. And then the ending man

[@chuckenniggets1662]

same i wanted benny and chloe to live their lives out together 😭

[@Helixprotogen]

@@chuckenniggets1662 me too

[@victoriatrevino3479]

Same

[@medbii]

This game had me crying within the first flashbacks. I'm a sucker for this kind of stuff, and just the thought of seeing my mother's face again as a ghost had me sobbing. Needless to say I was an absolute wreck by the end of the game. I love my mama, and the thought that one day she'll be gone breaks my heart. 10/10

[@oliver170]

My niece is 7 years old and she's become very interested in everything I do, reading comic books, playing unusual and indie videogames, etc. so from time to time I let her pick a comic book or a videogame to play together, she mostly chooses because of the cover, and so she did with this. Damn... what an experience we had with this, crying our eyes out together. Thanks to the devs, I could tell this really stimulated her emotional growth.

[@FabyArtz]

You're a good father Oliver. Hope everything's well

[@XLgamer1055]

Beautiful game, First thing to make me cry in years

[@lilultime6555]

Me too

[@Starlitsoul0359]

I wasn’t prepared for this

[@alllovelain]

everyone said this game made them cry and I thought I was just missing something until the end and it hit me like a truck. 11/10 experience.

[@10kkillerz71]

If this game teaches you one thing is that be thankful for life while you have it and don’t take it for granted because everyone’s life is precious in there own way remember that.

[@rylanleonhardt8221]

Thank you! I don’t have a pc but this game looked really cool! Glad someone posted it!

[@rabbadoodles4522]

Some people were saying it was sad but I didn't know it would be this sad. The ending hit me so hard in a way I never expected.

[@gorillabean5029]

Y'all know the boat in the beginning of the game where we spawn? It reminded me of the boat little Ben drew.I also remember the quote the teacher told him to write which was: "Those who don't remember the past are condemned to repeat it"

[@GM360]

His dad is the same voice of Chad from Clarence lol

[@GM360]

Also this game is a great example of an emotion that’s hard to describe sometimes. I’m crying after watching this and have absolutely no idea why

[@nishat5184]

I KNEW IT WAS CHAD FROM CLARENCE THANK YOU FOR POINTING IT OUT OMG I KNEW IT SOUNDED FAMILIAR

[@cwalle7369]

And Grizz from We Bare Bears

[@ally_oopy3688]

This broke me. I lost my mom to cancer over 2 years ago now. I would give up everything to talk to her one last time. Losing your mom at 15 takes a toll on you for sure.

[@rex2813]

@rex2813 hace 1 segundo "why he's smiling like that?" "he must be somewhere that he likes" that line at the end hit hard and the song of the end

[@NexusSomnia]

I feel like you lose a lot of emotional weight of the ending speech without swapping between his mother and the Ferryman

[@graydoughnut3848]

This game is so beautiful I want to go into too much detail about how I feel but this story made me cry

[@Puppy_Puppington]

As soon as i saw they adopted the cat / had kitties. I knew they were gonna suffer a horrible death lol. And not just because of the foreshadowing coyote bit. But because of a sinking feeling inside.

[@drchrxme4687]

I kind of pissed me off the way he would ignore the piano and just look at random objects then go back and fourth repeatedly

[@drchrxme4687]

@JAHQUAZE EDWARDS i know but it still triggered me because i play piano and the off notes are irritating, i guess i have ocd to piano

[@AmazingAutist]

@@bnuuyzs It's a joke

[@might-e9216]

At least, he lived a happy life. That's not something everybody gets. All that matters was that he was happy, he accepted it.

[@ghostishi05]

the last part of the game- it's really enough to make a grown man cry....

[@bear8469]

it’s so sad the way his paintings of his mother got blurrier and blurrier, as if he was forgetting what she looked like :(

[@cats-a-lot3609]

Lol at the beginning the lier birds caw when the ferryman says how great of a story teller he is Noice detail 👍

[@caltheanimal1447]

When the wolf guy told the gatekeeper that before her sat the soul of a child who died before he could grow old I felt an immediate hut of tears to my eyes and the ending story his mom told him before he died makes me wanna cry so bad and I usually don't cry

[@caltheanimal1447]

*hit of tears

[@caltheanimal1447]

1:32:00

[@megs4193]

This game isn't showing the heart of the character, it's showing the insight of the person playing 😢, I've watched one female and now one male and I could tell which was which without even knowing, it shows emotional awareness 😢 outstanding, so real honest so human ❤.

[@qwispss9154]

I am sobbing

[@nikolai1337]

Same here my man I usually don’t cry when it comes to video games but man this hit hard for me

[@spiritinstinct]

Same I can’t even describe how I’m feeling rn

[@rattmandoug8644]

same ..

[@alienpizzaparty9996]

I'm a very emotional person but this is the hardest I've cried to a game or to anything at all that wasn't just me overthinking

[@alexisespinoza-desjardins6362]

I don't why it's so heartwarming. I don't know why it makes me cry. I just know that there's something in it that's just so blatantly normal, so life-like that it makes me realize that the unknown is exactly what we desire and that we should embrace it, even though it's scary.

[@raywang287]

This game just gave me Thanatophobia (Fear Of Death)

[@Puppy_Puppington]

I lost a brother to cancer few years ago. It’s not fair that people die so young. It always seems to be the most kind and gentle souls who get it the worst. I can’t stand it.

[@fire2box]

With a webcam by blinking and problems with it desyncing the final bit kept "skipping" between the mom and the ferryman saying the exact same thing but at the same pace so nothing was missed and there were no pauses in the story.

[@huntermorgan6177]

19:19 As a musician, her not counting on time, combined with the piano not matching the metronome, combined with the OTHER out of sync metronome at the bottom gave me so much anxiety

[@dratuang2962]

Your such a redditor

[@jognsaf1338]

@@dratuang2962 lol well said

[@Katzykeens]

This is why I do not trust whenever an animal is featured in a video game. Y'all always kill em ._. SYMBOLIC REASONS ASIDE, I AM STILL CRUSHED.

[@lyannelove7359]

Okay, i'll be honest. I cried

[@fire2box]

I wonder what Chloe did after it all.

[@smoothbrain9779]

Me too man. This game has been on my mind all day since watching this yesterday. The worst part is how brief it is. I have so many questions about all of the characters.

[@dreamless417]

58:26 Omg I feel what you’re feeling with that drawing (|||. launchpad )😂😂😂😂😂

[@lukesmith5418]

This game is amazing. Hope you enjoyed it!

[@mitsukimiyawakifangirl]

53:17 Not a minute I haven't cried after this part, this game is truly amazing.

[@illumimarrow423]

I feel bad but I didint cry at all ... I just felt bad “-“

[@breadbutcooler]

bruh stop looking up in the middle of the piano playing it’s so infuriating lol

[@benjaminyambao2944]

one of the best story that i have watch i like how he dream of a whole life dreaming of the his future he became successful and meet chloe as an adult even i can't dream of such things i really like how the story goes "a boy who had a big dream"

[@MyDogisEvil]

i ever cried during this amazing story but i felt things my favorite character was the dad by far, props to the voice actor man what a great story what an even better game

[@witchmaker8393]

I’m not crying I’m just ugly gagging on air while eye water is on my face.

[@heavencooki6817]

Man the kittens getting eaten hit me so hard. I was in tears 😢😔

[@jevvy3295]

I found myself yelling at my screen for him to press the button 😂

[@itzkoi7372]

Man that ending hit me like a truck-

[@nettemarie8073]

I kinda want Markiplier to play this game, but I worry it could be too much for him. He did loose his dad when he was younger.

[@Raysomii]

Its been long time since i cried... Thank you i needed that

[@xtoritwilightx]

I like the no commentary because you can watch it like a movie! Very beautiful game with a good message. I love it and it will be in my top favorites! 💙

[@Sunflower-sg1it]

I didmt expect to cry so much :( 10/10

[@goodgamegamer3946]

I was crying cuz of the point where it was near the ending :( \

[@ShoMinazuki]

Officially the first game that made me cry

[@ალექსანდრეოთხოზორია]

masterpiece watched it as a movie few times

[@evannthenubb4341]

He blinked 137 times

[@clitaralexanderr.613]

Can I ask, where did the cats go? Edit: nvm it's fucking sad :c

[@thejokerheehee]

They died, I NeEd TiSsUeS

[@crinklescat1871]

Oh this was beautiful. Cried a good bit but especially at the end. Like at the moms story and the cat in the room. What a beautiful game.

[@TOAOera]

Bruh... so it was all a lie? I'm sad it was. Hm, I feel like they could have done more with Chloe. Like what if he didn't die young and his imagination was actually true? I'd like to see how that would end.

[@PunmasterSTP]

Such a beautiful game.

[@best8040]

im crying rn i started cerying at the moms story towards the end omg shits to sad

[@ehoheleren8552]

thank you so much for this video

[@dreamless417]

37:45 lmao😂😂

[@woomylover2006]

Why does the ferryrider sound like that troll gnome guy with the weird nose from power rangers mistic force

[@BigMossRock69420]

I didn't cry, but I am now hunched over with my face in my hands.

[@JackieTheAddict]

I think I need therapy...

[@aidanwhiteley6820]

The dad sounds like chad from Clarence

[@HistoryMapsMaster]

I love that game its too good i almost cried.....

[@imasealarparparp5321]

I’m going to watch this high asf tonight 4/20, heard a lot of great things I’m so psyched

[@kurochan5755]

YOOO!!! SAME!!!

[@imasealarparparp5321]

@@kurochan5755 ayyyy how was it 😂😂 I honestly didn’t watch mine the full way through I got too high and distracted like an hour in, finishing now

[@kurochan5755]

@@imasealarparparp5321 yeah same here! I watched halfway through and got hungry and passed out. Woke up early feelin good tho 😂

[@imasealarparparp5321]

@@kurochan5755 haha cheers my man 😂😂

[@imasealarparparp5321]

@@kurochan5755 hey man just found this a year later. How ya doing now?

[@RainBsalt]

Men even in his after life he still wish to lived a different life 😭😭😭😭

[@elizah789]

If I'm going to be a parent I want to be like them :))

[@aaronadethegamer]

Definitely one to try this. It looks gorgeous and moving :)

[@Aidenmm]

fuck rewatching this makes me cry like hell

[@kaveman9895]

Is the red lighting ball thing supposed to represent death?

[@tdog999100]

His illness spreading through his body, becoming larger getting closer, bringing him to death

[@ExecutorQ3]

pain

[@BluPump]

I'm so mad and sad at the same time

[@everettshay9718]

This was so lovely, thank you for sharing

[@yongconde1038]

Wait what if the person doesn't know how to use the piano

[@elizah789]

Please tell me that the voice of Grizzly the bear is also Richard!

[@LucasFabiano-wv5gc]

W clhoe

[@h0b0y0da4]

God it hurts man

[@cats-a-lot3609]

Ok crap just realized the ferryman is a coyote

[@mori_a.Wolfboi]

😔the end was realy good

[@johnthefool8462]

why richard sould like Chris Pratt

[@zidaxi5297]

i sat there for an hour and 41 minutes just watching😖 also why does his dad sound like hopper from stranger things

[@sever7868]

Hey idk if this is possible but if anyone can help me find all soundtracks for this game i would be very happy thank you

[@bunyigma2870]

The sounds like grizzly from we bare bears,😭

[@char3475]

bestis dont watch this youll cry for days

[@blank4707]

i know i’m late to this but wow i just... this is amazing on new level thanks you

[@dinahmite6038]

If I had emotions I would have cried

[@alivewolf3432]

😥😢😭😊❤ It was beautiful

[@peter9899]

Thank you.