Beleriand at War | Of the Battle for Beleriand : Silmarillion Explained - Part 1 of 3

[@swainsmommy]

After rewatching the LotR movies for years and finally reading the books, I began searching KZbin for Tolkien lore. And I have to say you have the very best channel I've come across. I'm constantly spouting Tolkien facts to my husband and kids and thanks to your videos I'm beginning to be able to answer their questions. Thank you for being such a fun part of my family!! Stay groovy, mellon!

[@tolkienuntangled]

Thanks! I'm really glad you enjoy the channel.

[@rafaelbarbosa6654]

Perfect commentary!!!! Best channel ever

[@alanmike6883]

@@tolkienuntangled I love ulmo too Dave

[@victorianguyen6620]

The way u explain Tolkien lore is so colorful. Like we r in the tale ourselves, instead of just reading the book back to us. This is why I like ur channel Dave! Thanks for making these videos. I've learned so much important back lore!

[@seanhartel5362]

I remember back in the good ole days in 2013 when I first read The Silmarillion. There was no KZbin channels, just Gold Seven and Jenny Dolfen and all the art of these beloved characters. Now there are almost too many KZbinrs that do Tolkien Lore. But I do have to say: far and away, Rainbow Dave has the best content and enthusiasm. And most importantly, he gets it. He understands the depths of the significance of all these beautiful and tragic events that unfold in this tapestry. He deserves 500K subs easy. Thank you for all that you do Rainbow Dave!

[@alohafer]

Trying to power through my 14 hour shift and this is exactly what I needed! Thanks Rainbow Dave!

[@masonclark531]

Two eyes, and as often as I can boil em’ mashI’ em’ and take the hobbits to Isengard

[@jimthethird4636]

These are the best Tolkien videos on KZbin IMHO. Thank you!

[@abelbabel8484]

The level of insight and analysis is just something else. Considering the exact etymology of words in their interpretation? That's a cut above the rest. Keep up your wonderful work, Dave, you are killing it 👍

[@tolkienuntangled]

Thanks! I'm really glad you enjoyed the video.

[@cliverobinson2130]

@@tolkienuntangled rivderdsjj

[@abelbabel8484]

@@cliverobinson2130 rivderdsjj indeed

[@TheCounterCulture2023]

By far the best Tolkien KZbinr, thanks for the video.

[@ardaea2529]

Around 6th I'd say

[@AMikeStein]

By far the best Tolkien lore channel. Sure some channels have longer videos but it’s really just a ton of power points like reading from a list of things that happen…. Where as you not only quote the lore and dialogue but you break down everything from character growth to why a character changes, how they feel and the kind of fundamental person they are to begin with. It’s incredible and such a beautiful ability.

[@lilzin7779]

You don't know how much I've been looking forward for your newest vid!

[@garretttekampe9564]

Again I can't wait for Fridays to get here for this reason.

[@ryanratchford2530]

Oh boy!! So excited to watch these! Can’t wait to rewatch the whole playlist now!

[@Samuel-ke1wu]

You're the best Channel out there when it comes to Tolkien! Hands down, bar none! When I'm not listening to the Bible, The Simarillions, The Fall of Gondolin, or The Children of Huron audio books, you're my go to guy to fall asleep. Which isn't easy for me. I've found falling asleep to good tales of interest with a good voice helps. So thank you. By doing what you're doing you help more than you know!

[@marleyjr00]

Im finally glad we got to this point. Been watching for a while just waiting to get here.

[@kylemoore687]

Another fantastic video as always can't wait to watch the rest of the series

[@Enerdhil]

Excellent, thorough breakdown of everything that happened between the Dagor Bragollach and the Nirnaeth Arnoediad.

[@Eclipce051]

As always your videos are the most detailed and easy to follow

[@tolkienuntangled]

Thanks!

[@chefitaly7339]

So happy you’re back

[@samwill7259]

I remember having my mind blown by CGP Grey when he revealed that most of the great battles for the soul of the world had happened BEFORE Lord of the Rings had even started. The worst bad guy was already defeated and we were watching the world in its last great age. It really shows how impossibly massive that Middle Earth is

[@michellebeckham5310]

Yay! Back to the timeline. I been waiting for this, im gonna cry.

[@tsuchan]

Welcome back! And thanks for another super-fantastic video!

[@tolkienuntangled]

Thanks!

[@8Smoker8]

Can't wait for the War of Wrath video!

[@emsey6097]

Yea!!! I love these Video's!!! Your a Legend Rainbow Dave!!! Hugs for all your work!!!

[@tolkienuntangled]

Thanks! I'm really glad you enjoy the channel.

[@DaleCoreySanford]

Finally finished. Rainbow Dave , you are amazing as always! I eagerly await more!

[@MrEd1024]

I can't get enough. Beautiful.

[@jasperlachance6211]

I'm loving these videos. I get popcorn, and watch these awesome documentaries on the TV 😊

[@Anonymous-ve7pi]

Mad respect for your research, evidenced opinions & topical content! You're my favourite Tolkien geeking channel💙 Can't wait to watch this in a bit

[@tolkienuntangled]

Thanks!

[@lenin972]

Can't wait for next week, you add so much depth to the tale

[@Agreus93]

I love the way you tell the story, always a pleasure to listen your vids! Can wait for the next parts! Cheers!

[@tolkienuntangled]

Thanks!

[@MellowMutts270]

I have SOOOOOOOOO been looking forward to this! Never a disappointing video Raindbow Dave!

[@colinlowrie5655]

Keep up the great work rainbow Dave 🌈 I love the content keep it up and your doing an amazing job

[@kattharsismic]

I finished rewatching the Beleriand Playlists yesterday, as I hoped that you would start the next chapter soon, and what do you know! You have! Thank you for all your work, you have become one of my favorite channels!

[@joshuaott7783]

Yay! Thank you RD for this upload. Great way to start a Friday

[@derubain5774]

Yes! Waited for this for a long time ☺️

[@sayftaleb6020]

so much information, beautifully put, thank you so much for explaining the first age.

[@KickassMcfly]

Thanks for being here to give my brain pause, I often feel overwhelmed with what I think of the world and your videos have done wonders to take my mind off of it

[@katjones7497]

I just love the way you tell the events. I cant wait to hear more and so glad you are making these videos.

[@gregorysilvernail1739]

Exceptionally well researched and incredibly thorough!!!!! 😊 Always such a pleasure watching your videos ♥

[@tolkienuntangled]

Thanks! I'm very glad you enjoyed it.

[@Sorrowfulsoull]

Totally Awesome! I love the details! I just finished the Children of Húrin for the 5th time. I can never get enough of Tolkien!

[@alanmike6883]

I love how ulmo is essentially a Rogue who doesn't abandon his love for the children of eru

[@thedojj5026]

CNN c am

[@robmaddison8645]

Ulmo loved the freedom of the sea, never took up with a Valier, and never trusted Morgoth when he was held captive in Valinor. The least Manwe could do was give Ulmo his blessing to aid Eru's children against Morgoth in Middle Earth.

[@ItzAngeles]

Legend! been a pleasure waiting for this

[@lordofthehouseofstormcrows8615]

Well met RD! KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK MELLON! My favorite battle is The Fall of Gondollin. I know it's not considered a battle in war of the jewels. It's just so bad ass to hear about Tuor, and my absolute favorite flute playing, ass kicking elf, THE Lord of the House of the Fountain. ECTHELION!!!

[@tolkienuntangled]

I absolutely cannot wait to get to Gondolin!!

[@cristopherfernandez5765]

Finally. Been waiting for this 🙌

[@TheEliasNoel]

Yessss have been waiting for this one for a while!

[@ZeepDr]

Thank you for guiding me through the Silmarillion! Watching from the beginning and it's been a wonderful journey!

[@abigailg9188]

I truly enjoy your content! Another great video! I’m thankful you’re back!

[@FutureOverYou]

Man, I love this channel. The content is told so well, is knowledgeable yet easily understood. Great job, our Rainbow teacher!

[@sunnyp6869]

I look forward to Fridays for these vids but I must say I'm extra thrilled that we've reached this tale. Can't wait for the next vids. Wish the story wasn't so depressing though :(

[@Spielkalb-von-Sparta]

_Feanor died but that was not to be much of a loss because he was kind of a terrible person._ Lol! I love that phrase! 🤣

[@majorjerk77]

False, true fans know that Feanor did nothing wrong 😆

[@Spielkalb-von-Sparta]

@@majorjerk77 🤣🤣🤣

[@chrisschmalhofer4348]

I just watched the Feanor: Zero or Hero video and half expected RD to say “… not much of a loss because he was kind of a massive jerk… see this video here for an in-depth explanation.”

[@feanordidnothingwrong]

Yeah, he was only the most powerful elf to ever live. NBD

[@inakis10]

Feanor was a jerk, but I still love him. He’s a badass

[@PalmelaHanderson]

You one-upped yourself yet again. Fantastic job!

[@tolkienuntangled]

Thanks!

[@hfcriske]

I really love these Silmarillion stories

[@ZemiEmperor]

Oh yes, keed us feeding us with the goodies, Dave! 🤓😉

[@chaiwarrior11]

Looking forward to this, thanks, m8.

[@lilzin7779]

Me 2,man

[@BrianStorm742]

Although I am personally of the "Gil-galad was Orodreth's son, not Fingon's" school, as that appears to be the consensus, I am SO EXCITED for this new series!!! Finally!!! (Also looking forward to the video about Gil-galad's parentage, of course. You never disappoint).

[@echuidor]

I believe that Gil-galad was Fingon's son which is why the High Kingship passes to *him*

[@BrianStorm742]

@@echuidor I mean, Christopher Tolkien has said it was an editing mistake on his part and that JRR Tolkien intended for Gil-galad to be Orodreth's son. But to answer your question: the kingship of the Noldor seems to have been based on the question: who is the oldest male descendant of Finwë (not counting the ones still in Valinor, of course). Whether Gil-galad was Orodreth's son or Fingon's: he is the only candidate left. Besides him, only Galadriel remains after the destruction of Beleriand, but she's obviously a woman. So Gil-galad's parentage is largely irrelevant for him becoming High King of the Noldor.

[@echuidor]

​@@BrianStorm742 Gandalf, I mean Tolkien, intended for many things to happen Sam, I mean Brian, but not all came to pass because he finished his story before he could finish his story. Therefore, his decisions remain unnanounced. Example: the round world Silmarillion, the creation of the first Orks. Who knows, perhaps the millisecond before he died a neuron fired in his brain with the message that he ultimately decided that Gil-galad's father is Fingon? Question mark? Period.

[@BrianStorm742]

@@echuidor I mean, that's kind of the beauty of it. I'm not saying it's definitively wrong to believe Gil-galad is Fingon's son. I am saying that him being Orodreth's son doesn't make him any less eligible for the High Kingship.

[@Enerdhil]

Who's yo' Daddy, Ereinion?

[@gunders85]

Thank you for another great video! And send my regards to Mr. and Mrs. Dave for being the most awesome people ever, calling their son Rainbow

[@FRODOGOOFBALL]

So epic, I forgot to press the like button the first time I watched this. Thank You! Wonderful summary of these events!

[@ericthompson5274]

I truly love this channel

[@tolkienuntangled]

Thanks!

[@ericthompson5274]

@@tolkienuntangled I run a second age rpg, and I use your channel as a huge resource!

[@kylemoore687]

@@ericthompson5274 That's awesome you play locally or online?

[@ericthompson5274]

@@kylemoore687 locally, around the table in the basement

[@kylemoore687]

@@ericthompson5274 that's awesome do you ever record it? Whats your storyline?

[@Brandon_Bonanza]

Another epic video, Dave!

[@justQthx]

Thx #RainbowDave I now wait on bated breath for the next video to post it’s like your favorite TV series when the next episode is released I need to know what happens next

[@victorinosparkajen9405]

i need to binge watch your playlists again to catch up LOL

[@doop2541]

Excellent video--thanks

[@denissediaz3640]

Thank you for these videos Rainbow Dave.

[@scottjohnson8382]

Your vids are amazing! Please make more of the 2nd and 3rd age!

[@tolkienuntangled]

Thanks!

[@berginkulenovic3995]

Love the video!!!

[@terenceheusaff967]

This is what I've been waiting for. Merci :) 😀

[@gronis9]

Nice intro. Great work as usual.

[@xedra]

I love your videos, and especially they way you read passages from the books. They should totally hire you to narrate all of Tolkien's works!

[@kellydavidson3379]

Not sure I'm ready for this ... but here we go!

[@taraldarion2500]

Really loving the outro animation. Keep up the good work!

[@DaleCoreySanford]

Yes! I have been waiting for this. After seeing the trashfire Amazon is about to do I and many Tolkien fans need this. Thank you sir!

[@BigApeBooks]

Great stuff as always! Keep up the great work!

[@Sparkalonius]

I’ll beg again for a longer greater chronological playlist 😇

[@tolkienuntangled]

I will in time, but first I want to remake the earliest videos. They’re important to the story, but not the highest quality. Eventually I want to make a playlist that will tell everything in chronological order from the creation of everything to the Fourth Age.

[@centurymemes1208]

I am sooo excited for some prologue glimpses from the rings of power! 😍😍😍

[@centurymemes1208]

the two trees, ungoliant and the dagor bragollach 😍

[@KeytarArgonian]

In 10 years time, when you’ve finally Untangled all of Tolkien I beg you to do the Same for Elder Scrolls Lore.. I’m almost tempted to say it’s the same size, possibly even Bigger than Tolkiens legendarium, and your style would be AMAZING for that content. Thanks for all you do!

[@JerrBear1974]

You are indeed groovy, RD! I look forward to your content more than the soon to be abomination that the Amazon series will be.

[@dyoolyoos]

I wish someone would make a LOTR series with you as one of the writers.

[@tolkienuntangled]

Me too.

[@mlebrooks]

Maybe they are using these as background reference and there will be a rainbow reference or something else as an Easter egg

[@ratiounkn3210]

I love these longer videos.

[@KingOfHarlots86]

You are really good at these😮. Great work man👏🏿👏🏿

[@tolkienuntangled]

Thanks!

[@andrejlavric1460]

awsome video

[@fran5594]

W Friday already cheers

[@UtilemUnus]

Even though your videos sometimes and especially this one can drop names and lineages so fast to make your mind numb lol However I must say as a avid KZbinr you are very good at drawing out the excitement and the anticipation of the future story!!!!! I love this feeling thank you

[@WouterDRav]

Wow I recently found you and was mostly going through your older catalogue, this intro slaps!

[@alanmike6883]

The first age imo Dave was the stuff of legends. Think about it. The elves at their height. Magic existing with the world. People knew of the powers of the west and for a time there were four centuries of peace. To a elf only a blink of a eye but to a mortal with the average life expectancy of 60, must've seemed like paradise. But all good things must come to a end

[@GenuinelyCurious120]

I'm prepping to read The Silmarillion for the first time. My illustrated edition will be here in two days! I'm so excited, it'll be followed shortly by The Hobbit and Lord of the Rings. I'm so excited to reread those too!

[@jamieabbott4613]

You smashing it bro didn't know much about the history and Tolkien's lore but learning now easy to do so with your channel have binged watched hours of your content now keep up the good work.🤙🤙

[@tolkienuntangled]

Thanks!

[@SpiritDomain1144]

Thank youuuu!!!!!

[@gregk2369]

good job!

[@silverwingdragon4161]

I read the Silmarillion thinking that Gondolin would be more prominently involved than it was, but I guess that makes sense given that barely anyone even knew about it.

[@eriklee5362]

You are a delight my friend

[@ianheins650]

Nice work dude

[@TheMarcHicks]

He is also credited with "corrupting" men as well.....causing them to hate & fear the "Gift of Illuvitar". Even the Edain never fully escaped from this particular corruption.

[@amandahill5304]

Love it following intently xx

[@lostname9850]

Please continue the books vs movies series it was so good

[@DHTC888]

WooHoo!!! 😊❤💛💚💙💜

[@Mr713mexican]

I’ve always wanted to see a clip on thingols and his relationship with each noldor big elf character and 2nd/3rd age big elf character

[@cristianserban2820]

The time of talking about the final battle of the First Age has arrived.

[@jayt9608]

All this lore is better than anything Amazon will release. Your channel is on the list of those that I will suspend all other entertainment, and even minor unimportant business to hear. Lotus Eaters, Ben Shapiro/Daily Wire, Church Militant, Geeks and Gamers, RK Ourpost, Nerdrotic, and Andrew Klavan are also on that list. I believe that Tolkien would be thrilled to see his work so well analyzed and described. My youngest sibling I'd only six, but I anticipate the day that I will introduce her to this channel so she may one day be instructed in the great tales constructed by one of the greatest linguistic minds of the 20th century.

[@astridchladek1927]

Oh divine anticipation 😊😊😊

[@calico27]

I sincerely hope someone from the Amazon series is watching your videos.. and that you get to second age before they finish filming everything!

[@astridchladek1927]

Oh lovely surprise! Oh joy!

[@carlcramer9269]

Sindar with axes is indeed very cool, and with their long-term friendship with the dwarves, it makers perfect sense. Where else would they get their weapons - the Noldor learned to make swords in Arda from Morgroth himself, not in Middle-Earth. So the first weapons in Middle Earth were likely bows of elvenmake and axes of dwarven make.

[@thespyingeyeofmordor]

I wonder where Narsil went into after being forged by Telchar. Thingol, or Maedhros?

[@haleyschreiter9746]

While I fully understand the other side of the argument, Gil-galad to me will always be Fingon's son. Perhaps if the amendment had been made in Unfinished Tales, I could have learned to cope with the disappointment. But not until Vol 12 of HoME? Nope, sorry, no can do. By then I was (and still am) far too emotionally invested in fantasy's most epic father/son/grandson trio - Fingolfin, Fingon, Ereinion. Fingon is my favorite character in all of Tolkien, so I'm both anticipating and dreading the next two videos. Perhaps he can also receive the "full character breakdown" treatment at a later date? Please? I dare say he's worthy of it!

[@Durins_Babe]

Please don't call him Morgoth, it's suuupeeer pejorative and mean. Nasty elves made up that name as an insult, he's actually a super nice guy.. He even gave me a job! 😉

[@Spielkalb-von-Sparta]

Go back to sleep, cutie! 😆

[@mlebrooks]

Lol

[@plompyy]

2 years later, I found this hysterical. #sayhisname #teammelkor