Best 12 Volt Impact Driver - Head To Head Test

Best 12 Volt Cordless Impact Driver 2019
Milwaukee Impact Driver Purchase Link: shrsl.com/1qcdv
Metabo Impact Driver Purchase Link: shrsl.com/1qd1m
BOSCH Impact Driver KIT Purchase Link: shrsl.com/1qdks
Article Link:
www.toolboxbuzz.com/head-to-h...
Watch out other Head-Head tests - ALL on one page here: www.toolboxbuzz.com/category/...
Speed Test- Installing 10-16 x 3 Self-Drilling Screw - Winner Makita and Milwaukee
Both Makita and Milwaukee averaged 9 seconds. Hilti came in third with an average time of 9.7 seconds.
Speed - installing 3” Star Drive Coated Screws- Winner Milwaukee
The following chart shows the results of this test:
Milwaukee averaged 1.5 seconds per screw and finished in first place. It beat out a win over the Dewalt by .58 of a second, which came in at 2.08 seconds.
Third was the Makita at 2.48 seconds. Clearly the data shows a close race for this application, and that these tools are fast when installing 3” screws.
Runtime - Screws Driven Based On Adjusted Watt Hours - Winner Bosch
We used the 3-inch framing screws test to determine runtime. The most important/realistic result is comparing number of screws fastened per watt-hour. By using watt-hour (total battery pack energy) we level the field for both voltage and amp-hours.
Watt-Hours is calculated by multiplying the voltage (actual voltage, not the MAX that some companies advertise) by the battery pack Amp-Hours. This calculation allows us to compare the total energy available to do the work based on both the voltage and size of the battery pack (amp-hours).
Bosch installed 145 fasteners and took a very comfortable first place. Second place went to Makita with 129 screws, followed closely in third place by Milwaukee with 126 screws.
Tool Temperature
During the runtime tests we observed some of the tools heating up, at the end of the runtime test, at the point of tool exhaustion we took temperature readings of the tool and batteries. We did not rank these measurements, but list them here for your information.
Best 12-volt Cordless Impact Driver Ergonomics Winner - DEWALT
For the ergonomics evaluation the team evaluated the following: grip, trigger switch, battery change, forward / reverse switch, vibration, balance, maneuverability, LED, Collet, and Speed change function / location.
For each category, the team ranked them 1, 2 or 3, (1 being the best)
The Dewalt took best ergonomics and is truly a comfortable tool to use, followed very closely by Makita.
The Dewalt took best score in every category and scored a 2 in the battery change. The Makita took best score in all categories except the collet and speed changing location. Third place went to the Bosch who excelled in the LED category, battery change and speed change button.
The Dewalt is a nicely sized tool, at 5.05 inches long and 1.75 pounds it is extremely comfortable to use.
Decibels - Winner Makita
These impacts all measured in a range of 94.1 to 99.6 decibels.
Decibel Procedure
Before we describe the tests we conducted, we wanted to talk a bit about sound-level test procedures.
Power Winner - Milwaukee, Metabo and Makita
We wanted to show you how they compared to each other in relative torque strength.
For this test, we used 3/8”x 8” lag bolts and installed them into three layers of 4x6 pressure treated lumber.
Three of the eight impacts were able to fully seat the 3/8" x 8" lag bolt; Milwaukee did it the fastest in 45 seconds, Metabo completed the install in 1:08 minute and the Makita did it in 1:10 minute.
The other impacts did not fare as well. The Dewalt was able to install the lag bolt 6-1/4" out of 8-inches and the rest were between 2-3" of lag penetration.
Price - Best 12-volt Cordless Impact Driver - Winner: Ridgid
Warranty - Winners: RIDGID / Hilti
Overall Best 12 Volt Cordless Impact Driver - Winner: Makita
The Best 12 Volt Cordless Impact Driver goes to Makita - by a long shot. Milwaukee came second and Dewalt a distant third.

[@nickhall1376]

Wait a second... You mean to tell me that a head to head competition doesnt involve chucking two drivers together and burning the motors out??? Somebody please tell Wranglerstar

[@bradwearsprada4728]

Let's be real, wranglerstar is a joke, he's a woodland firefighter who thinks making a work bench makes him a tool expert.

[@coltonjacobs5383]

bradwearsprada I stopped watching him a while back when he started making a bunch of drama bullshit.

[@fat1234568]

@@coltonjacobs5383 like how he calls anything that uses metric useless?

[@classikz]

Lol that guy is a hack

[@taylorwyant778]

He's is more for entertainment than test

[@thaitichi]

So happy whenever I see a new Concord Carpenter Head to Head. You guys set the bar when it comes to tool reviews. Keep up the amazing work!

[@vileguile4]

Yeah, these are the best!

[@yup3398]

I agree. So good to not have guys screaming at you while clearly pushing a product along with clickbait titles.

[@toolshopguy2080]

One of the few youtubers that keep a high quality standard for there videos instead of rushing out videos everyday. Keep up the great job you guy's. I definitely appreciate the hard work.

[@aaronstone5899]

I find myself reaching for the 12v milwaukee a lot more than i thought i would love that thing

[@franklong6269]

I own the M12, and it's a beast. It is easily the best 1/4" impact driver on the market right now.

[@mangkanor1261]

I had bought my makita driver about a year from now it’s nice to know how it really fair with other tools, thank you for the that well made review.

[@jrod264winmag]

As a professional electrician and hobby mechanic I've been using Milwaukee tools for 20+ years, never been disappointed

[@vasilhrisca5536]

Jess Roberts not even when the company was sold to China??

[@vasilhrisca5536]

Karol Palazej in your book that has only one page that shows how big of a fanboi you are! Lol

[@davo7512]

Vasil Hrisca what did Milwaukee do to hurt you?

[@RomboutVersluijs]

IS it normal that an Milwaukee m12 impact driver has this high pitch sound or whining sound when its active?

[@davo7512]

Rombout Versluijs if you pull the trigger enough that the motor is starting to engage but doesn’t spin does it make the noise?

[@wildgoose6596]

You guys do excellent work! It is amazing how far the 12v products have come! Just yesterday I used my 12v stubby impact on an inspection and I didn't even need to break out the 18v.

[@awesomearizona-dino]

As always... Awesome test...Thank you for all the efforts to help us make INFORMED decisions.

[@paulstoolbox]

You always do a thorough job Rob. I can see a lot of work hours into your reviews. Greatly appreciated!

[@ConcordCarpenter]

Paul Ricalde www.toolboxbuzz.com/head-to-head/best-12-volt-cordless-impact-driver/

[@weldonpinder7295]

I agree

[@tontakely]

I appreciate this test. I have the Dewalt 12v Screwdriver, and I love it! Now I know that getting the Dewalt 12v impact driver will not be a waste of money. Thanks!

[@dannywening6233]

Whenever someone asks my opinion on what tool to buy I dig up one of your comparison vids and have them watch it. You guys honestly give the best tool reviews. That being said... I go with Milwaukee for the 12 V line and Makita for the 18V line in my shop..

[@jeremylowery2557]

I’ve watched so many head to head comparisons but this is the first that looked PROFESSIONAL. Others are good and entertaining but this was another level. Good job.

[@cfltitan]

Excellent video. I LOVE my Milwaukee M12 fuel impact driver! This thing is unbelievably powerful and fast. When you watch for their sales they're priced very reasonably too.

[@evanepp]

Awesome Testing guys! Thanks for your time and effort to make these extremely informative videos!

[@savage6394]

I find your Tests fair and very informative. Thanks as always for the time and energy put into these tests.

[@austinmoyer9805]

Wow. This is the first video of yours that I’ve watched. And I can only say wow. Absolutely the best tool comparison video. Insanely thorough and packed with super helpful info

[@ConcordCarpenter]

Austin Moyer thx watch more Searcy our head To head playlisr

[@designer-garb572]

I love these video's, so thorough and so fair, a bit of a Dewalt fanboy but Makita has been catching my eye lately

[@ariefdsesprit3409]

..yes.. i experience the same situation.. :-)

[@donwooss]

You guys are the best reviewers!

[@LiamBehan-mi8kr]

Another brilliant video guy's. Really In depth and very informative. Really appreciate your time and input. As consumers makes our job a lot easier when we have all the information before we buy. Awesome job Rob! 💪

[@dominicmckee9009]

I have been waiting for a video like this! Thank you!

[@kimnimbus1291]

Another great review and video! Thank you for taking the time to make this head-to-head and look forward to your upcoming videos 👍👍👍🙏♥️

[@ConcordCarpenter]

thanks Kim

[@fatherfirefighter7751]

You guys are simply hands down the best at thorough and proper comparisons. Although I will say I am still waiting on the 1/2" impact comparison......just saying.

[@crunkosaur]

they are carpenters not mechanics

[@fatherfirefighter7751]

@@crunkosaur ......Who do tool reviews and comparisons. The 1/2" impact is a tool

[@DMC888]

@@fatherfirefighter7751 Carpenters use those heavy duty impact drivers for decking and tree houses don't they?

[@fatherfirefighter7751]

@@DMC888 I would say yes they do

[@majstrujeme8352]

Father Firefighter yes but really socket impacts are mechanic specific tools if you don’t mind the fatter handle Milwaukee stubby 12 volts are great.

[@BiggMo]

I love my Bosch. The small size fits in awkward cabinet locations and I really like the trigger control- but several of those tested I haven’t tried, so my opinion is not a comparison

[@elektrikahectorfernandezol5341]

Yo acabo de vender mi Bosch Gdr 12v-110,y acabo de adquirir el Makita Td 110 tengo que reconocer que la diferencia es muchísima. El makita es muy muy rápido,ergonómico,la precisión del gatillo es fabulosa,y en cuanto a potencia,he llegado a meter tornillos de 8x 250. kzbin.info/www/bejne/hmnJZ3-bYtSCjNU kzbin.info/www/bejne/eWqvdWhjo9iXb7c Y el peso es de sólo 1,100 kg intente hacer eso con el Bosch. Y lo he comprado en Amazon por 205€ td110+cargador +2x 4h/h+Macpak. Tengo que darle toda la razón a la personas que han hecho el vídeo. Soy un profesional Electricista con más de 35 años de experiencia. Un saludo desde España.

[@workisfun...2438]

Agreed! I am a Makita all the way platform guy, except for my 12 volt. Bosch for the same reason, very compact, very easy to fit into those tight areas and drag along into an attic. Plus, I haven't seen a better 12 volt platform flashlight than Bosch's either, absolutely love that design!

[@coolrich8781]

I’ve got the old 12V Bosh with a brushed motor. I’ve had it over 11 years and only had 1 fail with 1 out of the 2 batteries it originally came with. It doesn’t have an LED light like the new ones have but I rarely need an LED for it and when I do need an LED, I have a LED head mounted one for attic work. I bought a back up battery once one of my original batteries failed, after about 5 years. I used to use that Bosch 12V Impact drill to drive 5/16 screws through building structure “red iron.” I always needed 2 5/16 self tapping screws to go through red iron cause if I only used 1, it would tear off the heads on those screws through red iron. I would use the first 5/16 self tapping screw to go halfway through the red iron, back it out and dump it, than use another 5/16 self tapping screw to finish the hole and support my hangers for commercial ductwork hanging straps. Sure, I had to charge those batteries a few times a day BUT it did the job. Because of the quality build of the 12V impact drill I decided to step my game up and buy the 18V Impact Drill and 18V Hammer Drill kit. I “used” to be a Dewalt fanboy until I had an issue with a 14V nicad system. I owned that Dewalt Drill for about 14 months but only used it about 30 days in total cause I fell in love with the 12 and 18V Bosch lighter lit/ion battery system. One day, 14 months after the initial purchase of the Dewalt Nicad system, I tried to use it and it no longer had a variable trigger system. It was either off or full speed. I figured, no worries cause the Dewalt had a 3 year warranty and I had ALL THE RECEIPTS. I brought the Dewalt Drill to one of there local drop off authorized repair shops. After a day or so of inspecting the drill I was informed that it would cost ME about $50-60 to replace the trigger assembly. I argued with the customer service rep that out of 14 months, I only used it for MAYBE a month. The rep said that the repairs weren’t covered under Dewalt 3 year warranty because the trigger was considered a “consumable part,” (normal wear and tear part), and consumable parts were only covered the first year. I was LIVID because after purchasing that Dewalt, I discovered the 12V Bosch, loved it so much so I purchased the 18V Bosch Impact and Drill/Driver combo kit, so I rarely used that Dewalt in 14 months of ownership. I told the rep, “it was a defective product because it failed with only 30 days of actual usage.” The rep stood his ground on charging me to repair the drill at cost so I asked for my drill back and contacted Dewalt headquarters. I presented my dilemma to them and they sent me a prepaid shipping postage label to send the drill to them. I told them I was in the industry for over 20 years at the time and owned many Dewalt products but was willing to change the yellow and black brand for the blue brand (Bosch), and would let all contractors know what I experienced with their crappy warranty AND would go on as many forums as possible, that I knew of and slam their warranty and product. Dewalt corporate sent me a refurbished drill with 2 new 14V batteries, new charger and new case. I was pleased they chose to go that route but the whole incident left a bad taste in my mouth that I gave the whole Dewalt kit to my older brother who is a DIY and not a tradesmen. That must have been around 2008 and since than I’ve NEVER purchased another Dewalt product. I now ONLY use Bosch and Hilti. I had a problem once with my 18V Bosch Impactor within its 3 year warranty period. I called Bosch, explained the issue. They took my credit card info, in case I didn’t return the defective 18V Impactor, sent me a preprinted shipping label the same day and shipped out a brand new drill to me the next day. I received the drill a few days later, used the same box the drill came in, added the preprinted shipping postage label and dropped it off at UPS the next day. Bosch stands behind their warranty and doesn’t have all the fine print with exclusions listed as does Dewalt. Proud owner of all tools Bosch.👌👍😉

[@raunefare]

I have the Bosch at home and the Milwaukee at work. The Bosch seems so slow after using the Milwaukee.

[@BiggMo]

benjamin hansen: which would you say in more accurate ? And what’s your opinion about Milwaukees controls?

[@mariodesmo]

Good video ! I just happen to be in the market for one of these and I was about to buy an 18V but now you've got me thinking. As you mention, you really don't need the extra weight of an 18V tool. And after watching this, realistically a 12V tool will do just fine on my projects, and be easier to carry around. Thanks!

[@carlmccoy662]

If you have to carry one of these around in your tool bag, you want to consider the weight and the bulk. Precious space in a bag that is already too heavy, especially going up a ladder. Also fitting into tight work spaces is EXTREMELY important. Other considerations are the availability and assortment of additional tools within that battery platform.

[@ConcordCarpenter]

Carl McCoy size and weight are here- www.toolboxbuzz.com/head-to-head/best-12-volt-cordless-impact-driver/

[@codelicious6590]

I recently went for the Bosch 12v impact set just because the price was not that much more than cheaper, my need is fairly light duty and I had older 18v that I was very happy with. Plus, I got a killer deal on the reciprocating saw (12v) and it is awesome.

[@tunjimike]

I love the effort you guys put into the tools testing, you are very objective in your testing, i am from Nigeria 🇳🇬 and i am a huge fan of Milwaukee tools, but i think the makita is stepping up to the challenge real good

[@ianthompson9058]

Brilliant. Thorough. And extremely informative as always. Great work

[@ConcordCarpenter]

If you'd like to see some of the other H2H tests we've done they all live here: www.toolboxbuzz.com/category/head-to-head/

[@drreason2927]

I enthusiastically bought Dewalt's driver when it came out... and took it back after half a day's work. Thanks to your show I will give Makita a try. Thanks!

[@ariefdsesprit3409]

..just what i think.. been Dewalt fan, but Makita cacth the eyes.. :-)

[@ChristianZamoranoVieri]

World class comparison. Love those videos you guys to. It doesn't matter to me that you are not a "prof testing lab". Keep up the good work 😊

[@52morse]

I hesitated a spell on my last cordless purchase but went with the Milwaukee 12v. LOVE

[@ConcordCarpenter]

@James Edward - Brother, please do not list the link to jump ahead to the winner. Let folks watch the video or figure it out for themselves. We have at least 40 hours of testing, writing, filming and editing in this H2H. We want folks to watch the video.

[@Rockcal11]

A Concord Carpenter / ToolBoxBuzz Good job .. i know my red winner ;)

[@ConcordCarpenter]

@James Edward thanks pal

[@davidusry5048]

@@Rockcal11 always!!!

[@GSPirosaki]

Here's the link for the winner! 00:01

[@Cial]

Hate people that do that, it's like ruining the ending to a good book.

[@colinmurphy3724]

Can't wait to see a 12V Cordless Drill comparison!

[@EDVERSiTY]

I love the use of charts throughout, makes it look more like a professional keynote than a video. Great presentation.

[@josejuarez8227]

You make the best reviews. Hands down. Thank You!

[@yangevening]

been using Bosch for 3 yrs, perfect driver

[@Sparkystacoma]

I have a 3XL hand. I love my Milwaukee as my hand actually fits there with or with out gloves on. Yeah it is loud, but I use mine on Simpson lags for hanging tvs and it has enough finesse for receptacles and switches. I have used the makita and Dewalt and they're great tools. But I'll stick with my Milwaukee and the 3.0 batteries really last a long time. It eats the 2.0 and 1.5 batteries alive tho! Great video I'm waiting for the next one.

[@alexjburkhardt]

Excellent video. Equal to, if not better than, tool tests and roundups from the major magazine players. Recognizing that each user has an optimal balance of functions is something not often discussed. You usually hear the argument to simply stick with your current color/platform, but this takes it to another level. For some, the Dewalt or Makita grips are the main selling point. For others, it's the power and speed of the M12 for driving large fasteners. I personally love my M12 Fuel Kit, but will freely admit that the angled head and larger grip are bested by the Makita, and Dewalt too now that they've updated their 12V line to be competitive again.

[@AirborneSapper82]

I've said it before and I'll say it again. You guys do the absolute best when it comes to testing. I am always impressed at the level of detail you take to compare all of the different brands. Thank you and keep up the great work.

[@SuperJohn12354]

These are great reviews, but I found a fitter that pulls them apart the tools and shows you what's inside them , which was eye opening to what really is the better brands, he goes threw the parts and what type of plastic, bearings etc they use and how they are engineered, you will never look at some brands the same way again.

[@ckone671]

Thank you Rob! WE LOVE your hard work and input, always much appreciated! Never stop your brilliant work!

[@drewt1081]

Spent half the day shopping for these, dammit! lol Actually you just made my day, thank you.

[@justinthyme2666]

This is the first video of yours I've seen and you guys are awesome. So much good information and organized so well. A few minutes in I clicked like and at the end I subscribed.

[@leochen4891]

Thanks for keeping the comparison as fair as possible.

[@sylvana393]

Have done 3 kitchen cabinet installs with the Bosch. Has plenty of power for this and is very light and compact.

[@ajdizzle4shizzle]

Amazing review as usual. The time and detail of your reviews are second to none...Excellent work!

[@zapadeeboom]

Thanks for the review and all your efforts. Very comprehensive and "real world" testing IMHO I've switched many of my tools over to Milwaukee over the last 2 years. I'm a handyman, I do a little of nearly everything. I have M18 drill and driver and I bought the M12 pair about 7-8 months ago. I rarely use the M18s any more. But, it's good to have them available. I'll only buy FUEL buy hardly any OneKey. Keep up the magnificent work!

[@Fictitious_Character]

Always the most thorough head to head comparisons.

[@MrArcticPOWER]

Another amazing head to head test as always. I'm a Dewalt fan and I don't mind admitting the're not always the best tools once I've watch your tests. You guys seems unbiased and trustworthy that's for sure.

[@ConcordCarpenter]

This one is pretty dam good!

[@aggresive_hef6103]

dewalt is my go to brand as well i think the only better brand is Milwaukee but it cost way more

[@akira5982]

Been using my m18 milwaukee gear daily since 2008 installing solar, thousands of roof screws & still using the same impact & drill only replacing brushesswhen needed, & still using the same 4 3ah batteries 12 years old which are now starting go under heavy angle grinder use, only now may 2020 i just bought new gear but the best thing about milwaukee is the massive range of gear & the batteries are still still the same type just more powerfull so u can use it with ur old gear, go Milwaukee 👍

[@markjarman7819]

Best reviews on you tube and put across in a great way. Keep them coming thank you

[@frontlinefinishcarpentry4193]

I bought the bosch 12v brushless impactor. Thanks for your efforts with this video, it was very helpful.

[@LetsGoHelio]

Damn this is the best tool review I’ve ever seen. Bravo!

[@foxwood67]

Great thorough reviews. I love em. Since i own 15 or so M18 batteries i dont think ill be changing to the M12 lineup. Keep up the great work. How about oscillating tools 🙂

[@wagbjorn]

another great head-to-head comparison. Thanks guys, you rock!!

[@twindadpiper8590]

Great Video thanks Rob! And TBB I have the Milwaukee and Bosch 12v impacts and I love both

[@mattjones3257]

Loved the lag test but more importantly appreciated your insightful commentary on it that very, very few people will ever need to do that, and that this is not the target application for 12v drivers. For me, 12v drills and drivers are my go to for repetitive tasks with small fasteners where power matters a lot less than control. When I need to sink a lag, I’ll grab my 18v impact. Otherwise, any of these would suffice for my use.

[@Savantjazzcollective]

Don't worry about a sound chamber Db reading, that is not a real world situation. frequencies given off that resonate stronger in a garage or build site situation are most important, which you have actually done. Good job!

[@phbrinsden]

I have a full range of DEWALT 20 volt max tools in shop as well as yard. Just recently I decided that the 20 volt tools are actually more than needed power for some jobs so added a 12 volt max set drill driver and impact driver. Turns out that for most jobs they are easily powerful enough. As I age it’s nice to have the slightly lighter and more compact tools to hand. But out in the field the big boys go along. Your reviews are by far the best and I really don’t waste time with others. You test on several levels, unbiased and objective. Great job.

[@williamdavis922]

Excellent job as always fellas, know one does a head to head better, and more thoroughly than you guys. Awesome!!

[@tomcieszenski7249]

I'm basically stuck with Milwaukee M18 everything it seems like. I really like the line but as a finish carpenter I can run up to 7 or 8 different cordless tools every day. I usually have two batteries charging at the same time that can be used in any of them. That sort of makes it hard not to be brand loyal unless you want to deal with 8 different battery chargers and constantly not being able to use a tool because you have dead batteries. Beware on the purchase of your first cordless tool. It may end up being your entire tool line. Milwaukee makes good long lasting pro grade tools though so I'm good with my line.

[@AnkurSethi108]

Aren't the 18v impact drivers too powerful for your work?

[@WeldingForJesus]

@@AnkurSethi108 Putting it on a lower setting, he can adjust the power and gain battery life. OneKey makes that even more versatile. 12V is nice in many ways, but it is always easier to downsize power from a tool than trying to get that ultralight, cute little lady tool do heavy duty jobs.

[@laneweaver3562]

I don't know if you know this, but they make adapters so to make any brand of battery work on another brand's tools.

[@bassheadlife492]

@@AnkurSethi108 I love my m12 lady tools, m18 too!

[@CK2957]

In the same boat but with DeWALT. Not complaining though. Every tool I own from DeWALT have been preforming great! Glad I decided to go with them when I first got tools. Batteries definitely determine brand loyalty though lol

[@enra72]

you put a lot of hard work into this video very impressed im subscribing

[@ConcordCarpenter]

Thanks- check out our other H2Hs here: www.toolboxbuzz.com/category/head-to-head/

[@anto3sge]

Great video very informative I do have to say as an owner of a Milwaukee 12v impact gun with heavy multi use daily as a service engineer the balance and ergonomics of this tool is greatly increased with the larger 4 or 6ah battery's which also provide a better base stand too

[@SilentGUASclan1]

This is one of the best comparison videos I have seen comparing the major brands, I would love to see one with the 18/20v batteries, the biggest reason is that most tools use those batteries and then you wouldn't need to pay extra for batteries and a charger for the 12v when you already have the 18/20v stuff.

[@landscaperconnection]

have to say, the Milwaukee warranty is second to none. I've had tools WELL outside the 5 year warranty and they fix or replace the whole tool no questions asked and shipped both ways for free. Also think an area missed here was size of tool, some of these 12v tools are dam near the same size as an 18v. Nonetheless another outstanding battle completed by your team!

[@ConcordCarpenter]

Everest Landscape none are larger than an 18v. BOSCH is smallest

[@Mack_Dingo]

@@ConcordCarpenter were they all they same battery capacity? I know you handicap the milwaukee with low AH batteries

[@hornetf18]

I’ve found the Milwaukee is very fast and powerful, as well as compact, but heats up a lot, likely due to the compact size not allowing space for vents or cooling.

[@ConcordCarpenter]

We saw similar findings

[@jascospeed]

Then you'll hate the rest even more. Milwaukee ran the coolest in this test, look at the temp chart in this video.

[@ANocers]

This guys top F’n notch when it comes to reviews. I changed or bought a few tools now because of you and your channel. Top shelf my friend

[@mattrickard3716]

3 years later and this video is still able to put all of the marketing hype into perspective. I can't complain about being poor and then go and splash out on Milwaukee when you've proved that a Makita will do the job. This is the info that guys like me need to see to know which battery system/brand to go with.

[@ryancasey4807]

Bosch has actually been doing the three light option on their tools since the early 2000's :) Just a heads up

[@MangoGino]

Awesome review! I like the Makita 12v, but I think their Sub-compact is on point and way better. Being pretty much the same tool, but having the advantage of using 18v batteries which I already have lots of. I can then use these same batteries with their outdoor and other (18vx2) 36v tools. Pretty happy with Makita's way of putting their consumers first and great design ergonomics. It's not always about the higher numbers that the marketing guy decides to put on the stat sheet.

[@realMDizzy]

Yeah I wish they made more subcompacts!

[@RomboutVersluijs]

Can is ask what a subcompact tool is?

[@austenhatch3285]

@@RomboutVersluijs simply the same tool redesigned to be as small as possible. Makita has a couple sub compact versions of their 18v tools which make them small but powerful

[@RomboutVersluijs]

@@austenhatch3285 thanks for the info!

[@carlcox7332]

I love my old 12v Makita. That thing has been a battle ship. I have 2 18v Makita and 2 12v Bosch but the little Makita is my favorite unless I'm driving lags or deckmates all day. A 4ah battery will last all week on that thing. And the ballance is great.

[@BPDRacing1]

Nice job. Thanks for putting this comparison together...Love this stuff.

[@herman66mi83]

I’ve been looking for impact driver. This was very very helpful in evaluating!

[@CrimeVid]

The little Bosch is by far the most comfortable for me

[@WCW4469]

Great comparo for the 12V impact drivers. Will we see the Milwaukee 12v Surge against the first place Makita, just for fun??

[@badger0888]

As always; comprehensive, thorough and a balanced review to help us make informed choices. Keep up the great work. I use Dewalt and Milwaukee but the torpedo battery/grips don't suit my style.

[@dmitriyk.7461]

Great video for me to make a decision on what tool I should buy for my fathers birthday. Thank you, I like it allot.

[@WarmongerSmurfOnXbox]

I paused on their table to do the points myself (lower is better): 1) Milwaukee 10pt 2) Makita 11pt This cuts out the useless categories of ergonomics, decibels, and price. The ergonomics is subjective. I like the thicker handles of the in battery handle, than the thin handles. Decibels only matter in extremely limited places. Price should not be on the list at all. You look at the list see what you can afford and go with the highest rated on the list that you can afford. That being said I love these videos. They are very in-depth.

[@ConcordCarpenter]

My friend - that is why we share the information with you - chose what's important to you and make your own decision. Well-done!

[@mainsource8030]

the new milwaukee m12 surge impact is my new fav, its incredible and quiet!

[@causticearth1980]

Thanks for the heads up. I have been looking to make a switch, love my current tool. Was looking into a 12 volt line that fits and me and the applications I need it for.

[@WookieeRage]

Nicely done. Thank you for explaining your process and reasoning so well!

[@evanwhite3714]

I think it would be cool to see another cordless skilsaw head to head considering brands like Makita, Dewalt, Milwaukee, and Hilti have all come out with heavy duty rear handled saws

[@PatriotPaulUSA]

I agree! I just got my new Makita LXT 18v and it is 5000 RPM vs my old and still running fine LXT at 3700 RPM Its remarkably stronger and faster and it was only 123.95 bare tool! I stayed with the single 18v 6.5" but it was tempting to go dual 18v 7.5" but I am no longer a professomal, just a "pro homeowner" now. ha ha

[@michaelc7283]

Hi, This was a great 12v comparison on all these tool brands. I like the look but now that all these 18v & 20v are so compact i don't really have the need for a 12v (drill or impact) anymore. Wow, the milwaukee fan base are going to have a cow knowing that it came second place, LOL.... I don't have to worry i use both DeWalt 20v and Milwaukee 18v. I'm happy with both brands. You are right dewalt does have the best grip on their tools. Thanks for all the hard work put into this video.

[@ConcordCarpenter]

Good point - my newest 18v is pretty small and with a 2Ah battery its fairly light too

[@michaelc7283]

@@ConcordCarpenter Yes, i also use the new 3.0 batteries (m18 & 20v) and it's not too bad.

[@jeremylehman5675]

You all do such a great job thanks answering questions that we mite have and a lot makes sense thaks

[@johnmcdonagh5325]

Wow! An excellent job of comparison. Unbiased- keep up the good work!

[@UNKN0WN_YT]

I love 12 volts and went through a few of them before I settled on a set. I first had the MIlwaukee, then Makita, and then Bosch. I’m speaking of the drill/driver set. The Milwaukee and the Bosch have the same grip, which is too uncomfortable (and I have pretty good-sized hands), so I returned them. I loved the Makita. But in the end, I ended up with............the Makita, but....the 18-volt subcompact. They’re actually smaller than the 12-volt. The drill is actually smaller. And more power. And I can use the 18 volt batteries I already have.

[@thetruth5210]

@Greg D My guess is if you’re complaining about the grip you can’t palm a basketball.

[@orijimi]

@@thetruth5210 There's more to it than that. The battery takes up so much space that the rubber overmolding is super thin on 12v Milwaukee.

[@UNKN0WN_YT]

@@thetruth5210 acutally, I have pretty big hands. I can palm a basketball. But, as Orijimi said, the battery in the Milwaukee and Bosch takes up so much space. And if you want to put in one of the bigger batteries, then you have a fat grip, AND you have a battery that takes on the form factor of the Makita and DeWalt. But the Makita and DeWalt have much more comfortable grips. And according to this video, the Makita is a better impact driver anyway. So take that!

[@thetruth5210]

@Greg D It depends on what you plan on doing with your 12V impact. If you are an electrician and you’re out doing a trim and you’re going to spend most of your day driving 6/32 and 8/32 screws do you really need something that can drive an 8 inch lag bolt? Because that power demand happens every time that you pull the trigger. I can install wedge anchors in concrete floors for data racking or audio racking, install wedge anchors in masonry on the side of a building to hold up CCTV cameras and install 3 1/2 inch lag bolts and a two by fours all with a Bosch PS32 it also fits into my Veto Pro Pac easily. Watching these videos is like watching a dodge ram with a Cummins diesel in it pull over a barn and then saying this is the best truck that’s available. So how many barns do you pull over? I need something that can do my job reliably and with longevity which is why I own the Bosch PS 32 and the Hilti SID 2-A. I would not wish on my worst enemy and endurance test of driving 6/32 screws into plastic fiberglass or sheet metal to have a legitimate endurance test because each one of these tools could drive hundreds if not thousands of fasteners. In high-speed low torque scenarios like the one I just described that most electricians are doing the Bosch and the Hilti outshined the competition! P.S. Also as an electrician if I have to drill down in a scenario from a one gang box opening into the basement in a home if I have the Makita or the Dewalt that is another trip back out to the van, but if you have the Bosch or the Milwaukee they fit through the single gang hole and with a regular 6 inch paddle bit Along with a 8 inch drill extension you don’t need to make a return trip out to the van (to get a 2’ or 4’ bit) and all of that fits in your tool bag. If wasting time to get better ergonomics is your thing or you’re working in the shop environment knock yourself out, but for those working out in the field it’s a simple choice. IMHO Just a thought...

[@samueltopps9015]

I think the Milwaukee battery clips could be designed to last longer more like the spring loaded clips on Ryobi 18v batteries. In Canada there was a black Friday deal to get the fuel impact, drill, 2ah, 4ah, and charger for 139 Canadian. The sound problem can also be helped by upgrading to the new 12v surge driver

[@macmcmillen6282]

Great comparison. Very, very helpful, and much appreciated!

[@robinyourhood164]

I love these videos. Keep doing what your doing 😊

[@whattheheck5083]

Great test! Ryobi/ Milwaukee fan boys at it again!!

[@procrastinator1842]

I enjoyed this video, but there is something missing, the whole purpose of ditching 18V in favour of 12V is size and weight savings. I've had Ridgid and now Milwaukee and if I can't be bothered putting my tool belt on, it fits in my work pants side pocket, not to mention it fits in my tool belt pocket. The block style battery on these other 12V tools is a step in the wrong direction.

[@joshuasteele5108]

Exactly the milwaukee in my opinion has the best ergonomics and that's the whole point of these tools. If i want to drive a ton of fasteners im not using a 12v tool.

[@canmtb4676]

Couldn’t be happier for having purchased Makita XWT08Z LXT (different model tested here). Works superbly with its breakaway torque of 1200 ft-lb.

[@theitalian556]

Very well put together video! Every phase was covered! I really like Makita, Dewalt, Milwaukee and Ridgid. Never tried the rest.

[@kasper7106]

i have the 20v Dewalt set but i find myself reaching for the 12v Milwaukee tools 90 percent of the time. They have more than enough power to do most of task I come across

[@ConcordCarpenter]

kasper7106 agreed

[@lbyoung8420]

kasper7106 I agree, I have over a dozen of the Dewalt 20 volt all brushless and they’re fantastic, but I honestly prefer the ease of the smaller M12 lineups Fuel impact and hammer drill.

[@vasilhrisca5536]

LB Young keep up with DEWALT bro! Too many are buying into a Chinese company.

[@l00nybin]

@@vasilhrisca5536 Ummm... the 12V DeWalt Extreme that was tested (the DCF801) is made in China.

[@jamespremo1]

A category that should be considered heavily is how large the 12v offerings are in each brands lineup. I have recently switched to Milwaukee M12 for size and weight. Their catalog of 12v offerings is impressive. My M18 chargers for my blower, 10 inch sliding miter saw and sawzall also charge my M12 batteries. My Flexvolt chargers also charge my 20v max batteries. My point is that the platform is a huge consideration. Not just the individual tool. For professionals anyway.

[@ConcordCarpenter]

Great points - and advice

[@muddybadgers5205]

Awesome head to head and very thorough as always

[@ericksanchezHN]

I amazed how good this video was! Hands down for this comparison...

[@PatriotPaulUSA]

I have been using my LXT Makitas for over 10 yrs and just keep adding tools. I am always the one guy not using red or yellow stuff but my tools and batteries just keep blasting away.

[@bradleyhannesson1973]

patriotpaul me too!👍🏻

[@MustPassTruck]

Still waiting for a 12v drill/hammer drill head to head.

[@kb7722]

Great job as always! Very valuable reviews!

[@plantastudio5048]

Kepada sesiapa yang tengah cari impact driver yg sesuai atau yg bagus. Video ni tunjukkan contoh yg baik