What's With All The Extra-Long Top Tube Bags?

[@simirving]

I’ve been using a Restrap bag for 6 months, and it’s great. Due to the steep angle of my bike’s toptube, items tend to slide towards my seatpost. To stop this, I made two dividers out of old bank cards, folding their short edges and fixing in place with Velcro - works a treat and gives the bag walls more support.

[@nathanpieper4634]

That intro was AWESOME! The little Santa clause laugh when describing how much more it can now fit really, really got me.

[@adoj105]

I used a full Restrap top tube bag on the GDMBR this year. It was great once you got used to tipping the bike a little bit when you stop riding. Losing the stand over clearance was my biggest concern but it really wasn't that big of a deal once you got used to it. It provided a lot of extra space for camera gear or light extra gloves along with standard snacks.

[@Outsideville]

Is it trickier to get to snacks while riding? Or with one long zipper do you have things bounce out while you reach for those yummy gummy bears?

[@adoj105]

@@Outsideville I didn't have any issues. It zipped from both sides so I could grab the zipper that was best and the bag keeps its shape with the plastic sides and the top comes in a fair bit so even when it's unzipped everything is still pretty protected. Things did have a tendency to slide back though. Heavier cylindrical items did end up in the back.

[@nikveldkamp8630]

My alternative recommendation: [Certainly no cheaper option, but because aesthetically I prefer horizontal top tubes,... ] I simply distribute the volume onto two smaller TTbags. The rear one, mounted inversed under the saddle, makes nearly perfect use of the space (could be higher). This combination leaves me the space exactly where I need it when stepping off.

[@Ghjhfbnn]

But then you are not able to put something long in your separate bags, like tent poles

[@williamschultz298]

@@Ghjhfbnn And? It's just an alternative with the tradeoff of easier organization and step-over. Just strap them on the side of the top-/downtube.

[@omare_biketonature]

Just received my Restrap race top tube bag, looks great!

[@Outsideville]

Short legs and high top tube already challenge my stand over ability. I'll stick with shorter bags.

[@notpablo8369]

Why buy a bike with high top tube😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Outsideville]

@@notpablo8369 many bikepackers make this choice to allow for a larger frame bag. That is my preference for less-technical routes.

[@TheRflynn]

Long legs and a slanted top tube already challenge my stand over ability. And the idea of choosing a bike to fit the bag, as opposed to the other way around, is wroooong. At 3:25 I’m missing something. The bike has a rack, racks take panniers. Why risk crotch contact when there is an alternative.

[@Outsideville]

@@TheRflynn Thanks for sharing your perspective! My frame choice balances stand-over comfort with a geometry that suits my needs for loading and handling. While it might not work for everyone, it’s been a great fit for me.

[@hc3820]

@@notpablo8369 to fit a bigger frame bag 🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨🫨

[@martyjohnson142]

I have JPaks long top tube bag and as all of my bags from Joe, love it!!

[@clc1117]

I made myself a full length top tube bag and have been using for over a year on my Hightower. I think this type of bag works well with full sus where the sloping top tube provides ample stand over height. I’m able to slip a full sized Nalgene at the base under the nose of my saddle and still have tons of room for up front. I’m flat I used a large molded zipper as I tend to stuff it quite full. The only issue I’ve had is slight knee rub on the bag. I now wear sun sleeves over my knees to negate the contact. I like that this system is light and makes running a large rear bag/rack unnecessary. It is surprising that a manufacturer would spec small coil zippers on bikepacking bags. I would definitely be worried about reliable while deep in the bush.

[@jamesdoolan8040]

The Restrap Race long to tube bag looks great. Used it a lot and love it

[@thefucrew9865]

I will stick with larger top tube bags, and leave the long ones to you guys. I need the space when getting off and on, including in a hurry, so that I don't "squish the berries." Keep up the great work !!! Love the information and updates !!! In Chicago, and new to this.

[@pascalbewernick7117]

I use the Miss Grape Big Node 2H and I love it ❤

[@caseyfraser2643]

I like my jpak farva..carry all my small pieces for easy to locate @ camp..great videos all the time Neil

[@gardenkeeper7639]

My long Apidura expedition top tube bag fell apart in South America. For 100 usd it did not hold up and Apidura customer service is awful. Switched to the Tailfin top tube bag and the quality is amazing. I’m done with zippers; happy with the fold over bag with side clasp.

[@alindberg8001]

Hard tail party just did a video on his full top tube bag from Rouge Panda 😊

[@GaryChastain]

Added a long top tube bag to my bikepacking setup on my Bearclaw and like it a lot.

[@WINDLECOMMARANDY]

South City Stitchworks in STL is TOP in the top tube bag category imo. Fully custom, crazy durable, zippered mesh pockets for trackers or trash. Good stuff.

[@BIKEPACKINGcom]

Rad, thanks for sharing.

[@huntos83]

I’m a big fan of a long top tube bag, for ultra events they are so useful and it’s the best location for all the small bits and bobs and snacks you want close at hand. I have both the 1.5L and 2L Restrap Race top tube bags which have been great. But I recently switched over to Tailfin bags and have just ordered their long 2.2L bag today which looks amazing, I already have their small 0.8L one so I’m certain I’ll like the new one. Though I will miss the elastic mesh sections on the sides of the Restrap bags which are so useful

[@steveschurr5967]

If your bike has a sloping top tube, like my rigid mountain bike, your frame bag is really limited. I like the idea of a bigger top tube bag. More storage and your standover doesn't get outrageous. Now I want more than two direct mounting bolts.

[@markjthomson]

I have the Restrap full length, love it. only reason I don't have one on my other bike is the top tube is too short.

[@92376]

I ride tubulars; zip tie the spare tire to my top tube. Carry small Knipex diagonal pliers to cut the ties

[@Robert_Thomas832]

Protects mens plums and makes it harder to get on/off. Good work 👍

[@comounaverdura]

The larger top tube bags hold more items than the smaller bags.

[@fishsayswhatsgoingon]

They definitely designwd theese keeping baguettes in mind.

[@buzzman4860]

I liked the Restrap bags

[@rustyshackleford9498]

I don't want a largefarva. I want a goddamn liter of cola!

[@MrRay645]

awesome you stressed the zipper types, they are the weak link for every bike bag, tent, and jacket I have ever owned. I will take big clunky one handed operation zips that are fine with being over stuffed every time even at the expense of water tightness over the small toothed weather sealed ones... easy enough to use cheap dry bags inside on them for anything that cant get wet. Nothing is really water proof anyway, once you get a season or so most things tend to get far less water resistant.

[@AndrewSteavpack]

I’m surprised people don’t like its appearance. I like the half frame bag allowing water bottle cage use and find the full frame bag takes away from the bikes shape and aesthetic. Also much more usable on full sus frames, my Ibis in particular.

[@francoispayen]

Nope, not for me. Even regular top tube bags are a mild annoyance when pedaling out of the saddle and standing over the bike in general, the full length ones would be a nightmare. They're also quite expensive for an objectively very small storage space...150 USD for 3 liters? That's nuts.

[@sneakyray9160]

What about Topeak top fuel? I like it!

[@leafbag5]

Talk to me about the starling mini murmur at 14:30 that's running single speed. Is the axle path on that bike set up to support SS? I'm very intrigued!

[@leafbag5]

Did some more digging and discovered it's actually their "beady little eye" model that's designed for SS! Very cool.

[@simplemagi6286]

It's a little bit weird, when you use a $150 bag and put

[@simplemagi6286]

I mean, these pretty and tech bags are really nice products, but considering cost, there are too many options...

[@xstrikethreex]

What does the price of the contents have to do with how much a bag should cost? What a strange criticism.

[@framue]

Semi-off-topic what is the rear rack that is shown on your Otso Warakin? It looks perfect, exactly what I’m looking for. Thx for any feedback.

[@BANDW1]

I use brand Rhinowalk 2.1l Triangle top tube bag - Wilderness Series BHD0015BK, very good e not expensive

[@KNURKonesur]

GoPro on a small tripod, phone, powerbank, gloves, a bunch of gels, and the space shrinks quickly :D

[@CycleXplorer]

Will it replace my double tailfin toptube bag set up?

[@jonpoon3896]

Unfortunate my inseam is too short for them

[@jimmccorison]

I wish long top tube bags would work for me, but with short legs, they are a no-go. Even regular top tube bags jam into my junk when I'm stopped.

[@daniels.2720]

Haha > who needs "standover" anyhow ?? On my gravel bike myself > 1L top bag is enough

[@triciaco2499]

I

[@powerpolo4779]

What model of luggage rack does the orange bicycle have?

[@alindberg8001]

Mica rack, or Rat tail as it's now called.

[@Bertie..]

Don't use a full frame bag as I prefer space for my bottles. I use a full-length bag under the top tube and plan to replace my small top tube bag with a full length.

[@lucborot2219]

Top tube bags and triangular bags fitting between the tubes are not good for short blokes like yours truly.

[@eternaltome3376]

Bagpacking

[@VinnieCeeCycling]

Aaaand just when I thought I was done with cycling spending for the year, Tailfin goes and completely messes up my budget. Again.

[@CycleXplorer]

Haha similar issues

[@Mike-vd2qt]

Too much fuss and fiddle with frame bag systems hauling gear. They're fine if you're fast enough to cover big distances between resupply if you're racing. Otherwise, racks and panniers are simple, durable, no zippers, more capacity, easier organization. Comparing weights vs frame bags, I got 1.4 pounds more total weight for racks, panniers, front and rear (weighed both sets of mine). Bonus, weight is centered lower on the bike with panniers. Contrary to recent belief you do not have to fill panniers, but the capacity is there when you want to haul something special into camp like water or beer. Happy trails ☮

[@Saxtoo]

You need a top hat bag. 🎩 Get real, Topfin... £40 for a 1.1L 🫣 £96 for a 4.5L frame bag 😶🤒🥵 RockBros 1.6L £12.95 🤗 RockBros 3L frame bag £16.29 😘

[@IK47-d2l]

150USD for a small bag? WTF the bike industry absolutely lost its mind, I would get it on AliExpress for 20USD max. 😂

[@BIKEPACKINGcom]

If you find one on Ali that has those v-mounts let me know, I would like to check it out, thanks.

[@erics9214]

No. Just no. I'm not sure how other people fit their bikes, but those long bags would be a constant threat to the family jewels whenever I need to stand on climbs.

[@billmaidment]

Great video but not a product for me. Wow! Look at that push button phone on the wall.

[@fernandorosales2789]

Did anyone else think this video was starting with a Muslim prayer?

[@mattmason7498]

By framebags are usually massive so in the name of aesthetics I’ll pass but thanks for the roundup.

[@___IG]

Very scary intro

[@CJ-xv2cw]

Being a man I think I'll pass.