Bionicpig reacts to She Revenge Murdered Her Step Father

[@EmiaRaine]

I don't like how, through the presentation of the video itself, the stepdad wasn't really condemned for his actions in comparison to Jade. What she did was technically wrong, yes. I agree on that, she probably should have turned him in for "proper" punishment. However, I believe she was completely justified. She took it too far, absolutely, she shouldn't get away with it, but she definitely doesn't deserve a long sentence for this. Her stepdad betrayed her trust and abused her without her knowledge and he doesn't seem to receive too much blame aside from the obvious "what he did was wrong but ya know, she did kill him after all". I don't know, something about that feels off to me. I get the feeling that the larger focus on her murder of him in contrast with his abhorrent preying on her was due to the right and wrong of it all. The supposed "morality" of murder compared to secretitive pictures. It's more wrong to kill someone (even if they don't deserve breath) than to keep illicit pictures of a family member without their knowledge? This is a messy case. Both people are in the wrong, but on different levels. She probably shouldn't have killed him, but she doesn't deserve harsh punishment for it. And yeah, let's be honest here, possibly even if she did turn him in, he would've gotten out in no time anyway. Just look at that case a few weeks back with the old guy who assaulted a woman's children and was allowed to move back into the apartment and be around kids. He got barely a slap on the wrist, however the mother who permanently stopped him was given a way harsher sentence because murder was involved. Sometimes I think morality just exists in certain cases to cushion our fear about what we might actually feel.

[@dragonslayingsaiyan9026]

'Technically wrong?' When is pre-meditated murder only technically wrong? Also pig and his live viewers have a braindead take by trying to call this self-defense and that he deserved it. Not one of these bastards knows what it is like to take a life and how powerful of an act it is. He definitely deserved to be imprisoned, and she had plenty of evidence for a strong chance at getting a conviction. Also, how can you say she is completely justified and also say she took it too far? That is completely contradictory. He definitely exploited her, but I wouldn't say he abused her. As far as we know, he never did anything physical to her or any one else. The second case you brought up isn't a good take. He didn't just get a slap on the wrist, he was able bail himself out. The case hadn't even gone to court yet, and they can't forcefully evict someone out of a building based on an allegation. There was a high chance that the police or even the landlord would have been able to remove him from the building due to his previous convictions, but that still takes time for the courts to do. The guy deserved to go to prison for life, but people don't get to go around killing other people. Not defending these pedos, but I really hate it when people think murder is justified and that some people should be allowed to get away with it. Should have locked them both up for life, that is a worse punishment in my opinion.

[@EmiaRaine]

@@dragonslayingsaiyan9026 Don't get me wrong, I do agree with your points here. This shouldn't have happened in the first place and jail was the better course of action for both. When I made this comment I was more rubbed the wrong way by the idea that they were kinda glossing over his invasion of privacy (and the possibility that he might not have suffered many consequences had things gone differently - but we'll never know now). Yes, murder is far worse and the way she handled it was wrong. I could see her point of view even if it was aimed in an extreme direction. And no, absolutely, people shouldn't go around just killing others because that person did something wrong. Some cases are more complicated than others, but I do agree that this particular one shouldn't have happened even if I can understand why this woman might jump to the worst decision.

[@Sophia-vk5bq]

I agree, she was obviously traumatised and the emotions she was feeling probably caused her to take advantage of the situation and kill him as opposed to planning out his murder. So many actually vile Human beings who murder get parole or sent to a mental institute and in this case just going to a live in facility to help her and make sure she won't kill again or become dangerous to herself and others would be so helpful in her case. I feel so bad for her because our society creates an environment where murder is a more viable solution for someone like her than going to the law. Where being sexualized by her own fucking guardian somehow brings her shame. Its society creating its own monsters and then being shocked that monsters exist.

[@kcm4321]

she's a goddamn queen. this "father figure" is a disgusting predator. killing him is perfectly acceptable.

[@zooweemama_3978]

Sorry for bringing up green m&m rule 34 at the beginning of the stream I didn’t think it would carry through so long I repent for my sins

[@maggiebrum6347]

25:38 my neighbor had over 600 vids and pics of CP that he bought and created (he has 2 daughters) and he was in jail for 6 months waiting for trial and they released him

[@diddilydarndang]

A teacher of mine was the same when I was about 9 / 10 His electronics were seized and didn't even get any jail time and it's disgusting how often people get away with it

[@cissyiniguez]

That only happens if they turn snitch. For CP it's mandatory unless they use them to catch bigger fish.

[@cartooncritique6625]

Not that I condone murder (though I do believe in making the punishment fit the crime), I can't say that I completely blame her either. If I was in her shoes I can't promise that I'd be rational.

[@lilweedsea]

Sure it wasn’t legal, but it makes sense to feel so upset and angered by what she saw. Her feelings are valid even if her actions aren’t necessarily legally valid. Legality of things makes real justice hard to interpret, in a way I stand by the law but I also stand by the human being. It’s an unfortunate situation all around and I feel sorry for her despite her poor actions. We can’t have the things we want all the time, we can’t always punish the people who hurt us and due to living in a (relatively) civilized society, we can’t just maim or kill people who do us wrong, we have to rise above our emotions and think rationally in order to avoid needless consequences and live life to the fullest regardless of our traumas.

[@daisyninja3674]

I wonder why her lawyers didn’t go for a crime of passion plea since they tend to get reduced sentences. Maybe it would have required her to confess to the crime and that wasn’t on the table. Idk

[@IWantToPetYourDog]

I swear the jury saw it as "he didn't touch her".

[@QuikVidGuy]

I think because even a minute can qualify as premeditation

[@felixdragonheart]

Hearing stories like this progressively make me feel more misanthropic tbh

[@thespacealien171]

🤔A lot of murderers are misanthropic, js.

[@mysticmuffin2198]

?

[@cartooncritique6625]

Welcome to my world.

[@Sophia-vk5bq]

That's kind of understandable.

[@beyondviolet]

yeah I usually avoid them tbh, I only occasionally come back to this channel because I’m morbidly curious lol

[@Vincisomething]

The fact that she found out because he had it as a screensaver...

[@cintaminbunny]

I just realized this. He's so gross.

[@QuikVidGuy]

If you're frustrated, I'd recommend seeing someone react to the first episode of Better Call Saul, where the teenagers desecrate a mortuary. It's Called res ipsa loquitur or "The evidence speaks for itself," and Jimmy loses that case

[@Sophia-vk5bq]

It sucks that she got prison for this, and even more that her friends and loved ones kind of stabbed her in the back when she asked for help.

[@QuikVidGuy]

"being the supposedly good person that she is" wtf is that? Dude was sexually abusing her since she was underage and the host makes it sound like she was a monster

[@never_null]

honestly i think she was justified, he absolutely had it coming. she had the right to get back at him for what he had done to her and she did it (just in my opinion ofc, ik she didn't have the legal right technically)

[@dragonslayingsaiyan9026]

Murder is getting back at someone now, huh? Also shows how little she cared about her friends that she would ask them to be involved.

[@never_null]

@@dragonslayingsaiyan9026 getting her friends involved was a bad call yes, but getting rid of a person like that is not a bad thing

[@davidlionheart2438]

Narrator says: "NONPROFIT butterfly farm" Pig says: "How do you make money with a butterfly farm???" I say: "Seriously?"😐

[@tendrel135]

Forgot to mention , your outro is on the jukebox in my head. Sometimes i catch myself singing it. 🤣🤣🤣💛💛💛

[@earthboundmother205]

The Closing Shift. That’s the drink I make at Chilla’s Coffee

[@optimalzero]

Do you ever forget that your PFP is literally just a camera shot going up your nose

[@Anna_Crossing]

sommetimes i do

[@benheath112]

YES YOURE FINALLY ON COFFEE HOUSE CRIME I RECOMMENDED IT BEFORE

[@ariannastemp9798]

im a jade supporter. he had it coming and she deserved that satisfaction

[@Outlet_660]

1:00 i felt personally offended

[@ColtonWhite123]

BORN AND RAISED SAN DIEGO OH NO BRO

[@galleo9462]

Im torn first yes she killed a dude so she has to get punished HOWEVER a lighter sentence seems fair as it wasnt self defense but it was somewhat justified id say if the police searched the house they have his pc and the proof she wasnt lying soooo

[@habijjj]

She committed first degree murder which means that she intentionally planned it out then tried to rope in other people to helping her hide it. Someone being a creep doesn't justify their death. If it was SA then I'd 100% agree with you but it wasn't.

[@never_null]

@@habijjj i feel like this absolutely qualifies as sexual assault

[@galleo9462]

@@never_null ty lol im not saying she should get off scot free im saying she should get a lighter sentence if you have never been the Victim of any form of sexual crimes be it assault or what her father did then you dont really understand what we have gone through sure its not physical but rape or things like it, its not the physical pain that lasts forever its the phantom pain the memory the mental struggle of the event that NEVER leaves you so in my opinion murder while not what she should have done I can understand her reaction and yes she should be punished but not as severe as someone murdering for thrill/fun, honestly if I was her id of just been straight up admit it explain why.

[@never_null]

@@galleo9462 yeah exactly, I've been a victim of it too so I can absolutely see why she reacted the way she did, especially considering it was her dad. I would have been honest about it too, it kinda just made her look worse to lie about it rather than try to get like a crime of passion sentence or somethin

[@carnuatus]

@@never_null the thing is, they found her texts. Those texts disallow the possibility of it being ruled a crime of passion. She took her time, plotted it out and it wasn't RIGHT when she found out about it. It was premeditated so even if she cooperated she would NOT have gotten crime if passion.

[@MageMelonVT]

The thing about being a defense attorney is that your job is to protect your client, but just as importantly, is making sure the government doesn't overstep it's bounds. Defense attorneys have to be zealous advocates for their clients, all clients, at all times. Because if they aren't, then the government can easily start overstepping and suddenly innocent people are being put in prison everywhere. You can't have it be halfway. Some attorneys are scumbags, yes. But it's your client's life on the line. And the same for prosecution. If you are prosecuting someone, then you A) are pretty certain they did the crime and B) you believe you have the evidence to prove it. Prosecution in criminal courts are representing the people and the state. They also have to be zealous advocates for their "clients". Everyone has to be doing their hardest for their client or else the system fails.

[@QuikVidGuy]

Attorney Tom frequently said "they're not necessarily there to get someone found innocent, they're there to make sure the defendant's human rights aren't violated" which also suck because they can't contradict their client's plea, so if the client says NG when they're obviously G, they have to cook up a best-case scenario

[@wompwomp1015]

free my girl Jade she did nothing wrong..... * I think she could have gotten it down to a manslaughter charge if she'd been honest. that said, maybe she was just listening to her lawyer**

[@agateomania712]

On a side note from the vids intentions- it really skeeves me out how she can just be like “I can pay to bail out”, even with how fucked up he was/how much it was “deserved”. It creates a weird atmosphere where people who are richer can afford to just bail out. Sure there were conditions to hers but… eeeeehhh. ://

[@Nemesis7293]

"Who names their kid Cash? Awful name".................Says the guy who named his kid "Ezra"🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@jadedk1tten]

coffeehouse crime is my fav true crime channel

[@TotalSH]

Yesss CoffeeHouse Crime!! So glad you found this channel.

[@alexanderirving4605]

Lol my name is Kash awful name indeed I caught a stray bullet from Mr. pig

[@MissDelete2098.]

3:07 - Why?. 😑.

[@DjDeedzD]

Halfway through the video, and I'm not saying it is right, but I kind of get it. If he was found guilty, it would likely be a slap on the wrist and not to do it again. Then there are so many cases where the person is still somehow involved in their lives if they're a significant other to a family member or otherwise. It's awful. Edit : Yeah, looked into it a bit more and basically a lot of people defending the step-father said he wasnt a drinker or didn't have drugs when there was evidence he did and the court was making up the underage photos of her when they existed. She was 39 by the way so 16-39 is a long time and that shock mustve been immense. Not okay, but I really dont think her turning him in wouldve been the same ot stopped it.

[@tomprestengaming996]

As my dad used to say trust everyone just don't trust the devil inside them.

[@weirdwormsaloon4088]

I can’t fucking pay attention to that coffee house crime channel or whatever it is because every sentence sounds the fucking same and I’ve started the video over 4 times after getting halfway through without COMPREHENFING ANYTHJNGTHJNG because they talk so robotically I just have no clue what they’re saying at all

[@weirdwormsaloon4088]

Okay I’m trying again maybe I’ll hear the story this time

[@weirdwormsaloon4088]

Nope I’m 5 minutes in again and all I know is that someone’s an interior designer and someone named their kid Cash

[@spaceofwaste4956]

I love that the Midwest talks shit about everywhere else when all of us Midwesterners know damn well that our states are the worst

[@QuantumEgghead]

Don’t you mean the southerners? /j

[@carnuatus]

Pig talks about the Midwest being shit all the time, what are you talking about.

[@spaceofwaste4956]

@@carnuatus I didn't mean it sarcastically I actually just think it's really funny that we do it

[@carnuatus]

@@spaceofwaste4956 gotcha, gotcha.

[@QuikVidGuy]

Hey we may almost kill each other every day and have the most illegal guns and the highest rate of de facto segregation and no real destination spots and...... ........but at least we have restaurants!

[@a_lil_special]

Do you know how to get to bells canyon?

[@RavenJade666]

Ahh coffeehouse crime!

[@tendrel135]

Oh, this is local for me. Yikes. I'm very close to Solana Beach

[@kakashi15114]

California is a fire place to live it’s just so damn expensive

[@itsace2648]

The Waffle House has found it's new host

[@haroldwilliams2194]

The Waffle House has found a new host

[@cissyiniguez]

The dude took pictures of her that she never knew about, never molested her, never even came onto her. If he'd had physically done something to her, I could be more forgiving, but I'd say she definitely went overboard. She planned his death for days, tried to get other innocent people involved in her crime, and (though amateurish) tried to hide the body. This is the text book definition of 1st degree murder. I don't see how there could be any other verdict.

[@RavenJade666]

He may not have touched her but he's still a child predator and deserves it. I'm a victim of grooming when I was a kid. I never got any justice..

[@RavenJade666]

He chose to look at his step daughters nudes from when she was a child. That in itself is horrific and disgusting

[@cissyiniguez]

She was 16. And again, she never knew, nor felt uncomfortable around him. I can have sympathy for how she felt finding out, but not for what she did.

[@dragonslayingsaiyan9026]

Exactly right.