British Barrister Analysis of Amber's Cross-Examination UK Trial

[@dwentlandt1022]

My issue as a nurse with this cast issue. Johnny didn’t have a full hard plaster cast on his right hand. He had a plaster half cast that is then wrapped with an elastic bandage to secure it in place. Those plaster casts are fairly thin for a couple main reasons. East access in case of an emergency, to allow for swelling, and it’s only designed to make someone pause when they are about to do anything with that hand. It’s to give support and protection but it’s called a soft cast or splint. They break very easily. I know this because I’ve been in them a few times after surgery. I usually have to go in and get it replaced a few times or they have to change it to a fiberglass half cast after a few days post surgery. Moisture from sweat causes them to get soft. Humidity in the air can also cause them to get soft. If he had hit her once really hard would have broken the cast and he would have had to get it replaced right after hitting her. There’s no way he hit her once let alone multiple times and did not damage his cast as well as his hand. They would have had to do surgery again to repair damage to his hand.

[@JaeZee1268]

Thank you for explanation from medical pov.

[@mariefraser9403]

@dwentlandt1022 Exactly xx I’m a ortho theatre nurse n I’ve made this point too on other channels xx👍

[@anniet6292]

Also he had merca

[@thecasualgamer5611]

Not to mention, her face would have been a bloody pulp if she was hit more than once with a cast. It wouldn't have just been "unpleasant" and "not memorable", she would absolutely remember a cast hitting her in the face.

[@laurencejohnston2191]

Good point

[@slayofbengal]

In the US trial, Johnny's hand surgeon was a rebuttal witness. He testified that if Johnny hit someone "repeatedly" with the cast, it'd be severely damaged. Then he was asked if there was ever a damage to Johnny's cast, his answer was no

[@jessdickson9465]

I love Michael!!! Your picture is the best !!!!😂😂

[@susandemir9960]

Maybe it is because you are inteligent and honest.... and clearly the judge is not. I am so disgusted with the " Old boy network " that still continues in the law. Please continue to debate and explain. You are so good at explaining. Well done. First saw you on "Popcorn Planet. You are so cool.

[@nomadscavenger]

The VA judge was in a difficult position and maybe felt compelled to find something in A's favor (and for the sake of A's many supporters), and discount the rebuttal witnesses!!!? There was one holdout on the jury; hence the $2 mill for her, which is a total crock - how can you (J's lawyer) defame when telling the truth... she perpetrated a hoax? And she did and is still doing it. I think the judge was mostly fair and very smart, but I'm beginning to think not. What else is the BBB going to bring to light next, I'm wondering.🤔🤗

[@tychi8826]

I’m pretty sure she would remember if he had a cast and would put that as part of her statement. Made no sense, considering how horrifically she described other statements.

[@GenuineUntelligence]

@@nomadscavenger the judge didn't decide anything in the US case, the verdict and compensations awarded were all decided by the jury.

[@Bahbahlatje]

When the UK verdict was handed down, the Johnny Depp support community (and me amongst them) were shocked. We were familiar with the evidence in the case and we were sure that the judge would see the discrepancies as the lies they are. When we read the verdict, the judge went out of his way to fill in gaps in Amber's accounts to make it work that he found for her and he went out of his way to discredit Johnny's witnesses and Johnny's testimony (due to his drug use, even though Amber is a heavy drug and alcohol abuser, too). We were deeply disappointed with how far Judge Nicols went out of his way to find a way to side on Amber's behalf despite the discrepancies between her various interrogatory statements and her actual testimony. I have to assume that Amber put on the same performance on the stand that she did in the VA trial. I wasn't sure Johnny would win the VA trial up until the verdict came in because of the Judge's findings in the UK trial. Fortunately, the VA jury were more astute than Judge Nicols. Travesty of justice the UK verdict was, travesty of justice. Amber has been way to enabled by the Uk verdict, by the media, her schtict for the UN as a DV spokeswoman and as an ACLU ambassador. This is what drove her to go through with the VA trial because she got away with it in the UK and she thought she could charm the VA jury, the way she did Judge Nicols. They've created a monster. She's going to keep smearing Johnny as long as she's enabled and that is a miscarriage of justice. Fortunately, the UN seems to have dropped her as a spokeswoman. As a DV survivor myself, it grinds my gears that this abuser was being raised up as a DV survivor and running a con on society with the help of the media, the UN, and the ACLU.

[@catherinepraus8635]

Well said

[@nomdeplume2213]

Ditto!

[@markrichardson5496]

The UK judge was never going to rule in johnnys favour, some ‘jumped up amercan movie star coming over here telling us what we can or cant print’ his judgments on every count found a way to see her side, didnt matter what johnny said, he was never going to win it

[@patricknez7258]

Spot on! 💯 Judge Nicol should be ashamed of himself and embarrassed imo

[@patriciadiamond1305]

We all feel so passionate because we now see a TOTAL injustice handed down to Johnny by a BIASED Judge. All those years later inspit of that wrong decision, being married to an EVIL WITCH,he shines as a beautiful person. We cannot go back,but we can right a definite miss carriage of justice.

[@meoueo]

the doctor that treated him said that hitting the with the soft cast he had would have damaged it, and it was never damaged!

[@windycityliz7711]

Yes! So it wasn't a "plaster cast" at all. Her husband (whom she is accusing) was still newly injured, which she caused. And, it would have hurt him like bloody hell to hit anything, and possibly re-injured his reconstructed finger if he had.

[@bcrouch2626]

@@windycityliz7711 not only that he had a very painful infection that doctor was worried would make Johnny lose his finger if they couldn't get it under control and gone . Matter fact he got that infection 2 different times

[@michellekirby5050]

Exactly!!

[@brendaplunkett8659]

I broke my index finger once. It killed me to touch anything for months and it was in a soft cast. I doubt he hit anyone with a broken, infected and reconstucted finger in a semi hard cast.

[@nonmihiseddeo4181]

@G: Using a cast of any kind as a weapon will damage the bone(s) the cast is meant to protect. So, there'd be damage to the surgical repair of the finger and its blood vessels/nerve reattachments, as well. AH is not credible. How the UK judge believed her shows bias, in my view, against Depp/men.

[@grmmyantju8369]

This was very interesting! Being a survivor of DV and SV. There is no doubt being hit repeatedly with a cast you would not have left out. It would have been a significant point to make in the statement. Mahalo!

[@stefania-eleni1347]

Yes! Not like the cast "detail" is on the same level as jewelry! She's just beyond reasoning!

[@michellebaxterneedovey7103]

Considering how much she enjoys focusing on details and elaborating I’m surprised she forgot to mention the cast - not. She’s very good at proving how she makes stories up as she goes.

[@stefania-eleni1347]

True! She can be particular that the dog stepped on a bee, but when asked why you didn't mention the cast from the beginning she would throw at the examiner that this is just a detail like the one on what kind of jewellery she was wearing at that time. She's really spitting people in the eye!

[@markmathisen3908]

The amazingly ironic thing is that she THINKS she's great at coming up with these statements and making it up on the fly. She is SO delusional that she just cannot understand for the life of her why people don't believe her. In her mind she's the greatest actor ever and that she can convince anyone of anything. Luckily, those of us that don't dwell in her delusions can recognize just how bad at it she is. If she had even a SLIGHTLY better grip on her acting and details it could have turned out much worse for Johnny. Thank God anyone with a brain sees everything she says as utter bullshit.

[@hollyhouston5837]

And how many times did she "forget" to mention how the rings would've felt slamming into her face, and damage they would have caused if her accusations were true!

[@mariat108]

Yes we love these cross-comparisons. Thank you! Let's see the criminal charges coming soon...

[@notonmywatch4291]

BBB I like the way you pick the bones out of the statements and communicate it so clearly. I enjoy and appreciate your work. Thank you.

[@vickigmatobopandjosh9400]

Johnny's hand cast was considered a semi soft cast which was plaster on top & bottom for stability but soft on sides to allow for swelling. The condition of his finger at time of stairs "claim" was extremely delicate with skin graph, newly attached tip & pin inserted in it. Timing of all that was newly done (less then 2 weeks) so there was NO WAY POSSIBLE he could have gotten that physical with his hand. Can't believe the judge was that blind to make his choices for Amber!!

[@RobertLeather]

The more I hear from the judges, the more is seems he was willing to bend every sense of incredulity to make her story fit. I’m finding it harder and harder not to believe there wasn’t considerable bias here.

[@RajanSagoo]

I couldn’t agree more

[@redwarpy]

He should have excused himself due to the connections he had with both The Sun & AH.

[@muhammadhaquim6481]

No offense but I want to know where the judge study law so that I will not send my son there to take up law

[@cheetyliciousmeowmeow1085]

The judge was biased cause son is in media business. Probably paid off to😬

[@smokeynewton]

We've heard rumors of corruption in the UK trial. Is there any avenue open for the courts to re-examine that trial to look for improprieties?

[@flyingfig12]

@@Dizzy-zd7im from what i understood, the appeal was closed to him, he wasn't even allowed to try to appeal as the judge shut that down. There's a petition to get to be able to appeal as we speak.

[@lauriedi1]

Thank you for this analysis. I can only hope someone influential can listen to your logic, review the evidence revealed since the UK trial, and speak to whomever must be spoken to in order to get true justice in this case.

[@jerrygeorgopolis8015]

Excellent ! If that was true, AH would Never Leave that out. However, after watching the entire trial, and replaying, reviewing AH's defense and prosecution testimony, you realize she loves to exaggerate the details as she goes.

[@justlooking1985]

I think Amber heard lied about everything she said against Johnny Depp, it’s more like that’s everything that she did to him. I really enjoy your channel and your expertise, thank you 🙏🇨🇦

[@catherinepraus8635]

Whole lot of projection huh

[@ublu3631]

@@catherinepraus8635 that’s exactly what AH did, correct. She projected everything on JD and accused him of her own violent behavior. And if you think otherwise, you clearly didn’t watch the trial (tbh, even watching that train wreck of an interview should be enough to show what a gaslighting narcissist that woman is)

[@michellebaxterneedovey7103]

Considering how much she likes to focus on details and enjoys elaborating I’m surprised she didn’t mention the cast……… not! She’s very good at showing that she makes things up.

[@TheNikki5449]

Agreed! Terrible woman😡

[@glo3139]

She’s a REAL PIECE of WORK!!!! When you encounter a person who refuses to take ANY ACCOUNTABILITY for anything that he or she does, most likely, you have just had an encounter with a severe NARCISSIST. She lies like a RUG, (ironically, no pun intended). I’m sorry, but I don’t believe ANYTHING that she claims or says. I wish that she would be HIT with Perjury charges. That’s one smack that will show her a taste of REALITY!!! A real victim would not use the words that she chose to use. Would a true victim of such awful violence still love and adore the person who hurt you so terribly? Are you trying to stay relevant in a world that does not care about you any longer? You were never a big star Miss Heard, I am being very kind by saying that you’re acting is mediocre at best. You’re not cut out to be the big Hollywood actress. You will never receive that Oscar that you so desperately crave, and As for relationships, well I don’t understand how any sane person in the world who would trust you now? You are a puzzle indeed!!! You are indeed a gaslighting Rubics Cube!!!!

[@itsjbr]

AGREED! She is horrible

[@dejahdanger]

She’s a terrible actress and it comes through in her lies.

[@markmathisen3908]

She doesn't concern herself with trivial details like being beaten in the face with a cast, she tends to focus on the condition of the floor, you know, like you do. Dirty carpet, 'parakeet' flooring, those are the details that MATTER! 🤦

[@cherylj7460]

I wonder what that judge thinks about such a contrasting ruling by another court. And yes! I really appreciate you reading directly from transcripts. It’s the only way to compare, really. Very fascinating!

[@serahngash9262]

After reading your commentary and watching the full VA case, am amazed that the judge ruled in her favour... this case should be included to the many miscarriages of justice cases in the UK

[@cherylj7460]

You have to remember, she did not win in the UK, as she was not the plaintiff or defendant. She was the main witness- and was believed. But her claim that “we won”, (maybe it was her attorneys statement) is false. The Sun publication won, Depp lost.

[@sharebare3941]

It just amazes me that she wasn’t hospitalized, being hit with a casted hand would have swollen so bad, broke facial bones, cracked teeth, and that judge believed her? Oh yeah she knew someone who knew him and it was a favor to agree with her so that the sun could be protected! Dirty dirty dirty politics

[@annakarenina3188]

1 he had active MRSA infection during this alleged incident, so he would have been in excruciating pain. 2. Could the UK trial have actually given [either side, but especially any party who was telling lies/exaggeration] to almost do a "dress rehearsal" before Virginia? 3. Given that AH was allowed to sit in for all evidence in the UK, despite only being a witness not a party, what impact do you feel this had on evidence given either on stand in UK, or full evidence given in USA? 4. Loving this cross comparisons. Learning so much.... I am left scratching my head as to to the underpinning logic for how conclusions were reached, but am not in a position to question a salaried senior judge's determinations in public.... (Writing between the lines.)

[@RajanSagoo]

That’s where “with the greatest respect to the learned judge” comes in handy 😉

[@gretchenbaker7435]

Oh really good points. Also I remember testimony that he was avoiding opiate pain relief.

[@mclarenjohnf1]

I would like to point out 2 things I have broken my scaphoid bone in both wrists and with that break I once decided I would be alright to drive a go cart, I did quite well for 3 corners when the rear broke loose and I hit a tyre barrier at fairly low speed, my left hand and wrist were fine my right with the break was agony, my plaster cast crumpled like paper and I spent 5 hours back in hospital before they could replace the whole thing with a fiberglass version and yes I felt every tiny knock in that one too. Secondly I had to have carpal tunnel surgery and that was in a half cast to start and the pain I went through from the slightest tap was unreal, using ether of these injuries you would not be using a cast as a weapon the pain would have you being sick.

[@stefania-eleni1347]

This just proofs just how unemphatic with her husband's pain she was. If she wanted to paint him as a monster, even the cast played a part.

[@ileanahernandez1709]

She said in the UK trail it was a hard cast and in the US the Johnny Depp lawyers brought in not only his doctors who operated on his finger they also stated it was a soft cast. This was an expert opinion so as a non expert myself I don't remember all the details.

[@artyflaneur6928]

Great analysis the London trial doesn’t get enough attention

[@derek.....]

it’s a shame that Johnny Depp didn’t get an “Amber Alert” before he met and married her.

[@CaliWeHo]

For sure! He met her "nice Southern girl" personality. 😭

[@redlady120]

hahaha Nice pull there

[@Psammead21]

@@CaliWeHo I only saw that clip since the end of the trial and it was pretty heartbreaking to watch it. "Oh, if you only knew the half of it, JD..." was my first thought 🙁

[@mariankay6482]

Actually, he did. His daughter didn't come to the wedding and many of his friends said they had concerns. Alas, love is blind...

[@Melissa_Badhorse]

There were plenty of red flags he ignored

[@SaltStorm007]

I have been THOROUGHLY ENJOYING your content! Even the Non-JD/AH videos have been excellent and just as entertaining💯I also want to tell you that your Wife is ABSOLUTELY LOVELY & you both make a BEAUTIFUL COUPLE! Congratulations on celebrating your Crystal/15yr Anniversary recently & that necklace/earring set was GORGEOUS...excellent taste sir...well done! I wish you both the ABSOLUTE BEST! Thanks again for producing the excellent content that you create! Pray you both have a wonderfully blessed day/week/year/lifetime💯🙏🏴‍☠️

[@patriciaching100]

Mahalo.. going through the transcripts where those of us who have expierenced DV/Murder as my mother killed my father. The truma never leaves as decades have passed and I am 79 now. My body still screams when I sense a Abuser who is masquerading as AH. I am hopeful identifying AH's behavior and not going deeper, allows the public to see what is in front of them.

[@ahc1957]

No one ever mentions that there is a painful injury inside of that cast. I had a cast on a broken wrist. I found myself protecting my wrist inside that cast. Imagine the pain he would be in with serious injury inside the cast. Would he have taken a chance of re-injuring his finger, especially for a musician.

[@barbaramcmillan3835]

I seem to recall at some point during the trial, it was referred to as a Soft cast, but not sure when/where I heard that. I'm glad you brought this up, as they do seem to be referring to a Hard cast, which would certainly have been much worse, had it been true. I do hope the UK case is reopened, it was clearly unjust.

[@captaindunsell8568]

But won’t there be pain associated with it … makes no sense

[@stillraven9415]

It is a cast cut in half like they do to remove it, then ace raps them together over the hand so that it can expand if there is swelling. It would have been unbearable pain to either be hit with or to hit someone. It would have been the most important thing to mention about that incident.

[@jenniferst.george810]

One of Johnnys surgeons pointed out the soft cast

[@lishengshun2873]

Another thing to note is that JD's doctor testified that there was NO damage to the cast when he removed it.

[@nomdeplume2213]

The sides were soft. The top and bottom were hard cast

[@elainejohnson6955]

When Johnny had his finger dismembered, it would also hurt JOHNNY to hit someone with the casted hand.

[@pamelahogan8265]

Excellent point.

[@stefania-eleni1347]

She is constantly throwing dust in everybody's eyes

[@SketchieRecordsUK]

Was this a 'friday afternoon at 'the Gentlemens' Club' judgement? What was he thinking? Thanks again sir, your unpicking of this 'judgement' is fascinating!

[@experiencefloridawithjulie4568]

Thank you for going over her UK testimony.

[@aresmars2003]

The key thing I've concluded from this whole trial is that people lie, like Amber, and this is confusing to me when there are people who can contradict your lies, but I explain it in the phrase "I was only defending myself". If Amber projects Johnny as a "Powerful man", then how does she get back at someone who is "powerful"? Lies do the trick. But I still don't get how she thinks she can get away with it. And apparently she needs "narcissism" to do it, whether she has NPD or not. It is a weird skill to have, to always double-down on any lie, and always have an "explanation" that makes sense to no one except people who believe you'd not lie. It must be a skill that works in abusive households when you grow up, so it becomes second nature to "always lie first", whatever is happening. I know men lie too, but women clearly are more easily trapped by this "hypoagency" - a need to play the victim, knowing others will believe you and act in your place, on your lies. It's a feigned weakness, but also a real weakness, because you destroy relationships, friendships, and so you have to gain "power" through wealth or social status so those losses don't matter.

[@cherylj7460]

Yes! It is confounding. To witness this doubling down on lies that seem, to us, so obvious. I knew a woman a few years back, who began to tell me about being raised by a mother who was narcissistic and just very damaged. Her father was an alcoholic. She spoke of how they fed off of each other’s sickness. She was comparing her mother to a certain politician, here in the US at the time. It was interesting. Now, this woman was now in her 60’s, had a beautiful, stable family, and had broken that cycle. My question to her after hearing many stories of this, was, what happens when they are proven liars, and there is no denying? And if they seem to double down on these lies, is there another level of realization that they just don’t admit to, out loud? She said “never”! It never happens that they ever, realize or see, even if shown, the error in their way. The sickness is so deep, it prevents them from ever coming to any realizations. This is when the blame and projection takes over and allows them to stand tall, when they should be ashamed. People have called Amber evil and purposely planning JDs demise. But she does have this mental illness. How else can she make so many contradictory statements and explain it away? And think we don’t see it? Then again, these same dysfunctions are often seen in murders- usually men,(this is statistically true) get found out and confronted about their lies, and then kill their wife or girlfriend. I guess the sickness is on a spectrum.

[@aresmars2003]

@@cherylj7460 I have to legally evict my older brother who lived with me for 7 years after his divorce, and knew there was drug use in my house, and things stolen by his friends who'd stay over, but I didn't want to deal with it. I'd secretly collect charred spoons and pipes from his room occasionally and put in a box to show him if I ever got tired of his lies and excuses, but in the end I never showed him, saw he'd always make up one more lie for any hard evidence. I was surprised I decided I knew what I knew and just said "Time for you to leave". I had written a poem 6 months before I did the eviction thinking about honesty, after some long forgotten incident. But at least I understand something of addiction - it changes people, a sort of pain that only has one cure, and covering shame was just a necessary side effect. But he did tell me two years after, after treatment, that he might have overdosed in my house, and there was nothing I could have done besides what I did. And it was Minnesota's cold winters that got him into treatment when he had no other place to go. Incidentally, I also saw how he was largely passive, and people would take advantage of him, steal things, crashed his car, etc. So addicts are also passive liars more than violent ones. And like Johnny, people like Amber apparently believe her word is better than him as an addict, and her lies would win, no matter how unbelieveable. So being a wealthy addict means being taken advantage of, like Johnny, and Amber just one of many who took advantages of his kindness and trust. ----------- Honesty When given evidence of your crime, Do you come clean nearly every time? Or do you offer blank stares? Or try to split logic by hairs? Which way gets us ahead? Which is best when all is said? Honest thieves are harder to long hate While clever tricksters only delay a sad fate.

[@mountainsno]

Agreed. On a very simple level, I think, that if she had seen that his power was his love and decency and hard work, she could have held his hand, he would have helped her in every area of her life. Sure if she fell out of love, leave. But if she loved, loves, and she had respected where he had got to in life, instead of being crazy jealous, just imagine the loved and cared for person she could have been? It occurred to me today that she says she wanted to join the conversation of ie the metoo movement. But she didnt realise from which direction she was joining in. The muddy waters of anyone using their body to further their career, feeling trapped by masculine power or not, ironically is something she could speak to on a personal level, so it seems. Riding the elevator with only successful people via the bedroom. You honestly couldnt make this stuff up.

[@scrappingsharica]

Really enjoying your content. Personally AH needs to be in a padded room somewhere. She really has problems. What she did to JD Was just Awful, All of it.

[@Jaybird-i1t]

Thank you for keeping us informed. I love my sister, she passed last year. No way in hell I would of left this out, if she was beaten by her husband especially if I was there. It was left out because it never happened.

[@gracej4306]

Hey you should shout out the UK judgement appeal petition in each of these videos. I strongly think more people would aign if they knew about it!

[@sue9932]

Thank you for referring Pluto. What a great channel. Really enjoy your insight. Thank you

[@forevermyalways4821]

Thank you for all your videos breaking down all this info! So glad I found your channel! You rock!

[@BlackBeltBarrister]

Thank you so much 😊 🙏

[@josieau]

Yes! I’d love more of these videos, please! I really appreciate your videos and explanations.

[@Backforthefuture]

Brilliant! Thank YOU for taking time to bread this down and compare for us 👍

[@hazelhadley-britt6396]

That 1st statement is what JD's security said on the stand. He got between AH and JD.

[@markusgorelli5278]

If I was being hit by a guy whose hand was in a cast, one of the thoughts that would be sure to cross my mind is, "Look at this fella. He hand mash-up and he still wanna cuff me down wid it." 🤣 I noticed that nobody - neither AH, her sister, the security nor (importantly) the NURSE ever expresses any concern over this.

[@SuperVictoriousV]

Nurse and Security guy didnt have any concern because it didnt happen. JD didnt hit any body

[@harryf1867]

Being 'hit hard and repeatedly' 'with a hard plaster cast' I would not describe as 'unpleasant'. Painful yes. Excruciating yes. Agonizing, gut-wrrenching yes. Unpleasant no.

[@Peter-jl4ki]

That's because you don't have her magical healing powers.

[@samanthawhang7498]

@@Balletified And ice.

[@katiehettinger7857]

Another example of Amber having no empathy, she would have made up a better lie, if she could imagine how painful using his damaged would be or the amount of damage being struck hard and repeatedly would have done.

[@bamsblood]

it's obvious she's a mutant, with super fast healing abilities faster than wolverine

[@jefffletcher8209]

BBB love your incisive examinations of the most important parts of these trials. Thanks. Look forward to more

[@marycolburn4602]

Off this exact topic. But have y'all seen where Australia is investing now because of AH statements of the UK trial about entering Australia with the dogs illegally ,as now during the Virginia case showed AH was told NOT to bring them ..SHE LIED AGAIN

[@aClownBaby-]

Oh I missed that? Who’s testimony was that revealed

[@raven4090]

I have. I'm glad they're doing it and I hope she gets prison time there for it, because it's not the kind of thing you can just say, "Oh well, nothing bad happened," about. Potentially risking the health of all the animals in Australia just because she thinks she rules the world is a serious issue.

[@marycolburn4602]

@@aClownBaby- the house manager depo

[@marycolburn4602]

@@raven4090 exactly. NO ONE should be allowed to break laws just because they think they're above them....AH definitely thinks she's above everything..IMO

[@aClownBaby-]

@@raven4090 Same, same. I’m glad Australia is serious about it

[@dieselblazehaze-desireiona6910]

Thank you for doing these as they really shed light on what is going on here. Yes please do more.

[@slister45]

I now play a game with myself every time I come to your channel where I try to hit the LIKE button before you can ask 😊

[@roses9339]

If I was a Law student you would be an excellent tutor and mentor. I thoroughly enjoy your vids, you give clear and concise explanations. Cheers Rosemary Perth Western Australia (71 yrs)

[@KravKernow]

I'm doing a seminar on ethical dilemmas at the bar this evening. Totally unrelated I might add to my ethics advice on a previous livestream. I volunteered for this. But I shall definitely catch up on this as soon as I'm free. Enjoy everybody!

[@EmbraceTerror]

You can be as honest as the day is long if you're not a manipulator, and not likely to be manipulated. Ethics is kind of a moot point.

[@wildkitties4]

Thank you very much for the cross examinations. Fascinating!

[@cilandialane3084]

I believe there is more to that staircase incident than the two sisters are saying. Was that their plan to drug Johnny up to the point they could have an excuse for him accidently falling down the stairs. Since we know she copies others and how they do things, like M Peterson story. Something is way off about the staircase. I sure hope she don't copy others with her child, sister and friends like has happened in history with her types of people.

[@Benjamin_An]

If you read the Jennifer Powell declaration, then you can make sense of the situation. The roles were reversed and Whitney actually got in the middle, but because she feared AH was trying to push JD down the stairs. I guess, by getting in the middle, she got pushed by AH nearly down the stairs. It actually makes sense that AH would've feared that her sister was about to fall down the stairs, but she couldn't accept that she was the one responsible (as always) and blamed JD for it. In her testimony it became this weird distortion with JD hitting her beforehand. I guess there was some sort of intuition to break JD to a point where he would commit Sudoku or just would have been an empty shell in AH's hands. Probably not from the start, but when JD mentioned a break-up.

[@cilandialane3084]

@@Benjamin_An I will read all of that more carefully. I think it started from the very beginning she set him up.

[@rrainnecross8065]

Trust!!

[@peskypirouette7388]

Just watched Peter Tragos from The Lawyer You Know who stated you two are going to team up to help us understand The UK trial between JD & AH. This will be fantastic! TYSM! Truly appreciate both of you helping us out. Your video on crown court was very helpful

[@goonigal7758]

I would really love to see. A comparison of each of the 14? Incidents in Timeline order comparing the UK and the US trial along with your comments.

[@agbonjoshuajesse6600]

Your in-depth analysis is exceptional and topnotch #Justice4JohnnyDepp

[@paulmurgatroyd6372]

This only works if the apartment was fitted with Penrose stairs, thereby allowing everyone to be simultaneously behind AND in front of everyone else.

[@cherylj7460]

Hmmm! Though I’m not familiar with Penrose stairs, I’ve seen very confusing testimony from all parties- as to who was behind who, or in front of and how did security actually get between…

[@paulmurgatroyd6372]

@@cherylj7460 These are the stairs: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penrose_stairs I thought it fitting for an impossible situation to feature impossible architecture. I do apologise... 😉

[@cherylj7460]

@@paulmurgatroyd6372 Sounds very interesting! I thank you.

[@tammysigworth2681]

There would have been no way that Johnny's cast would have been left out in the statement, Amber's. I just wonder if there is going to be a re-trial in the UK!

[@LindaJones-dk3fz]

Johnny had a 'soft' cast, there was plaster over the top of both middle fingers and the sides were left open so as to allow for swelling. His finger at the time was extremely fragile (as per his surgeons testimony in the us court! It is very interesting even the US said that mr depp did not proper justice.

[@LindaJones-dk3fz]

Should read Us judge

[@conniecheuk7630]

Not so easy to include details when the event didn't actually happen that way. That's why she inserts and repeats trivial details such as light bulbs and dirty carpet and descends into emotive language to persuade the Jury (in Virginia) because she needs time to sequence events and she obviously finds picturing events she has never experienced trickier than she expected when she told the initial lies in 2016! The incidents are then disjointed and out of sequence, which TikTok fans found hilarious trying to reenact (see Johnny and AH represented by cats on the sofa, then edge of sofa and on carpet). Good thing she's not a film editor! Continuity would be completely out of the window! 😅

[@patriciaburns1033]

Will you get into trouble for calling a British judge out for the decisions made in the British trial? I hope not as you are providing a fantastic service here that I for one am enjoying immensely.

[@RajanSagoo]

I think he’s been very respectful, despite disagreeing with the Judge’s findings, which he has every right to do. I don’t think I would be so polite. I find it very difficult to see how the judge could so blindly believe everything AH said, while ignoring everything JD said, unless he was biased, or otherwise incentivised 😉

[@patriciaburns1033]

@@RajanSagoo I agree with you, why I said it is because the British judicial system can be Elitist and doesn't seem to take criticism very well

[@RajanSagoo]

@@patriciaburns1033 yes I got that, and it’s a great point! I should’ve said that in the first place, lol, my bad.

[@cherylj7460]

@@RajanSagoo or, perhaps, a bit seduced by her beauty

[@6862211]

Thank you for sharing this!!

[@ryangallo9356]

Thank you for sharing all of this. She is simply a lying liar who lies. It is very helpful to see the testimony from the UK case compared to the US case. As a lawyer in the US, it is fascinating to hear barristers as they do their work examining witnesses. We have similar foundations in common law and it thrills me to hear good cross by any legal practitioner. It seems to me that barristers are often more polite than we would be in the US. That is probably cultural. I love the civility. We have lost that in the US for the most part.

[@davidparkins1808]

Mr BBB an absolutely lucid analysis. Where do we petition for your elevation to Judge! (The Judge in this case listed the doubtful evidence, and then went on to say "but I believe it anyway", without giving any reasoning.)

[@mamasuki]

Thank you so much for sharing details from the UK trial. Especially since AHs keep pointing to that case as so damning to the DV by JD. I also appreciate the respectful way you share where you see issues with evidence, testimony and rulings.

[@eleazarrobiso6797]

The judge was predisposed to a verdict before he heard all the evidence. That is sad and disturbing.

[@nicolapegg6429]

Great job explaining it

[@TheOnlyKillena]

Thank you! I love hearing you break things down. But I really love when you break down the 2 different cases. Although not the same but still the same. Lol if that makes sense 🤣 but truly thank you I love your insight on all you are talking about. Even the things that are just for or in the UK.

[@SuedeNymme]

What was that judge thinking of!

[@SunshineMix101]

😎😎😎 'Another great video. 'Really enjoying the comparison vids as it allows all of is non-legal specialists a very different perspective and insight into system. 😎😎😎

[@geraldinepetrou9699]

Wow , she is made of steel. She ought to become a wrestler or boxer, and she has super powers, . She has instant healing powers.What a piece of work she is.

[@tiffanyb.7596]

Amber didn’t realize there were SMART people listening to her outlandish stories 😂 THANK YOU, We always appreciate your view on this case! 😊🦋

[@hazelhadley-britt6396]

JD was able to use the injured hand in Australia due to shock. It is the bodies way to temporarily help you. Your brain does not recognise the pain until help arrives. You know you are in pain but something happens. This happened when I was attacked in more than 1 home invasion. Everything changes. Hearing, sight, smell. Everything. That includes how your body registers pain.

[@marliceyork5867]

Yes!! Please do more comparison videos!! 💜💜💜

[@kat5757]

Maybe you don't believe it because you are a highly intelligent "unbiased" person! LOVE your channels and your Floof!! 💙

[@genacrooker8701]

Oh yes yes I love these videos that you make please make more please, and thank you so very much!

[@tanyawarwick3520]

I feel like AH would benefit from a much better group of people around her who genuinely want to help her. I mean… I’m enjoying the entire car crash, but at some point someone has to say to her…” it’s time to stop this. Admit the truth. Let it go. Let JD go. Be honest with yourself. And let’s get you some real help. She clearly set out to destroy him from the very beginning because of what she was telling her therapist for years. In the hope that would be all the evidence she needs. Someone who only makes notes of the things you say. Not to mention, if he/she saw any of these injuries or even believed AH , they would probably have insisted on physical examinations/police intervention. But she didn’t see a medical practitioner. Never went to hospital. Took No pictures showing these horrific injuries that would have been sustained during these extremely brutal attacks by her account. The photos she took just don’t add up to what she described. I sometimes look like I have a purplish yellowiness under my eyes when I’ve had way too much to drink the night before. And I don’t do “anything else”. Its time, AH. Time to let go of the lies. Preferably admit the truth and vow to get help and be a better person. I do find most People are super forgiving of anyone who admits their wrong doings. Even if it’s been years. It’s gotta be worth a try. Cos this tact is obviously not working at all. As I say, I’m fascinated and I am enjoying the whole thing. However. I’m starting to think this woman is heading for a serious nervous breakdown. And it’s turning into a Victorian freakshow. We’re just watching her damage herself. She’s surrounded herself with yes people. And that’s what sick people do. She refuses to acknowledge the truth. But she’s in desperate need of a real friend to be real with her and to make her see what she’s doing now to herself.

[@Mo_0521]

I agree that it would have been in the statement 100%. I have a story of a fight on my elementary school bus when I was younger, my sister blocked a punch to my face by putting her arm in between my face and the girl’s fist that was about to strike me…. But that’s not how I tell it because the KEY point of the story is that my sister had a cast on her arm and when she put it in between the fist and my face, the girl struck the cast instead and it hurt the girl instead of hiring me. (This ended up pissing off the girl even more, but that’s another story). The point is the cast (and my sister) is the star of that story. It’s a key factor. I have NEVER told that story and “forgotten” to mention the cast.

[@fabiennefappani9531]

Pourquoi AH n'a pas fait des photos s'il l'a tapée aussi fort et si souvent, les marques sur son visage devaient être très visible à ce moment là ???

[@justlookattheflowers4239]

That UK judge needs to brought to justice.

[@HeidisLovelyLovie]

This is a really good comparison of AH's statements. It's so clear that she embellishes her story every time she tells it. She is such a liar!

[@stillraven9415]

Can we get an reenactment of when Amber jumped between JD and herself?

[@Psammead21]

Yep, still trying to figure that one out myself 🤔🤦🏻‍♀️

[@movingforward3030]

I must have missed that. That story was so weird I lost track.

[@patriciahughes4213]

She had been practicing for the roll of the flash?

[@Loki-Landsby]

IKR?😂

[@kenm6948]

As always, I appreciate your breakdown of the staircase incident. I started watching the VA trial about six weeks ago and came across your channel as a result. I have also watched nearly all the content producers who have made YT videos discussing the trial and various aspects of testimony and have been impressed overall with the conclusions drawn. I was not familiar with the UK trial until I watched some of your videos. I am absolutely aghast that the “respected judge” could come to the conclusion he did in JD’s claim against the Sun. In my opinion, Ms H has absolutely zero credibility.

[@Petra-R]

have you analyzed the painting incident where she and her sister changed their story on the stand into two different incidents? i would like to see a video from you about that

[@Jo-razz]

I do finding it very interesting. To have it broken down it gives me a clear understanding how it works in court & how a judge comes to his decision. I had the opinion that particular situation, didn't make sense, on the staircase & maybe she was lieing. Now I feel even stronger about it. Yes, please do more of the brake down. Thank you.

[@jennyhunter9346]

Very grateful for such insight into this court case.

[@isabellaloxley7711]

More genius insight into the inconsistencies and the lies that that woman spouted throughout both trials. Thank you Daniel 🙏🏻. Shouldn’t the UK judge have recused himself due to the conflict of interest with his links to the Sun newspaper? JD was stitched up like a kipper and no mistake 🤬

[@freespiritme0129]

Thank you for clarifying it. I was curious as to how come the British Court did not see through AH lies and deceit. You have clarified it, thank you so much!

[@mrsloveleebest]

I love the comparative analysis of the trials, thanks 🙌

[@gemmih8315]

I am a DV survivor and I had years of DV. There is many things that don’t add up for me with AH’s statements etc, for starters the bottle incident… now this DID happen to me and believe me I felt it. I knew what that bottle was like and it caused damage and I needed treatment. Then being git with anything, I remember it as if it was yesterday and still after all this time I am having counselling for it. You don’t forget major incidents like being smacked in the face with a plaster cast. She described it as “unpleasant” again not really words I’d have used but that’s just me. I would love to ask you something about the law if there is a way in which I can contact you at all? Thank you for these videos. Keep up the awesome work.

[@forevermyalways4821]

Plus she even testified he always wears multiple rings on both hands! The rings alone would have caused some serious damage to skin, wouldn’t they?

[@janephilpott6565]

It is definitely fascinating, thank you so much for sharing 👏

[@remydonadillo5018]

With all these things coming out, the jurors must be patting theirselves on the backs for the right and just decisions they rendered. I can't help but feel the pain and anger of JD in losing the case in UK. If I were his relatives and I have the means I would appeal the case. Not necessarily to get justice for him but to correct the wrong system of UK court for the sake of other poor victims.

[@marilynnschroeder4436]

Thank you again, and again! Great coverage!

[@Karen_DNP]

Do appreciate your fairly unbiased telling of what AH and others have said. I truly don’t believe JD scrawled messages on the mirrors and lamp shades after just having his fingertip cut off. Besides hitting someone while your repaired 3x surgically finger and it’s still in a cast, would be extremely painful. Yet all this hitting by JD to AH, she has no photos of her injuries except for those taken when she filed & got a TRO, yet admitted she did this because her attorney told her that she & all her freeloading friends would have to move out of the ECB penthouses in 21days. This case is just so bizarre and filled w/lies and perjury by AH, WH & all her witnesses. Why UK Judge Nichol ruled the way he did, I’ll never understand nor forget his honor’s bias for AH vs the truth. Enjoy your commentaries, as always!!💯 💜✌🏼🦋

[@lauraf2584]

The judge's interjections are really helpful to the witness, insuring that she doesn't contradict herself during her testimony. I find this a very disturbing element of the way in which trials are conducted. These interventions make the judge's impartiality questionable. But a note about the cast. It is my understanding that the cast was not the sort of solid, all round plaster cast one gets for a broken bone, but rigid on the front and back surfaces and soft/softer on the sides. So I don't know how unpleasant it would be for someone to be struck by it, but I would hazard a guess that it would have completely messed up the cast itself and the immobilized digit within it, probably necessitating medical intervention for the wearer of the cast.

[@justerin1222]

I love your breakdowns. Thanks for your time doing these!

[@georgefarrington895]

This Amber person is extremely dangerous she lies at will time and time again. It seems AH and her sister are lying and lying all the time I wonder if perjury is on the cards.

[@CoriRee]

Thank you for such a thorough explanation.

[@Mikeinriver]

Great channel glad I stumbled upon you during Heard/Depp!

[@sharonfleming6353]

Listening to all that, all I kept thinking was, wouldn’t her face be. Severely broken and where’s the images as she was camera happy , love your material. Very well executed and great to listen to 🇬🇧

[@jmda58]

Her and her sisters stairs story were totally different! AH said he was at top and sister said he ran up from behind?! Her own evidence proved her to be an abusive liar and manipulative person! Her lies are especially unpleasant.

[@rostallar4243]

Thank you, you make it much easier to understand. From the Land Down Under 🇦🇺.

[@tiabiamama]

I think it is quite valuable for you, a barrister, to go over these points for us. We cannot let her lies stand, and perhaps by bringing light to them, she will have less room to maneuver if she intends to appeal or continue on in public speaking about how she "won" the first case.