Blood in the Sand | Full Episode

Two teens killed on the same California beach six years apart. DNA on one of the victims leads to two suspects - one of them worked for the police. "48 Hours" correspondent Richard Schlesinger investigates. Watch more full episodes of "48 Hours" on Pluto TV.
#48hours #crime #mystery
Crime. Social justice. Impact. "48 Hours" investigates the most intriguing crime and justice cases that touch on all areas of the human experience including greed and passion. "48 Hours," which premiered in 1988, has developed a rich history of original reporting and impact journalism that has helped exonerate wrongly convicted people, caused cold cases to be reopened and solved, and along the way changed lives.
Subscribe to the “48 Hours" KZbin channel: / @48hours
Watch full episodes of “48 Hours”: www.cbs.com/sh...
Listen to the "48 Hours" podcast: link.chtbl.com...
Listen to the "My Life of Crime with Erin Moriarty" podcast: link.chtbl.com...
Follow “48 Hours” on Instagram: / 48hourscbs
Like "48 Hours" on Facebook: on. 1KkQuRn
Follow "48 Hours" on Twitter: / 48hours
Subscribe to our newsletter: cbsn.ws/1RqHw7T
Download the CBS News app: cbsn.ws/1Xb1WC8
Try Paramount+ free: bit.ly/2OiW1kZ
For video licensing inquiries, contact: [e-mail]

[@48hours]

Click here to watch more full episodes of "48 Hours": kzbin.info/aero/PLcFHkKbd_jTJiRmfUfLX2Ay_hnf5j3cxH

[@AustinPowers6969]

Wow, such a well-done episode.

[@TabithaJones-rg9ig]

Great episode. I am wondering why the authorities...investigators, didnt do a set up of a young in love couple with cops surveillance...it doesnt make sense....bad police work.

[@BOREDANDWELLBORED]

"Police said the murders are connected with the same signature breast mutilation"..... after the case was solved...."update, police said the two case are NOT related and we're still looking for suspects".. the moral of the story is these police department are working for money, unethical and lies about everything. Looking for suspect means money in their pockets. The detective who worked at rape cases and had his trace of blood found was contamination as presented on video where in 84 they were careless about preserving pure samples. The detective never said "the girl I photographed died" on the phone, why would a SMART detective even say that on the phone in 2012 knowing phones are tampered? that was another lie by the for profit 666 police department. Here's the likely truth, the case was solved when the convicted rapist died in 2011, his dna is the evidence. More likely for both murders, again the police likely tampered with the time frame of the time he was in jail during the event of the 1st case. He was a CAREER RAPIST and they released him from jail so he can do it again. But the police department cannot make money off dead suspects so they targeted the detective who committed suicide, RIP. Unfortunately even if you reveal the names of these demonic San Diego police, there's millions who received the mark that will replace them.

[@lindamccormick8607]

Znga

[@alliecat9847]

He needs to forgive himself.

[@teamcougars]

The poor boyfriend, you can see the sadness in his eyes all these years later 😢

[@GeminiJonson]

Unless whomever killed the 1st girl,immediately covered her mouth and grabbed her legs and arms or hit the boyfriend 1st and knocked him out.Did the 1st girl scream and if so nobody heard her There's just too many unanswered questions for me.

[@nikos9257]

@@GeminiJonson Indeed this is too much work for just 1 person!!

[@caitlynpeiffer9773]

@@GeminiJonsonthey said in the video that Jim (the boyfriend) was attacked first. He was left unconscious, unable to defend himself or Barbara.

[@eddiemclaughlin-e2m]

@@GeminiJonson if she was asleep .......that should answer that question

[@DizzyDior12]

I love the way Barbara's family describe her. She wasn't an angel, she was wonderfully human.

[@mamarobyn]

My daughters and I always talk about this and say god forbid something happened to one of us let's all be honest please don't anybody start with the SHE LIT UP THE ROOM!!!!

[@rhiannon0717]

I’m glad I’ve never lit up any rooms. I feel like that must make me less likely to be murdered. 😂

[@markwolfshohl6562]

Yeah

[@MrGrumpyGills]

@@mamarobyn 🤣👍

[@MrGrumpyGills]

@@rhiannon0717 🤭

[@SCOOBYDOOBY664]

You can feel the pain and guilt in Jim's voice .. he truly regrets that decision to sleep on the beach

[@Summer09824]

I feel the dad was too harsh on him though. I understand the grief & anger but they were just teenagers and he will feel guilty for the rest of his life for someone else’s evil actions.

[@2710daisy]

Who wouldn’t???

[@betsylaughlin8652]

Oh my goodness yes…his recounting of waking up cold, wet, alone, covered in blood? I feel fit this man. Teenagers do stuff like this every night all over the would, and later in life can look back and laugh about those exploits. I do that! I feel so sorry for this man and the victim’s family. 15 years old, she’d barely begun to live. I pray she didn’t suffer too long, that she passed out wasn’t fully present for the pain.

[@millieatr]

@@Summer09824 I agree he was to harsh , and i would hope by now he would have apologized........OF COURSE the kids went to the beach , thats what kids do

[@BS-dq1kz]

@@Summer09824Agreed. That part really hurt my heart.

[@eustab.anas-mann9510]

No way these are his only 2 victims. He was way too comfortable attacking a couple for his "first" crime.

[@cannablissdreams]

his wife was awarded over SIX MILLION DOLLARS after he killed himself.. that's an absurd epilog to the story of a GRAPEST

[@BS-dq1kz]

@@cannablissdreamsWhat?! Why? I’ve seen this episode before and don’t recall anything about his wife. I’ll have to finish watching it but your comment has me stunned.

[@cannablissdreams]

@@BS-dq1kz it's at the very end of the episode.. in notes written on the screen.. right before closing credits.. it was a jury award in a wrongful death suit

[@Goldiegirl2009]

@eustsb - did you hear at the end that they don’t believe these two cases are related after all? Guy who drowned was in prison when Barbara was killed and Brown was in college 500 miles away. The second case could be a copycat.

[@di_kid00]

@@Goldiegirl2009or maybe they met somewhere, possibly at a strip club and decided to hint together… Ted Bundy did the same and murdered some of his victims with a friend. But after watching the whole ep, it’s more likely it was cross contamination… that convict was the only killer. :(

[@gaiagreen2690]

A 14 and a 15 year old girl are NOT "young women," they are teenagers and in the eye of the law, they are CHILDREN. Please be careful because words matter. Both girls were still children, not women.

[@valleygirl2530]

Actually in the eyes of the law the two girls were “minors”. Not children.

[@Camibug]

@@valleygirl2530the point still stands.

[@gaiagreen2690]

@@valleygirl2530 Exactly - they are not women but underage minors. Which means that they are not adults and cannot be described as women.

[@whereisyourfaith1454]

And what were they doing sleeping overnight at the beach w/guys in their sleeping bags, mom and dad??

[@daryldixon3685]

They were young women, teenagers, and kids... either way I cannot believe they thought they were murdered by separate killers in the same exact location, the same way, with the same sick sand signature!

[@ElaAusDemTal]

"My husband would never go after teenage girls!" It's not like he'd tell you that, what with you being his wife 🙄

[@DavidGreg066]

Indeed! I pray God gives you lots of beautiful days, I’m David Greg originally from Spain Granada, I live in Austin Texas and you ?

[@andreea007]

The evidence point to the guy being innocent. But for some reason you're hooked on what his wife says...

[@ronswansonsdog2833]

@@DavidGreg066WTH lol

[@zukostryder]

3:18 right I'm like... almost every "wife" says that and that is just disgraceful to those who he harmed

[@free2saywhatever]

He did not do it. He was not guilty beyond a reasonable doubt by any means. Look up touch DNA and how easy it for touch DNA to end up on a victim.

[@NaturalBornKelli]

I couldn't imagine the guilt Jim must feel having Barbara's parents telling him to protect her and he couldn't.

[@johnscanlon2598]

The dad is in the wrong blaming him tho he doesn’t need that extra guilt on him

[@boobooiswho5661]

It wasn't Jim's fault, it was the horrible murder's fault. Place blame where it belongs.

[@2julsofmine]

How could he defend her against a monster?

[@alexhatfield4448]

It sounded like he was severally beaten. What can you do this is just an all around awful thing.

[@mpaige7081]

Ok call me crazy but what dad leaves town and says to a teenage boy…”take care of my daughter, etc..while im out of town???” He was a teenage boy 😳

[@angelfishbby]

"God gave her to me to keep me humble. And it worked. " That's the cutest thing I've ever heard a parent say.

[@BS-dq1kz]

I thought the exact same thing! I have 3 kids and my older two are respectful and mind me really well. My youngest is smart. She’s so smart like my husband but she also isn’t as well behaved. She’s a lot to handle at times. I used to look at other parents with their ill behaved children and think how good my kids were and that I’d done a great job. Lol. Then, I had her. Ha! I love her of course but she’s definitely changed the entire dynamic of our household. She’s also made me choke on my pride a little. So, when I heard the mom say that, I thought the same as you and then I thought to myself how that’s exactly what my youngest daughter does for me. I know it’s different than what this mom was probably saying but nonetheless…

[@Kollextionm]

Gave me my son to humble me tooooooo 😂😂😂😂😂

[@Jkaye13]

All my children humbled me! 😄

[@Scorned405]

Where was God when she was being murdered??

[@Scorned405]

@@LesGrossman_69 That’s very unhealthy and disturbing

[@-skyandrainbows]

The way she talked about her daughter 😍 This is a mom who understands why you get children and how to appreciate and embrace their personality in all its grace ❤

[@SNAFU78]

48 Hours does an excellent job of covering cases, in every respect.

[@donbuyshousescash4765]

Yes there the best

[@Eli-yp9ol]

Better than these annoying podcasts 😂

[@spirals73]

I just wish the YT comments were as intelligent, present company excluded, of course.

[@YouAreStarDust]

@@spirals73that may never happen 😅😂

[@terrikansy126]

BTK’s family was also shocked to find out all the horrible things he did. You don’t always know people the way you think you do.

[@TheCowgirlNiamh]

Well his widow got 6 million in her wrongful death suit. I guess it pays to be oblivious.

[@helena3631]

his wife knew he was a piece of work she just wanted to stand by her man and being a pick me

[@bushmonster1702]

Not sure how you can watch this episode and not come to the conclusion that the cops messed up. You should watch again and especially listen to key information.

[@eirenmist2301]

@@bushmonster1702 Absolutely, and I am glad she got the judgement against them. Hopefully, they learned to be more thorough with subsequent cases. The compelling thing for me was that Bible verse he left marked to indicate how hopeless he felt that he could ever convince his wrongful accusers that he was innocent. I hope he felt comforted that God understood when certain humans did not.

[@doreenkucek335]

​@@TheCowgirlNiamh16:05

[@Mark-gg6iy]

It never ceases to amaze me when spouses think they know their partner as though people are going to disclose the worst about themselves to the most important person in their life financially.

[@OctPSfever]

She won $6M by marrying to a serial killer.

[@mermaid30019]

And it amazes me that she was awarded 6 million for him taking his own life smh

[@aksez2u]

Normally I would agree with you, but the facts in this case lead me to believe that the MICROSCOPIC speck of DNA was cross-contamination and Mr. Brown was innocent. Don't forget that the poor victim had blood on her jeans that belonged to a serial rapist. For heaven's sake does that really make sense to you?

[@aksez2u]

@@madelainemadelaine2934 Yes, there was a MICROSCOPIC SPECK of DNA from a guy who worked in the lab and BLOOD ON HER JEANS from a convicted serial rapist, and they went with the lab guy. Usually I think DNA is a slam-dunk, but this one makes no sense.

[@masunrise7471]

Yeah BTK comes to mind. Everyone, including his family thought he was an awesome person. But we all know how that ended.

[@EJ-74]

It's so sad teenagers can't go out and have a good time without having to worry about some maniac killing them. This was evil vile and disgusting!!!

[@taras6806]

Absolutely. It should be possible for anybody of any age. Unfortunately, we have to recognise the terrible fact that killers walk among us.

[@jasonstaples4364]

Mom always said “nothing good happens after midnight” monsters everywhere.

[@mbekka1]

That’s why they must stay home and don’t go anywhere without their parents,,,

[@taras6806]

@@mbekka1 Agreed, entirely. Unless of course in the rare and awful cases that parent/s or carer/s are abusive.

[@taras6806]

@@jasonstaples4364 It is always after midnight except on the dot of midnight.

[@viewbens]

The courage of Jim telling Barbara’s parents. What a man!

[@gravedigger6632]

😂😂😂 u funny

[@musicisgoodforthesoul999]

​@@gravedigger6632grow up

[@DR-mq1vn]

I'm a 55 year old woman. I remember disobeying my parents and doing things I shouldn't have done when I was a teenager. All of us thought our parents were being over-dramatic and overly protective. But our parents were just trying to protect us because they loved us so much. When you are a teenager (and into adulthood too), you just don't think that anything bad will happen to you. And odds are that nothing will happen. But there is always a chance. There are evil people in this world, just looking for an open opportunity. Everyone reading this - please think about what you are doing, stay aware of your surroundings, do things in groups, not alone, and always tell a trusted person of your plans. Better to be cautious and safe, than sorry later. And I hope that one day Barbara's case will be solved and justice served.

[@cruisepaige]

Be things happen to a lot of us.

[@evernight.]

It'll never be solved. It happened 46 years ago...

[@J24J]

Very well said. At that age and even beyond, you don’t think about these things. I remember my college years and there was never any fear about our safety. I believe that most of us make it out of those years by luck and good fortune that nothing like this happened to us. There are so many stories about those that were not so lucky. Very sad.

[@natscat4752]

Good advice. I shudder to think of some situations I got into and how things could have gone wrong. Including hitch hiking as a teenager where the man driving who was about 60 told me he had champagne in the boot. Luckily he was just a cheeky old dog pushing his luck and he dropped me off safely without opening the champagne.

[@ArtCE47]

I was born and raised in San Diego and spent every day of summer on Torrey Pines. I had no idea this ever happened. Absolutely tragic and unimaginable because La Jolla is such an incredibly upscale and affluent area. Poor Jim ❤

[@valleygirl2530]

I spent 20 years enjoying that beach and I never once heard about the murders and that one was still unsolved.

[@johnscanlon2598]

Seal beach is great

[@mknels1299]

Some never watch the news. I do.

[@ClaireAhBella]

I was there yesterday - it’s such a beautiful place.

[@roseelley4470]

Same! I grew up there and spent every summer on that beach in the 80’s and never even heard these stories.

[@LAVirgo67]

Teenagers feel immortal. They don't feel that danger applies to them. They are establishing themselves as future adults. Sadly, this makes them vulnerable to crime.

[@LadyAngela678]

Very true.

[@diamonddeliliah123]

Yup especially the ones from the 70s and 80s those were wild time

[@Holy.HannaH]

Well the one had written a will already so I'm guessing she didnt feel immortal. But I do think it's hard for most to fathom just how quickly and easily life can be snuffed out.

[@jdbakerassociates]

Well I mean they weren’t out jumping off cliffs, they just wanted to sleep on the beach, bothering no one, they shouldn’t have been killed. That shouldn’t be a death sentence

[@Thekidisalright]

This is just victim blaming. If kids can’t even enjoy their time at the beach without being murdered, the society collectively failed them, the same way our kids get murdered in school nowadays.

[@MA__]

I went camping with a friend who wanted to sleep on the beach in her sleeping bag instead of with our friends at our nearby camp. I didn't want to but decided to do it with her so she wouldn't be out there alone. Before I feel asleep i heard voices and three men were approaching us. I greeted them in a loud voice before they could come to close, my heart pounding, and they asked about some party they were looking for and went on their way. My friend slept through the whole thing. It was all fine but I was not ok with that kind of vulnerability and danger. Could have been very bad

[@smears6039]

The world needs more friends like you. Good on you for having such a good head on your shoulders.

[@cultmamacultmama3571]

But even with you there - three guys would have had an easy way with both of you, had they attacked you.

[@brianmaitai7685]

One could have been "Big Foot"...

[@FloeticEnigma]

The fact that the two crimes were so similar and in the same area makes me believe it was one person who committed both crimes. It sounds like the police took the easy way out and blamed the dead guys for the one they could pin on them. Fact is, a lot of crimes go unsolved. They consider one solved, but they did that to help their own numbers. Looks like two unsolved crimes to me.

[@maclac48]

Sounds about right. God knows tho. 🙏🏿

[@Carmen-us1ew]

I agree!! They do need to look more into the first guy that committed suicide.

[@JanelleC717]

I'm with you all the way. There's someone out there who thinks the police are a joke.

[@mermaid30019]

His blood was on her, there was DNA proof. Don’t forget there are some times copycats.

[@mikepeng1568]

As a molecular biologist who had designed clinical trial assays using DNA, I have seen sample cross contaminations all the time if people don't follow the strictest lab practice. The police cannot just dismiss the possibility of sample contaminations in the criminal lab. There is a well known story among molecular biologists that in Germany the police was puzzled the suscepts in several unrelated cases was the same woman until they figured out that lady who did not wear gloves when assembling the sample collection kits

[@patwhite7970]

Jim stepped up to the plate when telling Barbara's parents. The guilt he still feels

[@nilvolentidificileest]

How can a case be considered solved by police if the police has two version of suspects without any found connection between them?

[@johnscanlon2598]

That’s what I’m asking , the forensics tech just may be innocent

[@nilvolentidificileest]

Also, when there are two identical cases, and both of their suspects have alibis for the first one, and there's a viable explanation for the DNA of one of the suspects. Just wow.

[@amazinggrace9114]

@@johnscanlon2598he’s guilty, those lie detector tests are extremely accurate, those other comments he made and the suicide of himself. We are looking at a guilty guy

[@bushmonster1702]

low level police are not brilliant at their jobs in general.

[@martinmayfield1932]

It’s a joke. They just wanted to “solve” the case. It’s kind of scary how detectives operate

[@kayleidanielle7499]

His wife got 6 MILL and the victims families couldn’t even get answers….wtf!

[@Tamara-id1pe]

His wife was victimized by Law Enforcement, the families were victimized by criminals. Law enforcement has a duty to act appropriately

[@LifeisANovel]

​@@Tamara-id1pesimple and to the point. People will understand this if they don't react off emotions.

[@mikeypiros6647]

They should sue for wrongful death of their daughter.

[@ExiledStardust]

Yeah, that's disgusting. He was a creep and most likely involved, but even if he wasn't, it isn't the police department's fault he chose the easy way out. I have so sympathy for a dude so creepy that female coworkers didn't want to be in the same room with him. The wife doesn't deserve to profit from his cowardice.

[@petermanji8116]

@@ExiledStardust What??? The police acknowledge that he couldn't have been the one in the end and you say he deserves it because of some offhand interactions with a colleague. Did you miss the part where they said he wasn't a good communicator and wasn't great with people? I mean you are what is wrong with the world today, that man was bullied to his death

[@rebekahwolkiewicz449]

I really appreciate that guy sending help back for his girlfriend. His injuries were awful and yet she was the first thing he mentioned. And his friend was so selfless, going to look for her despite seeing what a monster had done to his friend.

[@lynamor2959]

Jim is a big sweetheart. I can tell. 😢. So sorry this happened to them all. What monsters live amongst us. Can’t blame teens. They are so innocent minded~. Blame the damn psychos!!!

[@tpw9099]

That’s right! Not the kids, parents etc. who r at fault killers are the ones we all need to blame appropriately for this kind of tragedy! No one should have to deal with these horrible kinds of happenings but we do have to unfortunately

[@Moonewitch]

The parents shouldn't have been mad at the boyfriend! They were all kids. He wasn't an adult chaperone. He almost didn't make it himself. How do they think his parents felt? He more than likely sustained his injuries trying to fight to protect her. I'm glad they gave him an apology.

[@janicescott6569]

I agree completely. Teens brains aren’t even fully formed and they think they are invincible.

[@PinkGrammarGirl]

Meh, it's a human response.

[@tundrawomansays694]

@@janicescott6569Yep. And they’re gonna make poor choices/decisions occasionally. This is normal Childhood Growth and Development and at best, we can offer our POV, our guidance (please keep it low keyed, parents) but ultimately it’s their decisions. It’s scary as a parent to learn to lighten up on our kids in adolescence because we know what *we did.* We also took a lot of risks. *As our kids get older we need to loosen the reins, not tighten them.* Our kids are not extensions of us, they’re their own unique “human beans.” Let them be who they are-and remember, you have an Identity outside being a “parent.”

[@lifesajoke6965]

If that was my daughter I'd be mad at everyone and everything.

[@professionaltrollgirl2682]

He was almost an adult. Teens know right from wrong. He wasn't a toddler. Taking a girl to a secluded area for sex and being irresponsible means it's his fault!!!

[@stevent4955]

This a horrible tragic story 😢 God Bless the families of the victims

[@TNT-km2eg]

Your god-dog blessed them all right . As well as he blesses parents of 9 000 000 children under age of five dying each year worldwide . And all the others dying and suffering .

[@SV-xb1rg]

@@TNT-km2eg what’s wrong with children suffering and dying if you’re just star dust. That’s like a rock crying over another rock that got stepped on.

[@elijahstewart1970]

My condolences to both of the Families.

[@gingercollier7949]

WOW! It could have been cross contamination for sure. Sounds like San Diego PD needs to reopen these two cases.

[@tpw9099]

It really does and I’m glad she won that case they ruined the guys life!!!!

[@Tuturial464]

​@@tpw9099or he ruined the girls life. Being a creep and cross contaminated DNA isn't enough but he should have been pursued.

[@zyphil]

@@Tuturial464 He was pursued, and despite that, he ended up committing suicide cause he was a weak person according to the people who knew him. Did you even watch the video?

[@danieldougan269]

The innocent explanations about the suspect who worked in the crime lab are perfectly reasonable to me. The fact that the police never charged him during his life tells me they were afraid to take it to court against a defense. There is, at the very least, a lot of room for reasonable doubt in that case. I'm not saying I KNOW he's innocent, but the point is for the jury to know the defendant is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. I haven't seen all the evidence, and obviously, there was no trial, but I would vote to acquit him based on what I have seen here.

[@jenniferanderson9402]

After hearing the way the crime lab operated in the 80's I have my doubts that Brown murdered Claire. Also the way his friends said he was able to be bullied. Cops can bully. Jim was just a kid himself doing what teenagers do. He has suffered enough. Peace to him.

[@rhiannon0717]

Hearing that the lab technicians would bring in their own seminal fluid to confirm the accuracy of the lab tests is wild!

[@DiddlyD-xx2ih]

Brown was hundreds of miles away in college when the girl was murdered. The Widow won a 6 million suit against the San Diego police.

[@lori8492]

I agree

[@cindytrayer4279]

If he went to trial I believe he would have gotten off bc there definitely was reasonable doubt.

[@PinkGrammarGirl]

Having 2 separate guys' DNA on her? Once I heard one was a tech, I immediately thought contamination. The suicide guy is most likely the culprit.

[@janetfilger8326]

These two poor victims look incredibly alike. Their noses and face shape and coloring and smiles look like close relatives: sisters or cousins. Even hairstyles are shaped similarily. Whoever raped and stabbed them definitely had a "type" of beauty that obsessed him. Very sorry this happened to both young girls and for their families. ❤ 😢 RIP😢❤

[@artisthusnatalal3099]

Aaaah people tell me my husband looks similar to me as if we're Sister and Brother lol😆🙈

[@tundrawomansays694]

@@artisthusnatalal3099Let’s hope you don’t turn up dead, my friend! ;-)

[@artisthusnatalal3099]

@@tundrawomansays694 Haahhaaa...hhhaaa😂😂😂

[@katarzynamariamuszynska2811]

Maybe he had type he liked or girl with similar look refused ,rejected him😢

[@karenlong5622]

It's been said also that a caretaker/owner of a dog begins to resemble the dog after a while ... what gives?!@@artisthusnatalal3099

[@jimparsons4312]

Barbara’s parents STILL mad at Jim for taking her to the beach broke my heart in a million pieces

[@katiel1979]

Yeah they we’re just kids he was attacked too and had his love killed he wasn’t responsible for thier daughters choice they need to hug him

[@jimparsons4312]

@@katiel1979 I know. He’s carrying so much trauma to begin with. I feel terrible for him 💔

[@ritam768]

The father apologized to him all the way back in ‘94. It was just the initial anger/shock.

[@Tomboyy9818]

@@katiel1979were* their*

[@gdurandeau1143]

Well, it's understandable that the parent's hearts were broken in a zillion pieces.

[@markuse3472]

The letter(s) or journal, or Will, Claire Hough left for her parents were so lovely and caring, very thoughtful of her. The mothers statement on those letters or Will from Claire, "it's always a puzzle...but it is also a treasure" is absolute. So accurate.

[@sheiladeinhart6876]

Jim you were just a kid . You loved her with all your ❤ she would never wanted you to carry this guilt with you . She adored you ❤ please remember your human . A good person ❤❤

[@theeditor1149]

I think of all the things i did when i was younger that could have turned out badly. In barbara's case the unthinkable did happen. I feel sorry for the boyfriend but he shouldnt blame himself. He could not have known what would happen to them. He was severely injured too. I hope he finds peace over this.

[@prettyblkgyrl74]

It's crazy that the severely injured boyfriend was actually considered a suspect. I understand the police have to do their due diligence, but under these circumstances REALLY?!? 🤔

[@Kat.Evangeline]

His head was swollen twice it's size.

[@nb-user25]

He was probably a suspect for less than a day or something. It’s like a thought that comes and goes.

[@SidewaysInTraffic]

Bullcrap. You have to watch the story where the bf/husband (cant remember the relationship status) took his girl to the beach also and killed her, then shot himself 4 times to make it look like it wasn't him. He got caught because there were Google searches of where to shoot yourself and not die. And he drove 10 miles while bleeding to get help for his girl.

[@sylversyrfer6894]

⁠@@SidewaysInTraffic - I know that case you mentioned. The guy did internet searches on how to minimize injury when shooting oneself. And he did just that. He was never in a coma for 4 days. He did NOT have metal plates put in his head. He did NOT come close to dying - all of which Jim experienced. HUGE difference.

[@prettyblkgyrl74]

@@sylversyrfer6894 HUGE DIFFERENCE INDEED… (I remember that other case too)

[@michaelhasse2568]

That's the worst horror, being attacked in your sleep

[@skygazer6898]

I hate the thought of some killer out there living their life and not being held accountable for taking a life. Those poor girls had their whole lives in front of them, I hope one day the killer or killers will be found and there will be some kind of justice for the girls and their families.

[@Marlaina]

More than likely it was the man who drowned

[@LadyIarConnacht]

Probably not, because then the lab would have to admit their shoddy practices.

[@blynpontemayor176]

Rest in paradise girls....what a sad story 😢

[@TNT-km2eg]

They are not resting anywhere . They are not anymore . Dead

[@soccer1970-f5f]

@@TNT-km2eg what a delightful ray of sunshine you are.😑

[@TNT-km2eg]

@@LesGrossman_69 Empty semantics of a dilettante . Collection of contradictions

[@skatergirl8019]

I find it really hard to believe these cases aren’t related.

[@WilliamBonney-gl2qf]

Agreed!! Anyone with half a brain can link these 2 murders together. The way in which both Barbara & Claire were murdered were eerily similar.

[@ameliacoburn4787]

It is! Only other thought I had was the 2nd was a copy-cat. I think there's a good chance the rapist guy did the 2nd one, but he was in prison when the 1st happened....

[@tutuMiyako]

​@@ameliacoburn4787 I think the probability of the second case being a copy-cat is very low for one reason: most of people who lived in the area at the time didn't even know that something happened there, let alone HOW and at what exact location...

[@nikkimit2k]

Jim it's never to late for healing. I wish for you it come true to feel free from this heavy load.

[@corsousa]

The father of the girl has no right to be upset and angry at the boyfriend. The poor guy was beaten to one inch of death and the father blames for what happened. That’s not right

[@Kat.Evangeline]

Tragic

[@julieuk5855]

If they had not gone out, his daughter would have been safe but she too was responsible.

[@eraldadevole]

@@julieuk5855yeah but the boy wasn’t her dad, he was her bf and was a teen also. So yeah he is responsable same as barbara herself, meaning 2 young teens wanting to live life. None of them to blame, teens do not always listen to their parents, it is what it is. The only one to blame is the killer

[@GhastlyCretin]

He doesn't blame him anymore. He read a letter he wrote to the boyfriend in 1994 saying as much.

[@TanjiToo]

Do none of you watch the whole thing? He forgave the bf.

[@jenniferfiler945]

I love her mom she keep it real about her daughter she didn’t turn her into a perfect Saint

[@itscherryamber]

I'm confused. The husband called his friend and said the girl he photographed on the beach ended up dead? Like, what. He clearly knew her then? And also he admitted to photographing a child?! Was the beach the same one she was found on? And the wife is there saying it was all cutesy glamour shots? If it was an underage girl, there ain't anything cute about it. What is happening, how did he not do it? Am I missing something

[@irishdaisy1628]

i was wondering where are the photos? if he recalled taking them.

[@sarahpiaggio2693]

She didn't say he showed her photos of the girl who was murdered. She said he showed her examples of the kind of photos he took. He obviously showed her the most innocent-looking ones, and ones of people who weren't under age. But it's likely that he didn't do it because the forensic evidence is contaminated and there was ALSO forensic evidence of a convicted rapist, which surely should make us consider the probability that THAT man committed the crime, not a guy who worked in the lab

[@itscherryamber]

@@sarahpiaggio2693 yes, I would have also suspected the rapist but apparently he was in jail during the time she was murdered?

[@sarahpiaggio2693]

@@itscherryamber Really? Well in that case none of their forensic evidence from that time is reliable at all

[@silverstuff182]

Even if Brown photographed her, that doesn’t indicate that he killed her. Apples and oranges. And there is no evidence that he DID photograph her. It’s sad that he succumbed to the pressure.

[@peternolan4107]

I live in San Diego. The way this case was handled and the resulting suicide are no surprise to me. Good to see how much Rebecca Brown was awarded in her lawsuit.

[@maalban12]

How sad how some spouses can be so blindsided. He killed himself bec of his guilt!!

[@spirals73]

1. You don't have proof he was guilty. 2. There are multiple reasons for suicide. How can you be so blindsided?

[@kellyflores4931]

These weren’t young women. There were CHILDREN.

[@Tenekai]

Strange choice of words, huh?

[@kellyflores4931]

@@Tenekai very strange…

[@Tenekai]

@@kellyflores4931 unfortunately, this is the way the culture is headed. Policies are being put in place by Democrats to protect peds.

[@smears6039]

@@Tenekaigive me a single example of that happening. Which party is currently and historically advocating to keep child marriage legal? Hint, it’s not the democrats (I’m not a fan of either but you’re just straight up lying)

[@evapunk522]

Teenagers are young women, are they still minors..yes, but using the term young women makes sense because they are technically mature biologically...but just not mentally yet. If you go to a young adult section of a bookstore, these are books for teens..so yeah, they are young women..

[@julesrandolph5687]

What an unbearably sad and tragic story, My heart goes out to the parents of both young women. It's the living loved ones of victims who get a life sentence of sorrow.

[@diannenaworensky6698]

Thank you 48hours for putting this full episode on

[@TheCrabbyCrafterlol]

I love that this interviewer does NOT coax answers from interviewees via body language and head nods/shakes. He poses the question with neutrality and lets the people he's talking to answer for themselves. (unlike so many other tc show hosts/interviewers who puppet the entire conversation by telling people in non-verbal ways how they're expected to answer the questions).

[@zetacrucis681]

The way you're seeing interviews on TV shows / documentaries does not take place in real time. Prompts, responses and reactions are always shot in different takes and later cut together in post-production for the final edit. It's impractical doing it any other way.

[@paulinegallagher7821]

And he reminds me of Stephen Spielberg! I looked him up to see was he a brother or something, but no lol.

[@gj5990]

I’m sorry but what innocent man kills himself for being accused and not being charged? He had support from other people including wife. Looks like a guilty man to me.

[@jessicablair5610]

I read a book about the cases. But watching those two men read that final letter the dad wrote to the boyfriend had me in tears. Such a tragedy.

[@brianmeen2158]

So what do you think happened? Do you believe the law enforcement official was guilty of both murders? This case is a bit messy

[@jara4766]

The daughter is just as responsible for not following the rules and going out as her boyfriend was. No one is responsible for this except the maniac who went on a murderous rampage.

[@fin2-em2mf]

MEN ....as usual...whats new

[@Tavieme]

I currently hike at this beach regularly and had no idea about this. Just heartbreaking.. these two will be the first thing I think of when I’m there again.

[@L1KECLOCKWORK]

New uploads on back to back days? Love it

[@truthhurts3524]

Right! Made me double check it wasn’t Tuesday.

[@jimwerther]

​@@truthhurts3524 Or Friday. But then again, they missed last Friday. Weird.

[@mirkatu3249]

Wow those two girls look so similar! What an interesting case regarding the early DNA testing practices. It's too bad there wasn't a concrete conclusion. 😞

[@GGGGGG-qj2un]

I liked Richard Schlesinger as a 48 Hours correspondent. The most memorable story he has done is Grave Injustice. I’ve been watching 48 Hours since 80s. Where is Maureen Maher?

[@newbooks9858]

This shows why it is important to get a lawyer and not talk to cops or media or anybody. Because the cops don't care, they just want to nail somebody, innocent or guilty.

[@pixi2209]

🎯

[@UnIimited_Power]

A 14 year old is a girl, not a young woman. I don't know why people say that. Like they're trying to minimize the crime.

[@Tracy-xe9zu]

People referring to teenage girls as "young women", especially when in this case they're only 14 and 15 years old, is incredibly creepy and very gross. They are not adults, stop thinking of them like adults, stop treating the case like they're adults. But since society writ large will eagerly blame women for anything (including being the victim of a crime) it probably sounds better blaming "young women" than "children".

[@skechers28227]

Oh man, this case... I'm gonna be thinking about this for weeks now.

[@zombiechicken7114]

The nickname that person had and they never thought they should report him to higher ups or suspect him? Reminds me of the recent metropolitan police officer who was also known as a serial predator but protected by his colleagues till he killed Sarah Everard. Disgusting. Anyone who knew should be fired.

[@ktcooki276]

Yes that killer was nicknamed THE GRAPIST by his colleagues that's appalling

[@DiddlyD-xx2ih]

Brown was hundreds of miles away in college when the girl was murdered. The Widow won a 6 million suit against the San Diego police.

[@tpw9099]

Report the guy for what because he was a pervert? He did t hurt anyone that they knew of?? What the hell is wrong with u people??? What kind of sick mob mentality to ruin another’s life is that? Wow??? Wth is wrong with society today?? Mind ur own business stop judging others he was a pervert that does not make him a killer or rapist??? What would u report seriously?? I cant believe 45 people agree with that kind of nonsense??? All of you Must be like 20-35 yrs old?? Because people never ran around reporting every little effing thing to the boss before you people started playing “ let’s police the people around us” mind ur business and take care of yourself my heavens

[@andreea007]

Idk...The guy got that nickname for doing back then what most americans are doing nowadays. Moral standards were way different those days. And he worked in that lab. He could have easily replace the evidence sample if he was indeed guilty. Looks like a clear case of cross contamination.

[@shmwmlam3953]

He got that nickname for going to strip clubs. Who doesnt do that nowadays? What is criminal about it? If it is criminal why strip clubs are legal?

[@llamamama2910]

Why the hell was a convicted rapist out again? They need to be in prison for life!

[@PinkGrammarGirl]

If rapists got life in prison, millions of murders wouldn't happen...

[@llamamama2910]

@@PinkGrammarGirl so true-except for the murders after to avoid a witness to land them in prison for life. Already an issue-rapists are often murderers.

[@debandmike3380]

it's pretty apparent after watching so many episodes of this show that the police ruin just as many lives as criminals.

[@lex1216]

Word

[@ClaireAhBella]

I was shocked to hear Torrey Pines - it’s one of my favorite places. And to share a name with one of the deceased made me feel a strong connection to this case. What a beautiful young woman & what a beautiful family she had. ❤

[@Simplelivingslowliving]

How sad to not know who and why this was done to your daughter. I have daughters and I couldn’t live with the grief I don’t think. Heartbreaking.

[@tundrawomansays694]

And let’s hope you never have to, my friend. Sometimes I don’t think there’s anything scarier than being parents of teens. They need space and we need to loosen up the reins, not hold them tighter despite knowing they’re gonna make decisions that aren’t the best. I don’t know about you but throughout my life (I’mma old widow broad) I’ve learned more from my poor decisions than I ever learned from my “better” decisions.

[@Memg007]

Please tell them to not be reckless and not fall under peer pressure. People say “oh kids being kids, teenager being teenagers” which is ridiculous in this day and time where criminals are everywhere.

[@jasonpalacios1363]

Very sad story my heart goes out to the families and the friends of those 2 victims, may those 2 victims RIP.

[@cali.girllivinnnevada8]

Bro almost died, can you really be mad at someone for not keeping your child safe when they couldn’t even keep themselves safe do to the fact that they were asleep when the attack took place??? I mean COME ON Dad! (Edit) In all seriousness I know that when parents lose a child, that their thinking can be a lil skewed. My thoughts and prayers go out to anyone who’s lost someone they love….💔

[@mallorycannon3011]

I've seen this episode before and that part always bothered me. Doesn't the dad think that that Jum suffers with survivors guilt as it is? Or blaming himself. 3ven though he shouldn't.

[@tmcgruder2]

Right like why is your teenager allowed to sleep outside overnight and not at home?!!!

[@cali.girllivinnnevada8]

@@tmcgruder2 her parents were unaware that they were leaving the house that night. They were not home and they were out of town, so don’t blame the parents. Those two teenagers promised they were going to stay home, and didn’t!

[@persgodiva]

Guys, those feelings ... I don't think we can understand them. There's so much grief and pain involved. Leave them to their feelings, it's not for us to judge.

[@cali.girllivinnnevada8]

@@persgodivaI actually totally agree with you….

[@michellecg4771]

Kevin Brown just looks unhinged on all his pictures 😫He’d definitely make me feel uncomfortable

[@free2saywhatever]

Uncomfortable does not mean a murderer.

[@TheWritingsonthewalls]

The way the three men that were suspects ALL killed themselves is no coincidence. The way Claire wrote out a will at 14? ..leads me to think that she had been exposed to something or someone dangerous. The way her friend warned her weeks before she was murdered not to go out on her own late at night anymore leads me to believe her friend suspected that Claire was putting herself close to danger. The way he admitted to a friend that a girl he had taken pictures of was murdered on the beach. At the very least he was obviously taking underage/child p photos of her. Idk I feel as though there was a sick seedy teenage girl "photography" community that all of these men participated in (the creepy letters from the psychic sounds like how a guilt racked creep would describe a young girl he photographed) the other 2 men were not linked to Barbara, but there also could have been others that were also part of their sicko socially awkward boys photo club. And I think both of these girls at some point went to get glamor shots of themselves from this ring of men. As for Rebecca Brown, denial ain't just a river in Egypt. She seemed like she knew more than she was letting on to.

[@hislittlemrs.9235]

I've never seen someone cry so hard, with so few tears.

[@antisocialsocialite5046]

Sooo Barbara was going to get glamour shots done while she was sleeping on the beach with her boyfriend? 🤔 Make it make sense

[@adriankasan6344]

If he wasn't guilty why would you take your own life

[@anneofgreengables1619]

Also timing...

[@zyphil]

Did you not watch the video? He was a person with a weak personality who could've been bullied according to all his former coworkers and even his wife. Hundreds of stories about people offing themselves even though they end up being exonerated after death.

[@irenestrmnss4331]

Think he did it.

[@nativeroscoe64]

Well, I disagree with giving the widow $6 million. Her husband was the only suspect. His suicide brings up a lot of questions about who and what he might've done. Or did.

[@anneofgreengables1619]

Yes. Absolutely

[@Visong3]

I can understand why parents felt angry at the boyfriend but i hope they understand that he is a victim also and worst of all he has to live with this.The dead are dead but for the persones that They leave behind is the real pain

[@smears6039]

Yeah it made me pretty sick to see their total lack of empathy for someone their daughter loved, and who lost the love of his life and nearly his own. Their daughter is gone but causing more harm to a victim is indefensible. They are her PARENTS, THEY are responsible for her safety, and instead of showing compassion they blame a 15 year old kid that they put the responsibility of watching their daughter onto who was knocked unconscious and imo acted so heroically to be on deaths door and his first concern is for his girl. They’re pretty disgusting, especially seeing how the father is STILL blaming jim in recent interviews.

[@melisentiapheiffer3034]

I think the father was projecting his inability to protect his daughter onto the boyfriend. I have immense sympathy for them because this was an extremely traumatic event for them.

[@AbbieKirk-qr1gm]

You become very angry after losing a child...you take it out on people...but there's nothing he could of done as he was unconscious and badly beaten...I hope he doesn't blame himself.

[@crystalthomas1192]

Prayers 2 both families and the deceased loved ones

[@Pauly421]

He definitely did it. The wife is in denial soooo damned hard, and his attorneys seem like complete basket cases.

[@Kat.Evangeline]

Agreed !!!

[@Tamara-id1pe]

Based on what actual evidence? Can someone put him at the crime scene? Did he brag about it? Did they find the girl’s belongings at his home? Does he have a single accusation of violence in his past? Can they even show that he knew this violent rapist accomplice? Did they ever think there were two perpetrators before this “DNA discovery”? Anything? The court system clearly didn’t find the evidence, so I’m curious where it is

[@jimwerther]

​@@Tamara-id1pe I lean your way. They absolutely did not have enough to get a conviction.

[@lindseyyoung9149]

​@Tamara-id1pe Totally agree. He definitely didn't do it, and they're so stuck on him as the suspect that they're no longer looking for the actual killer and in turn adding to the families suffering. There are way too many people judging on emotions and not evidence. It's absolutely terrifying!

[@jimwerther]

@@lindseyyoung9149 "Definitely"? How do you know that with absolute certainty? Clearly they lacked enough to charge, let alone convict. But "definitely" is a bridge too far for me.

[@e.b.squared]

I definitely think he is the best suspect for the case. Unfortunately, the evidence was completely messed up, and I think there is enough reasonable doubt that he could have gotten off. Tragic story all around.

[@DiddlyD-xx2ih]

Brown was hundreds of miles away in college when the girl was murdered. The Widow won a 6 million suit against the San Diego police.

[@PinkGrammarGirl]

Occam's Razor says the suicide rapist is the culprit and the tech is contamination. If it's the tech, how do you explain the other guy??

[@Memg007]

He’s guilty and a coward for sure.

[@FienDeLaere]

exactly @@PinkGrammarGirl

[@DoobieDeb]

So sad heartbreaking Deepest Condolences

[@RatedArggg]

Going to a strip club isn't suspicious. Laughing at a rape report IS.

[@netta96]

That's the biggest clue to me

[@p.sherman3158]

Don’t leave your teenagers behind when you go out of town.

[@Daniel_Capital]

This is a ridiculous and asinine comment

[@p.sherman3158]

@@Daniel_Capital believe what you want. 👍🏻

[@cultmamacultmama3571]

It can happen on their way to school and it frequently does. You don't need to be out of town for something to happen to your child.

[@p.sherman3158]

@@cultmamacultmama3571 no but the chances are much greater when you are gone.

[@tracypolselli1464]

I was a teenager in San Diego county at the time, my parents had the news on all the time and I don’t remember ever hearing about this back then (even though I’ve heard about it since on true crime shows). Heartbreaking.

[@roseelley4470]

Same!

[@gittenielsen95]

"God gave her to me to keep me humble". I wish I had a mother like her. God bless.

[@valleygirl2530]

I’m spooked! I spent a lot of time on Torrey Pines beach in the 1990’s-2000’s. It’s a great walking beach. I spent 3 late night hours with a friend on one occasion. I didn’t know about those murders - I wish I had. I’d walk the whole length of the beach often at sunset - Alone! Holy crap!!

[@pazza4555]

These were once in a million crimes, and nothing has happened since the 1980s. There's no reason to avoid that beach

[@mermaid30019]

@@pazza4555she meant alone. Putting herself in danger at night

[@Misscnyp]

Way to make it about you... get over yourself.

[@brendaleverick3655]

The wife is usually clueless, or doesn't care about the victims, as long as her marriage stays intact.

[@inesfreire9135]

Yup, pretty crazy

[@free2saywhatever]

Brown didn’t do it. If you watch the show, it is clearly explained how easy it was to have his DNA end up on the victim in simple cross contamination. She is not clueless at all, and far from it.

[@indyhill2781]

Not on the victim, in the victim.

[@jesusfaith2232]

“Normal man stuff” the wife says, she is in denial!

[@V.M.R.25]

I’m very upset the police dropped the ball with these two investigations. They had tunnel vision with the DNA found on the second victim and failed to investigate for more suspects. If I were a juror, I couldn’t say the accused is guilty based off the DNA swab after hearing the DNA swab could have been contaminated by the accused during working in the same lab it was processed. This case needs more investigation and justice.

[@DiddlyD-xx2ih]

With the conditions in that crime lab, there is no way the DNA evidence would have even been admissible in court.

[@tpw9099]

I would have to say not guilty they definitely did not have a strong case n they knew it too

[@debmc2291]

I think the guy who drown was Claire's killer and Kevin Brown's DNA was mishandled in the lab.

[@Tuturial464]

​@@debmc2291or brown is the killer. DNA evidence isn't enough but his behavior is. And hey. What's the best way to hide as a killer than be a scientist. His past is suspicious and should have Been looked at

[@smears6039]

@@debmc2291100%

[@persgodiva]

ngl the DNA evidence is weird to me. Two people who have never met?

[@Soubhik12345.]

These old episodes are sweet ❤

[@superpixelated7354]

Og

[@cali.girllivinnnevada8]

Sweet???? They’re brutal murders!! 🤨

[@Pauly421]

This is from 2018

[@griseldasmith6375]

🤔

[@StarlightSelenite]

@@Pauly421It’s odd. Some of these people look like they are acting. It makes some of the parts look fake or hokey. Imo.

[@Cyn...Cyn1]

They were kids, doing kids things. Especially in that day and age, kid were more free to be kids. In no way should he be blamed for her death. You can't protect anyone while your sleeping. I know that father was hurting but it was just wrong to blame him. That poor guy has to live with this for the rest of his life.

[@remycallie]

Here's a tip. Don't go away on a trip and ask your 15 year-old daughter's surfer boyfriend to take care of her for you.

[@iseultbourke4692]

They did not do that, she was left with a family friend.

[@remycallie]

@@iseultbourke4692 If you listen, the father says explicitly that he talked to the boyfriend before he left and said "take care of my little girl." At a minimum he knew this guy was sleeping with his fifteen-year-old daughter and it didn't seem to bother him.

[@elsie6828]

Both girls were not being supervised by their parents at the time of their murders, that much is true.

[@LadyIarConnacht]

It's true, the beach culture in the 70's was very wild and free. Teenagers did all kinds of crazy, unsafe things and a lot of teens in CA were killed.

[@jammieclaychristiansen8638]

My heart goes out to Jim Alt. I can’t even imagine the PTSD he must have gone through and survivors guilt. Truly heartbreaking. This young man has to have be forever haunted. 💔

[@laurenS94]

Barbra getting awarded 6million by jury.. yet police still say it was him and case solved?! Smh. Rip to both young women.. how tragic. Prayers for Jim to be able to heal and forgive himself. ♥️

[@DJ-iv2xo]

Why was the wife of a suspect awarded 6 million dollars?

[@peterj5106]

It's a pretty low blow by Police..... waiting until after he's passed then announcing that he's basically guilty! What happened to "innocent until proven otherwise"?

[@heidifredricks8641]

So basically, these families are deprived of justice bc the samples were mishandled. Awesome.

[@DiddlyD-xx2ih]

No one knew how to handle samples at the time. DNA wasn't a thing.

[@shelbybutler9714]

His wife justifying his behavior is disgusting, including the suicide reasoning. He was in his 30's and raped a 14 year old child- not a woman or a "young woman"- a CHILD. At the very least, he took explicit photos of a child. He was a dirt bag. Looking the other way and treating this lecher who joked about rape as though he were a model citizen, especially as a woman, is almost more reprehensible to me as his crime itself. Both of these people are evil in my book.

[@paulinegallagher7821]

She met him on a classified ad and married him a few months later. She didnt know him at all.

[@sminfluencer3860]

Terrible detectives work! In Clare’s case there was clearly contamination of the sample and an innocent person took his life! Evidently both cases are related and unsolved. As for the suspects blood found on Clare who drowned, I would say that was their killer. There was no other murders after he drowned and both murders had a signature, the cutting of their breast. May both victims rest in peace ❤

[@MariaWelsh-lu6fg]

You are right👍.

[@SweetSummerChild1967]

The suspect who drowned was in prison for the SA of someone else when Barbara (the girl from 1978) was killed. And I don't believe Kevin Brown was guilty. If he went to trial with that weak evidence- considering the potentially contaminated evidence, I believe he would've been cleared. Such a shame for both girls, their families, and the wrongly accused. At least his wife successfully sued the police dept.

[@smears6039]

Yeah that blew my mind. A convicted rapist’s blood was found and then offed himself THE DAY of the anniversary of it!! Serious misconduct, but the LA and San Diego police forces have always been a complete mess, some of the stuff they got away with in the 70’s and 80’s is a guide on what NOT to do in an investigation, the USA Police need a serious and complete reform, they hurt more people than they help, and terrorize the citizens that they “swear” to protect.

[@vincentferrigno2767]

How often do defense attorney's say there is zero proof my client ever was there.

[@futuremelina]

So shes defending her weird husband because he was a quiet good man? Lady he killed himself and left you alone! He didnt care about you in the end and left selfishly, and shes so slow that shes still defending him.

[@mariej6962]

I think he didn't.

[@b.abrackus6403]

She is totally in denial

[@LifeisANovel]

​@@mariej6962I agree.

[@LifeisANovel]

Lol you know you can get your point across without negative words. Tbh she's like most women who'll defend their husband especially since you guys get so emotional. Refer back to your comments lol. Either way. Both suspects are dead. Nothing can be done about that.

[@redxriceball]

He was a creep and a predator. She looked like a child, there is no way he didnt know she was underage. The wife is a fool.

[@HellaReckless]

Rebecca did the right thing. They didn’t prove her husband did it!!

[@bazoena]

You can see Barbara was Jim's soulmate.