"People who say it cannot be done should not interrupt those who are doing it."
@johnnyson74743 жыл бұрын
Oh they'll definitely interrupt. I remember them laughing at Elon and ridicule him that reusable rockets and electric cars are IMPOSSIBLE. Do you notice how you don't find them anywhere unless Elon comes up with a new project? It's because they looked stupid after making these claims as if they already know what they're talking about. They are the same people that doubted the impossible technologies that we have today. They even go as far as to stop these visionaries from achieving the impossible because they don't want to get proven wrong. These people are literally the embodiment of the "all talk no action'' type. So the only people they love to criticize or put down are the "less talk more action" types. It's a pattern within itself it is not hard to miss how others behave in such a way. Perhaps it's just human nature and it tends to repeat itself. Or maybe because of their upbringing that made them that way that if something is impossible thou shall not pursue.
@aceyage3 жыл бұрын
@@johnnyson7474 Neither e-cars, nor reusable rockets were considered impossible. For anyone knowing a bit of science, Elon Musk is a little boy playing around. Guy's a con man and sociopath.
@johnnyson74743 жыл бұрын
@@pneumantic6297 unfortunate for NASA's engineers to not believe this was possible but good thing someone made it happened while getting laughed at by NASA's engineers
@shukrantpatil3 жыл бұрын
So please explain as per why is has NASA paired up with space X for several space projects till date ?
@hassanjacobs75063 жыл бұрын
@@aceyage You know him? And what is the con he is performing?
@Semmster3 жыл бұрын
Everything is impossible until someone does it.
@blackjack21433 жыл бұрын
Damn straight
@CountryLifestyle20233 жыл бұрын
@Michał Bryza If you tell Elon Musk it's impossible than he will do it ! Lol 🤣🤣. Hold my beer I gotta do another impossible thing lol. This guy is single handedly colonizing Mars and trying to save our planet. I would not doubt Elon.
@babyrapjesus3 жыл бұрын
Love is not the seed of evil, neither is the love for power and fame, nor greed, imo it creates mental conditioning. Oppression and lies are the same in my eyes because your lies oppress someone's conception and perception of reality with any lie and there's no telling how much damage it can cause across time it's self. Remember it's Together not To-Get-Her I don't want a wall of texts so don't even get me started on my conecpt of opressive mindsets
@Singularity20603 жыл бұрын
What about living forever? You can never prove it bec UNTIL xD
@CountryLifestyle20233 жыл бұрын
@@Singularity2060 says you.
@Radioposting3 жыл бұрын
"We will _NEVER_ be able to achieve heavier than air flying machines."
@MadLabZ3 жыл бұрын
Everyone tells me that man cant travel at the speed of light BUT that is untrue, if humanity survives into the digital consciousness age (SOONER THAN LATER) we will be able to transmit our consciousness our "mind" into space as a radio transmission to a receiving host or infrastructure like the tesla bot. leaving earth becomes almost entirely free with the added bonus of no loss of life/avatar, no pollution . THIS WILL HAPPEN IF SOCIATY STAYS GLUED TOGETHER!!!!
@dannygjk3 жыл бұрын
@@JosephSilv4 They are both virtually the same thing.
@satoshinakamoto72533 жыл бұрын
its been done before by braingate and those compaines in 2008, its vey possible
@MadLabZ3 жыл бұрын
your edit tho lol, im assuming you came to the same conclusion that the speed of light and the speed of a radio transmission both travel at 186000MPS ;) never the less 'IF" we keep progressing at any level we can only assume this is a possible future scenario, I mean come on if someone like me can think this up in 2021 what will be going on in 50-100 years from now. we will always have uphill challenges as humanity but things will evolve regardless. Maybe our level of tech already supports receiving some other type of foreign digital consciousness and its already working with Elon's toys (automated factory's acting as an extension and bridge per say) just waiting for the right moment.....everyone thinks little green men will come running out of a metal trash can but do you really think this is how an advanced being would travel or communicate through the cosmos...I think not its just not efficient and sounds insulting to all other intellectual life ?
@cedriceric97303 жыл бұрын
But at least birds could do it so we had hope but hacking a brain dear , 🤣 NO.
@NoXic883 жыл бұрын
A big thank you from millions of people, to Dr. Miguel Nicolelis! And many wishes of future success to Neuralink! We love you
@amt59113 жыл бұрын
23:55 So he says he's not convinced Neuralink is even real, then provides no evidence to back his accusation except for "it can't happen" & "it's against the laws of physics" but then gives no further explanation. He's honestly seems jealous more than anything.
@AllYouWantAndMore3 жыл бұрын
He seems to be confusing advancements with invention. Just because a new electric vehicle is not that different than an old electric vehicle, doesn't mean it is not a novel approach and a significant advancement.
@Me__Myself__and__I3 жыл бұрын
Yeah, for being so supposedly intelligent Nicolelis is showing himself to be rather short sighted, egotistical and dumb.
@robynburrows3 жыл бұрын
@@brilliantly_me All of our energy needs and much more can be solved with solar, wind, and energy storage / batteries (such as Tesla mega packs). We’re just not there today. It will take a major shift (which I think is coming) to move away from our fossil fuel infrastructure, but if we don’t, well why even wake up in the morning, because we’re all f’d.
@liamhackett5133 жыл бұрын
The hyper loop. Really bright idea that one. He will say and do anything because the limelight props up the inflated stock value of tesla
@Myrddnn3 жыл бұрын
@@liamhackett513 LOL. Six different companies took the public domain idea and are today working on hyperlinks. Even China has plans to build one. You don't sound smart when you say things like that.
@liamhackett5133 жыл бұрын
@@Myrddnn boring multiple layers of tunnels for fleets of electric cars to whizz around in. Really fcking bright idea.
@Jevaughn3 жыл бұрын
Strong "Old Man Yelling From Porch" vibes. So much saltiness coming off the screen from Nicolelis, my blood pressure spiked. In all seriousness, there are several disqualifying issues here. First is how he plainly mischaracterizes Elon's statements six ways to Sunday. Miguel is also acting like it's Musk who's doing the work, rather than literally a host of ambitious younger people in the field, some of whom no doubt idolize Nicolelis. Maybe even some who were trained by him? And let's not even go in on him making hard statements on what is and isn't and will and won't ever be possible. As per usual, the *results* produced by the *army of geniuses* led by Elon - who guide Elon on what is doable as he in turn guides them on what is possible - will speak for itself as time goes on.
@Jevaughn3 жыл бұрын
@@gamerfortynine Exactly. Neuralink is carrying the state of the art forward and bringing in cross-disciplinary collaboration that other labs couldn't manage but that Elon with his umbrella of resources can. Nobody's promising uploaded minds within the decade or whatever. Neuralink publishes papers too - their advances will help humanity figure out exactly how much is doable and how to do it decades faster than otherwise. Throwing shade is counterproductive.
@Unityframe3 жыл бұрын
lol he is so salty he isn't getting credit. He needs to relax and keep researching and his time for the news headline will come
@Me__Myself__and__I3 жыл бұрын
@@Jevaughn Small minded people throw shade when they see others accomplish what they could not. Nicolelis may be smart in some ways, but that doesn't mean he isn't short sighted and stupid in others. Anyone taking a hard stance that technology will NEVER be capable of doing something that is allowed by physics is guaranteed to be proven wrong (eventually). This pattern of technology has been repeated so many times that anyone who can't see it is an idiot. Elon understands this pattern of technology progress far better than most and he has learned to optimize for it and we can all see the successful outcomes at Tesla and SpaceX as a result.
@gumstuckinmypocket3 жыл бұрын
The speed at which private tech companies move these days is light years faster than the snail that is academia. The ol' salty prof is seeing 30 years of budget and time constrained university research eclipsed by private progress, apparently eclipsed by orders of magnitude. Imagine the things ol' saltsman Nicolelis could do with Neuralink resources and development speed. (They are hiring... Nicolelis... and the boss might laugh off the insults.)
@Me__Myself__and__I3 жыл бұрын
@@gumstuckinmypocket A lot of people used to the snails pace and low expectations of academia can't adapt to or survive in the cooperate world. And Elon's has higher expectations than most. There have been staff who came from academia who dropped out of Neuralink, likely for these reasons. Nicolelis would never be able to cope with having to achieve measurable results in short periods of time.
@ressque3 жыл бұрын
The fact that Nicolelis brings up "patents" tells you absolutely everything you need to know about this situation and his commentary henceforth. SMDH...
@null2523 жыл бұрын
Yeah, pretty embarrassing.
@trinityastial51613 жыл бұрын
He honestly sounds like a jealous ass rich kid who can’t get past a level and gets pissed off that someone else can. He’s probably stumped and can’t proceed further with his ideas and so his only retort is to bring up patents and talking bad about Elon and neuro
@Paulctan3 жыл бұрын
@@trinityastial5161 Yes!! I think you hit upon the correct reason. He took his BMI research as far as *HE* could go and is now stuck there, so therefor it must be impossible by the laws of physics!
@latenerd24413 жыл бұрын
LOL apparently Him and his Uni have patents on the whole BMI concept when it's legally impossible to patent a concept. He might be a pioneer but he also full of shit rn
@brednbudr24063 жыл бұрын
Exactly. Just made it abundantly clear where he's trying to steer this.
@Weezer0229 ай бұрын
Lot of the comments talking crap about Nicolelis without any research on the guy whatsoever. He is a true neurologist with a post PHD who achieved remarkable things in the field of neuroscience and a true expert with 5+ decades of career in academia. While Elon Musk is just a billionaire who wants to achieve great things and leave a legacy but is not knowledgeable technically speaking in any of the fields of the companies he own. Nicolelis dedicated his life to figuring out how to make Parkinson’s disease and damaged medula patients to recover their mobility through technology and brain integration so he is more than qualified to speak on the subject. Also he strongly believes that we should not limit our brains to artificial intelligence as it is nothing but data from the past, and our brains are more complex than that.
@mysterynewsbrasil Жыл бұрын
Before you defend Elon's """genius""", remember that Nicolelis is the guy who actually came up with all that tech, Neuralink founders were his students, and Musk is only a marketer.
@gaborszollosy21533 жыл бұрын
If someone starts his criticism with insulting that's a huge red flag. See "Elon Musk barely knows where the brain is". The fact that Neuralink's device can access the brain through many more channels and also that deep learning techniques and computing capacity exploded in the recent years might mean that Neuralink can achieve new level of quality in brain/machine interfacing. Elon Musk's team also have a strong product centered approach.
@Me__Myself__and__I3 жыл бұрын
Did you catch his mention of patents? Nicolelis is an ineffectual old man yelling off his porch that he wants credit now that someone else is actually making tremendous progress.
@MadLabZ3 жыл бұрын
That old man's just butthurt because for his entire lifetime he's only been able to work with a fraction of the bandwith that musk is playing around with so yeah he probably feels a little pissed about that🤣 if they compete against each other or if they join forces either way it's a win for the team✌😎✌
@FilipCordas3 жыл бұрын
@@MadLabZ Neuralink products don't work they publish little to nothing so there really isn't a way to determine if anything they publish in their marketing material is actually working. Musk does this all the time like when he made Tesla bail out his failed Solar City company. Elon is extremely good at one thing and one thing only, getting political government funding. Even Tesla is only making money due to complicated emission credits they get from other car companies. Also his factories are almost completely financed by the government if they where actually going out of Tesla the company would never be profitable.
@MadLabZ3 жыл бұрын
@@FilipCordas that's one brutal pill I refuse to swallow however I will be unbiased about the situation and say that since Max left I'm sure they are expected to take a massive hit and what a prime-time for a disgruntled old head to chime in about something he felt like he should have the spotlight on long ago and please don't play stupid we all know the Elon Musk is not the single-handed scientist for every single business that he procuress or develops he is a man that knows what he wants and goes for it why waste time developing something that someone else has already developed you take that developed research and build upon that speeding up progression even more also if he doesn't do it someone will this is not some sci-fi far-fetched story facts show that neuralink works along with many other BMI teams around the world
@thebgEntertainment13 жыл бұрын
@@FilipCordas Stop watching Thunderf00t and go buy some TSLA stock
@Agrestic3 жыл бұрын
Any scientist that claims an advancement is an 'impossibility' has forsaken the point of the scientific process.
@blinded65023 жыл бұрын
Holy hell, you're absolutely right
@carolynm84213 жыл бұрын
Exactly. To say that "Elon Musk doesn't even know where the brain is." He's clearly annoyed that someone else is claiming they can do something he can't and not giving him credit for his work in the space.
@MotorcycleRebuilds3 жыл бұрын
@@carolynm8421 he's threatened by Elon and his patents show that.
@btuttle82 жыл бұрын
@@carolynm8421 Basic mature arguing, never use personal insults on the other party if you want to be taken seriously
@sprytnychomik2 жыл бұрын
@@btuttle8 Then Elon shouldn't be taken seriously.
@fredbloggs59023 жыл бұрын
“When a distinguished but elderly scientist states that something is possible, he is almost certainly right. When he states that something is impossible, he is very probably wrong”. - Arthur C. Clarke (First Law).
@edwardmorpeth59883 жыл бұрын
Everything is impossible until someone achieves it.
@turtleninja40323 жыл бұрын
So that means everything is achievable ?
@theDubleD3 жыл бұрын
@@turtleninja4032if you can dream it, you can make it!! I've been a space pilot in VR and am extremely grateful for the times we live in, even though everything's horse shit at the same time.
@Jack-The-Gamer-3 жыл бұрын
@@turtleninja4032 as long as you aren’t breaking the laws of physics, yes. You have to remember that, it it’s core, the world is just a cluster of atoms. Once we start manufacturing on the atomic scale, that’s more or less the end game. Atomic scale manufacturing and a complete understanding of consciousness and the human brain are the two big components to immortality, tbh.
@adamrak75603 жыл бұрын
@@Jack-The-Gamer- two big components in a horrifying permanent distopy too, if we mess it up.
@rubenvalencia79592 жыл бұрын
The establishment has always been wrong about Elon Musk. Never a good bet.
@brandoncampbell97943 жыл бұрын
They also said he'd never get to space and would never get a car on the road. Who's laughing now.
@ConnoisseurOfExistence3 жыл бұрын
Nicolelis seems to be quite knowledgeable and intelligent person. However, his words about Neuralink and Elon seem to be rather based on emotion. Also, it's not very smart to bet against what technology can achieve eventually. People discuss way more impossible things than this - superluminal spaceship engines (warp drives), for example. Serious designs for such have been theoretically proposed by professional scientists. I think that full scale brain-machine interfaces are possible and will be achieved in under 10 years from now.
@gr1f1th3 жыл бұрын
I agree. Nicolelis is approching this from his lab. Elon has a Ai supercomputer going online for tesla that he will lend processing to Neuralink this will allow insane advancements that will interpret and decode the signals coming out of our brain and the stimuli as input. that alone will gain hung advancements.... BUt look over there it's a Tesla Robot! Now we can tie that to give amputee's replacement limbs.... Adding simple sensor that then go to nuralink to tell the brain "what" the limb is touching or "how hard" the grip is. Mind bending advancements.
@MadLabZ3 жыл бұрын
imagination is creation, look at your computer or cell phone and think to yourself how many ideas, imagination and people did it take to create your device ? probably thousands of parts and pieces each part had to be dreamed up, imagined, and then created....almost like a symphony of minds and creation all leading up to well i cant tell you the ending and that ok :)
@lamjay66563 жыл бұрын
Yeah some of Elon’s aspirations with neuralink seem far fetch, especially for our current level of knowledge on the brain and consciousness. But to totally disregard any achievement of neuralink easily makes him appear biased, emotional or have a hidden agenda.
@Abhishek-ip7zb3 жыл бұрын
I really hope it'll be available to everyone in 10 years with amazing features 🧡🙏
@slartibartfast79213 жыл бұрын
Nicely said…. And encouraging timeline, although I’m a little more conservative
@slim11003 жыл бұрын
It’s like watching people arguing about the first flight and the types of planes that developed.. each believed theirs was the answer. I think Elon is going about this the right way by enticing the smartest people to work on the project and putting it the required resources. Overall they will end up with the passenger liner while others have a very focused F22 or a single prop bush plane.
@satoshinakamoto72533 жыл бұрын
its been done before by braingate and those compaines in 2008, its vey possible
@ThreepwoodFan3 жыл бұрын
@@adrianaadnan9958 dude what... Women not liking their babies or not liking anyone beside them is a thing but that's a different story. Technology will advance if we want it or not. It will be more and more like a separate entity. We have to merge with it or else we are doomed. You can't stop the progress now.
@MichaelGreenLagos3 жыл бұрын
Yes a lot like Thomas Edison
@remo273 жыл бұрын
@@adrianaadnan9958 Elons relationship with his mother is good. She apparently raised a person who cares very much about the world as whole, and by the way, has a shit ton of friends. I don't get what you are going on about.
@dstr13 жыл бұрын
@@adrianaadnan9958 Try inductive reasoning with the same topic and produce the results.
@fredbloggs59023 жыл бұрын
It’s worth reviewing what we know: It has 1,024 channels of output. It is completely sealed. It is fitted by robot. The AI software learns to correctly interpret the signals within hours. The first versions will probably cost $20k - $50k. Is there anybody else in the world doing anything remotely close to this?
@tsujan39843 жыл бұрын
I wish more company and scientist worked on something like this and to this extend. Even if it's wishful promise (the timeline) it's still better than what we have now. Wouldn't you say? I really don't wanna fan boy but It's not the person I am fascinated with, it's the seemingly plausible ideas that he brings to my attention that no one else does, whether it be fully automatic electric car, Space travel or merging with AI.
@MadLabZ3 жыл бұрын
I love that neuralink is moving progressively but I can assure you there are a vast ocean of other equally interesting ways to interface with the mind using sound frequencies and different Optical pattern sequences something also think about how a Tesla car perceives the world around itself we are basically just an advanced version of that so I can deduce Humanity down to just a fancy sensor for the collective consciousness cause😎sorry its happy hour for me so ViBN to the future.
@stephenevans-2paradox7673 жыл бұрын
Surely, the people saying it will be impossible haven’t ever made progress trying it like the folks achieving small victories this far.
@adamrak75603 жыл бұрын
I heard that some university labs have something similar. But they do not have enough funding for robotically placing the electrodes. So they have much less (working) electrodes. Most of the work Neuralink does is trying to turn the research which was already done, into a working product. They do some truly original research too, but relatively little, so they do not want to publish. Their implementation details are basically business secrets.
@MadLabZ3 жыл бұрын
@@adamrak7560 well considering they have a non-invasive and invasive version I would imagine it in the future something like starlink would be able to read your brain waves with a proper calibration and improper equipment kind of creepy to think about😎
@ofconsciousness3 жыл бұрын
The moment he said "download your brain to a CD"...wow. So you don't just totally lie about what Elon said, you make the lie blatant by referencing a piece of hardware that hasn't been in use since I was a small child. It's really hard to take him seriously. Would have felt really different if he praised Neuralink's accomplishments and took the opportunity to brag about the groundwork his research laid. I think he may have gotten more popularity that way.
@joshlewis5752 жыл бұрын
He as someone who is honestly looking out for humanity, unlike musk, he don't give a shit about popularity. He's pissed that he has to scratch and claw for every penny he gets for his provable research. While musk gets handed 100s of millions because people think he's Tony stark
@amyshoemaker57702 жыл бұрын
This brain scientist is not looking for popularity He is trying to warn people against this Neurolink insanity. But of course it's up to the people if they want to be turned into zombies cyborgs
@thefoundingtitanerenyeager23452 жыл бұрын
Facts I don’t think Elon ever stated that you could download your brain into a computer much less a CD.
@PhilfreezeCH2 жыл бұрын
I am pretty sure the reason he used a CD in this case is to show just how insanely limited current storage technology is compared to our brain. It is estimated that our brain has a storage capacity in the petabyte range but that would likely not be enough since it takes likely more information to describe the stored information and the way it is stored, than to just store the information itself (you need the first one to be able to use the second one though). Even if we assume the absolut lowest end one petabyte. The absolut maximum per-drive storage capacity at the moment is 100GB, you would need at least 10 of them (probably more to have some redundancy) but each costs 40‘000$, so that is not exactly feasible. Currently the price per TB of hard drive storage is roughly 15-20$, lets use 15$. That means it still costs 15‘000$ without any redundancy to store the smallest assumption of what our brain is capable of.
@ralphylaure25272 жыл бұрын
Maybe we should worry about knowing much more about the nature and dynamics of proteins, enzymes, DNA first, at the molecular and macro levels so we can handle Failures and Uncertainties
@ptu19693 жыл бұрын
I think this is another example of the establishment's common response after being challenged. First deny, then ridicule, finally acceptance.
@Lesminster3 жыл бұрын
If some elderly and distinguished scientist says something is possible he's most likely right. When he says something is not possible he's most likely wrong.
@Poxenium3 жыл бұрын
couldn't have said it better 👍
@Pyriphlegeton3 жыл бұрын
This is the first of Arthur C. Clarke's "Three Laws": 1. When a distinguished but elderly scientist states that something is possible, he is almost certainly right. When he states that something is impossible, he is very probably wrong. 2. The only way of discovering the limits of the possible is to venture a little way past them into the impossible. 3. Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.
@Me__Myself__and__I3 жыл бұрын
Nailed it.
@Me__Myself__and__I3 жыл бұрын
@@PyriphlegetonI love Clarke's work, how have I not heard of those before? #1 is absolutely correct here.
@ibcavid3 жыл бұрын
We don't really understand the situation, for example there are statements in mathematics that have been proven to be neither provable or disprovable. It doesnt mean that it is just very difficult to prove, but quite litterally impossible. I dont know if thats the case here but i am pretty sure it is
@siagrim7013 жыл бұрын
yeah...unfortunately this "expert" sounds like his knowledge/understanding has long since stagnated and he is no longer open to what is possible with current technology. you see it all the time, pioneers who just don't keep themselves open to the new just stagnate in the old and become irrelevant. this guy is on his way and adds being jealous on top of this. all of this is especially noticeable in that zoom call with his students via his tone and dismissiveness. its kind of sad.
@marionogueiraramos94883 жыл бұрын
yes, he should be cheering Neuralink for making heavy investments to give his scientific discoveries practical applications
@Me__Myself__and__I3 жыл бұрын
Nicolelis recently retired. So he's just a curmudgeonly old scientist yelling from the porch of his retirement home. He didn't accomplish all that much for his many decades of work and he is now clearly jealous of others who will accomplish much more in much less time. Nicolelis is setting the tone for how he will be remembered, which will likely be poorly when remembered at all 20+ years from now.
@MuitoDaora3 жыл бұрын
@@Me__Myself__and__I "He didn't accomplish all that much for his many decades of work". Nicolelis is THE name in the field. Neuralink is essentially based in his discoveries. But yeah he should be cherishing and not dismissing which is sad.
@fabiosilva96373 жыл бұрын
@@Me__Myself__and__I lmao... You just embarrassed yourself in this comment. Delete it before it's too late.
@Me__Myself__and__I3 жыл бұрын
@@MuitoDaora Its hard not to have a negative opinion of the man considering the statements he has been making. He comes off as petty and jealous.
@djmir43 жыл бұрын
Very smart people who dedicate themselves to a specific field of work often narrow their views of what is possible for good reasons. Creativity and innovation requires out of the box thinking. Both are useful tools at the right time.
@FuncaliciousFeet2 жыл бұрын
very well said
@philad20792 жыл бұрын
And very smart people drop that idea if necessary. Amazon sells a lot of things and does a lot of work things. It focus is selling “economy of scale” which makes it not have a focus as it sells and does variety. The same applies to Google.
@b-chu97472 жыл бұрын
Elon is a clown and neuralink is a SCAM like everything he does. Go back to school.
@ouimetco2 жыл бұрын
It is almost impossible to argue with this comment. Literally.
@daleevans32503 жыл бұрын
In the summer of 1954, I told my Fatherinlaw that we were going to the Moon and was politely told that I was crazy. It took 15 more years but we did it.
@angelcordero7173 жыл бұрын
Experts also say, landing a rocket is impossible, or a car that runs on batteries, I CAN CONTINUE THE LIST but won’t!
@d.c.monday41533 жыл бұрын
So Neuralink is impossible? Good! That means Elon will find a way of doing it!! He has done this with everything he has tried and this will be no exception.
@angeldna25663 жыл бұрын
Musky is into technocracy like his granddaddy. I don't know how you feel about technology ruling all but I don't much care for the idea. Especially if it's 'mandated' (lol) for everyone to integrate technology into them & their children's bodies.
@vladimirirkhin3 жыл бұрын
@@angeldna2566 no one said anything about mandate or anything being mandatory...
@lennysmileyface3 жыл бұрын
How's that hyperloop going?
@dislike__button3 жыл бұрын
One thing I learned in life is to never bet against Elon Musk.
@vladimirirkhin3 жыл бұрын
@@dislike__button and how to recommend videos from a decade ago
@neovi64243 жыл бұрын
Science is cool but engineers are the ones who really end up driving progress and changing the world.
@Giga_Chad1AD3 жыл бұрын
@@MM-nx8dt I think he might be talking about scientists but scientists and engineers are literally the same.
@satoshinakamoto72533 жыл бұрын
its been done before by braingate and those compaines in 2008, its vey possible
@thebgEntertainment13 жыл бұрын
@@Giga_Chad1AD No engineers make stuff, scientist ussually use that stuff to investigate further
@crubs833 жыл бұрын
Scientists discover knowledge. Engineer take that knowledge and make use of it. Scientists take the things that engineers make to help them discover more, and so the cycle continues.
@pabrodi3 жыл бұрын
@@MM-nx8dt If we depended exclusively on scientific theories, we wouldn't have bicycles or airplanes, as we don't have a solid physics that explains balance or lift.
@futuroptimist3 жыл бұрын
I think an important thing to keep in mind is that Neuralink is working on operationalizing former lab research on a large scale, much like how Tesla is utilizing machine learning state of the art in its FSD stack. Like you mentioned, Neuralink is absolutely not denying that its work builds on prior art, so I definitely am not convinced by the “copycat” argument.
@NeuraPod3 жыл бұрын
Great point Futuroptimist.
@feonor262 жыл бұрын
No, absolutely not. The former heads of Neuralink were doing something sensible with it as they wanted to help people with prosthesis etc. Then came Elon who had watched too many sci-fi movies and promised you could download knowledge and skills to your brain like they do in The Matrix and he also promised you could upload your brain into a computer. I mean COME ON!!! Not ONE fucking critical question from ANY journalist ANYWHERE?!? Jesus fucking Christ people, are you that gullible?!
@dubeme.30143 жыл бұрын
Now that experts are saying that it definitely won’t work, I’m even more sure that the company will be successful.
@luigeribeiro3 ай бұрын
"curing mental ilness with a chip implanted in your brain" that's one of their claims, which are pseudocience, only to get more money from VC. Neuralink is taking steps to become Theranos 2.0.
@joshuacothran31343 жыл бұрын
Imagine what he said about reusable rockets that land themselves lol
@sprytnychomik2 жыл бұрын
Not a new concept and vertical landing was done before.
@cosmicaug9 ай бұрын
@@sprytnychomik around a couple of decades earlier, IIRC.
@jamesharter49735 ай бұрын
The problem with landing a rocket is not crushing the bottom. That's what SpaceX achieved the no one could before.
@magnamic56143 жыл бұрын
Amazing coverage! I really appreciate this level of detail. Great job, Ryan and thanks. Edit: It’s quite possible that Elon’s claims could be wrong…BUT..it’s important that we try and fail to say whether or not a claim IS impossible. It’s our duty, as human beings, to learn from our past, fail in our present to secure our future.
@ofconsciousness3 жыл бұрын
Can we all just appreciate this comment? Thank you, @Magnamic !
@NeuraPod2 жыл бұрын
Thanks Magnamic
@raphaelnunes59253 жыл бұрын
I've already encountered multiple Brazilian researchers claiming that Elon's efforts are either fruitless or too complicated to be even presentable in simple terms as he has done multiple times already. As a Brazilian myself, I think that, because of how we where taught watching over the news is a great and indispensable way of staying informed, we tend to get stuck at the surface level information presented by sensationalistic news outlets. Also, I THINK that, because we live on a third world country, in terms of new and upcoming technologies, instead of acquiring new information and drawing hypothesis and assumptions based on our prior knowledge, we tend to draw immediate conclusions because of our overall lack of touch with technological advancements and marksmanship that we and our parents have failed to grasp (But I'll have to look that up ;P.)
@slartibartfast79213 жыл бұрын
Doesn’t it seem like whenever we introduce national pride into any equation, it just fucks things up royally?
@Franklin_Araujo3 жыл бұрын
Pra mim, o Musk não só vai conseguir como vai deixar a porteira aberta para os próximos que virão.
@Franklin_Araujo3 жыл бұрын
Se o Musk conseguir que uma pessoa incapacitada recupere pelo menos um pouco de suas capacidades, logo no início do projeto, já vai ser um grande avanço.
@fernandobernardo63243 жыл бұрын
Comentário sem nenhum sentido.
@raphaelnunes59253 жыл бұрын
@@fernandobernardo6324 Só trazendo algo à ser discutido e reforçando a ideia de que nada é garantido quando o tempo entra em questão. Eu meio que generalizei o pensamento crítico apresentado pelo Dr. Miguel Nicolelis pra todo brasileiro, mas sem concretizar nada, justamente pra gerar discussão e reforçar o meu segundo ponto de que o correto é não trazer conclusões baseadas em experiências passadas, mas sim, trazer hipóteses. Se o jeito sarcástico do Brasileiro de duvidar de toda nova tecnologia não tem nada a ver com que eu mencionei, eu adoraria que alguém trouxesse uma contra-proposta. Por exemplo, eu sei que eu tô errado principalmente por incluir o próprio Dr. Nicolelis, que trabalhou tantos anos nesse ramo fora do Brazil, na questão de que o nosso país está consideravelmente atrasado na busca por novas tecnologias, só queria ver se alguém iria me corrigir.
@jacobrobbins86063 жыл бұрын
As a supporter of Neuralink, its easy to get ruffled feathers here. But scientists like Nicolelis, despite the envy, are helping keep the big picture and history of the science in hand. It's good for any form of scientific advance to have constraints. Innovation should be guided by sound theory.
@remo273 жыл бұрын
If he has CONSTRUCTIVE criticism (that didn't come off as personal attacks) and well founded doubts (rather than "It can never be done!" without identifying a first principle of science as to why) you'd be right. Unfortunately if someone isn't paying him to trash Elon and Neuralink(Elon has lots of big enemies now for just about every one of his companies), he comes off as a bit jealous or resentful and thus he is overdoing his criticism at the minimum. Of course this means he becomes easy to dismiss entirely, which is unfortunate.
@risingredstone59493 жыл бұрын
where's hyperloop?
@aviralsinghal12743 жыл бұрын
Everything is possible as long as its not violating the laws of nature.
@zerosugarmatcha73483 жыл бұрын
It's like the first man invented the telescope, after he heard someone else built a telescope 1,000 times more powerful and arguing: there's nothing new to see, go home!
@shuriken48523 жыл бұрын
Dr. Nicolelis just seems salty because Elon made more progress in a year than he did in decades. His argument is like saying that because he invented the first pong console, that Elon inventing the Nintendo NES is the same, it is one thing to create an expansive low volume basic product, it is a whole different ball game to design a low cost complex mass-produceable one. Plus I would be curious to know how difficult it is to install their probes and if they can easily remove them with very little scarring or trauma like Neuralink.
@lamjay66563 жыл бұрын
Completely agree. Salty is the word. Or he has a hidden agenda.
@satoshinakamoto72533 жыл бұрын
its been done before by braingate and those compaines in 2008, its vey possible
@Me__Myself__and__I3 жыл бұрын
Nicolelis is a curmudgeonly old man yelling from the porch from his retirement home. The physical implant technology, being self contained and the surgery robot are things no one else has done. Those are the things that would be required for real-world useable adoption in many people. So for those things alone Neuralink is way ahead of everything else and inventing things no one else has done - but you don't see Nicolelis giving them ANY credit for any of that.
@shuriken48523 жыл бұрын
@@satoshinakamoto7253 If I remeber correctly, Braingate is using the Utah array with only 100 electrodes. Like I said Pong vs NES, not the same.
@russellpuff19963 жыл бұрын
"Reusable rockets are impossible." "Making compelling electric vehicles are impossible." I see a pattern here where Elon's companies do the impossible.
@congratz93962 жыл бұрын
Reminds me of the saying “once is a chance, twice is a coincidence and the third time is a pattern”. He’s definetly going for the pattern
@alireid58742 жыл бұрын
the pattern seems to be that they are all long cons. Time will tell...
@Ashakat422 жыл бұрын
Musk had nothing to do with developing the Tesla.
@jimgrant45782 жыл бұрын
The space shuttle was reusable since 1980. Not perfect, but reusable.
@rabokarabekian4092 жыл бұрын
They have not done the impossible, but only the unpredicted. DO you know what the word, "impossible" means?
@Knossos223 жыл бұрын
1 - "When a distinguished but elderly scientist states that something is possible, he is almost certainly right. When he states that something is impossible, he is very probably wrong." 2 - "The only way of discovering the limits of the possible is to venture a little way past them into the impossible." 3 - "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic." Arthur C. Clarke Three Laws of Prediction Hazards of Prophecy: The Failure of Imagination On the other hand, it is common to see entirely unqualified individuals assert what might be possible, for entirely unreasonable reasons... Most of the time, most people, have mostly no idea of what they are actually asserting. This was recently and very nicely encapsulated in this quotable: "We have a large segment of the country that has opted out of reality." ~ Steve Schmidt, former Republican Strategist
@lawrencefrost90632 жыл бұрын
Some smart people think too highly of themselves. This is a prime case.
@odderret3 жыл бұрын
Great video. Sour grapes from an old academic... I'm sure that he has done great work for BMI and neuroscience, but he's clearly bummed out that he is not in the spotlight. Petty
@burstmxde66173 жыл бұрын
Exactly my thoughts too..
@Radioposting3 жыл бұрын
Why do I get the feeling that Nicolelis is just a little bit butt-hurt?..
@proteslapower9303 жыл бұрын
Elon Musk will leave Nickelalice in the dark ages with his lab rats. Elon's mind works so fast he already knows how he's going to win and leave others look like they are standing still or walking backwards.
@slartibartfast79213 жыл бұрын
All the while doing it in a way that is more conscious of the sensitivity of the animals he works with. You can judge an individual on how they treat other life forms.
@stevencoardvenice3 жыл бұрын
Lol you Elon musk fangirls crack me up. Totally delusional, and believe in this fake persona he has created
@mathewk29613 жыл бұрын
What I was hearing throughout this video was Miguel Nicolelis saying me, me, me, I, I, I. And from Elon Musk came; We did such and such, and it took Us to develop this. Miguel Nicolelis is more concerned with being recognized in the annals of science as a great scientist than being a great scientist. Yes, he has made some great steps forward but how much more could he achieve if he wasn't so worried about someone else getting the glory. I once worked for a very successful business man when I was a kid. One day i asked him how he was able to be so successful? He replied, " I hire people who can do the job better than me.". This is also Elon Musk in a nutshell.
@ralphylaure25272 жыл бұрын
Yes it is..got to remember though for an Entrepreneur, their bragging rights are less their Ego than their bank accounts.
@macfou144 Жыл бұрын
14:31 compared a video call to neuralink is beyond stupid
@GHSxBloodrage3 жыл бұрын
miguel mixes up some things in his statements against elon or neuralink. I am surprised that he is against it instead of wanting to work on it ... I mean he would have the possibility to finish what he has started many years ago.
@josebonete3 жыл бұрын
Nicolelis has been doing this for over 30 years. Neuralink has been doing it for 5 years. In 5 years, Neuralink has caught up to Nicolelis and I might say passed Nicolelis up. The level of advancements in material science alone is beyond Nicolelis expertise. Give it another 5 years and Nicolelis will eat his words and be left in the dust of his old research. What if any, advancements Nicolelis has made in the last 5 years? None. It seems to me he is just trying to gain recognition for himself of old discoveries. As if no one credits him for it. Everyone does, me included. in 24 months it will become clear.
@luizfsborges3 жыл бұрын
Why in 24 months?
@josebonete3 жыл бұрын
@@luizfsborges Simply because Neuralink have passed Nicolelis' research. All of the technology that Neuralink is creating will be new. One of the areas that Nicolelis has not done is the use AI. Another area is the digitization of the signals. The brain is analog. This is where Nicolelis' research have stopped. He has no expertise in digitization. Another area is technology miniaturization. There are several companies building wafer fabs that can manufacture 3 nanometer chips. Another area is electrode technology. Currently, the electrodes goes straight in. Imagine how the oil industry have done. Early on oil drilling was basically straight down. Then they created an oil drill that can turn in different directions. Now imagine an articulating electrode that can avoid blood vessels and travel deeper to the optimum area of the brain. Another area is the number of nodes per electrode. Imagine having millions of nodes. Another area is .... well you get the picture.
@ibcavid3 жыл бұрын
I think you don't understand what science really is. Nicolelis has been researching and getting results for decades. What do you mean by saying Neuralink caught up to him . Nicolelis got results and published them, it means there is no need to re discover or re event things he published that's why it took Neuralink 5 years to "catch up" and litterally do not get almost nothing new.
@ibrab.51143 жыл бұрын
@@ibcavid Exactly
@happyguy87253 жыл бұрын
Someone just shit on their own reputation
@johnnyson74743 жыл бұрын
Car expert as well as engineers said the same thing for electric cars and reusable rockets. Now they are just eating their words. This new company will revolutionize how we communicate with technology. I am already calling it now.
@smkh28903 жыл бұрын
At 3:53, there is a patent held by Duke that " covers the WHOLE CONCEPT of BMI" Is there also one for the idea of "wheeled vehicles", or 'food cooking" ? And that this patent on a CONCEPT is held by a University is doubly ironic.
@edgallagher86753 жыл бұрын
7 years ago any rocket scientist would've told you landing a spent booster back on earth was impossible. 11 years ago any automotive engineer would've told you that making an electric car that can compete with an ICE car in price and performance was impossible. Impossible just means Elon Musk hasn't done it yet.
@LucasAndradeX3 жыл бұрын
Can you show any relevant scientist in the field that made those affirmations?
@TheFinalsTV3 жыл бұрын
This guy sounds like a crusty old man.. He's gotten credit where credit is due. Just seems like another entitled professor shooting innovation down to preserve his spotlight.
@tenzinpassang48123 жыл бұрын
I listened to Miguel's full interview on Ladan's podcast. He sounded lot like Bob Lutz during early Tesla stage. Although this might one of the biggest challeenge for Elon, I loved when Miguel said, "it's impossible to do what he's claiming becuase it's against the law of physics." A brain solution limited by physics, i'll take my chances with Elon. 😎😎😤😤
@ThisIS_Insane3 жыл бұрын
Remember, he has warnings for his own AI project, so he knows there is a certain amount of risk. Lots of it.
@waynerussell64013 жыл бұрын
Nickola and Daimler made similar assertions on the Tesla Semi. “If Tesla really delivers on this promise, we’ll obviously buy two trucks - one to take apart and one to test because if that happens, something has passed us by. But for now, the same laws of physics apply in Germany and in California.” Daimler’s head of trucks, Martin Daum
@markbons77662 жыл бұрын
interesting to watch such a distinguished neurologist inadvertently neuter his own argument
@adriandimitrijeski3 жыл бұрын
Guess what, once upon a time, astronomy 'experts' like buzz aldrin said that reusable rockets were impossible...
@AKeNeN2 жыл бұрын
You are overly charitable towards Musk and don’t comprehend the criticisms. You read Nicolelis’ warning of Duke’s patent over BMI, which precludes Neuralink from using the technology without a license, but you’re takeaway is that Nicolelis felt under appreciated. Musk has a pattern of misleading and manipulating people and speaking on matters for which he lacks any competence, but your defense requires you to take a handful of statements out of context from various other lies and adopt the most favorable interpretation.
@jasoncasey30053 жыл бұрын
Luckily I can completely ignore this title because I believe in Elon and he has a knack for doing the impossible
@karlenter23803 жыл бұрын
You mean trying the impossible. What has he done what looked impossible?
@jasoncasey30053 жыл бұрын
@@karlenter2380 huh so far the most glaring examples would be creating reusable rockets when everyone else said it was impossible. And creating an electric vehicle that is better in every metrics than ice vehicles. Of course I could go on about the boring company and it's electric boring machines that are already multiple times more efficient than anything else that was ever created on the planet. And then we go into transitioning the whole globe to renewable energies with mega battery packs and better solar. Would you like me to go on?
@saberpendragon89363 жыл бұрын
Experts are only good at telling you why something is impossible. - Peter Diamandis
@matheusv.deazevedovenicism68833 жыл бұрын
Awesome quote
@murbella73 жыл бұрын
I love hearing about these 'experts' They are the ones who said man could not fly. There are still some around today who believe that the earth is flat.
@fransmanlaparis48303 жыл бұрын
"the problem with smart people is that they often think they are way smarter than they really are" - Elon Musk I mean, Everyone seem to doubt Elon, from Neil Armstrong, who said that he didnt believe in SpaceX and Elon. Another expert in the field but wildly wrong. When Elon talked about the chance of POSSIBILITY of "inserting" information or knowledge to the brain he said that would need the help of an stronger AI to learn and understand your brain so good it could be possible. Please for the love of god, dont ever say "It is impossible, he is just dumb" when you compare to what AI could do, cause the fact is WE DON'T KNOW how much they could do. Don't be like Alibaba creator Jack Ma saying "Nothing can be smarter than humans" cause that is such ignorance...
@MellobotX3 жыл бұрын
I am cautiously optimistic about neuralink. I am an aeronautical engineer at the TU Delft and additionally had a cerebral infarction in 2008. ir. Nils Haeck M.Sc.
@fgabrieltomas3 жыл бұрын
Elon to the Professora: hold my beer
@therealjoeysalazar3 жыл бұрын
Hahaha! Every "expert" always doubts musk in the beginning.
@harrywoods97843 жыл бұрын
Just a thought, there are many Paths to the top of a mountain ,Elon it’s just on a different path 🤔
@gregbailey453 жыл бұрын
Followed same path to the point where it petered out...
@pavanpyda2 жыл бұрын
musk will introduce himself as founder of twitter in few years
@NeuraPod2 жыл бұрын
Lol, I don't think that's true.
@trevorcarriveau99593 жыл бұрын
Elon Musk fanboys and apologists are honestly just funny to me. Clearly the dude who made this video, as he said, really doesn't know anything about the brain or its function. Many of the claims made by Musk regarding this technology are honestly just laughable to anyone who understands anything about the brain. This isn't a question of whether or not we currently have the technology do download people's consciousness, it is a question of whether it is theoretically possible to do so, which it isn't. It simply cannot be done, and it will never be done. We don't live in a magical fantasy land or a sci-fi universe; we live in the real world. In the real world, your consciousness is not something that can ever be separated from your physical brain. The two things are completely inseparable.
@dkoo2323 жыл бұрын
It's nice to see opposing opinions to level out hype. Still optimistic though :)
@vladimirirkhin3 жыл бұрын
leveling out hype... I like the ring of it
@joshuasilva80573 жыл бұрын
Remember when nasa said landing and reusing rockets was impossible, then spaceX figured it out by using an app game to gather data.
@HalNordmann2 жыл бұрын
They never said it was impossible. After all, the Shuttle proves otherwise.
@goodtimesbadtimes52732 жыл бұрын
Ask Elizabeth holmes
@GrayFoxGamingHD3 жыл бұрын
They also had electric cars 100 years ago. That didnt stop Elon from making it better. Nicolelis is an expert in the field , but i also have a feeling his butthurt that someone else is having a go at anwsering questions his been unable to so far. I fully support them both and also the dream that this tech can make people in wheelchairs walk again.
@thefoundingtitanerenyeager23452 жыл бұрын
Sure we may have had electric cars for 100+ years in fact there was electric cars BEFORE gas, the reason why they weren’t implemented is that the battery technology was wayyyyyyyyyyyy worse and the range and speed for the first electric car were nothing compared to the first gas cars. So electric cars started selling I’m the 2000s because the battery technology was finally competitive to gas
@AniMageNeBy3 жыл бұрын
“People who say it cannot be done should not interrupt those who are doing it.”
@giannishofman8288 Жыл бұрын
He sounds like he is unsure never the less its the political ambition he seeks for funding to do as he wants
@FunkyMonkeyInTheTrunky3 жыл бұрын
Nothing is impossible
@martin1b3 жыл бұрын
It sounds like Nicolelis is so proud of himself, he's jealous someone may take his research and do something he couldn't do. While he should be proud of his accomplishments, it sounds like it's gotten the better of him. He needs to understand, unless the research goes into a usable product, it's useless. Musk is just the right man for this. He has a proven track record of taking what others think can't be done, assembles a team, and does it. I'm excited to see what Neuralink will do.
@HalNordmann3 жыл бұрын
Connecting a computer to a brain probably isn't technically impossible. However, we are still a long way away from that - and the way Neuralink approaches the problem really sounds weird even to somebody with limited knowledge in the field. It will turn out just like Theranos, mark my words.
@DomainAspect3 жыл бұрын
Probably.
@tres1552 жыл бұрын
except unlike Theranos we actually have a working model in a monkey, the monkey can control a game with its mind.
@michal_king4783 жыл бұрын
The issue with most of these critics is their inabillity to look into the future. Its not about whats available today but whats gonna be possible tomorrow. With enough research and dedication, theres not a thing that would be impossible.
@mariusgreeff31432 жыл бұрын
Do we need a brain expert to tell us this.
@sawyerw57153 жыл бұрын
I was part of the Moore's law advance of IC's as I worked in ECAD for decades. Nicolelis is like someone who invented the transistor, complaining about people moving on to IC's, large scale IC's(LSI), very large scale(VLSI), etc. Exponential advances tend find new capabilities and applications. I think he would be better served to admire Neurolink advances, and potentially even use their devices to advance his own research. Today's world tends to reward those who get involved in "controversy", because it gains clicks, so in a way he is just trying to maintain relevance as he is being passed technologically. He also probably wants to establish some ownership through existing patents. It comes across as sour grapes as the expression goes.
@ralphylaure25272 жыл бұрын
If that is all to be concerned about as the Human brain is being manipulated, ..kind of remind me of the days some would gladly ingests Elixir of highly radio-active potions for their proclaimed curative benefits
@kabzebrowski Жыл бұрын
His problem is not people doing research, it's: 1. doing research which is highly based or even the same experiments he did, while not giving him nor his predecessors the due credits; 2. turning science into a cheap show. Portuguese sources are way more indepth in these matters.
@fredbloggs59023 жыл бұрын
Given that Neuralink has already been demonstrated to have functions good enough to transform many people’s lives on a massive scale (even if it’s only spinal injuries, the sheer numbers are challenging, 290,000 in the US alone), attacking Elon seems unwise, if highly fashionable at the moment, this will not age well.
@vigneshkr70722 жыл бұрын
How an overhyped lobotomy help with nerve injuries? Or do you mean some movement aids controlled by this brain chip interphase.
@olfrud2 жыл бұрын
When have they demonstrated that? Any empirical data or do refer to their wishlist of things they want to do?
@fredbloggs59022 жыл бұрын
@@olfrud a chimp was able to play pong within a few hours. The device has 1024 channels and functions without wires penetrating the skin which is important to prevent infections. The video is on the company KZbin channel.
@neenabzamro37592 жыл бұрын
they also said electrical cars and retrieveable rockets are impossible but look where we’re at now.
@longiusaescius253711 ай бұрын
@neenabzamro3759 musk didn't make any of that
@neenabzamro375911 ай бұрын
@@longiusaescius2537 if it wasnt for musk it wouldve been in the books only
@longiusaescius253711 ай бұрын
@@neenabzamro3759 gigs copium
@unbreakableldorado77233 жыл бұрын
They said that about every single thing Elon was involved in. Zip2, X, PayPal (banks are gonna laugh at it), Tesla (it can never be profitable!!!), SpaceX (impossible to land a rocket), Hyperloop (there will never be a prototype), the boring company, Neuralink..
@b199er3 жыл бұрын
Even at the very least, for scientific research Neuralink will be revolutionary. Consider high resolution sampling of 4k-1M neurons in various regions all over the brain, this will enable mapping out on a more intimate level the functionality of all regions of the brain (well dependent on how far probes can be inserted). While we know generally how the motor and sensory cortices map to the body, it's unlikely this has been well documented in a 3D model of the brain, and unlikely that we have details of precisely how many neurons map to one's right index finger, and so on, is there a continuum kind of like unwrapping a 3D skin on to a 2D texture, does the exact position vary, and how does the calibration differ between brains of the same species. The same could be applied to the visual cortex/optic nerve, audio, smell, taste, emotion, cerebellum, and various mid-brain activity (to better understand how those components regulate the body). A lot is possible, and will really give us a better understanding of how the brain works at a more fundamental level. What makes up our visual cortex space, and could you add extra content i.e. widen the FOV or introduce an entirely new sense like temperature by stimulating some neurons with varying amounts proportional to the measured body temperature? They say the brain is very plastic (can adjust and adapt to different sensory & motor requirements), this could be very fascinating.
@SkepticalCaveman3 жыл бұрын
Elon is an optimist, optimists gets things done even if it takes longer than estimated. Pessimists don't get things done because they don't even try.
@toomanyaccounts2 жыл бұрын
Elon is a con artist
@kalebbruwer3 жыл бұрын
Elon's brilliance is not in coming up with new ideas, but in bringing them to market. People need to understand that that still has a lot of value
@TheKevphil2 жыл бұрын
Sounds like Steve Jobs.
@jtcoding64223 жыл бұрын
It might not be a new idea but I believe that Elon has brought the field to the light of the public. This will allow more to contribute and hopeful bring about advancements that otherwise would've taken many more years to achieve. I don't think Nicolelis' work will be over looked. We often study and learn of the pioneers in the field we research. Instead I'm certain his help would be useful in advancing the field further and possibly help Neuralink better scope what they plan to achieve.
@ralphylaure25272 жыл бұрын
What about clearly state what you plan to achieve to the world and remain strictly within a known and verified boundary. Remember, in no time this effort will be duplicated by other competent parties and hopefully ethics will not be lagging far behind and the interest of the general public will be protected.
@jtcoding64222 жыл бұрын
@@ralphylaure2527 I'm not necessarily sure what you mean by "state what you plan to achieve to the world" they have already stated what they wish to do with this technology. Also how is a field expected to advance when it is limited to "known and verified boundaries". Regardless, none of the experiments have really pushed the boundaries, all they have done so far is upgrade the tech that is being used in these experiments.
@tannereckmann54043 жыл бұрын
The question is not if it will work it already is working for playing pong and etc. The question is how long will it take to attain various different new capabilities. Each new capability requires more knowledge.
@JonathanCandor3 жыл бұрын
He sounds like he definitely knows what he's talking about but also he sounds like he is not using the cutting edge tech. Elon has access to the most advance tech in the world not only because of the money he has but also because he is a tech developer.
@grains4253 жыл бұрын
Reminds me of when Einstein was arguing against quantum physics.
@kex03 жыл бұрын
It's so painful to listen to this fossil.
@coultonharmon22663 жыл бұрын
The fact that he coupled his claim with an insult "he barely knows where it is" tells you all you need to know.
@RAILWAY_FILMS Жыл бұрын
it USED TO BE that when you searched for the fact that the neuralink probes are installed in monkeys, that they work great at first but they ALWAYS quit working after several months. all that effort and surgery for a TEMPORARY use never to be reused again
@Frank72364 Жыл бұрын
I bet you think Tesla will achieve Full Self Driving next year and that Tesla will sell 20 million cars /year someday, just because Elon Musk said so. Right? Btw, why did you put that photo of an asian guy in the bottom corner? Is that like watermark of yours? You put watermark on someone else’s content?
@breathtakingsamurai9813 жыл бұрын
This situation reminds me of like when scientists and engineers back in early 1900s published articles in newspapers on why it's impossible to build a flying machine because it's heavier than air...
@thefoundingtitanerenyeager23452 жыл бұрын
There’s a infamous newspaper released 5 days before the Wright brothers successful plane that says on the first page in big letters on the front page A flying machine will take 5-10 million years to create
@simonsn499611 ай бұрын
the theory of human flight being possible was already established by Otto v. Lilienthal when he flew 250m with his (ridiculous looking- google it) flight machine. Sadly he couldnt refute the articles because he sadly crashed and died
@ronnonyabizness52403 жыл бұрын
I recall in 1982 a group of young scientists were able to create an interface that allowed blind people to see through a video aperture. Another group were able to create an interface that allowed audio from a Mic to create sound for deaf people. Innovation comes from people doing the improbable, not impossible. Some scientists (people) cannot step outside of the box and therefore will never be innovators. They are still valuable contributors performing the repetative tasks required in a formula, however asking them to reach beyond their paradigm is like asking them to flap their arms and fly like a bird.
@chrisoverton96723 жыл бұрын
You probably remembered wrong as they are only now have had a successful case in that. Even with modern technology whose sole purpose is to restore vision, the ability to do so just isn't there. What we've been only been able to develop is to restore light and vague images/shapes and only to individuals who at one point went blind from eye problems, our brain isn't built to process the amount of information that a camera would require to bring back 20/20 vision or to even just be not legally blind. A lot of the issues which Musk overlooks talking about with Neurolink is a lot of the problems he's trying to convince people it would fix are issues that most of the time aren't even the fault of the brain. Deafness, Blindness, Addiction, Paralysis are all very much issues that can be local to your body or have nothing to do with the brain in most cases.
@s-man20232 жыл бұрын
I appreciated this video giving credence to Nicolelis and Elon/neuralink. For sure, old academics are skeptical of work being done outside the rich mahogany of the university meeting rooms. This is to be expected. Otherwise Nicolelis would have turned his concepts into his own Neura(insert key aspect to company name here). It is fascinating to see such complex problems carefully optimized and I hope it works medically, before it gets turned into a gaming platform.
@NeuraPod2 жыл бұрын
Thanks Sean.
@ralphylaure25272 жыл бұрын
Though I agree with the shortcomings of "Mahogany University" as a research and educational model for 21st-century problems, this is far more than about Nicolelis and Elon Musk: All brain-bearing creatures should have a voice in this endeavor...
@markbrix93853 жыл бұрын
The Musk fanboy cult in the comments section is crazy. They can't stand any kind of criticism...
@spqri33 жыл бұрын
The criticism is coming from a person that is declaring ownership of the concept of BCI. Seems that he goes out of his way to poison the public well. Maybe he wants to sue?
@lexlex443 жыл бұрын
""We will NEVER be able to achieve heavier than air flying machines." " That was a clown idea said by some people who obviously did not use their brains enough to realize that birds are heavier than air and still fly, this doesn't make Tesla's ideas less clownish and pointless.There were many bad ideas and inventions before the good ones kicked in.
@laurenthomas95743 жыл бұрын
In Elon’s words, “it’s already done.” 🥰
@BC.aNewSeason3 жыл бұрын
I think that Elon Musk's capabilities should never be underestimated. He sees things differently, develops visions, conducts analysis and takes effective progressive action. And over time he is proven to be successful.
@ditcher61463 жыл бұрын
You need watch thunder foot videos... Why elon is big con artist...
@morteza10243 жыл бұрын
In a nutshell, he's just sad because he thinks he's not getting enough credit. You decide whether that's true or not.
@peterhaywood41112 жыл бұрын
I would like to know specifically why, as Nicholelis claims, why the aims of Neuralink defy physics? I didn't hear any examples for this assertion.
@Weezer0229 ай бұрын
Because the brain is dependent on physical experiences and organic neuroplasticity to create INTELLIGENCE. A digital brain will NEVER be able to replicate an organic brain
@sathaniel_3 жыл бұрын
Ohh this video is so good, this is the best way to approach this topic and respond to Miguel Nicolei. I think this man is a denier and he is upset with the Neuralink team for stealing him protagonism. His work on this field was amazing and it's sad that he did not get the recognition he deserve, but it seems to me that he doesn't understand the Elon's influence on the public and media, no mention the incredible way Elon works and the achievements he has achieved with the teams of talented people that he bring together.