BROWN SAUCE TASTE COMPARISON | FOOD REVIEW | SHOUTOUTS

[@SuperLittleTyke]

Big Alert for Iceland customers over the age of 60! As of Tuesday 24 May, and every Tuesday thereafter, Iceland is giving people over 60 a 10% discount on all shopping with no minimum spend. Proof of age, such as a driving licence or senior bus or rail card will be required. So I'm going to start buying other groceries there, too. Iceland stock the basics like milk, butter and bread. The butter is the same price as at Tesco and Aldi, but 10% off makes Iceland the cheaper buy on Tuesdays. Let's see whether other supermarkets will follow suit with discounts for pensioners.

[@WhiteUnicorn82]

If I start paying myself the money that I pay into my pension, I'm a "pensioner". Thanks for direction, sir!

[@benjyharris1244]

Thank you`s kindly! (: i`l mention this to my parents.. I just got another 26 years to go.. (:

[@suenettleton2286]

That's good for pensioners to know

[@hopebgood]

Rishi Sunak will find a way to put a stop to this. Discounts for older people? Outrageous. Just in case....yeah I'm being sarky.

[@55billijay]

What a great move by Iceland. Will the greedy giants such as Morrisons etc follow suit, I would be very surprised

[@sarahstrong7174]

No added sugar usually means added artificial nasties.

[@chipnroll]

daddies for me because of the vinegar hit love it all comes down to people personal taste

[@WorldbreakerHulk1390]

I really like your vids. Straight up direct review / comparison from a regular guy. 👍

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

thanks 😊

[@johnancill7397]

HP sauce used to be made a few miles from where I live and what made it so nice was the water that was underneath the factory, they also made the daddy's sauce on the same site and next door to that was a brewery.

[@nigelh4617]

Good old HP Aston. The aroma of fruity and regular sauce used to waft across the Expressway on a warm day and make me hungry for a fry-up.

[@johnancill7397]

@@nigelh4617 you couldn't beat that smell and you could taste it

[@nealgrimes4382]

I don't think either of them are as good as they used to be both made in other countries and both have cheaped out on the ingredients

[@Nik2555]

Hammonds chop is really popular in barnsley. I got some to try cos I’ve moved to border of sheff and Barnsley, got one of them big bottles. It doesn’t have any turmeric in it more of a vinegary flavour, I Definately prefer hp

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Cheers pal 👍👍

[@alexandersimpson3638]

Stopped getting HP on principle, I’ve tried a few and if it ain’t got tamarind I don’t buy it.. Some have too much nutmeg and it spoils it for me.. Should be sweet, tangy and hack a little kick.. Bramwells is good for the price, a couple of shakes of Lea & Perkins into the bottle, then shake makes it very good indeed.. 👍

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Cheers pal

[@stewis]

Eating brown sauce off a spoon. The things you do so we don't have to 🤣🤣

[@margaretdifford194]

Always Daddies for me .. not sure how you stomach all these sauces, well done.

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

thanks

[@55billijay]

Got to be Hammond's chop sauce for me. Been having it since as far back as I can remember. Great with pie peas and chips. Cheers Gareth. Great video asper

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

thanks 😊

[@Simon-kv4vt]

Agreed.

[@stevewhitcher6719]

I had the skinny BBQ sauce it is low cal wasnt very nice as a condiment but as i dont like to waste food it was OK as an enhancement to homemade chilli con carne or savoury mince. I used to like Hamonds Chop sauce but havent seen it for Donkeys, where did you get it from?. I used to have HP every time for decades but stopped buying it when they moved the Factory from Aston to Poland! I like the lidl one as its complex but not that expensive. Now that its summer i must go to Aldi to try some of the foods you have shown us and see if they are different to Lidl. We go to the car boot in Guildford on a sunday and Aldi is in Guildford. Near me its Tesco, Lidl or sainsburys. When i worked in Nutfield Morrisions and iceland were on the way home. When i worked in Croydon it was Asda and Iceland. I think the supermarkets choose a location where there arent many supermarkets. So i would not worry about you not getting Lidl or Sainburys.

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

cheers Steve

[@gracetaylor1967]

I get mine from Morriston and I think asda might sell it too.

[@ab4113]

My favorite brown sauce is Hammonds Chop sauce, best by far i think, good yorkshire sauce from a Glasgow Boy

[@martynsharp4962]

Bramwells or chop for me. As you say we all have differing tastes.

[@DamonSlater]

Just like Heinz is the best for red sauce, HP is the best for brown sauce, and they always will be.

[@ianbennett1491]

Used to have Yorkshire Relish as a kid. It was lovely.

[@stewartgovan1672]

Hi Gareth thanks for another informative review. You're going to have to build a new cupboard to accommodate all those sauces. Lol. Looks like the, HP, Bramwells and Daddies were the best ones. God knows how you made it through that review mate, It was like brown sauce overload. Keep up the spot on work from Scotland.

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

cheers, i know im slowly getting moved into the garage lol

[@stewartgovan1672]

Haha. I can imagine you will be popular with your missus.

[@alanhughes5775]

love brown sauce with most things

[@roygawthorpe3395]

When I was in the UK Chop sauce was my favourite, here we can only get HP or M&S. they are both OK but I miss Hammond Chop.

[@JohnSmith-cj7ps]

Been eating brown sauce all my life eat it by the ton for over 70yrs Buy it in bulk im not on my own in this we still think daddies still got the edge followed by hp you can keep the rest! All of them!

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Stokes is amazing

[@johnnytasker1531]

Hi Gareth. Fab review- right up my street. That was quite a marathon tasting session. Good choice of your favourites, I'm going to treat myself to some Stokes. Thanks for this. 😋

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Hope you enjoy it!

[@johnnytasker1531]

@@BaldFoodieGuy Thanks man. 😋

[@maurice720]

Hp is my fav . I buy reggae sauce more now than I do brown sauce tho

[@brianmcneill1972]

the sauce you want to try is Gold Star Chip Shop Sauce in a lot of chippies in Scotland it's not salt and vinegar it's salt and sauce!

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

yes couldent get that sorry.

[@richardneale246]

Great Video Gareth. Thanks for the research and the info.

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Glad it was helpful!

[@donandrew9276]

Very dedicated, I could not taste so many different sauces one after another in such a short time

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Glad you liked it

[@ianmiller1879]

i done a test like you with hp and branwells on crumpets with butter, hp was 2.40 and branwells was 59 p, hp was just a bit better but not 4 times better ie the price, so branwells for me from now on buddy. so glad you done this matey.

[@margaretrobinson1670]

Great review Gareth, l love the chop sauce it’s got a lovely taste.😋👍

[@theprebuiltdave7423]

Tiptree brown sauce is the best hands down!

[@GreenoEats]

Looked like you were getting some serious Brown Sauce fatigue by the end there fella! I've had the Stokes, and it's great. Normally go for HP though.

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Good stuff

[@jshaw4757]

First civilian too get brown sauce fatigue I'm sure lol...Good job didn't have too finish the lot

[@johnroberts2331]

Hi, another great video. Next comparrison should be Mayo! I'm now thinking of buying Stokes sauce now!

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

so good John

[@georgeh5745]

Over a dozen different "daddies sauce!" Who'd have guessed that back in the day? Good stuff mate 👍

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

thanks 😊

If you haven't seen it you absolutely have to watch the movie Intermission with Colin Farrell or if you re-watch it now you'll now see it in a different light. *no spoilers*

[@angelaharvey2034]

I like the HP sauce, but I will try the M&S one too.

[@Arcadia61]

Grew up with HP sauce. To me, brown sauce IS HP. But willing to try Stokes, if I find it.

[@raytwigg6881]

Tried a variety over the years , not in 20 minutes. You are a star . Settled on HP .

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

haha cheers

[@MrJamiez]

I love brown sauce, on a sausage & bacon butty in the morning! Thanks for review.

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Any time!

[@KimTebrok]

ASDA, is OK. Next to HP which is possibly the supreme brown sauce. Might be wrong😩

[@Jonny_The_Organism]

HP has always been my favourite!… no ifs no buts!… but Skinny… I once thought about it, considered the label, then went straight for the HP!!

[@kevinhughes7565]

Where do you get the Stokes sauce . I've got the m&s and it's lovely on a sausage barm . Well done getting through all those sauces .

[@sparkymarky9883]

Hi there love the video good work nice to back on here after being Ill it nice to be back on here keep up the good work

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

hope you ok pal

[@sparkymarky9883]

@@BaldFoodieGuy better now than I was thank you for asking

[@malcolmhardwick4258]

The ultimte mighty Brown sauce test ! Done well ! Lucky for me I live in the netherlands and can get HP brown sauce at the local shop !

[@merc6154]

Great I absolutely love your channel Could you do a butter/margarine off, tea off, coffee off, mayo off, gravy off 😉

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

thanks yes will do thanks 😊

[@Steve10578]

Having watched the Tomato sauce comparison video, I predicted another sauce comparison video would follow. Looking forward to the BBQ sauce comparison next and maybe a mint and apple sauce to follow, LOL.

[@YTDumpsterBaby]

Daddies for bacon, HP for Beef and 5 star for battered or breaded fish.

[@karlos55555]

Branston Brown sauce is the best I've had but will definitely be trying that Smart Price one for value, cheers Gaz

[@davewhiteman8353]

I love brown sauce. The world has been waiting for this review!

[@janicecox1143]

I like Branston fruity brown sauce

[@TheCho-k4m]

You're a beast Gareth, doing the hard work so we don't have to! 💪😊😁 Great job fella!

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Thank you 🙌

[@benjyharris1244]

Wilkin & Sons Ltd Tiptree Brown Sauce is the best sauce money can buy, its £5 for 310g but its worth every penny.. (:

[@menopausalbarbie7467]

Thanks for another honest review 💜💜💜

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

You are so welcome! xx

[@rdfb2]

That was a challenge trying that lot for sure , Inmy cuboard its daddies first HP second as me mum always had it on the table , gone give the Bramwell's a go as you got try things and i do love me brown sauce cheers gaz .

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Cheers mate yes it certainly was. Cheers for watching pal 👍

[@liamh9814]

Daddies was the best once. Then they moved production to Holland and it went massively down hill.

[@missmaryhdream6560]

I love the chef brown sauce, 😋 delicious

[@filecore]

Great stuff. I do like the Stokes, but my favourite is the Wilkins/Tiptree brown sauce. It's very fruity and sweet, which is right up my street.

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Thanks for sharing!

[@cowgirl.4363]

Thanks for that, I was looking for a sweet one, sweetness wasn't mentioned in any of the sauces. I'll try it. Their tomato ketchup is nice too

[@r7coo]

Tiptree is amazing

[@tormentedsoul906]

You can’t beat a bit of brown sauce on y’breakfast barm,mmmm. Spot on vid 😆

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

absolutely yum 😋

[@lucifermorningstar4606]

Haven't tried the posh ones, but I do love the Aldi brown sauce though the HP is better. Next for an instant gravy off?

[@elizaann8495]

HP Fruitys my fav and OK Sauce { which Colmans the mustard maker now own and make}

[@ASH.......................1976]

Great review Gaz 👍 and quite funny at times ,I found myself doing the same facial expressions as you !😄

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

haha cheers

[@ASH.......................1976]

@@BaldFoodieGuy 😊👍

[@thebeermonsterreviews]

what do you think are best things to cook in air fryer i just got one bud

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

chips are good. Whole chicken cooks real good too, we did one last night. Frozen food with batter on them, Chicken nuggets, fish fingers etc.

[@janicedickinson2496]

Great review your comparison videos are fab xx

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Thanks so much! 😊 x

[@martinwarner1178]

108 years HP was made in Birmingham, then they moved production to Netherlands! So, I am searching for a alternative. Hence watching your excellent video. Thank you. Peace be unto you.

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Cheers Martin

[@darrengiles5456]

Can you tell me where you got the stokes brown sauce. Dazza g

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Amazon pal

[@darrengiles5456]

Cheers gas. Ordering now.

[@coreylee9028]

Good one again this gaz. Love the detail on price per gram. My fave is HP, Lewis’ fave is Stokes!

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

thanks Corey.

[@paulthurston2883]

HP for me all day long.

[@jeffreyhodge5564]

Zhammonds my favourite ,lovely on egg on fried bread.Yum

[@davmar5648]

Another great video Gareth. Stotes is my favourite as well. It was on offer so I tried it now it's svregular purchase for me. Like you state it is a full bodied sauce and pours easily with no shaking to pour necessary. It far outweighs HP for me as I think HP hits you hard so to speak. Stotes ketchup also pours easily and is packed with taste. Yes Its more expensive but you don't need much of it.

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

You're welcome 👍👍

[@darrenreynolds9462]

Another great review Gaz, well done for getting through all them sauces! I love brown sauce, and have recently purchased a bottle of Stokes, and I have to say, it's the best I have ever had and by some distance. So I use that for 'best' and HP for 'every day use' Sorry I missed the live on Friday, I was poorly. Cheers mate.

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

yes that Stokes is good Darren isnt it.

[@jj8995]

STOKES every time quality and class have you tried their tartar sauce it's excellent

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

No not had that one, yes it's cracking sauce

[@derbyjohn972]

Learnt some new word's 🤣🤣. Definitely try some new brown sauces 👍🏻👍🏻

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

enjoy John.

[@stevenmintandrews4859]

Cheers Gareth great review mate, I love the M&S one . Lovely with a sausage sarnie 👍🍻👍

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Oh definitely Steven, so good 🤤🤤👌👌

[@samhenwood5746]

Great honest review but HP only on a sausage sandwich 🥪🤗

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

thanks

[@DJDonnelly]

Can you compare different chocolate spreads? Anything from Nutella to supermarket own brands

[@321dunkduncan]

Brilliant video 😬 thanks as always ☺️

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

My pleasure!

[@tajjywajjyonionbhajji6198]

Eh up Gazza hows tha doin. Amazing video. I was showing my wife the HP sauce on the video. I used to love HP. It made really good suntan lotion. Only thing is it attracted flies. Just kidding. Dont they refer to Newcastle brown ale as brown sauce?

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

bit saucy this one haha

[@denisebell8422]

We always have hp Brown sauce yummy on beans on toast 😋😋

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Sounds great!

[@davidbell7688]

Hi. I am glad that you like the Stokes brown sauce. Actually, we buy Sainsburys own brand and like that but haven't tried Stokes . Have you done a mayonnaise taste off? We didn't think that we like mayonnaise until we tried the Stokes mayonnaise. We don't like any own brand, nor Heinz but we don't mind Hellman's. Funnily, Stokes contains olive oil which I don't like but it's nice in their Mayo. We don't have a high income but we push we the boat for Stokes so we will try their brown sauce too. Thanks.

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

yes good one that cheers

[@garyfearon5637]

Impressive collection. Great review gareth ✌

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Glad you enjoyed it

[@SausageFingers73]

Hammonds Chop sauce ws discontinued a couple of years ago, where did you find that?

[@darrell4328]

Brilliant 👍👍👍👍👍 HP Fruity is pure nostalgia

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

thanks 😊

[@gilgammesh1]

I forgot that HP Fruity even exists xD

[@sarahillingworth2718]

I like hp or daddies.. what do u do with other sauces when you've finished with them lol

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

cheers

[@thetezz0001]

Once again an excellent video mate

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Thanks again!

[@alberttatlock1541]

I always liked HP, but it got expensive so I tried a few other cheaper ones (Daddies, Tesco, Lichfield, Morrisons) and they ALL went straight in the bin, harsh and vinegary. So I went back to paying more for HP. After seeing this I might give Marks &Spencer a try, I tried their tomato sauce after seeing your video and it was good.

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

yes good one that

[@stevewhitcher6719]

If you have a lidl or an aldi near by try their own brand! I always used to buy HP and as you say the cheapers ones are harsher and more vinegary. I like the lidl one which is more complex and smoother and i would guess the aldi one would be the same. Alot of the aldi products i have had in the past are very similar to the lidl ones. Its just lidl are near me so i'm more familar with them.

[@EE12CSVT]

Try Aldi's. It's a more complrx flavour than HP. My favourite is Stoke's, but nobody here sells it, and it's expensive when I can find it.

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

I got my stokes off Amazon pal

[@EE12CSVT]

@@BaldFoodieGuy So I noticed. Interesting review, thanks.

[@jeffreyhodge5564]

Ps hp brown sauce in glass bottle they have a limited bottle run ,Big Ben I. Covered in Scaffolding while it’s under repair ,not many supermarkets sell hammonds ,a certain Bradford rebased retailer does ! My second favourite is Branson brown sauce ,

[@suenettleton2286]

The bramwells is aldi make we buy all the time . It was a bit saucey in your kitchen today (lol 😆 🤣). Great review as always 👍

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

haha always lol

[@peterbilt3385]

Glad you reviewed Hammonds Chop, but surprised you did not like it! Can I asked where you managed to get it for so cheap? I was discontinued in all tne supermarkets down here in Cornwall a few years ago. I used to be able to buy it from Morrisons. I have had to pay loads for it on Ebay. Online supermarket shopping sites said it was available for ages, but always showed out of stock. Definitely going to try Stokes though!

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

home bargains Peter

[@jameskrell4392]

M&S or Waitrose for me, nothing to do with snob value, they don't contain glucose-fructose. I was suprised to see that HP does, its bad for your joints amongst other things. Stokes is alright too but around £1.50 dearer. I treat myself occasionally.

[@Poppy-sf1uj]

Trying all them brown sauces,your funny you gaz 😂😂

[@whodeanimania712]

do you know what "HP" stands for in hp sauce ????

[@bedfordshiremodeller4491]

Houses of paralment hence why it's called HP... i think as Big Ben is nxtdoor to that building

[@neilsmith1239]

not sure if u can get gold star brown sause in england missed that one lol thats the chippy brown sause lol nice with a splash of pickele vinegar thru it tho lol great video

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

not seen that one Neil.

[@veryangry4679]

You made me laugh when that skinny sauce come out lmao

[@poppypalais3108]

Great review. The Daddies went down hill about 3 years ago, it used to be quite thick, but now, as you say, runny and thin. The only other one I like, is Dewhirsts, which is close to HP. But it's hard to get hold of, as only Poundstretchers and Poundland seem to occasionally stock it. If anyone knows anywhere else that has it, please let me know🤞

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Thanks for the info!

[@PotatoPirate123]

Dewhurst has been owned by a few investment companies over the years - I think it's DMB Foods and S.L.O. foods depending on the type of product now. To be honest I thought most of the range was trash when I looked at the ingredients in Pound Stretcher, but I guess with brown sauce it's all about the balance of flavour. I would imagine that you can get the exact same brown sauce under a different brand name though if you do some research. I can't even find any trace of it online though, just the ketchup.

[@poppypalais3108]

​@@PotatoPirate123 Big in the 80s I recall, with shops opening all over the place. Then they seemed to disappear overnight. F*** all "investment companies". Assets strippers and nothing else.

[@localhero761]

I'm all brown sauced out

[@stevencavanagh1613]

I use hp brown sauce but would defo use chop if I could find it , it's the tastiest sauce by miles especially on a good old fashioned pig butty 😋

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

cheers Steven.

[@stevencavanagh1613]

@@BaldFoodieGuy keep up with the reviews it's good to see someone actually takin an interest in everyday life 👍

[@nige3801]

Great vid Gareth, if you haven't a big review list in place could you do a coffee review? Brand names against Supermarket ones

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

cheers Nige yes good one that pal thanks 😊

[@thegeordieweatherman8460]

We've stocked up on the Bramwell's, for when SHTF. It's fairly inexpensive, and glad you picked it as a favourite.

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

Cheers pal

[@thegeordieweatherman8460]

@@BaldFoodieGuy Nee bother 👍🏻

[@ryanperrykjkujkhkj8065]

What do you do with all that brown sauce after these videos

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

put them in the fridge to use Ryan.

[@bedfordshiremodeller4491]

He does giv them to som of his friends/his brother as well

[@harrymunk9852]

Amazing review mate, you got enough sauce to last ya for ages lol, spot on mate, keep up the good work bro

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

yes I know lol

[@Ianjowett1]

love the chop sauce , a bit different than a lot , also i like daddies sauce too

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

daddies is there pal

[@septembervirgo3723]

Did you actually watch the video? Daddies was definitely there!

[@anthonystewart677]

The Chop sauce was really popular back in the 70s and early 80s. We used to have it all the time. Now I use HP. Tesco's and Daddies.

[@Ianjowett1]

@@septembervirgo3723 yeah i didnt notice at first..my bad .

[@Ianjowett1]

@@BaldFoodieGuy yeah noticed after i typed sorry .

[@pammyb1972]

Hammonds Chop Sauce has always been my favourite brown sauce! Even when I was a kid I preferred brown sauce to red, and it was always Chop in our cupboard. My brother loved red sauce so there was no arguing ha ha!! Sadly I have been diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes 4 months ago, so now I use the Skinny sauce, which tastes different and is quite runny but I do love the taste :-)

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

oh im sorry to hear that.

[@pammyb1972]

Bald Foodie Guy yea it’s been a big learning curve, and it took a while to get used to the consistency and taste of the skinny sauces as they are very different, but there’s still so much choice in food these days for diabetics so I’m kind of enjoying the change…. Plus the three stone weight loss isn’t so bad either ha ha!

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

@@pammyb1972 well done 3 stone loss, good on you 👌👌👌

[@pammyb1972]

Bald Foodie Guy it’s certainly improved my general heath for sure! Thank you 🤗

[@trevorsbarkingmadchannel4501]

Love your comparisons. Does seem aldis bramwells are really very good in many ways. Great vlog. Thank u 🙏

[@BaldFoodieGuy]

You are so welcome!

[@bigyin2013]

Gold star is the dady of all brown sauce