Rolex Submariner vs Blancpain Fifty Fathoms vs GO SeaQ - 10k Diver Comparison

[@impexRQ]

Come on ... you need to be realistic... you can’t even compare a Rolex submariner with Blancpain or Glashütte , these two are hand crafted watches and high horology ... these are not mass produced watch produced by industrial machines and with quality issues like a Rolex ... Rolex is at the level of Omega but never in the level of Blancpain or Glashütte

[@travelandwatches8]

Giving a 10 for the Rolex? The Rolex movement is not on the same level as the other two.

[@michaelriera6277]

Absolutely the Rolex movement although robust is mass produced non decorated nothing special.

[@low-keyautummn5940]

Agree as would many more.

[@Kerry870]

Of course, Rolex is just robot made movement :))

[@barrylattuca5352]

The Rolex is a nice watch. But, it isn’t even in the same league as the other two. I would choose the GO. But, it would be a tough decision between the GO and the Blancpain. I understand it’s a subjective comparison. However, giving each movement a 10 is where you lost me. The Rolex movement is not on the same level.

[@michaelriera6277]

Not close by a long shot

[@saaddjoukhadar4074]

@@michaelriera6277 no comparision when it comes to movement

[@meson183]

Is it though? True, Rolex is not high horology. You don't get to see the movement simply because Rolex do not do display backs. But what you so get is a rock solid workhorse movement that is not just incredibly robust, reliable and accurate, but is proven to be so for decades. It is in this area that the Rolex movement earns it's score of 10.

[@Jay-xr3sb]

@@meson183 at the high end the finishing on the movement plays a big part in the movement category. Rolex don't bother as it adds a huge amount to the cost and their movement are robust but nothing special. A high end quartz will be more robust that any of them

[@robertocarrillo9919]

Totally agree, not even close!

[@MrJdp1968]

Loved that comparison but you did seem a little biased to the Rolex. I know it’s all about personal opinions but for me the Rolex would come last out of the three.

[@mirekb50]

A little?

[@krit5339]

He says he's not a brand snob, and I have seen much bigger snobs, but he is a Rolex fanboy at best.

[@omarion07]

Why? Is it because your confirmation bias tells you blancpain and glashutte are miles ahead of the Rolex? In the movement category, Bruce showed you how the Rolex is the most precise out of the three using a measuring device. The hulk uses 3135 calibre, so the new 2020 submariner with 3235 calibre should perform even better. The rest is subjective and a matter of personal taste.

[@krit5339]

@@omarion07 By that logic a quartz Timex is better than a Rolex.

[@Leftystrat]

The ff has a tool bezel better build quality. I have both. The ff is easier to read above and below water.. whatever and who really cares

[@JamesandRibble]

I would only by a watch from a company willing and able to sell me one. Other people can demean themselves, sucking up to dealers and buying overpriced trinkets to move up a waiting list. Not for me.

[@michaelriera6277]

Here here!

[@cubex68]

On point. Mayor's rep told me story where they paraphrased to a customer who wanted to celebrate his retirement with a stainless steel Rolex that he'll probably be not alive by the time his name gets on top of the waiting list

[@low-keyautummn5940]

Absolutely James, I second that. Those days are gone, times have changed, ain't no one's waiting for anyone any more. Very prehistoric way of dealing/purchasing.

[@low-keyautummn5940]

@@cubex68 Lol, another important factor to look at before setting foot in a Rolex AD.

[@SpencerCookertin]

Absolutely some guys like getting bent over by big corporate. If I can't walk in and buy something then I won't buy from them.

[@111danish111]

I like the Blancpain out of these three particular models.

[@tienchan271]

Fifty Fathoms with X-71 bracelets on will take this review to another level.

[@light1531]

Hulk (and all Subs) should offer a reverse cyclops just like a Panerai Radiomir, and then welcome to this decade.

[@light1531]

Love the Blancpain with blue dial and black bezel and no waiting list OR the fly back chrono, full calendar, moon phase, date pointer 5066f-1140-52b adorable and with complications plus blue dial! And probably for that price you can have a Panerai Luminor with a blue dial and some complications with an in-house movement!!!

[@John..18]

Glashutte, would be the one for me,,, beautiful,,,

[@Jay-xr3sb]

Rolex brand recognition: 10 Preception: 4. Is it fake, are you just flexing, no imagination and a little douchy

[@low-keyautummn5940]

Lol

[@kraitshakti]

And yet if you were offered a Rolex at MSRP you’d rush over like Speedy Gonzalez to buy one ....! That’s the funny thing about most (not all, but definitely most) of those that complain about Rolex. It is only because they (i) cannot get one at MSRP or, even more sadly, (ii) cannot get a genuine Rolex. Thus they hate, and it’s quite sad for them. 😀

[@Jay-xr3sb]

@@kraitshakti With Rolex, money that hasn't gone into watch development went into marketing the name. It's the most well know watch brand, if you want recognition from the widest audience and to 'flex' then its your watch. Even an OP can give you the rep. I tried the 41mm sub and found the clasp too big. The lugs better designed but the bracelet now too wide. It still annoys me that the don't have double AR coating, anything on the caseback. Personally, I also dislike the Mercedes hand. Also, too many people own it in my line of work, what's the point just to be in a club. A fine inoffensive watch that did nothing for me, no wow factor. I knew right away that I'd be chasing it for its image and arguments about value retention. Would I buy one at retail, yes. Who wouldn't, I'd try it out for a bit, knowing I'd turn a profit when I sell. That alone should explain the demand. I don't mind getting into a watch chat with another watch person, but I don't want the attention from random people that are impressed/jealous knowing that I have 10k rolex strapped to my wrist. I have since bought a mint discontinued omega planet ocean 2500 liquidmetal limited edition. I have seen plenty of the standard ones in the wild but never this one. To me it's better in every way but it could be a tad thinner. The fit is fine but an adjustable clap would be nice. If you need to go with what everyone else gives you credit for then get the rolex, unless you really like the style.

[@tdaveniii]

You forgot to mention the tacky date bubble.

[@jamessymington2466]

Glashutte for sure. They’re all great but the effort made in turning out that Glashutte edges it for me.

[@watchtheflow3880]

Well more hands have touched the blancpain tough. Most of go work is done by machines…

[@Moe90rules]

my favorite is the blancpain. mostly due to the highest finishing on the movement

[@henrik2456]

The Rolex is simply inferior to the other two, by quite a margin, in every single component.

[@omarion07]

That's your opinion

[@omarion07]

@Jake Roberts opinions don't matter. Facts do. If we're talking robustness, durability and precision then Rolex is above those two brands. If we're talking about movement finishing and refinement then GO and BP are above but not by a big margin as the dude above suggested. I'm a watch enthusiast myself and i don't need ads to fall in love with Rolex.

[@Norman-mn7gp]

Glashutte Original SeaQ Panorama Date is the best ....

[@southnx]

3 great pieces make for a difficult decision. Can't go wrong with any of them, but for me it would be the 50 Fathoms. Just something about the history and the look that appeal to my WIS sensibilities

[@Leftystrat]

And you can get em!

[@silverlakeas]

I would imagine that the quality of the Blancpain & Glashutte movements would be greater than Rolex?!?

[@fifthpint4571]

I suppose it depends on how you define quality, and what you want from the movement. Rolex finish is relatively basic, but in terms of robustness, serviceability, accuracy and reliability it is really second to none. Taken from a utilitarian, every-day-dependable standpoint, Rolex movements are some of the best in the game.

[@Jay-xr3sb]

@@fifthpint4571 like a quartz? Even less hassle. In the high end automatic world you can't be embarrassed about the finish of your movement unless its embarrassing or not there. They save on costs, hard to mass produce the finish on the GO.

[@silverlakeas]

@@fifthpint4571 I agree absolutely.I would rather have those attributes you have listed in a movement, especially a tool watch than anything

[@scottfulps2065]

Easily.

[@cavanon]

@@Jay-xr3sb And mainly the Rolex watch price takes on top the sponsorships like F1, Golf, Tennis and other events not the quality. This comparison is like comparing Lexus with Bentley cars, makes no sense. The GO plays UEFA Champions League quality and Rolex plays UEFA Europa League. The Rolex is the one that everyone knows because of ads, the other two are for people that appreciates horology.

[@Jeremy88888888]

My dream watch is the Blancpain. With 5 days power reserve, basically there's no worry it will stopped even if u don't wear it for few days. I find the gold with a leather strap for the Blancpain looked nice and elegant. Would be better if it come without date. Rolex is really too common and it's not on the same level as the other 2 brands.

[@antonhallergren588]

That blancpain is gorgeous, I agree and I may very well buy one.

[@PatrickSittinger]

GO nailed it! The movement is the best, the quality is the best and the design is stunning. Every day, when I take a look on the stunning curved sapphire glass and the numerals, I feel that it is extra ordinary.

[@Prophet293]

yeah whatever, i only buy rolex because I can't afford luxury watches and i need to sell it later to get my $ back

[@michaelkessler9467]

As you can’t buy the Rolex, why even do a comparison using it. It’s a watch that is unavailable, therefore the whole video is hypothetical.

[@michaelkessler9467]

You are right about one thing. It is a ridiculous video

[@bingoberra18]

its a 14k diver :)

[@luxman9463]

I came to the comments to say the same thing.

[@joelopic]

Can get plenty on Amazon or eBay second hand though. I wouldn't. Prefer the others

[@Brian-ee1gx]

The Glashutte is beautiful. If only they offered that version in 40-41mm, with a fully brushed bracelet...

[@castleincorporated]

agreed, it'd be perfect if they would add a clear back to the 39.5 and brush the bracelet. im a big guy and i really like the clear back and the pano date... I might just get the pano go seaq and have the bracelet brushed...

[@VmanStudioz]

This is a Diver Legend and for good reason! This watch has REAL "Soul" and is loaded with personality. It is Ferrari over Mercedez. I've had the Sea Dweller and the Fifty Fathoms. I sold off the boring utilitarian form of the Sea Dweller and kept the Fifty Fathoms as the only Haute Horology Diver in my collection and never thought twice about it. The Sea Dweller went towards an H Moser, so this was a major upgrade in the collection. Overall, you will rarely ever find anyone else with a Blancpain on the wrist compared to every Tom, Dick, and Harry who wears a sub. Follow your heart, follow the beauty, heck - even follow the science. This haute horology piece beat the Rolex Sub Mariner to market in 1953; this is the true first modern day dive watch ever built. Commissioned by the French Military, Cousteau wore this watch with great pride It was years before Blancpain's patent expired on the Unidirectional bezel and Rolex copied that onto their sub-mariner. You too can own a piece of history. Thank me later...

[@johnnyguitar6697]

This is frankly a very good video, Bruce, thanks for making it. The only points I find debatable is rating the finish / build quality of the Submariner above that of the FF. Both the FF and the GO are in a different league altogether for finishing vs. the Rolex. And also for movement where, for all its robustness, the Rolex is miles behind both the other brands.

[@impexRQ]

Sorry Bruce but you can’t even have a mass produced watch like Rolex next to a hand-crafted piece of Art like Blancpain. Blancpain is all about horology … you honestly cant have them in the same level - Very disappointed about it .. it’s totally disrespectful for a company like Blancpain .. it’s like comparing a Ferrari with a Mercedes Benz C- class

[@Ritzkraqa_85]

Just bought the SeaQ last week because I said to myself, "F Rolex, I'm not paying these extreme secondary market prices". What happened to the days of walking into a store and coming out with an item as long as you can afford it? It's a great watch!

[@tung103hh8]

build quality should be fifty fathoms the best

[@simonbarr9489]

I would wager that a number of customers who buy the rolex dont know the other 2 even exist, they are buying it as a status symbol to show other people. Id have the blancpain out of those 3.

[@Jay-xr3sb]

Crystal on the rolex...eyesore cyclops and no AR for no reason. 4/10.

[@peterpark650]

Should have included availability category.

[@itskyyuuuu]

and give rolex a 1. the other 2 a 10. all of a sudden rolex comes in last

[@gpearce11]

@@itskyyuuuu You could probably give Rolex a 5. Its impossible to find in retailers, but is readily available second-hand, for a price.

[@bryansmith7490]

I have a Rolex Ceramic Sub “no date” and love it, however I have fallen in love with the Glashutte and looking for a dealer near me. Thanks for the great videos and showing your fans that there is more than just Rolex.

[@jasgsxr2726]

I would have to take the Blancpain, I just love that bezel, face, movement and finish, part of a 3 watch collection.

[@impexRQ]

The Glashütte SeaQ Panorama Datum is a amazing piece ... Blancpain very closed second ...

[@9443-c5b]

You’d have to be high to think the Rolex finishing and build quality is better than BP. This is not a matter of your opinions being subjective, this is pure bias and only because you own the Rolex. Rolex is not even in the same league. Comparing true Haute Horology to effin mass produced dung. And oh, I have the sub and the BP.

[@tienchan271]

to those whom never own FF, they can only see Rolex is the best. typical youngster whom only think Tesla is the best. I wish there is a Museum of mechanical watches and see Rolex displayed there. these same fanboys will never appreciated the muscle cars between 60's and early 70's.or earlier...

[@joelrosenberg8704]

Blancpain fifty Fathoms Automatique in a complete different league then GO & Rolex. The ultra luxury diver!

[@Brian-ee1gx]

The GO is on par with the FF, and better in some respects.

[@joelrosenberg8704]

@@Brian-ee1gx Do you own any of these timepieces? I do and the GO is new in the game and not even close to a FF.

[@Brian-ee1gx]

@@joelrosenberg8704 I have tried all three in person, and I would put the BP and GO on par with each other from a finishing & quality standpoint. The BP has a more intricately finished movement, but the GO has much more complex case finishing.

[@corneliusscipio777]

Dislike because you want only increase the value of your Rolex and not make a profi comparison. Personally I like more the Fifty Fathoms, but the clear winner here in overall is the german.

[@SpencerCookertin]

The Rolex movement does not get a 10. You can't see it, and it's not even finished that well. No man hours are spent working by hand on it. Reliability? Sure, but so is a quartz and both have no finishing.

[@BruceWilliams]

Anything that is perfectly accurate, reliable, and runs for a decade without needing any attention is the ideal movement. I couldn't mark it down. The others may be pretty. But they cant keep up in the practical portion of the experience like a 3135 can

[@contaygious]

Great video but the perfect 10 for Rolex value doesn't make as much sense :)

[@contaygious]

The reason is because your omega video comparison makes them really close it the omega is way cheaper so that's my reason :)

[@chazzcombs]

The Rolex doesn't even belong with those other 2. I only had to watch up to category 3 to know how it was going to go and skipped to the end. Blah.

[@low-keyautummn5940]

Excellent question Bruce, was waiting for that. Glashutte by a mile. Whether it be my money or someone else's. Glashutte breaks the barrier in aesthetics and raises it by quite a few notches leaving behind Rolex and BB FF quite some way back. Nice comparison although I would have taken the Glashütte a lot closer to the Rolex score, like 90.

[@itskyyuuuu]

GO is one of my favorite houses the 70s original chronograph is my favorite watch. I'd go with GO

[@edwardblack7133]

Ok watched it now....in which areas was is the finishing of the blancpain not so good? Not had one in hand for more than a few mins before

[@adalbertthomalla4887]

I would give Rolex Movement a 5. To value all movements on same level is really not professional.

[@rpalomo12]

Wow Your rate movements for Rolex at the same level as a blancpain. I don’t think you know watches like you think you do. No disrespect ofcourse. It’s like saying Ferrari v12 vs bmw v8 are in same league but everyone knows it isn’t even comparable

[@pcp-xo1wj]

I watch the videos in order to see the models “in action” versus static photos. A very valuable experience. But, I don’t know why you bother to do the dog and pony show comparing to the Rolex. You’re so biased that I can predict the outcome ahead of time.

[@stevesaka8191]

As someone who has owned all three, the FF and GO are superior in finish***, the wrist fit of the Rolex bracelet is superior due to its adjustability, the accuracy of the FF and GO are superior over the Rolex***, the way the watch sits on the wrist is superior for the FF and Rolex - it is actually surprising how well the FF sits on the wrist, it wears more like a 43mm due to the short, down turned lugs, the SeaQ has excellent wrist fit for me, but I could see how it would be an issue for those with thinner wrists, the lume is far superior on the FF, the history goes to FF, the marketing goes to Rolex, the resale value definitely goes to Rolex, the Rolex is the most durable, almost a really expensive beater, the wrist pop/cool factor goes to the FF, but to Rolex for those who don't know watches - no one except watch people notice the GO, the Rolex gets the "is it real/fake and how much did it cost" from non-watch folks, but the "oh another Sub..." from watch people, the FF gets "that is a beautiful watch" from the non-watch folks and outright drool from the people into watches. The Rolex is more versatile and fits better on folks with a 165mm or smaller wrist - for reference my wrist is 195mm. The Rolex is the least expensive to service. Imo, I would rank them #1 FF, #2 Rolex and #3 GO, but honestly all three are exceptional watches and I understand how any of the three are loved by their owners - and I can easily see the owners of the SeaQ being annoyed I put it in the #3 spot as it is a technically superior watch to the Rolex in most ways. ps: I think the Sea Dweller is a better comparison scale wise to the big-boy FF & GO in this video - I own this also - my rankings remain the same, except the Sea Dweller is technically better for actual dive use. And while I am at it, the FF with the Blue Dial and Red Gold case is a total show stopper, not a practical diver due to cost, but it is my most beloved watch. ps: While I am just spitting my opinion, in the GO I suggest folks consider the Seventies Chronograph Panorama Date - not a diver so it is not a good alternative to these three, but it does have 100 bar water resistance and is my favorite Glashutte Original - it is a unique beauty and an amazing piece - totally love it! ***Bruce - this is the one part of your video that I just can't wrap my head around your perspective... on no planet does the machined Rolex Submariner have the best fit and finish compared to these other two hand crafted and finished pieces - I can appreciate you prefer the design of the Sub, but that is not the same as fit and finish.. And ditto on the movement accuracy, I just am befuddled as to how you came to this conclusion - your Hulk's 3135 must be one of those totally nutz on ones, because there is no way that movement is more accurate to the SeaQ's 36-13 or FF's 1315. And don't even get me started on power reserve... Hulk = 48 hours, SeaQ = 100 hours, FF = 120 hours.

[@ensh888888]

Thank you for the comparison ! Awesome ! However, I would disagree that Rolex movement is on par with both GO & Blancpain, its nowhere in that league.

[@kraitshakti]

The Rolex movement cannot compare with them in regard to finishing. The GO and Blancpain movements cannot compare with Rolex in regard to accuracy.

[@nishantprakash5928]

@@kraitshakti who said? Blancpain and GO has been tested with SIX positions Rolex is tested with FIVE positions Blancpain and GO has higher power reserve by a mile. Blancpain and GO literally has hand finished movements Rolex isn't even close.

[@curiousk5182]

With 15k I would buy immediately with the GO SeaQ with the grey dial - it’s simply gorgeous and an other level of watch making compared to the Rolex. For the retail price, the Rolex would my clear favorite. Thx for the video!

[@Jay-xr3sb]

Shall we add...not being a target for a mugging

[@contaygious]

😂 Right? Should brand perception be the mugging category?

[@daley3]

Just an observation, you are always biased with your Rolex Sub, as seen in your previous comparison videos.

[@MisterTalent]

You are so wrong about almost everything in this review, you still have to learn a lot about watches 😊

[@tienchan271]

You are absolutely correct! I own all these pieces and other for many years. To a general public with younger generation, Rolex is brain washing everyone into believing they are the Patek or AP. But to someone with knowledge and years of experiences over 25 yrs. Rolex is no different than a Seiko.

[@corneliusscipio777]

@@tienchan271 yep, an overpriced Seiko. If Rolex would cost 5000-6000 USD, okay...

[@haxx7128]

Blancpain for me

[@benanthony3985]

Did you guys hear about the diver in the Bahamas that died because of bezel playback? Tragic

[@DanboShaw]

I heard his diver had a 120 click bezel, so he ran out of oxygen 30 seconds earlier than expected, poor guy

[@kk7sm]

@@DanboShaw LOL - well, it has less to do with oxygen than decompression stops - he shorted himself 30 seconds on his decompression stop and got the bends! :-)

[@craigdlazarus]

SeaQ for me Bruce. Thx for the video, nice comparison. Keep 'em coming....

[@Daavi85]

They're all great watches and I think anyone would be happy to own any one of them but if I could pick just one my favorite has always been the Fifty Fathoms, that's my pick.

[@hunterphan5506]

As a dive watch lover, my choices are Blancpain and Glashutte. I love going to an AD and stare at them thru the display. While I respect Rolex, their designs have never moved me. That’s is actually a good thing because there is no way I can get on the wait list or afford to pay an arm and leg on the grey market for a Sub. If I could pick one out of three for free, I would go with Blancpain.

[@floydmorrison2025]

What a great video, I really enjoyed that! I'd personally go for the Blancpain, as it's always been a grail of mine. I just love the timeless look of the case, dial, bezel & brilliant movement. Your recent videos have really piqued my interest in the Glashutte divers. I wonder if they used a flat sapphire crystal for the display caseback, instead of a bubble crystal, if it would wear better. Wasn't surprised to see Rolex win this, however.

[@Vargadumi]

I would give the Sub 9 for fit and comfort because the crown and the edges on the lower side can be distracting and also 9 for the movement because of the 48 hours of power reserve. Wouldn’t change the emd result though and thats fine IMO.

[@Roy-vh9rp]

16:25 Of course youtubers and bloggers who talk nice about Rolex shouldnt be on the waiting list ;) So the "subjective value" of buying a watch for a lot less than market value is great

[@stevefox8605]

Still prefer your Seamaster myself 👍🏻

[@Jay-xr3sb]

And the older ceramic at that. Also the BP bathyscaphe.

[@andreaiacolina]

I hadn't ever experienced these 3 pieces in real life, so I cannot choose one, but on paper and for the design my choice is the Glashuette SeaQ Panorama date. Anyway 3 gorgeous pieces with incredible histories.

[@agill2103]

I dont have any of the 3 however i would go for the GO! Its looks really special.

[@Windmill360]

Nice overview but too obviously biased towards Rolex. Rolex in no way has a better movement or finishing than Glashutte or Blancpain. If you base it on movement robustness than you might as well give an ETA watch a higher score than Patek. Still, nice review but too much not-so well-hidden Rolex fanboyism.

[@pauloconnor5101]

Love the glasshute

[@angrybanana6223]

Blancpain for sure. The GO doesn't have a design that I fancy and the Rolex is a bit same-y. I don't think the hype of a Rolex is reflective of any sort of technical innovation or aesthetic superiority. The Blancpain beats it in both (subjective, I know).

[@richardweir3342]

All nice, but I would say the Blancpain should win. I've never seen a lume so good yet you gave it a 9, movement hand finished= better, brand history, the oldest watch manufacturer. Love your stuff Bruce but this is looking a little bit bias. But like you say everyone has an opion. Great video though, first time I have seen a comparison like this, you should do more of these.

[@tourbeyond4372]

Bruce, I’d like to see a similar video at the $5K and $2K price points

[@mljcab1]

I am not as impressed with Rolex for several reasons. Rolex does not invest in the same level of hand finish as the Glashutte Original or the Blancpain. The lack of availability of Rolex watches drive me away from brand. I will never pay gray market prices for a watch that is a bit over priced at retail. Of the two other watches, I am most impressed with SeaQ. That Blancpain is a close second. For my money Glashutte is the real value and the highest horological brand of three. I’m a large man so devaluing a large watch for being large is total nonsense. From my point of view, Rolex sub is too small. I would have thought a sea dweller would have been a better fit for this head to head comparison. All of the categories used in this head to head should have carried the qualifier, “Subjective”. From my subjective point of view the final rating should have been Glashutte SeaQ, Blancpain Fifty Fathoms and coming in a distant third would be the Rolex Submariner.

[@entroheat]

Glashutte no way is better than Blancpain which is oldest brand to date.

[@macoyupadoodle]

Pls review the New Polaris Mariner time date only.

[@nicolaspetitmengin1931]

Completely biased to Rolex. FF has an higher quality movement than the Rolex one.

[@mahmudulislamkhan]

Thanks for the video. It seemed heavily biased towards Rolex though. Rolex movement may be accurate, but it has no finishing what so ever. It hides conveniently behind a solid caseback.

[@jcb0920]

I'm saving up for the 50 Fathoms. Love everything about it. Would like to own the Sub but not at what the average buyer is forced to pay.

[@tienchan271]

I own all 3 time pieces. FF on X71 bracelet is the best of the 3 pieces. I purchased all these before 2018. paid $7000 for hulk (no one care for it at the time), $9000 for FF and $7500 for GO. I believed majority of the public has no idea about the watch movement or the definition of quality engineered mechanical watch. they watch too many youtube grey market hype of making the sale on a brand. who know? maybe the next 5 year Seiko could be the main event and be worth triple?? or Casio??

[@Leftystrat]

Taken Rolex and ff under water . The Rolex is a tonker toy compared to the ff. Us navy divers couldn’t think any improvement necessary for the blancpain ff.I go with the pros people!

[@FuneralDirectorJoe]

I only own one of these three fine watches. The one I chose to own is the Submariner. Wearing one can almost be described as boring because every aspect is the result of a very long history. Every day my Rolex loses two seconds. Guaranteed! Everyone who notices it “drools” over it. Owning a Submariner made me buy a second Rolex. I purchased an Air King. Designed after a speed car instrument panel and also will deliver 2 seconds a day “loss” of time. I do not only own Rolex’s. I also have Girard Perrageaux, Planet Ocean, Tudor and Ploprof. I enjoy the Submariner the most! Thank you for making such an entertaining video.

[@michaelriera6277]

Since the mass produced Rolex is impossible to get anyway, I’ll take the beautiful Blancpain. Rolex indifference, artificial supply constraints and AD/boutique terrible service has in my view marred a great watch.

[@sr-up3uu]

GO, Blancpain>rolex

[@LlyleHunter]

Of the three there’s no secret why the Sub endures with its prolific basic design and level of finish, quality and known reliability. One thing to note however is that the micro adjustment clasp on the Glashutte’s bracelet sets the standard for ergonomic function and any watchmaker not paying attention as they design their next generation of improved bracelets will be missing the mark.

[@vincentchampion8986]

Curious as to why you chose to use the SeaQ panorama in this comparison instead of the 39.5mm. Based on your categories I think it might have come closer to the Sub picking up points in fit/comfort and design/versatility.

[@atis23]

Blancpain came last. Hahahaha got to be a joke.

[@vishaldev13]

I wish the GO came in a 40mm size, slightly thinner and a longer power reserve.

[@barrettmccann]

The standard SeaQ (non-panorama date) is now available in blue. Model 1-39-11-09-81-70, 39.5mm diameter, 12mm thick, but just 40-hr power reserve. $10,200 US.

[@barrettmccann]

The SeaQ Panorama Date that Bruce reviewed advertises a 100-hr power reserve.

[@federicopedata2950]

If you put the x71 bracelet on the Blancpain win for sure…

[@tienchan271]

agree! I own the FF with X71 bracelet. I also purchased the Hulk back in 2018 for $7000. I tried to get rid of it many time, but kept it for only one reason. investment. other than that I still believed it no where near FF.

[@federicopedata2950]

@@tienchan271 I also had a hulk 2 years ago (paid new 8000 euro) but the blancpain honestly is much better quality..😎 i'm seriously thinking of a one with a bracelet..

[@tienchan271]

@@federicopedata2950 if I can only have the one watch in a lifetime. I would be happy with FF on X71 bracelet

[@federicopedata2950]

@@tienchan271 me too 👏👏

[@jnet6]

Forget about rolex till they do something about supplying stocks to the ADs, you may want to put subjective value that anyone can buy in current situation instead of the RRP watches.

[@timmcdonald5335]

The only negative I would say about a Sub is that it should have gone back to the beautiful pre ceramic case. Apart from the shape what people forget is that the new subs are heavier.

[@scottjmcclellan]

BP and GO are head and shoulders above the Rolex… no contest…

[@damachine3]

Phecond...but phirst to say phirst

[@Talon173]

personally I find all these watches too big so my pick would be the Planet Ocean in 39.5mm spec. Out of the 3 it would be the GO though. The Rolex is a great watch at RRP....but I’ve tried, and in my area there’s no chance

[@moritzmuller855]

I would go for the Glashütte, without a doubt. As all the other reviews I saw said, the Rolex is not even in the same ballpark. The Rolex might actually cost USD 1000 to produce, as you mention, however, there is no way the guys from Glashütte are able to pull it of at this price. It simply as a totally different league and the Blancpain, as well.

[@metro2171]

Great review Bruce , three great divers that deserve their own shine . Value for money the hulk is the ultimate . The hulk is the watch for me all day.

[@FMAlchemst]

Thank you Bruce for the Comparison! Blancpain 5015 have the best watch finish, but the worst strap.

[@tienchan271]

you should see fifty on X71 bracelet.

[@scottlalonde2878]

Thank you, Bruce, great comparison. I can't afford any without dipping into the emergency fund, but if I were to have one dropped in my lap....I'd say Rolex first, GO second and BP last. As gorgeous as the movement on the Blancpain is, it just doesn't appeal to me. Sometimes during the day, I picked the GO. Let's face it: all three are awesome! Thanks again.

[@michaelfierman3256]

That was a ton of fun and I'm glad i was awake for it before bed. I can tell you right now that I would buy the grey dial Glasshütte with the steel case and rose gold crown and hands. That is one of my favorite watches I have seen ( online) in the last few years. It might cost a smidge more than 15K, but only a hair more. I love the look of that watch. Black no date Sub would be second choice. I think the Blancpain is rather ungainly. It reminds me a bit of a hockey puck. The lume was pretty amazing though. I'll give you props for being very fair in your assessment, despiste your bias for the Hulk. I can't wait to see what everyone else says tomorrow. PS I just looked up the retail price: $14,800. I made it!

[@boris7540]

If I had the opportunity to buy some Rolex steel sports model at retail I would definitely go for it. I would wear it, enjoy it and sell for a profit after some time. For that money I may buy something completely different. At this price point I would rather go for something else than a diver 🙂

[@low-keyautummn5940]

On repeat play, I think that you should have given the GOSQPD the 10 that it deserves and 8.5 to the Sub.

[@tienchan271]

These reviews are not fair for fifty fathoms, IF I were to pick for the REVIEW, it would be: Hulk VS blue fifty fathoms with X-71 bracelet

[@samcrockett845]

Late to the party on comment- so basically talking to self. I am the crazy guy who has actually considered cross-shopping these very watches to fill the gap of my “premium diver” category. Been quite the challenge as they are more apples to oranges. I think you have done a great job breaking things down and while these things are by definition subjective, still making a reasonable argument for your opinions. Entertaining comparisons but as always it comes down to personal choice. FOR ME, the GO tics all the boxes.

[@itskyyuuuu]

Rolex perception is SOLELY down to marketing what are you talking about?? that marketing being done in the 60s and 70s mostly. They were smart enough to make sure it was on the wrists of some of the most famous people in the world.

[@jh-il5sb]

rolex does have great marketing, that's what successful companies do. that's how they stay relevant and their watches so sought after for all these decades. but at the end of the day even great marketing can only do so much if people don't connect with the product and their isn't sustained quality . i surely wouldn't buy a kia car because roger federer or tiger woods were sponsored by them.

[@Tonysoprano497]

They are all superb. Personally I think the GQ is stunning in the metal . However I’m big on comfort, fit and wearability it’s probably the most important factor for me in a sports watch , the GQ appears to miss the mark here therefore for me it’s the hulk . People do love to hate on it but it is unquestionably a truly great sports watch

[@leeuppersouth8200]

The Rolex is a of design and size that fits the eye and wrist of most buyers in this segment. It’s solid case-back hides a machined finish workhorse movement that doesn’t disappoint in accuracy and durability. In horological ranking, the Sub is much more akin to Omega and Grand Seiko. The BP and GO combined, produce less than 30,000 watches annually compared to Rolex in excess of one million. The small workshop-like manufacturing of BP and GO allow for hand finishing of movements and cases that Rolex simply can’t do. The smaller manufacturers are for true enthusiasts that demand the unique qualities described. In Kentucky we’d say we’re comparing Quarter Horses to Thoroughbreds. Ironically, Rolex sponsors most all Thoroughbred events! Enjoyed the video Bruce! Keep up the good work.

[@Eric-i1r]

I’d prefer the GO any day. I’d like to have a 43mm GO in blue, a 39mm GO in green, and a 39mm GO in black.

[@Jay-xr3sb]

Bathyscaphe needs to be there!

[@MrMatt1923]

I’m not a fan of the FF. I love the GO, but it’s thickness kills it for me. I’d have to choose Rolex all day.

[@sadaka201]

GO all the way....but of course the big R is the winner. Can't be different, can it?

[@brandonnickerson8934]

The bezel seems odd. Idk if it's the small print, and seeing double with the seconds markers. The bubble saphire is yet another fugly feature. And lastly, the date location is a cluttered mess.

[@mkyhou1160]

GO is a nice watch but just a horrible weak brand. Brand new models for sale 60 percent off retail, so sure, if you aren’t worried you might one day need to sell it’s fine, but if life does take a wrong turn it’s nice to know with a Rolex you can easily cash in.

[@sadaka201]

@@mkyhou1160 Your comment shows me exactly the difference between a watch connaisseur and a wanna be. Which type are you? Please tell me where I can by a new SeaQ for 60% off retail. I buy it right away...

[@mkyhou1160]

Jean-Marc König not a SeaQ but here are GOs that retailed for double the price they sell for new - 15k off. GO is a very weak brand, if you have the wealth to gamble the same won’t happen to a SeaQ go for it. I don’t, people need to be careful. www.ashford.com/us/watches/glashutte/cat480026.cid

[@kotch31pui]

Rolex is overall the best watch in term of social perception, being quality watch, and maybe asset investment, anyway I would take 50 fathoms if I never seen SeaQ, I really its finishing of the case and caliber, light playing, and the clasp and bracelet.

[@realalexmackenzie]

If given the choice to purchase one of them today (leaving aside the market price vs RRP on Rolex aspect), I would go with the BP. Pure class. Heritage. Uniqueness. Let's face it, if you go to a summer BBQ with your sub, good chance that there is some other guy there, with a Sub. Not so much the BP. Also, being a larger guy in terms of height and frame, I would likely opt for the slightly larger SD43 to fill the Rolex slot in the collection. I sold my SD43 last year to buy a DSSD, but I'm just not warming to the thickness and the crystal distortion, so it is currently looking for its next owner. If I can get back on a Rolex waitlist, I will rebuy the SD43. Though the premiums are fading fast, so maybe I will be negotiating a discount at the AD. :o Also have firm plans to acquire the BP in the next year or two. Mad respect for the GO as well. I love the value proposition that many of the German brands bring to the table. I see them only going up in esteem as the years go by. I can absolutely see adding the GO Pano to the collection, especially if the secondary market is favourable.